* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Download View PDF - CiteSeerX
Survey
Document related concepts
Transcript
THE PERIODIC SYSTEM 139 number of electrons in the outermost ring. As mentioned, whereas Thomsonâs structures did not claim to represent real atoms, those proposed by Bohr were realistic models. Also with regard to method and approach, the two physicists differed. Thomsonâs theory was, or can be regarded as, an attempt to establish a deductive or âmathematical chemistryâ, at least in principle.5 His electron structures were the result of calculations, and empirical considerations of the properties of elements did not enter. Bohr, on the other hand, was well aware that he could not do without empirical input. In spite of what he told in his letter to Oseen, his theory of the periodic system was not obtained âdeductivelyâ. As he admitted, physical principles, whether classical or based on the new quantum theory, â[are] in most cases not sufficient to determine completely the constitution of the systemâ (ibid.: p. 198). He therefore followed an eclectic methodology, freely mixing mathematical calculations and general principles with knowledge of the physical and chemical properties of the elements. The latter considerations were no less important than the first, and if the two approaches collided he usually gave priority to the results suggested by empirical knowledge. This particular eclecticism was not only a characteristic methodological feature in Bohrâs 1913 theory, but also in his later theory of 1922 (Kragh, 1979). 5. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS The historical roots of the modern theory of atomic structure are to be found not only in the development of physics, but also in the development of chemistry. Among the chemical phenomena that have influenced atomic theory, the periodic system of the elements is perhaps the most important. The existence of regularities in the properties of the elements, such as summarised in the periodic table, was a source of puzzle as well as inspiration to many scientists who wanted to know the underlying mechanisms and causes they assumed to exist. Mendeleevâs classification scheme played a heuristic role in early views of atomic structure: a good atomic theory was expected to give some kind of explanation of the periodic system, or, at least, be consistent with it. Of course, an atomic model could not be derived from the periodic system alone and then be