* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Download Designer Babies
Polycomb Group Proteins and Cancer wikipedia , lookup
Site-specific recombinase technology wikipedia , lookup
Population genetics wikipedia , lookup
Epigenetics of neurodegenerative diseases wikipedia , lookup
Pathogenomics wikipedia , lookup
Behavioural genetics wikipedia , lookup
Gene expression programming wikipedia , lookup
Human genetic variation wikipedia , lookup
Artificial gene synthesis wikipedia , lookup
Essential gene wikipedia , lookup
Heritability of IQ wikipedia , lookup
Genetically modified crops wikipedia , lookup
Genetically modified organism containment and escape wikipedia , lookup
Genome evolution wikipedia , lookup
Nutriepigenomics wikipedia , lookup
Quantitative trait locus wikipedia , lookup
Genomic imprinting wikipedia , lookup
Genetically modified food wikipedia , lookup
Epigenetics of human development wikipedia , lookup
Ridge (biology) wikipedia , lookup
Public health genomics wikipedia , lookup
Minimal genome wikipedia , lookup
Gene expression profiling wikipedia , lookup
Genetic engineering wikipedia , lookup
Microevolution wikipedia , lookup
Genetic engineering in science fiction wikipedia , lookup
Genome (book) wikipedia , lookup
Biology and consumer behaviour wikipedia , lookup
Gonzales 1 Dominique Gonzales Professor John Haner WRI 10 13 May 2015 Final Paper Designer Babies: Future or Destruction? Designer babies are in the future. Scientists can already manipulate some genes in order to determine sex or lower the chance of—or even eliminate—some diseases. Soon doctors will be able to choose whatever traits a parent wants. For instance a couple will be able to go to the doctors wanting to get pregnant and request a healthy baby with hazel eyes and dark brown hair. The couple may also like a baby boy who is both academically and athletically advanced. The doctor then will inseminate the woman and manipulate the genes in order for the fetus to become the baby the family ordered. Designer babies are going to be the new fashion and technology, scientists are already able to pick gender and notice early on if an embryo has the genes for different diseases. When pre ordered designed babies does happen who is in charge of the genes and are people allowed to choose whatever traits they want for their children? Once designer babies are a social norm will people with genetically enhanced athletic genes be allowed to participate in sports? Will the divide between natural born and genetically modified people create tension and class differences in society? What will the future hold if designer babies become the normal way to reproduce? With all these questions in mind society will Gonzales 2 either be improved by designer babies or separated between natural born and the genetically modified. Fig. 1 Example of building your baby based on physical traits. From “Debate Topics: Designer Babies” What is a Designer Baby? The Manufacturing Scientists are on the verge of making designer babies a reality for parents. Genetic engineering is what will be used to create designer babies, “genetic engineering is the process of artificially manipulating these inheritible characteristic [genes]” (Baird 13). At the moment we can modify and engineer nonhuman genes for example; “the gene that makes jellyfish florescent has been inserted into mice embryos, resulting in glow-in-the-dark rodents” (12-13). This process is a form of genetic engineering, which is taking the genes from one organism and inserting them into another. There have been many different type of experiments increasing a rodent’s muscle mass and a mouse’s loyalty to its partner and many other tests (13). Though this type of genetic engineering has provided results, it was not efficient, it Gonzales 3 took many trials that resulted in many mice being born deformed while only one succeeded (13). According to BBC News, designer babies are “genetically modified for beauty, intelligence or to be free of disease” (Gallagher 5). As of today scientists are able to choose the sex of an embryo and even determine if the life form will have certain diseases such as; cystic fibroses, down syndrome and even some forms of cancer (Macrae, et al.). The process of checking an embryo for diseases is through embryo screening; embryo screening is used by comparing the tissues of the embryo with that of genetically diseased tissues (Baird 14). Embryo screening is only the beginning of what is to come with genetically modifying genes. Within a short period of time any person will be able to choose what they want their baby to look like. The Distribution As of now in order to choose the gender of a baby the mother must be inseminated with the certain gender’s embryos. At the moment this process is very expensive and not a common commodity. In fact many fertility clinics have an extensive criteria a family and the woman must meet before insemination can be considered (Suzanne Leigh “Choosing Your Baby’s Sex”). In the future though, designing your own baby may be possible to anyone, that is, if genes are not patented and sold for a higher price. Ethical Issues The Gene Market Gonzales 4 Fig. 2 Cartoon of a “Designer Baby” and a poll on parent’s thoughts on designing babies from “Genetically Designed Babies”. In the future when genes can be modified in fetuses and parents are able to choose the traits of their future child, who will have ownership of genes? One of the biggest issues will be if anyone is able to paten genes. Say the first people to successfully design a baby decides to paten those genes, is gene patenting legal? Also are parents allowed to choose any type of genes they like without limitation? In one case a family decided to have two deaf children by choice (Shaw 409). In this case the children were inseminated and not genetically modified but the couple deliberately chose a donor who had a long line of deafness in his heritage. If people can choose traits for their children some may want to choose mild disorders for them. The problem with this is the effects on those children. They will grow up knowing that their parents choose to make them deaf, blind or any other disability Gonzales 5 instead of letting them be completely healthy. These children can develop long-term psychological issues as well as social disorders. Parents can forever traumatize their children just by choosing the wrong genes for them. When polled though it is a debate whether modifying genes for disorders is immoral or not (fig. 2). Another ethical issue is whether or not everyone will be able to design their baby or will it only be provided to the rich and upper class? Will designer babies be like designer clothes, where only the wealthy can afford them? At the moment freezing eggs, insemination and gender choice is a lot of money, sometimes up to $4,000 just for insemination and up to $10,000 to freeze a woman’s eggs (Fertility Treatment). Will designer babies be accessible to all people, especially if genes are patented? The Enhanced Olympics When people are allowed to design their babies and enhance their children with superhuman abilities, will they be treated equally with natural born students? As of now college admissions is an extremely competitive process. With some schools that only accept ten percent of applicants each year, students struggle to show their uniqueness and academic skills. When babies are born with super human abilities such as intelligence those who were natural born will have a major disadvantage. Those superhuman students will get the best of grades and the college acceptances as well as raising the standard to an immeasurable ability for natural born students. Those natural born students will have to work double in order to be chosen out of the same race as genetically enhanced students. Despite having to come second in academics natural born people will also have to compete with people who are genetically enhanced athletes. In the future, when designer babies Gonzales 6 are the social norm, will superhuman people be allowed to compete in the Olympics? If they are allowed to compete in professional sports competitions wouldn’t enhanced genes be similar to the use of steroids, which is banned in the United States. Steroids are a way to enhance a person’s abilities; athletes are the most common steroid users (Thompson 287-288). This is similar to genetic enhancing. Natural born and genetically enhanced children should compete separately or steroids could be legal in order to level the playing field for all participants. One of the biggest questions in designing babies is whether these children will look different from a normal human or just like everyone else? If they do happen to have sharper qualities that distributes them from the rest a separation can occur between natural born and designer born people. Fig. 3 expresses the thought of people looking identical to one another without a sense of diversity. The World Divided In the future when designer babies are the social norm and everyone is enhancing their children, there is chance that a division will occur between the Gonzales 7 natural born and genetically modified people. To the natural born people these super humans will have superiority because they are supposed to hold the best of the genes. In the movie Gattaca humans were genetically enhanced at birth and therefore those people where at the top of society. They—the designer made—had the best jobs while natural born people were left as low class with no skill mundane jobs such as janitors. This will cause a clash of classes and in the end could eventually lead to a civil war. If designer born children did become the norm and superior human race than our society would be less diverse and therefore could be easily killed off by a disease. The whole reason for diversity is so that genes are different and can be mutated in order to survive. If one virus infects a person then all those people with that exact same structure will meet the same fate as the first. Designer babies can lead to an apocalyptic world. On top of no biodiversity, designer babies leave the gate open or a population to look exactly the same (see figure 3). Without proper regulation and morals the human population can be at risk of another Hitler and his Aryan perfect race idea. In the Future? In the near future designer babies will be available to all expecting mothers. There are still many issues to go along with genetically modifying embryos. At the moment doctors are only able to detect diseases and in some cases gender. When scientists do finally learn how to manipulate genes people will be ecstatic to design their own child. Before designer babies become the norm a few laws of who can own and paten genes as well as availability of the process should be considered. Next Gonzales 8 would be to discovering ways of integrating designer people into our society in a way to avoid conflict and any other crisis that shall occur. Proposal At this point in time designer babies is inevitable, the question is how will they impact our society and will it be for the best? The reason designer babies what inevitable is because “We have little choice, as the reweaving of the fabric of our genetic makeup has already begun” (Baird 13). Baird expresses that we have already started the process of gene manipulation and there is no turning back from here. Many people have objections towards designer babies but a point no one talks about is the fact of having healthy babies. Designer babies are not just a way to manipulate the physical appearances of children. It is a chance to make future generations healthy and more sustainable. It is one of our natural instincts to make sure our species continue on and flourish. At the moment many of our offspring are being hurt or even dyeing because of genetically inherited diseases, if we have the chance to be rid of these devastating diseases than we should be attempting it, for the future of our species. At the moment only families that cannot have children are able to use genetic engineering and other resources in order to create life. These families should be allowed to have a healthy baby if the technology is available to them. Also there are already embryos that naturally get rejected from the body and screening embryos is the same thing only done by humans, for a good cause (Baird 15). Over all, embryo screening and genetic engineering for life altering diseases should be allowed and encouraged. Gonzales 9 One of the issues for designer babies is if genes should be patented or not and if they are patented, who can have ownership? Many people believe that ownership of genes is inhumane and should not be allowed. People are also skeptical about designer babies possibly not being diverse and leading to an Arian belief. If genes are allowed to be patented with restrictions then it can eliminate the scare for Arianism because different companies will have different genes available. Though, I personally believe that genes should not be patented and genes should have a free market. Will designer babies create a superior race and a rift between natural born and enhanced individuals? Many people are afraid of creating a superior race with enhanced abilities. With the studies now, the goal for enhancing genes is just to do that enhance and individuals’ abilities not to automatically give them a super human power. Enhancement gives the individual the ability to reach a higher potential than normal, but it is up to the individual to reach their full potential (Verlinsky 26). With is enhancement the human species can evolve into a more advanced and sustainable species. Having people with enhanced intelligence may help the world find sustainable resources and other answers we have been searching for. Superhuman abilities may be our saviors. They will not look any different than natural born children so in reality it will not create a war between the two types of people. Designer babies are about to turn into a reality the thirst for a better future is what drives scientists and activists for advancement in genetic engineering and embryo screening. If you had the chance to have a beautiful and healthy baby Gonzales 10 wouldn’t you take that chance. In the future when designer babies, embryo screening and genetic engineering is used with humans we have to regulate gene patenting and make other restrictions in order to prevent anything severely bad from happening. If we control the situation than we will be able to efficiently evolve the human race into a greater more powerful and sustainable species. Gonzales 11 Works Cited Babies - OTHERS - Teacher Jocelyn. N.p., n.d. Web. 9 Apr. 2015. <http://tx.englishch.com/teacher/jocelyn/others/genetically-designed-babies/>. Baird, Stephen L. "Designer Babies: Eugenics Repackaged Or Consumer Options? (Cover Story)." Technology Teacher 66.7 (2007): 12-16. Academic Search Complete. Web. 12 May 2015. "Debate Topics.": Designer Babies. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 Mar. 2015. <http://debatetopics-arron.blogspot.com/2009/01/designer-babies.html>. Gallagher, James. "'Designer Baby Debate Should Start'" BBC News. BBC News, 18 Jan. 2015. Web. 1 Mar. 2015. <http://www.bbc.com/news/health30742774>. "Fertility Treatment: Artificial Insemination (IUI) | BabyCenter." BabyCenter. N.p., n.d. Web. 9 Apr. 2015. <http://www.babycenter.com/0_fertility-treatmentartificial-insemination-iui_4092.bc?page=2>. Gattaca. Dir. Andrew Niccol. By Andrew Niccol. 1997. DVD. Klitzman, Robert, Paul S. Appelbaum, Wendy Chung, and Mark Sauer. "Anticipating Issues Related to Increasing Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis Use: a Research Agenda." Reproductive Biomedicine Online. 17 (2008): 33-42. Print. Leigh, Suzzanne. "Choosing Your Baby's Sex: What the Scientists Say | BabyCenter." BabyCenter. N.p., Oct. 2014. Web. 01 Mar. 2015. <http://www.babycenter.com/0_choosing-your-babys-sex-what-thescientists-say_2915.bc>. Gonzales 12 Macrae, Fiona. "The IVF Embryo Test That Can Detect 15,000 Genetic Diseases." Mail Online. Associated Newspapers, n.d. Web. 18 Mar. 2015. <http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-1196664/The-IVF-embryo-testdetect-15-000-genetic-diseases.html>. Shaw, David. "Deaf by Design: Disability and Impartiality." Bioethics. 22.8 (2008): 407-413. Print. Thompson, Helen. "Performance Enhancement: Superhuman Athletes." Nature. 487.7407 (2012): 287-289. Print. Verlinsky, Yury. "Designing Babies: What the Future Holds." Reproductive Biomedicine Online. 10 (2005): 24-26. Print.