Download Impacts of Climate Change on the Management of Upland Waters

IMPACTS OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON THE MANAGEMENT OF UPLAND WATERS:
THE RHONE RIVER CASE
Pr Dr Jean-Paul BRAVARD
Head of the Rhone Watershed Workshop Zone
University Lumière-Lyon 2,
Faculté GHHAT, Département de géographie
5, avenue Pierre Mendès-France, 69676 Bron cédex, France
[email protected]
1
2
Summary
The Rhone river watershed covers a surface of 98 000 000 km2, including 10 000 km2 in
Switzerland. Most of the discharge originates in the Alps, but a significant contribution is
provided by the Jura Mountains and by the western Massif Central. The main river are the
Rhône, the Saône, the Isère and the Durance. The total discharge at the sea 1700 m3.s-1.
Since 10 years, several models have detailed the General Circulation Model proposed by the
IPCC (1996 and 2002) and predicted changes of the natural components of the hydrological
cycle, from temperature and precipitation, to ice and snow cover and to river discharge. They
anticipate on a decrease of total discharge, a marked decrease of summer discharge, an
increase of winter discharges and winter storms, a decrease of ice and snow cover inducing a
change in the river regime.
However, one of the main characteristics of the Rhône is the high level of economic
development which has triggered complex impacts on river and lake hydrosystems. High
altitude reservoirs have affected the river regimes since at least 50 years, to the detriment of
summer discharge, altering the pristine mountain discharges. While the temperature of
Geneva Lake increased during the last 20 years for climatic reasons, the temperature of the
French river course of the Rhône was affected by the impact of nuclear power plants. These
documented changes anticipate on the changes predicted during the XXIth century and
provide most interesting insights into the the future of aquatic ecosystems.
At last, an attempt was made to summarize the possible impacts of climate and river changes
on the future uses of water and on humans. Hydropower and thermal power will be affected,
as well as tourism and agriculture through an increase of pressures on the consumptive uses of
water. Human health may be affected as well as the level of risks in valley bottoms.
3
1 - Introduction
During the last 10 years, many detailed studies and general reports (IPCC, 2002; Deneux, 2002;
Renaud et al., 2002; Pont, 2003; Husting, 2005; OcCC, 2003) have been devoted to the impacts
of predicted climate change in Europe, and notably in the Alps and on the Rhône River. These
reports deal mostly with the probable changes in the hydrological regime of the Upper Rhone
River in Switzerland, and with the hydrological and ecological changes of the Rhone River
downstream of Geneva. This report will present a summary of the main results obtained by
specialists of the question, which combine past, present and future changes of natural
components of hydrosystems, as well as the complex interactions of natural and human induced
changes. The approach will take the complete hydrosystem into account, from upland
ecosystems down to the delta of the Rhone, with some insight into the tributaries. We decided to
follow the proposal made by Leblois et al. (2005), i.e. making a distinction between “effects”
and “impacts”. “Effects” are changes, or direct consequences of climate change on
hydrosystems, while “impacts” are consequences of the latter on human uses of water or
instream uses of water (ecological requirements).
While much research has been done on river discharge, few studies have dealt with water as a
resource, prone to locally intensive uses and sensitivity to climate change. At a broader scale
than the rivers, and considering combined criteria, an interdisciplinary study has considered past
situations to check the causes and effects of “degradation”, “desertification” and human
“desertion” in selected areas of the Mediterranean, notably in the Southern Rhone valley during
the Holocene and the XIXth c. (Van der Leeuw, 1998). We will not address this broader
perspective below.
2. Studied area and methods
2.1. The Rhone River basin
The Rhone river watershed covers a surface of 98 000 km2, including 10 000 km2 in Switzerland
(Fig. 1). The Swiss Rhone in Valais is influenced by mountain climate. Its natural regime is
characterised by low winter discharge due to snow detention, by high spring and summer discharge
due to the melting of snow and ice. Like other subalpine lakes, Geneva Lake smoothens flood peaks
downstream, similar to Annecy Lake for the Fier River, and Bourget Lake for the Rhone. The
tributaries of the Rhone between Geneva and Lyon (notably, the Arve, Fier, Guiers and Ain rivers)
4
drain lower ranges but preserve the snow-melt regime, while the glacial influence is strongly
attenuated. Due to the oceanic influence on the Jura Mountains, the 200 km Ain river may peak at
2400 m3/s, which is as much as the upper Rhone. The Saône River, which joins the Rhône in Lyon,
has a typically oceanic regime with high discharge during the cold season and low discharge during
the warm season, due to evapo-transpiration. As a consequence, downstream Lyon, the
“compensated” type regime is more regular (Pardé, 1925). Flowing from the Alps, the left bank
tributaries regenerate the snow-melt influence, while right bank tributaries and the Durance deliver
high discharges during the fall and the spring, under Mediterranean influence. At Beaucaire, the
regime is characterized by low flow from September to November, along with risks of marked low
flow.
2.2. Observed climate and hydrological change since the XIXth c.
Climate is widely considered to have changed since the Late XIXth century and during the last
decades. Climate change may have affected both temperatures and precipitations. Change in
temperature is not documented since the late XIXth in the hydrosystem of the Rhône. Temperature
of large subalpine lakes, such as Lake Geneva, is proved to have increased by 1°C since the 1960’s.
Concerning river discharge, statistical tests applied to 8 gauging stations of the Rhone river
downstream Geneva demonstrated that hydrology is stationary. However two types of ruptures are
apparent, one locally in 1891, due to artificial developments at the outlet of Lake Geneva, the
second one at the end of the 1970’s, with the occurrence of wet decades throughout the basin,
following a period (1940-1975) of lull. A new cycle rich in strong floods has occurred in recent
years, similar to the late XIXth period, but no effect of global change having been detected yet
(Sauquet et Haond, 2003). This study introduces an important point. This report deals with the
impact of climate change on the Rhone River hydrosystem. Traditionally this question is dealt with,
using predicted climate data and expected induced changes in the different compartments of natural
systems as well as predicted impacts on human uses. In this report, the registered changes since ca
20 years will be presented because their occurrence is documented and because they provide tested
useful insights of expectable changes in the future.
Moreover, changes in hydrological hydrosystems incorporate human induced changes, particularly
in highly developed watersheds. Indeed, the control on upland hydrology has been a long term
process in the Alps, changing the hydrology of rivers. Also, thermal plants have been located along
the Rhone River to benefit from cooling by its waters, thereby inducing an increase of water
temperatures and consequences on aquatic ecosystems.
5
6
2.3. Modelling the changes
The assessment of climatic change has been traditionally based on general circulation models
(GCM) which typically have a resolution of 2.5° latitude and 3.75° longitude. At the basin scale, the
General Circulation Model (IPCC, 1996, 2002) projects that the expected climate warming will
enhance the hydrological cycle, with higher precipitations in winter, higher rates of evaporation and
decreased precipitations in summer and during the fall, and a proportion of liquid to solid relatively
greater at high altitude. Two scenarios have been tested:
-
B2: average temperature would increase by 2-2.5°C in one century
-
A2: average temperature would increase by 3-3.5°C
This model having been recognized to be unable to reproduce the characteristics of variables at the
regional and short time scales, different projects have been launched in order to address this issue.
Computations were made in the Suiss Alps, using a high resolution model (20 km x 20 km) under a
hypothesis of a doubling of CO2 concentration. The MEDALUS Project (1996-1999) was funded by
the EEC to explore future changes, such as desertification of the Mediterranean domain. In this
programme, Palutikov J.P., Goodess C.M. (2000) applied downscaling procedures to develop
scenarios in Spanish and Italian regions. The ECLAT-2 project (1998-2001) was funded through the
Climate and Environmental Program of the DGXII of the EEC to complement the IPCC, IGBP and
HDP Programmes. Downscaling techniques were applied to the Rhone basin (Noilhan et al., 2000),
using selected GCM ouputs in the basin for doubled C02 concentration conditions. These studies
explored the sensitivity of the production functions of the hydrological model to anomalies in
precipitations and temperatures for selected sub-basins during the period 1981-1985. The ECLAT-2
programme provided the first evaluation of predictable climate change impacts in the basin in
different components of the water budget, such as runoff, snow and soil moisture availability for the
interface between soil and atmosphere. It was based on the GEWEX-Rhone programme which used
the macroscale Coupled ISBA MODCOU (CIM) model for the 1981-1998 time series. This model
was calibrated with present day conditions using atmospheric forcing, land surface types, soil
freezing, surface runoff, evapotranspiration, river flow series and snow depth in the Alps. This
model was run over 15 years for spatial resolutions ranging from 1 to 8 km. Indeed, it was
recognized that the model could be used for testing the GCM anomalies (Habets et al., 1999;
Etchevers, 2000). Research was continued through the programme GICC-Rhône (1999-2004) with
the hypothesis of a doubling of CO2 concentrations in 2050 (Leblois and Grésillon, 2005).
7
3. Predicted changes of the natural components of the hydrological cycle
3.1.Climatic change
3.1.2. Present and predicted changes in air temperature
During the XXth century, the average temperature of the globe increased by 0.6 +/-2°C (IPCC,
2002). The Alps experienced a warming of temperatures comprised between 1° and 2°C. However,
more than 1°C out of the strong recent increase, which occurred since 1990 (along with a decrease
in precipitations), could be related to positive values of the NAO (North Atlantic Oscillation, a
measure of the intensity of westerly flow and associated storms tracks) according to Beniston and
Jungo (2002). These authors propose that warming would have been weaker without the NAO
effect and suggest that we should “improve the performance of models in simulating NAO decadalscale variability”.
During the XXIth c., global temperature should increase by 1.4 to 5.8°C (IPCC, 2002). In the Suiss
Alps, the worst scenario is that winter temperatures could increase by up to 4°C and summer
temperatures (July) by 6°C (Beniston et al., 1995). Horton et al. (2005) proposed a scenario of +1°C
(expected for 2020-2049) and two scenarios considering two increased green house gas emissions
(period 2070-2099: + 2.4 to 2.8 °C and +3.0 to 3.6°C, with rates higher in summer than for annual
averages). In France, the ECLAT-2 programme models predicted warming for all the months, but
temperature increases were greater from July to September, ranging from 2.5°C to 7.5°C according
to the different models tested. The GICC-Rhone study, using the ARPEGE-CLIMAT model,
predicts an average yearly increase of 2.5°C and an increase in July of 4°C for the doubling of CO2
concentration.
3.1.3. Changes in precipitations
According to GIEC models applied to France, with the B2 scenario, precipitations would increase in
the winter, while they would be reduced by 5-25% in the summer. According to the A2 scenario,
summer droughts would be more severe with a decrease of 20-35% in summer rainfall, associated
with severe episodes. In the Swiss Alps, Beniston et al. (2003) have shown that “milder winters are
associated with high precipitations levels than cold winters, but with more solid precipitations at
elevations exceeding 1,700 – 2,000 m above sea-level, and more liquid precipitations below”. With
expected climate warming, the average predicted precipitations would not change, but summer
precipitations should decrease, while winter precipitations would increase (Fig. 2-A). Modelling of
8
winter storms suggest a stronger frequency of southern flows from the Mediterranean and heavy
storms, like 1999 Lothar storm (Beniston, 2004). Also, periods of drought could be more frequent
as well as periods of heavy rainfalls. Higher snowfalls at high altitudes would not compensate for
increased ice-melting. According to Beniston et al. (1995), winter precipitations would increase by
15% in the Western Alps. In France, the ECLAT-2 programme predicted a minimum of
precipitations in summer months (from -45% to +8%), and increased precipitations in winter, up 530% according to the models.
The changes associated with an increase in global temperature are rendered more complex by
interactions with the NAO shifts. Indeed, the amounts of precipitation are influenced by the
Northern Atlantic Oscillation. Beniston (1997) has correlated thick snow cover and long duration in
the Swiss Alps with high NAO index because during these episodes, winter temperatures shift
toward higher values («the frequency of temperatures exceeding the freezing point is more than
doubled above 1000 m, thus enhancing the potential for early snowmelt»).
3.1.4. Changes in the depth and duration of snow cover
The depth of snow cover is influenced by temperature. At Portes Pass (Northern French Alps, alt.
1,320 m), snow depth from February 11th to 20th has decreased during the last 40 years (fig. 3). The
strong reduction in the last ten years is “probably related to climate warming” (Etchevers & Martin,
2002; Martin & Etchevers, 2002). This reduction in the duration of snow cover has been
hypothetised by Föhn (1991) and documented in the low altitude zones of the Swiss Alps. Using
satellite imagery, Baumgartner & Apfl (1994) observed a reduction of snow cover by 3-4 weeks
during the late 80’s and the early 90’s. An average increase of 4°C in temperatures, forecasted by
several regional models for this area of Europe, would reduce the volume of snow by ca 50% in the
Swiss Alps. For every °C increase in temperature, the snow line will rise by about 150 m so
9
10
that“regions where snowfall is the current norm will increasingly experience precipitation in the
form of rain. » (Beniston, 1997).According to the scenario of Météo-France (Martin & Durand,
1998), assuming an increase in temperature of +1.8 C°, at an elevation of 1,500 m, the average
length of snow cover, presently comprised between 160 and 180 days in the Northern French Alps,
could decrease down to 125-135 days. In the Southern Alps, it could decrease from 130-100 down
to 80-55 days/yr (Fig.3). This means one month less of snow cover that today (SAFRAN-CROCUS
snow model, in French ARPEGE GCM - Equipe Climate Modelling and Global Change).
According to the GICC-Rhone study, the depth may be reduced by 50% at low altitudes, but is less
affected at higher altitudes (1800-2000 m). In the different scenarios, the areas covered by snow
decrease by 25-40% (Etchevers & Martin, 2002; Lebois et Grésillon, 2005).
As a result of climate change, glaciers have already retreated because they stand close to the
freezing point. Haeberli (1994) considers that past and present fluctuations of glaciers and
pergelisol are proofs of past and present climate changes through the changes in energy balance.
Due to the green house effect, the velocity of observed changes exceeds the changes monitored
during the Holocene. Haeberli (1995) and Haeberli and Beniston (1998) have shown that «the
glaciers of the European Alps have lost about 30 to 50% of their surface and about half of their
volume. 30-50% of existing mountain glacier mass could disappear by 2100 if global warming
scenarios in the range of 2-4°C indeed occur». With an upward shift of 200-300 m in the altitude of
the line of equilibrium , the reduction in ice thickness could reach1-2 m per year (Maisch, 1992).
The sensitivity of the line of equilibrium to temperature is between 60 and 120 m/°C according to
different authors (Green et al., 1999; Maish, 2000; Vincent, 2002). According to Vincent (2002),
glaciers of the French Alps retreated during two periods :
-
From 1942 to 1953, due to low winter snow falls and to a high rate of retreat in summer
-
From 1982 to 1999, due to a high level of summer ablation (from 1.9 m to 2.8 m at 2800 m at
the elevation of 2800 m). This is due to a strong increase of the energy balance.
The difference in mass balance between 1800-1850 and 1970-1980 is comprised between 0.50 and
1.00 m in water equivalent for the glaciers of the French Alps (Vincent, 2002). Six et al. (2002)
proposed that the mass balance of alpine glaciers could be negatively correlated to the oscillations
of NAO index, as Beniston et al. (1995) proposed for periods of warm temperature and low
precipitations.
3.2. Present and predicted changes of discharge
11
12
3.2.1. Vegetation, soils and water balance in mountain ecosystems
Changes in direct water consumption by existing vegetation will occur. They will be due to changes
in forest cover and to changes in the amount of evapotranspiration. If an increase in water
consumption can be predicted, then a decrease of river flow is logical. At the basin scale, the GICC
study predicts that the pattern and the spatial extension of natural vegetation would not change
significantly, so hydrology would not be affected by this parameter. However, on the long term,
vegetation will colonize the upper slopes of the Alps. In the Southern regions, the decrease of water
content in soils and vegetation will increase the stress on vegetation, may induce a higher sensitivity
to fires during the driest periods of the year, and increase exposition to soil erosion (IPCC, 2001).
For instance, the 2003 summer drought provoked several fires in the Vercors, a wet massif of the
Northern Prealps, which had not experienced any fire during the last decades.
3.2.2. River discharges
The statistical study of river discharges in France did not detect any significant change in the
number and the intensity of floods since the mid-XXth c. Also, it is impossible to confirm any
change in low discharges, mostly because of heavy human impacts on rivers (Lubès-Niel & Giraud,
2003; Lang et al., 2005). However, the situation may be different concerning the regimes of
mountain rivers. Indeed, the specific annual discharge of mountain rivers is higher than the specific
discharge of extended watersheds including lowland areas. This results from higher precipitations,
low evaporation rates, and by conditions favouring runoff. “The hydrological regime is strongly
influenced by water accumulation in the form of snow and ice and the corresponding melting
processes resulting in a pronounced annual cycle of the discharge. A modification of the prevalent
climate and especially of the temperature can therefore considerably affect the hydrological regime
and induce important impacts on the water management” (Horton et al., 2005). The recent increase
in temperatures has probably already had consequences on river regimes.
In Switzerland, “shifts in snow-pack duration and amount will be crucial factors in water
availability» for runoff according to Beniston et al. (2003). The increase in winter temperatures
will have clear consequences on the beginning of snowmelt and on the reduction of flow during the
spring at low altitudes and on summer flow at the highest altitudes. The rarefaction of snow cover
below 1000 m will reduce runoff. These shifts will affect river regimes with higher winter
discharges (Fig. 2-B). However, increased evaporation in winter may partly reduce runoff and river
discharge. Climate warming will increase the average discharge of rivers flowing from glaciers at
13
first during the period of retreat, but then will decrease summer discharge, as rivers will
progressively lose their glacial-type hydrological regime. A detailed study has been performed on
the potential impacts of climate change on the runoff regimes of 11 small catchments having glacier
surfaces comprised between 0 and 50%, at altitudes ranging between 1340 and 2940 m, under
different hydrological regimes (Horton et al., 2005; Schaeffli, 2005). Predictions were developed
for a scenario of +1°C (expected for 2020-2049) and two scenarios considering two increased green
house gas emissions (period 2070-2099: + 2.4 to 2.8 °C and +3.0 to 3.6°C, with rates higher in
summer than for the average). The conclusion are the following for the +1°C scenario:
- A decrease of annual precipitations
- An increase of winter precipitations, with the risk of higher flood peaks
- A decrease of summer precipitations
- A strong decrease of ice-covered areas, due to the strong increase of summer
temperatures. The regimes will be mainly driven by snow-melt during the Late XXIth c.
- A decrease in the amplitudes of discharge
- A significant decrease of annual discharge (5-15% for the +1°C scenario) due to the
reduction of precipitation, the increase of evapo-transpiration, the long term decrease of glacier
surface and discharge.
Horton et al. (2005) predicted “a significant decrease of the total annual discharge and a shift in the
monthly maximum discharge to earlier periods of the year due to the temperature increase and the
resulting impacts on the snow melt processes”. At lower altitudes, “the influence of precipitations is
more pronounced and the variability of the predicted climate change impact is mainly due to the
large range of predicted regional precipitation change” (Fig. 4).
In France, a statistical analysis of discharges at 140 gauging stations from 1975 to 1990 show a
reduction of snow-melt regimes to the benefit of “transitional” regimes and to a marked irregularity
in the seasonality of regimes. With the warming of climate, “minimal and maximal discharges will
be observed more frequently than in present times during other periods of the year than it is
presently expected”. In others words, prediction will be more difficult and the authors recommend
the adoption of a probabilistic approach (Krasovskaia et al., 2002). However specialists consider
that discharge regimes have not changed enough to justify any change in the policy of dam
management (D. Duband, oral comm.). The coupled ISBA-MODCOU model was used in three subwatersheds and on the entire Rhone basin for a selected warm year, then tested for the prediction of
change (Noilhan et al., 2000; Etchevers et al., 2001; Etchevers & Martin, 2002; Leblois, 2002;
Leblois & Grésillon, 2005) (Fig. 5-6-7).
14
15
16
17
18
19
- In the Doubs basin, the snow-rain regime shifts to rain regime with an increase of
discharge in December and January, and a decrease in spring, without a significant change of the
total yearly discharge.
- In the Saône basin (Mâcon), the rain regime remains the same, but discharges decrease
in summer (Fig. 5).
- In the Isère basin (Northern Alps), the maximum shifts from April to March, the winter
maximum increases, and the summer minimum decreases by 50% (Fig. 6).
- In the Southern Alps, during contemporary dry years, the Durance basin experiences a
“precocious and excessively rapid snow melt… resulting in an early peak and correspondingly very
weak summertime flows”. The simulated change forecasts “an annual reduction of river discharge
and of the soil moisture, decreasing by as much as 30% below the present values” (Fig. 7).
- However, if “the reduction of snowfall and earlier snow melting (increased air
temperature) induced a decrease of the average snow depth by 50% and of the snow duration by
more than one month”, snow pack at high altitude is less affected because even with the air
warming, the average air temperature would remain below 0°C.
- The Ardèche river basin experienced a “significant reduction in summer flow” and a
strong reduction of the soil water content, … “reflecting the heavy reduction of precipitation in that
area”
The GICC-Rhone programme extended these conclusions drawn from sub-waterheds to the larger
area of the French part of the Rhone basin (Leblois et al., 2005):
- Average yearly discharge and low flows decrease (from May to November), but high
discharges increase. Low flows may be reduced by 40-50% close to the outlet of the Rhone.
- Spring flow related to snow-melt decreases since the warming of the climate reduces
snow depth and the duration of snow cover, and snow melt occurs one month earlier.
- The behaviour of rivers in the winter depends on the different scenarios, but generally
the increase of winter rainfall induces an increase of winter discharges
3.2.3. Interactions between sediment supply and floods
Considering winter peak flows, they should interact with changes in sediment fluxes and, locally,
with the hydraulic geometry of rivers, increasing waterborne risks. The increased elevation of
pergelisol due to increased temperatures will decrease the cohesiveness of soils, and trigger mass
movements (Haeberli et al., 1990). Extreme rainfalls and increased average winter temperatures,
increased alternations of freezing and warming in weak rocks, will increase landslides and rockfall
20
hazards. However, recent catastrophic events in the Mattertal (Valais region) in 1987, 1993, and
2000, and above-average concentration of events have been proved to be caused by insufficient and
short archival data (Stoffel et al, 2005).
These changes in slope processes will increase sediment inputs into rivers, will induce deposition
and will raise the level of floods, interacting with land occupation issues along valley floors. This
trend could affect northern regions of the basin, as predicted by Beniston et al. (1995).
4. Observed current human impacts on the hydrological variables
4.1. Hydrological impacts of high altitude reservoirs on the river regimes
The effects of the ongoing natural climate warming up of climate on river regimes are rendered
more complex by the impacts of the management of Lake Geneva and of upland reservoirs. The
economic use of Lake Geneva has slowly changed since the Late XIXth century to the benefit of
tourist activities predominantly, which require a constantly high water level during the warm
season. The development of the tourist industry has imposed a reduction in the amplitude of vertical
variations in Geneva Lake, inducing a reduction in flood control and difficulties for the optimal use
of water at the outlet (Coulouvrenière dam). The Rhone at the outlet of Geneva Lake was initially
developed to maximize the efficiency of energy production, through strong variations in the level of
the lake, and then unpredictable variations downstream. However these variations have decreased
with time, since the conservation volume of the lake, which peaked in the 1850’s (810 hm3), was
reduced to meet the needs of tourism (i.e. stability) of the Vaud and Valais cantons (330-340 hm3
after 1892). The artificial regime of the lake decreased the discharge of the Rhône from July to
October (to preserve a capacity of storage in case of a summer flood) and increased it in the winter
for the production of energy (Bravard, 1986).
These changes interfered with the impacts of the development of energy production in the Alps.
Indeed, the fast development of water storage in high altitude reservoirs of upper Valais since the
1950’s has impacted the filling up of Lake Geneva because more and more water was used in the
inner Alps during the spring. This delays the filling up of Lake Geneva and affects the hydrology of
the Rhone downstream Geneva, high summer discharges being reduced when compared to natural
discharges. At the end of the 1960’s, the cumulated conservation storage was up to 1400 hm3, i.e.
three times the conservation storage of lake Geneva (Bravard, 1986). H. Vivian (1983, 1989)
insisted on the impacts of Valais dams on the regime of the Rhône River. During the winter season,
the production of high priced energy in Valais increases river discharge (deep waters of reservoirs
21
do not freeze and may be turbined). These impacts trigger a change in the regime of the Rhone
River at Porte de Scex, which loses part of its mountain characteristics (ice-fed and snow fed
regime toward a regime artificially similar to a rain-fed regime). This change, which is still visible
at Valence, allowed Vivian (p. 66), to state that “the hydrological regime has become an oceanic
type”. Upstream of Lyon, low flow no longer occurs in winter but during the fall, while the winter
high flow downstream of the confluences with the Ain and the Saône increases (“exaggeration of
the natural regime”). Similar changes have been noticed in the Isère watershed since modelled
discharges differ significantly from gauged discharges. It is worth noticing that reservoir
construction upstream of Saint-Gervais strongly decreased spring discharges to the benefit of all the
winter months. Thus, the predicted increase of winter flow is already anticipated by the artificial
increase linked to the production of hydro-energy.
In conclusion, the impacts of Lake Geneva and mountain reservoirs cumulated since they store
water in spring and summer and decrease the Rhône discharge during these seasons and increase the
discharge during the cold season. These artificial changes have anticipated the ongoing and
expected impacts of climate warming, even if a higher degree of complexity in engineered flow
could be taken into account. This complexity would deserve more interest and international
collaborative research, considering the economic consequences along the French course of the river
(running of the nuclear power plants).
4.2. Human impacts on water temperature
The temperature of Lake Geneva increased by 1°C since the 1960’s, while temperature of Annecy
lake increased of 1°C since the late XIXth c. The temperature of the Rhone river increased by 1.3 to
3°C in the different stations between 1977-1987 and 1988-1999. They increased notably during the
spring and the summer. The former temperature at Orange is then the present temperature at Lyon
(Poirel, 2004). This warming up is distributed between natural and human-induced causes.
The CNR had estimated the yearly average warming up impact of the chain of hydroelectric
schemes at 0.14°C due to the slower velocity of flow in the 16 reservoirs (Cottereau, 1989). A far
more important part of the warming up must related to the impacts of nuclear power plants. Indeed,
the influence of these plants on the thermal regime has been demonstrated by Electricité de France
(Desaint, 2004). 90% of time, the theoretical impact is less than 3°C just below the plants, while the
average warming up is 1.72°C (Bugey plant), 1.03 (Saint-Alban plant), and 1.34°C (Tricastin plant).
Temperatures have a strong seasonal behaviour, depending on the meteorology, on the discharge of
the Rhone, on the input of cool water from the tributaries (Isère River), and on the energetic
production of the plants. The artificial warming up decreases downstream of the plants, but the
22
warming up due to the upstream Bugey plant is still noticeable on the lower Rhône, only it is
delayed in time. The residual artificial warming up is comprised between 1° and 1.5°C on the
downstream course.
5. Complex changes of water ecosystems
5.1. Changes in river ecosystems: upland rivers and foreland rivers
Considering a reduction of discharges by of 30-40% and an increase in temperature during the dry
months throughout the basin, biologists (Pont et al., 2003) working in the GICC programme
propose the following preliminary results :
- The potential reduction of cryophilous and rheophilous fish species, such as the trout, the
bullhead, the loach, the Planer lamprey, and the introduced sun perch. The main threshold will be a
2°C increase in temperature. This trend would enhance the already noticed reduction of these
species already noticed in Europe, which has been caused by river training. Considering the impact
of decreased discharges on river hydraulics and river habitat for fish, models predict the negative
impact of lower summer discharges on reophilic species, such as grayling, dace and barbel. Their
abundance could decrease by 20% due to this factor.
- Some Cyprinids will be positively affected, such as the chub, the bleak, and the perch. The most
rheophilous Cyprinids will colonise the upstream river reaches
- Some families of macroinvertebrates are negatively influenced by increased temperature (Perlidae,
Odontoceridae, etc…). In fact, several physical and chemical factors interact in a complex manner
with temperature increase.
These tendencies reinforce the negative impacts of river training monitored since the XIXth c. along
rivers of Europe.
The response of exotic vegetal species has been studied in south-western France and the
conclusions may be extrapolated with caution. Competitiveness of the most thermophilous species
will be positively affected by an increase in temperature of 1°C (Tabacchi & Planty-Tabacchi).
At last, it is of major concern to look at the effects of the recent warming of the rivers. Two types of
studies have documented these changes:
-
The average yearly temperature of the Saône River increased by 1°5C between 1987 and
2003. The 2003 summer heat wave could exemplify future years since temperature at the
highest since 1500 at least. Mouthon & Daufresne (2006) studied the response of mollusc
communities between 1996 and 2004. The resilience of these communities to high
temperatures is low, particularly for Pisidium. As much as “more than half the mollusc
23
species currently inhabiting the potamic area of the Saone and Doubs rivers, and
probably other large rivers, are probably directly threatened with extinction”.
-
The effects of a 1°C increase since 1985 has been studied on macro-invertebrates of the
Rhône. While improvement in water quality did not introduce significant changes in
community structure, temperature was proved to be a major factor all along the river
whatever the constraints linked to local development schemes may have been
(hydropower schemes, nuclear power plants). The period was characterised by the
progressive development of invasive species and progressive changes in native
community structure, due to gradual environmental changes (Daufresne et al., 2004).
Moreover, large recent floods (pulse disturbance) and 2003 heat wave triggered rapid
shifts. They were beneficial to eury-tolerant and invasive taxa in the downstream and
middle river reaches. No sign of recovery was observed after disturbances and the
sensitivity of community structures seem to increase with time, due to catastrophic
bifurcations (JF Fruget, oral comm..).
5.2. Changes in lake ecosystems
The impacts of the increase in temperature in the large subalpine Lake Geneva has been studied for
the current conditions, which provide some insights into predictable changes linked to global
warming. Temperature increased by 1°C along the vertical profile since 30 years ago (Fig. 8). The
thermal stratification sets up one month earlier in the epilimnion, along with the primary production
and the growth of herbivorous zooplankton. Complementing the human-controlled decrease in the
concentration of phosphorus, the spring mixing of water, then the availability of nutrients, and the
structure of phytoplankton and grazers, were influenced by the winter warming up of the lakes,
which in turn is linked to the NAO (Anneville et al., 2005). The different fish species were also
affected by the warming of water (Gerdeaux, in press; Gerdeaux, 2005):
-
The arctic chars (Salvelinus alpinus and Coregonus lavaretus) are endemic species
adapted to the cold deep waters of the hypolimnion since the Late Glacial Period, alike in
Arctic areas. They have a strong importance in fishing economy of the lake. These
species spawn in winter when photoperiod and temperature both decrease. The warming
of the lake delays spawning in December, reducing the development of embryos so that
larvae are hatching a few days earlier than before, and are benefiting warmer waters and
plenty of food from plankton. Then moderate warming benefit the artic chars whose
24
25
catches increased from 50 tons in the 1970’s to 300 tons since the late 1990. Bottom
temperature increased from 4.5°C to 5.5°C during the last 30 years. When temperature will
be as high as 7°C, ovogenesis of females will be halted and these species will not be able to
adapt.
-
The roach is a cyprinid living in the warmer epiliminion and spawns in May, one month
earlier than before. Generally speaking, white fish have benefited the recent warming of
the lake through better survival of larvae due to increased plankton food supply
-
The perch, which lives deeper (below the epilimnion), does not benefit from the earlier
warming of water. Since the reproduction of perch does not occur earlier, the alevins no
longer benefit from the presence of roach larvae and experience a slower growth.
In the future, the lakes will experience a warming up from warmer air temperature and tributary
waters. Earlier snow melting and earlier peak flows from the Alps will increase spring warming of
the lakes. Also, the reduction of glacier mass will reduce the cooling by tributaries in late spring and
summer. This impact of warmer waters on the vertical profile will depend on the future conditions
of mixing influenced by changed conditions of stratification and by tributary inputs. Danis et al.
(2004) have particularly studied the future conditions of water mixing behaviour, using a thermal
model. Annecy lake is a monomictic lake experiencing one full mixing when air temperature cools
surface waters down to the maximum density of 4°C. The mixing of Annecy Lake will be
preserved. The epilimnion temperature would increase of ca 2.2°C in one century. The hypolimnion
temperature will experience the same change thanks to the high transparency of water, which allows
the absorption of solar radiation. The regular overturning will then be preserved. However, like in
Geneva Lake, the arctic char will disappear due to the increase in temperature above 7°C.
6. Predictable impacts on the uses of water and on humans
6.1. Energy
6.1.1. Hydropower
The general reduction in runoff will affect the production of hydraulic energy throughout the Alps,
particularly in the Southern Alps which will be submitted to the strongest reduction. In Switzerland,
the scenarios of change predict a reduction of the mean annual hydroelectricity potential due to a
significant decrease of mean annual discharges. After 2050, the reduction of summer discharge will
26
reduce the differences in seasonal discharges, inducing an easier management of energy production.
The winter discharges will increase in response to earlier snow-melt and to increased precipitations.
Spring discharges will increase, but the change will be more limited. The modelling the Mauvoisin
hydropower plant production allowed B. Schäfli (2005) to predict a 36% decrease between 1961 to
1990, and 2070-2099. The same behaviour is predictable in the Northern French Alps (cf the regime
of the Isère River, fig. 6).
Since the future hydrological regimes will be driven more by precipitations than by snow-melt and
glacier-melt processes, the “inter-annual variability of mean annual discharge is expected to
increase”, and possibly “the year-to-year hydroelectricity potential” (Horton et al., 2005). The
filling up of high elevation reservoirs will occur earlier in the season thanks to earlier snow melting
and to increased winter temperatures.
Economically, this change may fit with the highest values of energy during winter peaks of demand.
However, the recent increase in summer consumption of energy observed during the hot months of
2003, due to the use of electric coolers, has triggered peaks of prices on the European market. This
unexpected peak of demand will value summer production and may change the conditions of water
storage in the Western Alps to the detriment of summer storage, considering that increased
precipitations in winter decrease the importance of summer storage for winter production.
6.1.2. Thermal powercooled by rivers
Increased temperature of the Rhone will reduce the production of thermal energy,following the
Carnot rule. The cooling of nuclear power plants of the Rhône in France requires differences in
temperatures between the river and the cooling system. Any warming of the river decreases the
potential of energy production since the maximum temperatures of the releases are controlled by
strict rules. However, it is probable that these regulations will be softened to the detriment of
aquatic ecosystems, as it occurred in August 2003,. This policy will be all the more probable that
energy prices will increase during the hot season.
6.2.
Tourism
Climate change will have impacts on tourism through the status of water. Beniston (2003) proposes
to make the distinction between direct impacts (through conditions for specific activities) and
indirect impacts (through changes in landscapes and the modified pattern of economic demand). We
will consider herein the direct impacts upon tourism based on snow and lakes.
27
6.2.1.
The challenge of snow cover reduction
According to Abegg and Froesch (1994), an increase of temperature of 2-3°C by the year 2050
would adversely affect ski resorts located at low altitude (below 1,200-1,500 m). Warmer winters
will bring less snow at these altitudes, and snow will melt faster, reducing the probability of
practicing skiing, a sport requiring a snow cover of 30 cm during at least 100 days. A 2°C warming
would reduce the reliability of resorts in Switzerland from 85% in the late XXth c. down to 63%,
affecting in particular the low altitude resorts (Koenig and Abegg, 1997). In Isère department,
France, the Conseil Général ordered a study dealing with the last 29 winters. The results point to the
vulnerability of the resorts whose ski runs are lower than 1,500 m in elevation, the snow cover
being more and more uncertain. In the Drôme department, the Conseil Général finances the yearly
financial deficit of 4 small ski resorts. In 2003, it granted the construction of the upper ski-lift of
Rousset resort, above 1,400 m, into the perimeter of a protected natural area.
To avoid the headlong pursuit of the communes in charge of developing winter sports, the Conseil
Général of Isère Department proposed a new type of contract to the lowest resorts in order to avoid
being financially sollicited in case of a series of winters deprived of snow. Indeed, these changes in
snow cover and in the duration and quality of the winter season will have economic consequences,
such as in Morzine-Avoriaz resorts complex (Frangialli & Passaquin, 2003). The lack of snow is
being compensated for by costly investments in snow-making equipments, better vegetation cover
on the runs, by the development of resorts at higher altitudes, and by investments in other types of
activities. If over-frequentation may be predicted in high altitude resorts, Christmas and Easter
periods will generate less incomes and the value of estates will decrease at lowest altitudes. The
heavy past investments may not be refunded, which affects the finances of communes or private
investors. Thousands of seasonal workers will have shorter seasons and reduced incomes.
The development of artificial snow has been precisely documented in the French Alps (Dugleux,
2002). In 2002, 85% out the 162 ski resorts of the French basin of the Rhone were able to produce
artificial snow, on 15% of surfaces, mostly between 1,500 and 2,000 m, but at higher and higher
altitudes. This is detrimental to local water resources since making 2 m3 of snow requires 1 m3 of
unfrozen water, while the torrents are at low flow. In 1999-2000, 10 hm3 of water were used in 119
resorts in Savoy, i.e. the same amount that a city of 170 000 inhabitants, or 20% of the volumes
used for domestic uses. In terms of specific consumption, artificial snow requires 4000 m3/ha, to be
compared with 1700 m3/ha for the irrigation of corn in the Alps. Water for artificial snow has three
origins:
28
29
- More than one third of resorts experience shortages in water supply for domestic uses, because
in 25% of resorts, snow production competes with human uses (total volume : 2 hm3 per year).
- 50% of ski resorts have built artificial tanks storing 20 000 to 150 000 m3 (total volume: 5 hm3
per year)
- 25% of resorts withdraw water from rivers during the cold season.
Making artificial snow has impacts on the aquatic environment :
- Tanks are harmful to wetlands, have no hydrological impacts on rivers during the cold
season, but are filled in during the summer season, and may be prone to destruction by floods
- Direct winter withdrawals impact rivers at low flow, from November to February
(January represents 30% of the total consumption).
Dugleux (2002) proposed an indicator of pressure upon low flow discharges. For 60% of resorts,
withdrawal represents less than 10% of low flow discharge. For 11 resorts it represents from 30 to
49% of this discharge, for 2 of them, more than 50% (Fig. 9). It has been underlined that, if the
present impacts are not too harmful, they will develop in the future. Since artificial snow meets
major economic objectives (the survival of the resort in some cases, the maximum snow depth on
all the tracks during the complete season), the phenomenon must be strictly monitored and
controlled.
6.2.2. Water supply to southern resorts
Water supply to resorts (swimming pools, lawns), and for leisure (golf courses) will be reduced if
summer precipitations decrease and if evaporation increases, notably in the Southern part of the
watershed (Ceron & Dubois, 2003). Mountain reservoirs will be solicited, as it is presently the case
in the Ardèche basin where a minimum discharge guarantees the practice of canoeing in the
downstream gorges, in July and August.
6.2.3. Maintaining levels of large subalpine lakes
Tourism on large lakes will be impacted by climate change in a complex way. Coupled with the
early reduction of discharge, it will probably impact the conditions of the seasonal filling up of
Lake Geneva. Annecy and Bourget Lakes have small tributaries which will be affected by earlier
snow-melt and by decreased summer discharge, in a context of increased evaporation, like in 2003.
Due to water withdrawal for domestic uses from Annecy Lake, and withdrawal of used water
collected around both Annecy and Bourget Lakes, the natural inputs into the lakes have been
artificially reduced. Maintaining high water levels in summer, for the sake of aesthetics and tourism
30
is a challenge, which precludes any variation for the sake of the sustainable ecology of banks in
Annecy Lake. In the case of Bourget Lake, maintaining a high and constant level would require
supplying water from the Rhone to the lake, as in July 2003.
6.3. Pressures on the consumptive uses of water
6.3.1. Present consumptions in the Rhone watershed (France) and along the Rhone River
The total withdrawals at the watershed scale have a total amount to 15 800 hm3/year (table 1),
but do not exceed 4600 hm3 if one excludes withdrawals from the Rhone River (most of this
withdrawal is just a diversion to the cooling systems, since a small proportion is lost in cooling
towers, most of the cooling systems being “closed” systems). This yearly volume must be
compared with the yearly discharge of the Rhone River at the outlet, i.e. 54 000 hm3 (95 000 hm3
are stored in lakes and 15,5 hm3 stored in the decaying alpine glaciers.
Domestic
uses
1900
Industry
950
Thermal
energy
11 200
Irrigation
Total
1750
15 800
Table 1: Withdrawals in the Rhone watershed for the different water uses, France only (hm3/year)
Excluding energetic uses,
-
The withdrawal from the Rhone River alone stands below 850 hm3/year (Table 2), i.e. the
represents less than 1,6 % of the total discharge into the Mediterranean.
-
The withdrawal at the watershed scale (4600 hm3/y) represents 8,5 % of the discharge into
the Mediterranean.
Part of these withdrawals devoted to domestic uses, agriculture and industrial processes are not
consumed and go back to the ground waters and to the river.
Superficial
water
Ground water
Total
Domestic
uses
10,4
212,6
223
112,1
Thermal
energy
11 200
Irrigation Irrigation Others
by gravity pression
45,6
134,8
0
277
390
0,1
11200
4,3
49,9
Industry
Table 2: Withdrawals from the Rhone River only (hm3/an)
31
13,7
150
15,4
15,4
6.3.2. Irrigation in the perspective of climate change
The GICC-Rhone study (Leblois et al, 2005), using the STICS model, predicts that the doubling of
CO2 concentration will induce a shorter seasonal cycle for corn cultivation (reduction by 21%), and
a 15% loss of yield. The shorter cycle induces an increase of irrigation rates which cumulate with
increased plant requirements due to climate warming. However, the earlier growth reduces the
intakes in August, the most difficult periods for river hydrology. The Drôme river case study
provided interesting insights into future climate change, since the average yearly temperature
increased by 0.9°C and the temperature of July by 2°C, with marked consequences on hydrological
resources. The GICC study predicts that agriculture will probably adapt through a reduction of
irrigation practices to the benefit of crops less dependant on water resources.
The pressure upon water resources (superficial water and groundwater) will change in a complex
way. Industrial consumptive uses are decreasing, while domestic uses are stagnant, partly due the
rise of prices. Global water consumption by agriculture will be influenced by EEC policy and by the
global market, in ways that are difficult to predict today. It is clear that different ecoregions have
different potentialities and that a unique set of rules is not recommended to overcome periods of
water shortage. Beyond the modelling of river discharges, the GICC-Rhone study recommends to
investigate the different components of water balance at the scale of the geographical units. The
variations of precipitations from year to year, and the variation of water volumes should be
computed for a better management of resources in situations of potential conflicts.
It is worth considering the present responses of farmers to drought, such as they occurred in 1989,
and in 2003 and 2004, because they may announce future massive forms of adaptation to situation
of crisis:
-
In the “ecoregions” prone to the drying up of rivers and deprived of subterraneous
resources, i.e. mainly in the crystalline regions of the basin, farmers were granted to built
tanks intercepting the headwaters and the hypodermic flow. Hundredths of tanks have
been built along the eastern rim of the Massif Central since 30 years (Lyon Mounts,
Vivarais). They induce severe reduction of summer flow and decrease winter floods
during the period of infilling. As such, they have been proved to induce so severe impacts
upon river hydrology and ecology that they are no longer a priority of public authorities,
even if they are economically efficient.
-
A kind of adaptation is the development of wells into the alluvial aquifer bordering the
river. This practice is detrimental to small rivers, which are fed by the aquifer and are
prone to severe and long-lasting drying up. Authorities are reacting by delineating the
32
riparian aquifers and by limiting the authorisations of pumping from the wells
(Bonhomme and Nicolas, 2005).
-
Most of the recent developments concern the aquifer included inside the deep and rich
mollassic sandstones of the Alps and Jura foreland. Water extraction is so intense that the
groundwater levels are declining due to a negative balance between the refilling by the
precipitation and the extraction during the warm season. Public authorities have recently
decided to develop a network of piezometers in threatened areas, because they are
sensitive to the over exploitation of water resources (in some rare cases, water for
domestic uses was no longer available due to the lowering of the groundwater level).
Undoubtedly, controlling the volumes that are really extracted from aquifers will be a
challenge.
As it has been presented in the above developments, human interference with the effects of climate
change is increasing as far as agricultural uses are concerned. The more river discharges will be
affected by water withdrawal from aquifers, the more it will be difficult to make the distinction
between anthropogenic impacts and changes induced by climate change, even along large rivers like
the Rhône.
While admitting that French agriculture will need more security, Redaud et al. (2002) recommended
to reinforce regulations aiming at controlling irrigation in order to better respect the low flow
objectives of the Watershed directory schemes (SDAGE) in heavily impacted basins.
6.3.3. Massive withdrawals from large rivers
Water intakes from large rivers in Southern France is quite a story. In the mid-fifties, the Durance
and the Rhone rivers were affected by large withdrawals with different purposes. The average
yearly discharge of the Durance River was 210 m3/s at the confluence into the Rhone River. On the
upstream course of the river, the Serre-Ponçon dam (1955-1959), along with a complex hydraulic
system on the Verdon (a left bank tributary), allowed the diversion of 0.7 km3 for energy production
and 0.2 km3 for agriculture into a lateral canal designed for carrying up to 300 m3/s. Also, part of
the discharge was diverted to the cities of the Mediterranean coast in order to secure water supply in
a period of growth of tourism. The lower reach of the canal pours into the Etang de Berre, to the
detriment of the Rhone discharge. Downstream Serre-Ponçon, the minimum discharge of the river
is no more than 2 m3/s during most of the year (when the canal discharge is not exceeded), while the
absolute minimum was 25 m3/s before 1960. R. Warner (2000, 2001) described the artificial river
corridor as case of “desertification”. The vast array of upstream developments ensured “exotic”
areas (the irrigated and coastal regions): “with further effective reductions in precipitations and
33
increase in temperature, sustaining these enterprises will be very difficult. The opportunity for
further exploitation is virtually nonexistent. So the trends for desertification already apparent will
continue and promote greater concern” (Warner, 2000).
The Languedoc canal (1957-1960) was dug to divert up to 75 m3/s from the Petit Rhône, the eastern
branch of the Rhone in the Camargue delta, for the sake of irrigated agriculture. However,
withdrawals have never exceeded 15-20 m3/s, due to lack of consumption in the low coastal plains,
which remained widely devoted to non-irrigated vineyards. In 1995, the company ruling the canal
and a society delivering drinkable water to the city of Barcelona proposed to divert 10-15 m3/s from
the Rhone to Barcelona, using the same intake. The purpose was to secure water delivery to
Barcelona and provide better quality. The development of tourism, and the increase of summer
discharge of coastal rivers in Languedoc were other objectives. This project failed for complex
political reasons but it reveals the renewal of pressure upon the Rhone River.
6.4. Risks
6.4.1. Floods
The major apparent risk is linked to increased flood hazards. If winter floods occurring on rivers in
Switzerland have negative influences on discharges in downstream countries, then these countries
may ask for improved retention in the Swiss lakes and reservoirs, along with political consequences
(Schädler, 2003). In the last 15 years, severe floods occurred in the Upper Rhone downstream
Geneva (1990 was the 1 on 100 years flood), and in the lower Rhone (for instance:1993, 1994,
2003). As stated above (Sauquet & Haon, 2003), they may be just a cycle of high discharges as
many occurred in the past. Also, they may be the first signals of changed climate towards higher
peak floods. Anyhow, they revealed the strong vulnerability of the Rhone valley to flooding. In
1995, the French government launched a large study called “Global Rhône study”, combining
hydraulics, sediment transport and land occupation, as these different topics having been recognized
as complementing each other. The 2003 flood, approximately the 1 in 100 years flood for the
downstream gauging stations, motivated the French government to launch the so-called “Rhône
Masterplan” (2005) which includes a series of measures to mitigate the human consequences of
flooding, the reduction of hydrological hazards being recognized as quite impracticable. The
expected risk explicitly refers to the largest past floods (1856), to extremal scenarios combining
several meteorological origins (the so-called “general flood” in the sense of Pardé, 1925), and to the
negative impacts of the occupation of the floodplain. It is thus worth noting that the possible effects
of climate change on the intensity of large flood is not taken into account, despite the possible
34
increase in extreme winter events. Also, to face the expected changes, the French Ministry of
Environment and Sustainable Development recommended to extend the number of the “Plans de
Prévention des Risques” and to improve forecasting procedures (Redaud et al., 2002).
6.4.2. The Camargue delta and the mouth of the Rhone River
In the perspective of sea level rise, the coast dunes protecting the Camargue delta will be threatened
and brackish water may extend upstream, changing the ecological conditions of the lower river.
According to Provansal and Sabatier (2000), the main cause of present coastal retreat is not sea
level rise but the decrease of sediment supply from the Rhône River which has complex causes
(sediment retention in reservoirs, impacts of embankments of the Rhône, reforestation of the
watershed, etc…). The velocity of the coastal retreat should increase, in particular if sea storms and
surges get more intense.
Also, the intrusion of brackish water will affect the Grand Rhone itself. In the 1990’s, an outcrop of
bedrock has been suppressed for the sake of navigation downstream the city of Arles, making easier
the intrusion of marine water at low flow. It is probable that the expected reduction of low flow and
sea level rise will induce longer periods of brackish conditions between flood pulses upstream of
the present limit, to the detriment of human uses (domestic uses and irrigation of paddy fields inside
the delta).
6.4.3. Increased temperatures and pathologies
The warming up of water temperature should increase the sanitary risks through better conditions
for hosts of virus (West-Nile virus, bird influenza, etc…), such as horses, mosquitoes and birds. The
Workshop Zone “Rhône Watershed” (P. Sabatier) launched a research programme on the
environmental parameters controlling the sanitary conditions in marshland areas.
Conclusion
Changes have begun on the hydrosystem of the Rhône River due to the direct impacts of recent
climate warming. These documented changes interfere with human-induced changes in a highly
developed watershed. Predicted changes linked to modelled climate change may have significant
hydrological, ecological and economic impacts in the next decades.
35
References
- Abegg B., Froesch U., 1994: Climate change and winter tourism: impact on transport companies
in the Suiss canton of Graubünden. In: Beniston M. (ed), Mountain Environments in Changing
Climates. Routledge Publ. C°, London & New York, p. 328-340.
- Abegg B., Koenig U., Burki R., Elsasser H., 1997: Climate impact assessment in tourism. Die
Erde, 128, 105-116.
- Anneville O., Gammeter S., Straile D., 2005: Phosphorus decrease and climate variability:
mediators of synchrony in phytoplankton changes among European peri-alpine lakes. Freshwater
Biology, 50, p. 1731-1746.
- Arnell N., 1999: The effects of climate change on hydrological regimes in Europe. Global
Environmental Change, 9, p. 5-23.
- Becker A., 2005: Runoff processes in mountain headwaters catchments: recent understanding
and research challenges. In: Huber, Bugmann H., Reasoner M.A., (eds), Global Change and
Mountain Regions, Springer Verlag
- Becker A., Bugmann H. (eds), 1997: Predicting Global Change Impacts on Mountain Hydrology
and Ecology: Integrated Catchment Hydrology/Altitudinal Gradient Studies. IGBP Report 43,
Stockholm.
- Becker A., Bugmann H. (eds), 2001: Global Change and Mountain Regions. The Mountain
Research initiative, IGBP Report 49, Stockholm
- Beniston, M., 1993: Prévisions climatiques pour les Alpes: une revue des techniques de
régionalisation, La Météorologie, 45, p. 38-44.
- Beniston, M., (ed.), 1994: Mountain Environments in Changing Climates, Routledge Publishing
Company, London and New York, 492 p.
- Beniston M., 1997: Variations of snow depth and duration in the Suiss Alps over the last 50
years: links to changes in large-scale forcings. Climatic Change, 36, p. 281-300.
- Beniston M., 2000: Environmental Change in Mountains and Uplands. Arnold Publ., London &
Oxford Univ. Press, New York, 172 p. - Beniston M., Ohmura M., Rotach M., Tschuck P. , Wild
M., and Marinucci M.R., 1995: Simulation of climate trends over the Alpine Region: Development
of a physically-based modeling system for application to regional studies of current and future
climate, Final Scientific Report No. 4031-33250 to the Swiss National Science Foundation, Bern,
Switzerlan 200.
- Beniston M. (ed), 2002: Climate Change. Implications for the Hydrological Cycle and for Water
Management. Advances in Global Change Research, Kluwer Acad. Publ., Dordrecht & Boston, 503
36
p.
- Beniston M., 2003: Climatic change in mountain regions: a review of possible impacts. Climatic
Change 59, p. 5-31.
- Beniston, 2004: Extreme climatic events: examples from the alpine region. Journal de Physique
IV, 121, p. 139-149.
- Beniston M., 2005: Changement climatique et impacts possibles dans la region alpine. Rev. de
Géographie Alpine, 2, p. 13-29.
- Beniston M., Jungo P., 2002: Shifts in the distribution of pressure, temperature and moisture and
changes in the typical weather patterns in the Alpine region in response to the behavior of the North
Atlantic Osciilation. Theoretical and Applied Climatology, 71 (1-2), p. 29-42.
- Beniston M., Keller F., Goyette S., 2003: Snow pack in the Suiss Alps under changing climatic
conditions: an empirical approach for climate impacts studies. Theoretical and Applied
Climatology, 74, p. 19-31.
- Beniston, M., M. Rebetez, F. Giorgi, and M.R. Marinucci, 1994: An analysis of regional climate
change in Switzerland, Theor. and Appl. Clim., 49, 135-159
- Bonhomme B. Nicolas J., 2005: Bilan de la sécheresse 2003 et 2004 en Rhône-Alpes vis-à-vis des
eaux souterraines. Rapport final. Bureau de la Recherche Géologique et Minière, RP-54245-FR, 64
p.
- Braun L.N., Weber M., Schulz M., 2000: Consequences of climate change for runoff from Alpine
regions. Annals of Glaciology, 31, 19-25.
- Bravard J.-P., 1986 : Le Rhône du Léman à Lyon. Lyon, Ed. La Manufacture, 451 p.
- Bravard J.-P., Dupont Ph., 2002: The Rhone watershed: from tamed and plentiful waters to
environmental impacts. Colloque sur l’Eau, Shanghai, 6-9 Novembre 2002, Assoc. Fr. pour la
Coopération Scientifique et Technique.
- Burlando P., Pellicciotti, Strasse U., 2002: Modelling mountainous water systems between
learning and speculating looking for challenges. Nordic Hydrology, 33 (1): 47-74.
- Ceron J.-P., Dubois G., 2003: Tourisme et changement climatique : une relation à double sens. Le
cas de la France. 1ère Conf. int. sur le changement climatique et le tourisme, Djerba, Tunisie, 17 p.
- Cottereau C., 1989: Les problèmes d’environnement et d’impact liés à l’aménagement du Rhône.
La Ville et le fleuve, colloques du Com. Trav. Hist. & Sc., 3, p. 73-105.
37
- Daufresne M., Roger M.C., Capra H., Lamouroux N., 2004: Long-term changes within the
invertebrate and fish communities of the Upper Rhone River: effects of climatic factors. Global
Change Biology, 10, 124-140.
- De Jong C., Collins D.N., Ranzi R. (ed.), 2005: Climate and Hydrology of Mountain Areas,
Wiley, Chichester, 338 p.
- Deneux M., 2002: Rapport sur l’évaluation de l’ampleur des changements climatiques, de leurs
causes et de leur impact prévisible sur la géographie de la France à l’horizon 2025, 2050 et 2100.
Paris, Office parlementaire d’évaluation des choix scientifiques et technologiques, 291 p.
- Desaint B., 2004: Etude thermique du Rhône – Phase 2 – Rapport préliminaire. EDF, Branche
énergie, 55 p. + annexes.
- Dugleux E., 2002: Impact de la production de neige de culture sur la resource en eau. Coll. “L’eau
en montagne: gestion intégrée des hauts basins versants”, Megève, 7 p.
- Etchevers P., Golaz C., Habets F., 2001: Simulation of the water budget and the river flows of the
Rhône basin from 1981 to 1994. Journal of Hydrology, 244, p. 60-85.
- Etchevers P., Golaz C., Habets F., Noilhan J., 2002: Impact of a climate change on the Rhone river
catchment hydrology. Journal of Geophysical research-Atmospheres 107 (D16), doi:
10.1029/2001JD000490.
- Etchevers P., Martin E., 2002: Impact d’un changement climatique sur le manteau neigeux et
l’hydrologie des bassins versants de montagne. Coll. “L’eau en montagne : gestion intégrée des
hauts bassins versants”, Megève, 8 p.
- Frangialli F., Passaquin F., 2003: Tourisme durable et changement climatique : l’exemple des
Alpes françaises – Le cas de Morzine-Avoriaz (France). 1ère Conf. int. sur le changement
climatique et le tourisme, Djerba, Tunisie, 10 p.
- Gerdeaux D., 2005: Restoration of the whitefish fisheries in Lake Geneva. The roles of stocking,
reoligotrophication, and climate change. Ann. Zool. Fennici 41, p. 181-189.
- Gerdeaux D., in press: Impacts des changeemnts globaux sur les communautés lacustres et le
fonctionnement des lacs. Coll. Marseille, Rhône-Méditerranée (2003), Centre d’Océanologie de
Marseille.
- Gillet C., Dubois J.P. 2003. La reproduction de la perche et du gardon dans le Léman. Cybium, 27:
72-73.
- Gillet C., Dutin Ph.,: Effect of temperature changes on the reproductive cycle of roach (Rutilus
rutilus, L) in Lake Geneva from 1983 to 2001.en révision dans la revue Journal of Fish Biology.
38
- Gillet C. and Dubois J.P. A survey of the spawning of perch (Perca fluviatilis L.) in Lake Geneva
from 1984 to 2003. Effect of water temperature and size of females on the timing of spawning.
Soumis pour publication à Journal of Fish Biology.
- Green A. Broeker W.S., Rind D., 1999: Swiss glacier recession since the little Ice Age:
reconciliation with climate records. Geophys. Res. Lett., 26, p. 1909-1912.
- Haeberli, W., 1990: Glacier and permafrost signals of 20th-century warming, Ann. Glaciol., 14,
99-101
- Haeberli, W., 1994: Accelerated glacier and permafrost changes in the Alps, Mountain
Environments in Changing Climates, M. Beniston, (ed.), Routledge Publishing Company, London
and New York, 91-107.
- Haeberli W., 1995: Glacier fluctuations and climate change direction. Geogr. Fis. Quat., 18, p.
191-199.
- Haeberli, W., P. Muller, J. Alean, and H. Bösch, 1990: Glacier changes following the Little Ice
Age. A survey of the international data base and its perspectives, Glacier Fluctuations and Climate,
J. Oerlemans, (ed.), D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht, 77-101
- Haeberli W., Beniston, 1998: Climate change and its impacts on glaciers and permafrost in the
Alps. Ambio, 27, p. 258-265.
- Huber, Bugmann H., Reasoner M.A., (eds), 2005: Global Change and Mountain Regions,
Springer Verlag
- Hulme M, Barrow, E. M., Arnell, N.W., Harrison, P. A., Johns, T.C. and Downing, T.E. (1999)
Relative impacts of human-induced climate change and natural climate variability, Nature 397,
- Husting P., Jouzel J., Le Treut H. (Ed.), 2005: Changements climatiques, quels impacts en
France? Greenpeace, Paris,139 p.
- IPCC, 2002: Climate Change 2001, Synthesis Report. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK,
397 p.
- Krasovskaia I., Gottschalk L., Leblois E., 2002: Signature of changing climate in river flow
regimes of Rhône-Mediterranean-Corsica region. La Houille Blanche, 8, p. 25-30.
- Krippendorf J., 1984: The capital of tourism in danger. InE.A. Brugger et al. (eds), The
Transformation of Suiss Mountain Regions, Haupt Publ., Bern, p. 427-450.
- Leblois E., 2002: Evaluation des possibles impacts du changement climatique par modélisation
distribuée (projets Gewex-Rhône et GICC-Rhône. La Houille Blanche, 8, p. 78-83.
- Leblois E., Grésillon M., 2005: Projet GICC-Rhône. Rapport final revisé, version courte. 23 p.
- Lubès-Niel, H., and L. Giraud. 2003. _Floods in France: is there a change? _in. XVIe conférence
du centre Jacques Cartier, Lyon, France.
39
- Maisch M., 2000: The long-term signal of climate change in the Swiss Alps: glacier retreat since
the end of the Little Ice Age and future ice decay scenarios. Geogr. Fis. Dinam.Quat., 23, p. 139151.
- Martin E., Durand Y., 1998: precipitation and snow cover variabiltity in the French Alps. In:
Beniston M. and Ines J.L. (Eds), The impacts of Climate Change on Forest, Springer Verlag,
Heidelberg/New-York, pp. 81-92.
- Martin E., Etchevers P., 2002: Impact des variations climatiques sur le manteau neigeux,
incidence sur l’hydrologie nivale, les avalanches. La Houille Blanche, 8, p.
- Martin E., Etchevers P., 2005: Impact of climatic changes on snow cover and snow hydrology in
the French Alps. In: Huber, Bugmann H., Reasoner M.A., (eds), Global Change and Mountain
Regions, Springer Verlag
- Noilhan J., Boone A., Etchevers P., 2000: Application of climate change scenarios to the Rhone
basin. ECLAT-2 Toulouse Workshop, key-note paper 4.
- OcCC, 2003: Evènements extrêmes et changements climatiques. Organe consultatif sur les
Changements Climatiques, Berne, 94 p.
- Palutikov J.P., Goodess C.M., 2000: Application of climate change scenarios for impact studies on
ecosystems over the Mediterranean area. ECLAT-2 Toulouse Workshop, key-note paper 3.
- Poirel A., 2004: Etude thermique du Rhône – Phase 1 – Complément d’étude. Extension des
resultants à la période 2000-2003. EDF, Branche énergie, 55 p. + annexes.
- Pont D. (coord.), 2003: Programme GICC-AQUABIO. Conséquences potentielles du changement
climatique sur les biocénoses aquatiques et riveraines françaises. Rapport final, p…………
- Price M., Kohler T., Wachs T. (eds), 2000: Mountains of the World: Mountain Forests and
Sustainable Development. Paul Haupt Publ., 42 p.
- Provansal M., Sabatier F., 2000: Impacts de la montée du niveau de la mer sur la côte du delta du
Rhône. In Paskoff R. (éd.) : Le changement climatique et les espaces côtiers, Actes du coloque
d’Arles, 12-13 octobre 2000, p. 78-81.
- Redaud J.-L., Noilhan J., Gillet M., Huc M., Begni G., 2002: Changement climatique et impact sur
le regime des eaux en France. MEDD, Mission Interministérielle sur l’effet de serre. 41 p.
- Sauquet E., Haond M., 2003 : Examen de la stationnarité des écoulements du Rhône en lien avec
la variabilité climatique et les actions humaines. Coll. "Barrages et développement durable en
France. Paris, Comité Français des Grands Barrages et Ministère de l'Ecologie et du Développement
Durable, p. 261-270.
- Schädler B., 2003: Effets des changements climatiques sur les hydrosystèmes alpins. EAWAG
News, 55, p. 24-26.
40
- Schaefli B., 2005: Quantification of modelling uncertainties in climate change impact studies on
water resources: Application to a glacier-fed hydropower production system in the Suiss Alps.
Doctoral Thesis, n° 3225, Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Lausanne, 209 p.
- Schröter, D., Cramer, W., Leemans, R., Prentice, I.C., Araújo, M.B., Arnell, N.W., Bondeau, A.,
Bugmann, H., Carter, T.R., Garcia, C.A., de la Vega-Leinert, A.C., Erhard, M., Ewert, F.,
Glendining, M., House, J.I., Kankaanpää, S., Klein, R.J.T., Lavorel, S., Lindner, M., Metzger, M.J.,
Meyer, J., Mitchell, T.D., Reginster, I., Rounsevell, M., Sabaté, S., Sitch, S., Smith, B., Smith, J.,
Smith, P., Sykes, M.T., Thonicke, K., Thuiller, W., Tuck, G., Zaehle, S., & Zierl, B. (2005).
Ecosystem Service Supply and Vulnerability to Global Change in Europe. Science Online, 27
octobre 2005.
- Six D., Reynaud L., Letréguilly A., 2002: Variations des bilans de masse des glaciers alpins et
scandinaves sur les dernières décennies, leurs relations avec l’Oscillation du climat de l’Atlantique
Nord. La Houille Blanche, 8, p. 34-35.
- Stoffel M., Lièvre I., Conus D., Grichting M.A.?, Raetzo H., Gärtner H.W., Monbaron M., 2005:
400 years of debris-flow activity and triggering weather conditions, Ritigraben, Valais, Switzerland,
Artic, Antarctic, and Alpine Research, vol. 37, n° 3, p. 387-95.
- Vincent C., Fluctuations des bilans de masse des glaciers des Alpes françaises depuis le début du
20 siècle au regard des variations climatiques. La Houille Blanche, 8, p. 20-24.
- Van der Leeuw S. (coord.), 1998: The Archaeomedes Project. Understanding the natural and
anthropogenic causes of land degradation and desertification in the Mediterranean basin. European
Commission, Environment and climate program, EUR 18181, Luxembourg, Office for the Office
Publ. of the EEC, 440 p.
- Vivian H., 1989: Hydrological changes of the Upper Rhône. In Petts et al. (Eds): Historical
Changes of large Alluvial Rivers. Western Europe. Chichester, Wiley & Sons, p. 57-77.
- Warner R., 2000: Gross channel changes along the Durance River, Southern France, over the last
100 years using cartographic data. Regulated Rivers: Research and Management, 16, p. 141-157.
- Warner R., 2001: Relevance of geomorphology in exploitive and sustainable management of
water resources in the Durance River, France. Integrated Water Resources Management (Proc.
Symp. held at Davis, California, IAHS Publ. n° 272, p. 277-284.
- Zierl B., Bugmann H., 2005: Global change impacts on hydrological processes in Alpine
catchments. Vol. Water Resources Research, 41: W02028, doi: 10.1029/2004WR003447.
- Zimmermann M., Haeberli W., 1989: Climatic change and debris flow activity in high mountain
areas. In Rupke J., Boer M.M. (Eds): Landscape Ecological Impact of Climate Change on Alpine
Regions, Lunteren, The Netherlands.
41
42