* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Download Determinants of Duration and Mean Rate of Ventricular Ejection
Management of acute coronary syndrome wikipedia , lookup
Cardiac contractility modulation wikipedia , lookup
Coronary artery disease wikipedia , lookup
Heart failure wikipedia , lookup
Cardiac surgery wikipedia , lookup
Electrocardiography wikipedia , lookup
Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy wikipedia , lookup
Myocardial infarction wikipedia , lookup
Aortic stenosis wikipedia , lookup
Jatene procedure wikipedia , lookup
Mitral insufficiency wikipedia , lookup
Arrhythmogenic right ventricular dysplasia wikipedia , lookup
Determinants of Duration and Mean Rate of Ventricular Ejection By E. BRAUXWALD, M.D., S. J. SABXOFF, M.D. AXT> W. X. STAIXSBY, SC.D. The independent influences of stroke volume, heart rate, aortic pressure, hypothermia, sympathoniiiuetic amines, metered mitral and aortic valvular regurgitation, and alterations in myocardial contractility on the duration and mean rate of ventricular ejection and filling were studied. These observations were made in a metabolically supported, isolated heart preparation with performance characteristics comparable to the nouisolated heart. I Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 18, 2017 T HAS long been recognized that the duration of mechanical ventricular systole is inconstant and is modified by a variety of hemodynamic, physical and humoral influences. It is generally held that mechanical systole is abbreviated by tachycardia 1 " 3 and the administration of sympathomimetic amines, 8 ' 4 and prolonged by an increase in stroke volume 1 ' 8i 4 and by hypothermia. 5 " 7 The effects of an increase in aortic pressure have been inconstant.s> 4> 8 However, in previous studies on the duration of ventricular ejection, the effect of independently altering each pertinent variable while holding the others constant has not been accomplished. The objectives of this investigation were to ascertain the effect on the duration and mean rate of left ventricular ejection of the independent alteration of stroke volume, heart rate, aortic pressure, temperature, cardioactive sympathomimetic amines, and mitral and aortic valvular regurgitation. METHOD The isolated supported heart preparation, the performance characteristics and stability of which have been described in detail elsewhere," was employed. This preparation consists of an isolated dog heart from which all coronary venous blood flows into the venous system of an intact, anesthetized dog which in turn continuously replaces biochemically normal arterial blood into the reservoir of the isolated heart system. The independent augmentation of stroke volume while heart rate WJIH held constant by right atrial stimulation was From the laboratory of Cardiovascular Physiology, National Heart Institute, Bethesda, Md. Received for publication January 3, 1958. achieved by increasing left atrial inflow and adjusting the aortic resistance so as to keep mean aortic pressure constant. Similarly, the independent effect of changes in aortic pressure while maintaining stroke volume and heart rate constant was studied by appropi-iate adjustment of left atrial inflow and of the aortic resistance. The effects of heart rate changes were observed by varying the atrial stimulation rate while maintaining mean aortic pressure and cardiac output constant. The effects of hypothermia were studied by cooling the blood in the reservoir of the isolated, supported heart system while maintaining mean aortic pressure, cardiac output and heart rate constant. The duration of left ventricular ejection was measured from aortic pressure pulses obtained through a catheter in the aortic arch with a Statham P-23D strain gage and generally recorded at 100 mm./sec. paper speeds on a direct-writing oscillograph. Speeds of 50 mm./sec. were occasionally used. The interval between the onset of the rise in aortic pressure and the incisura was taken as the duration of ejection." The mean rate of ventricular ejection in milliliters per second was calculated as the stroke volume in milliliter divided by the duration of systolic ejection in seconds. RESULTS Effects of Changes in Stroke Volume. The effects on the duration and mean rate of ventricular ejection of augmenting stroke volume while holding heart rate, mean aortic pressure and temperature constant are shown in figure 1. An increase in stroke volume was accompanied by an increase in the duration of ejection per beat and per minute. This observed increase, however, was small relative to the increase in stroke volume. Accordingly, the mean rate of ejection was substantially augmented with increases in stroke volume. The Circulation KrMr.areh, Volnmr VI. May 195! BKAUXWALD, SAKXOFP AND STAINSBY 320 STROKE 1 1 / 1 1 / tOO*cJ»«c. T* 200 VOLUME cc I 1 1 Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 18, 2017 / 173 / ISO IZS / i 0 B ^ 7 / --/ / / 13 CO / - y , / 20 1 23 STROKE 1 30 VOLUME 1 1 33 40 4B CC ^ ^ / - - - h / / / / 1 CARDIAC / . OUTPUT 1 . 1 Littrs/mln. Pia. 1 Top. Relationship between stroke volume and tlio duration of systolic ejection per beat in msec. (ordinate) and the consequent influence on the mean rate of ejection {dashed lines) in 1 experiment. Heart rate constant at 115. Mean aortic pressure constant at 100 mm. Hg. Solid dots, value3 obtained at 36.2 C, open circles, values obtained at 30.0 C. Flo. 2 Middle. Influence of heart rate on the relationship between stroke volume and the duration of systolic ejection per beat in msec, (ordinate). Mean aortic pressure constant at 118 mm. Hg. Dashed lines, mean rate of ejection. Heart weight, 209 Gm. Fio. 3 Bottom. Influence of heart rate on the relationship between minute cardiac output and the total duration of systolic ejection in seconds per minute (ordinate). Dashed lines, mean rate of ejection. Same experiment as figure 2. data in figure 1 a r e representative examples of the results in 12 of 13 hearts. Effects of CJianges in Heart Bate. Figures 2 and 3 are representative examples of experiments in 6 hearts. Stroke volume was augmented at each of 3 different heart rates while mean aortic pressure and temperature were held constant. At any given heart rate the duration of ejection per beat was prolonged as stroke volume was augmented, as noted above. However, as can be seen from figure 2, at any given stroke volume, the duration of ejection per beat was shorter at the higher heart rates. The mean rate of ejection with any given stroke volume was, therefore, greater at the higher heart rates. As the heart rate was increased, the shortening of the duration of ejection, however, was small relative to the increase in heart rate; thus, the total duration of ejection per minute was prolonged. The data from the experiment shown in figure 2 were then examined from the point of view of the relationship between cardiac output and the total duration of ventricular ejection per minute (fig. 3). It was observed that, as the heart rate was increased, at any given cardiac output the shortening of the duration of ejection per beat was small relative to the increase in heart rate, and the total duration of ejection per minute was therefore prolonged. The mean rate of ejection was therefore diminished with any given cardiac output at the higher heart rates. Thus, while at any given stroke volume an increased heart rate will shorten the duration of ventricular ejection per beat, at any given cardiac output an increased heart rate will prolong the total duration of ventricular ejection per minute. Comparison of Effects of Changes in Heart Rate and Stroke Volume. Two sets of data from 1 experiment are shown in figure 4. In the first (solid dots), stroke volume was augmented by increasing cardiac output at a constant heart rate while mean aortic pressure was held constant. In the second (open circles), stroke volume was augmented by lowering heart rate while cardiac output and mean aortic pressure were held constant. When stroke volume was augmented by low- 321 VENTRICULAR EJECTION -i Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 18, 2017 ering heart rate, the prolongation of the duration of ejection per beat was substantially greater than when similar increases in stroke volume were induced by augmenting cardiac output at a constant heart rate. The difference iu the slopes of the two lines shown in figure 4 indicates how changes in rate, per se, may modify the relationship between stroke volume and the duration of ejection. These results are representative of those obtaiued in 4 similar experiments. Effects of Increasing Mean Aortic Pressure. Substantial changes in mean aortic pressure had little influence on the duration of ejection in 6 of 7 hearts. As shown in figure 5, the relationship between stroke volume and duration of ejection at a constant heart rate was relatively constant at mean aortic pressures of 75, 100, 125, and 150 mm. Hg. In this range it was repeatedly observed that, when mean aortic pressure was elevated at any given stroke volume and heart rate, no significant change in the duration of ventricular ejection occurred even though filling pressures varied substantially. These observations are not consonant with the views of Wiggers.4 However, it was observed in the 2 experiments in which such observations were made (fig. 5) that when, at a given stroke volume, mean aortic pressure was elevated markedly (175 to 200 mm. Hg 3 ), a lengthening of the duration of ejection did occur. Effects of Temperature. When temperature was progressively decreased while stroke volume, heart rate, cardiac output and mean aortic pressure were held constant, a progressive lengthening of the duration of ejection and a progressive diminution of the mean ejection rate were observed (fig. 6). These data were representative of the experiments in 3 hearts. The effect of temperature on the relationship between stroke volume and the duration of ejection is shown in figure 1. It was observed in 2 experiments in which this relationship was examined that, with mean aortic pressure and heart rate held constant, at any given stroke volume the duration of ejection was substantially longer at the lower temperature. Effects on Duration of Ejection of a De- • 1— 1 i / SOccAtc IOC I 1 1 I 1 / y L /' 0 / -> / 50 /SOccstm / ' / 1 ' ft? / PO 15 / / 20 25 STROKE VOLUME ' 1 ' 1 1 ' 275 - 250 225 200 - 175 i , i 1 10 JO STROKE VOLUME cc TCMPOUTUftC, 0CMCES CCNHOflAOC Fio. 4 Top. Eelative influence on the relationship between stroke volume and duration of ejection per beat in msec, (ordinate) of (a) increasing stroke volume at a constant heart rate by augmenting cardiac output {solid dots) and of (b) increasing stroke volume by lowering heart rate at a constant cardiac output {open circles). Numbers contiguous to the open circles, indicate heart rate. Dashed lines, mean rate of ejection. Heart weight, 352 6m. Fio. 5 Middle. Influence of aortic pressure on the relationship between stroke volume and the duration of ejection per beat in msec, (ordinate). Numbers, the mean aortic pressure at which each set of values was obtained. Heart rate constant at 150. Heart weight, 271 Gm. Fio. 6 Bottom. Relationship between the blood temperature and the duration of ejection per beat in msec, (ordinate) and mean ejection rate. Stroke volume constant at 18.2 ml. Heart rate constant at 115. Mean aortic pressure constant at 100 mm. Hg. BRAUXWALD, SARXOFF AXD STAIXSBY 322 STROKE VOLUME cc Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 18, 2017 Fio. 7. Eelationship between stroke volume and the duration of ejection per beat in msec, (ordinate) (a) in the prosonce of a descending limb on the ventricular function curve (open circles) and (b) after the administration of 5 mg. mephentermine sulfate {solid dots). Xumbers contiguous to points, left ventricular end-diastolie pressure in cm. HiO. Heart rate constant at 160. Mean aortic pressure constant :it 100 nun. Hg. Dashed lines, mean rate of ejection. Heart woight, 222 Gm. scendiiig Limb on the Ventricular Function Curve. In ] experiment evidence of failure was manifest by a depressed ventricular function curve with a descending limb.10 An increase in the duration of ejection accompanied the elevation of filling pressure in spite of the decrease in stroke volume which occurred on the descending limb of the curve. Following the administration of 5 mg. of mephentermine sulfate, an agent which elevates the ventricular function curve and abolishes the descending limb,11 the above noted reversal of the relationship between stroke volume and duration of ejection was abolished; the range of filling pressures was also lowered (fig. 7). Effects of Sympathomimetic Amines. Figure 7 also demonstrates that following the administration of mephentermiue sulfate, at any given stroke volume, the duration of ejection is shorter and mean rate of ejection higher with heart rate and mean aortic pressure constant. This has been treated in detail elsewhere.11 Similar observations were also made with norepiuephrine and nietaraminol. Studies on Duration of Ventricular Ejection in the Xoirisolated Heart. A previously described preparation1- in which the independent control of the pertinent hemodynamic parameters of the in situ heart's performance could be obtained was also employed for the type of analysis illustrated above. In the 4 such nonisolated heart experiments, observations were made on the influence of stroke volume, aortic pressure, heart rate and sympathomimetic drugs. The results were found to be similar to those described. A summary of all results is shown in table 1. Effect of Mitral and, Aortic Regurgitatwn un Duration of Systolic Aortic Ejection. An analysis of data was made from experiments on acutely induced and continuously metered mitral and aortic regurgitation.13'14 In 3 experiments on dogs weighing an average of 25 Kg., mitral regurgitant flows of 2.0 to 4.0 L./min. were induced while forward cardiac output was held constant. This did not influence the duration of ventricular ejection into the aorta. In contrast, in 3 other dogs of similar weight, aortic regurgitant flows of 2.2 to 3.5 L./M. were accompanied by substantial increases in the duration of systolic ejection which were comparable to those observed when total ventricular stroke volume was increased by similar amounts in the absence of regurgitation. DISCUSSION The interpretations derived from previous investigations on the determinants of the duration of systolic ejection are complicated by: (a) the instability of the preparations employed and the consequent difficulty in the use of sequentially obtained data,s (b) lack of direct measurement of stroke volume,1"1 and (c) the lack of independent control of the pertinent hemodynamic parameters.1'7 The isolated, supported heart preparation employed in the above studies is one in which stability, nonfailing performance characteristics, simultaneous measurement and independent control of the required hemodynamic parameters could be achieved.0 In addition, the performance of the isloated heart under study was uninfluenced by neural and humoral factors which, in an intact dog preparation, may be evoked by interventions such as infusion VENTRICULAR EJECTION 323 TABLE 1.—Summary of Observations on Factors Which Modify Duration and Mean Bate of Ventricular Ejection Experimental conditions Intervention Mean aortic pressure Increased stroke volume Increased heart rate Increased heart rate Increased mean aortic pressuret Hypothermia Descending limb V. F. curve Sympathomimetic amines * * A • + Heart rate Stroke volume * A A * * * * * * * * Observation*Cardiac output A A * * * V * Duration ejection (m«eo /beat) A — A A Duration Mean rat** ejection ejection (see./min.) (mJ./syst-sec.) A A A — A A — A A A Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 18, 2017 * Hemodynamic parameters held constant. t See text and figure 5 regarding the effects of markedly elevated mean aortic pressure. and vena caval and aortic compression, maneuvers used in previous investigations.4 These data are of interest in the interpretation of observations on the splitting of the second heart sound in the normal and diseased state. During inspiration the augmentation of right ventricular stroke volume,16 is accompanied by a widening of the interval between aortic and pulmonic valve closure.10'1T This may be bast explained by the effect of such an increase in stroke volume on the demonstrated increase in the duration of ventricular ejection (fig. 1). Similarly, in patients with atrial septal defects, the widened splitting of the second sound is compatible with the known discrepancy between right and left ventricular stroke volumes. Further, the fixation of the interval between aortic and pulmonic valve closure during respiration, a sign detectable by auscultation,17 suggests that in such patients the respiratory phase has little influence on right ventricular stroke volume. In contrast, in patients with patent ductus arteriosus, in whom the stroke volume of the left ventricle exceeds that of the right, abolition or reversal of the normal splitting has been observed.18 The data shown in figure 6 indicate that pronounced elevation of resistance to ventricular pjection results in its prolongation and may help to explain the wideuing of the normal splitting in pulmonic stenosis19 and the observed abolition and even reversal of the normal splitting in aortic steno18 sis. It is self-evident that, with the exception of the slight changes in the duration of isometric contraction and relaxation which might occur,4 those factors modifying the duration and mean rate of ventricular ejection have a reciprocal influence on the duration and mean rate of ventricular filling. One interesting implication of this relates to the dynamic alterations accompanying mitral or tricuspid stenosis. In addition to the well-appreciated effect of heart rate on the time available for mitral valve flow, it becomes evident that an increase in stroke volume at any given heart rate will produce an elevation of the pressure gradient across the valve. This would result not only from the increased flow, per se, but also because of the encroachment on the length of diastole resulting from the increased duration of ventricular ejection (fig. 1). The experiments described may also be helpful in the analysis of factors influencing coronary flow in the presence of coronary artery disease. Under these circumstances the influence of the metabolic factors which normally regulate coronary vascular resistance12' 20' 21 would seem to be largely obviated by the change in the locus of the critical resistance element from the adjustable arteriole to an artery with a fixed orifice. When this is the case, coronary flow is determined principally or solely by hydraulic factors, prominent among which is the time available for flow, i.e., the duration of diastole.20 It would appear that tachycardia, an in- BRAUNWALD, SARNOFF AND STAINSBY 324 Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 18, 2017 crease in stroke volume, the presence of a depressed ventricular function curve and/or a descending limb, hypothermia and markedly elevated systolic pressures each prolong the duration of ventricular ejection per minute and thereby reciprocally diminish the time per minute available for coronary flow. Although it has been demonstrated that an isolated increase in stroke volume does not, of itself, substantially augment the myocardial oxygen requirement21 or coronary flow,12 the manifestations of myocardial hypoxia with an increased stroke volume when coronary artery disease is present can be at least partially explained by the decrease in time available for coronary flow (fig. 1). An accompanying tachycardia not only augments the myocardial oxygen requirement21 but would also intensify the flow time limitation by further prolonging the duration of systole per minute (fig. 3). On the basis of considerations deriving from Laplace's law,21'22 it is clear that, with any given rate of development of myocardial wall tension, the rate of development of intraventricular pressure will be a function of the ventricular radius. The duration of ejection at any given stroke volume is, in the final analysis, a function of the rate of development of the intraventricular pressure. "When the ventricle is on the ascending limb of its ventricular function curve,10 an increase in the end-diastolic fiber length is accompanied not only by an increase in the force of contraction8 but also by an increase in its rate. This is evidenced by the higher mean ejection rates that accompany augmented stroke volumes (fig. 1) and tends to counteract any prolongation of ejection brought about by the increase in radius, per se. However, should a further increase in radius and fiber length bring the ventricle onto the descending limb of its function curve and a decline in both the force of contraction and mean rate of ejection occur, a consequent substantial prolongation of the duration of ventricular ejection takes place even though stroke volume declines (fig. 7). SUMMAHT A systematic investigation of factors influencing the duration and mean rate of both left ventricular ejection and filling was made in a stable, isolated heart preparation with performance characteristics comparable to those of the in situ heart. An increase in stroke volume alone lengthens the duration of ventricular ejection and increases the mean rate of ejection. An increase in heart rate alone at any given stroke volume shortens the duration of ejection per beat, prolongs the duration of ejection per minute and increases the mean rate of ejection. An increase in heart rate at a constant cardiac output greatly shortens the duration of ejection per beat, lowers the rate of ejection but prolongs the duration of ejection per minute. An increase in mean aortic pressure alone has little influence on either the duration of ventricular ejection until markedly elevated mean aortic pressures are reached. Under such circumstances, duration of ejection is lengthened and the mean rate of ejection decreased. Hypothermia alone prolongs the duration of ejection while sympathoniimetic amines have the opposite effect. Unlike the nonfailing heart, the failing heart exhibits an increase in the duration of ejection as stroke volume declines on the descending limb of its ventricular function curve. The clinical implications of these observations were discussed. SUMMABtO IN INTERLINGUA Un investigation systematic del factores que influentia le duration e le intensitate medie del ejection e del replenation sinistroventricular esseva excutate in un stabile prcparato de corde isolate con characteristicas de performance comparabile a illos de un corde in sito. Un augmento del volumine per pulso sol prolonga le duration del ejection ventricular e accelera le valor medie del ejection. Un augmento del frequentia del corde so, a non importa qual volumine per pulso, reduce le duration del ejection per pulso, prolonga le duration del ejection per minuta, e accelera le valor medie del ejection. Un augmento del frequentia del corde a nn constante rendimento cardiac reduce grandemente le duration del ejection per pulso, relenta le intensitate del ejection, sed prolonga le duration del ejection per minuta. Un augmento del pression VEXTRICULAR EJECTION Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 18, 2017 aortic medie sol ha pauc influentia super le duration e super le intensitate del ejection ventricular usque marcate elevationes del pression aortic medie es attingite. Alora le duration del ejection es prolongate e le intensitate medie del ejection es reducite. Hypothermia sol prolonga le duration del ejection durante que aminas sympathomimetic ha un effecto contrari. Per contrasto con le corde in stato de non-fallimento, le corde in stato de fallimento exhibi un augmento del duration del ejection quando le voluuiine per pulso se reduce al latere descendente de su curva de function ventricular. Le signification clinic de iste observationes es discutite. 325 I. Starling's law of the heart studied by means of simultaneous right and left ventricular function curves in the dog. Circulation 9: 706, 1954. 11. WELCH, G. H., JR., BRAUNWALD, E., CASE, R. B., AND SABNOFF, S. J.: The effect of mephentermine sulfate (Wyamine) on myocardial oxygen consumption, myocardial efficiency and peripheral vascular resistance. Am. J. Med. In press. 12. BRAUNWALD, E., SARNOFF, S. J., CASE, R. B., STAINSBY, W. N., AND WELCH, G. H., JR. Hemodynamic determinants of coronary flow: Effects of changes in aortic pressure and cardiac output on the relationship between myocardial oxygen consumption and coronary flow. Am. J. Physiol. 192: 157163, 1958. 13. BRAUNWALD, E., WELCH, G. H., JR., AND SABNOFF, S. J.: The hemodynamic effects of REFERENCES 1. LOMBARD, W. P. AND COPE, 0. M.: Effect of posture on the length of the systole of the human heart. Am. J. Physiol. 49: 140, 1919. 2. WIGGERS, C. J. AND KATZ, L. N.: The specific influence of the accelerator nerves on the duration of ventricular systole. Am. J. Physiol. 53: 49, 1920. 3. REMINGTON, J. W., HAMILTON, W. F., AND AHLQUIST, R. P . : Interrelation between the length of systole, stroke volume and left ventricular work in the dog. Am. J. Physiol. 154: 6, 1948. 4. WIGGERS, C. J.: Studies on the consecutive phases of the cardiac cycle: II. The laws governing the relative durations of ventricular systole and diastole. Am. J. Physiol. 56: 439, 1921. 5. HEGNAUER, A. M., SHRIBER, W. J., AND HATERIUS, H. D.: Cardiovascular response of the dog to immersion hypothermia. Am. J. Physiol. 161: 455, 1950. 6. BERNE, R. M.: Myocardial function in severe hypothermia. Circulation Research 2: 90, 1954. 7. CORDI, L.: Functional changes of the heart during hypothermia. Angiology 7: 171, 1956. 8. PATTERSON, S. W., PIPER, H., AND STARLING, E. H.: The regulation of the heart beat. J. Physiol. 48: 465, 1914. 9. SARNOFF, S. J., CASE, R. B., WELCH, G. H., JR., BRAUNWALD, E., AND STAINSBY, W. X. : Observations on the performance characteristics and oxygen debt in a non-failing, metabolically supported isolated heart preparation. Am. J. Physiol. In press. 10. — AND BEHOLUND, E.: Ventricular function : quantitatively varied experimental mitral regurgitation. Circulation Research 5: 539, 1957. 14. WELCH, G. H., JR., BRAUNWALD, E., AND SARNOFF, S. J.: The hemodynamic effects of quantitatively varied experimental aortic regurgitation. Circulation Research 5: 546, 1957. 15. BRECHER, G. H. AND HUBAT, C. A.: Pulmonary blood flow and venous return during spontaneous respiration. Circulation Research 3: 210, 1955. 16. BRAUNWALD, E., FISHMAN, A. P., AND COUHNAND, H.: Time relationship of dynamic events in the cardiac chambers, pulmonary artery and aorta in man. Circulation Research 4: 100, 1956. 17. LEATHAM, A. AND GRAY, I. R.: Auscultatory and phonocardiographic signs of atrial septal defect. Brit. Heart J. 18: 193, 1956. 18. GRAY, I. R.: Paradoxical splitting of the second heart sound. Brit. Heart J. 18: 21, 1956. 19. LEATHAM, A., AND WETTZMAN, D.: Ausculta- tory and phonocardiographic signs of pulmonary stenosis. Brit. Heart J. 19: 303, 1957. 20. GREGG, D. E.: Coronary Circulation in Health and Disease. Philadelphia, Lea & Febriger, 1950, p. 98. 21. SARNOFF, S. J., BRAUNWALD, E., WELCH, G. H., JR., CASE, R. B., STAINSBY, W. X., AND MACRUZ, R.: The hemodynamic determinants of the oxygen consumption of the heart with special reference to the tension-time index. Am. J. Physiol. 192: 148-156, 1958. 22. WOODS, R. H.: A few applications of a physical theorem to membranes in the human body in a state of tension. J. Anat. & Physiol. 26: 362, 1891-92. Determinants of Duration and Mean Rate of Ventricular Ejection E. BRAUNWALD, S. J. SARNOFF and W. N. STAINSBY Downloaded from http://circres.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 18, 2017 Circ Res. 1958;6:319-325 doi: 10.1161/01.RES.6.3.319 Circulation Research is published by the American Heart Association, 7272 Greenville Avenue, Dallas, TX 75231 Copyright © 1958 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Print ISSN: 0009-7330. Online ISSN: 1524-4571 The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on the World Wide Web at: http://circres.ahajournals.org/content/6/3/319 Permissions: Requests for permissions to reproduce figures, tables, or portions of articles originally published in Circulation Research can be obtained via RightsLink, a service of the Copyright Clearance Center, not the Editorial Office. Once the online version of the published article for which permission is being requested is located, click Request Permissions in the middle column of the Web page under Services. Further information about this process is available in the Permissions and Rights Question and Answer document. Reprints: Information about reprints can be found online at: http://www.lww.com/reprints Subscriptions: Information about subscribing to Circulation Research is online at: http://circres.ahajournals.org//subscriptions/