Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
REPAIR AN T. OF AVULSED EXPERIMENTAL E. J. HEMS, From An STUDY IN R. E. CLUTFON, the University experimental CERVICAL M. ofEdinburgh model A. GLASBY School, established Scotland to investigate the possibility of repairing cervical nerve roots avulsed from the spinal cord, as occurs in traction injuries of the brachial plexus. In five sheep the C6 root was avulsed and the ventral root was reattached using freeze-thawed muscle as a short graft (0.5 cm). Recovery was assessed after one year by electrophysiology and histology. Stimulation of the root produced muscle contractions in four out offive sheep. Action potentials were recorded distal to the grafts in all five sheep. Histological examination showed regenerated fibres in the ventral roots in all cases. These fibres could be traced distally to the brachial plexus. Our study confirms that motor fibres can regenerate out of the spinal cord into the ventral roots and reinnervate muscles, and suggests that reimplantation of avulsed roots is a surgical option in selected cases of traction injury of the brachial plexus. J Bonefoint Received Surg [Br] 25 January 1994; 1994; 76-B:818-23. Accepted 11 March ROOTS SHEEP Medical was NERVE 1994 Traction injuries to the brachial plexus usually result from road-traffic accidents, and often occur in young people. They have a devastating effect on the function of the upper limb. In recent years surgical exploration of the brachial plexus with excision and grafting of damaged areas has become more common (Jamieson and Bonney 1979; Birch 1992). Damage proximal to the dorsal root ganglion, however, is not amenable to surgical repair (Bonney 1991; Millesi 1991). Traction on nerve roots usually results in avulsion from the surface of the spinal cord (Sunderland 1974) and may be associated with damage to the cord itself. Recent work has raised the possibility of the repair of nerve roots avulsed from the spinal cord (Carlstedt 1991; Hems and Glasby 1992). There is considerable experimental evidence to suggest cell that bodies axons in the ventral in the anterior grey roots, horn which of the have spinal their cord, can regenerate distally in a manner similar to those which have been divided in a peripheral nerve (Kilvington 1907; Tower 1943; Moyer and Kimmel 1948; Christophersen and Wintsch 1977; Carlstedt Ct al 1986; Hems and Glasby 1992). Carlstedt et a! (1986) showed in the rat that axons can grow out of the spinal cord into ventral roots reimplanted after avulsion and that they make functional connections. Cullheim vation of muscles the dorsal roots ganglion. Useful et a! (1989) demonstrated in similar experiments have their cell bodies regeneration would reinner- in cats. Fibres in in the dorsal root therefore require fibres to grow into the spinal cord and make new connections in the CNS. The classical view is that this cannot occur; this was confirmed by Carlstedt et a! (1989) in adult animals. Reinnervation of the cord from dorsal roots may be possible in neonates. We have established an experimental model in the T. E. J. Hems, MA, DM, FRCS, FRCS Ed, Senior Orthopaedic Surgery John Radcliffe Hospital, Headington, Oxford OX3 Registrar 9DU, in Trauma and C6 root (the highest UK. R. E. Clutton, BVSc, DVA, MRCVS, Lecturer in Veterinary Anaesthesia Royal (Dick) Veterinary School, University of Edinburgh, Veterinary Field Station, Easter Bush, Roslin, Midlothian EH2S 9RG, UK. M. A. Glasby, MA, MSc, FRCS, FRCS Ed, Reader Department of Anatomy, University of Edinburgh Place, Edinburgh EH8 9AG, UK. Correspondence ©1994 British 0301-620X/94/S84S 818 should be sent Editorial Society $2.00 in Anatomy Medical School, to Mr M. A. Glasby. of Bone and Joint Surgery sheep for the study (Hems and Glasby simulate the human Teviot plexus) was caused only was divided found of the repair of cervical nerve roots 1992). A large animal was selected to situation as closely as possible. The root contributing to the sheep to be surgically minor proximal and repaired accessible forelimb proximal brachial and division weakness. to the root The root ganglion. Evidence of regeneration was found in the ventral The present study extends this work to investigate roots. the repair of roots avulsed recovery of function. assess Freeze-thawed from muscle ThE the cord autografts JOURNAL OF BONE and were to used AND JOINT in the SURGERY REPAIR repairs since method of they have (Glasby 1991a,b). et a! 1986a; Glasby et a! 1990; As there appears to be no possibility repair regeneration of in the been short shown defects dorsal roots facilitate access to the ventral possibility of fibres crossing dorsal roots. MATERIALS to be these not Pereira et a! of effective were removed was microscope to any and divided give access from Before the first water, was withheld for 12 to medication was xylazine hydro- chloride (Rompun; Bayer, Newbury, UK) 0.2 mg/kg given intravenously. Five minutes later anaesthesia was induced with ketamine, 2 to 4 mg/kg intravenously (Ketalar; Parke-Davis, Eastleigh, Hampshire, UK). The the dura. Heerbrug The lateral using Under M690) dorsal edge to the ventral the cord ends outside (Wild, longitudinally. removed. The an operating the dura was opened rootlets were divided of the dura was retracted rootlets which a Rhoton nerve and to were then avulsed hook and the torn trimmed. spinae, water for the experiment. food, but Preanaesthetic of which nerves 819 ROOTS NERVE A piece sheep procedure 18 hours. CERVICAL effective roots and to prevent between the ventral METhODS five an in peripheral AND We used OF AVULSED of muscle was obtained from frozen in liquid nitrogen, and as previously described (Glasby small piece (0.5 cm), was then cut to size, aspect of the with fibres longitudinally inserted between the spinal cord and the erector aligned, anterolateral ventral rootlets, secured in place with fibrin glue (Tisseel: Sevenoaks, UK). The dura was patched (Ethicon Ltd, Edinburgh, UK) which was place. the thawed in distilled et a! 1986a,b). A and Immuno Ltd, with Surgicel also glued into The wound was then closed with Vicryl (Ethicon). When surgery was almost finished the neuromuscular trachea was intubated with a cuffed endotracheal tube which was connected to a mechanical ventilator (CapeWayne; Cape Engineering Ltd, Warwick, UK). The minute volume of ventilation was 150 ml/kg. Anaesthesia was maintained with halothane 1.5% to 2% delivered from a vaporiser (Fluotec Mk III; Ohmeda, Steeton, West blockade atropine Yorkshire, UK) Carrier gas-flow After one year electrophysiological and histological examinations were carried out. The sheep were anaesthe- in an oxygen/nitrous rates were 2 (02) oxide (1 :2) mixture. and 4 (N2O) 1/mm. was reversed with (60 .tg/kg) mixture. (750 mg) recovery. further and flunixin Postoperative doses offlunixin doses an edrophonium Second (1.1 mg/kg) medication of cefuroxime 1.1 mg/kg (500 doses tg/kg)/ of cefuroxime were given consisted 750 mg 12-hourly, before of two 8-hourly and three both intravenously. After induction, the jugular vein was catheterised and an intravenous infusion of Hartmann’s solution begun at a tised as before except withheld. Induction rate of 10 ml/kg/hr. Before surgery, intravenous injections of buprenorphine (Temgesic; Reckitt and Co!man, Hull, UK) 10 rig/kg and flunixin (Finadyne; Fisons, Coalville, Roche Products Ltd, Welwyn Garden City, UK) 0.5 mg/ kg mixed with ketamine 2 to 4 mg/kg. Neurophysiological investigation precluded the use ofneuromuscular blocking agents on this occasion. A CS to C6 laminectomy was UK) 2.2 mg/kg, were Ltd, given. Greenford, antibiotic a non-steroidal Cefuroxime UK) 750 a peripheral Massachussetts). mental nerve doses for urinary measured. was 1 .0 ml/kg/hr with surgery fully and sterile the 7 rig/kg Bellerica, with incre- (Norcuron; given when the Vital signs first twitch were frusemide carried Short constant-voltage stimuli were applied if necessary (Lasix; in an operating theatre conditions. head fixed The animals securely in were placed a Mayfield 76-B. No. 5, SEPTEMBER 1994 wire bipolar C6 root just from from stimulating proximal the spinal for contractions. differential studies (Fig. 1). to A electrode was to the brachial generator 9200: girdle When low-impedance EMG recording into the contracting muscle and NL1O4A cord (0. 1 ms, 1OV) square-wave a signal source (Dagan Omnipulse Minnesota). The shoulder observed of neurosurgical head holder. The laminae of CS and C6 were exposed on one side through an 8 cm longitudinal midline incision. A hemilaminectomy was performed at the level of the CS to C6 space to expose the dura and the C6 root, the dorsal part VOL. power tion, log out both C6 roots plexus. carried out electrophysiological of reinnervation of muscles plexus. UK). was to expose to the brachia! First, we find evidence of the and urine production maintained in excess 2 mg/kg bra! muscles 0.3 mm palladium placed under the monitored preanaesthetic medication was with midazolam (Hypnovel; performed. The incision was then extended laterally on both sides to the posterior triangle of the neck with resection of the facet joints and division of the paraverte- Orga- using a catheter in the auricular pressure and ECG (lead II). The was catheterised output was Hounslow, All (Bard Biomedical, was maintained visible. anaesthesia arterial blood bladder Urine Hoechst, stimulator Relaxation UK) pattern throughout artery for blockade was produced with pancu25 pg/kg intravenously (Pavulon; OrgaLtd, Cambridge, UK) and monitored by of vercuronium Cambridge, stimulus under prone drug, Laboratories was used prophylaxis. Neuromuscular ronium bromide non Laboratories non, anti-inflammatory (Zinacef; Glaxo mg intravenously that was a.c. and isolated Dagan Corporamuscles were possible a electrode connected amplifier bipolar was inserted to a Neuro(Digitimer Ltd, Welwyn Garden City, UK). The output was fed to the Yinput of a digital oscilloscope. A bipolar needle electrode insulated except for the last 1 mm was then in the anterior were branch possible applied horn. from of the and C6 placed placed in the Square-wave a signal spinal cord stimuli generator. root was over a 0.3 mm The divided brachial as far palladium with its tip (0.1 ms, 1OV) plexus distally wire bipolar as T. E. J. HEMS, 820 R. E. CLUTFON, to M. A. GLASBY the recording averaged between time I I EMG (CMAP) ele:trode site. The signal 16 action potentials the stimulating and to the first peak of the action to calculate the conduction All e!ectrophysiological on the norma! and grafted averaging in each recording facility case. The cathodes potential distance and the were recorded velocity. studies were performed sides. The animals were under anaesthesia on completion of (intravenous pentobarbitone 20 mg/kg). the both killed investigation The C6 root and the adjacent spinal cord were removed and specimens obtained for histological examination from: A, the ventral root above the dorsal root Fig. Diagram ventral to show the apparatus root repairs. 1 for electrophysiological assessment of C6 specimens were processed as described by Gschmeissner, Gattuso and Glasby (1990) to produce 1 .tm thick resinembedded transverse sections for light microscopy. Sections were examined for overall appearance. Morphometric analysis was carried out on sections of the ventral roots using a Vids III computerised image-analysis Posterior primory ganglion; B, the complete root before the branching of the posterior primary ramus; C, the anterior primary ramus; and D, the brachial plexus root (Fig. 2). The romus system (Analytical UK). Branch Measuring A sample of 200 to In addition, Diagram to show the position D (see text) from which examination. Latency: cord 2 of the graft the specimens in the C6 root and the sites A to were taken for histological at the year Fig. 3 amplifier and on a digital a ground sections were ofthe fixed spinal in formalin, and cut and stained with methylene and eosin, and luxol fast blue with potential. electrode after grafting, the sheep showed a gradual procedure cord when over probably the root the first few Any functioning regenerated from muscle on the normal of avulsed C6 ventral repair. These occurred ventral as roots. are some connected recordings repair each ‘Lotus and ‘Sta- as a result was avulsed, Two after of trauma but these to the recovered weeks. motor fibres in the C6 root must the spinal cord through the repaired ventral root. Stimulation of the C6 brachial plexus root caused twitching of scapular muscles on the grafted side in four out of five sheep. The magnitude of the contraction was less than that on the normal side. Figure 3 shows recordings of the EMG obtained from the brachiocephalicus muscle after stimulation of the C6 root following Recordings of the EMG from the brachiocephalicus side and on the repaired side one year after grafting roots (amplifier gain x2000). action transverse the the initial have compound from using in the proximal forelimb weakness. weakness and spasticity of the hindlimbs rapidly differential a.c. was displayed of Cambridge, improvement had some SV electrode Ltd, measured RESULTS 8-Oms spinal recording complete level embedded in wax, blue, haematoxylin creosol violet. In the 0 was section. Statistical analysis was carried out Symphony’ (Lotus Corporation, Massachusetts) tistica’ (StatSoft Inc, Tulsa, Oklahoma). prevertebrol muscles Fig. Systems fibres to a Neurolog filter NL12S. oscilloscope In all was electrophysio!ogical placed in tissue close 20 cm from A compound NL1O4A The output to record a confirm grafted C6 root the reinnervation the spinal action when spinal cord indicating abolished after the excluding that a result of regeneration It is of note that the effect potential stimulating of muscle into the reinnervated had repaired muscles cord. was recorded the anterior from horn recovery of motor fibres. ventral roots were divided, of volume conductance. THE JOURNAL OF BONE the of the This was therefore The AND JOINT mean SURGERY REPAIR Fig. OF AVULSED CERVICAL NERVE ROOTS 4a Cross-sections of the anterolateral part of the spinal cord and repair of the ventral roots (luxol fast blue and creosol at the C6 level (a) on the normal violet stain x28). Table I. The axon and fibre diameters of normal and repaired avulsion are compared with previous values obtained after root ventral division Roots Roots avulsed Fibre diameter Control ventral roots Median Mode Upper quartile Lower quartile Mean (sm) Axon diameter 7.70 9.80 9.60 4.70 7.29 SEM 12.50 12.20 14.50 8.60 11.56 4.01 0.13 N 1000 SD Repaired ventral Median Mode Upper quartile Lower quartile Mean 821 (tm) Fig. 4b side and (b) one roots. Results and repair after avulsion root divided Fibre diameter (tm) Axon diameter 8.50 9.50 10.50 4.30 0.10 13.70 15.30 15.30 7.50 11.98 4.45 0.16 1000 800 800 5.50 2.90 3.50 7.70 1.30 4.80 1.70 3.45 2.13 0.07 4.70 Multiple 6.70 3.30 5.26 3.28 after year (tm) 7.60 3.56 0.13 roots 3.90 5.95 2.55 0.08 SD SEM N 1000 2.60 1.80 4.30 1.40 3.11 2.14 0.08 2.44 0.09 1000 800 800 Significance: Kolmogorov-Smirnov test p < 0.001 p conduction velocity in the grafted roots was 30.2 ± 3.3 ms which was significantly less than the norma! value of 50.35 ± 3.7 ms (j = 0.005) recorded at the same temperature. Cross-sections VOL 76-B, No. 5, SEPTEMBER of the 1994 anterolateral part of the spinal < 0.001 p < 0.001 p <0.001 cord on the repaired and normal sides are shown in Figure 4. In a!! cases the operated side ofthe cord was surrounded by scar tissue to which the dura adhered. There was also a variable amount of scar tissue and demyelination within the cord itself on this side. The number of large nerve- T. E. J. HEMS, 822 cell bodies the avulsion. the in the anterior At the point surface of the horn was of repair spinal cord reduced on the side of of the ventral roots on there containing regenerated fibres. Histological examination R. E. CLUYfON, were minifascicles of the ventral roots (A) M. A. GLASBY (Manthorpe et a! 1983). in brain-derived trophic rescue’ on Muscle is also neurotrophic factor known and to be rich related neuro- factors which are thought to be important ‘cellagents for motor neurones (Lindsay 1993). In this experiment, surgery on the ventral roots was the grafted side showed myelinated fibres to be present in all the sheep. Table I is a summary of the axon and fibre diameters obtained on morphometric analysis. The mean axon and fibre diameter was reduced compared with the normal side as is typical of regenerated fibres. Results were also compared with those obtained after ventral performed through a dorsal hemilaminectomy. As mentioned above two sheep had some temporary signs of damage to the spinal cord probably as a result of the avulsion trauma or retraction of the cord. Overall, the procedure appears to have been safe. A similar surgical roots were motor More distally (B, C, and D), fibres on the normal side can be improved well as the lamina divided and smaller-diameter repaired regenerated (Hems and areas had fibres Glasby 1992). of large-diameter been replaced on the grafted by side. and is regeneration out after avulsion This builds on our earlier ation after repair of ventral (Hems and Glasby 1992). in the from some that clearly ventral roots if the spinal cord. in a large more likely animal to be to the human situation. mean fibre diameter in the ventral roots was greater (p < 0.001) than that recorded after divided roots (Hems and Glasby 1992). This reflects the longer time allowed before assesscompared with 8 months) and strongly suggests functional and Young connective regenerating connections 1946). tissue roots were being Normal ventral roots but this is clearly as described made (1963). cells with production not occur in the CNS. (1990) that have shown blood-brain barrier and locally-produced there is a prolonged after avulsion trauma. trophic factors may of growth Risling et a! defect in the Blood-borne therefore be able to act on the CNS neurones (Kiernan and Contestabile 1980). An investigation of the levels of growth factors associated with root regeneration is under way. While we have not compared freeze-thawed muscle grafts with other methods of repair in this study they may be particularly beneficial to the process. Laminin, an important constituent of muscle basement membrane, is a potent neurite-promoting factor which has been shown to encourage sprouting from both CNS and PNS 1991). neck and If the roots foramena reattached late this procedure conclusion, subjects. Exposure of the facet joint as the stability of the operation was to the spinal would run the risk cord artery. An alternative would the spinal cord to important regeneration done could be passed back from the posterior of motor but of be to motor fibres can follow repair of a root avulsion injury and functional connections can be made. In addition, the method used is surgically feasible. The sheep is very similar to man both in the dimensions of the structures involved and in the time course for regeneration. Reimplantation roots could be a surgical traction injury to the brachial option plexus. in of avulsed selected cases of The authors wish to thank Mrs C. M. E. Glasby and Miss G. Valler for nursing help in the operating theatre and Mrs J. S. Wood, Mr R. Shields and Mr J. Cable for skilled technical assistance in the laboratory. This work was supported by grants from the Sir Jules Thorn Charitable Trust, the Wellcome Trust and the Cunningham Trust. No benefits in any form have been received or will be received from a commercial party related directly or indirectly to the subject of this article. REFERENCES Birch We have shown that regeneration of axons out of the CNS is possible. It is generally accepted that little regeneration occurs after injury to the CNS compared with the peripheral nervous system (PNS). Injury to the latter results in a proliferative response by Schwann cells and other supporting factors. This does was half affecting (Sanders contain very little increased in the by Gamble in human by resecting while not damaging the vertebral place nerve grafts from nerves. In showed regenerhad been divided there is evidence 20 cm from the spinal useful recovery can be after repair of avulsed roots and the results are therefore applicable The significantly repair of probably ment (12 results results which roots which In addition, of reinnervation of muscles cord. These findings confirm that histological be possible (Young of the if surgery that there is carried obtained model spine triangle electrophysiological show repair cervical should soon after an injury avulsed through the intervertebral DISCUSSION The approach neurones R. Advances the supraclavicular in orthopaedics. in diagnosis brachial Edinburgh, and treatment in closed traction lesion of plexus. In: Catterall A, ed. Recent advances etc: Churchill Livingstone, 1992; 65-76. Bonney G. Nerve root, plexus and peripheral nerve Oxbury J, eds. C/inica/ izeuro/ogy. Edinburgh, stone, 1991 :738-66. Carlstedt nerve T. Experimental roots in brachial studies plexus trauma. In: Swash M, etc: Churchill Living- on surgical treatment injury. J Hand Surg of avulsed spinal 1991; 16-B:477-82. Carlstedt T, Linda H, Cullheim S, Risling M. Reinnervation of hind limb muscles after ventral root avulsion and implantation in the lumbar spinal cord of the adult rat. Acta Physio/Scand 1986; 128:645-6. Carlstedt T, Cullheim 5, Risling across the PNS-CNS interface ResBu// 1989; 22:93-102. Chnstophersen J, Wintsch (Ber/) 1977; 4:15-9. M, Ulfhake B. Nerve fibre regeneration at the root-spinal cord junction. Brain K. Nerve grafts in nerve roots. Chir P/astica Cullheim 5, Carlstedt T, Linda H, Risling M, Ulfbake B. Motoneurons reinnervate skeletal muscle after ventral root implantation into the spinal cord ofthe cat. Neuroscience 1989; 29:725-33. Gamble EU. Electron microscope observations on the connective tissues of normal and regenerating spinal nerve roots in the rat. JAnatomy 1963; 97:481. Glasby MA, Gschmeissner SG, Hitchcock RJI, Huang CL-H, de Souza BA. A comparison of nerve regeneration through nerve and muscle grafts in rat sciatic nerve. Neuro Orthopedics 1986a; 2:21-8. THE JOURNAL OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY REPAIR Glasby MA, Gschmeissner SE, Huang muscle grafts used for peripheral Surg[Br] i986b; 11:347-Si. Glasby MA, Gilmour JA, Gschmeissner SE, Hems The repair of large peripheral nerves using skeletal a comparison with cable grafts in the sheep femoral Surg 1990; 43:169-78. Gschmeissner SE, Gattuso JM, Glasby regenerating through freeze-thawed in rats. ClinAnat 1990; 3:107-19. Hems TEJ, Glasby MA. Repair root ganglia: an experimental 1992; 74-B:9i8-22. CL-H, nerve de Souza BA. Degenerated repair in primates. J Hand TEl, Myles LM. muscle autografts: nerve. Br J P/ast MA. Morphology autogenous skeletal of cervical nerve roots study in sheep. J Bone Jamieson AM, Bonney G. An analysis of the operative plexus traction lesions treated between 1956 and Surg[Br] 1979; 61-B:516. Kiernan JA, Contestabile A. Vascular regeneration in the optic system (Ber/) 1980; 51:39-45. OF AVULSED of nerve muscle with regard i:988-90. Lindsay RM. Brain-derived neurotrophic factor: an NGF-related neurotrophin. In: Loughlin SE, Fallon JH, eds. Neurotrophic factors. San Diego, etc: Academic Press, 1993:257-84. VOL. E, Ruoslahti E, et al. Laminin promotes neuritic cultured peripheral and central neurons. J Ce/i Bio/ 76-B, No. 5, SEPTEMBER 1994 823 Moyer EK, Kimmel DL. The repair of severed nerve roots by the arterial sleeve method Neuroi 1948; 88:285-317. Pereira JH, Palande DD, muscle graft in leprosy. Pereira JH, Bowden results of repair to-end suturing.J Risling M, defect spinal toxin. of the fibres grafts with axonal Neuropatho/ ROOTS H. Brachial plexus injury in adults: operative repair. In: Gelberman RH, ed. Operative nerve repair and reconstruction. Vol. 1 . Philadelphia, etc: JB Lippincott, 1991:1285-1301. findings in brachial i978. J Bone Joint permeability associated of the goldfish. Acta NERVE Millesi proximal to the Joint Surg [Br] Kilvington B. An investigation on the regeneration of nerves, to surgical treatment of certain paralyses. Br MedJ 1907; Manthorpe M, Engvall regeneration from 1983; 97:1882-90. CERVICAL Subramanian Lancet 1991a; motor and sensory spinal of anastomosis. J Comp A, et al. Denatured 338:1239-40. REM, Gattuso JM, Norris RW. of digital nerves by denatured muscle HandSurg [Br] 1991b; 16:519-23. autologous Comparison grafts and of end- Sjogren AM, Linda H, et al. Demonstration of a persistent in the blood-brain barrier after ventral root implantation into the cord using immunogold technique and staphylococcal alphaIn: Johansson BB, Owman C, Widner H, eds. Pathophysio/ogy blood-brain barrier. Elsevier, Amsterdam, New York, Oxford, i990:SSS-9. Sanders FI(, diameter Young JZ. of regenerating Sunderland S. Mechanisms the neck and shoulder. The influence nerve fibres. of cervical J Neurosurg Tower 55. Regenerative capacity spinal cord. Arch Neuro/Psychiat Young PH. Posterior ed. Microsurgery 1991:149-58. cervical of the of peripheral connexion on the J Exp Bio/ 1946; 22:203-12. nerve 1974; of ventral 1943; decompressive cervical spine. root avulsion 41:705-14. roots after 49:1-12. in injuries avulsion from of the techniques. In: Young PH, New York: Raven Press,