Download Dimensioning a UPS for LED crest factor

Dimensioning a UPS/Inverter for LED crest factor
UPS and inverter backup units can be classified in two main categories, true sine wave and “quasi”
or “simulated” sine output and are usually specified by their VA and Watt rating.
Oscillogram 1 shows the voltage (red) and load current (yellow) of typical 600VA “quasi-sine” UPS
with 10x Verbatim 8.5W GU10 LED’s (#52310) without a dimmer – notice the 360V peak voltage
produced by the UPS! The discontinuous voltage output of the UPS causes severe lamp instability
when operated with a typical leading edge dimmer, shown in Oscillogram 2 and such UPS systems
should thus be avoided when dimming LED’s.
Problems can however be experienced when dimming LED’s operating from a pure sine UPS due
to an obscure parameter known as the load Crest Factor (CF). The CF which is typically rated at
3:1 for most UPS and inverter units, is the ratio of load peak current to the RMS current.
Illustration 1 for instance shows two loads which consume exactly the same power and have the
same RMS current, but the blue waveform has a CF of 1.414 (pure resistive load) and the red
waveform’s CF is 4.24. The large peak current of the high crest factor in the example clearly
shows that “more current” is required from the UPS than for the blue waveform, which requires an
associated de-rating of the UPS.
LED lamps can have large crest factors when not being dimmed, but when dimming with phase cut
dimmers, the crest factors can be extremely large. Illustration 2 shows the measured maximum
crest factors of 241 different dimmable LED models with a Shuttle trailing edge LED dimmer, some
have a crest factor as high as 25. Leading edge dimming however usually results in a much higher
crest factor, up to 46 in cases as is shown in the measured results of Illustration 3.
Such
extremely large crest factors implies a very large current rise or fall time which can further reduce
the “usable” VA’s of UPS or inverter.
To demonstrate this phenomena, a professional double conversion true sine wave 2000VA/1800W
UPS was employed to power the 10 Verbatim LED’s. The UPS has a load CF rating of 3:1 and is
capable of delivering 8.7 Amp RMS with a unity power factor load (thus CF of 1.414). The peak
current available is thus 12.3 Amp and taking the crest factor into account, the UPS can deliver a
maximum current of 26 Amp (obviously with reduced load wattage). Oscillogram 3 shows the
measured load voltage and current when the LED’s are dimmed with a trailing edge dimmer. The
lamp peak current is approximately 0.5A resulting in a maximum CF of 2.22 and the lamps have
stable dimming performance.
When employing a classical triac based leading edge dimmer with the same UPS and lamps, the
results change drastically: severe lamp flicker occurs with 85W of LED lamps on a 2000VA UPS!
Oscillogram 4 reveals the origin of the flicker: the dimmer turns on, but then the voltage from the
UPS falls away and starts up again. The lamp peak current is approximately 13.2A resulting in a
maximum CF of 11.8 (notice the difference in current scales between Oscillograms 3 and 4). The
UPS is thus unable to sustain the large peak current although it is well within the specification of
the particular model. The reason for this is due to the very sharp load current rise time of
approximately 130 000 Amp per second which exceeds the maximum load current rise time of
approximately 120 kA/s for the particular model. Above this limit, the UPS is unable to sustain
stable output voltage.
The choice of UPS, dimmer and LED model thus directly impacts the maximum rating of the UPS,
while the dimensioning of a UPS backup for LED’s, especially with leading edge dimmers, must not
only take the maximum crest factor into account, but also the current rise time.
Alex Cremer (Verbatim SA) 011 253 4940
MC Smit (Shuttle Lighting) 082465 2299
1/5
Illustration 1: These two waveforms both have a RMS current of 5 A, but their crest factors
are very different.(source: Ametek)
2/5
25.00
20.00
15.00
10.00
5.00
0.00
Illustration 2: Measured Crest Factor of 241 LED's with trailing edge dimming
50.00
45.00
40.00
35.00
30.00
25.00
20.00
15.00
10.00
5.00
0.00
Illustration 3: Measured Crest Factor of 46 LED's with leading edge dimming
3/5
Oscillogram 1: 10x LED's on a "quasi sine" UPS - no dimmer (LED shimmer encountered)
Time scale: 2.5ms/div. Voltage (red): 100V/div, Current (yellow): 1 Amp/div
Oscillogram 2: 10x LED's on a "quasi sine" UPS and 600W leading edge dimmer
(extremely poor performance and the risk of LED and dimmer failure)
Time scale: 2.5ms/div. Voltage (red): 100V/div, Current (yellow): 2 Amp/div
4/5
Oscillogram 3: 10x LED's on a true sine UPS with a Shuttle Trailing edge dimmer
Stable dimming performance
Time scale: 2.5ms/div. Voltage (red): 100V/div, Current (yellow): 1 Amp/div
Oscillogram 4: 10x Verbatim LED's on a true sine UPS with a triac Leading edge
dimmer (approximately 50% intensity)
Notice the dip in the voltage waveform which causes lamp flicker
Time scale: 2.5ms/div. Voltage (red): 100V/div, Current (yellow): 5 Amp/div
5/5