* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Download Chapter 4 - Bakersfield College
Applied behavior analysis wikipedia , lookup
Attribution (psychology) wikipedia , lookup
Humanistic psychology wikipedia , lookup
Developmental psychology wikipedia , lookup
Verbal Behavior wikipedia , lookup
Social psychology wikipedia , lookup
Abnormal psychology wikipedia , lookup
Index of psychology articles wikipedia , lookup
Cultural psychology wikipedia , lookup
Learning theory (education) wikipedia , lookup
Political psychology wikipedia , lookup
Behavior analysis of child development wikipedia , lookup
Descriptive psychology wikipedia , lookup
Theoretical psychology wikipedia , lookup
Insufficient justification wikipedia , lookup
Psychophysics wikipedia , lookup
Conservation psychology wikipedia , lookup
History of psychology wikipedia , lookup
Cognitive psychology wikipedia , lookup
Music psychology wikipedia , lookup
Experimental psychology wikipedia , lookup
International psychology wikipedia , lookup
Educational psychology wikipedia , lookup
Social cognitive theory wikipedia , lookup
Subfields of psychology wikipedia , lookup
Cross-cultural psychology wikipedia , lookup
Albert Bandura wikipedia , lookup
Psychological behaviorism wikipedia , lookup
Behaviorism wikipedia , lookup
PSYCHOLOGY AN EXPLORATION Second Edition CHAPTER learning Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White 4 why study learning? If we had not been able to learn, we would have died out as a species long ago. Learning is the process that allows us to adapt to the changing conditions of the world around us. We can alter our actions until we find the behavior that leads us to survival and rewards, and we can eliminate actions that have been unsuccessful in the past. Without learning, there would be no buildings, no agriculture, no lifesaving medicines, and no human civilization. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Learning Objectives • • • • • • • • • • • • • LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO LO 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8 4.9 4.10 4.11 4.12 4.13 Learning Classical conditioning Conditioned emotional response Operant conditioning: Thorndike and Skinner Important concepts in operant conditioning Schedules of reinforcement How does punishment differ from reinforcement? Problems associated with the use of punishment Factors limiting or enhancing operant conditioning Behavioral Techniques and Behavior Modification Cognitive learning theory Observational learning Real world example of use of conditioning Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White What is Learning? LO 5.1 Learning • Learning – Relatively permanent change in behavior Brain physically changes in response to learning – Brought about by experience or practice – Any kind of change in the way an organism behaves is learning Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Pavlov and Classical Conditioning LO 5.2 Classical conditioning • Ivan Pavlov – Russian physiologist – Studied digestion in dogs Dogs naturally salivate in response to food (reflex) Pavlov’s dogs salivated in response to other stimuli as well Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Pavlov and Classical Conditioning LO 5.2 Classical conditioning • Ivan Pavlov – Labeled classical conditioning Learning response to a stimulus other than the original New response does not naturally occur in response to the stimulus, is learned Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Dr. Ivan Pavlov and students working in his laboratory. Pavlov, a Russian physiologist, was the first to study and write about the basic principles of classical conditioning. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Classical Conditioning Concepts LO 5.2 Classical conditioning • Unconditioned stimulus (UCS) – Naturally occurring stimulus – Leads to an involuntary response – Unconditioned: “Unlearned” or “naturally occurring” • Unconditioned response (UCR) – Involuntary response to naturally occurring stimulus Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Classical Conditioning Concepts LO 5.2 Classical conditioning • Conditioned stimulus (CS) – Stimulus is able to produce learned reflex response – Paired with the original unconditioned stimulus – Conditioned = “learned” – Neutral stimulus Becomes conditioned stimulus when paired with an unconditioned stimulus Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Classical Conditioning Concepts LO 5.2 Classical conditioning • Conditioned response (CR) – Learned reflex response to a conditioned stimulus. – Sometimes called conditioned reflex Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 5.1 Classical Conditioning Before conditioning takes place, the sound of the metronome does not cause salivation and is a neutral stimulus, or NS. During conditioning, the sound of the metronome occurs just before the presentation of the food, the UCS. The food causes salivation, the UCR. When conditioning has occurred after several pairings of the metronome with the food, the metronome will begin to elicit a salivation response from the dog without any food. This is learning, and the sound of the metronome is now a CS and the salivation to the bell is the CR. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Classical Conditioning Principles LO 5.2 Classical conditioning • CS must come before UCS • CS and UCS must come very close together in time – Ideally, only several seconds apart • Neutral stimulus must be paired repeatedly with UCS before conditioning takes place • CS is usually a stimulus that is distinctive from other competing stimuli Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Could this be you? The anxiety that many people feel while in the dentist’s office is a conditioned response, with the dentist’s chair and the smells of the office acting as conditioned stimuli. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Classical Conditioning Concepts LO 5.2 Classical conditioning • Stimulus generalization – Respond to a stimulus similar to original conditioned stimulus with conditioned response • Stimulus discrimination – Not making a generalized response to similar stimulus – Similar stimulus was never paired with the unconditioned stimulus Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Classical Conditioning Concepts LO 5.2 Classical conditioning • Extinction – Disappearance/weakening of learned response Follows removal or absence of the unconditioned stimulus (classical conditioning) – Removal of reinforcer (operant conditioning) Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 4.2 Strength of the Generalized Response An example of stimulus generalization. The UCS was an electric shock and the UCR was the galvanic skin response (GSR), a measure associated with anxiety. The subjects had been conditioned originally to a CS tone (0) of a given frequency. When tested with the original tone, and with tones 1, 2, and 3 of differing frequencies, a clear generalization effect appeared. The closer the frequency of the test tone to the frequency of tone 0, the greater was the magnitude of the galvanic skin response to the tone (Hovland, 1937). Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Classical Conditioning Concepts LO 5.2 Classical conditioning • Spontaneous recovery – Reappearance of learned response after extinction – Response usually weak and short-lived • Higher-order conditioning – Strong conditioned stimulus is paired with a neutral stimulus – Neutral stimulus to become a second conditioned stimulus Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 4.3 Extinction and Spontaneous Recovery This graph shows the acquisition, extinction, spontaneous recovery, and reacquisition of a conditioned salivary response. Typically, the measure of conditioning is the number of drops of saliva elicited by the CS on each trial. Note that on the day following extinction, the first presentation of the CS elicits quite a large response. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 4.4 Higher-Order Conditioning In Stage 1, a strong salivation response is conditioned to occur to the sound of the metronome (CS1). In Stage 2, finger snapping (CS2) is repeatedly paired with the ticking of the metronome (CS1) until the dog begins to salivate to the finger snapping alone. This is called “higher-order conditioning,” because one CS is used to create another, “higher” CS. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Conditioned Emotional Response LO 5.3 Conditioned emotional response • Emotional response classically conditioned to occur to learned stimuli • Examples: – Fear of dogs – Emotional reaction to seeing an attractive person, baby animals, etc. – May lead to phobias – irrational fear responses Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Conditioned Emotional Response LO 5.3 Conditioned emotional response • Vicarious conditioning – Classical conditioning acquired by watching the reaction of another person Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 4.5 Conditioning of “Little Albert” After “Little Albert” had been conditioned to fear a white rat, he also demonstrated fear to a rabbit, a dog, and a sealskin coat (although it remains uncertain if stimulus generalization actually occurred as this fear was to a single rabbit, a single dog, etc.). Can you think of any emotional reactions you experience that might be classically conditioned emotional responses? Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Taste Aversion LO 5.3 Conditioned emotional response • Conditioned taste aversion – Nausea or aversive response to a particular taste – Exposure to taste was followed by a aversive reaction Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Taste Aversion LO 5.3 Conditioned emotional response • Conditioned taste aversion – Occurs after only one association Biological preparedness – Animals learn associations with only one or few pairings – Survival value as animal could die with multiple tastings Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Conditioned taste aversions in nature. This moth is not poisonous to birds, but the monarch butterfly whose coloring the moth imitates is quite poisonous. Birds find their food by vision and will not eat anything that resembles the monarch. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Why Classical Conditioning Works LO 5.3 Conditioned emotional response • Stimulus substitution – Pavlov’s explanation – Conditioned stimulus (CS) becomes substitute for unconditioned stimulus (UCS) due to close pairing of two • Cognitive perspective – Conditioning occurs because CS provides information or expectancy about UCS forthcoming Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Operant Conditioning LO 5.4 Operant conditioning: Thorndike and Skinner • Involves voluntary behavior • Learned through the effects of pleasant and unpleasant consequences to responses Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Operant Conditioning LO 5.4 Operant conditioning: Thorndike and Skinner • Thorndike’s Law of Effect – If a response is followed by a pleasurable consequence, it will be repeated – If followed by an unpleasant consequence, it will tend not to be repeated Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Skinner’s Contribution LO 5.4 Operant conditioning: Thorndike and Skinner • Stressed the study of only observable, measurable behavior. • Operant conditioning – Voluntary behavior used to operate on the environment – Focus on the effects of the consequences of behavior Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 4.7 A Typical Skinner Box This rat is learning to press the bar in the wall of the cage in order to get food (delivered a few pellets at a time in the food trough on lower left). In some cases, the light on the top left might be turned on to indicate that pressing the bar will lead to food or to warn of an impending shock delivered by the grate on the floor of the cage. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Reinforcement LO 5.5 Important concepts in operant conditioning • Reinforcement – Event or stimulus following a response that increases the probability the response will occur again – Primary reinforcer Reinforcer that meets a basic biological need – hunger, thirst, touch Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Reinforcement LO 5.5 Important concepts in operant conditioning • Reinforcement – Secondary reinforcer Reinforcer associated with a primary reinforcer – praise, tokens, gold stars Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Positive and Negative Reinforcement LO 5.5 Important concepts in operant conditioning • Positive reinforcement – Pleasurable consequence follows response • Negative reinforcement – Removal of unpleasant stimulus increases response – Escape from, or avoidance of an unpleasant stimulus. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Table 4.1 Comparing Two Kinds of Conditioning Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Schedules of Reinforcement LO 5.6 Schedules of reinforcement • Partial reinforcement effect – Response is reinforced after some, but not all, correct responses Response tends to be resistant to extinction • Continuous reinforcement – Reinforcement of each and every correct response Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Schedules of Reinforcement LO 5.6 Schedules of reinforcement • Fixed ratio schedule – Number of responses required for reinforcement is always the same • Variable interval schedule – Interval of time must pass before reinforcement becomes possible – Amount of time different for each trial or event. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White When people go fishing, they never know how long they may have to dangle the bait in the water before snagging a fish. This is an example of a variable interval schedule of reinforcement and explains why some people, such as this father and son, are reluctant to pack up and go home. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Schedules of Reinforcement LO 5.6 Schedules of reinforcement • Fixed interval schedule – Interval of time that must pass before reinforcement becomes possible – Amount of time passing is always the same • Variable ratio schedule – Number of responses required for reinforcement is different for each trial or event. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Slot machines provide reinforcement in the form of money on a variable ratio schedule, making the use of these machines very addictive for many people. People don’t want to stop for fear the next pull of the lever will be that “magic” one that produces a jackpot. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 4.8 Schedules of Reinforcement These four graphs show the typical pattern of responding for both fixed and variable interval and ratio schedules of reinforcement. The responses are cumulative, which means new responses are added to those that come before, and all graphs begin after the learned pattern is well established. Slash marks mean that a reinforcement has been given. In both the fixed interval and fixed ratio graphs, there is a pause after each reinforcement as the learner briefly “rests.” The “scalloped” shape of the fixed interval curve is a typical indicator of this pause, as is the stair-step shape of the fixed ratio curve. In the variable interval and ratio schedules, no such pause occurs, because the reinforcements are unpredictable. Notice that both fixed and variable interval schedules are slower (less steep) than the two ratio schedules because of the need to respond as quickly as possible in the ratio schedules. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Punishment LO 5.7 How does punishment differ from reinforcement • Follows a response, making it less likely the response will happen again • Is the opposite of reinforcement – Punishment weakens responses, reinforcement strengthens responses Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Punishment LO 5.7 How does punishment differ from reinforcement • Is the opposite of reinforcement – Punishment by application The addition or experience of an unpleasant stimulus following a response – Punishment by removal Removal of a pleasurable stimulus Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White This young man’s father is applying punishment by removal as he takes the car keys away from his son. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Table 4.3 Negative Reinforcement Versus Punishment by Removal Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Problems with Punishment LO 5.8 What are some problems with punishment • May cause punished to avoid the punisher instead of the behavior being punished – Wrong response is learned • Can encourage lying to avoid punishment Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Problems with Punishment LO 5.8 What are some problems with punishment • May create fear and anxiety – Emotions not conducive to learning • Hitting provides model for aggression – Behavior is being modeled by the punisher Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White How to Make Punishment More Effective LO 5.8 What are some problems with punishment 1. Punishment should immediately follow the behavior it is meant to punish. 2. Punishment should be consistent. 3. Punishment of the wrong behavior should be paired, whenever possible, with reinforcement of the right behavior. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Stimulus Control LO 5.9 How operant stimuli control behavior • Discriminative stimulus – Provides organism a cue for making a certain response in order to obtain reinforcement Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Operant Conditioning Concepts LO 5.9 How operant stimuli control behavior • Shaping – Small steps toward goal behavior are reinforced until goal behavior is met • Successive approximations – The steps in behavior leading to a particular goal behavior Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White This dog has been trained to help its physically challenged owner. Operant conditioning principles can be used to train animals to do many useful tasks, including opening the refrigerator. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Operant Conditioning Concepts LO 5.9 How operant stimuli control behavior • Extinction – Removal of reinforcement – Response drops out • Generalization – Response occurs with stimuli only similar to the original stimulus Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White One way to deal with a child’s temper tantrum is to ignore it. The lack of reinforcement for the tantrum behavior will eventually result in extinction. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Operant Conditioning Concepts LO 5.9 How operant stimuli control behavior • Spontaneous recovery – Reoccurrence of a once extinguished response – Same as with classical conditioning Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Behavior Resistant to Conditioning LO 5.9 How operant stimuli control behavior • Instinctive drift – Tendency for an animal’s behavior to revert to genetically controlled patterns after learning – Animals have genetically determined instinctive patterns of behavior – These instincts differ from species to species. – Some responses cannot be trained into an animal regardless of conditioning. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Raccoons commonly dunk their food in and out of water before eating. This “washing” behavior is controlled by instinct and is difficult to change even using operant techniques. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Applying Operant Conditioning LO 5.10 Behavior modification • Behavior modification – Use of conditioning techniques to create changes in behavior • Token economy – Desired behavior is rewarded with tokens that can be exchanged for desired items or privileges Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Applying Operant Conditioning LO 5.10 Behavior modification • Time-out – Organism is being “removed” from opportunity to obtain positive reinforcement • Applied behavior analysis (ABA) – Uses shaping-skills broken into small steps – Prompts are removed over time Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Biofeedback and Neurofeedback LO 5.10 Behavior modification • Biofeedback – Use of feedback about biological conditions to bring involuntary responses under voluntary control I.E.: blood pressure, heart rate • Neurofeedback – Form of biofeedback – Uses brain-scanning devices to provide feedback about brain activity Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Cognitive Learning Theory LO 5.11 Cognitive learning theory • 1950s and 1960’s interest in cognition – Mental events that take place inside a person’s mind while behaving • View began to dominate experimental psychology • Key theorists: – Tolman, Kohler and Seligman Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Latent Learning LO 5.11 Cognitive learning theory • Edward Tolman (1930) • Taught three groups of rats the same maze – Group 1 Rewarded each time at end of maze Learned maze quickly Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Latent Learning LO 5.11 Cognitive learning theory • Taught three groups of rats the same maze – Group 2 In maze every day; only rewarded on 10th day Demonstrated learning almost immediately after receiving reward Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Latent Learning LO 5.11 Cognitive learning theory • Taught three groups of rats the same maze – Group 3 Never rewarded Did not learn maze well • Latent learning – Learning remains hidden until application is useful Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 4.9 A Typical Maze This is an example of a maze such as the one used in Tolman’s experiments in latent learning. A rat is placed in the start box. The trial is over when the rat gets to the end box. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 4.10 Learning Curves for Three Groups of Rats In the results of the classic study of latent learning, Group 1 was rewarded on each day, while Group 2 was rewarded for the first time on Day 11. Group 3 was never rewarded. Note the immediate change in the behavior of Group 2 on Day 12 (Tolman & Honzik, 1930). Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Insight LO 5.11 Cognitive learning theory • Kohler (1925) • Sudden perception of relationships among various parts of a problem – Allows solution to problem to come quickly Cannot be gained through trial-and-error learning alone “Aha” moment Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Another of Köhler’s chimpanzees, Grande, has just solved the problem of how to get to the banana by stacking boxes. Does this meet the criteria for insight, or was it simple trial-and-error learning? Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Learned Helplessness LO 5.11 Cognitive learning theory • Martin Seligman (1975) – Studied escape and avoidance learning – Noted dogs who had been unable to avoid shock did not avoid shock when opportunity became available Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Learned Helplessness LO 5.11 Cognitive learning theory • Martin Seligman (1975) – Described learned helplessness as the tendency to fail to act to escape from a situation History of repeated failures in the past creates belief that nothing can be done – Depression may result from learned helplessness Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 4.11 Seligman’s Apparatus In Seligman’s studies of learned helplessness, dogs were placed in a two-sided box. Dogs that had no prior experience with being unable to escape a shock would quickly jump over the hurdle in the center of the box to land on the “safe” side. Dogs that had previously learned that escape was impossible would stay on the side of the box in which the shock occurred, not even trying to go over the hurdle. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Observational Learning LO 5.12 Observational learning • Learning new behavior by watching a model perform the behavior • Bandura (1961) – Children observed and later spontaneously imitated observed aggressive behavior • Learning/performance distinction – Learning can take place without actual performance of the learned behavior Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Figure 4.12 Bandura’s Bobo Doll Experiment In Albert Bandura’s famous Bobo doll experiment, the doll was used to demonstrate the impact of observing an adult model performing aggressive behavior on the later aggressive behavior of children. The children in these photos are imitating the adult model’s behavior even though they believe they are alone and are not being watched. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Four Elements of Observational Learning LO 5.12 Observational learning • ATTENTION – To learn through observation learner must first attend to the model • MEMORY – Learner must be able to retain memory of what was done – Example: remembering steps in preparing a dish seen on a cooking show Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Four Elements of Observational Learning LO 5.12 Observational learning • IMITATION – Learner must be capable of reproducing actions of the model • MOTIVATION – Learner must have the desire to perform the action Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Applying Psychology to Everyday Life LO 5.13 Real world example use of conditioning • Toilet Training a Cat – Use operant principles – Shaping Transition from litter box to toilet is done in stages – Prepare “the training arena” Optimizing bathroom success – Positive reinforcement on a variable schedule Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Misha’s first attempt without the box. He scored two out of a possible four. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White Misha demonstrates proper squatting posture. Note the look of firm concentration. Psychology: An Exploration, Second Edition Saundra K. Ciccarelli • J. Noland White