Download Extreme!Events!and!Climate!

Document related concepts

German Climate Action Plan 2050 wikipedia , lookup

Global warming controversy wikipedia , lookup

Heaven and Earth (book) wikipedia , lookup

Numerical weather prediction wikipedia , lookup

Global warming hiatus wikipedia , lookup

ExxonMobil climate change controversy wikipedia , lookup

Soon and Baliunas controversy wikipedia , lookup

Climatic Research Unit email controversy wikipedia , lookup

Michael E. Mann wikipedia , lookup

Politics of global warming wikipedia , lookup

Climate change denial wikipedia , lookup

Global warming wikipedia , lookup

Climate resilience wikipedia , lookup

Fred Singer wikipedia , lookup

Atmospheric model wikipedia , lookup

Economics of global warming wikipedia , lookup

Climate change feedback wikipedia , lookup

Instrumental temperature record wikipedia , lookup

Climate engineering wikipedia , lookup

Climate change adaptation wikipedia , lookup

Effects of global warming on human health wikipedia , lookup

Climate change and agriculture wikipedia , lookup

Climatic Research Unit documents wikipedia , lookup

Climate governance wikipedia , lookup

Climate change in Tuvalu wikipedia , lookup

Citizens' Climate Lobby wikipedia , lookup

Climate sensitivity wikipedia , lookup

Effects of global warming wikipedia , lookup

Media coverage of global warming wikipedia , lookup

Solar radiation management wikipedia , lookup

Scientific opinion on climate change wikipedia , lookup

Public opinion on global warming wikipedia , lookup

Climate change in the United States wikipedia , lookup

Attribution of recent climate change wikipedia , lookup

Climate change and poverty wikipedia , lookup

IPCC Fourth Assessment Report wikipedia , lookup

Years of Living Dangerously wikipedia , lookup

Surveys of scientists' views on climate change wikipedia , lookup

General circulation model wikipedia , lookup

Effects of global warming on humans wikipedia , lookup

Climate change, industry and society wikipedia , lookup

Transcript
!
!
!
!
14th!Swiss!Climate!Summer!School!
!
Extreme!Events!and!Climate!
!
!
Congressi!Stefano!Franscini,!Monte!
Verità! !
23!–!28!August!2015!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
Supporting!bodies!
!
!
Center!for!Climate!Systems!Modeling!
ETH!Zurich!
CHN!L12.2!
Universitätsstr.!16!
CH98092!Zurich!
http://www.c2sm.ethz.ch/!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!!!!!
!
Monte!Verità!
Via!Collina!!
CH96612!Ascona!
http://www.csf.ethz.ch!!
!
ETH!Zurich!
Rämistrasse!101!
8092!Zurich!
https://www.ethz.ch!
!
University!of!Bern!
Oeschger!Centre!
Zähringerstrasse!25!
CH93012!Bern!
http://www.oeschger.unibe.ch!
!
Swiss!Reinsurance!Company!
Mythenquai!50/60!
P.O.!Box!
CH98022!Zürich!
http://www.swissre.com!
!
!
!
Federal!Office!of!Meteorology!and!
Climatology!
Meteoswiss!
Operation!Center,!B.O.!Box!257!
CH98058!Zurich9Flughafen!
http://www.meteoswiss.ch!
!
!
!
!
!
The!Global!Energy!and!Water!Cycle!
Experiment!
http://www.gewex.com!
!
World!Climate!Research!Programme!!
7bis!Avenue!de!la!Paix,!!
Case!postale!2300!Nations!
CH91211!Geneva!
http://wcrp9climate.org!
!
Table of Contents
Aebi
Christine
Cloud Radiative Effect depending on Cloud
Type and Cloud Fraction
1
Agel
Laurie
Exploring the Dynamical Causes of Northeast
US Extreme Precipitation
3
Alvarez-Castro
M. Carmen
European summer heatwaves and North
Atlantic weather regimes in the last
Millennium
5
Battaglia
Gianna
Probabilistic Estimates of Marine N2O
Emissions
6
Bernet
Daniel
Flood damage claims of houseowners
promise insights about surface runoff in
Switzerland
8
Bevacqua
Emanuele
Statistical Modelling of Compound Floods
10
Blumer
Sandro R.
Extreme Winter Cyclones in the North Atlantic
in a CESM1.0.1 Last Millennium Climate
Simulation”
12
Borodina
Aleksandra
Robust changes in extreme events
13
Brugger
Sandra O.
FROZENFIRE – a contribution to Paleo Fires
from high-alpine ice cores over the last two
millennia
14
Lukas
Blocking detection with observations from
radio occultation: A case study
16
Buzan
Jonathan
The importance of including the globe
temperature (radiation) in the Wet Bulb Globe
Temperature index
17
Colfescu
Ioana
Evaluation of Mechanisms of Extreme
Temperatures over Europe and North
America
19
Crasemann
Berit
Impact of Arctic Sea Ice on Circulation
Patterns, Planetary and Baroclinic Waves
20
Doroszkiewicz
Joanna
Estimation of flood-adaptation indices in
varying climatic conditions
22
Duchez
Aurelie
The role of the ocean on the development of
European weather extremes
Rebecca
Understanding the Characteristics and
Predictability of
Flood Events at the Global Scale
26
Erhardt
Tobias
What controls atmospheric particle sizes over
the Greenland ice sheet? – Influence of
changing deposition regimes
28
Gibson
Peter B.
Synoptic variability in the CMIP5 models over
Australia: implications for the simulation of
extreme heat
30
Gómez-Navarro
Juan José
Exploring nearly on-in-a-millennium scenarios
of extreme rainfall through dynamically
downscaling palaeoclimatic simulations
32
Brunner
Emerton
24
Hakala
Kirsti
Hydrological climate change impact
assessment – addressing the uncertainties
34
Hauser
Mathias
Role of soil moisture vs. recent climate
change for heat waves in western Russia
35
Huhtamaa
Heli
Crop failures and extreme climate events in
historical Finland
36
Ionita
Monika
Predicting the June 2013 European Flooding
based on Precipitation, Soil Moisture and Sea
Level Pressure
38
Keller
Louise
Response surfaces of Swiss flood events to
enable and evaluate robust adaptation
39
Kis
Anna
Analysis of extreme precipitation indices in
the Carpathian Region using regional climate
model simulations
41
Lenggenhager
Sina
The role of atmospheric blockings in central
European flood events – A casestudy
43
Lienert
Sebastian
Interannual variations of NPP in European
forests
45
Lo
Shih-how
Projecting high-resolution extreme climate
indices with observational constrain
47
Loughran
Tammas
The Influence of Climate Variability on
Australian Heat Wave Frequency, Duration
and Intensity
49
Abdul
Statistical Evidence of the Influence of Solar
Activity on Atlantic Multi-decadal Oscillation
(AMO) and All Indian Summer Monsoon
Rainfall (AISMR) in Climate Model
Simulations
50
Maruša
Consideration of risks, connected to extreme
weather events, in spatial planning of energy
infrastructure
52
Meresa
Hadush K.
Nonstationary Precipitation Implication on
precipitation maximum propability Curves for
Hydraulic Infrastructure Design in a Changing
Climate
54
Messmer
Martina
Past, present and future impact of Vbcyclones on extreme precipitation over
Central Europe
56
Daniel
Understanding Extremes: A Multi-proxy, High
Resolution Record of Wildfire and
Precipitation History from Basin Pond, Maine,
USA
58
Fadzil
Understanding the Development of Deep
Convection over the western Malaysian
Peninsula during Inter Monsoon
60
Monhart
Samuel
HEPS4Power – Extended-range
Hydrometeorological Ensemble Predictions
for Improved Hydropower Operations and
Revenues
62
Nicolai-Shaw
Nadine
Drivers of soil moisture at the global scale
64
O
Sungmin
Uncertainties in measured extreme
precipitation events
66
Nadav
Assessing hydrological regime sensitivity to
climate change in a convective rainfall
environment: a case study of medium-sized
eastern Mediterranean catchments
68
Malik
Matko
Miller
Mohd Nor
Peleg
Pistotnik
Georg
Probabilistic Modeling of the European
Severe Thunderstorm Climate
70
Pregnolato
Maria
Extreme Weather Events Impact Modelling: a
Transport Case Study
72
Prein
Andreas
A review on regional convection-permitting
climate modeling: Demonstrations, prospects,
and challenges
74
Ragettli
Martina
Evaluation of heat-related mortality and
adaptation measures in Switzerland
76
Rey
Fabian
Exploring eight millennia of climatic,
vegetational and agricultural dynamics on the
Swiss Plateau by using annually layered
sedimentary time series
78
Richardson
Doug
Drought forecasting using statistical methods
80
Rothlisberger
Matthias
A climatology of synoptic-scale Rossby wave
triggering events
82
Rugenstein
Maria
Atmospheric and oceanic warming patterns
depend non-linearly on the forcing magnitude
84
Savre
Julien
Development of a hybrid finite-element Cloud
Resolving Model including grid adaptivity
85
Benjamin
Added value of very high resolution model
simulations for the coasts of Northern
Germany using the example of two case
studies of extra- tropical cyclones
87
Schaaf
Katharina
Exploring the causes of rare extreme
precipitation
events in the south-eastern Alpine foreland
region
88
Schubert-Frisius
Martina
A global regionalization of NCEP-Reanalysis
using a high resolution general circulation
model
90
Schwander
Mikhaël
Analysis of solar influence on tropospheric
weather using a new time series of weather
types
91
Strobach
Ehud
Decadal Climate Predictions Using
Sequential Learning Algorithms
93
Thiery
Wim
Hazardous thunderstorms over Lake Victoria:
climate change and early warnings
95
Trefalt
Simona
Radar Characteristics and Patterns Related
to Convective Wind Gusts in Switzerland
96
Tuinenburg
Obbe
A new classification of atmospheric droughts
98
Tuttenuj
Daniel
Extreme River Floods in Western Switzerland
and the Lake of Constance Region in the
Period Prior to Instrumental Measurements
99
Usui
Takafumi
Adaptation decisions and damage costs
under uncertainty in an empirical general
equilibrium framework
100
Volonte
Ambrogio
Sting Jet analyses in extratropical cyclones
103
Schröer
Claudia
The impact of increased Mediterranean sea
surface temperatures on central European
extreme precipitation
105
Weber
Helga
Remote sensing of past and recent fires:
Assessing the accuracy of different satellite
products
107
Wild
Simon
Was the extreme storm season 2013-14 over
the North Atlantic and the UK triggered by
changes in the West-Pacific Warm Pool?
109
Wilson
Louise
Projections of Australian Regional
Temperature Extremes from CMIP5 Models
110
Zarrineh
Nina
Searching for synergies in crop rotation
manage- ment – A simulation-optimization
approach
112
Zbinden
Eveline
Catastrophic Magdalena or not? The flood
events of AD 1342 in Central Europe
114
Ziehmer
Malin Michelle
Early to Mid-Holocene climate variability from
multi-millennial tree ring isotope records
116
Volosciuk
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Cloud Radiative Effect depending on Cloud Type
and Cloud Fraction
Christine Aebi (1,2), Julian Gröbner (1), Niklaus Kämpfer (2), Laurent
Vuilleumier (3)
(1) Physikalisch-Meteorologisches Observatorium Davos, World Radiation
Center, Davos, Switzerland
(2) Oeschger Center for Climate Change Research and Institute of Applied
Physics, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
(3) Federal Office of Meteorology and Climatology MeteoSwiss, Payerne,
Switzerland
Radiative transfer of energy in the atmosphere and the influence of clouds on the
radiation budget remain the greatest sources of uncertainty in the simulation of
climate change. Small changes in cloudiness and radiation can have large
impacts on the Earth’s climate. Depending on the wavelength range, the effect of
clouds on the radiation budget can have an opposing sign. For assessing this
effect and the corresponding changes, frequent and more precise radiation and
cloud observations are necessary.
The role of clouds on the surface radiation budget is studied in order to quantify
the longwave, shortwave and the total cloud radiative effect (CRE) depending on
the atmospheric composition and cloud type. The study is performed for three
different sites in Switzerland at three different altitude levels: Payerne (490 m
asl), Davos (1’560 m asl) and Jungfraujoch (3’580 m asl).
On the basis of data of visible all-sky camera systems at the three
aforementioned stations in Switzerland, up to six different cloud types are
distinguished (Cirrus-Cirrostratus, Cirrocumulus-Altocumulus, Stratus-Altostratus,
Cumulus, Stratocumulus and Cumulonimbus-Nimbostratus). These cloud types
are classified with a modified algorithm of Heinle et al. (2010). This cloud type
classifying algorithm is based on a set of statistical features describing the color
(spectral features) and the texture of an image (textural features) (Wacker et al.,
2015). The calculation of the fractional cloud cover information is based on
spectral information of the all-sky camera data. The radiation data are taken from
measurements with pyranometers and pyrgeometers at the different stations.
First we calculate the longwave and shortwave CRE for cases where only one
cloud type is present. This calculation is performed for the two stations
Jungfraujoch and Payerne and the six different cloud types separately. On the
basis of case studies we get a better understanding about the influencing factors
1
of the CRE. In a second step we want to expand the study in order to calculate a
climatology over a whole year of the longwave and shortwave CRE and its
sensitivity to integrated water vapor, cloud cover and cloud type for the three
above-mentioned stations in Switzerland. For the calculation of the shortwave
and longwave CRE the corresponding cloud-free reference models developed at
PMOD/WRC are used (Wacker et al., 2013). As the study is restricted to daytime
data so far (due to cameras measuring in the visible), we are developing an allsky thermal infrared cloud cam (IRCCAM), which enables nighttime
measurements and analyses as well.
References
Heinle, A., A. Macke and A. Srivastav (2010) Automatic cloud classification of
whole sky images, Atmospheric Measurement Techniques.
Wacker, S., J. Gröbner and L. Vuilleumier (2013) A method to calculate cloudfree long-wave irradiance at the surface based on radiative transfer modeling and
temperature lapse rate estimates, Theoretical and Applied Climatology.
Wacker, S., J. Gröbner, C. Zysset, L. Diener, P. Tzoumanikis, A. Kazantzidis, L.
Vuilleumier, R. Stöckli, S. Nyeki, and N. Kämpfer (2015) Cloud observations in
Switzerland using hemispherical sky cameras, Journal of Geophysical Research.
2
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Exploring the Dynamical Causes of Northeast US
Extreme Precipitation
Laurie Agel (1), Mathew Barlow (1)
(1) Department of Environmental, Earth, and Atmospheric Sciences,
University of Massachusetts Lowell, Lowell, MA
Extreme precipitation in the Northeast US (NE) can have devastating
impacts on health, economies and infrastructure due to flooding and significant
snowfall. This research examines the nature of NE extreme precipitation, and
identifies the key ingredients and underlying dynamics associated with these
events. Daily station precipitation data (1979-2008) from 35 sites of the United
States Historical Climatology Network (USHCN; Easterling et al. 1999) are used
to identify the dates of the top 1% of precipitation at each station. The extreme
precipitation on these dates displays a seasonal cycle that is distinct between
inland and coastal regions, and is strongly linked to synoptic storm tracks. Most
NE extreme precipitation occurs embedded in precipitation events of 3-5-day
duration; however extreme precipitation itself is generally confined to single-day
events, suggesting a combination of synoptic and mesoscale mechanisms. A
number of methods are used to determine the ingredients and underlying
dynamics (synoptic and local circulation, moisture availability and pathways,
stability, etc.) associated with these seasonal and regional events including
composites, pattern identification, trajectories, and Q-vector analysis.
In this poster, we present the results of two types of pattern identification
techniques to analyze NE extreme precipitation. The first utilizes the k-means
clustering technique, which employs an iterative algorithm to separate events into
a set number of groups, or clusters, that minimizes the squared Euclidean pointto-centroid distance within each cluster. Because synoptic storms are strongly
linked to the extremes, Modern-Era Retrospective Analysis (MERRA; Reinecker
et al. 2011) blended daily tropopause heights over the domain -100°W to -60°W
and 30°N-54°N, on extreme dates only, are used as input to the k-means
algorithm. Objective techniques identify two preferred partitionings – one with
three clusters and one with 7 clusters. The 3-cluster solution (Figure 1a) shows a
deep trough with its axis aligned NE-SW from the Great Lakes into the Gulf
region, an eastern ridge pattern, and a trough with its axis aligned NW-SE across
the Mid-Atlantic states. The 7-cluster solution shows two variations of each of the
three previous clusters, with an additional shallow trough across southern
Ontario. The second technique utilizes Self-Organizing Maps (SOMs), in which
the continuous pattern space occupied by a field is discretized into a twodimensional array of pattern characteristics. Daily MERRA blended tropopause
heights (1979-2008) are input to the SOM routine to create various pattern
3
mappings, including a 5x6 solution (Figure 1b). The percent of extreme days as
well as the percent of each k-means cluster that is accounted for by each SOM
pattern is calculated. In this manner we are able to identify the key synoptic
circulation patterns that are linked to extreme precipitation in finer detail than
provided by either pattern technique alone. For patterns that explain the most
extreme dates, we then generate composites of other meteorological fields such
as moisture convergence, vertical ascent, baroclinicity, and stability, to develop a
more complete picture of the key ingredients and dynamics underlying extreme
NE precipitation.
References
Easterling, D. R., T. R. Karl, J. H. Lawrimore, and S. A. Del Greco, 1999: United
States Historical Climatology Network daily temperature, precipitation, and
snow data for 1871–1997. ORNL/ CDIAC-118, NDP-070. Carbon Dioxide
Information Analysis Center, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN,
84 pp.
Kohonen, T., 1995: Self-organizing maps, 2nd edn. Springer, Berlin.
Michelangeli, P., R. Vautard, and B. Legras, 1995: Weather Regimes:
Recurrence and Quasi Stationarity. J. Atmos. Sci., 52, 1237–1256.
Rienecker, M. M., and Coauthors, 2011: MERRA: NASA’s Modern-Era
Retrospective Analysis for Research and Applications. J. Climate, 24, 3624–
3648.
Figure 1. MERRA blended tropopause height anomalies for a) k-means clusters
of extreme precipitation days only, and b) SOM patterns for all days 1979-2008.
The frequency of each pattern and the percent of extreme dates accounted for by
pattern are shown above each SOM panel.
4
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
European summer heatwaves and North Atlantic
weather regimes in the last Millennium
M.Carmen Alvarez-Castro*, Romain Trasancos, Pascal Yiou
IPSL-LSCE CEA-Saclay, Orme des Merisiers, 91191 Gif-sur-Yvette, France
*[email protected]
Abstract
The European summer heatwaves have been increasing in frequency and magnitude in
the past decades. A higher confidence in future changes in such extremes necessitates to
have a better knowledge about extremes behavior in the past climate. The last millennium is well documented in terms of climate forcings. Modelling e↵orts have provided
a wealth of climate simulations covering the last millennium. We want to exploit such
data in order to assess how models simulate extreme summer heatwaves.
The surface temperature and precipitation are closely related to atmospheric patterns. It has been shown that rainy winter/spring seasons reduce the frequency of hot
summer days whereas dry seasons can be followed by summers with high or low frequency
of hot days. In this poster, we show the relation between winter/spring precipitation with
the frequency of hot days in the 10 hottest summers in Europe and Southern Europe
during the Medieval Warm Period (MWP 1150-1250), the Little Ice Age (LIA 16501750), and the historical-present period (1850-2005). We first focus on a millennium
simulations with the IPSL model (IPSL-CM5). We use daily temperature, precipitation, and SLP data from CMIP5 (Coupled Model Intercomparison Project phase 5) and
a couple of IPSL simulations with diferents forcings. Summer weather regimes has been
computed as well for NCEP and 20th Century reanalysis data sea level pressure data in
order to compare observations with the same period (1948-2005) in CMIP5 and IPSL
simulations outputs.
We discuss and present the results comparing the e↵ects of hydrological deficits in
the preceding season, and the occurrence of specific weather regimes, during the hottest
summers over Europe and SouthWestern Europe. This analysis compares di↵erents
climate forcings simulations.
5
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Probabilistic Estimates of Marine N2 O Emissions
Gianna Battaglia, Fortunat Joos
Climate and Environmental Physics, Physics Institute and Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
Nitrous oxide (N2 O) is an atmospheric trace gas (pre-industrial level ⇠270 ppb, currently ⇠325
ppb, increasing by ⇠0.25% yr 1 ) that plays important roles in the stratospheric ozone cycle and as
a greenhouse trace gas that, molecule by molecule is 200 times more e↵ective than CO2 (Gruber ,
2008). N2 O is emitted to the atmosphere naturally from poorly constrained microbial processes
on land (⇠6 Tg N yr 1 ) and from the oceans (⇠4 Tg N yr 1 ) and anthropogenically (⇠10 Tg
N yr 1 ) as a result of, for instance, agriculture, fossil fuel or biomass and biofuel burning (Ciais
et al., 2013). In the atmosphere, N2 O undergoes photodissociation with a lifetime of ⇠120 yr (Ciais
et al., 2013). The uncertainties in the natural emissions of N2 O to the atmosphere, including their
sensitivities to environmental conditions, however, are high: The latest estimates given by the
IPCC for marine N2 O sources, for instance, range from 1.8-9.4 TgN yr 1 citepCiais2013. It is
therefore important, to better understand the processes and sensitivities controlling marine N2 O
emissions to the atmosphere.
In the oceans, chemo-autotrophic nitrification and chemo-heterotrophic denitrification processes
impact N2 O. Both processes are tightly linked to the cycling of organic matter. Nitrifiers oxidize
NH3 + - which is produced by remineralization of organic matter - to NO3 with oxygen as their
source of energy where a small fraction of the nitrogen ends up as N2 O as a side-product. This
N2 O yield has been proposed to depend on oxygen concentrations, but is is unclear whether it
increases linearly or exponentially (Suntharalingam et al., 2000; Jin and Gruber , 2003; Nevison,
2003; Zamora et al., 2012; Zamora and Oschlies, 2014). In the denitrification pathway - where NO3
is used as terminal electron acceptor for the oxidation of organic matter in the absence of oxygen
- N2 O represents an intermediary product during the reduction of NO3 to N2 . It is unclear, at
which oxygen concentrations denitrification sets in and at which rates the individual steps proceed
(Zamora et al., 2012; Zamora and Oschlies, 2014; Babbin et al., 2015). As a consequence the
relative importance of the two production pathways is still debated.
We implemented di↵erent N2 O production schemes (Butler et al., 2000; Suntharalingam et al.,
2000; Jin and Gruber , 2003; Nevison, 2003; Zamora et al., 2012; Zamora and Oschlies, 2014)
accounting for the mentioned uncertainties in our cost-efficient Bern3D Earth-System Model of
Intermediate Complexity. The Bern3D model features a 3-D frictional-geostrophic ocean and an
OCMIP2-type marine carbon cycle (Ritz et al., 2011). We optimize the proposed parameters
governing N2 O production within the water column in a probabilistic, Monte-Carlo-type, Bayesian
framework (Steinacher et al., 2013) by applying observed dissolved N2 O data as a constraint.
Dissolved N2 O measurements have recently been compiled within the MEMENTO database (Bange
et al., 2009). N2 O emissions of the observation-constrained model ensemble will then be determined
for both future and past (e.g. Younger-Dryas) environmental conditions.
1
6
Bibliography
Babbin, a. R., D. Bianchi, a. Jayakumar, and B. B. Ward (2015), Rapid nitrous oxide cycling in
the suboxic ocean, Science, 348 (6239), 1127–1129, doi:10.1126/science.aaa8380.
Bange, H. W., T. G. Bell, M. Cornejo, A. Freing, G. Uher, R. C. Upstill-Goddard, and G. Zhang
(2009), MEMENTO: a proposal to develop a database of marine nitrous oxide and methane
measurements, Environ. Chem., 6 (3), 195–197, doi:10.1071/EN09033.
Butler, J. H., J. W. Elkins, T. M. Thompson, and K. B. Egan (2000), Tropospheric and Dissolved
N2O of the West Pacific and East Indian Oceans During the El Nino Southern Oscillation Event
of 1987, Journal of Geophysical Research, 94.
Ciais, P., C. Sabine, G. Bala, L. Bopp, V. Brovkin, J. Canadell, C. A., R. DeFries, G. J.,
M. Heimann, C. Jones, C. Le Quéré, R. Myneni, P. S., and P. Thornton (2013), Carbon and
Other Biogeochemical Cycles, in Climate Change 2013: The Physical Science Basis. Working
Group 1 Contribution to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
Change.
Gruber, N. (2008), The Marine Nitrogen Cycle:
10.1016/B978-0-12-372522-6.00001-3.
Overview and Challenges, 1–50 pp., doi:
Jin, X., and N. Gruber (2003), O↵setting the radiative benefit of ocean iron fertilization by enhancing N2O emissions, Geophysical Research Letters, 30 (24), 2249, doi:10.1029/2003GL018458.
Nevison, C. (2003), Global distribution of N2O and the deltaN2O-AOU yield in the subsurface
ocean, Global Biogeochemical Cycles, 17 (4), 1–18, doi:10.1029/2003GB002068.
Ritz, S. P., T. F. Stocker, and F. Joos (2011), A coupled dynamical ocean-energy balance atmosphere model for paleoclimate studies, J. Climate, 24 (2), 349–375, doi:10.1175/2010JCLI3351.1.
Steinacher, M., F. Joos, and T. F. Stocker (2013), Allowable carbon emissions lowered by multiple
climate targets., Nature, 499 (7457), 197–201, doi:10.1038/nature12269.
Suntharalingam, P., J. L. Sarmiento, and J. R. Toggweiler (2000), Global significance of nitrousoxide production and transport from oceanic low-oxygen zones: A modeling study, Global Biogeochem. Cy., 14 (4), 1353–1370, doi:10.1029/1999GB900100.
Zamora, L. M., and A. Oschlies (2014), Surface nitrification: A major uncertainty in marine N2O
emissions, Geophysical Research Letters, 41, 4247–4253, doi:10.1002/2014GL060556.
Zamora, L. M., a. Oschlies, H. W. Bange, K. B. Huebert, J. D. Craig, a. Kock, and C. R. Löscher
(2012), Nitrous oxide dynamics in low oxygen regions of the Pacific: Insights from the MEMENTO database, Biogeosciences, 9 (12), 5007–5022, doi:10.5194/bg-9-5007-2012.
2
7
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Flood damage claims of houseowners promise
insights about surface runoff in Switzerland
Bernet D. (1), Prasuhn V. (2), Weingartner R. (1)
(1) Institute of Geography & Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research
& Mobiliar Lab for Natural Risks, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
(2) Agroscope, Institute for Sustainability Sciences ISS, Zurich, Switzerland
A few case studies exemplify that surface runoff, understood as flash floods
explicitly formed and propagating outside of the river network, may be
responsible for a large share of flood damages in Switzerland (e.g. Bezzola,
Hegg 2008). A couple of practical methodologies exist, with which the hazard of
surface runoff can be estimated (Kipfer et al. 2012; Rüttimann, Egli 2010). In
general, however, little is known about when, where and why surface runoff
occurs.
Flash floods caused by surface runoff have very short response times, occur
rather diffusely and are therefore very difficult to observe and measure directly.
Furthermore, surface runoff events generally do not leave silent witnesses, which
could be used to analyze the process. A promising source that might indicate
surface runoff indirectly, are damage claims of houseowners recorded by Public
Insurance Companies for Buildings (PICB). In 19 out of the total 26 Cantons of
Switzerland, PICB hold a monopoly position and insure (almost) every building
within the respective administrative zones. Therefore, each damage to buildings
caused by an insured natural hazard, which includes flooding from surface runoff,
are generally registered within the respective Canton.
To address the knowledge gap concerning surface runoff, all 19 PICB were
inquired to provide damage claim records of houseowners. Overall, 14 approved
our inquiry and delivered gapless flood damage records covering the past 9 to 35
years (22 years on average) counting over 80’000 flood related damages. The
minimal provided information of each damage claim is the location (address) and
the date of the damage.
The delivered data are heterogeneous and, consequently, time-consuming to
harmonize. Nevertheless, the large areal and temporal coverage of the provided
data records promise that robust, quantitative statements about surface runoff as
a natural hazard can be made. Preliminary analysis show that exploiting damage
claim records of PICB to learn more about surface runoff is feasible and
worthwhile.
8
References
Bezzola, G.R.; Hegg, C. (Eds.) (2008): Ereignisanalyse Hochwasser 2005. Teil 2
- Analyse von Prozessen, Massnahmen und Gefahrengrundlagen. Bundesamt
für Umwelt BAFU, Eidgenössische Forschungsanstalt WSL. Bern
(Umweltwissen, Nr. 0825).
Kipfer, A.; Kienholz, C.; Liener, S. (2012): Ein neuer Ansatz zur Modellierung von
Oberflächenabfluss. In Gernot Koboltschnig, Johannes Hübl, Julia Braun (Eds.):
12th Congress INTERPRAEVENT 2012. Proceedings : 23-26 April 2012,
Grenoble, France. Klagenfurt: International Research Society
INTERPRAEVENT, pp. 179–189.
Rüttimann, D.; Egli, T. (2010): Wegleitung Punktuelle Gefahrenabklärung
Oberflächenwasser: Naturgefahrenkommission Kanton St. Gallen.
9
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Statistical Modelling of Compound Floods
E. Bevacqua (1), D. Maraun (1), M. Widmann (2), M. Vrac (3)
(1) Ocean Circulation and Climate Dynamics, GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel, Kiel, Germany.
(2) School of Geography, Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
(3) Laboratoire des Sciences du Climat et de l’Environnement, IPSL, CNRS, Centre d’Etude de Saclay, Gif‐sur‐
Yvette, France.
In the recent report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change on
extreme events it has been highlighted that extreme compound events (CEs) has
received little attention so far (Seneviratne et al., 2012). CEs are multivariate
extreme events in which the individual contributing events might not be extreme
themselves, but their joint occurrence causes an extreme impact (Leonard et al.,
2013).
We develop a multivariate statistical model to analyse the physical mechanisms
underlying CEs and to quantify the risk associated with these events, both in
present and future climate. Particularly, a function describing the impact of these
events is defined to quantify their associated risk. The multivariate model is
based on pair-copula constructions (PCCs) and includes meteorological
predictors. The key idea of the copula approach is to build the multivariate
distributions modeling the marginal distributions separately from the dependence
structure among variables. Copula flexibility is however limited to model highdimensional dependence structures, so here PCCs is used. In PCC the
dependence structure is decomposed into two-dimensional copulas, some of
which are conditional (Hobæk Haff et al., 2015).
Here is presented a first application about compound flood (joint storm surge and
high runoff) for Ravenna, Italian Adriatic area. The modeled situation is that
showed in the image below. Variables indicates water level of sea or rivers.
Hourly data from the last 5 years during the period November-February were
selected.
The X variables are used to build the multivariate statistical model using the
PCC. The Impact is defined as the river level in the location of the variable
Y River1 , which is dependent on X variables. We compute the return period of
the impact to asses the flood risk. The Impact function is defined as a quadratic
polynomial combination of X variables such that it fits the Y variable.
Bootstrapping X variables from the built model, we computed the return periods
of the impact variable obtained like the combination of simulated Xs (black line in
the graph below). The red line shows the return period computed directly on the
empirical data from Y River1 , only to show that the results are consistent.
10
In the following table are showed the dependencies of the pair copula selected
for the fitted model.
Pairs Copulas
Kendall's Tau
c Sea R3 (u Sea ,u R3 )
0.19
c R3 R2 (u R3 ,u R2 )
0.45
c Sea R2 ∣ R3 (u Sea , u R2)
0.08
Although the dependencies of the pair copulas c Sea R3 and c Sea R2 ∣ R3 are low,
we show that they are relevant to asses the risk of the flood. In fact, substituting
the c Sea R3 and c Sea R2 ∣ R3 with independent copulas, there is an important
underestimation of the risk, due to a relevant increase of the return period (blue
line in the graph).
It is planned to transfer the model to validate climate models and assess the
future risk of CEs.
References
Seneviratne, S., Nicholls, N., Easterling, D., Goodess, C., Kanae, S., Kossin, J., Luo, Y.,
Marengo, J., McInnes, K., Rahimi, M., Reichstein, M., Sorteberg, A., Vera, C., and
Zhang, X. (2012). Managing the Risks of Extreme Events and Disasters to Advance
Climate Change Adaptation, Cambridge University Press.
Leonard, M., Westra, S., Phatak, A., Lambert, M., van den Hurk, B., McInnes, K.,
Risbey, J., Schuster, S., Jacob, D., and Stafford-Smith, M. (2013). A compound event
framework for understanding extreme impacts. WIREs Clim. Change, doi:
10.1002/wcc.252.
Hobæk Haff, I., A. Frigessi, and D. Maraun (2015), How well do regional climate models
simulate the spatial dependence of precipitation? An application of pair-copula
constructions. J. Geophys. Res. Atmos., 120, 2624–2646. doi: 10.1002/2014JD022748.
11
Swiss Climate Research Summer School on Extreme Events and Climate
Title: “Extreme Winter Cyclones in the North Atlantic in a CESM1.0.1 Last Millennium
Climate Simulation”
Authors: Sandro R. Blumer, Christoph C. Raible, Flavio Lehner, Thomas Stocker
Address: Climate and Environmental Physics, Physics Institute and Oeschger Centre for
Climate Change Research, University of Bern, [email protected]
Abstract
Extreme cyclones and their associated impacts are a major threat to mankind, as they often
result in heavy precipitation events and severe winds. The last millennium is closest to the
Anthropocene and has the best coverage of paleoclimatic information. Therefore, it could
serve as a test bed for estimating natural forcing variations beyond the recent observational
period and could deliver insights into the frequency and intensity of extreme events, including
strong cyclones and their dependency on internal variability and external forcing.
The aim of this study is to investigate how the frequency and intensity of extreme cyclones in
the North Atlantic have changed in the last millennium, in particular during prolonged cold
and warm periods and which changes might be expected for the 21st century.
We use a comprehensive fully-coupled transient climate simulation of the last millennium (AD
1000-2100) with a relatively high spatial (0.9x1.25 degrees) resolution and define six climatic
periods according to prolonged cold or warm phases: Medieval Climate Anomaly (MCA), AD
1150-1200, Little Ice Age (LIA), AD 1450-1500, Maunder Minimum (MMI), AD 1645-1720,
Historical (HIS), AD 1850-2005, Modern (MOD), 1960-2010 and Projection (PRO), AD 20062099. Cyclones are then detected and tracked in 12-hourly output using an algorithm that is
based on the geopotential height field on 1000 hPa. Additionally, two intensity criteria for
extreme cyclones are defined: the 90 percentile of the mean gradient in geopotential and the
90 percentile of the precipitation within a radius of 500 km around the cyclone centre at every
time step during the lifetime of a cyclone. These criteria consider two aspects of cyclone's
intensity: extremes in wind and precipitation.
The results show that extremes of North Atlantic winter cyclone intensity are significantly
stronger with respect to the geopotential height gradient during prolonged cold periods and
weaker during prolonged warm periods. Especially, the projection for the 21st century shows
a significant weakening as the mean of the 90 percentile of the geopotential height gradient
decreases by 4.1 % from MOD to PRO. This intensification of extreme cyclones during
relatively cold periods compared to relatively warm periods can be explained by an increased
meridional temperature gradient accompanied by an increased baroclinicity. In contrast, the
extremes of winter cyclones with respect to precipitation are weaker in the prolonged cold
periods and stronger during warm periods, such that an increase of 4.4 % in the mean of the
90 percentile of total precipitation is estimated from MOD to PRO. This intensification is
expected on the basis of the Clausius-Clapeyron relationship.!
12
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Robust changes in extreme events
Aleksandra Borodina(1), Erich M. Fischer(1) and Reto Knutti(1)
(1) Institute of Atmosphere and Climate, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
Changes in extreme events are of particular relevance due to their potentially severe impacts
on the society and ecosystems. Here we analyze how extreme events (TXx, TNn and
temperature percentiles of daily averages) relate to a mean state (seasonal and yearly
means) in CMIP5 models. Large internal variability obscures this relationship in present day,
however for long term projections this relationship becomes clear. As a result we are able to
deduce by how much the globe has to warm before we can identify regions over which
observational constraint – method that uses present day observations/reanalyses to limit the
range of plausible projections – can be applied. Then we use this method to narrow down the
spread across models, which directly translates into reduced uncertainties associated with
projections.
13
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
FROZENFIRE – a contribution to Paleo Fires from
high-alpine ice cores over the last two millennia
Sandra O. Brugger (1), Erika Gobet (1), Michael Sigl (2), Dimitri Osmont (2),
Daniele Colombaroli (1), Margit Schwikowski (2), Willy Tinner (1)
(1) Institute of Plant Sciences and Oeschger Centre for Climate Research,
Altenbergrain 21, 3013 Bern
(2) Paul Scherrer Institute, OFLB/109, 5232 Villigen
Wild fires are a main ecological disturbance agent across ecosystems worldwide,
driving vegetation dynamics and biomass availability. Fires also regulate the
emission of important greenhouse gases in the atmosphere and hence play a
key role in the global carbon budget. In recent years, devastating, uncontrolled
fires have increasingly occurred on all vegetated continents, resulting in
enormous economic costs (Moritz et al. 2014). Air pollution plumes related to
extreme fire events are of growing concern due to their effect on human health
(Peel et al. 2013). Nevertheless, the drivers for long-term biomass burning trends
are still debated. For the period since 1850 a decoupling of fire activity from
temperature and population density trends was proposed (e.g. the "broken fire
hockey stick"-hypothesis). This may correspond to an increasing landscape
fragmentation, but is unsupported by other data, suggesting that the underlying
processes are not fully understood. In combination with an increasing fire
severity in the recent decades this uncertainty raises major public and scientific
concerns about future management strategies under climate change (Kehrwald
et al. 2013).
Microscopic charcoal (>10µm) as a proxy for fire activity, framboid organic
particles (or soots) as a proxy for fossil fuel combustion, and pollen and spores
as proxies for vegetation composition and agricultural activity preserve in ice
cores over millennia (Eichler et al. 2011).The aim of this project is to reconstruct
regional paleo fire and vegetation history trends in the Mediterranean realm and
Europe, Western and Central Siberia, tropical Amazonia and the Arctic (see
figure 1). The investigated geographical regions either contribute largely to global
fire emissions or provide recent high quality data for proxy calibration. We use
existing ice cores with an excellent chronological control, particularly over the last
150 years. Yearly resolution allows the linkage of modern ice core data with
coinciding satellite images. Further back in time we will compare our data with
existing vegetation and fire records from sedimentary sites stored in the
ALPADABA and NEOTOMA databases to assess the spatio-temporal relevance
of the ice-core inferred data. Climate models will be applied to better understand
the proxy sources. In addition to the optical approaches described here,
paleoclimatic and paleoenvironmental dynamics will be reconstructed by
geochemical means (e.g. oxygen isotopes, black carbon, important ions such as
K+ and Ca+ ), as done in the framework of the SNF-Synergia project Paleo Fires
of which FROZENFIRE is a part. These concerted interdisciplinary and multiproxy
14
efforts will allow us to assess vegetation and societal responses to climatic
change and wildfire disturbance, specifically for the last two millennia
the
period that experienced important climatic changes and an increasing
globalization of economy. Our data will contribute to testing the “broken fire
hockey stick”-hypothesis by disentangling the role of climate, vegetation and
human impacts on biomass burning to significantly advance the understanding of
the role of extreme wildfire events and vegetation responses under future climate
change scenarios.
Figure 1 Location of the glacier sites 1 Colle Gnifetti (Switzerland), 2 Belukha
(Russia), 3 Tsambagarav (Mongolia), 4 Illimani (Bolivia) and 5 Lomonosovfonna
(Svalbard) with schematic indication of main source areas for air mass transport
(grey arrows) overlaid on a map of the mean annual area burned (Giglio et al.
2013).
References
1) Moritz M. A., Batllori E., Bradstock R. A., Gill A. M., Handmer J., Hessburg P.
F., ... & Syphard A. D. (2014): Learning to coexist with wildfire. Nature,
515(7525), 58-66.
2) Peel J. L., Haeuber R., Garcia V., Russell A. G., & Neas L. (2013): Impact of
nitrogen and climate change interactions on ambient air pollution and human
health. Biogeochemistry, 114(1-3), 121-134.
3) Kehrwald N. M., Whitlock C., Barbante C., Brovkin V., Daniau A. L., Kaplan J.
O., ... & Werf G. R. (2013): Fire Research: Linking Past, Present, and Future
Data. Eos, Transactions American Geophysical Union, 94(46), 421-422.
4) Eichler A., Tinner W., Brütsch S., Olivier S., Papina T. & Schwikowski M.
(2011): An ice-core based history of Siberian forest fires since AD 1250.
Quaternary Science Reviews, 30(9), 1027-1034.
5) Giglio L., Randerson J. T. & Werf G. R. (2013): Analysis of daily, monthly, and
annual burned area using the fourth generation global fire emissions database
(GFED4). Journal of Geophysical Research: Biogeosciences, 118(1), 317-328.
15
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate – extended abstract
Blocking detection with observations from radio occultation: A
case study
L. Brunner1,2 , A. K. Steiner1,2,3 , B. Scherllin-Pirscher1,3 , M. W. Jury1
1
Wegener Center for Climate and Global Change (WEGC), University of Graz, Graz, Austria
2
FWF-DK Climate Change, University of Graz, Graz, Austria
3
Institute for Geophysics, Astrophysics, and Meteorology/Institute of Physics, University of Graz, Graz, Austria
Blocking describes an atmospheric situation where a persistent and stationary high pressure system weakens or reverses the westerly flow at mid latitudes. In the northern hemisphere blocking
preferably occurs in the Atlantic/European and the Pacific regions and can trigger heat waves
in summer and cold spells in winter. Due to its contribution to these weather extremes blocking
has been under close scientific investigation in recent years.
So far most of the research focused on blocking analysis in models and reanalysis data sets. We
use for the first time an observational data set based on the Global Positioning System (GPS)
Radio Occultation (RO) method. RO is a satellite-based remote sensing technique utilizing GPS
signals influenced by the Earth’s atmosphere. The WEGC RO retrieval delivers profiles of atmospheric parameters like pressure and geopotential height with global coverage. To validate our
results we also use a reanalysis data set from the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather
Forecasts (ERA-Interim).
Here, we investigate the feasibility of blocking detection in RO data for two exemplary blocking
events: the blocking over Russia in summer 2010 and the blocking over Greenland in late winter
2013. We implemented an adequate sampling strategy for best data exploitation and applied a
commonly used blocking detection method based on meridional geopotential height gradients.
Our results show that both exemplary blocking cases are well represented in RO data. Atmospheric variability is well resolved and the detected blocking patterns are consistent with those
in ERA-Interim. Our findings hence demonstrate that observations from RO are highly useful
for blocking research.
1
16
The importance of including the globe temperature (radiation) in the Wet Bulb Globe Temperature
index
Jonathan R. Buzan (1,2) and Matthew Huber (1,2)
(1) Department of Earth Sciences, University of New Hampshire, Durham, New Hampshire.
(2) Institute for the Study of the Earth, Oceans, and Space, University of New Hampshire, Durham, New
Hampshire.
Heat related issues cause reductions in work capacity, and increases in injury and deaths, globally. In the
Unites States, heat is the number one cause of death from natural disaster [NOAA, 2014]. Heat stress
occurs when the human body is overwhelmed by internal heat production. External heat load prevents
dissipation of internal heat, and quantifying external heat loads is difficult. There is a 100+ year long
history of various methods to quantify heat loads with diagnostic indices [Epstein and Moran, 2006].
High wet bulb temperatures are recognized as the primary external heat load that causes heat stress
[Haldane, 1905]. Short and long wave radiation are non-negligible components of heat load, as well
[Brunt, 1943]. The Wet Bulb Globe Temperature (WBGT) combined temperature, humidity, winds, and
short and long wave radiation to measure heat load, and was developed to reduce military training
casualties [Minard et al., 1957]. WBGT is now an ISO industry standard for diagnosing heat stress in
work place environments [Parsons, 2006; 2013]:
(1)
(2)
Where Tw is the wet bulb temperature, Tglobe is the globe thermometer (a black copper globe that measures
short and long wave radiation and sensible heat fluxes), and T is temperature, all measured in degrees
Celsius. WBGTindoor is the standard for diagnosing heat stress in environments with no solar load and
includes thermal radiation.
Recent applications using global datasets and Earth system models, the WBGT index is diluted by
modifying the standardized equations. These applications omit the radiation term, globe thermometer,
and replace the measurement with temperature [e.g. Dunne et al., 2013; Kjellstrom, 2015]. The authors
justify their modification with the assumption of working conditions are indoors or in the shade, yet, the
standard for indoors/shaded environments calls for measurements of thermal radiation, not temperature.
We aim to improve this situation by implementing the full WBGT into the Community Land Model
version 4.5 [Oleson et al., 2013]. We calculate a theoretical globe thermometer [Liljegren et al., 2008]
and wet bulb temperature using the latest accurate computational methods [Buzan et al., 2015]. The
globe thermometer is calculated above and below the canopy representing all outdoor environments that
workers experience. We show that in shaded forested environments, replacing the radiation term with
temperature overestimates WBGT. This is significant, because human responses to heat stress is nonlinear, and a change in WBGT of 0.5 to 2 increments can be the difference from heavy work restrictions
to mild work restrictions. We also show the differences between a shaded environment with the long
wave radiation term and a non-shaded environment with short and long wave radiation can result in
differences WBGT 1-2 increments regionally, demonstrating the importance of including short and long
wave radiation in all work environments.
References
NOAA. "Don't Let the Heat Have You Beat!" NOAA, 18 June 2014. Last access. 9 June 2015.http://
www.noaa.gov/features/earthobs_0508/heat.html
Brunt, D. (1943), The reactions of the human body to its physical enviroment, Q.J.R. Meteorol. Soc.,
69(300), 77–114, doi:10.1002/qj.49706930002/abstract.
17
Buzan, J. R., K. Oleson, and M. Huber (2015), Implementation and comparison of a suite of heat stress
metrics within the Community Land Model version 4.5, Geosci. Model Dev., 8(2), 151–170, doi:
10.5194/gmd-8-151-2015.
Dunne, J. P., R. J. Stouffer, and J. G. John (2013), Reductions in labour capacity from heat stress under
climate warming, Nature Climate Change, 3(4), 1–4, doi:10.1038/nclimate1827.
Epstein, Y., and D. S. Moran (2006), Thermal comfort and the heat stress indices, Industrial Health,
44(3), 388–398.
Haldane, J. S. (1905), The Influence of High Air Temperatures No. I, Journal of Hygiene.
Kjellstrom, T. (2015), Impact of Climate Conditions on Occupational Health and Related Economic
Losses: A New Feature of Global and Urban Health in the Context of Climate Change, Asia Pac J
Public Health, doi:10.1177/1010539514568711.
Liljegren, J. C., R. A. Carhart, P. Lawday, S. Tschopp, and R. Sharp (2008), Modeling the Wet Bulb Globe
Temperature Using Standard Meteorological Measurements, Journal of occupational and
environmental hygiene, 5(10), 645–655, doi:10.1080/15459620802310770.
Minard, D., H. S. Belding, and J. R. Kingston (1957), Prevention of heat casualties, Journal of the
American Medical Association, 165(14), 1813.
Oleson et al. (2013), Technical Description of version 4.5 ofthe Community Land Model (CLM), 1–435,
doi:DOI: 10.5065/D6RR1W7M.
Parsons, K. (2006), Heat stress standard ISO 7243 and its global application, Industrial Health, 44(3),
368–379.
Parsons, K. (2013), Occupational health impacts of climate change: current and future ISO standards for
the assessment of heat stress, Industrial Health, 51(1), 86–100.
18
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Evaluation of Mechanisms of Extreme Temperatures
over Europe and North America
Ioana Colfescu (1), Simon Tett (1), Gabi Hegerl(1).
(1)School of GeoSciences, University of Edinburgh, Grant Institute, The King's Buildings,
James Hutton Road, Edinburgh EH9 3FE Edinburgh
Understanding future changes in the frequency, intensity, and duration of extreme temperatures
is important for devising adaptation strategies that minimize damages to humans and not only.
We quantify monthly-scale changes in the location and intensity of seasonal temperature extreme
events, during the first and latter half of the 20th century in the 20 th Century Reanalysis. The
regions of study are North America and Europe, along with some preliminary analysis over India.
The regional probabilities of change in extreme events occurrence for the two periods are
quantified using Probability Density Functions while composite analysis is used for studying the
main synoptic weather patterns associated to the events .
An assessment of the capability of CMIP5 models to simulate these extreme events and their
mechanisms is also performed by comparing the model patterns with those obtained from the
20C reanalysis.
Similarly to previous studies, our results indicate that climate models simulate mechanisms
associated with temperature extreme events reasonably well. Quantitative analysis of extreme
temperature and circulation show that for the two periods there are changes in circulation
patterns associated with extremes.
References
Mechanisms of Temperature Extreme Events in Climate Models over Europe
Oliver Krueger et al 2015 Environ. Res. Lett. 10 014002 doi:10.1088/1748-9326/10/1/014002
19
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Impact of Arctic Sea Ice on Circulation Patterns,
Planetary and Baroclinic Waves
Berit Crasemann (1), Klaus Dethloff (1), Dörthe Handorf (1), Ralf Jaiser(1),
Hiroshi Tanaka (2), Tetsu Nakamura (3), Jinro Ukita (4)
(1) Alfred Wegener Institute, Helmholtz Center for Polar and Marine
Research, Research Unit Potsdam, Germany
(2) Center for Computational Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Japan
(3) National Institute of Polar Research, Tachikawa, Japan and Hokkaido
University, Sapporo, Japan
(4) Niigata University, Niigata, Japan
Arctic amplification and recent Arctic sea ice decline affect the meridional
temperature gradient between Equator and North Pole and the mid-latitude
circulation patterns.
Many studies have used re-analysis data such as ERA-Interim and NCEP in
order to investigate the influence of decreasing Arctic sea ice on the atmospheric
circulation.
In this study, we additionally make use of two AGCM (atmospheric general
circulation model) for Earth Simulator (AFES4.1) sensitivity experiments with
different sea ice conditions in the Arctic.
One sensitivity experiment uses the monthly averaged SST/ICE for a five year
period from 1979-1983 (high ice, “CNTL”), the second experiment uses the
SST/ICE conditions for 2005-2009 (low ice, “NICE”). The model has a resolution
of T79L56 (model top at 60km), uses fixed greenhouse gases, O3, aerosols and
solar incident. Each model simulation is a perpetual run over 60 years.
First, we analyse the impact of Arctic sea ice on the instability rates and
amplitude of planetary and baroclinic waves using a spectral primitive equation
model derived by a orthonormal basis of vertical structure functions and Hough
functions.
Generally, the most unstable modes in low and high ice periods exist in the
synoptic domain at wave numbers 6-10. These modes appear in the middle
troposphere with a wave amplitude maximum at 40-50°N and are related to
synoptic scale cyclones. Februaries following autumns and winters with low
Arctic sea ice lead to a weakened polar vortex and more unstable modes in the
synoptic domain.
In order to focus on the synoptic scale processes, we have applied a cluster
analysis for the simulated daily sea level pressure fields for low and high ice
20
phases. The cluster analyses have been performed in a reduced state space
spanned by the leading EOFs (empirical orthogonal functions). We will present
the detected changes in the structure and frequency of occurrence of preferred
circulation patterns and subsequent changes of storm tracks.
References
Tanaka, H.L. (1985): Global energetics analysis by expansion into three
dimensional normal mode functions during the FGGE winter. Journal of the
Meteorological Society of Japan, 63, 180-200
Tanaka, H.L. and E.C. Kung (1989): A study of low-frequency unstable planetary
waves in realistic zonal and zonally varing basic states. Tellus, 41A, 179-199
Nakamura, T., K. Yamazaki, K. Iwamoto, M. Honda, Y. Miyoshi, Y. Ogawa, and
J. Ukita (2015), A negative phase shift of the winter AO/NAO due to the recent
Arctic sea-ice reduction in late autumn, J. Geophys. Res. Atmos., 120,
doi:10.1002/2014JD022848.
21
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Estimation of flood-adaptation indices in varying
climatic conditions
Joanna Doroszkiewicz (1), Renata Romanowicz (2)
(1) Institute of Geophysics Polish Academy of Sciences;
Księcia Janusza 64, 01-452 Warsaw, Poland
Hydrology and Hydrodynamics Department
(2) Institute of Geophysics, Polish Academy of Sciences;
Księcia Janusza 64, 01-452 Warsaw, Poland
Hydrology and Hydrodynamics Department
Adaptation to future climatic condition requires the formulation of a management
strategy based on adaptation indices. Adaptation to floods under changing climate
conditions requires adaptation indices specified for future floods which can be used by
water management bodies and land use planners to reduce the flood risk in the future.
Our work consists of several steps (Fig.1). In the first step regional/local land use
(zoning) plans and flood risk plans prepared by the President of National Water
Management Board are analysed.
In the second step we perform rainfall-runoff modelling using available hydrometeorological observations and future climate GCM/RCM simulation obtained from
the ENSEMBLES (Najafi reza M., 2012; Demargne, 2010; Cloke ,2009) and
EUROCORDEX projects (Kotlarski et al., 2014; Jacob, D. et al., 2013). Bias correction
of climate model projections of temperature and precipitation is performed using
Quantile Mapping (Maraun, D ,2010; Boé,2007). Hydrological modelling is performed
using grey-box type transfer function and HBV models (Kiczko et al. 2015; Bergström,
1995) using selected Polish catchments as case studies. Only catchments with nearly
natural conditions were selected in order to separate climatic and anthropogenic
influence. The third and fourth steps consist of flow routing using the SOBEK 3
software (Deltares, 2013) to model flood waves in future and present climate
conditions. In this stage of work we use the mountainous Biala Tarnowska river
located in Sothern part of Poland as a case study. The last two steps consist of the
estimation and evaluation of flood adaptation indices. These are: (i) the length of time
water levels exceed a critical value along the river; (ii) probability of inundation of riskprone areas and (iii) flood recurrence interval. The research had been done within the
project Climate Change Impact on Hydrological Extremes (CHIHE).
22
Fig 1 working scheme
References
1. Bergström, S., 1995. The HBV model. In: Singh V.P., ed. Computer models of watershed
hydrology. Water Resources Publications, Highlands Ranch, CO,443–476.
2. Boé, J., L. Terray, F. Habets, and E. Martin, 2007, Statistical and dynamical downscaling of
the Seine basin climate for hydro-meteorological studies. International Journal of Climatology,
27(12):1643–1655.
3. Cloke, H. and F. Pappenberger, 2009, Ensemble flood forecasting: A review. Journal of
Hydrology, 375(3–4):613–626, 2009.
4. Jacob, D. et al., 2013 “EURO-CORDEX: new high-resolution climate change projections for
European impact research” ,Springer 2013
5. Demargne, J., J. Brown, Y. Liu, D.-J. Seo, L. Wu, Z. Toth, and Y. Zhu, 2010, Diagnostic
verification of hydrometeorological and hydrologic ensembles. Atmospheric Science Letters,
11(2):114–122.
6. Kiczko A., Romanowicz R. J., Osuch M., Pappenberger F., 2015, On-line assimilation of
ECMWF forecasts: Biała Tarnowska case study, in: Stochastic Flood Forecasting System,
Eds Romanowicz R. and Osuch M., Springer (in print).
7. Kotlarski, S.et.al., 2007,.: Regional climate modeling on European scales: a joint standard
evaluation of the EURO-CORDEX RCM ensemble, Geosci. Model Dev., 7, 1297-1333,
doi:10.5194/gmd-7-1297-2014, 2014.
8. Maraun, D., Wetterhall, F., Ireson, A. M., Chandler, R. E., Kendon, E. J., Widmann, M., ... and
Thiele‐Eich, I.,2010, Precipitation downscaling under climate change: recent developments
to bridge the gap between dynamical models and the end user. Rev.ofGeop, 48(3).
9. Najafi reza M., Moradkhami H., Piechota T. C., 2012, Ensemble streamflow prediction: climate
signal weighting methods vs. Climate forecast system reanalysis, J. Hydrol., 442-443, 105116.
10. Deltares, 2013,SOBEK 3 Hydrodynamics Technical Reference Manual,version:3.0.1.29298
23
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
The role of the ocean on the development of European weather
extremes
A. Duchez(1), J. Hirschi(1), A. Forryan(2), P. Courtois(3), A. Blaker(1), B. Sinha(1), A. New(1), A. Scaife(4), T.
Graham(4) and M. Andrews(4)
(1) National Oceanography Centre Southampton, UK.
(3) University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
(2) University of Southampton
(4) Met Office Hadley Centre, Exeter, UK
Globally, current and future climate changes result in increasing frequency and intensity of droughts
(AghaKouchak et al., 2014), rainfall and associated flooding (Hirabayashi et al., 2013), and storm/hurricane
intensity and associated coastal inundation (Hallegatte et al., 2013). For Europe, the associated economic
loss burden was €415 billion and an estimated 140 000 lives lost for 1980-2010.
Key questions that arise are: Can an upward trend in natural extreme events be recognised and predicted at
the European scale? What are the key drivers within the climate system that are changing and making
extreme weather events more frequent, more intense, or both?
The ocean is a key driver for natural and anthropogenic climate variability. The ocean stores 1000 times
more heat than the atmosphere and redistributes heat around the planet. In the Atlantic, the heat transported
by the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC) makes a substantial contribution to the mild
maritime climate of North Western Europe and provides a controlling 5-10°C benefit to European climate.
Interest in the AMOC has been stimulated by the prospect of its gradual weakening during the 21st century as
suggested by the climate model scenarios of the fourth and fifth Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
(IPCC) assessment reports (Solomon et al., 2007; Stocker et al., 2013) and any slowdown in the AMOC is
expected to have profound implications for climate change over Europe.
However the role of the ocean in development of regional weather extremes is still unclear. Since 2004, the
RAPID array at 26°N has monitored the AMOC (Duchez et al., 2014; McCarthy et al., 2015). Several papers
have established a direct link between a substantial reduction in the AMOC (30% decrease, Bryden et al.,
2014) during winter 2009-2010 and the extreme winter of 2010 when the UK experienced its coldest
December for more than a century (Buchan et al., 2014).
AMOC
SST Correlation (lag 5)
1
75 o
N
0.8
0.6
60 o
N
0.4
45 o
N
0.2
0
30 o
N
−0.2
15 o
N
AMOC anomalies impact the oceanic heat transport and
heat content, which can affect SSTs and the atmosphere
(Sonnewald et al. 2013) and Duchez et al. 2015 show that
the AMOC can be used as a precursor for the
development of North Atlantic SST anomalies and leads a
SST dipole pattern by 5 months (Fig. 1). In this poster,
particular emphasis is given to the link between the
AMOC and European extreme events.
−0.4
−0.6
72 o
W
o
0
54 oW
o
36 W
o
18 W
−0.8
−1
Fig. 1: Lagged correlations between the SST and the
AMOC at 26°N. The AMOC leads the SST by 5 months.
Black contours indicate 95% significance levels and were
obtained using a composite analysis.
Using state-of-the-art coupled climate simulations from the UK Met Office (historical and future scenario
runs) as well as real observations (SST data and RAPID-AMOC observations), we analyze extremes in these
24
datasets and investigate whether they are conducive to the occurrence of extreme precipitation and
temperature events over Europe (like in 1969-1970 or 2009-2010).
PRCPTOT (mm) Trend (/year) (tt 0.05)
3
o
84 N
2
Latitude
1
o
72 N
0
o
60 N
−1
o
48 N
We characterize European precipitation extremes using a
subset of the 27 core indices from The Expert Team on
Climate Change Detection and Indices (Tank et al., 2009, Fig.
2) and relate them to the atmospheric modes of variability
over Europe in order to establish the large-scale
atmospheric circulation patterns that are conducive to the
occurrence of extreme precipitation events.
We also assess the evolution of future frequency and
intensity of extremes under climate change.
−2
o
36 N
24oN
80oW
40oW
Longitude
0o
40oE
−3
Fig. 2: Trend in annual precipitation (1976-2115).
References
• AghaKouchak et al., 2014: Global warming and changes in risk of concurrent climate extremes: insight
from the 2014 California drought. GRL. 41(24), 8847-8852.
• Bryden et al., 2014: Impact of a 30% reduction in Atlantic meridional overturning during 2009-2010.
Ocean Sci. 10, 683-691.
• Buchan et al., 2014: North Atlantic SST Anomalies and the Cold North European Weather Events of
Winter 2009/10 and December 2010. Mon. Weather Reviews. 142, 922–932.
• Duchez et al., 2014: A new index for the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation at 26°N. J.
Climate. 27 (17), 6439-6455.
• Duchez et al., 2015: Potential for seasonal prediction of Atlantic sea surface temperatures using the
RAPID array at 26°N. Submitted to Clim. Dyn.
• Hallegatte et al., 2013: Future flood losses in major coastal cities. Nature Climate Change. 3, 802-806.
• Hirabayashi et al., 2013: Global flood risk under climate change. Nature Climate Change. 3, 816-821.
• Klein et al., 2009: Guidelines on Analysis of extremes in a changing climate in support of informed
decisions for adaption. World Meteorological Organization, 56.
• McCarthy et al., 2012: Observed Interannual Variability of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning
Circulation at 26.5N. GRL. 39, L19609.
• McCarthy et al., 2015: Measuring the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation at 26°N. Prog in Oc.
130, 91-111.
• Solomon et al., 2007: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the 4th
Assessment Report of the IPCC. Cambridge University Press, UK and New York, USA.
• Sonnewald et al., 2013: Atlantic meridional ocean heat transport at 26°N: impact on subtropical ocean
heat content variability. Ocean Sci. 9, 1057-1069.
• Stocker et al., 2013: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fifth
Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Cambridge University Press, UK
New York, USA. 1535 pp, doi:10.1017/CBO9781107415324.
• Tank et al., 2009: Guidelines on Analysis of Extremes in a Changing Climate in Support of Informed
Decisions for Adaptation. WMO-TD No. 1500. Climate Data and Monitoring. World Meteorological
Organization, 2009.
25
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Understanding the Characteristics and Predictability of
Flood Events at the Global Scale
R.Emerton (1)
(1) Department of Geography and Environmental Science, University of Reading
Flooding is the most frequent of all types of natural disaster, accounting for 40.5% of all natural
disasters in 2014 (117 flood events from a total of 289 natural disasters) (Guha-Sapir et al., 2015).
Flood events can be caused by a variety of natural processes, and affect millions of people every year
through displacement from homes, unsafe drinking water, destruction of infrastructure, and injury
and loss of life during a flood event. In 2014 alone, almost 3,000 people were killed by floods, and
more than 34 million people were affected worldwide (Guha-Sapir et al., 2015).
With an increasing global population and increasing populations living in flood-prone areas, the
anticipation and forecasting of flood events is key to managing, preparing for and protecting against
extreme events, from local to national and international scales. Several centres now run operational
flood forecasting models, many of which provide forecasts for specific locations, river basins or
countries (Alfieri et al., 2012). Forecasting floods on the global scale in addition to the local/catchment
scale enables a global overview of forecasted flood events, which is crucial to many areas of the globe
where there is limited access to early warnings.
The Global Flood Awareness System (GloFAS) of the JRC and ECMWF provides a global overview of
upcoming floods in large world river basins. The system integrates the ECMWF operational 50member Ensemble Prediction System with the Lisflood hydrological model in order to produce
Ensemble Streamflow Predictions (ESPs) on the global scale out to 45 day lead times, daily. The
resulting ESP maps are compared with reference threshold maps derived from streamflow
climatology, giving 2 year, 5 year and 20 year return periods, which are used as the alert thresholds
for early warning. (Alfieri et al., 2013)
The first research aim of this project looks at evaluating the seasonal, annual and geographical
patterns of floods in river basins across the globe through analysis of characteristics such as duration,
frequency, intensity and recurrence within a season. Through use of GloFAS, the ERA-Interim (~34
years) and ERA-Clim (~110 years) extensive reanalysis datasets have been used to identify past
extreme flood events and produce global and regional overviews of flood characteristics under past
and present climate conditions. These datasets are currently being used to determine the atmospheric
precursors to extreme events, in order to evaluate the changes in flood characteristics due to
atmospheric features and teleconnections, presented here for the example of the El Nino Southern
Oscillation (ENSO). These results will further lead to analysis of the predictability of flood events in
regions across the globe, and any evidence for changes in extreme flood events under changing
climate regimes, aiming to answer the questions of:
“Are we able to use large scale atmospheric flow features and teleconnections to understand the
predictability of flood events and improve early warnings?”
“What are the potential changes in the characteristics and predictability of extreme flood events in
river basins across the globe under climate change?”
26
References
Alfieri, L., P.Burek, E, Dutra, B. Krzeminski, D. Muraro, J. Thielen and F. Pappenberger, 2013: GloFAS global ensemble streamflow forecasting and flood early warning. Hydrology and Earth System
Sciences, 17, 1161-1175
Alfieri, L., P. Salamon, F. Pappenberger, F. Wetterhall, and J. Thielen, 2012: Operational early warning
systems for water-related hazards in Europe. Environmental Science and Policy, 21, 35-49
Guha-Sapir, G., R. Below, and P. Hoyois, 2015: The CRED/EM-DAT International Disaster Database.
Available online at www.emdat.be - Universite Catholique de Louvain - Brussels - Belgium., Last
Accessed 27 January 2015
27
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
What controls atmospheric particle sizes over the Greenland ice sheet? –
Influence of changing deposition regimes
T. Erhardt (1); H. Fischer (1); D. Wagenbach† (2)
(1) Institute for Climate and Environmental Physics and Oeschger Center for
Climate Change Research, University of Bern, Switzerland
(2) Institute for Environmental Physics, Heidelberg University, Germany
Insoluble particle concentrations and their size distributions are routinely
measured in polar ice cores to reconstruct past atmospheric dust loads and are
often interpreted in terms of changes in atmospheric transport. However the
transfer of mineral dust particles from the atmosphere to the ice is not well
understood, especially regarding the preserved particle size distributions (PSDs).
Here we present an extension to a conceptual deposition model for aerosols
based on precipitation scavenging and gravitational settling including the size
distribution of the particles (Davidson et al., 1996; Fischer et al., 1998). The
extended model can be used to study the effect of different atmospheric PSDs
and changes in accumulation rate on the preserved particle concentration and
their size distribution. It can also be applied to reconstruct past atmospheric dust
conditions using accumulation rate reconstructions and measured PSDs. We
apply the model to previously published size distribution data from North GRIP
(Greenland) (Ruth et al., 2003) to investigate the influence of the changing
deposition regime during the fast transitions between cold stadial and warm
interstadial conditions during the last glacial.
During the last glacial climate archives from Greenland show large oscillations
between cold stadial and warmer interstadial conditions. These transitions from
cold to warm states occur within decades and are associated with 5 – 16 °C
changes in average temperature and increases of the accumulation rate by a
factor of two (Kindler et al., 2014). The dust record exhibits coincidental changes
in the particle mass concentration of a factor of 5 – 18 with accompanying
changes in the PSDs, that occur on time scales faster than 30 – 200 yr, which is
the temporal resolution of the PSD record (Ruth et al., 2003).
In general the transfer to the ice shifts the particle size distributions towards
larger particles. This effect is more pronounced, the lower the accumulation rate.
During the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM), when accumulation at NGRIP is at its
lowest, geometric mean particle diameters in the ice are up to 10 % larger in the
ice with respect to particle numbers and up to 25 % with respect to particle
volume. The contribution of dry deposition to the number (volume) flux peaks at
25 % (50 %) during the LGM with average values around 7% (20 %).
28
Reconstructed atmospheric geometric mean particle diameters show similar but
dampened variability compared to the PSDs in the ice.
Overall the model shows that size distribution information for ice core records
need to be corrected for depositional effects and that some of the
stadial/interstadial variability in PSD parameters can be explained by the
accompanying large changes accumulation rate.
References
Davidson, C. I., Bergin, M. H. and Kuhns, H. D.: The Deposition of particles and
Gasses to Ice Sheets, in Chemical Exchange Between the Atmosphere and
Polar Snow, edited by E. W. Wolff and R. C. Bales, pp. 276–306, Springer,
Heidelberg. 1996.
Fischer, H., Wagenbach, D. and Kipfstuhl, J.: Sulfate and nitrate firn
concentrations on the Greenland ice sheet: 1. Large‐scale geographical
deposition changes, JGR, 103(D17), 21927–21934, doi:10.1029/98JD01885,
1998.
Kindler, P., Guillevic, M., Baumgartner, M., Schwander, J., Landais, A.,
Leuenberger, M., Spahni, R., Capron, E. and Chappellaz, J.: Temperature
reconstruction from 10 to 120 kyr b2k from the NGRIP ice core, CP, 10(2), 887–
902, doi:10.5194/cp-10-887-2014, 2014.
Ruth, U., Wagenbach, D., Steffensen, J. P. and Bigler, M.: Continuous record of
microparticle concentration and size distribution in the central Greenland NGRIP
ice core during the last glacial period, JGR, 108(D3), 4098–5000,
doi:10.1029/2002JD002376, 2003.
29
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Synoptic variability in the CMIP5 models over
Australia: implications for the simulation of
extreme heat
Peter B. Gibson (1,2), Petteri Uotila (3), Sarah E. Perkins (1,2), Lisa V.
Alexander (1,2) , Andrew J. Pitman (1,2)
(1) Climate Change Research Centre, University of New South Wales,
Sydney, New South Wales, Australia
(2) ARC Centre of Excellence for Climate System Science, University of
New South Wales, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia
(3) Finnish Meteorological Institute, Helsinki, Finland
Our confidence in climate model projections depends, in part, on the ability of
models to capture present day climate and associated variability over a range of
time scales. However, climate models are less commonly assessed at time
scales relevant to daily weather systems, despite being particularly important for
the realistic simulation of various extreme events. In this study we employ a selforganizing maps procedure (SOMs) to evaluate various aspects of synoptic
systems in the Australian region simulated by the CMIP5 climate models.
We find that a small group of models simulate the historical frequency of synoptic
systems well. A much larger group of models are well suited to simulating the
persistence and transitional phases of synoptic systems. Considering all models
and synoptic aspects collectively we find model performance to be related to
model horizontal resolution but unrelated to vertical resolution or representation
of the stratosphere (Figure 1). These findings have implications for selecting
models most useful for future projections over the Australian region, particularly
for projections related to climate extremes whereby day-to-day synoptic
variability are important drivers of extreme heat. The finding that some models
score highly across these synoptic metrics for the region is encouraging.
We further illustrate how key synoptic circulation types, attained through the
SOM procedure, are related to measures of extreme heat spatially across the
Australian continent. Links between synoptic variability and extreme heat are
examined separately for summer and winter seasons to suggest seasonality in
the forcing. We demonstrate how the use of circulation types can further aid our
understanding of drivers of extreme events, beyond what is possible through
simple compositing methods. Under this approach, future work will investigate
the combined influence of soil moisture and synoptic variability on the nature of
30
Australian heat extremes. Understanding processes in the land-surface and
atmosphere linked to heat extremes may help improve both long-term climate
change projections and seasonal forecasts.
Figure 1: scatterplots showing relationship between metrics (correlation
coefficients) in the various CMIP5 models and reanalysis (JRA-55), computed
against 20CRv2 for the period 1958 – 2005. Models in top (bottom) panel plots
are grouped by horizontal (vertical) resolution. ‘Frequency correlation’ is a
measure of the model to simulate correctly the node frequencies observed in
20CRv2.
31
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and
Climate
Exploring nearly on-in-a-millennium
scenarios of extreme rainfall through
dynamically downscaling palaeoclimatic
simulations
Juan José Gómez-Navarro (1,2), Christoph Raible (1,2), Sandro
Blumer (1,2), Martina Messmer (1,2), Olivia Martius(1,2)
(1) Climate and Environmental Physics, Physics Institute, University of Bern
(2) Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research
(3) Geography Department, University of Bern
Extreme precipitation is a natural phenomenon that can lead to severe
ooding and are a threat to human activities, especially in areas
densely populated such as Switzerland. On the one hand, the climatic
characterisation, i.e. severity, frequency and spatial distribution of
such events, is necessary to design policies that protect public assets
and private property and allow reinsurance companies to accurately
estimate risks. On the other hand, the study of such events can lead to
process understating, which is eventually needed to develop reliable
projections about the behaviour of such situations under ongoing
climate change (IPCC-SREX, 2012).
However, the study of extreme situations is hampered the fact that
they are, by de.nition, very rare. A proper characterisation of such
events, like one-in-a-century storms, is limited by the relatively short
instrumental period, which limits the available datasets and forces the
extrapolation of data. This study proposes a new approach that allows
to investigate storms based on a synthetic, but physically consistent
database of weather situations obtained from a very long climate
simulation. In particular, an 800-year simulation carried out with a
comprehensive Earth System Model (ESM) is used as a surrogate of the
real climate.
We use the CESM1 model run with a spatial resolution of 1 degree
(Lehner et al. 2015). However this resolution is not .ne enough to
reproduce realistically the spatial structure and severity of extreme
precipitation events in the Alpine area, so this dataset is dynamically
downscaled with the Weather Research and Forecasting model (WRF)
to a .nal resolution of 2 km (Gómez-Navarro et al. 2015). However,
simulating the 800 years generated by the ESM at such high resolution
32
is infeasible nowadays. Hence, a number of case studies are previously
selected. This selection is carried out examining the precipitation
averaged in an area encompassing Switzerland in the ESM.
Precipitation is accumulated in several temporal windows: 1 day, 2
days, 3 days, 5 days and 10 days. The 4 most extreme events in each
category and season are selected. This leads to a total of 336 days to
be simulated.
Clearly, this database of extreme precipitation can not be used as is,
since the framework of the ESM simulation followed by dynamic
downscaling has to be corrected in terms of systematic biases prior
applying the results back in the real world. Hence, a 20-year climatic
simulation with the same con.guration in both models is carried out.
The comparison of the climate reproduced by this simulation and that
derived from an independent simulation driven by ERA Interim is used
estimate the biases of the model chain. Finally, Quantile Mapping
(Maraun, 2013) is applied, which allows to remove systematic biases in
the case studies and make the simulated rainfall comparable to reality.
References
Gómez-Navarro, J. J., C. Raible and S. Dierer: Sensitivity of the WRF
model to PBL parametrizations and nesting techniques: Evaluation of
surface wind over complex terrain. Geoscienti.c Model Development,
2015. Submitted.
IPCC-SREX: Managing the Risks of Extreme Events and Disasters to
Advance Climate Change Adaptation. A Special Report of Working
Groups I and II of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change,
edited by: Field, C. B., Barros, V., Stocker, T. F., Qin, D., Dokken, D. J.,
Ebi, K. L., Mastrandrea, M. D., Mach, K. J., Plattner, G.-K., Allen, S. K.,
Tignor, M., and Midgley, P. M., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge,
UK, and New York, NY, USA, 2012
Lehner, F., K. Keller, C. C. Raible, Juliette Mignot, Andreas Born, F. Joos,
and T. F. Stocker: Climate and carbon cycle dynamics in a CESM
simulation from 850-2100CE. Earth System Dynamics, 2015. In press.
Maraun, D.: Bias Correction, Quantile Mapping, and Downscaling:
Revisiting the In3ation Issue. Journal of Climate, 26, 2137–2143, 2013
33
Kirsti&Hakala&
Department&of&Geography&
Hydrology&and&Climate&
University&of&Zurich&
Winterthurerstrasse&190&
CHA8057&Zürich&
Switzerland&
&
[email protected]&
+41&(0)&79&1705941&
http://www.geo.uzh.ch/en/units/h2k/&
!
Updated!abstract!for!2015!Swiss!Climate!Summer!School:!!
!
!
Hydrological&climate&change&impact&assessment&–&addressing&the&
uncertainties&
!
!
Abstract&
&
Society&needs&improved&knowledge&regarding&possible&impacts&of&climate&change&on&
hydrology.&The&embodiment&of&such&perturbations&includes&floods&and&droughts&of&
growing&severity&and&frequency.&Quantification&of&these&threats&is&important&as&a&base&
for&sensible&adaptation&measures.&This&research&will&explore&impacts&of&climate&change&
on&catchment&discharge&and&will&address&the&challenge&of&better&characterizing&and&
communicating&their&uncertainties.&It&will&in&particular&focus&on&the&integrated&
evaluation&of&CORDEX&regional&climate&model&simulations,&using&hydrological&modeling&
at&the&catchment&scale.&
34
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Role of soil moisture vs. recent climate change
for heat waves in western Russia
Mathias Hauser (1), René Orth (1), Sonia Seneviratne (1)
(1) Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science, ETH Zurich, Switzerland
Using the framework of event attribution, anthropogenic climate change
was found to have a discernible influence on the occurrence-probability of heat
waves, such as the one in Russia in 2010 (Otto et al., 2012). Soil moisture, on
the other hand, is an important physical driver for heat waves as its availability
has a large influence on the partitioning of the available surface net radiation into
latent and sensible heat flux (Seneviratne et al., 2010, Fischer et al., 2007).
The presented study investigates the relative importance of both drivers
on heat waves in the region of the 2010 Russian heat wave. This is done with a
large number of ensemble members from climate simulations prescribing sea
surface temperatures and greenhouse gas concentrations from the 1960s, the
2000s and 2010.
The statistics agree well for modeled and observed annual daily maximum
temperatures (TXx), and modeled soil moisture and ERA-Interim forced offline
simulations. However, the extreme temperature and soil moisture conditions of
2010 were not sampled. Thus, additional climate simulations, prescribing realistic
2010 soil moisture conditions were carried out.
Using the second hottest TXx since 1951 as a threshold, it was found that
climate change has approximately tripled the risk of exceeding this threshold
magnitude. Sea surface temperatures of 2010 led to a 1.7 fold risk, only. Given
2010 soil moisture conditions the risk to exceed the temperature threshold are 13
times higher than in the 1960s, highlighting the importance of soil moisturetemperature feedbacks for this particular heat wave.
References
Fischer, E. M., Seneviratne, S. I., Vidale, P. L., Lüthi, D., & Schär, C. (2007). Soil moistureatmosphere interactions during the 2003 European summer heat wave. Journal of Climate, 20(20), 5081-5099.
Otto, F. E., Massey, N., Oldenborgh, G. J., Jones, R. G., & Allen, M. R. (2012). Reconciling two
approaches to attribution of the 2010 Russian heat wave. Geophysical Research Letters,
39(4).
Seneviratne, S. I., Corti, T., Davin, E. L., Hirschi, M., Jaeger, E. B., Lehner, I., Orlowsky, B. &
Teuling, A. J. (2010). Investigating soil moisture–climate interactions in a changing climate: A review. Earth-Science Reviews, 99(3), 125-161.
35
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Crop failures and extreme climate events in
historical Finland
Heli Huhtamaa (1, 2)
(1) University of Bern, Institute of History & Oeschger Centre for Climate
Change Research, Switzerland
(2) University of Eastern Finland, Department of Geographical and
Historical Studies, Finland
Finland is often referred to as the “most northerly agricultural country in the
world” (e.g. Mukula and Rantanen 1987; Mela 1996; Hollins et al. 2004), where
climatic conditions have largely influenced agricultural practices and crop
variations (Holopainen and Helama 2009). Climate and weather extremes have
brought crop failure and famine throughout the history. For example, during the
climate-triggered famines of the 1690s and 1860s approximately every third and
twelfth, respectively, Finn died from malnutrition and related diseases (Myllyntaus
2009).
Current and future impacts of climate change on agricultural production have
gained increasing interest over the recent decades. Studies of historical
responses to extreme weather and climate events may provide important insight
into the vulnerability of agricultural production and its fluctuations over space and
time (Pfister 2010).
Therefore, the relationships between crop failures and extreme climate and
weather events in Finland AD 1300–1900 are investigated. Evidence of past
harvest fluctuations, crop failure history and climate variability is gathered from
tree-ring proxies and documentary source materials. First, the events that caused
considerable damage to crop production in historical Finland are identified.
Second, the possible social responses to these events are investigated. When
people succeed or failed to cope with the extreme events? Moreover, were they
able to response to the changes in the frequency, intensity and duration of these
events?
Past experiences help us to better understand the present and to identify
vulnerabilities in a long-term context. As Finland is a marginal area of crop
cultivation that is highly sensitive to variations in climate and weather, centennial
long perspective may provide us with a wide spectrum of possible socioenvironmental responses to climate variability.
36
References
Hollins P.D., Kettlewell P.S. & Peltonen-Sainio P. 2004. Relationships between
climate and winter cereal grain quality in Finland and their potential for
forecasting. Agricultural Food Science, 13: 295–308.
Holopainen J., Helama S. 2009. Little Ice Age Farming in Finland: Preindustrial
Agriculture on the Edge of the Grim Reaper’s Scythe. Human Ecology, 37: 213–
25.
Mela T. 1996. Northern agriculture: constraints and responses to global climate
change. Agricultural Food Science, 5: 229–234.
Mukula J. & Rantanen O. 1987. Climatic risks to the yield and quality of field
crops in Finland: I. Basic facts about Finnish field crops production. Annales
Agriculturae Fenniae, 26: 1–18.
Myllyntaus T. 2009. Summer frost. A natural hazard with fatal consequences in
pre-industrial Finland. In: Mauch C. & Pfister C. (eds.), Natural disasters and
cultural responses: case studies toward a global environmental history, Lexington
Books, Lanham, pp. 77–102.
Pfister C. 2010. The vulnerability of past societies to climatic variation: a new
focus for historical climatology in the twenty-first century. Climatic Change, 100:
25–31.
37
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Predicting the June 2013 European Flooding
based on Precipitation, Soil Moisture and Sea
Level Pressure
M. Ionita (1,2), M. Dima (1,3), G. Lohmann (1,2), P. Scholz (1), N. Rimbu (1)
(1) Alfred Wegener Institute Helmholtz Center for Polar and Marine
Research, Bremerhaven, Germany
(2) MARUM, Bremen University, Bremen, Germany
(3) University of Bucharest, Faculty of Physics, Bucharest, Romania
Over the past decades Europe has experienced heavy floods with major
consequences for thousands of people and billions of Euros worth of damage. In
particular, the summer 2013 flood in Central Europe showed how vulnerable
modern society is to hydrological extremes and emphasizes once more the need
for improved forecast methods of such extreme climatic events. Based on a
multiple linear regression model, it is shown here that 55% of the June 2013 Elbe
River extreme discharge could have been predicted using May precipitation, soil
moisture and sea level pressure. Moreover, our model was able to predict more
than 75% of the total Elbe River discharge for June 2013 (in terms of magnitude)
by incorporating also the amount of precipitation recorded during the days prior
the flood, but the predicted discharge for the June 2013 event was still
underestimated by 25%. Given that all predictors used in the model are available
at the end of each month, the forecast scheme can be used to predict extreme
events and to provide early warnings for upcoming floods. The forecast
methodology could be efficient for other rivers also, depending on their location
and their climatic background.
38
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Response surfaces of Swiss flood events to enable
and evaluate robust adaptation
L. Keller1,2, O. Rössler1,2, R. Weingartner1,2
(1) Institute of Geography, University of Bern, 3012 Bern, Switzerland
(2) Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research, 3012 Bern, Switzerland
The multidisciplinary SNF Sinergia project “Climate Change Extremes and Adaptation
Strategies Considering Uncertainty and Federalism” (CCAdapt) aims at advancing the theory
of adaptation to extreme flood events by accounting for (a) uncertainty about future flood
occurrence, (b) the characteristics of different adaptation measures as well as (c) the federal
setting in Switzerland. As a final result feasible adaptation strategies taking into account these
aspects will be evaluated.
The presented study will deliver the hydrological basis for the overall project by assessing
future flood frequencies in selected Swiss catchments under consideration of uncertainties
about projected climate change. Instead of using the classical “top-down” approach by
applying climate projections as input for a hydrological model we will make use of the “bottomup” approach that is based on a sensitivity study of climate impacts on hydrology. This
response surface method allows the consideration of a broad range of possible future climate
conditions as well as readily evaluation of new climate projections and can be used as a flexible
tool in planning of adaptation measures (e.g. Prudhomme et al., 2010).
A crucial point in this approach is the generation of meteorological input data. Here, this task
will be guided by analysis of past flood events, which will reveal the role of different flood
process types and specific hydro-meteorological conditions for flood generation in the selected
catchments during the 20th century. Based on this process study meteorological storylines of
flood events will be generated, which will allow for an extension of the delta change approach
commonly used with the response surface method to more sophisticated modifications of the
climate data. Apart from varying the quantities of meteorological input variables we will include
variations of their spatial and temporal patterns. Finally, the storylines will be related to specific
climate projections in order to evaluate the probabilities of the obtained response surfaces
under predicted future climate conditions. Additionally, the hydrological impact of storyline
parameters for which there is no projection available, e.g. specific spatial precipitation patterns,
will be investigated. This will shed light on uncertainties which are not reflected in climate
projections.
Hydrological modelling of the flood events will be adapted to the identified process types to
improve simulation quality and will possibly result in a multi-parametrization approach.
Overall, we expect to develop an extended response surface approach, which allows for more
realistic and more comprehensive alterations of the climatic data by considering the hydrometeorological storylines identified to be crucial for flood generation in the catchments. This,
in turn may to lead to a more realistic and more intuitively apprehensible climate impact
assessment for adaptation planning.
The poster that will be presented at the summer school will give an overview of the planned
works of the PhD project and will show preliminary results.
39
References
Prudhomme, C., Wilby, R. L., Crooks, S., Kay, A. L., and Reynard, N. S.: Scenario-neutral
approach to climate change impact studies: Application to flood risk, Journal of
Hydrology, 390, 198–209, doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2010.06.043, 2010.
40
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Analysis of extreme precipitation indices in the
Carpathian Region using regional climate model
simulations
Anna Kis (1), Rita Pongrácz (2)
(1) PhD student, Dept. of Meteorology, Eötvös Loránd University
(2) Assistant professor, Dept. of Meteorology, Eötvös Loránd University
Extreme weather events may result in various environmental damages and
economical losses. In order to reduce their potential risks and develop appropriate
adaptation strategies, it is essential to make estimations for the future as reliable as
possible.
Precipitation data of regional climate model (RCM) simulations from the
ENSEMBLES project (van der Linden and Mitchell, 2009) were used for this study. A
quantile-based bias-correction method (Formayer and Haas, 2010) was applied to
the raw data (Pongrácz et al., 2014), for which the CarpatClim database (Szalai et
al., 2013) served as a reference. Hence, systematic errors (underestimation in
summer precipitation amount and overestimation in the rest of the year) were
eliminated.
From the bias-corrected daily precipitation outputs of 11 RCM simulations, several
precipitation-related indices defined by relative and absolute threshold values were
calculated for the entire 1961–2100 period, indicating both dry (e.g., MDS, CDD) and
wet conditions (e.g., RR1, RR10, RX5, R99p). Future changes by 2021–2050 and
2071–2100 relative to different reference periods (1961–1990, 1971–2000, 1981–
2010) were determined for the Carpathian Region as well as for five subregions
within this domain (containing gridcells from Slovakia, Ukraine, Hungary, Romania
and Serbia).
The estimated seasonal mean changes of six climate indices are summarised for the
late 21st century in Fig.1. According to our results, drier summers are clearly
projected for the future in the Carpathian Region. More specifically the maximum
number of consecutive dry days (CDD) and the mean dry spell (MDS) are both likely
to increase by about 40% on average in summer, while the number of precipitation
days (RR1) is projected to decrease (by 20–30% on average) according to all of the
11 simulations. More precipitation days are estimated only for winter, however, the
uncertainty is quite high (some RCM simulations projects decrease of RR1). The
number of heavy precipitation days (RR10) is likely to increase, except in summer;
however, in the solstice seasons the sign of the change is uncertain. All the
simulations indicate increasing trend in winter, the average estimated change is 36%.
For winter and autumn clearly increasing trends of the highest five-day precipitation
total (RX5) and the 99th percentile of daily precipitation (R99p) are projected –
therefore more intense precipitation is estimated for the end of the 21st century
compared to the reference period –, while in spring and summer the inter-model
inconsistency is quite high. The spatial distribution of estimated changes suggests
clearly that drying trends are more pronounced in the southern regions, whereas
wetter conditions are estimated for the northern parts of the domain.
41
Fig.1. Projected multi-model mean seasonal changes of precipitation indices in the
Carpathian Region for 2071–2100 relative to the reference period 1971–2000. Coloured
columns indicate the multi-model mean changes of spatial average indices’ values; grey lines
refer to the entire range of RCM estimations (from the minimum at the bottom to the
maximum at the top).
References
Formayer, H., Haas, P., 2010: Correction of RegCM3 model output data using a
rank matching approach applied on various meteorological parameters. Deliverable
D3.2 RCM output localization methods (BOKU-contribution of the FP 6 CECILIA
project). http://www.cecilia-eu.org/
van der Linden, P., Mitchell, J.F.B., Eds., 2009: ENSEMBLES: Climate Change
and Its Impacts: Summary of research and results from the ENSEMBLES project. UK
Met Office Hadley Centre, Exeter, UK, 160p.
Pongrácz, R., Bartholy, J., Kis, A., 2014: Estimation of future precipitation
conditions for Hungary with special focus on dry periods. – Idıjárás 118. pp. 305–
321.
Szalai, S., Auer, I., Hiebl, J., Milkovich, J., Radim, T., Stepanek, P., Zahradnicek,
P., Bihari, Z., Lakatos, M., Szentimrey, T., Limanowka, D., Kilar, P., Cheval, S., Deak,
Gy., Mihic, D., Antolovic, I., Mihajlovic, V., Nejedlik, P., Stastny, P., Mikulova, K.,
Nabyvanets, I., Skyryk, O., Krakovskaya, S., Vogt, J., Antofie, T., Spinoni, J., 2013:
Climate of the Greater Carpathian Region. Final Technical Report. www.carpatclimeu.org
42
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
The role of atmospheric blockings in central
European flood events – A casestudy
Sina Lenggenhager (1, 2), Olivia Romppainen (1, 2), Stefan Brönnimann
(1,2), Mischa Croci-Maspoli (3)
(1) Institute of Geography, University Bern
(2) Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research
(3) MeteoSwiss
Flood events are among the most devastating weather-related events in Europe
and can lead to large economic losses and even fatalities. A large number of
parameters are involved in the triggering of flood events. Essential parameters
are the intensity, lifetime and stationarity of the flood triggering weather system
and the preconditioning of the catchment basin. These parameters are largely
affected by the occurrence of atmospheric blockings. Stucki et al. (2012) have
found 10 out of 13 severe flood events in Switzerland to be associated with
blockings over Russia. This illustrates the potentially important role of
atmospheric blocking for flood events in Europe.
Atmospheric blockings, due to their longevity and stationarity, ensure extended
periods of precipitation associated with extratropical cyclones in the geographical
area upstream of the blocking area. On the one hand, recurrent precipitation
events lead to a strong preconditioning of the catchment basin, on the other hand
the progression of the upstream weather systems is slowed and thereby the
precipitation period over a catchment is prolonged. Furthermore, cloud diabatic
processes might be central to the establishment and maintenance of blocking
anticyclones. The precipitation responsible for the flood could hence potentially
extend the lifetime and strength of a blocking anticyclone located downstream of
the flooded area.
The analysis of the meteorological conditions that lead to the recent flood in
Ticino in November 2014 provides a first step towards the understanding of the
interactions between atmospheric blockings and flood events. There have been
four major precipitation events between October and November 2014. The first
one has already taken place in the beginning of October and was possibly
associated with an atmospheric blocking over Eastern Europe. It was essential
for the preconditioning. The second one took place from November 3 to 5 and is
showing a similar pattern. The last to events (November 9-12 and 14-15) were
more likely influenced by the upstream flow. They followed very closely and
triggered the floods.
43
References
Grams, C. M., Binder, H., Pfahl, S., Piaget, N., & Wernli, H. (2014). Atmospheric
processes triggering the central European floods in June 2013. Natural Hazards
and Earth System Science, 14(7), 1691–1702. doi:10.5194/nhess-14-1691-2014
Schwierz, C. (2004). Perspicacious indicators of atmospheric blocking.
Geophysical Research Letters, 31(6), L06125. doi:10.1029/2003GL019341
Stucki, P., Rickli, R., Brönnimann, S., Martius, O., Wanner, H., Grebner, D., &
Luterbacher, J. (2012). Weather patterns and hydro-climatological precursors of
extreme floods in Switzerland since 1868. Meteorologische Zeitschrift, 21(6),
531–550. doi:10.1127/0941-2948/2012/368
44
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Interannual variations of NPP in European forests
Sebastian Lienert(1), Stefan Klesse(2), Renato Spahni(1), David Frank(2),
Fortunat Joos(1)
(1) Physics Institute and Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research, University of Bern
(2) Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research WSL
Introduction
We investigate interannual variability in net primary productivity (NPP) of
European forests using the dynamic global vegetation model LPX-Bern. The
model results are compared to estimates of annual biomass increment from a
European-wide tree ring network.
Methods
The Land surfaces Processes
and eXchanges (LPX-Bern
[1,2]) model simulates
terrestrial biosphere processes,
including the water, carbon and
nitrogen cycles and competition
between different plant
functional types. Monthly
climate timeseries (CRU
TS3.22 ([3]) as well as annual
nitrogen deposition [4] and
atmospheric CO2
concentrations [5] are used to
force the model. The
simulations use a spatial
resolution of 0.5x0.5 degrees.
Figure 1: Coefficient of variation (Ratio between
Tree diameter reconstructions, standard deviation and mean of NPP) between 1980
allometric equations, and stand and 2009. The circles represent measurements.
density measurements allow for an empiric estimate of the annual biomass
increment [6]. These measurements are used to verify the model results.
Results
We investigated the relationship between interannual variability (i.e. standard
deviation) and the mean of NPP. We find a positive correlation between the
two variables across Europe meaning that increased growth generally leads
to increased variability. Interannual variability is typically around 20% of mean
NPP with lower than average variability in northwestern Europe and higher
than average values in Southern and parts of Eastern Europe (Figure 1). The
high values in certain cells are due to a lack of growth at the beginning of the
simulation leading to high variability with respect to the mean.
To quantify the coefficient of variation, we plot standard deviation against the
45
mean, for both measurements and simulation (Figure 2). By using linear
regression a slope of about 0.23 is obtained (blue), which is in reasonable
agreement with the slope from the limited number of measurements of 0.15
(yellow). If we consider grid cells, where measurement are available, the
agreement is increased further (red).
Figure 2: Standard deviation of NPP in dependence of mean NPP from 1980 to
2009. The values from the simulation are indicated by blue and red dots, with the
red dots designating cells where measurements are available. The yellow dots
represent measurements. Also included are linear regressions for all sets of
points.
Outlook
In addition to the above mentioned simple relationship between interannual
variability and mean NPP, we will also investigate the sensitivity of NPP to
climate.
References
[1] Spahni R, Joos F, Stocker BD, Steinacher M, Yu ZC (2013) Transient simulations of the
carbon and nitrogen dynamics in northern peatlands: from the Last Glacial Maximum to the
21st century. Climate of the Past, 9, 1287–1308.
[2] Stocker BD, Roth R, Joos F et al. (2013) Multiple greenhouse-gas feedbacks from the land
biosphere under future climate change scenarios. Nature Climate Change,3 ,666–672.
[3] Harris I, Jones PD et al. (2014) Updated high-resolution grids of monthly climatic
observations the CRU TS3. 10 dataset. International Journal of Climatology, 34, 623–642.
[4]Lamarque et. al.(2013) Multi-model mean nitrogen and sulfur deposition from the
Atmospheric Chemistry and Climate Model Intercomparison Project (ACCMIP): Evaluation
historical and projected changes.Atmos. Chem. Phys., 13, 7997-8018
[5]Dlugokencky E and Tans P, NOAA/ESRL (www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/)
[6]Babst F, Bouriaud O, Alexander R, et al (2014) Towards consistent measurements of
carbon accumulation: A multi-site assessment of biomass and basal area increment across
Europe. Dendrochronologia, 32,153-161
46
Projecting high-resolution extreme climate
indices with observational constrain
Shih-how Lo <[email protected]>
Cheng-Ta Chen <[email protected]>
National Taiwan Normal University, Department of Earth Sciences, Taiwan
Extreme rainfall index has been an important issue when climate change
is discussed. In IPCC AR5 report, there are many researches regarding how
“frequency” or “variance” will change, while intensity is barely come up. The
reason why we care about the change of the intensity in future is that the
government needs the absolute values of extreme rainfall index to make a
threshold once a disaster policy is made. Many researches have used IPCC
AR5 models to estimate the extreme rainfall index of climate change. However,
those models only carry low or mid-resolution. It is difficult to capture the
extreme rainfall in low resolution models. The other drawback is it will lose lots
of intensity when we use different models form IPCC AR5. This study needs
to remap different models at the same resolution, so it can be expected that
the process will make high resolution models lose the intensity of rainfall.
Figure 1 shows how many the RX5DAY index (top event) will lose in different
models at T42 resolution.
The intensity of rainfall decreases with the reduction of resolution in a
model. In that process, the relationship between intensity and resolution is
called “area factor”. In our research, we remap T.R.M.M. data into each IPCC
model and compare that with original T.R.M.M. data (at 25km resolution) to
obtain area factor (Figure 2). If the bias of models is not taken into account, it
can easily downscale model resolution to 25km by using area factor.
When the CCSM4 model (high resolution model) is remapped to T42
resolution, the global mean in RX5DAY index will decrease by 10% and 50%
for the top event, as shown in Figure 3. Having used the area factor to
downscale resolution to 25km, the RX5DAY index’s global mean in NorESM1
model (low resolution model) and CCSM4 model will increase to 106 mm/day
and 118.4 mm/day, respectively. Both of their rainfall value get closer to 123.3
mm/day observed by T.R.M.M. after doing downscale. As a result, it is not
necessary to remap a model to the lowest resolution in an IPCC AR5 model,
which still can keep the characteristics of rainfall in high resolution condition,
making the extreme rainfall index under climate change easier to discuss.
Key words: Downscale, Extreme rainfall index, Climate change
47
Figure1. Bar charts of the RX5DAY index (top event) difference between original resolution
and T42.
Figure2. (Left) The distribution of TRMM’s RX5DAY index at data grid sizes of (a) 1440X400,
(b) 640x320, (c) 320x160, (d)144x90, (e) 128x60 . (Right) The method to create area factor
from T.R.M.M. data.
Figure3. Comparison of the RX5DAY index estimated from the TRMM, NorESM1-M and
CCSM4.The RX5DAY index estimated from different grids. (a),(e) original resolution, (b),(d),(g)
T42 and (c),(e),(h) downscale to 25km.
Reference:
Chen, C. T., and T. Knutson, 2008: On the verification and comparison of
extreme rainfall indices from climate models.
J. Climate, 21, 1605–1621
48
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
The Influence of Climate Variability on Australian Heat
Wave Frequency, Duration and Intensity
Tammas Loughran, Sarah Perkins, Lisa Alexander, Andy Pitman
Climate Change Research Centre, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW,
Australia.
For Australia there are a number of modes of variability that influence its climate. Their influence
on rainfall and temperature is relatively well established, however this influence is the result of a
complex interaction of many dynamic processes and separating them out poses challenges.
Furthermore, there has been very little research done on how they relate to the frequency, duration
and intensity across Australia.
This study aims to identify the interannual varibility of summer heat wave characteristics using
principle component analysis and relate them to three modes of climate variability for Australia: El
Nino Southern Oscillation (ENSO), the Indian Ocean Dipole (IOD) and the Southern Annular Mode
(SAM). We find that the dominant climate mode for Australian summer heat wave frequency and
duration is ENSO and affects the Queensland and northwest regions of Australia.
49
Statistical Evidence of the Influence of Solar Activity
on Atlantic Multi-decadal Oscillation (AMO) and All
Indian Summer Monsoon Rainfall (AISMR) in Climate
Model Simulations
Abdul Malik1, Stefan Brönnimann1, Alexander Stickler1
1
Oeschger Center for Climate Change Research and Institute of Geography,
University of Bern, Switzerland
In this study, Atmosphere Ocean Chemistry Climate Model (AOCCM) simulations
with SOCOL-MPIOM accompanied with observational datasets have been used to
investigate the influence of solar activity on AISMR and AMO. Four different sets of
transient simulations from AD 1600-2000 including all major forcings, carried out in
the framework of the SNF project FUPSOL I, have been studied (L1, L2, M1 and M2
simulations of [1]). The simulations vary in solar forcing and ocean initial conditions.
In all model simulations, solar irradiance reconstructions by [2] have been used, with
strong Shapiro forcing (6 W/m2 mean TSI amplitude) in the L1 and L2 runs, and
medium Shapiro forcing (3 W/m2 mean TSI amplitude) in the M1 and M2 runs. Runs
with indices 1 and 2 have different initial ocean conditions. Initially, we have validated
SOCOL-MPIOM for AISMR with respect to several observational datasets (Twentieth
Century Reanalysis, 20CR, AD 1901-2000, [3]; Global Precipitation Climatology
Center, GPCC, AD 1901-2000, [4]; Monsoon Asia Drought Atlas, AD 1600-2000, [5]).
Figure 1 demonstrates the difference of the FUPSOL ensemble simulations (mean of
L1, L2, M1 and M2) compared to GPCC and 20CR. From Figure 1 it is clear that the
model simulates the monsoon season climatology of AISMR reasonably well for most
parts of the Indian sub-continent, whereas large differences are found over the
Western Ghats, the Himalayans, and the coastal ranges in Burma due to low spatial
resolution of the model (3.75°×3.75°). Figure 2 shows a comparison of the observed
(GPCC) and simulated (FUPSOL) annual cycle of AISMR. The model annual cycle
for AISMR shows an RMS error of 0.60 mm/day compared to GPCC. Moreover, we
have validated the relationships of AISMR with ENSO and AMO with the HadISST [6]
and Kaplan SST [7] datasets. The model shows a correlation coefficient (CC) of -0.51
between AISMR and the Niño3 index which is close to the observed correlation (0.42) during the period AD 1901-2000. [8] found a CC of 0.50 between decadal
AISMR anomalies and a decadal AMO index for 20th century. Our model is in
agreement with a CC of 0.41. Further, in our analysis we have found strong statistical
evidence of the influence of solar activity on AMO and AISMR both in observations
and climate model simulations. We have found statistical evidence that North Atlantic
SSTs are positively correlated with TSI on annual, decadal, and multi-decadal time
scales in climate model simulations and NOAA reconstructed SSTs [9]. Also AMO
influences the Niño3 and AISMR. We have calculated Spearman’s partial CCs, using
multiple liner regression technique, between AMO & TSI, AMO & Niño3, AMO &
50
AISMR, AISMR & TSI, and Niño3 & TSI while controlling or partialling out the the
effects of external factors/variables such as CO2, Tropospheric Aerosol Optical
Detpth (AOD), Stratospheric AOD etc. We have tried to investigate whether the
influence of TSI on Niño3 and AISMR is direct or it comes through AMO modulation
by TSI. We plan to do superposed epoch analysis of AISMR anomalies for high and
low solar activity during the entire simulated period (AD 1600-2000).
Figure 1. Difference of the FUPSOL ensemble
simulations with GPCC (right) and 20CR (left).
Figure 2. Comparison of the observed (GPCC)
and simulated (FUPSOL) annual cycle of AISMR.
References
1. S. Muthers, J. G. Anet, A. Stenke et al., The coupled atmosphere-chemistryocean model SOCOL-MPIOM, Geosci. Dev. Discuss 7, 3014 (2014),
10.5194/gmdd-7-3013
2. A. I. Shapiro, W. Schmutz, E. Rozanov et al., A new approach to the long term
reconstruction of the solar irradiance leads to large historical solar forcing,
Astron. Astrophys. 529(A67), 3023 (2011), 10.1051/0004-6361/201016173
3. G. P. Compo, J. S. Whitaker, P. D. Sardeshmukh et al., The Twentieth
Century Reanalysis Project, Quarterly J. Roy. Meteorol. Soc. 137, 1(2011),
10.1002/qj.776
4. U. Schneider, A. Becker, P. Finger et al., GPCC full data reanalysis version
6.0 at 0.5°: monthly land-surface precipitation from rain-gauges built on GTSbased and historic data, 2011, 10.5676/DWD_GPCC/FD_M_V6_050
5. E. R. Cook, K. J. Anchukaitis, B. M. Buckley et al., Asian monsoon failure and
megadrought during the last millenium, Science 328(5977), 486 (2010),
10.1126/science.1185188
6. N. A. Rayner, D. E. Parker, E. B. Horton et al., Global analyses of sea surface
temperature, sea ice, and night marine air temperature since the late
nineteenth century, J. Geophys. Res. 108(D14), 4407 (2003),
10.1029/2002JD002670
7. A. Kaplan, M. Cane, Y. Kushnir et al., Analyses of global sea surface
temperature 1856-1991, Journal of Geophysical Research 103, 18,567(1998)
8. K. J. Manish, A. C. Pandey, Trend and spectral analysis of rainfall over India
during 1901-2000, Journal of Geophysical Research 116, 1 (2011),
10.1029/2010JD014966
9. T. M. Smith, R. W. Reynolds, T. C. Peterson, et al., Improvements to NOAA's
Historical Merged Land-Ocean Surface Temperature Analysis (1880-2006),
Journal of Climate, 21, 10, (2008), http://dx.doi.org/10.1175/2007JCLI2100.1
51
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Consideration of risks, connected to extreme weather events, in spatial
planning of energy infrastructure
Maruöa Matko (1), Branko Kontiæ (1), Mojca Golobiè (2)
(1,) Joûef Stefan Institute, Jamova cesta 39, 1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia
(2) Biotechnical Faculty, Department of Landscape Architecture, Jamnikarjeva 101, 1000 Ljubljana,
Slovenia
The research investigates how to include risks to electric infrastructure due to extreme weather
events (EWE) into the spatial planning. The ultimate goal is reduction of societal cost associated to
damaged infrastructure, while intermediate goal is proper siting of new infrastructure. The work
covers both development and testing of a method for integrating risks and spatial planning. The
possibilities of application of the method are wide, ranging from different types of extreme weather
events, diverse infrastructure, as well as different geographical scales and regions.
The method consists of four steps:
1.
Determination of the geographic scope and intensity level of extreme weather event
based on data on past occurence
2.
Analysis of vulnerability of a system (electric energy infrastructure, location/area where
infrastructure is situated) tospecific EWE
3.
Determination of probability/frequency of occurrence of an extreme weather eventat a
particular site/region where specific energy infrastructure is or is going to be located
4.
Integration of the three steps towards determination of physical and other (e.g.,
economic, health) consequences leading to specification of risk index
The steps are schematically presented in Figure 1.
Figure 1: Steps in risk analysis
The method was tested on two case studies:
∑
Siting of new transmission lines in Slovenia considering consequences of heavy sleet in
2014
∑
Vulnerability of HPPs on the Sava river and NPP Kröko to heavy rain
52
Siting of new transmission lines in Slovenia considering consequences of heavy sleet in 2014
First, risk to electric power lines in Slovenia due to sleet was assessed. Further consideration shows
that results of risk assessment can be applied in spatial planning by means of avoiding areas where
the infrastructure would be most vulnerable and could be an important component of decision
making.
Figure 2: The proposed corridors of planned 400 kV powerline Berièevo - Divaèa overlayed with the map of risks
due to sleet - frequency of occurrence of sleet with specific intensity
Vulnerability of hydroelectric power plants to heavy rain
The analysis of past interruptions of the hydroelectric power stations on three Slovenian rivers (Sava,
Soèa and Drava) was carried out. An important component of the risk assessment method is the
evaluation of vulnerability of HPPs associated to the erosion potential in the watersheds, which is
then used in comparative evaluation between different river basins for the ultimate purpose of
informing siting of future energy infrastructure, HPPs, transmission lines, and others.
Figure 3: Risk indices for the Sava, Drava and Soèa river watersheds combined with erosion model results
References
IAEA. (2013).Techno – economic evaluation of options for adapting nuclear and other energy infrastructure to
long-term climate change and extreme weather. CRP IAEA, first Research coordination meeting, Wienna, April
2013
Kontiæ, D., & Kontiæ, B. (2008). Introduction of threat analysis into the land-use planning process. Journal of
Hazardous Materials, 163(2—3), 683-700.
Pütz, M., Kruse, S., Casanova, E., & Butterling, M. (2011). Climate Change Fitness of Spatial Planning. WP5
Synthesis Report. ETC Alpine Space Project CLISP
53
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Nonstationary Precipitation Implication on precipitation
maximum propability Curves for Hydraulic Infrastructure
Design in a Changing Climate
Hadush K. Meresa1 , Adane A. Awass2, Marzena Osuch1, Renata J. Romanowicz1
1
2
Institute of Geophysics Polish Academy of Sciences
Arbaminch University , water technology institute
Climate change could fundamentally alter the frequency, duration, extent and/or
severity of hydrological events. Extreme hydrological events are mainly depends
on the extreme climatic events that are growing more severe and frequent in the
world, calling into question how those changes are incorporate and formulate in
our Hydraulic infrastructure design. Currently our infrastructures are designed on
the bases of observed precipitation and probable maximum precipitation(PMP)
curves with the assumption of stationary, that is considered the climate extremes
will not vary significantly over time. However, climate change alter both the
climate and hydrological extremes in time and space, which is called
nonstationary. In this paper we addressed nonstationary issue b/c current PMP
curves can substantially underestimate Hydrological extremes and thus they may
not be suitable for hydraulic infrastructure design in a changing climate.
Therefore, it is necessary to confirm considering of nonstationary of extremes
climate and hydrological data are more robust and accurate estimation of design
streamflow for hydraulic infrastructure projects and flood mitigation works.
Generally, we compare the result from assumption of stationary and nonstationary
condition in different period of future climate. As per the result, we show that a
stationary climate assumption may lead to underestimation of extreme
precipitation, which increases the flood risk and failure risk in infrastructure
systems. The same result was also observed in the seven and fourteen days sum
maximum of precipitation in all catchments. We then present a generalized
framework for estimating nonstationary PMP curves and their uncertainties using
Bayesian inference. The methodology can potentially be integrated in future
design concepts.
Key words: climate change, nonstationary, PMP, uncertainty,
54
A
B
C
D
Figure. 1 Annual maximum from three days sum of precipitation maxima return level vs
return period in Prosna catchment:
A) under stationary condition,
B) non-stationary during the period of observations 1971–2100,
C) non-stationary based on median of sampled parameters, and
D) non-stationary based on the 95 percentile of the sampled parameters or Low Risk (LR)
non-stationary
References:
Barua, S., Muttil, N., Ng, A. W. M., and Perera, B. J. C. (2013). “Rainfall trend and its
implications for water resource management within the Yarra River catchment, Australia.”
Hydrol. Processes, 27(12), 1727–1738.
Halwatura D. , A. M. Lechner A.m., and S. Arnold S. (2015) “Drought severity–duration–
frequency curves: a foundation for risk assessment and planning tool for ecosystem establishment
in post-mining landscapes” Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci., 19, 1069-1091, doi:10.5194/hess-19-10692015
Rootzén H, Katz RW (2013) “Design life level: quantifying risk in a changing climate”. Water
Resour Res 49: 5964–5972
Yilmaz A. G., and Perera B.J. (2014) “Extreme Rainfall Nonstationarity Investigation and
Intensity–Frequency–Duration Relationship” J. Hydrol. Eng. 1160-1172.
55
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Past, present and future impact of Vb-cyclones on
extreme precipitation over Central Europe
Martina Messmer (1,2), Juan José Gómez-Navarro (1,2), and Christoph C.
Raible (1,2)
(1) Climate and Environmental Physics, Physics Institute, University of
Bern, Bern, Switzerland
(2) Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research, University of Bern,
Bern, Switzerland
Cyclones, which develop over the western Mediterranean and move
northeastward, are a major source of extreme weather and responsible for heavy
precipitation over Central Europe. However, despite their importance, the
relevant processes triggering these so-called Vb-events and their impact on
extreme precipitation are not yet fully understood. Gaining insight into these
processes is crucial to improve the projection of changes in frequency and
severity of Vb-driven extreme events under future climate change scenarios.
To identify prominent Vb-situations, this study applies a cyclone detection and
tracking tool to the ERA-Interim reanalysis (1979-2013). Results indicate that
although Vb-cyclones are rare events (2.3/year), they are present in around 15%
of all extreme precipitation days (99 percentile) over the Alpine region during the
analysed period. Still, only 23% of all Vb-events are associated with extreme
precipitation, indicating high variability in precipitation amounts across these
events. Thus, we further explore this variability and show that a major parameter
in triggering heavy precipitation in such events is the large-scale dynamics, while
the thermodynamic state of the atmosphere seems to be of secondary
importance. Thus, precipitation amounts are closely linked to the intensity of the
Vb-cyclone, although it is important to note that the impact they produce is rather
local and strongly dependent on the interaction between the large-scale
circulation and the complex orography around the Alps.
The impact of climate change on Vb-events is also explored in this
contribution. It can affect such events mostly through two mechanisms: changes
in the thermodynamic state of the atmosphere through global warming, or shifts
in the large-scale circulation that leave a footprint in the trajectory and intensity of
Vb-cyclones. To obtain a first glance on the changes associated to modifications
in the thermodynamic processes during Vb-events under climate change, we
56
perform a number of sensitivity experiments to assess the role of the Sea
Surface Temperature (SST) and its contribution to the moisture content in the
atmosphere. For this, we use the regional climate model WRF, which allows
simulating a physical consistent response of Vb-cyclones to different SSTs,
leaving the dynamical component of the problem fix through experiments. The
changes in SST are designed to follow the expected temperature changes in a
future climate scenario, also considering the uncertainty in such projections. The
regional climate model allows simulating explicitly the diabatic processes and the
influence of the Alps, which are of major relevance for the Vb-cyclones.
Preliminary results indicate that an increase of up to 3 °C is needed to noticeably
influence the precipitation amounts delivered over Central Europe during Vbevents. This indicates a non-linear response to the SST warming, and is in broad
agreement with the previous finding indicating that thermodynamic state only
plays a secondary role in triggering precipitation during Vb-events. Future studies
will address the influence of climate change on the large-scale dynamics, and
how this modifies the trajectory and depth of Vb-cyclones. For this, we will
compute and analyse a number of transient simulations driven by comprehensive
Earth System Models run under climate change scenarios.
57
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Understanding Extremes: A Multi-proxy, High
Resolution Record of Wildfire and Precipitation
History from Basin Pond, Maine, USA
Miller, Daniel R. (1), Bradley, Raymond S. (1), Castañeda, Isla S. (1)
(1) Department of Geosciences, University of Massachusetts – Amherst,
Amherst, MA, USA, 01003
Future impacts from climate change can be better understood by placing
modern climate trends into perspective through extension of the short
instrumental records of climate variability. This is especially true for extreme
climatic events, as the period of instrumental records provides only a few
examples and these have likely have been influenced by anthropogenic
warming1. Multi-parameter records showing the past range of climate variability
can be obtained from lakes. Lakes are particularly good recorders of climate
variability because sediment from the surrounding environment accumulates in
lakes, making them sensitive recorders of climate variability and providing highresolution histories of local environmental conditions in the past. In some cases,
such as at Basin Pond, Fayette, Maine, USA, sediment is persevered efficiently
enough to produce distinguishable annual laminations (varves) in the
sedimentary record. The varved record at Basin Pond was used to construct an
accurate, highly-resolved age-to-depth model over the past 300 years.
Using a multi-proxy analysis, including organic biomarker analysis of
molecular compounds and sedimentological features preserved in the sediment
record, a history of environmental change and climatic events at Basin Pond was
constructed. These sedimentary analyses were compared with the record of
known extreme events (from instrumental measurements and historical
documents), including 129 years of high-resolution (daily) precipitation and
temperature meteorological data, and two known wildfire events over the past
190 years. Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs), a class of organic
compounds that can be used to trace combustion activity2, 3, were found in
abundance in the Basin Pond sedimentary record. Peaks in the abundances of
two PAHs (retene and chrysene) and the ratio retene/(retene + chrysene) were
found to be highly correlated with the known wildfire events occurring in the
historical period, giving promise in using these compounds and ratio as a robust
proxy for regional wildfire events in northeastern U.S lacustrine sediment
records. Current work is underway on extending the record of regional wildfire
activity over the past 1,000 years using biogeochemical analysis of sedimentary
PAHs.
58
References
1 Bradley,
R.S. (Ed.), 2014. Paleoclimatology Reconstructing Climate of the
Quaternary, in: Paleoclimatology (Third Edition). Academic Press, San
Diego.
2 Denis,
E.H., Toney, J.L., Tarozo, R., Scott Anderson, R., Roach, L.D., Huang,
Y., 2012. Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) in lake sediments record
historic fire events: Validation using HPLC-fluorescence detection. Organic
Geochemistry 45, 7–17. doi:10.1016/j.orggeochem.2012.01.005.
3 Wilcke,
W., 2000. SYNOPSIS Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) in Soil
— a Review. Z. Pflanzenernähr. Bodenk. 163, 229–248. doi:10.1002/15222624(200006)163:3<229::AID-JPLN229>3.0.CO;2-6.
59
Swiss%Climate%Summer%School%2015:%Extreme%Events%and%Climate%
!
Understanding%the%Development%of%Deep%Convection%over%the%
western%Malaysian%Peninsula%during%Inter%Monsoon.%
!
Fadzil%Mohd%Nor1,%Pete%Inness1,%Chris%Holloway1%
%
(1)%Dept.%of%Meteorology,%University%of%Reading%
%
Orography! plays! an! important! role! in! the! development! and! spatial! pattern! of! heavy!
rainfall!over!the!Maritime!Continent.!This!work!is!looking!to!understand!the!mechanism!
involved!in!the!development!of!severe!convection!over!the!western!Malaysia!Peninsular!
during! inter! monsoon,! April?May! (AM)! and! September?October! (SO).! This! work! also!
looks! at! the! role! of! orography! and! Sumatra! Island! on! the! development! of! the! severe!
convection! and! the! rainfall! pattern.! The! number! of! rainy! days! is! generally! higher! over!
the! western! Malaysian! Peninsula! during! inter! monsoon! periods! than! during! monsoon!
seasons.!Based!on!the!gauge!data,!a!higher!number!of!rainy!days!was!observed!over!the!
inland!gauge!stations!than!the!west!coastal!stations.!This!result!agrees!with!the!previous!
studies!that!propose!that!the!interaction!between!sea!breezes!and!lee!waves!from!the!
mountain!as!well!as!the!mountain?valley!winds!reinforced!convection!activities!over!the!
mountainous!area!(Joseph!et.al.!(2008),!Qian!J.!H.!(2008),!Sow!et.!al.!(2011)).!The!same!
results! were! shown! in! TRMM! and! APHRODITE! analysis,! where! higher! number! of! rainy!
days! was! observed! over! the! inland! regions! rather! than! the! coast.! Diurnal! analyses!
showed!most!of!the!rainfall!occurred!in!the!afternoon!until!late!evening!and!mostly!is!
not!associated!with!the!active!phase!of!the!Madden?Julian!Oscillation.!For!heavy!rainfall!
analysis,! days! with! daily! rainfall! rate! above! the! 90th! percentile! were! determined! and!
analyzed.! Although! previous! results! showed! a! higher! number! of! rainy! days! were!
observed! during! inter! monsoon,! the! number! of! days! with! the! rainfall! above! the! 90th!
percentile!is!not.!More!heavy!rainfall!days!(above!90th!percentile)!were!observed!during!
winter!monsoon!over!the!west!coast!and!inland,!and!more!heavy!rainfall!days!during!SO!
over! the! northwestern! coast.! The! detailed! analysis! of! convection! activities! will! be!
analysed!using!high!resolution!model!by!simulating!two!case!studies,!one!each!from!AM!
and! SO.! These! two! events! caused! flash! floods! and! heavy! rainfall! over! the! west! coast!
Malaysian!peninsula.!Limited!area!domain!model!with!12!km!outer!domain!and!1.5!km!
inner!domain!were!set!up!for!the!model!run.!Sensitivity!experiments!will!also!be!done!
by! removing! orography! and! removing! Sumatra! Island.! We! will! use! the! simulations! to!
study!the!mechanisms!involved!in!the!development!of!severe!convection!on!these!dates!
and!how!orography!and!Sumatra!Island!affects!this!development!and!associated!rainfall!
over!the!western!Malaysian!Peninsula.!
%
%
%
%
1"
"
60
References%
Joseph,!B.!et!al.!(2008).!Sea!breeze!simulation!over!the!Malay!Peninsula!in!an!intermonsoon!
period.!!Journal(of(Geophysical(Research!113.D20,!p.!D20122.!
!
Sow,!Khai!Shen!et!al.!(2011).!Numerical!simulation!of!a!severe!late!afternoon!thunderstorm!over!
Peninsular!Malaysia".!Atmospheric(Research,99.2,!pp.!248!!
!
Qian!,!J!Hua!(2008)!Why!precipitation!is!mostly!concentrated!over!island!in!the!Maritime!
Continent.!Journal(of(Atmospheric(Science,(65,(pp!1428?1441!
!
!
!
2"
"
!
!
!
!
!
61
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
HEPS4Power – Extended-range
Hydrometeorological Ensemble Predictions for
Improved Hydropower Operations and Revenues
Samuel Monhart (1,2,3), Konrad Bogner (1), Christoph Spirig (2), Mark
Liniger (2), Fred Jordan (4) and Massimiliano Zappa (1)
(1) Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research WSL,
Mountain Hydrology and Mass Movements, Birmensdorf, Switzerland
(2) Federal Office of Meteorology and Climatology MeteoSwiss, Climate
Prediction, Zurich-Airport, Switzerland
(3) Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Sciences (IAC), ETH Zurich,
Switzerland
(4) e-dric, Lausanne, Switzerland
In recent years large progress has been achieved using operational hydrologic
prediction for lead times of up to ten days to manage flood events and droughts.
Beside predictions of extreme events many applications in the private and the
public sector would profit from hydrological forecasts exceeding the 10 day
forecast horizon. In particular the hydropower community would benefit strongly
from such extended-range forecasts for planning purposes and operations of
multi-reservoir sites. The meteorological extended-range predictions have
improved their skill during the last years. However, the operational use of such
forecasts for hydrological applications at lead times of 15 to 60 days has not yet
been established.
The new Swiss Competence Centers for Energy Research (SCCER) are
established to develop fundamental research. The subdivision investigating the
supply of energy (SCCER- SoE) focuses on innovative solutions in the field of
GeoEnergies and HydroPower. Within this framework the aim of the project
HEPS4Power is to demonstrate the added value of an operational extendedrange hydrometeorological forecasting system for fine-tuning hydropower
operations. The value-chain starts with the collection and processing of
meteorological data (MeteoSwiss) passed to operational application of state-ofthe-art hydrological modelling (WSL) and ends with the optimization of user
specific presentation of the data with an experienced partner in energy
forecasting (e-dric).
62
We will provide an overview of the planned steps to establish such a hydrometeorological prediction system for alpine catchments. In a first step
downscaling techniques need to be evaluated. This evaluation will be done for
Europe with a focus on the alpine region with complex topography. The
appropriate method will then be used to downscale ECMWF extended-range
forecasts which leads to high-resolution meteorological input data tailored for the
hydrological model ensemble. In the second step we will use a multi-model
approach for ensemble discharge prediction. Similar to the meteorological model
output, post-processing techniques will be applied to improve the quality of the
forecast against observed discharge. The final step in the project then combines
the hydrological predictions with energy market prices in an optimization model to
increase the revenues of multi-reservoir sites and to provide management
guidelines for the hydropower system operators.
63
64
65
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Uncertainties in measured extreme precipitation
events
Sungmin O (1, 2) and Ulrich Foelsche (1, 2, 3)
(1) Institute for Geophysics, Astrophysics, and Meteorology/Institute of
Physics (IGMA/IP), NAWI Graz, University of Graz, Austria
(2) FWF-DK Climate Change, University of Graz, Austria
(3) Wegener Center for Climate and Global Change (WEGC), University of
Graz, Austria
Introduction
Ground-level rain gauges provide the most direct measurements of precipitation,
and therefore, despite recent advances in remote sensing observations, such
rain gauge data are still utilized for calibration of radar/satellite precipitation
estimates. Regional climate and hydrological models also require rain gauge
data for their validation purposes. For these reasons, it is an important
elementary process to understand rain gauge data and to evaluate their
associated uncertainties and errors for obtaining accurate data.
My PhD research aims to assess the uncertainties in measured precipitation by a
high-resolution ground-based weather network, WegenerNet (hereafter, WegNet,
see ‘Materials and Planned approaches’). The research mainly addresses
extreme events since these are connected with high uncertainties in the
measurements and they can impact directly our societies and economies.
Research Questions
The main question of the research is ‘by how much has extreme precipitation
been underestimated?’, and in detail:
What/how much uncertainty is inherent in the WegNet data?
How much do national weather stations underestimate precipitation during
intense convective events due to under-sampling?
How can the WegNet data be utilized for calibration of remote sensing?
66
Materials and Planned Approaches
The WegNet is a dense network of 151 meteorological stations within an area of
about 20 km × 15 km centered near the city of Feldbach in the southeast of
Austria. The WegNet has a horizontal resolution of ≈ 1.4 km and employs ‘tipping
bucket’ gauges for precipitation measurements. Regular measurements started
in January, 2007, precipitation data are sampled every 5 minutes.
At first, a quantitative assessment of uncertainties in the WegNet is required to
use it as a ground reference. The uncertainties can be investigated at a point but
also in the whole domain. For one point study, for example, I am working on
systematic differences between measurements from different gauge sensors
since the WegNet data contain inherent bias due to its employment of three
different sensors. It will also be necessary to study the whole spatial data of the
WegNet to characterize the accuracy of grid-average precipitation.
The second part of study is planned to compare WegNet data with those derived
from other observation sources. The comparison can be conducted based on
scatter plots, statistical values such as bias, root mean squared error, mean
absolute error and so on. There are only two Austrian national weather stations
in the WegNet domain, so I could figure out how much we have been restricted
to data from those only two stations especially in extreme precipitation events.
The WegNet data also can be regarded as ‘true’ values for satellite estimates, for
example data from NASA’s Global Precipitation Missions which have only 1 by 1
degree resolution, in other word the high-resolution WegNet data will be a good
reference to evaluate error associated with the satellite estimates.
Conclusions
The results from this research will show the limitation of the current standard
weather stations to catch extreme precipitation amounts which are expected to
increase due to climate change. Also the feasibility of the WegNet data as a
ground reference will be secured so the data can be utilized beyond my PhD
research scopes.
References
Kirchengast, G., Kabas, T., Leuprecht, A., Bichler, C., and Truhetz, H.: WegenerNet: A
pioneering high-resolution network for monitoring weather and climate, B. Am. Meteorol.
Soc., 95, 227–242, 2014.
Villarini, G., W.F. Krajewski: Evaluation of the Research-Version TMPA Three-Hourly
0.25°x0.25° Rainfall Estimates over Oklahoma. Geopys. Res. Lett., 34,
doi:10.1029/2006GL029147, 2007.
Villarini, G., Mandapaka, P. V., Krajewski, W. F., and Moore, R. J.: Rainfall and sampling
uncertainties: A rain gauge perspective, J. Geophys. Res., 113, D11102,
doi:10.1029/2007JD009214, 2008.
67
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Assessing hydrological regime sensitivity to
climate change in a convective rainfall
environment: a case study of medium-sized
eastern Mediterranean catchments
Nadav Peleg (1), Eylon Shamir (2), Konstantine Georgakakos (2,3), and
Efrat Morin (4)
(1) Hydrology and Water Resources Program, Hebrew University,
Jerusalem, Israel ([email protected]), (2) Hydrologic Research
Center, San Diego, California, USA, (3) Scripps Institution of
Oceanography, University of California San Diego, La Jolla California, USA,
(4) Department of Geography, Hebrew University, Jerusalem, Israel
A modeling framework is formulated and applied to assess the sensitivity of the
hydrological regime of catchments with respect to projected climate change. The
study uses likely rainfall scenarios with high spatiotemporal resolution that are
dependent on projected changes in the driving regional meteorological synoptic
systems. The framework was applied to a case study in two medium-sized
Mediterranean catchments in Israel, affected by convective rainfall, by combining
the HiReS-WG rainfall generator and the SACSMA hydrological model. The
projected climate change impact on the hydrological regime was examined for
the RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 emission scenarios, comparing the beginning of the
21st century and the mid-21st-century periods from General Circulation Models
simulations available from CMIP5. Focusing on changes in the occurrence
frequency of regional synoptic systems and their impact on rainfall and
streamflow patterns, we find that the mean annual rainfall over the catchments is
projected to be reduced by 15% (outer range 2–23%) and 18% (7–25%) for the
RCP4.5 sand RCP8.5 emission scenarios, respectively. The mean annual
streamflow volumes are projected to be reduced by 45% (10–60%) and
47% (16–66%). Moreover, the streamflow season in these ephemeral streams is
projected to be shorter by 22% and 26–28% for the RCP4.5 and RCP8.5,
respectively. The amplification in reduction of streamflow volumes relative to
rainfall amounts is related to the projected reduction in soil moisture, as a result
of fewer rainfall events and longer dry spells between rainfall events during the
wet season. The dominant factors for the projected reduction in rainfall amount
were the reduction in occurrence of wet synoptic systems and the shortening of
the wet synoptic systems durations. Changes in the occurrence frequency of the
two dominant types of the regional wet synoptic systems (Active Red Sea Trough
and Mediterranean low) were found to have a minor impact on the total rainfall.
68
References
Peleg, N., Shamir, E., Georgakakos, KP., Morin, E., (2015), A framework for
assessing hydrological regime sensitivity to climate change in a convective
rainfall environment: A case study of two medium-sized eastern Mediterranean
catchments, Israel. Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 19, p. 567–581.
Peleg, N., Bartov, M., Morin, E., (2014), CMIP5-predicted climate shifts over
the East Mediterranean: implications for the transition region between
Mediterranean and semi-arid climates. International Journal of Climatology,
DOI: 10.1002/joc.4114.
69
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Probabilistic Modeling of the European Severe
Thunderstorm Climate
Georg Pistotnik (1), Henning W. Rust (2), Pieter Groenemeijer (3), Robert
Sausen (4)
(1) Ludwig Maximilian University (LMU), Munich, Germany
(2) Free University of Berlin, Berlin, Germany
(3) European Severe Storms Laboratory (ESSL), Wessling, Germany
(4) German Aerospace Center (DLR), Oberpfaffenhofen, Germany
Thunderstorms with phenomena like large hail, severe wind gusts, tornadoes and
flash floods are among the most important weather-related hazards in Europe.
Their small extent in space and time makes it difficult to collect large enough
pairwise samples of known events and underlying meteorological conditions to
examine their behavior.
As a remedy, objective reanalyses provide “artificial” gridded soundings which
allow the computation of covariates, or “proxies” for the probability of severe
storm occurrence, consistently across space and time (Brooks et al., 2003). We
computed such covariates from ERA-Interim (Dee et al., 2011) and matched
them with severe storm observations from the European Severe Weather
Database (ESWD; Dotzek et al., 2009) for the period 2006-2013 across central
Europe, where the reporting efficiency of such events was reliably high. Logistic
regressions were applied to smooth the probabilities and to extrapolate them into
unprecedented combinations of given predictors.
The probability of severe weather rises with increasing Convective Available
Potential Energy (CAPE) and with increasing 0-6 km vertical wind shear (deeplayer shear; DLS) for each investigated type – large hail (Fig. 1), damaging
winds, tornadoes and, surprisingly, also for flash floods.
Applying these probabilities to the entire ERA-Interim data set 1979-2013 allows
computing a synthetic European severe thunderstorm climate. Fig. 2 shows the
expected annual number of large hail events per 10.000 km2. Most prominently, it
rises from north to south, and it is also enhanced in the surroundings of large
mountains like the Alps and the Pyrenees. The other severe weather types
feature qualitatively similar patterns. Tornadoes, albeit generally less frequent,
are slightly favored over coastal compared to inland areas.
Among our most important results are the following: (1) CAPE and DLS are the
best two predictors for large hail, while CAPE and 0-1 km vertical wind shear
(low-level shear; LLS) are the best for severe wind gusts, tornadoes, and flash
floods; (2) adding a third predictor by introducing the 6-hourly convective
precipitation in ERA-Interim as a measure for the likelihood of convective
initiation, and a fourth one by splitting CAPE into its two individual components,
namely the vertical temperature gradient and low-level moisture, further improves
70
the results; and (3) linear logistic regressions are not a good enough fit and need
to be generalized to additive logistic regressions. These findings are significant
on a 95% level according to Chi Square and Likelihood Ratio Tests, respectively.
Finally, applying these proxies to MPI-ESM decadal climate predictions allows an
estimate of future trends of severe storm frequency in Europe. A weak and nonsignificant rising trend of severe thunderstorms from 1979 to 2013 is predicted to
continue in the upcoming decade, mainly resulting from an increase of CAPE
which overcompensates a decrease of vertical wind shear.
References
•
Brooks, H.E., J.W. Lee, and J.P. Craven, 2003: The spatial distribution of
severe thunderstorm and tornado environments from global reanalysis
data. – Atmos. Res., 67-68, 73-94.
•
Dee, D.P., and Co-Authors, 2011: The ERA-Interim reanalysis:
Configuration and performance of the data assimilation system. – Q. J. R.
Meteorol. Soc., 137:656, 553-597.
•
Dotzek, N., P. Groenemeijer, B. Feuerstein, and A.M. Holzer, 2009:
Overview of ESSL's severe convective storms research using the
European Severe Weather Database ESWD. – Atmos. Res., 93, 575-586.
Fig.1: Probability of >2 cm sized hail events [%] per 10.000 km2 and per six
hours as a function of sqrt(CAPE) and DLS. Left: observations. Right: additive
logistic regression. Black contours outline 1, 10, 100 and 1000 occurrences in the
training data set (the predictors are discretized to steps of one unit each).
Fig. 2: Expected annual number of >2 cm sized hail events 1979-2013 per
10.000 km2, modeled with an additive logistic regression based on the optimum
four predictors (vertical temperature gradient, low-level moisture, DLS, and
likelihood of convective initiation).
71
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Extreme Weather Events Impact Modelling: a
Transport Case Study
Maria Pregnolato (1), Richard Dawson (1), Alistair Ford (1), Sean Wilkinson
(1), Carmine Galasso (2)
(1) School of Civil Engineering and Geoscience, Newcastle University,
Newcastle (UK)
(2) Department of Civil, Environmental and Geomatic Engineering and
Institute for Disaster and Risk Reduction, University College London,
London (UK)
Critical infrastructures, such as transportation systems, are at risk of natural
hazards worldwide, in particular in urban areas. A changing climate and a strong
urbanization is posing under pressure communities, assets, and built environment.
As infrastructures can be considered the backbone of cities, network resilience has
become a necessary component of any structured development. A key to effective
acts on road transport network is an in-depth knowledge of their exposure and
vulnerability to geologic hazards, as floods, and the damage due to their impact
experienced across the network.
In recent years, since uncertainty trends dominate the scenario, flood management
has seen a transition from scenario-based approach to risk-based approach.
Therefore, risk modelling has assumed a key role in flood risk assessment (De
Moel and Aerts 2011).
This research addresses the challenges by focusing on the development of
probabilistic methodology for managing risk by modelling urban transport networks
within the context of flooding events, through a combination of climate simulations
and spatial representations. By overlaying spatial data on hazard thresholds from
a flood model and a flood safety function, different levels of disruption to
commuting journeys on road networks are evaluated as indirect tangible damage
(Jenkins et al. 2012). To calculate the disruptive effect of flooding on transport
networks, a function relating water depth to safe driving car speed has been
developed by combining data from experimental reports, safety literature, analysis
of videos of cars driving through floodwater, and expert judgement (Figure 1).
72
Figure 1. Representation of the safety driving speed as a function of the flooding water depth.
A preliminary analysis has been run in the Tyne & Wear (in North-East England)
region to demonstrate how the analysis can assessed the disruptions for commuter
journeys due to flooding. Nevertheless, it can be applied to present conditions as
well as future uncertain scenarios, allowing the examination of the impacts
alongside socio-economic and climate changes
As model validation is rarely performed in damage modelling and it is often
evaluated as a gap in the research, an urban flood validation on real data from
traffic flows is an on-going effort to assure the reliability of the method.
Future research directions are likely to undertake cost-benefit analysis of
adaptation measures, for an optimal employment of resources and a cost-effective
risk management. This new step will involve i) flood risk estimation of events with
different severity and frequency ii) a portfolio of potential risk reduction options iii)
quantification and comparison of benefits and cost of the different options selected.
References
De Moel, H., and Aerts, J. (2011). "Effect of uncertainty in land use, damage
models and inundation depth on flood damage estimates." Natural Hazards,
57, 407-425.
Jenkins, K., Glenis, V., Ford, A., and Hall, J. (2012). "A Probabilistic Risk-Based
Approach to Addressing Impacts of Climate Change on Cities: The Tyndall
Centre’s Urban Integrated Assessment Framework." UGEC Viewpoints,
Connecting Past and Present Lessons in Urbanization and the Environment (8).
73
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
A review on regional convection-permitting
climate modeling: Demonstrations, prospects, and
challenges
Andreas F. Prein (1,2),Wolfgang Langhans (3), Giorgia Fosser (4), Andrew
Ferrone (5), Nikolina Ban (6), Klaus Goergen (7,8,9),Michael Keller (6,10),
Merja Toelle (11), Oliver Gutjahr (12), Frauke Feser (13), Erwan Brisson (14),
Stefan Kollet (9,15), Juerg Schmidli (6,10), Nicole P. M. van Lipzig (16), and
Ruby Leung (17)
(1) National Center for Atmospheric Research, Boulder, Colorado, USA
(2) Wegener Center for Global and Climate Change (WEGC), University of Graz, Graz, Austria
(3) Earth Sciences Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, California, USA
(4) Meteo-France/CNRS, CNRM-GAME, Toulouse, France
(5) Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology, Environmental Research and Innovation Department,
Environmental Resource Center, Belvaux, Luxembourg
(6)Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
(7) Meteorological Institute, University of Bonn, Bonn, Germany
(8) Juelich Supercomputing Centre, Research Centre Juelich, Juelich, Germany
(9) Centre for High-Performance Scientific Computing in Terrestrial Systems, ABC/J Geoverbund, Juelich,
Germany
(10) Center for Climate Systems Modeling, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
(11) Institute of Geography, Justus-Liebig Universitaet Giessen, Giessen, Germany
(12) Regional and Environmental Sciences, Department of Environmental Meteorology, University of Trier,
Trier, Germany
(13) Institute for Coastal Research, Helmholtz-Zentrum Geesthacht Centre for Materials and Coastal
Research, Geesthacht, Germany
(14) Institut fuer Atmosphaere und Umwelt, Goethe-Universitt Frankfurt am Main, Frankfurt, Germany
(15) Agrosphere (IBG-3), Research Centre Juelich, Juelich, Germany, 16Department of Earth and
Environmental Sciences, KU Leuven Leuven, Belgium,
(17) Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Richland, Washington, USA
Regional climate modeling using convection-permitting models (CPMs; horizontal
grid spacing <4 km) emerges as a promising framework to provide more reliable
climate information on regional to local scales compared to traditionally used
large-scale models (LSMs; horizontal grid spacing >10 km). CPMs no longer rely
on convection parameterization schemes, which had been identified as a major
source of errors and uncertainties in LSMs. Moreover, CPMs allow for a more
accurate representation of surface and orography fields. The drawback of CPMs
is the high demand on computational resources. For this reason, first CPM
climate simulations only appeared a decade ago. In this study, we aim to provide
a common basis for CPM climate simulations by giving a holistic review of the
topic. The most important components in CPMs such as physical
parameterizations and dynamical formulations are discussed critically. An
overview of weaknesses and an outlook on required future developments is
provided. Most importantly, this review presents the consolidated outcome of
studies that addressed the added value of CPM climate simulations compared to
LSMs. Improvements are evident mostly for climate statistics related to deep
convection (such as the summertime diurnal circle of precipitation; Figure 1),
mountainous regions, or extreme events. The climate change signals of CPM
74
simulations suggest an increase in flash floods, changes in hail storm
characteristics, and reductions in the snowpack over mountains. In conclusion,
CPMs are a very promising tool for future climate research. However,
coordinated modeling programs are crucially needed to advance
parameterizations of unresolved physics and to assess the full potential of CPMs.
Figure 1. Mean diurnal cycle of (a) precipitation averaged across June, July, and
August (JJA) in Switzerland; (b) July 2006 in Switzerland; (c) June, July, and
August in the eastern part of the Alps; (d) annually in Southern UK; and (e) June,
July, and August in Baden-Wuerttemberg, Germany. All CPM climate simulations
show improvements in the shape (onset and peak) of the precipitation diurnal
cycle compared to their corresponding LSM simulations. The approximate
location of the model domains is shown in (f).
References
Prein, Andreas F., et al. "A review on regional convection ‐permitting climate
modeling: demonstrations, prospects, and challenges." Reviews of Geophysics
(2015).
75
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Evaluation of heat-related mortality and
adaptation measures in Switzerland
Ragettli Martina S. (1,2), Urbinello Damiano (1,2), Schindler Christian (1,2),
Röösli Martin (1,2)
(1) Swiss Tropical and Public Health Institute, Basel, Switzerland
(2) University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland
Amplified by global warming, there is a need to reduce the public health impacts
of exposure to hot weather. The health risks of heat waves may vary across the
globe depending on climatic, demographic and socioeconomic profiles. In
Switzerland, a heat wave occurring during summer 2003 caused an estimated
7% increase in all-cause mortality (Grize et al., 2005). As a consequence, the
Swiss Federal Office of Public Health provided recommendations on how to
behave during hot weather periods.
Our project aims to (1) evaluate implemented preventive measures to reduce
heat-related mortality, (2) to assess the effect of heat waves on mortality in
Switzerland, and (3) to identify meteorological parameters best describing the
heat effect on mortality.
First, adopted and recommended measures aiming to reduce heat-related
mortality in different counties in Switzerland will be collected and evaluated.
Second, Swiss mortality data (1995-2012) and meteorological data from
MeteoSwiss will be used to investigate heat-related excess mortality. The
hypothesis will be tested whether the effect of heat episodes on mortality has
been reduced since 2003. Finally, both the results of our project and of other
identified relevant epidemiological studies on the topic will be made available to
agencies and stakeholders in Switzerland by means of workshops and
newsletters.
The project will generate evidence on the meteorological parameters of heat
waves most strongly related to increased mortality. It will indicate whether an
increased sensitivity to health risks of heat waves and adopted policies have
reduced the extent of heat-related mortality in Switzerland. This information may
contribute to limiting the public health impacts of heat waves and climate change
worldwide, and will generate evidence for new potential adaptation measures
within health policy programs.
76
References
Grize, L.; Huss, A.; Thommen, O.; Schindler, C.; Braun-Fahrländer, C. Heat
wave 2003 and mortality in Switzerland. Swiss Med. Wkly. 2005, 135, 200-205.
77
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Exploring eight millennia of climatic, vegetational
and agricultural dynamics on the Swiss Plateau
by using annually layered sedimentary time series
Fabian Rey (1), Erika Gobet (1), Adrian Gilli (2), Albert Hafner (3), Willy
Tinner (1)
(1) Institute of Plant Sciences and Oeschger Centre for Climate Change
Research, University of Bern, Switzerland
(2) Geological Institute, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology Zurich,
Switzerland
(3) Institute of Archaeological Science and Oeschger Centre for Climate
Change Research, University of Bern, Switzerland
Annually layered lake sediment series from the Swiss Plateau are exceptionally
rare. To contain annual laminations (varves), such lakes need to be deep (>2030 m) to prevent bioturbation due to anoxic bottom waters and the bedrock has
to be carbonatic to build up light calcite summer layers. Furthermore the lakes
should be small (< 0.5 km2) to possess local to regional pollen and spore signals
as vegetation proxies. So far, only the two well-studied sites at Soppensee and at
Faulenseemoos delivered varve sequences at low altitudes. They cover the time
before the first significant increase of human impact during the Neolithic (around
6000 BP). With Moossee and Burgäschisee in Canton of Bern, we present two
new sites with varved sequences covering most of the cultural phases and the
transition periods in between (Neolithic, Bronze Age, Iron Age, Roman Period,
Migration Period, Middle Ages and Little Ice Age). Annually layered sediments
have the potential to enhance the chronological precision of sedimentary
sequences via a combination of varve counts with wiggle matching of
radiocarbon dates, an approach which often applied in archeology and
dendrochronology. Until now, studies combining archeology and varved
sediments are lacking because no varved series were available so far in
Switzerland. For both Bernese lakes, Neolithic pile dwellings mainly from the
Cortaillod Culture (5900-5600 BP) are known. Sometimes, these cultural phases
were very short (less than 20 years) and with the high precision of the varve
chronologies it may be possible to track even such short-term landnam phases.
The first focus of our study will be on Neolithic cultures (6500-4300 BP) since
most of the well-dated archeological findings are covering that time period. With
the findings at the excavation sites and the results from the lake sediments, it will
be possible to perform an on-site/off-site comparison. Our second focus will take
a closer look to the short-term events and important transitions between cultural
phases (e.g. Iron Age-Roman Period, Roman Period-Migration Period, and
Middle Age-Little Ice Age). The aim of our study is to understand the linkages
78
between past societies, land use, climate, vegetation and fire activity more
thoroughly than achieved so far.
79
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Drought forecasting using statistical methods
Doug Richardson (1), Hayley Fowler (1), Chris Kilsby (1), Francesco
Serinaldi (1)
(1) School of Civil Engineering and Geosciences, Newcastle University
Drought is a complex meteorological and hydrological phenomenon that can
have severe implications for natural habitats, ecosystems, and many social and
economic sectors. Generally drought is separated into four distinct operational
definitions functionally separated by the time scales under which they form.
These are (1) meteorological drought (below average rainfall), (2) hydrological
drought (e.g. streamflow deficits), (3) agricultural drought (soil moisture deficits)
and (4) socioeconomic drought (related to the demands of end-users). In the UK
drought is a recurrent feature of climate (Marsh et al., 2007) with potentially large
impacts on public water supply (e.g. 1975-76, 1995-96, 2010-12), yet it is rare
that a drought will encompass the whole country at once. This is due to spatially
varying precipitation and temperature levels and the type of primary water source
at risk. South and east England relies mostly on groundwater abstraction from
aquifers, whilst northern and western regions obtain water primarily from surface
water (Jones and Lister, 1998). Future climate projections display some
agreement that UK drought will increase in frequency, severity and spatial extent
(e.g. Rahiz and New, 2013), with repeat climatic conditions driving the 1975-76
drought a distinct possibility.
Water companies’ ability to mitigate the impacts of drought by managing
diminishing availability depends on forward planning and it would be extremely
valuable to improve forecasts of drought on a monthly to seasonal scale. By
focusing on statistical forecasting methods, this research aims to provide
techniques that are simpler, faster and computationally cheaper than physicallybased models. In general statistical forecasting is done by relating the variable of
interest (some hydro-meteorological variable such as rainfall or streamflow, or a
drought index) to one or more predictors via some formal dependence. These
predictors are generally antecedent values of the response variable or external
forcings. The examination of the behaviour of long-memory processes (e.g.
large-scale atmospheric circulation patterns, sea surface temperatures and soil
moisture content) in the time leading up to the onset, peak severity and
termination points of drought events should result in the identification of suitable
predictors to be included in the forecasting model, and further our understanding
of the drivers of drought.
A candidate model is Generalised Additive Models for Location, Scale and Shape
parameters (GAMLSS; Rigby and Stasinopoulos, 2005). GAMLSS is a very
80
flexible class allowing for more general distribution functions (e.g. highly skewed
and/or kurtotic distributions) and the modelling of not just the location parameter
but also the scale and shape parameters. Additionally GAMLSS permits the
forecasting of an entire distribution, allowing the output to be assessed in
probabilistic terms rather than simply the mean and confidence intervals.
References
Jones, P.D. and Lister, D.H. (1998) 'Riverflow reconstructions for 15 catchments
over England and Wales and an assessment of hydrologic drought since 1865',
International Journal of Climatology, 18(9), pp. 999-1013.
Marsh, T., Cole, G. and Wilby, R. (2007) 'Major droughts in England and Wales,
1800–2006', Weather, 62(4), pp. 87-93.
Rahiz, M. and New, M. (2013) '21st Century Drought Scenarios for the UK',
Water Resources Management, 27(4), pp. 1039-1061.
Rigby, R.A. and Stasinopoulos, D.M. (2005) 'Generalized additive models for
location, scale and shape', Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series CApplied Statistics, 54, pp. 507-544.
81
1
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
A climatology of synoptic-scale Rossby wave triggering
events
Matthias Röthlisberger1 , Olivia Martius1,2 and Heini Wernli3
1
Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research and Institute of Geography, University
of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
2 Mobiliar Lab for Natural Risks, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
3 Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
Extended Abstract
Synoptic-scale Rossby waves are ubiquitous in the extratropical flow and together with
jets and vortices they form the building blocks of extratropical dynamics. The triggering of synoptic-scale Rossby waves and the associated mechanisms have so far not
been analysed in detail. In this study a novel method is presented that automatically
identifies triggering events (TEs) of synoptic-scale Rossby waves on tropopause-level
waveguides. TEs are identified based on geometry changes of the 2 Potential Vorticity
Units (PVU) contours on two isentropic levels (320 and 340 K). The 2 PVU contours
are hereby regarded as proxies for the position and shape of the extratropical and subtropical waveguide respectively (e.g. Hoskins and Ambrizzi, 1993; Martius et al., 2010).
A TE is recorded in a zonally aligned (i.e. wave-free) longitudinal contour segment if
it becomes wavy over time and, additionally, the respective 2 PVU contour is wave-free
upstream of the segment.
In this study we focus on the mechanisms that lead to the formation of synoptic-scale
Rossby waves on tropopause-level waveguides. Viewed from a PV perspective, these
triggering mechanisms illustrate ways how meso- to synoptic-scale PV anomalies can be
brought to or generated near a wave-free upper-level waveguide. As a proof of concept
and in order to illustrate the potential of the identification algorithm, three example
TEs are presented in which distinct triggering mechanisms can be identified. In the
82
REFERENCES
2
first TE, a large convective system associated with strong diabatic processes leads to
the formation of an upper-level low-PV anomaly (e.g. Wernli and Davies, 1997) and
triggers a Rossby wave on the extratropical waveguide. In the second case, a meso-scale
lower-stratospheric high-PV anomaly (e.g. Kew et al., 2010) approaches the undisturbed
extratropical waveguide from the north and acts as trigger for a Rossby wave. The
third case illustrates the interaction between the two waveguides. A breaking wave
on the extratropical waveguide steers a lower-stratospheric high PV anomaly into close
proximity with the undisturbed subtropical waveguide and induces a wave on the latter
(e.g. Martius et al., 2010). The method is applied to ERA-Interim data from 1979 to
2014 in order to produce a feature-based climatology of TEs on the two waveguides in
the Northern Hemisphere during winter. Three main regions of triggering activity are
identified: the Northwestern Pacific, North America and the North Atlantic, as well as
North Africa and the Middle East.
In future work we will expand the climatology of TEs to all seasons and both hemispheres
and we will explore climatological aspects of Rossby wave triggering, such as possible
linkages between major climate modes and Rossby wave triggering.
References
Hoskins, B. J., and T. Ambrizzi. 1993. Rossby wave propagation on a realistic longitudinally varying flow. J. Atmos. Sci. 50, 1661–1671.
Kew, S. F., M. Sprenger, and H. C. Davies. 2010. Potential vorticity anomalies of the
lowermost stratosphere: A 10-yr winter climatology. Mon. Weather Rev. 138, 1234–
1249.
Martius, O., C. Schwierz, and H. C. Davies. 2010. Tropopause-level waveguides. J.
Atmos. Sci. 67, 866–879.
Wernli, H., and H. C. Davies. 1997. A Lagrangian-based analysis of extratropical cyclones. I: The method and some applications. Q. J. Roy. Meteor. Soc. 123, 467–489.
83
Atmospheric and oceanic warming patterns depend non-linearly on
the forcing magnitude
Maria Rugenstein1 and Reto Knutti1
1
ETH Zürich, Institute for Atmospheric and Climate
An understanding of the variability and extremes in a changing climate requires a robust understanding
of the sensitivity of climate to different timescales and magnitudes of perturbations. Since I do not work
directly on extreme events, I will present work on spatial patterns of global warming and its temporal
variability.
I show – in an idealistic setting for CO2 step function forcings – that the strength of the atmospheric
perturbation influences the ocean heat uptake and sea level rise in a non-linear fashion. The (local) rate of
change of ocean heat uptake in turn will influence the (local) atmospheric warming pattern, land-sea, and
low- versus high latitude warming contrast. We use the intermediate complexity model ECBilt-CLIO and
up to 90 ensemble members for each of the six forcing levels ranging from 1.07 to 16 times preindustrial CO2
concentration.
Very high CO2 forcing increases the stratification in the ocean, slowing down the channeling of heat into
the deep ocean. Very low, barely noticeable atmospheric CO2 forcing, also shows high equilibration time
scales, due to a very weak response of the circulation. “Standard scenarios” of CO2 increase, in the range of
the RCP scenarios, shows the strongest circulation response and the fastest ocean heat uptake.
Depending on the forcing scenario the heat is stored in different locations, which influences the sea level
rise globally and locally and sets the conditions for SST warming. I would be happy to discuss whether this
may have implications for the detection and attribution of extreme events.
84
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Development of a hybrid finite-element Cloud
Resolving Model including grid adaptivity
J. Savre (1), M. Herzog (1), C. Pain (2), J. Percival (2)
(1) Department of Geography, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK
(2) Department of Earth Science & Engineering, Imperial College London,
London, UK
Despite the recent development of highly-scalable atmospheric models (at
global, regional and cloud scales) and the emergence of extremely powerful
high-performance computing centers, we are still not able to accurately resolve
all the physical scales involved in the climate and weather systems. It actually
now appears clear that rethinking our existing models and the numerical methods
employed will be necessary to continue improving their performances while
increasing the affordable spatial resolution.
To achieve this goal, the next generation atmospheric models must offer
the possibility to better control the spatial resolution and numerical efforts by
increasing the flexibility of the numerical grid [1]. This includes models supporting
very irregular meshes and adaptive remeshing techniques. Of course, the
numerical methods used to solve the flow equations must be consequently
adapted to preserve some important numerical properties (accuracy, mass
conservation, no spurious oscillations...).
The Cloud Resolving Model (CRM) introduced and evaluated in this work
combines the use of adaptive triangular (in 2D, tetrahedral in 3D) meshes with
hybrid finite-element methods (continuous/discontinuous Galerkin methods). The
code is based on the Fluidity dynamical core (developed at Imperial College
London [2]) which has been enhanced to include dry and moist atmospheric
thermodynamics, cloud microphysics and appropriate boundary conditions to
solve cloud scale atmospheric flows.
The model introduced above has been thoroughly tested under dry
atmospheric conditions (dry convection, topographically forced gravity waves...)
and its ability to capture moist atmospheric processes (moist convection,
condensation/evaporation, precipitation generation...) has been demonstrated
(see Figure 1). In particularly, it has been shown that adaptive grids are able to
accurately capture the main features of buoyancy driven atmospheric flows
(Figure 2), without accuracy loss, but with a substantial performance
improvement (CPU time reduced by a factor up to 8 at comparable maximum
resolution).
85
Future works will focus on the improvement of the cloud microphysics
scheme and the application of the new modelling framework to actual cloud
conditions. In particular, as part of the EU-FP7 PEARL (Preparing for Extreme
And Rare events in coastal regions [3]) project, the model will be used to study
the development of heavily precipitating cloud systems over the eastern coast of
Denmark (Greve) which can regularly lead to severe floods.
Figure 1: Development of a 2D idealized squall line cloud system, 1h after initialization.
Bold line: cloud boundaries, color shadings: precipitation eld, vectors: wind vectors.
Figure 2: Density current simulations with a uniform grid (left) and adaptive remeshing
(right). Iso-contours and colors represent potential temperature perturbations from 0 K
to -15 K. The maximum resolution in both cases is 6 m.
References
[1] J. Slingo et al., Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A., 367, 815-831, 2009
[2] R. Ford et al., Mon. Wea. Rev., 132, 2816-2831, 2004
[3] www.pearl-fp7.eu
86
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Added value of very high resolution model
simulations for the coasts of Northern Germany
using the example of two case studies of extratropical cyclones
Benjamin Schaaf (1), Frauke Feser (1)
(1) Helmholtz-Zentrum Geesthacht, Germany
This study aims to analyse a range of added values for a very high-resolution
climate model simulation (RCM) which permits convection in comparison to a
regional model with coarser grid resolution.
Reanalysis data was dynamically downscaled with the RCM COSMO-CLM to a
much higher resolution, using in addition to the conventional forcing via the
lateral boundaries the spectral nudging technique in the model domain´s interior.
This method 'nudges' the large spatial scales of the regional climate model
towards the reanalysis, while the smaller spatial scales are left unchanged. It was
applied successfully in a number of applications, leading to realistic atmospheric
weather descriptions of the past.
The hindcast was calculated for the last 67 years, from 1948 until 2014. The
model area is the German Bight, including Northern Germany and parts of the
Baltic Sea. This is one of the first model simulations at climate scale with a very
high resolution of 2.8 km, so even small-scale effects can be detected.
Two case studies were analysed, storms Xynthia (February/March 2010) and
Christian (October 2013) which both moved through the model area. With a
filtering and tracking program the course of individual storms was tracked and
compared with observations. The high-resolution model simulation shows
precipitation areas which are not present in the coarser grid simulation,
especially in summer months when the maximum of convective precipitation is
reached. This leads to a higher monthly accumulated precipitation, which is more
realistic in comparison to observations. Also for wind speed and gusts one can
see a more realistic wind field in urban areas, which is caused by a better
description of surface topography. In addition return values and percentiles of
wind speed and precipitation were examined.
References
Geyer, B.: High-resolution atmospheric reconstruction for Europe 1948–2012:
coastDat2, Earth Syst. Sci. Data, 6, 147-164, doi:10.5194/essd-6-147-2014,
2014
87
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Exploring the causes of rare extreme precipitation
events in the south-eastern Alpine foreland region
Katharina Schröer (1, 2), Gottfried Kirchengast (1, 2, 3)
(1) Wegener Center for Climate and Global Change (WEGC), University of
Graz, Austria
(2) FWF-DK Climate Change, University of Graz, Austria
(3) Institute for Geophysics, Astrophysics, and Meteorology/Institute of
Physics (IGAM/IP), University of Graz, Austria
While there is still considerable uncertainty in how the character of precipitation
will change in space and time, the “frequency or intensity of heavy precipitation
events has likely increased in North America and Europe” [1], and extreme
intensities of short-duration precipitation events on the daily to sub-hourly scale
seem to increase unambiguously as temperatures rise [e.g., 2, 3, 4].
Statistical studies on extreme precipitation contribute substantially to the
research field. Thresholds, such as percentile values are used to classify
extreme events out of a given sample. Probability density functions (PDFs) are
sought, fit and applied to describe frequency, magnitude or recurrence intervals
of extreme precipitation events. We term such extreme events statistical extreme
events - “SEEs”.
These studies respond to the needs of engineering practice in e.g. infrastructure
design, or trend analysis of precipitation in climate studies, but they a) often
ignore outliers because of practical or statistical/data limitations (i.e. left out as
“residual risk”) and b) tell us little about the underlying processes of the climate
and weather system causing these outliers. We term these outliers that can only
be attributed to the distribution tails via large uncertainty ranges as rare extreme
events - “REEs”.
The main focus of this study is to identify and physically assess processes that
potentially differentiate REEs from SEEs under the hypothesis that REEs are
caused by a conjunction of specific conditions on different scales. We
differentiate spatio-temporal circumstances of large-scale/long-term and
regional/seasonal preconditioning that combine with specific local/short-term
event conditions.
In this initial study, we primarily examine precipitation records of high temporal
resolution (5 and 10 min) of the Austrian Hydrographic Service (AHYD) and
ZAMG (National Weather Service of Austria) meteorological station networks
over the climate-sensitive south-eastern Alpine foreland region. We delineate
temporally and spatially coherent precipitation events rather than treating regular
observation intervals as individual instances. The most extreme events found are
then systematically analyzed in depth, using a large pool of auxiliary data.
1
88
For each event, the preconditioning will be evaluated making use of extended
climate and weather information such as atmospheric analyses and synoptic
observations; complemented by a desk review of peer-reviewed scientific
literature, extreme event reports, retrospects of weather services and others. By
systematically exploring the spatio-temporal character and conditioning
processes of REEs on a per-event basis we aim to overcome some of the limits
of data-sparse statistics. In identifying specific patterns of processes generating
REEs we intend to contribute to understanding uncertainties associated with
extreme precipitation.
Looking ahead to later phases of the project, a desirable outcome is to use
findings from the analysis of the recent past to have valuable information to
evaluate extreme precipitation in climate model scenarios of the future.
References
[1] IPCC, 2013: Summary for Policymakers. In: Climate Change 2013: The
Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fifth Assessment
Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change [Stocker, T.F., D. Qin,
G.-K. Plattner, M. Tignor, S.K. Allen, J. Boschung, A. Nauels, Y. Xia, V. Bex and
P.M. Midgley (eds.)]. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom
and New York, NY, USA
[2] Trenberth, K. E. (2011). Changes in precipitation with climate change. Climate
Research 47 (1-2), 123–138. WOS:000289207700014.
[3] Berg, P., C. Moseley, and J. O. Haerter (2013, March). Strong increase in
onvective precipitation in response to higher temperatures. Nature Geoscience 6
3), 181–185.
[4] Kendon, E. J., N. M. Roberts, H. J. Fowler, M. J. Roberts, S. C. Chan, and C.
Senior (2014, July). Heavier summer downpours with climate change revealed by
weather forecast resolution model. Nature Climate Change 4 (7), 570–576.
WOS:000338837400021.
2
89
Authors:))
Martina)Schubert2Frisius)and)Frauke)Feser)))
Helmholtz2Zentrum)Geesthacht)(HZG),)Zentrum)für)Material2)und)Küstenforschung;)Germany.)
)
)
)
Title:)A)global)regionalization)of)NCEP2Reanalysis)using)a)high)resolution)general)circulation)model)
)
Abstract:)
)
Long2term) reanalysis) products) represent) an) important) data) source) for) numerous) climate) studies.) However,)
their)coarse)spatial)resolution)and)the)inhomogeneity)in)space)and)time)make)it)difficult)to)derive)changes)in)
meteorological) variables) over) time.) Therefore,) we) use) spectral) nudging) to) down2scale) the) global) reanalysis)
data) to) a) finer) resolution) with) a) general) global) circulation) model.) Besides) the) conserving) of) the) large2) scale)
atmospheric)information)and)the)resulting)finer)topography,)an)added)value)of)information)in)meteorological)
phenomena)of)medium)and)small)spatial)extensions)is)expected.)
)
Following) this) strategy) a) global) regionalization) with) the) global) high2resolution) atmospheric) model) ECHAM6)
(T255L95),) developed) by) MPI2M) Hamburg,) was) recently) performed) successfully) by) spectrally) nudging) NCEP1)
reanalysis)(T62L28))for)the)time)period)from)1948)until)April)2015.)This)simulation)enables)the)investigation)of)
long2term) changes) in) meteorological) phenomena;) the) focus) is) put) here) on) intense) storms.) We) found) in)
preliminary)analyses)the)expected)added)value)on)medium)and)smaller)scales)compared)to)the)driving)NCEP)
re2analysis)by)evaluating)them)with)observed)data)and)finer)resolved)re2analyses)from)DWD,)EOBS,)CRU)and)
ERA2Interim.) Most) of) the) regional) storms) like) hurricanes) and) typhoons) are) better) reconstructed) in) ECHAM6)
compared)to)NCEP1,)although)their)intensity)still)lies)below)those)of)best)track)data.))The)data)was)also)used)to)
present)first)results)of)tropical)cyclones)undergoing)extra2tropical)transition)(ET).))
)
)
)
90
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Analysis of solar influence on tropospheric
weather using a new time series of weather types.
Mikhaël Schwander (1,2), Stefan Brönnimann (1,2)
(1) Climatology Group, Institue of Geography, University of Bern
(2) Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research, University of Bern
Weather types describe daily atmospheric circulation variability over a given
region with a simple measure. Their use can be beneficial for historical
climatology, which increasingly targets day-to-day variability but lacks
comprehensive atmospheric circulation fields further back than 1871 (start of the
Twentieth Century Reanalysis). A new statistical method is used to generate a
daily weather type classification (WTC) covering the last 250 years. The method
uses an existing classification (e.g. CAP) available for a reference period and
extends it back to the end of the 18 th century. The CAP classification used in our
study is available from 1957 onward. It has been computed by MeteoSwiss using
ERA-40/ERA-Interim reanalyses (Weusthoff, 2011). In order to produce a
weather types time series which covers a longer time period than the available
reanalyses, we use early instrumental data from weather stations. A classification
(CAP9) is taken as a reference for a determined period. Let x be a vector with
information from stations 1...n for one day. x contains weather data from several
stations. For example, t=temperature, p=pressure, Δp=pressure tendency.
Further, let i denote the weather type (1 to 9 for CAP9). Then, the weather type of
day t is the type i that minimizes the following function (Mahalanobis distance):
∑i is the covariance matrix of x for all days in the reference period that pertain to
the weather type i.
We use instrumental data form Western/Central Europe in order to cover the
period 1763-2008. All the data need to be available for the reference period
(1957-1998), so the whole time series is calibrated over the same period. The
comparison of the new time series with the reference (obtained from ERA-40 and
Interim) shows a good correlation (0.85). However, the new methods performs
better for winter months than for summer.
91
This new WTC offers the possibility to analyze weather conditions over Europe
for more than two centuries with objective types. In the frame of the FUPSOL-II
project (Future and Past Solar Influence on the Terrestrial Climate), this new time
series is used to analyze solar activity changes on weather types in Europe
based on the frequency of occurrence of these types. This kind of analysis has
been performed by Huth et al. (2008), but it only covers the period 1949-2003.
The first results of the analysis over 245 years show a slight increase in the
frequency of easterly and northerly types over Western and Central Europe
under low solar activity in winter. Under high solar activity, there is a tendency
towards westerly types to be more frequent (linked to an enhanced zonal flow).
References
Huth, R et al. (2008), Solar activity affects the occurrence of synoptic types over
Europe. Annales Geophysicae, 26(7):1999-2004.
Weusthoff, T. (2011). Weather Type Classification at MeteoSwiss: Introduction of
new automatic classification schemes. Arbeitsberichte der MeteoSchweiz,
235:46.
92
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Decadal Climate Predictions Using Sequential Learning
Algorithms
Ehud Strobach (1) and Golan Bel (1)
(1) Department of Solar Energy and Environmental Physics, Blaustein Institutes for
Desert Research, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Sede Boqer Campus, 84990
Israel
Ensembles of climate models can improve future climate predictions and reduce their
uncertainties. We use Sequential Learning Algorithms (SLAs) [1] in order to establish a
weighted ensemble of climate models based on their past performance. This method has
several advantages, including the lack of a priori assumptions regarding the ensemble
members; the weight of the ensemble members can be updated upon the arrival of new
measurements, and it can be proved that the prediction of the weighted ensemble is at least
as good as the prediction of the best model if the learning period is long enough. Using this
method, we aim to achieve two main goals: to provide better future climate predictions and to
reduce their uncertainties.
We divide the predictions made by the climate models into two periods: a learning period and
a prediction period. During the learning period, the weights are assigned to the climate
models in a sequential manner. At the beginning, some initial weight is assigned to the
models. In the case of no a priori knowledge, the models are assigned with equal weights.
Then, a new observation is revealed, and based on this, the models are scored using a loss
function–an evaluation metric that measures the discrepancy between the predicted value
and the outcome. Finally, the loss function is used to update the weights of the previous
sequence. This process is repeated until there are no new available observations, and the
weights of the last learning sequence are used for future predictions–the prediction period.
The goal of SLAs is to minimize the cumulative regret with respect to each expert (i.e., climate
model). This quantity is defined as:
𝑛
𝑅𝐸,𝑛 ≡ ∑ (𝑙(𝑝𝑡 , 𝑦𝑡 ) − 𝑙(𝑓𝐸,𝑡 , 𝑦𝑡 )) ≡ 𝐿𝑛 − 𝐿𝐸,𝑛
𝑡=1
where 𝑡 is a discrete time, 𝑛 is the number of learning steps, 𝑝𝑡 is the forecaster’s (i.e., the
weighted average) prediction, 𝑦𝑡 is the outcome and 𝑓𝐸,𝑡 is the prediction by expert 𝐸; 𝑙 is the
loss function, which we define to be the squared error loss – 𝑙(𝑝𝑡 , 𝑦𝑡 ) ≡ (𝑝𝑡 − 𝑦𝑡 )2 . 𝐿𝑛 and 𝐿𝐸,𝑛
are the cumulative loss functions of the forecaster and the expert 𝐸, respectively. Using the
forecaster’s strategy, it can be shown that:
𝑛→∞
max𝐸=1,…,𝑁 (𝑅𝐸,𝑛 ) → 0,
meaning that the forecaster will predict at least as well as the best expert during the learning
period (provided there is a long enough learning period).
The SLAs were applied to a set of 30-year decadal experiments, from 1981-2011, of the
Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 5 (CMIP5). The first 20 years were used as a
learning period and the last 10 years (120 months) were used as a prediction period. Figure
93
1 shows the number of time points in which the Exponentiated Gradient Average (EGA) SLA
had smaller error (upper panel) and smaller uncertainty (lower panel) than the reference
climatology. White circles represent a significant improvement by the EGA algorithm, and
black circles represent a significantly poorer performance. The algorithm has also been
shown to improve the predictions of the simple average and the best model [2].
Figure 1: The number of time points in which the Exponentiated Gradient Average (EGA) SLA had smaller error (upper panel)
and smaller uncertainty (lower panel) than the reference climatology. White circles represent a significant improvement by the
EGA algorithm, and black circles represent a significantly poorer performance.
References
[1] Cesa-Bianchi, N., and G. Lugosi, 2006: Prediction, learning, and games. Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, UK.
[2] Strobach, E., and G. Bel, 2015: Improvement of climate predictions and reduction of their uncertainties using
learning algorithms. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics Discussions, 15 (5), 7707–7734, doi:10.5194/acpd-157707-2015, URL http://www.atmos-chem-phys-discuss.net/15/7707/2015/.
94
Hazardous thunderstorms over Lake Victoria: climate
change and early warnings
Wim Thiery1, Edouard Davin2, Sonia Seneviratne2, Kristopher Bedka3, Stef
Lhermitte1 and Nicole van Lipzig1
1
2
3
KU Leuven - University of Leuven, Belgium
Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Switzerland
NASA Langley Research Center, United States of America
Corresponding author’s e-mail address: [email protected]
Despite the lack of accurate statistics, fatalities among fishermen operating on
the surface of Lake Victoria are estimated to rise up to several thousands per
year, most of them caused by severe weather. Here we present the first
dedicated high-resolution, coupled lake-land-atmosphere climate projection for
the African Great Lakes region and investigate the influence of future enhanced
greenhouse gases on extreme thunderstorms over Lake Victoria. Our model
projections for the end-of-the-century underline the major role for Lake Victoria
in modulating extreme precipitation changes. Under a high-emission scenario
(RCP8.5), the 1% most extreme over-lake precipitation may intensify by 18%
towards 2071-2100 relative to 1981-2010, that is about three times faster
compared to the projected change over the surrounding land after isolation from
the mean change. The expected Clausius-Clapeyron scaling of precipitation
extremes to temperature increases holds over Lake Victoria but not over the
surrounding land, confirming the lake imprint on future precipitation change
patterns. Interestingly, this is in contrast to the change in average over-lake
precipitation, which is projected to decrease by -6% for the same period. By
further analyzing the high-resolution output we were able to explain this different
response. While mesoscale circulation changes cause the average precipitation
decline, the response of extremes is essentially thermodynamic.
Furthermore, a study of the controlling factors of extreme nighttime
thunderstorms over Lake Victoria revealed a strong dependency of the nighttime
over-lake storm intensity on the antecedent daytime land storm activity.
Physically, intense daytime land storms induce a moist anomaly in the lower
layers of the atmosphere, and cool the land surface. The cold anomaly limits
moisture divergence from the lake (weak lake breeze) while favouring nighttime
near-surface convergence (strong land breeze). Satellite-based observations of
precipitation intensity or thunderstorm activity may therefore serve as a risk
indicator for storm intensity over Lake Victoria the following night.
95
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Radar Characteristics and Patterns Related to
Convective Wind Gusts in Switzerland
Simona Trefalt (1,2), Olivia Martius (1), Alessandro Hering (2) , Urs Germann (2)
(1) University of Bern, Mobiliar Group for Climate Impact Research
(2) MeteoSwiss, Division for Radar, Satellite and Nowcasting
During the convective season (April to September) severe thunderstorms often affect
Switzerland, both North and South of the Alps. Heavy precipitation, large hail and wind gusts
may cause damage to buildings and agriculture among many others and represent
considerable costs for insurance companies.
Accurate real-time point measurements of wind gusts in Switzerland are available from ~130
ground weather stations, which make up a very dense network compared to the international
mean. Due to the high spatial (and temporal) variability of wind gusts the number of stations
is however still not high enough to provide a full depiction of the wind gust distribution over
the Swiss territory. Weather radar data, conversely, has a wide-ranging quasi-continuous
spatial coverage and permits the study of the 3D development of gust-producing cells and
the surrounding environment. Algorithms for wind gust detection from radar data exist for flat
topographic areas, but they cannot directly be adopted for the configuration of the
operational 4th generation C-Band Swiss Radar Network as well as in complex terrain. On the
one hand, the radar beam visibility close to the ground, where potentially damaging wind
gusts occur, is often limited by orography and the radars are too far apart to form a dual- or
multiple-Doppler network. On the other hand, the prioritisation of long-range measurements
such as for the Swiss Radar Network entails low Nyquist velocities, with the need for
complex dealiasing procedures. Additionally, existing methods frequently focus on detection
and nowcasting of mesocyclones, which are a small contributor to severe weather in
Switzerland. In consequence, other approaches need to be considered.
In this study, radar proxies are searched for an a posteriori detection of wind gusts to
construct comprehensive wind gust maps. Possible proxies are investigated as pre-cursor
signals of wind gusts as well, to contribute to severe weather warnings. In the analyses, we
relate non-Alpine weather station wind gust recordings above 20m/s (i.e. a damage threshold
used by insurance companies) for the convective seasons 2012-2014 to radar products in
the area immediately surrounding the stations. The radar products considered are MaxEcho,
EchoTop15, -45 and -50, Vertically Integrated Liquid (VIL), Probability of Hail (POH) and
Maximum Expected Severe Hail Size (MESHS), which are operationally computed at
MeteoSwiss. We furthermore investigate the (vertical) evolution of these radar products with
time, i.e. leading up to severe wind gusts.
The synoptic situation in Central Europe concomitant with severe wind gusts is examined
and first results suggest that during the analysis period gust-producing cells are
predominantly associated with an approaching or passing cold or warm front rather than
thermal thunderstorms or convergence lines. K-means clustering analysis is employed to
96
statistically characterise the occurrence of wind gusts related to different patterns in radar
reflectivity. Composites of the other afore-mentioned radar products are subsequently built
according to the k-means clustering classes. A discussion relative to the results of these
analyses will be presented in the poster.
97
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
A new classification of atmospheric droughts
Obbe Tuinenburg
Copernicus Institute, Utrecht University, The Netherlands
This research aims to increase the understanding of droughts globally, by analysis of the
atmospheric water budget during normal and drought periods.
Using an atmospheric moisture tracking model, precipitation is tracked back in the atmosphere to
create a climatology of the atmospheric moisture balance. The anomaly of this balance during
drought situations is determined to create a new classification of atmospheric droughts: locally
dominated (no atmospheric anomaly), moisture budget dominated (anomalous moisture advection
due to different evaporation in the moisture source area, but normal winds) and flow anomaly (wind
field anomaly).
Figure 1 shows an example of the methodology for October periods in Spain based on ERA-interim
reanalysis, which would probably be classified as moisture budget dominated. The top figures show
results of the atmospheric moisture tracking. Normally, the precipitation that falls in Spain has
evaporated quit nearby in the east-Atlantic, off the coast of Portugal and Morocco. During dry
periods, moisture sources shift northwards. The bottom panels show that October precipitation in
Spain correlates well with evaporation and temperature in the same east-Atlantic area.
Currently, the methodology is applied and analyzed globally for the current climate (1979-present)
and for CMIP5 climate change scenario's.
The possible utilization of the knowledge of the type of drought and statistical tele-connections is
an increased (statistical) predictability of droughts by monitoring sea- and land-surface conditions
in the evaporation areas that contribute to remote precipitation.
98
Figure 1: Evaporative origin of October precipitation falling in Spain for normal and drought
periods (top panels) and correlation of precipitation with surface evaporation and temperatures.
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Extreme River Floods in Western Switzerland and
the Lake of Constance Region in the Period Prior
to Instrumental Measurements
Daniel Tuttenuj, M. A.
Section of Social, Economic and Environmental History, Historical Institute,
University of Bern
Supervisor: Prof. Dr. Christian Rohr
The floods that occurred on the Aare and Rhine rivers in May 2015 and the
mostly successful handling of this event in terms of flood protection measures
are a good reminder of how important it is to comprehend the causes and
processes involved in such natural hazards. While the needed data series of
gauge measurements and peak discharge calculations reach back to the 19th
century, historical records dating further back in time can provide additional and
useful information to help understanding extreme flood events and to evaluate
prevention measures such as river dams and corrections undertaken prior to
instrumental measurements.
In my PhD project I will use a wide range of historical sources to assess and
quantify past extreme flood events. It is part of the SNF-funded project
“Reconstruction of the Genesis, Process and Impact of Major Pre-instrumental
Flood Events of Major Swiss Rivers Including a Peak Discharge Quantification”
and will cover the research locations Fribourg (Saane R.), Burgdorf (Emme R.),
Thun, Bern (both Aare R.), and the Lake of Constance at the locations Lindau,
Constance and Rorschach. My main goals are to provide a long time series of
quantitative data for extreme flood events, to discuss the occurring changes in
these data, and to evaluate the impact of the aforementioned human influences
on the drainage system. Extracting information given in account books from the
towns of Basel (Source 1) and Solothurn (Source 2) may also enable me to
assess the frequency and seasonality of less severe river floods. Finally,
historical information will be used for remodeling the historical hydrological
regime to homogenize the historical data series to modern day conditions and
thus make it comparable to the data provided by instrumental measurements.
99
The method I will apply for processing all information provided by historical
sources such as chronicles, newspapers, institutional records, as well as flood
marks, paintings and archeological evidence has been developed and
successfully applied to the site of Basel by Wetter et al. (2011). They have also
shown that data homogenization is possible by reconstructing previous stream
flow conditions using historical river profiles and by carefully observing and reconstructing human changes of the river bed and its surroundings. Taken all
information into account, peak discharges for past extreme flood events will be
calculated with a one-dimensional hydrological model.
Figure 1: Processing of historical information in order to calculate peak discharges of river
flow. Source: Wetter et al. 2011, 737.
References
Source 1: Wochen-Ausgabenbücher der Stadt Basel; Staatsarchiv Basel-Stadt:
Finanz G 1-84.
Source 2: Seckelmeisterrechnungen der Stadt Solothurn; Staatsarchiv Solothurn:
SM.
Wetter, O., Pfister, C., Weingartner, R., Luterbacher, J., Reist, T., & Trösch, J.
(2011): The largest floods in the High Rhine basin since 1268 assessed from
documentary and instrumental evidence. Hydrol. Sci. J. 56(5), 733–758.
100
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Adaptation decisions and damage costs under
uncertainty in an empirical general equilibrium
framework
Takafumi Usui (1), Frank Vöhringer (1, 2) and Philippe Thalmann (1)
(1) Laboratory of Environmental and Urban Economics, École Polytechnique Fédérale de
Lausanne, Switzerland.
(2) Econability, Switzerland.
1
Research objectives
Mitigation measures are primary research interests in order to prevent irreversible damages on the
environment attributable to anthropogenic interferences. However, due to the inertia of the climate
system, there is a growing need for adaptation strategies. An ex-ante assessment of adaptation
strategies is necessary, but it is methodologically abstract how to address uncertainty in the intensity
and the impact of climate change in economic modeling.
The goal of the project is to analyze decision rules for the implementation of adaptation measures
under uncertainty within the framework of a general equilibrium model. The project focuses on
extreme flood hazards in Switzerland, which could be associated with climate change. We will
discuss stochastic flood damages and related adaptation decisions employing a computational general
equilibrium (CGE) model. The damage costs caused by flooding will be estimated, taking into account
the long-term economic developments and the impact of climate change. Through the project, we aim
to show how uncertainty can be introduced into a CGE model and also to gain a better understanding
of the economic nature of different adaptation options for flooding.
2
2.1
Methodology and current results
CGE model with uncertain flood events
A CGE model is a unified framework for analyzing the efficiency and the equity of economic
decisions based on relative price changes. It is widely employed in various fields of applied economics
and especially in the field of energy and environment; numerous policy simulations can be found.
Uncertainty is of general interest for the CGE modeling community. Löschel and Otto (2009) tested
the sensitivity of modeling results to uncertainties about the cost and the performance of backstop
technologies such as CCS, using Monte Carlo analysis.
Perfect foresight is a common assumption in dynamic CGE models, however, this seems not to
be appropriate with stochastic shocks. In our simulations, we modify the modeling framework such
that agents in the economy have perfect foresight for macroeconomic conditions but the timing and
the intensity of floods are still uncertain. With this adjustment, the agents would be simply surprised
when floods occur and the capital stock would be damaged depending on the scale of flooding.
Fig.1 is an illustrative example for a capital accumulation path with a perfect foresight and a myopia
assumption. As shown in panel (a), the capital stock is accumulated in a proactive way since the agent
could forecast future damages by flooding. Whereas the agent is uncertain about flood events, as
1
101
4
4
3
Benchmark
Run 1
Run 2
Run 3
Run 4
Run 5
Run 6
Run 7
Run 8
Run 9
Run 10
Activity index of capital stock
Activity index of capital stock
Benchmark
Run 1
Run 2
Run 3
Run 4
Run 5
Run 6
Run 7
Run 8
Run 9
Run 10
3
2
2
1
1
0
0
0
10
20
30
Time series
40
50
0
(a) Perfect foresight
10
20
30
Time series
40
50
(b) Complete myopia
Fig. 1. Effects of different assumptions for the agent’s behavior on the dynamic capital accumulation
path. Ten independent simulation runs are extracted, where the timing and the damage scale of
floods are random parameters.
depicted in panel (b), severe damage on the accumulated capital stock can be expected, if there is no
adaptation effort.
2.2
Dynamic damage cost estimation
Over the last decades, the number of floods in Switzerland increased. For instance, the flood
in 2005 was especially damage-intensive and caused estimated about 3 billion CHF economic loss.
We start to define selected flood events and to show how damages for these empirical floods can be
estimated considering long term economic growth and climate change.
3
Future research plans
The next steps of the on-going research project are:
1. To introduce specific capital with which the economy can adapt to or downscale the impact of
the uncertain flood damages.
2. To select regional floods in Switzerland, evaluate damages with economic growth scenarios and
specify adaptation measures for selected events.
3. To implement within the existing CGE model for Switzerland, the GENESwIS.
References
Löschel, Andreas and Vincent M. Otto (2009) “Technological uncertainty and cost effectiveness
of CO2 emission reduction,” Energy Economics, Vol. 31, No. SUPPL. 1, pp. S4–S17, DOI:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.eneco.2008.11.008.
2
102
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Sting Jet analyses in extratropical cyclones
Ambrogio Volonte’1 , Peter A. Clark1 , Suzanne L. Gray1
1
(a)
Department of Meteorology, University of Reading, UK
(b)
Figure 1: Infrared satellite image from Meteosat (1a). Cloud-top brightness temperature (K) from MetUM
simulation (1b). Both images refer to the storm Tini at 06z on 12th February 2014. In the images the fronts, the
cloud head and the dry intrusions are highlighted; SJ stands for sting jet.
Extratropical cyclones can easily produce windstorms that have a large social and economic impact. Generally, these strong surface winds are related to low-level jets occurring along warm and cold fronts but, analysing
the Great Storm that affected the UK in October 1987, Browning (2004) and Clark et al. (2005) highlighted
that an additional region of strong surface winds can exist on the southern side of the cyclone centre, in the
frontal-fracture area located between the cold front and the bent-back front. These strong winds are related to
an airstream, called a “sting jet”, that exits from the tip of the hook-shaped cloud head in the mid-troposphere
and descends towards the surface, accelerating and reducing its relative humidity.
In this PhD project, “Dynamics of Sting Jets and their relation to Larger-Scale Drivers” funded by the AXA
Research Fund, we are investigating the large-scale factors controlling the generation and growth of sting jet
airstreams. The scope of this study is to understand and highlight the dynamical basis of the sting jet, in order
to provide a strong theoretical underpinning to the sting-jet related research. In particular, we aim to assess
the actual role of large-scale environmental parameters (e.g. cyclone background state) and the contribution of
diabatic processes and of effects such as the release of different atmospheric instabilities.
The first stage of this project, that we are currently carrying out, consists of the analysis of a real casestudy, the storm Tini, that affected the UK on 12th February 2014 (Figure 1). We are looking at the evolution
of this extratropical cyclone through simulations run with the MetUM, which is the operational forecast model
of the Met Office, UK, and by means of post-processing programs written using the Iris-Python language. With
this methodology we are verifying the presence of a sting jet in this storm and we are also analysing backtrajectories (computed with the software LAGRANTO (Wernli and Davies 1997)) and looking at instabilities’
diagnostics in order to gain further information on the sting jet dynamics. The poster will show the results of
this investigation.
The subsequent stage of the project, that we will soon start to undertake, regards idealised simulations to be
performed in a periodic channel configuration with baroclinic lifecycles. With this more general setting it will
be possible to understand more in depth the mechanisms leading to sting jets and address the main questions
of the project, using sensitivity experiments and examining carefully the role of potential vorticity and related
variables during the storm evolution.
103
References
Browning, K. A., 2004: The sting at the end of the tail: Damaging winds associated with extratropical cyclones.
Q. J. R. Meteorol. Soc., 130, 375–399.
Clark, P. A., K. A. Browning, and C. Wang, 2005: The sting at the end of the tail: Model diagnostics of
fine-scale three-dimensional structure of the cloud head. Q. J. R. Meteorol. Soc., 131, 2263–2292.
Wernli, H. and H. C. Davies, 1997: A Lagrangian-based analysis of extratropical cyclones. I: The method and
some applications. Q. J. R. Meteorol. Soc., 123, 467–489.
104
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
The impact of increased Mediterranean sea
surface temperatures on central European
extreme precipitation
Claudia Volosciuk (1), Douglas Maraun (1), Vladimir Semenov (1,2,3,4),
Natalia Tilinina (3), Mojib Latif (1), Sergey Gulev (3)
(1) GEOMAR Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel, Kiel, Germany
(2) A.M. Obukhov Institute of Atmospheric Physics, Russian Academy of
Sciences, Moscow, Russia
(3) P.P. Shirshov Institute of Oceonology, Russian Academy of Sciences,
Moscow, Russia
(4) Institute of Geography, Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia
Central European climate is influenced by the Mediterranean Sea, where a strong
increase in sea surface temperature (SST) has been observed during the last four decades.
One example of extreme weather events are cyclones following the “Vb” pathway.
These cyclones are generated over the Mediterranean Sea, travel northeastwards around
the Alps and then hit central European countries. These cyclones carry large amounts of
moisture and cause extreme precipitation, and subsequently flooding, particularly in
summer.
To investigate the impact of increased Mediterranean SST on extreme precipitation in
Europe, we analyze a series of simulations with the atmospheric general circulation
model ECHAM5. In the control run, we forced the model with the 1970-1999 SST
climatology. In an additional run, we replaced the Mediterranean and Black Sea SST
forcing with the climatology of the warmer 2000-2012 period. ECHAM5 was run at high
horizontal resolution (T159) and integrated for 40 years in each experiment. 20-season
return levels (RL20S) were derived as a measure of extreme precipitation for daily
precipitation in JJA (June - August). These return levels are estimated as quantiles of a
stationary generalized Pareto distribution, based on exceedances of the 95th precipitation
percentile.
Summer RL20S are increased in central Europe along the Vb cyclone track in the warmer
Mediterranean simulation, compared to the control run (see Fig. 1), although summer
mean precipitation does not change much. Due to the warmer climate in the
Mediterranean region, climatological mean evaporation and precipitable water in the
atmosphere are increased. On extreme days, composites show an even further increase in
precipitable water over the central European region and evaporation over the western
Mediterranean sea. This additional available moisture is transported from the
Mediterranean sea to central Europe. Over land, evaporation does not increase and,
hence, moisture recycling does not appear to play a major role in the simulated increase
in extreme precipitation. This finding suggests further increases in European summer
105
flooding, should Mediterranean SSTs continue to increase.
Figure 1: Simulated increase in 20-summer daily
precipitation return levels due to a warmer
Mediterranean sea.
106
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Remote sensing of past and recent fires:
Assessing the accuracy of different satellite
products
Helga Weber (1,2), Stefan Wunderle (1,2)
(1) Remote Sensing Research Group, Institute of Geography, University of
Bern, Switzerland
(2) Oeschger Center for Climate Change Research, University of Bern,
Switzerland
Over the last 40 years, increased levels of burning raised awareness of fireclimate-human linkages in the past to assess future interactions (Kehrwald et al.,
2013). These include the relative importance of rising temperatures, climate
variability, and management practices because levels of fire activity are expected
to increase in many regions as e.g. droughts intensify (Moritz et al., 2012). But
large uncertainties exist due to the amount, frequency, and intensity of burning
biomass emissions under changing climate. Over the last 150 years, fire records
showed a decoupling from fire activities of the main drivers temperature and
population density. The most important drivers of this phenomenon remain
debated and will be addressed by the interdisciplinary Sinergia project “Paleo
fires from high-alpine ice cores”. This research framework brings together
expertise of ice core analysis and interpretation, fire reconstruction from natural
archives, atmospheric modelling of fire tracers, and remote sensing of fire
activities to link past and recent observations.
The remote sensing subproject will identify fire events for Europe, Siberia, and
Amazonia based on different satellite sensors covering a time series of the last
30 years. For the compiled data set of fire events the retrieval accuracy will differ
for different satellite systems depending on the size of the fire, vegetation
coverage, and atmospheric conditions. However, merging of multiple satellite
products with different spatial resolutions is not widely done, but has been found
to be of high value for burned area estimates (Giglio et al., 2010). Therefore, an
accuracy assessment will be performed and their uncertainties analysed using
existent satellite products as well as the application and modification of retrieval
methods (e.g. MODIS, AVHRR, ASTER, and (A)ATSR). One of the first
objectives is to compare fire products and define the size of fires/burnt areas
related to vegetation coverage. This comparison and quality assessment is the
topic of the poster and will be accompanied by an illustrative example of the
different satellite products for one fire event. The result of the accuracy
assessment will aide the compilation of a homogenous time series based on
different satellite systems. Additionally, own retrievals of fires from NOAA/MetOp
107
AVHRR imagery will extend the fire time series to the last 30 years. This is the
only sensor with sufficient heritage for the needed time series and its potential
has been shown in several studies (e.g. Li et al., 2001). In future, this data set
will be used to investigate the influence of climate change on the annual fire
frequency, intensity, and size in different temperate, boreal, and tropical regions.
This enables the calibration of ice core fire proxies and supports modelling of
backward trajectories.
References
Giglio, L, Randerson, J T, Van der Werf, G R, Kasibhatla, P S, Collatz, G J,
Morton, D C, and DeFries, R S (2010). “Assessing variability and long-term
trends in burned area by merging multiple satellite fire products”. Biogeosciences
7.3, pp. 1171–1186.
Kehrwald, N M, Whitlock, C, Barbante, C, Brovkin, V, Daniau, A L, Kaplan, J O,
Marlon, J R, Power, M J, Thonicke, K, and Van der Werf, G R (2013). “Fire
Research: Linking Past, Present, and Future Data”. EOS 94, pp. 421–432.
Li, Zhangqing, Kaufman, Yoram J, Ichoku, Charles, Fraser, Robert, Trishchenko,
Alex, Giglio, Louis, Jin, Ji-Zhing, and Yu, Xinwen (2001). “A review of AVHRRbased active fire detection algorithms: Princi- ples, limitations, and
recommendations”. Global and regional vegetation fire monitoring from space,
planning and coordinated international effort, pp. 199–225.
Moritz, M A, Parisien, M A, Batllori, E, and Krawchuk, M A (2012). “Climate
change and disruptions to global fire activity”. Ecosphere 3(6). pp. 1–22. DOI:
10.1890/ES11-00345.1.
108
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Was the extreme storm season 2013-14 over the
North Atlantic and the UK triggered by changes in
the West-Pacific Warm Pool?
Simon Wild, Daniel J. Befort and Gregor C. Leckebusch
University of Birmingham, School of Geography, Earth and Environmental
Sciences, Birmingham, UK
In winter 2013-2014, the UK experienced exceptional stormy and rainy weather
conditions. The period from December 2013 to February 2014 was the stormiest
regarding frequency for at least 20 years according to the UK Met Office. While
the UK was hit by several high intensity storms, surface temperatures over large
parts of central North America fell to near record minimum values. One potential
driver for these cold conditions is discussed to be the increasingly warm surface
waters of the tropical West Pacific. It has been suggested that these increasing
sea surface temperatures could also be the cause for extreme weather over the
British Isles.
To test this hypothesis, we investigate potential mechanisms linking SST
anomalies the Western Pacific Warm Pool with European wind storm activity. We
will mainly focus on two research questions. Firstly: Was a chain of anomaly
patterns with origin in the West Pacific present in the winter 2013-14? And
secondly: What is the role of this mechanism in explaining interannual variability
of wind storms over Europe in the recent past?
Our results, using ERA-Interim Reanalysis from 1979 – 2014 for December to
February, show an absolute maximum of wind storm frequency for large parts of
the eastern North Atlantic and coastal regions of West Europe in winter 2013-14.
Wind storms are identified with a tracking algorithm based on exceedances of the
local 98th percentile of surface wind speeds. We also find an absolute minimum
for the surface temperature over large regions in central North America and a
substantially reduced number of cyclones in the eastern North Pacific in the
same season.
The convective activity over the West Pacific Warm Pool and the number of
cyclones in the eastern North Pacific are significantly correlated. The location of
the highest cyclone density in the North Pacific, respectively the PNA, is in turn
strongly related to temperature anomalies over central North America. We further
find a significant anti-correlation of interannual variability between surface
temperatures in North America and wind storm frequency in the eastern North
Atlantic.
Thus, we find indications for teleconnections between the variability of sea
surface temperatures in the West Pacific Warm Pool and European cyclone
activity, which supports the above suggested hypothesis.
109
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Projections of Australian Regional Temperature
Extremes from CMIP5 Models
Louise Wilson (1), Tony Rafter (1)
(1) Oceans & Atmosphere Flagship, CSIRO, Australia
Extreme heat events have major impact on Australian environment and society.
From a risk assessment and impact planning perspective, projections of changes
in the magnitude and frequency of these events is invaluable.
Here we present regional projections of daily temperature extremes from CMIP5
models under emission pathways RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 for Australia. We
examine annual maxima of daily maximum temperatures and annual minima of
daily minimum temperatures and derive 20-year return levels using extreme
value theory. Distribution parameters of a Generalised Extreme Value (GEV) are
fitted to data using the method of L-moments (e.g. Hosking, 1990), which is well
suited to small sample sizes (Kharin et al. (2005)).
Annual and 20-year maxima and minima temperatures are projected to increase
significantly over all of Australia by late in the 21st century, and projected
changes are found to be strongly dependent on the RCP. The magnitude of
changes in both mean and extremes are greatest over central regions for
maximum temperatures, decreasing to the north and south. Projections of
change in minimum temperatures are largest in northern regions and decrease in
magnitude towards the south.
The response of extreme temperatures to climate forcings is shown to be
spatially non-uniform over the Australian continent. In southeast Australia
temperature maxima increase more than minima, while temperature minima
increase more than maxima in other regions of the country (see figure 1).
We also investigate the differences in climate response of temperature extremes
against changes in mean. Comparison of annual mean daily temperature minima
and maxima (figure 1a and 1b) to annual (figure 1c) and 20-year (figure 1d)
maxima and minima temperatures is made in figure 1. Increases in maximum
temperature extremes are of greater magnitude than those for mean changes
over southeast Australia, but they are more closely aligned for other regions.
Relative increases of mean and extreme minimum temperatures follow a different
pattern. Minimum temperature extremes are projected to increase by more than
the mean over northern Australia, while elsewhere mean changes are projected
to warm by more than extreme minimum temperatures.
110
Figure 1: Median and 10th to 90th percentile range of projected change in daily
minimum (maximum) temperature in sub-clusters for 2080-2099 relative to 19862005 for RCP8.5. Shown in each box from left to right is (a) the annual mean
daily minimum (maximum) for the larger set of 37 models, (b) the annual mean
daily minimum (maximum), (b) the annual daily minimum (maximum), and the (d)
20-year return level of annual daily minimum (maximum) temperature from a
consistent subset of 24 models. The Australian average result is shown at bottom
left of each plot (from Ekstrom et. al., 2015, p.96).
References
Ekstrom, M, P Whetton, C Gerbing, M Grose, J Bhend, L Webb, et al. (including
L Wilson). Projections: Atmosphere and the Land. In: P Whetton, M Ekstrom, C
Gerbing, M Grose, J Bhend, L Webb, J Risbey., editor/s. Climate Change in
Australia Information for Australia’s Natural Resource Management Regions:
Technical Report. CSIRO and Bureau of Meteorology; 2015. 222pp.
Hosking JRM (1990) L-moments: analysis and estimation of distributions using
linear combinations of order statistics. J R Stat Soc 52:105–124.
Kharin, V, FW Zwiers, and X Zhang (2005), Intercomparison of near surface
temperature and precipitation extremes observations, J. Climate, 18, 5201–5223.
111
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Searching for synergies in crop rotation management – A simulation-optimization approach
N. Zarrineha,b, A. Holzkämpera,b, J. Fuhrera,b
a
Agroscope, Institute for Sustainability Sciences, Zurich, Switzerland
Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research, University of Bern, Bern,
Switzerland
b
Aim of the project
The agroecosystem is an interconnected system where management interventions have multiple effects on a wide range of ecosystem services. In this project, we aim to investigate - in a case study region in Western Switzerland - how
management of crop rotations can best be adapted both at local and regional
scales in order to increase yield stability of the crop production system under
more frequent climate extremes, while providing synergies between production
and other ecosystem services (i.e. water regulation, soil quality, carbon sequestration) and biodiversity conservation. A biophysical simulation model SWAT is
used in combination with multi-objective optimization.
Background
Previous studies revealed a wide scope for adaptation through changes in the
management of crop rotations (Klein et al., 2014). In particular, crop sequence
and conservation soil management such as reduced tillage, maintenance of residue surface cover, or use of cover crops can contribute to improvements of several ecosystem services (e.g. nutrient cycling, water regulation, soil protection or
carbon sequestration) (Delgado et al., 2013) while maintaining productivity. In
addition, management intensity and rotation diversity – particularly the introduction of cover crops - benefits species diversity (Schipanski et al., 2014).
Specific objectives
This study, which contributes to the European project “TALE - Towards multifunctional agricultural landscapes in Europe: Assessing and governing synergies between biodiversity and ecosystem services“ (BiodivERsA/FACCE-JPI) considers
three main objectives. First, different crop rotations including cover crops will be
assessed to identify optimal synergies between different ecosystem services at
the field scale. Second, effects of spatial configurations of selected crop rotations
on the provision of multiple ecosystem services will be analyzed to identify spatial
patterns of cropland management providing optimum synergies at the catchment
scale. Third, impacts of climatic change scenarios for around 2050 on synergies
and trade-offs between ecosystem services will be studied at field and catchment
scales.
112
Methodology
Two SWAT (Soil and Water Assessment Tool) models operating at different spatial scales are used. After calibration and validation, the model will be applied in
combination with local input data (soil, topography, climate). Simulation results
will be subjected to multi-objective optimization to identify optimized land management patterns to mitigate climatic change impacts while maintaining maximum synergies and minimal trade-offs (see Figure1).
Figure1: Overview of project structure
Expected results
Robust recommendations for adaptation planning will be provided at multiple
scales: optimized sets of rotations providing synergies between ecosystem services under different climatic conditions at field scale, and optimum spatial patterns of land management providing synergies between ecosystem services under different climatic conditions at catchment scale.
References
Delgado, J.A., Nearing, M.A. and Rice, C.W., 2013. Conservation practices for
climate change adaptation. In: L.S. Donald (Ed), Advances in Agronomy.
Academic Press, pp. 47-115.
Klein, T., Holzkämper, A., Calanca, P. and Fuhrer, J., 2014. Adaptation options
under climate change for multifunctional agriculture: a simulation study for
western Switzerland. Regional Environmental Change, 14, 167–184.
Schipanski, M.E., Barbercheck, M., Douglas, M.R., Finney, D.M., Haider, K.,
Kaye, J.P. et al., 2014. A framework for evaluating ecosystem services
provided by cover crops in agroecosystems. Agricultural Systems 125, 12-22.
113
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Catastrophic Magdalena or not?
The flood events of AD 1342 in Central Europe
Eveline Zbinden
Institute of Geography (GIUB), Hydrology Group,
and Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research, University of Bern, Switzerland
Introduction
One of the most severe flood of the last centuries in Central Europe seems to be the flood of AD
1342, the "Maria Magdalena flood". It occured in the summer AD 1342 and caused extraordinary
damages in many places.
But did other floods occur in AD 1342? Were these damages caused mainly by just one singular
flood event or by more than one?
The analyzed hypothesis for the investigation area of Central Europe are:
1) There was a catastrophic flood in AD 1342.
2) It was not the only catastrophic flood event in AD 1342.
State of knowledge
Several studies have been analyzed the flood event of AD 1342 in Europe during the last years
(Brázdil, Elleder, Glaser, Herget, Himmelsbach, Kiss, Pfister, Rohr and Zbinden. Those scientists
looked on details within their specific research area and time scale. Their methods differ and their
results.
Data and methods
The information on flood events has to be interpreted, combined and classified. The chosen data
consists of written sources by contemporary and non-contemporary sources. They descend from
the compilation by Curt Weikinn (1958), one of the most detailed collection of flood events in
Central Europe.
The methodological steps of source criticism can be summarized:
1. Installing a database of written sources + Dating by contemporary information
2. Mapping the cases by occurence in a place
3. Merging the places to flood events
4. Classifying the magnitude of floods (Pfister/Hächler 1991)
Some source texts do not have a detailed information of season, month or day within the year AD
1342. Therefore they can not always be linked directly with a dated event. For reaching a more
detailed dating, the chosen date was taken from the available contemporary sources. This
interpretation can be distinguished from the documented data information.
Results and Discussion
There are several flood events in AD 1342, that can be found in written sources for this year:
Early February:
Prague (Czech Rep.) and Dresden (Germany) - catastrophic event
Early February:
Rouen and Vendôme (northern France)
- strong event
Summer:
Avignon (southern France)
- strong event
Late June:
Hannover (Germany)
- very strong event
Late July:
Main- and Rhine area (many places in Germany)- catastrophic event
November:
Lombardia (northern Italy)
- catastrophic event
There has been a catastrophic flood event in late July in Central Europe. And another
catastrophic flood event was documented in early February in Prague and Dresden. These two
extreme events must not be seen as one event. A direct connection between the floods in
northern France at the same time as in Prague and Dresden can not be seen, yet.
114
Conclusion
The results can answer the hypothesis:
1) YES, there was a catastrophic flood in AD 1342 – on 22nd July. The damages as well as
the affected area were extreme. It reached the highest level in the classification-matrix.
2) YES, Maria Magdalena flood was not the only catastrophic flood event in AD 1342. There
were catastrophic floods in February and November.
In the year AD 1342, several flood events occurred in central Europe and caused severe
damage. Without source criticism and a detailed analysis, there can be a confusion of events in
winter and summer, especially when there's no dating in the text source.
References
The main references are:
Pfister, Christian; Hächler, Stefan (1991): Überschwemmungskatastrophen im Schweizer
Alpenraum seit dem Spätmittelalter In: Historical Climatology in Different Climatic Zones,
Würzburger Geographische Arbeiten, Heft 80). Würzburg. S. 127-148.
Weikinn, Curt (1958): Quellentexte zur Witterungsgeschichte Europas von der
Zeitenwende bis zum Jahre 1850. Band I (Zeitwende bis 1500). Berlin
Zbinden, Eveline (2011): Das Magdalenen-Hochwasser von 1342 –
der «hydrologische Gau» in Mitteleuropa. In: Wasser Energie Luft (Heft 3). Baden.
115
Swiss Climate Summer School 2015: Extreme Events and Climate
Early to Mid-Holocene climate variability from
multi-millennial tree ring isotope records
Malin Michelle Ziehmer (1,2), Kurt Nicolussi (3), Christian Schlüchter (2,4),
Markus Leuenberger (1,2)
(1) Climate and Environmental Physics, Physics Institute, University of
Bern, Bern, Switzerland
(2) Oeschger Center for Climate Change Research, University of Bern,
Bern, Switzerland
(3) Alpine Tree-Ring Group, Institute of Geography, University of Innsbruck,
Innsbruck, Austria
(4) Institute of Geological Sciences, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
The investigation of the evolution of Holocene climate and its variability in the
Alps mainly focuses on analyzing low-frequency archives such as glacier and
tree line fluctuations. The environment of the Alps reacts sensitively to changes
in climatic conditions such as variations of precipitation and temperature. For
instance, the current retreat of glaciers reveals a consequence of global warming
induced by global climate change. The investigated low-frequency records
expose an evolution of Holocene climate from a generally warm Early and Mid to
a relatively cool Late Holocene. However, the rare high resolution records often
do not indicate such a general long-term trend. The causes and mechanisms
behind the trends are not fully understood yet.
Recent finds of wood remains of long-lived trees in Alpine glacier forefields
changed the concept of Holocene glacier variability and therefore, the present
understanding of Holocene climate dynamics. Those findings prove that glaciers
in the Alps were usually relatively small and short in their extension during the
Early and Mid-Holocene (Joerin et al., 2008; Nicolussi and Schlüchter, 2012).
They further prove that the natural variability of postglacial climate is still not
sufficiently known. However; such knowledge is essential for climate model input
and the ability to disentangle natural from anthropogenic influences on the
Earth’s climate.
The study aims at establishing highly resolved isotope records from the
mentioned, calendar-dated wood remains covering the past 9000 years. Samples
are collected in glacier forefields in the Alps, thereby covering a large SW- NE
transect. Wood samples are separated into 5-year tree ring blocks from which
cellulose is extracted and is crushed by ultrasonic homogenization (Boettger et
al., 2007; Laumer et al., 2009). Stable isotopes of carbon, oxygen and hydrogen
are simultaneously measured using a recently developed method by Loader et
al. (2015). Stable isotope records, containing of a sample replication of four
116
samples per 5-year tree ring block, allow to establish stable isotope chronologies
over the Holocene.
A special focus is set here on the Early to Mid-Holocene climate variability
covering a time period from approximately 9000 to 6000 years BP, which opens
the opportunity to analyze minima and optima periods, but also to investigate
abrupt climatic changes which are most prominent in the Early and Mid-Holocene
such as the well documented 8.2 ka event. The new highly resolved isotope
records (C, O, H), which are combined in a multi-proxy approach with the tree
ring width and the maximum latewood density of analyzed wood enable a highresolution reconstruction of environmental conditions and of the natural variability
of the Early and Mid-Holocene.
References
Boettger, T., et al. Anal. Chem., 2007, 79: 4603-4612
Joerin, U.E. et al. QSR, 2008, 27: 337-350
Laumer, W., et al. Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom., 2009, 23: 1934–1940
Loader, N.J., et al. Anal. Chem., 2015, 87: 376-380
Nicolussi K., C. Schlüchter. Geology, 2012, 40: 819-822
117