Download The Commonwealth and Climate Change,West Bengal, Jan 2010

A PAPER PRESENTED
AT THE SEMINAR ON
GLOBAL WARMING – THE CHALLENGE OF
THE 21ST CENTURY : THE ROLE OF THE CPA
WEST BENGAL LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY
KOLKATA, WEST BENGAL, 11 JANUARY 2010
BY DR WILLIAM F. SHIJA
CPA SECRETARY-GENERAL
INTRODUCTION
Honourable Speaker, Honourable Members,
It is a great pleasure to be in West Bengal once again after my first visit in 2007.
At that time, among other things, I was able to meet a number of Parliamentary
and Government Leaders such as yourself and the Honourable Jyoti Basu whom
we find to be indisposed today. On behalf of the Executive Committee and the
Members of the CPA, I offer extensive prayers for the quick recovery of this great
statesman of India.
I am delighted that you have given me the opportunity to present to you the
contribution by the CPA Members in the ongoing global debate on global warming
2
and climate change. The CPA, as most of us know, was established in 1911 and is
due to celebrate its Centennial in 2011. It has close to 17,000 Members in
national, state and provincial legislatures across the Commonwealth. Their
regional, geographical and cultural diversities make them ideal representatives in
the robust exchange of ideas on global warming and climate change issue across
the world. The CPA usually runs a number of programmes at Branch, regional and
national levels. At these events, the issue of climate change has been discussed
extensively and Members have contributed to the possible solutions through their
national policies. The CPA has been actively discussing global warming and
climate change for the past three years now at its annual conferences; starting
with New Delhi in 2007, Kuala Lumpur in 2008 and most recently Arusha Tanzania
in 2009. The Association has also discussed the issue at the level of the Executive
Committee and has been able to formulate a Task Force on Climate Change for
the purpose.
3
CLIMATE CHANGE AS AN ISSUE
For almost a decade now, the issue of climate change has had agreements and
disagreements as to the cause of the problem. The emergence of the problem in
the 21st Century is manifested by extraordinary carbon emissions leading to
effects such as rising sea levels, extra ordinary drought, over-flooding and other
extreme weather conditions. In general, some scientists have argued that the
major cause for climate change is the increase in carbon dioxide levels in the
atmosphere which has led to the disturbance of the weather patterns across the
globe. However, there are other scientific observers who argue that the issue of
climate change has been hyped by individuals who wish to take advantage of the
situation for their own good. This situation of agreements and counteragreements on the issue has led to the present dilemma in arriving at conclusive
4
global agreements such as what was witnessed recently at the Climate Change
Conference in Copenhagen, Denmark in December last year.
The emergence of structured global discussions can be summed up by a number
of phases since 1987 when the United Nations established the intergovernmental
panel on climate change.
5
THE MAIN PHASES IN CLIMATE CHANGE DISCUSSIONS
1. Climate Change: Meeting the Challenge
1987 Report by a Commonwealth Group of Experts
In 1987, a year before the United Nations established the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change, the scientific panel charged with evaluating the risks of
global warming, Commonwealth Heads of Government commissioned a landmark
scientific study in 1989 on the effects of variations to the world’s climate.
The study led by eminent British scientist Martin Holgate warned of the
calamitous risks of inaction, including ‘severe tropical storms, floods, droughts or
extremes of heat’, concluding that the poor would be the ‘main victims’ of a rise in
worldwide temperature.
6
Climate Change: Meeting the Challenge’ called for:
 Improved research and monitoring
 National and international adaption strategies
 Safeguards for biological diversity and natural forests
 Reductions in CO2 emissions and energy usage
 Improved coastal defences to manage sea level rise
‘First major intergovernmental report’
The Holdgate report called for a “major international initiative” to establish
“global responsibilities” for preventing unmanageable rises in the world’s
temperature. It also spelt out practical steps which poor and small countries like
7
Guyana, Bangladesh, Maldives, and Pacific islands, could take to monitor their
changing environment.
Articulating the scientific consensus
Vince Cable, deputy leader of the UK political party, the Liberal Democrats, and a
former economic adviser within the Commonwealth Secretariat, helped
contribute to the Holgate study. Looking back, it was “arguably the first major
intergovernmental report” on climate change and sea level rise, he said.
“The conclusions are not controversial now but, at the time, broke new ground,”
Mr Cable recalled. “The group, which included developed and developing country
representatives from a wide range of backgrounds, first set out in rigorous, and
very qualified terms, the then scientific consensus and the consensus
forecast for global warming and sea level rise.”
Dr Holgate and his colleagues in the expert group, explained Mr
Cable, were able to highlight how climate change would “bear down
disproportionately on the world’s poorest people – more exposed to the risks
8
attendant on rain-fed agriculture, very often in the most marginal and disasterprone areas, and with few resources to adapt to change.”
A call to arms for world leaders
The report followed another Commonwealth study, ‘Our Common Future’, which
had developed a definition of the then controversial topic of ‘sustainable
development’ for policy-makers. The Holdgate report led to the development of
the small states grouping, the Alliance of Small Island States, which has lobbied
against big energy producing and consuming countries in the climate debate.
9
2. Langkawi Declaration on Environment, 1989
In October, Commonwealth leaders agreed the Langkawi Declaration on
Environment – a powerful statement which went on to influence the Rio Earth
Summit Declaration of 1992, which still guides the agenda on environmentally
sustainable development.
The Declaration noted that:
‘The current threat to the environment, which is a common concern of all
mankind, stems essentially from past neglect in managing the natural
environment and resources. The environment has been degraded by decades of
industrial and other forms of pollution, including unsafe disposal of toxic wastes,
the burning of fossil fuels, nuclear testing and non-sustainable practices in
agriculture, fishery and forestry.’
10
3. UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, 1992
Under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change negotiated at the 1992
Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro, nations committed to developing and
implementing climate protection measures "appropriate for the specific
conditions of each Party."
In addition, industrialized ("Annex I") countries agreed to
voluntarily reduce their Green House Gas (GHG) emissions to
1990 levels by 2000.
The Convention entered into force in May 1994 and has been
ratified by 186 countries including the United States.
Very few industrialized countries, however, have met the voluntary target.
11
4. Kyoto Protocol, 1997
The 1997 Kyoto Protocol significantly strengthen the 1992 Convention,
establishing binding emission targets for industrialized countries and establishing
a range of mechanisms to encourage cost-effective compliance.
The Kyoto Protocol is an international agreement linked to the United Nations
Framework Convention on Climate Change. The major feature of the Kyoto
Protocol is that it sets binding targets for 37 industrialized countries and the
European community for reducing green house gas emissions .These amount to an
average of five per cent against 1990 levels over the five-year period 2008-2012.
The major distinction between the Protocol and the Convention
is that while the Convention encouraged industrialised countries
to stabilize GHG emissions, the Protocol commits them to do so.
12
Recognizing that developed countries are principally responsible for the current
high levels of GHG emissions in the atmosphere as a result of more than 150 years
of industrial activity, the Protocol places a heavier burden on developed nations
under the principle of “common but differentiated responsibilities.”
The Kyoto Protocol was adopted in Kyoto, Japan, on 11 December 1997 and
entered into force on 16 February 2005. 184 Parties of the Convention have
ratified its Protocol to date. The detailed rules for the implementation of the
Protocol were adopted at COP 7 in Marrakesh in 2001, and are called the
“Marrakesh Accords.”
13
5. Lake Victoria Action Plan, 2007
In 2007, Commonwealth Heads of Government agreed the
Lake Victoria Commonwealth Climate Change Action Plan, a
statement of intent by governments to work both individually
and collectively on climate change.
The plan highlights six areas for co-operation:
1. Strengthening quality and participation in climate change
negotiations.
2. Promoting action through Commonwealth networks to deepen consideration
of the economic and human aspects of climate change.
3. Improving land use management and sustainable use of forest resources
(including widened international support for the Iwokrama Programme).
14
4. Studying the sustainability of fresh agricultural produce and exports from
developing countries
5. Supporting natural disaster management in member countries.
6. Providing technical assistance to least developed countries and small states.
15
6.
The CPA Malaysia and Tanzania Deliberations
As mentioned before, the Parliamentarians of the CPA have been discussing this
matter for some time now. At its annual conference in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia,
the CPA called for the establishment of a Task Force on Climate Change which was
further enriched by the Executive Committee in Bermuda. In Bermuda the
Executive Committee provided for seed funds to be able to follow up on the issue.
This has enabled the holding of web conferences and research on the events
surrounding the issue. In Arusha, Tanzania the CPA Members continued to discuss
the issue of climate change as it affects large, small, island and sub-continent
states, as well as rich and poor nations. The conference deliberated that
Members of Parliament need to vigorously follow up the issue of climate change
at the global level in order for Parliamentarians to be prepared to work on
appropriate legislation when the time comes to do so. The conference summary
containing this recommendation was distributed to all our Branches and partner
organisations, including the Commonwealth Secretariat and the United Nations.
The purpose of the distribution was to disseminate what the CPA Parliamentarians
16
thought about the problems and prospects surrounding the climate change
problem.
17
7. Port of Spain Climate Change Consensus:
The Commonwealth Climate Change Declaration, 2009
Commonwealth leaders met in Port of Spain, Trinidad and
Tobago days after pledges by the US and China in November
to limit their greenhouse gas emissions, amid concerns that
the Copenhagen meeting on climate change could fail to
agree substantial cuts.
Commonwealth leaders in their Declaration backed a multi-billion-dollar plan to
help developing nations to deal with climate change and cut greenhouse gases.
The Commonwealth Climate Declaration does emphasise that "an internationally
binding agreement is essential" but then concedes in the next sentence that "a full
legally binding outcome" will have to wait until 2010.
18
Commonwealth leaders "welcomed the initiative to establish, as part of a
comprehensive agreement, a Copenhagen Launch Fund starting in 2010 and
building to a level of resources of $10 billion annually by 2012".
The Declaration noted that "fast start funding" for adaptation should be focused
on the most vulnerable countries. "We also recognise the need for further,
specified and comparable funding streams, to assist the poorest and most
vulnerable countries, to cope with, and adapt to the adverse impacts of climate
change. We recognise that funding will be scaled up beyond 2012."
19
8. Copenhagen Accord, 2009
An agreement dubbed the Copenhagen Accord drawn up by a limited group of
countries was formally accepted by the Conference of the Parties to the UN
Framework Convention on Climate Change (COP15) during the closing session.
“The conference of the parties takes note of the Copenhagen Accord,” says a final
decision.
The text is still strongly debated, and it remains to be seen how many countries
will sign on to the Copenhagen Accord.
20
Indian Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh called it a "good deal" and told
Hindustan Times that India had "upheld the interests of developing nations" and
their "national sovereignty".
Global warming: The Accord agrees that global temperature rise should stay
below 2C (3.6F).
Reducing greenhouse gases: The treaty did not include any numerical targets for
cutting pollution.
Measuring emissions reductions: China refused to accept international monitoring
but agreed countries must measure their own emissions and report to the outside
world.
Finance to help developing nations adapt: Rich nations will provide 30bn dollars in
total by 2012 and 100bn per annum by 2020 to help poor countries adapt to
climate change.
21
Forests: The Accord will set up a new fund that pays poor nations not to chop
down trees.
Technology transfer: The world agreed to share information on new technology
that will help countries adapt to climate change and generate clean energy.
Carbon markets: Markets are mentioned as a "cost effective way" to cut
emissions.
22
THE WAY FORWARD
Similar to other global issues, the CPA will continue to work within itself and with
other Parliamentary bodies, and with the international community to arrive at
global agreements for tangible policies and legislation to implement climate
change solutions. It was for this reason that the CPA, represented in Copenhagen
by a few Parliamentarians and Secretariat Staff teamed up with other
Parliamentary bodies – Association of European Parliamentarians for Africa
(AWEPA), GLOBE International, and Parliamentary Network on the World Bank
(PNOWB) – to issue a statement on the Copenhagen Climate Change
deliberations. A Recommendation will be made to the Executive Committee to
increase the funds with which the Parliamentarians in the CPA could participate in
greater measure than before to ensure that their ideas and recommendations are
considered at global level.
I thank you.
23