* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Download Can we detect asteroid impacts with rocky extrasolar planets?
Cassiopeia (constellation) wikipedia , lookup
Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems wikipedia , lookup
Geocentric model wikipedia , lookup
Outer space wikipedia , lookup
Fermi paradox wikipedia , lookup
Aries (constellation) wikipedia , lookup
Definition of planet wikipedia , lookup
IAU definition of planet wikipedia , lookup
Perseus (constellation) wikipedia , lookup
History of astronomy wikipedia , lookup
Cygnus (constellation) wikipedia , lookup
Astrobiology wikipedia , lookup
History of Solar System formation and evolution hypotheses wikipedia , lookup
Observational astronomy wikipedia , lookup
Malmquist bias wikipedia , lookup
Astronomical unit wikipedia , lookup
Solar System wikipedia , lookup
Rare Earth hypothesis wikipedia , lookup
Corvus (constellation) wikipedia , lookup
Formation and evolution of the Solar System wikipedia , lookup
Comparative planetary science wikipedia , lookup
Planetary habitability wikipedia , lookup
B612 Foundation wikipedia , lookup
Extraterrestrial life wikipedia , lookup
Aquarius (constellation) wikipedia , lookup
The Space Review: Can we detect asteroid impacts with rock... http://www.thespacereview.com/article/761/1 Search Subscribe Enter your email address below to be notified when new articles are published: subscribe our privacy policy Giant impacts on exoplanets might be detectable from Earth, providing another means to study these worlds. (credit: Don Davis/NASA) Can we detect asteroid impacts with rocky extrasolar planets? by Michael Paine Monday, December 11, 2006 Caution: This article contains speculation, ballpark estimates, mathematics, and tables! Sixty-five million years ago a chunk of rock and ice perhaps 15 kilometers across collided with the Earth and wiped out many creatures, including the dinosaurs. This impact, known as the Chicxulub impact, must have created a spectacular flash. Was it bright enough to be detected as far away as Sirius? How many impacts like this are occurring in our region of the Milky Way? Have we any chance of detecting these impacts? These questions can be answered, in part, with a little mathematics, a few facts from astronomy and the audacity to assume that our solar system is “typical”. In 1994 astronomer Alan Stern asked a similar question and evaluated the detection of newly formed planets that were still glowing red hot from the accretion process. He 1 of 6 10/12/12 1:23 PM The Space Review: Can we detect asteroid impacts with rock... http://www.thespacereview.com/article/761/1 also calculated the detectability of giant impacts with planets like Neptune. Building on this work, let us consider the effects of a Chicxulub-size impact with planets similar to the Earth. Impact frequency The Earth suffers a Chicxulub-size impact every 100 million years or so. There are four rocky planets in our solar system, so we can expect one to be hit every 25 million years. However, half of these impacts will be on the side facing away from the Earth so a visible impact occurs, on average, once every 50 million years. During the first billion years of our solar system, though, the impact rate was at least 1,000 times as intensive as the present rate. This means the average rate over the four-billion-year life of the solar system is some 250 times the current rate, or one impact every 200,000 years. Number of stars in our region of the solar system It is about four light-years to the nearest star beyond our Sun, but that is fairly close compared with most stars. On average there is about one star for every 500 cubic light-years of space. This does not seem like much, but distance raised to the third power quickly produces large numbers: Radius of sphere (lightyears) 10 100 1000 Volume Average Number (cubic light frequency of of stars years) impact events 4200 8 26,000 years 4.2 million 8,000 26 years 4.2 billion 8 million 1.5 weeks So if we could detect a Chicxulub-size impact from 1,000 light-years away then it should only take a few weeks of observations to find one. The impact fireball The impact of an asteroid (or comet) into the surface of a rocky planet typically generates a hemispherical fireball with a diameter some 14 times the diameter of the 2 of 6 10/12/12 1:23 PM The Space Review: Can we detect asteroid impacts with rock... http://www.thespacereview.com/article/761/1 asteroid. This means the Chicxulub fireball was about 200 kilometers in diameter (and, as it happens, the Chicxulub crater has a similar diameter.) When fully expanded, the This impact, known as the Chicxulub temperature of the gases in the impact, must have fireball are about twice the surface created a temperature of our Sun, or about spectacular flash. Was it bright 12,000 kelvins. It is also enough to be detected as far convenient to compare the away as Sirius? How luminosity of the fireball with that many impacts like this are occurring of the Sun. This, in turn, can be in our region of the used to compare brightness at a Milky Way? distance. The relative luminosity, or ratio of the fireball luminosity to the Sun’s luminosity, is proportional to the square of the diameter ratio and the fourth power of the temperature ratio: Relative luminosity = (Fireball diameter/Sun diameter)2 x (Fireball temperature/Sun temperature)4 The Chicxulub fireball works out as having a relative luminosity of 3.6x10-7 (that is one divided by about three million) so the task of detecting the event a long way from our solar system seems daunting. However, that is not the end of the bad news. The fireball tends to mask itself so that not all of the light is emitted. This emissivity can drop to one percent or less depending on the characteristics of the impact. The good news is that Venus has a luminosity that is about one billionth of that of the Sun, so if we can detect a Venus-like planet around another star then it is likely that we could detect a Chicxulub impact, provided the detection system was fast enough to record a fireball that lasts about a minute. There might also be other, more effective ways to detect the complex radiation from these impacts but this analysis is confined to visible light. Detection from a distance The apparent brightness of stars is measured as “magnitude”. Magnitude is a type of reverse logarithmic scale. One interval of magnitude corresponds with a brightness decrease of a factor of 2.5. The faintest 3 of 6 10/12/12 1:23 PM The Space Review: Can we detect asteroid impacts with rock... http://www.thespacereview.com/article/761/1 naked-eye star has a magnitude of about 6.5. Sirius has a magnitude of –1.4. For the purpose of comparing the brightness of stars an absolute magnitude is used and is based on the brightness of the star if it was viewed from about 32 light-years away (10 “parsecs”). We now have enough information to take a guess at the apparent magnitude of a Chicxulub-size impact at various distances: Apparent Magnitude of Chicxulub Impact for Various Emissivities Observer’s distance (light years) Object Relative Absolute 100 1000 10 ly (emissivity) Luminosity Magnitude ly ly Chicxulub 20.9 19.7 22.2 24.7 3.6x10-7 (100%) Chicxulub 22.7 21.4 23.9 26.4 7.2x10-8 (20%) Chicxulub 25.9 24.7 27.2 29.7 3.6x10-9 (1%) Sun 1 4.8 3.6 6.1 8.6 Venus 1.16x10-9 27.2 25.9 28.4 30.9 Typical Spaceguard telescope systems (looking for near-Earth asteroids) have a limiting magnitude (detection threshold) of about 21 for a 100-second exposure. Therefore a Chicxulub-size impact viewed from 10 light-years away would be barely detectable (20.9), even at 100% emissivity. It seems that the Spaceguard system has no chance of detecting an extrasolar impact. Telescopes are currently being The detection of extrasolar impacts developed that will look at large would give scientist areas of the sky for transient a better idea of astrophysical events. For example, whether our solar system was typical. NASA’s Swift spacecraft recently In particular it detected a giant stellar flare some would be an indicator of the 135 light-years away. These new presence of other rocky planets. telescopes should have greater sensitivity than the Spaceguard telescopes (many of which are hand-me-downs). It is 4 of 6 10/12/12 1:23 PM The Space Review: Can we detect asteroid impacts with rock... http://www.thespacereview.com/article/761/1 therefore possible that one of these new systems will eventually come across a major extrasolar impact. So what: why bother with extra-solar impacts? First of all, astronomers looking for other types of transient events should be aware that they may, serendipitously come across an impact event. They should understand the likely signatures of impact events. The detection of extrasolar impacts would give scientist a better idea of whether our solar system was typical. In particular it would be an indicator of the presence of other rocky planets. The characteristics of the impact flash might also reveal the chemistry of the surface of the planet, just like the Deep Impact mission that collided with comet Tempel 1 in July 2005. Finally, the detection of these events would give a better understanding of the role that impacts play in the evolution of planetary surfaces and, perhaps, the evolution of life on those planets. Bibliography and acknowledgements Bondi, H, 1970, “Astronomy of the Future”, Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society, Vol. 11, p.443 (astronomy of the day was missing transient events) Collins G, Melosh H and Marcus R, 2005, “Earth Impact Effects Program: A Web-based computer program for calculating the regional environmental consequences of a meteoroid impact on Earth”, Meteoritics & Planetary Science Vol.40 No. 6, pp817–840. Harris A, 1998, “Evaluation of ground-based optical surveys for near-Earth asteroids”, Planet. Space Sci. Vol. 46 No. 2/3, pp283-290. Lewis J, 2000, Comet and asteroid impact hazards on a populated Earth, Academic Press. Stern A, 1004, “The detectability of extrasolar terrestrial and giant planets during their luminous final accretion”, The Astronomical Journal, Vol. 108 No. 6, pp2312-2317. 5 of 6 10/12/12 1:23 PM The Space Review: Can we detect asteroid impacts with rock... http://www.thespacereview.com/article/761/1 Thanks to Duncan Steel, Paul Davies, John Lewis, Alan Stern and Jay Melosh for advice on this topic. Michael Paine ([email protected]) is a consulting mechanical engineer based in Sydney. He maintains the web pages of the Planetary Society Australian Volunteers and has been lobbying the Australian government about the Spaceguard issue since funding was stopped in 1996. Home 6 of 6 10/12/12 1:23 PM