Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
2 Early Embryonic Cell Cycle Many biological processes are best studied in cells that are specialized for particular tasks. For example, studies on nerve cells have been the principal route to understanding the electrical properties of cells, and studies on muscle provided the foundation of our knowledge about how chemical energy is converted into movement. Because eggs are specialized for rapid cell division, it is not surprising that studies of them have made a fundamental contribution to unraveling the mysteries of the cell cycle. Nineteenth-century biologists first appreciated the advantages of eggs for studying the cell cycle, and they meticulously observed and beautifully described the early embryonic cell cycles of marine invertebrate and amphibian eggs. They recognized the division of the cell cycle into interphase and mitosis, and their observations on mitosis were remarkably accurate (Figure 2-1). But because at that time there was no way to appreciate (much less understand) the biochemical events that occurred in interphase, their discussions concentrated on the mechanics of mitosis and rarely speculated on the cell cycle as a whole. In the first half of the twentieth century, interest in eggs as experimental systems gradually declined, reflecting the inability to extend observations from microscopy to biochemistry. During the 1960s, however, progress in biochemical analysis and reproductive physiology, together with the invention of techniques to inject materials into living cells, led to a resurgence in the use of eggs for studying the cell cycle. Since then, experiments on eggs have contributed enormously to our knowledge of the cell cycle. Initially the techniques for injecting materials were useful only with very large cells, making frog eggs excellent subjects for analyzing the early embryonic cell cycle. The most widely used source of eggs is the South African clawed frog, Xenopus laevis. This chapter describes studies on frog eggs that identified the major inducer of mitosis and led to the idea that a simple biochemical oscillator drives the cell cycle. EMBRYONIC CELL CYCLES The eggs of amphibians, marine invertebrates, and insects are large cells that can divide very rapidly. A female frog can produce several thousand eggs, each 1 mm in diameter, that can be fertilized in vitro to produce a large population of cells that proceed synchronously through several cell cycles. The first cell cycle lasts 75 minutes and is followed by 11 synchronous cell cycles, each 30 minutes long (Figure 2-2). These divisions convert the originally solid egg into a hollow ball of cells, called the blastula, which then undergoes complex changes in shape that produce a recognizable embryo (Figure 2-3). In early embryonic cell cycles, G1 and G2 are largely suppressed, and the cycle consists essentially of a regular alternation of extremely rapid DNA replication and mitosis (see Figure 2-1). After the twelfth mitosis the cell cycle slows, and the synchrony between neighboring cells breaks down. In this book "cell cycle:early embryonic" refers only to these early, rapid, synchronous cell cycles. cell cycle:early embryonic The ability of eggs to divide without growing explains why early embryonic cell cycles are faster than somatic cell cycles. Somatic cells are born small and must import nutrients so that they can grow and duplicate all the components of the cell. Eggs, however, are large and inherit from their mothers a stock of nutrients, all the structural components of the cell, and almost all the enzymes that catalyze the processes of the cell cycle. As a result, apart from replicating their DNA, early embryonic cells have to produce only a handful of new components to proceed through a cell cycle that has been stripped to its bare essentials. Progesterone induces frog oocytes to enter meiosis and become unfertilized eggs The cells that give rise to eggs are called oocytes and begin life at the same size as typical somatic cells. Shortly after birth, oocytes replicate their DNA and then arrest in G2 for about 8 months as the cells grow to a diameter of 1 mm and stockpile the materials needed for the early embryonic cell cycles. To give rise to an egg, the fully grown oocyte must halve its chromosome number to convert itself from a diploid to a haploid cell so that fusion with a haploid sperm will produce a diploid embryo. The oocyte produces a haploid egg by going through the meiotic cell cycle, in which two rounds of chromosome segregation follow a single round of DNA replication . When female frogs are appropriately stimulated, the small cells that surround the oocyte secrete progesterone. This hormone acts on the oocyte, leading to nuclear envelope breakdown, chromosome condensation, and the assembly of the meiosis I spindle (Figure 2-4). The process takes about 5 hours, culminating in chromosome segregation and a highly asymmetrical cell division that expels half the chromosomes into a small cell known as the first polar body. The oocyte immediately enters meiosis II but arrests in metaphase for several hours as it travels through the oviduct of the frog to emerge as an unfertilized egg. Fertilization releases eggs from their metaphase arrest, allowing them to pass through anaphase of meiosis II, produce a second polar body and enter interphase of the first mitotic cell cycle. The events that convert fully grown oocytes into unfertilized eggs are known as meiotic maturation and can be studied in vitro by adding progesterone to oocytes that have been surgically removed from female frogs. Although several important differences exist between the meiotic and mitotic cell cycles (see Chapter 10), studies on the meiotic cell cycle were what first identified the key factor that controls both the meiotic and mitotic cell cycles. Cytoplasmic transfer experiments reveal a maturation promoting factor (MPF) that induces meiosis The mammalian cell fusion experiments described in Chapter 1 showed that mitosis dominates other states in the cell cycle. A similar result was obtained in frog experiments, in which the transfer of cytoplasm from eggs to oocytes demonstrated that meiosis is dominant to interphase. Isolated oocytes were treated with progesterone to induce them to mature into unfertilized eggs. remove about 5% A hollow microneedle was used to of the cytoplasm from an egg and inject it into an oocyte. The recipient oocyte matured as if it had been treated with progesterone (Figure 2-5). The injected oocytes that had matured were then used as cytoplasmic donors to inject fresh oocytes. This second round of recipients also matured, and they could in turn act as donors of cytoplasm that induced yet another round of recipient oocytes to mature. The ability to perform many such successive transfers showed that whatever promotes maturation is a component of the unfertilized egg, rather than progesterone carried over from the initial hormonally matured oocyte. For obvious reasons, the activity that induces maturation was called Maturation Promoting Factor (MPF). MPF can also stand for mitosis and meiosis promoting factor, a name that more generally describes its role in the cell cycle. Progesterone induces MPF activation and nuclear envelope breakdown only if the treated oocytes are allowed to synthesize proteins. containing cytoplasm, however, Injecting MPFinduces maturation even if protein synthesis in the recipient oocyte is inhibited. This observation implies that oocytes must contain molecules, called pre-MPF, that can be converted into active MPF by a series of posttranslational reactions. MPF activation is a purely cytoplasmic process, since oocytes whose nuclei have been removed still produce active MPF when treated with progesterone. Thus, even though MPF regulates the fate of the nucleus, the nucleus is not required for the activation of MPF. Progesterone In fertilized eggs the activation of MPF requires protein synthesis and induces entry into mitosis How widespread is the role of MPF in the cell cycle? The observation that oocytes could be induced to mature by injecting cytoplasm from mitotically arrested mammalian cells suggested that MPF exists in a wide range of cell types. The discovery that MPF activity rises and falls in the meiotic and mitotic cell cycles of frog eggs strengthened the suggestion that MPF plays a key role in regulating the cell cycle (Figure 2-6). After treating oocytes with progesterone, a 5 hour lag occurs before MPF activity rises rapidly to a peak at metaphase of meiosis I. Activity falls between the two meiotic divisions, rises again as the meiosis II spindle is assembled and then remains high during the natural cell cycle arrest in metaphase of meiosis II. Fertilization leads rapidly to inactivation of MPF and interphase of the first mitotic cell cycle. After fertilization, MPF activity rises each time the embryo enters mitosis and then falls as it enters the next interphase. In early embryonic cell cycles, entry into mitosis and activation of MPF both require protein synthesis in the preceding interphase. The role of MPF in inducing mitosis was investigated by injecting it into embryos that had been arrested in interphase by treatment with protein-synthesis inhibitors. The injected embryos entered mitosis, suggesting that the role of protein synthesis in early embryonic cell cycles is limited to inducing the activation of MPF (Figure 2-7). The presence of maternal stockpiles allows eggs to reduce the role of protein synthesis to controlling of the activities that regulate passage through the cell cycle, unlike somatic cells which must synthesize more of each component in each cell cycle. Cytoplasmic transfer experiments CELL CYCLE ENGINE In most cells, inhibitors of DNA synthesis prevent cells from entering mitosis, and inhibitors of spindle assembly keep them from beginning anaphase, suggesting that the completion of key steps in the replication and segregation of the chromosomes could regulate MPF activity. Surprisingly, experiments on frog eggs led to a very different conclusion. The cell cycle engine in frog eggs oscillates independently of DNA replication and spindle assembly When fertilized frog eggs were treated with drugs that inhibit DNA synthesis, the regular rise and fall of MPF activity continued unabated (Figure 2-8). As MPF activity increased, the nuclei broke down, and as it decreased, the nuclei re-formed, even though DNA replication was completely blocked. Treatment with drugs that inhibit spindle assembly also failed to prevent the regular oscillation of MPF activity or the response of the nuclei to its rise and fall. enucleated eggs MPF rose and fell normally. Even in Together these experiments show that, in frog embryos, purely cytoplasmic reactions activate and inactivate MPF and drive the nucleus, whether ready or not, into and out of mitosis. This conclusion clearly violated the dogma, derived from studies on somatic cells that the progress of the cell cycle was regulated by the state of the nucleus. The experiments on the early embryonic frog cell cycle suggested that it is controlled by a simple biochemical oscillator that periodically drives cells into and out of mitosis. We now know that the oscillator is a series of biochemical reactions in the cytoplasm that collectively lead to the periodic activation and inactivation of MPF. When MPF activity increases, the nuclei respond by breaking down and forming a mitotic spindle. When MPF activity declines, anaphase and cytokinesis follow, and the nucleus reassembles and replicates its DNA. In the early frog embryo, changes in the activity of MPF enforce changes in the state of the nucleus, but events in the nucleus do not influence the activation or inactivation of MPF. Although the independence of the frog egg MPF cycle from the nuclear cycle is unusual, even among embryonic cell cycles, it helps classify events in the cell cycle into two categories: reactions that make up a cell cycle engine and downstream events that the engine controls (Figure 2-9). The cell cycle engine consists of all the biochemical components, and the reactions between them, that cause the periodic activation and inactivation of MPF. part of the engine. MPF itself is A major goal of cell cycle research is to enumerate the components of the engine, purify them, and use them to rebuild a working engine in a test tube. Downstream events lie outside the cell cycle engine and are induced either by active MPF or by the inactivation of MPF. Active MPF induces the downstream events of mitosis, including chromosome condensation, nuclear envelope breakdown, and spindle formation. The inactivation of MPF induces the downstream events that mark the exit from mitosis and the beginning of interphase, including chromosome segregation, chromosome decondensation, nuclear reformation, and cytokinesis. In early embryonic cell cycles, DNA replication and duplication of the microtubule organizing center are also downstream events induced by the inactivation of MPF. In somatic cell cycles, however, these processes are caused not by the inactivation of MPF, but by an additional cell cycle transition, called Start, that occurs during G1, well after the inactivation of MPF (see Chapter 3). Transitions in the cell cycle engine activate and inactivate MPF Dividing the processes of the cell cycle into a cell cycle engine and a set of downstream events helps to reveal the logic of the cell cycle. The early embryonic cell cycle engine has two states: mitosis, where MPF is active, and interphase, where it is inactive. Transitions between these states induce the downstream events that produce profound rearrangements of the cell. After each rearrangement is complete, the architecture of the cell remains unchanged until the next transition in the engine occurs (Figure 210). Active MPF induces the changes that culminate in metaphase, and the cell does not enter anaphase and progress into interphase until the transition that inactivates MPF. Thus, the visible events of the cell cycle reveal transitions in the state of the cell cycle engine. The main reason that we consider the onset of anaphase marks the end of mitosis is that it occurs very shortly after the inactivation of MPF, so the end of mitosis directly reflects a change in the state of the cell cycle engine. The cell cycle engine is controlled more or less tightly controlled in different cells. In unfertilized frog eggs the cell cycle engine is arrested with high levels of MPF. Fertilization restarts the engine, which then runs freely, whether or not downstream events are completed successfully. In many embryos and all somatic cell cycles, each transition in the engine is regulated in response to the completion of downstream events. .i).cell cycle:downstream events; .ib.Cyclin:discovery; The destruction of cyclins at the end of each mitosis suggests a model for the cell cycle What makes the cell cycle engine oscillate? The experiments on frog eggs suggested that the regular oscillations in MPF activity drive the cell cycle but did not reveal the molecular nature of MPF or the enzymes that turn it on and off. The only clue was that protein synthesis was required to activate MPF in every cell cycle. were components, Perhaps the newly made proteins or activators, of MPF. With the benefit of hindsight, it now seems obvious that in either case the critical proteins would have to be used up or destroyed by passage through mitosis. If this were not true, it would be hard to explain why new protein synthesis was required to activate MPF. Many unsuccessful attempts were made to identify periodic proteins, whose periodic synthesis had been proposed to induce cell cycle transitions. Then, as often happens, what had been sought diligently, was stumbled upon accidentally. The breakthrough came from studies of protein synthesis in sea urchin eggs. Newly fertilized eggs were incubated with a radioactive amino acid and sampled every 10 minutes to analyze the pattern of radioactively labeled proteins. The amount of radioactivity in most proteins increased continuously throughout the experiment, but one protein behaved quite differently. It disappeared abruptly at the end of each mitosis and then gradually reappeared during the next interphase (Figure 2-11). Additional experiments showed that cyclin, as it is now called, is a periodic protein synthesized throughout the cell cycle but degraded at the end of each mitosis. The assumption that periodic proteins are periodically synthesized, rather than continuously synthesized and periodically destroyed, may explain why cyclin remained unidentified for so long. The behavior of cyclin suggested a simple model of the cell cycle engine, in which the activation of MPF drives cells into mitosis and the decline of MPF activity leads to the next interphase. rests on three postulates: The model the accumulation of cyclin during interphase activates MPF, active MPF induces the destruction of cyclin, and the destruction of cyclin leads to the inactivation of MPF. In this model the cell cycle engine flip-flops periodically between mitosis and interphase (Figure 2-12). The accumulation of cyclin in interphase leads to the activation of MPF and the induction of mitosis, and the ability of MPF to induce the degradation of cyclin leads to the inactivation of MPF and the next interphase. The model made three simple, testable predictions: Cy- clin is a protein that activates MPF or is a part of MPF, cells must accumulate cyclin to enter mitosis, and cells must degrade cyclin to exit mitosis. Chapter 4 describes experiments that confirmed these predictions and led ultimately to a more complex but more realistic picture of the cell cycle engine. Cyclins are found in all eukaryotes that have been examined, including yeasts, coelenterates, flies, echinoderms, mollusks, amphibians, mammals, and plants. We now know that there are many different cyclins, which form a large family of related proteins with different functions. Mitotic cyclins (cyclin B) are components of MPF, S phase cyclins (cyclin A) play a poorly defined role in the control of DNA replication, and G1 cyclins are important in catalyzing the events that move the somatic cell cycle from G1 into S phase. CONCLUSION The experiments on MPF in frog eggs and oocytes and the mammalian cell fusion experiments (see Chapter 1) both led to the conclusion that mitotic cells contain a dominant inducer of mitosis. In other respects, however, the two sets of experiments led to strikingly different conclusions. The studies of frog eggs revealed a cytoplasmic oscillator that drives the nucleus into mitosis even if DNA replication is unfinished, whereas in the fusion experiments cells entered mitosis only after DNA synthesis was finished. For many years the puzzling contrast between the dictatorship of the cell cycle oscillator in frog eggs and the interdependence of processes in the somatic cell cycle suggested that the early embryonic and somatic cycles were fundamentally different from each other. The ability to assay material for MPF activity meant that oocyte injection offered a method for characterizing and purifying MPF that the cell fusion experiments did not offer. hindered research on MPF. Nevertheless, two problems The first was purely practical: MPF proved extraordinarily difficult to characterize and purify, partly because the oocyte injection assay was cumbersome and technically demanding. Second, the possibility that MPF is active only in the specialized meiotic cell cycle meant that few people studied it until the evidence for its role in the mitotic cell cycle was overwhelming. As we shall see in Chapter 4, the pace of research on MPF increased exponentially during the 1980s, leading to the discovery that it is a universal component of a highly conserved cell cycle engine found in all eukaryotes. SELECTED READINGS General Wilson, E.B. The cell in development and heredity, 3rd ed. 1232 pp. (Macmillan, New York, 1928). This classical summary of the work of early light microscopists reveals the strengths and weaknesses of a purely descriptive approach to the cell cycle. Original articles Masui, Y., & Markert, C.L. Cytoplasmic control of nuclear behavior during meiotic maturation of frog oocytes. J .Exp .Zool . 177, 129-145 (1971). The discovery of MPF. Gerhart, J., Wu, M., & Kirschner, M. Cell cycle dynamics of an M-phase-specific cytoplasmic factor in Xenopus laevis oocytes and eggs. 1247-1255 (1984). J. Cell Biol. 98, Inhibitors of spindle assembly fail to prevent the regular oscillation of MPF activity. Newport, J.W., & Kirschner, M.W. Regulation of the cell cycle during early Xenopus development. 37, 731-742 (1984). Cell Injection of MPF into interphase cells induces them to enter mitosis. Evans, T., Rosenthal, E.T., Youngblom, J., Distel, D., & Hunt, T. Cyclin: A protein specified by maternal mRNA in sea urchin eggs that is destroyed at each cleavage division. Cell 33, 389-396 (1983). discovery of cyclin. blastula 6 definition 4 cell cycle downstream events 14 early embryonic 1-22 definition 6 early studies 1 maternal stockpiles 6 model 17, 19 organization 15 photographs 3 protein synthesis requirement 10 suprression of G1 and G2 4 engine See cell cycle engine MPF oscillation during 10, 12 transitions 15 cell cycle engine 12-20 autonomy in frog eggs 12 The definition 14 transitions 15 Cyclin classes 19 diversity 19 Cytoplasmic transfer experiments 8-11 downstream events definition 14 eggs see frog-eggs, sea urchin-eggs, clam-eggs, starfish-eggs, Drosophila melanogaster-eggs frog early embryonic cell cycle 4-16 eggs 12 cell cycle 4-16 cytoplasmic transfer experiments 8 life cycle 4-6 meiotic cell cycle 7-10 oocyte cytoplasmic transfer experiments 8 oocytes 4-10 induction of meiosis by progesterone 6-10 interphase downstream events 14 maturation definition 8 maturation promoting factor see MPF meiotic cell cycle 7 meiotic maturation definition 8 mitosis downstream events 14 induction by MPF 10, 12 MPF activation by post-translational reactions 9 discovery 8, 9 mitosis-inducing activity 10, 12 oscillation during cell cycle 10, 12 protein synthesis and activation 10 role in cell cycle transitions 15 periodic proteins 17 polar body definition 7 pre-MPF discovery 9 Progesterone induction of meiosis by 6-10 sea urchin eggs cyclin discovery 17 South African clawed frog see frog Xenopus laevis see frog Figure 2-1 Interphase of the first cell cycle, the first mitosis, and the second cell cycle of fertilized sea urchin eggs. Between interphase and mitosis, the chromosomes become visible, the nucleus breaks down, and the spindle forms. All of these changes are reversed as the cell proceeds into the next interphase. Not available Figure 2-2 Early embryonic and somatic cell cycles. Somatic cell cycles in frogs typically last about 1 day and have a G1 and a G2. Twelve rapid divisions occur after fertilization, after which the synchrony between the cell cycles of neighboring cells breaks down. Figure 2-3 Frog early development. As they emerge from the female frog, eggs are fertilized and undergo 12 rapid cell divisions to produce the blastula, a hollow ball of cells. The blastula undergoes complex structural rearrangements that ultimately give rise to a tadpole. Figure 2-4 Frog oogenesis, meiosis, and fertilization. Oocytes are born at the same size as typical somatic cells. They replicate their DNA and then arrest as they grow in diameter from 20 µm to 1 mm. Secretion of progesterone by the follicle cells that surround the oocyte induces it to undergo the first meiotic division and enter the second. The oocytes arrest in metaphase of meiosis II and emerge in this state as unfertilized eggs. Fertilization overcomes the metaphase arrest and initiates the early embryonic cell cycles. Figure 2-5 Discovery of MPF. Oocytes induced to mature into unfertilized eggs by treatment with progesterone are used to donate cytoplasm to untreated oocytes. The transferred cytoplasm contains active MPF (maturation promoting factor), which induces the recipient oocytes to enter meiosis. Maturation induces the activation of MPF in the recipient oocyte, allowing it to act as a cytoplasmic donor that can induce meiosis in a fresh round of recipient oocytes. Reference: Masui, Y. & Markert, C.L. J Exp Zool 177, 129-45 (1971). Figure 2-6 MPF fluctuations in meiotic and mitotic cell cycles. Oocytes have low levels of MPF activity. Progesterone induces the activation of MPF, leading to meiosis I. After a brief decline, a second rise in MPF activity induces meiosis II, and the oocytes remain arrested in metaphase of meiosis II with high levels of MPF. This arrest is overcome by fertilization, which leads to a precipitous decline in MPF activity. Interphase of the first mitotic cell cycle lasts about 60 minutes, while that of cycles 2 through 12 last about 15 minutes. Each mitosis lasts about 15 minutes and is initiated by the activation of MPF and terminated by its inactivation. Reference: Gerhart, J., Wu, M. & Kirschner, M. J. Cell Biol. 98, 1247-1255 (1984). Figure 2-7 Induction of mitosis by MPF. Treating fertilized eggs with protein synthesis inhibitors arrests them in interphase, but injecting partially purified MPF into the arrested eggs induces them to enter mitosis. Reference: Newport, J.W. & Kirschner, M.W. Cell 37, 731-42 (1984). Figure 2-8 MPF oscillates independently of DNA synthesis and spindle assembly. The fluctuation of MPF activity in normally fertilized embryos (the control) is compared with that of embryos fertilized in the presence of an inhibitor of DNA polymerization (aphidicolin) or spindle assembly (nocodazole). The oscillations in the three sets of embryos are identical, showing that the failure to complete DNA replication does not influence the reactions that periodically activate and inactivate MPF. Reference: Gerhart, J., Wu, M. & Kirschner, M. J. Cell Biol. 98, 1247-1255 (1984). Figure 2-9 Cell cycle engine and downstream events. The cell cycle is divided into two types of processes. MPF is part of the cell cycle engine, a biochemical machine that produces cyclical oscillations in the activity of MPF and other key cell cycle regulators that control downstream events. Active MPF induces the downstream events of mitosis, which interact to assemble the mitotic spindle. The inactivation of MPF at the end of mitosis induces the downstream events that lead to interphase, including chromosome segregation, and cytokinesis. In early embryonic cell cycles, DNA replication and duplication of the centrosome are consequences of the inactivation of MPF. Figure 2-10 Organization of the early embryonic cell cycle. Each transition in the cell cycle engine leads to coordinated changes that rearrange the cell. The cell remains in this new state until the next transition occurs in the cell cycle engine. The activation of MPF at the beginning of mitosis leads to the mitotic downstream events, which produce a cell with a metaphase spindle. The inactivation of MPF induces the interphase downstream events, which produce a G2 cell with replicated DNA and duplicated centrosomes (MTOC). Figure 2-11 Discovery of cyclin. The abundance of newly synthesized proteins was measured during the first two cell cycles of fertilized sea urchin eggs. Most new proteins increased in abundance steadily with time after fertilization. The abundance of cyclin, however, increased during each interphase and declined abruptly at the end of each mitosis. Reference: Evans, T., Rosenthal, E.T., Youngblom, J., Distel, D. & Hunt, T. Cell 33, 389-396 (1983). Figure 2-12 Early embryonic cell cycle model. The fluctuatation of cyclin abundance and MPF activity in the early embryonic cell cycle suggests a flip-flop model for the cell cycle engine. In interphase MPF is inactive, but the accumulation of cyclin leads to the activation of MPF and entry into mitosis. In mitosis MPF is active, but MPF induces the degradation of cyclin, leading to the inactivation of MPF and entry into interphase.