Download How Hard is Artificial Intelligence? Evolutionary

Survey
yes no Was this document useful for you?
   Thank you for your participation!

* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project

Document related concepts

Technological singularity wikipedia , lookup

History of artificial intelligence wikipedia , lookup

Ethics of artificial intelligence wikipedia , lookup

Philosophy of artificial intelligence wikipedia , lookup

Existential risk from artificial general intelligence wikipedia , lookup

Intelligence explosion wikipedia , lookup

Transcript
We have various methods available to begin to estimate the power of evolutionary search on Earth:
estimating the number of generations and population sizes available to human evolution3, creating
mathematical models of evolutionary “speed limits” under various conditions4, and using genomics to
measure past rates of evolutionary change.5 However, reliable creation of human-level intelligence
through evolution might require trials on many planets in parallel, with Earth being one of the lucky few
to succeed. Can the fact of human evolution on Earth let us distinguish between the following scenarios?
Non-hard Intelligence: There is a smooth path of incremental improvement from the simplest
primitive nervous systems to brains capable of human-level intelligence, reflecting the existence
of many simple, easily-discoverable algorithms for intelligence. On most planets with life,
human-level intelligence also develops.
Hard Intelligence: Workable algorithms for intelligence are rare, without smooth paths of
incremental improvement to human-level performance. Evolution requires extraordinary luck to
hit upon a design for human-level intelligence, so that only 1 in 101000 planets with life does so.
In either scenario every newly evolved civilization will find that evolution managed to produce its
ancestors. The observation selection effect is that no matter how hard it is for human-level intelligence to
evolve, 100% of evolved civilizations will find themselves originating from planets where it happened
anyway.
How confident can we be that Hard Intelligence is false, and that premise (2’) in the evolutionary
arguments can be supported, in the face of such selection effects? After a brief treatment of premise (3’’),
we discuss the theoretical approaches in the philosophical literature, particularly the Self-Sampling
Assumption (SSA) and the Self-Indication Assumption (SIA)—because, unfortunately, correctly
analyzing the evidence on evolution depends on difficult, unsettled questions concerning observerselection effects.6 We note that one common set of philosophical assumptions (SIA) supports easy
evolution of intelligence, but that it does so on almost a priori grounds that some may find objectionable.
Common alternatives to SIA, on the other hand, require us to more carefully weigh the evolutionary data.
We attempt this assessment, discussing several types of evidence which hold up in the face of observation
selection effects. We find that while more research is needed, the thesis that “intelligence is exceedingly
hard to evolve” is consistent with the available evolutionary data under these alternative assumptions.
However, the data do rule out many particular hypotheses under which intelligence might be exceedingly
hard to evolve, and thus the evolutionary argument should still increase our credence in the feasibility of
human-level AI.
2. Computational requirements for recapitulating evolution through genetic algorithms
3
Baum (2004) very roughly estimates that between 1030 and 1040 creatures have existed on Earth, in the
course of arguing that evolutionary search could not have relied on brute force to search the space of
possible genomes. However, Baum does not consider the implications of an ensemble of planets in his
calculation.
4
For instance, MacKay (2009) computes information-theoretic upper bounds to the power of natural
selection with and without sex in a simple additive model of fitness.
5
See, e.g., Hawks et al. (2007) on recently accelerating adaptive selection in humans, including
comparison of adaptive substitution rates in different primate lineages.
6
See Grace (2010) for a helpful review of these questions and prominent approaches.
4