Download Workshop 3 SVO and Punctuation

Survey
yes no Was this document useful for you?
   Thank you for your participation!

* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project

Document related concepts

Pleonasm wikipedia , lookup

Zulu grammar wikipedia , lookup

Sanskrit grammar wikipedia , lookup

Inflection wikipedia , lookup

Esperanto grammar wikipedia , lookup

Old English grammar wikipedia , lookup

English clause syntax wikipedia , lookup

Swedish grammar wikipedia , lookup

Navajo grammar wikipedia , lookup

Lexical semantics wikipedia , lookup

Scottish Gaelic grammar wikipedia , lookup

French grammar wikipedia , lookup

Georgian grammar wikipedia , lookup

Macedonian grammar wikipedia , lookup

Portuguese grammar wikipedia , lookup

Kannada grammar wikipedia , lookup

Lithuanian grammar wikipedia , lookup

Japanese grammar wikipedia , lookup

Italian grammar wikipedia , lookup

Yiddish grammar wikipedia , lookup

Chinese grammar wikipedia , lookup

Ancient Greek grammar wikipedia , lookup

Modern Hebrew grammar wikipedia , lookup

Russian grammar wikipedia , lookup

Malay grammar wikipedia , lookup

Serbo-Croatian grammar wikipedia , lookup

Turkish grammar wikipedia , lookup

Pipil grammar wikipedia , lookup

English grammar wikipedia , lookup

Polish grammar wikipedia , lookup

Latin syntax wikipedia , lookup

Spanish grammar wikipedia , lookup

Transcript
Workshop 3 : Logical Grammar and Punctuation
Sentences communicate information from the writer to the reader. Correct grammar and
syntax ensure that the information is conveyed unambiguously. Grammar establishes
certain rules for writing and speech; syntax involves the order and relationship of the
words in the sentence. Grammar is the electronic wiring that makes the telephone work.
You cannot connect any wire to any other wire and expect that the machine will work.
Similarly, you cannot put words in any order in the sentence and expect the sentence to
communicate.
Grammar and syntax have a logic- if the reader is to understand the meaning of the
sentence then that logic has to be followed. Note that we can ask questions of every word
in a correct sentence, and we can find the answer to that question in the sentence.
Poor grammar and syntax (floating pronouns and floating participles etc) throw the reader
off balance. The reader asks, “what is this word doing in the sentence” and can find no
answer and so has to try to guess what is in the writer’s head.
So, good editing means checking that all the parts of the sentence say something
precisely and clearly: that is, the words conform to the logic of the sentence.
If the writing is not logical, then the reader will not be convinced of the logic of the
analysis.
Let’s look first at the wiring, the parts of speech, and then at the complete machine, the
sentence and then at ways to make the sentence communicate more clearly and without
static.
The black panther stared menacingly from the tree.
Nouns: the names of people and things (drop bear, tree, dress, Umberto, James Cook
University, beauty, death). To find the noun, ask who or what of the verb? Who stared
from the tree? The panther.
Proper Nouns: (names of specific people or titles. Proper nouns are the only nouns that
have capitals- all other nouns use lower case). Li, Farida, Moses, President Bush, King
George (but note: “The president walked into the room”, “The king opened parliament”).
Adjectives: describe and modify nouns (what sort of panther? A black one)
Verbs: describe the action (swing, eat, sleep, write, talk, be, die). To find the verb, ask
what did the subject do? What did the panther do? It stared
1
Adverbs: modify verbs (how did it swing? menacingly).Most adverbs have a –ly ending.
He writes quickly. Quick is the adjective. She is a quick runner.
Do not substitute adjectives for adverbs. For instance, the adjective is “good” but its
adverb is “well” What sort of child is she? A good child. We cannot use “good” for the
adverb “well”. Eat good! This infelicity should be “Eat well”! (how should we eat? Not
what sort of eating is it). Of course, the formal response to “How are you” should be “ I
am well”; that is, how is my being/my health). “I am good” actually means that my
behaviour is saintly; a logical contradiction because to state I am saintly or morally
superior betrays a lack of humility which is the usual characteristic of the morally
advanced. “Good” describes a quality not a condition.
Prepositions: show position and relation of one thing to another (under, over, by, in,
beside).
Pronouns: stand for nouns (eg. It, this, I, me, you, we, us, our, who, which, that)
Note that every word in the sentence should be related to something else. To find out if it
is in the right place, ask a question of the word. There should be an answer. Good editing
requires that the writer read and ask questions of every sentence. If there is not a clear
answer in the sentence, then the sentence needs to be rewritten (look at the section below
Keep Verbs Consistent for examples of sentences which do not provide answers).
*
The clearest structure for an English speaker to understand is the SVO order. That is
Subject — Verb — Object.
Note that this framework is a complete idea, and note also that the verb is the essential
lynch pin. Without the verb the subject and the object cannot relate to each other. The
verb is the action, it is the expression of what the subject/agent is doing; without that
expression, there cannot be a result or an object.
Compare the following:
Kim entered the room.
Kim tiptoed into the room.
Kim staggered into the room.
Kim crawled into the room.
Kim minced into the room.
Kim exploded into the room.
Only the verbs change, but the mental picture in the head is quite different. The choice of
the verb alters the message communicated.
But that is creative writing, is this necessary in academic writing?
2
Compare
Bloggs (2004) says/writes that wigeons breed only in temperatures exceeding 25
degrees.
Bloggs
reported/
observed/
considered/
insisted/
maintained/
speculated/
hypothesised/ claimed…..
Vary the verbs so that the reader can see that you have read the article, understood the
implications, and contextualised Bloggs’ statement in the broader context of the
literature.
Words relate to each other in a sentence, and so do the parts of the sentence.
A sentence can be as short as a subject and verb, or can be very long with subordinate
support units. By and large, sentences should not exceed three typed lines.
A sentence is a complete thought. One idea = one sentence. Do not overload sentences
with information.
SVO A simple sentence needs a subject, a verb and sometimes an object. To find the
subject of a sentence, ask the question who or what of the verb.
The cat sat on the mat. Who sat on the mat? The cat.
To find the verb, ask what the noun/subject did. What did the cat do? It sat. If there is no
subject or verb in the sentence, then the sentence is in trouble.
The subject should go near the front of the sentence, but not necessarily be the first word:
Sitting under the shade of a green olive tree, the goat was a picture of contentment as it
languidly digested its lunch.
A sentence can be very short:
Go! [understood subject is you]
I am. [subject and verb]
Generally, we need to have the subject (or the main idea of the sentence) up the front,
then a verb then the consequence. Such a construction is the easiest form for English
readers to understand.
X: To ensure the accuracy of the numerical results a grid independence study was
performed.
√: The accuracy of the numerical results was checked against a grid independence study
3
Note the clunky word order of the first and the distorted passive which this sentence
structure demands.
Simple sentence—control unit only
The feral pig snorted menacingly.
Complex sentence—control unit and support unit or units
The feral pig, cornered by a pack of dogs, snorted menacingly at the approaching
hunters.
The support units are in italics. Sentences are made up of a mixture of control and support
units. Sophisticated sentences use many support units, but a proper sentence must always
have at least one control unit somewhere in there.
Control unit/support unit (principal clause/ subordinate clauses)
Although it was cold (support unit)
Although it was cold, I didn’t bother with a coat.
The sea that day, although it was cold, was a wonderful sight.
Nobody lit a fire, although it was cold.
Complex Sentences ( note the SVO structure is continued even in support units)
a) The 1903 paper, “Refutation of Idealism”, had an equally powerful impact. Before this
paper appeared, the prevailing mode of philosophy both on the Continent and in the
English-speaking world was idealism. It took many different forms, some post-Kantian,
some post-Hegelian, and some post-Berkeleyan, but all of them had in common the notion
that reality was ultimately mental.
b) Stephen J Gould: Questioning the Millenium, 33.
The human brain is the most complex computing device ever evolved in the history of our
planet. I do not doubt that conventional Darwinian reasons of adaptive advantage underlie
its unparalleled size and intricacy. Nonetheless, many of our brain’s most distinctive
attributes, centrepieces for any concept of a universal human nature, cannot be viewed as
direct products of natural selection but must arise as incidental side consequences of the
original reasons for such an increase in size.(For example, if I buy a personal computer
only to keep the spreadsheet on my family finances, the machine, by virtue of inbuilt
structure and quite apart from my intent, can perform a plethora of unanticipated tasks as
yet unconceived by any user. The more complex the device, the greater the number of
4
potential side consequences. The human brain is ever so much more powerful than this
personal computer)
Punctuation
Generally, punctuation can help the reader discern the difference between the control unit
and the support unit/s. Commas etc, are the marks which show what belongs in what unit
in a sentence.
Let’s eat Harry!
Here, there is no punctuation, and so the reader sees that the object of the verb ‘eat’ is
Harry. We can ask the question: whom shall we eat? The answer is Harry. If there is a
comma after “eat” then the reader knows that the expression. “let’s eat” is one unit of
thought, and is separated from Harry, which is seen as an aside- he is being addressed
and asked whether he wants to eat.
When feeding a shark often mistakes undesirable food items for something it really
desires.
Without punctuation, it is unclear whether the sentence means, “when [you] are feeding
a shark….”
When I last heard of him he was still acting naturally.
When I last heard of him he was still acting, naturally.
Here, without punctuation, the first sentence means that he was acting naturally (like a
normal, unpretentious person). The second one says that she was acting (i.e. posing,
pretending) and the “naturally” becomes a sarcastic aside which implies: “Well, that is
what I would expect from such a pretentious person”
The exhibition opens with an anonymous painting in which 16th century Venetian
diplomats identifiable only by their simple dress in comparison with the rich garb of the
locals are being presented to a Mamluk leader.
The Third Partition of Poland was the last and undoubtedly the most humiliating act in
the sorry decline of the once-powerful kingdom.
The people of Cornwall who depend upon fishing for their livelihood, initiated a strike
against the new EC quotas
The police although alerted too late for them to catch the thief that day continued their
investigations.
5
Unfortunately nothing of that nature was forthcoming the senator was clearly a troubled
man.
A capital letter marks the beginning of a declarative sentence a period signals the end
Note the different uses of however:
However people react, they will nevertheless always insist that they were justified in so
doing.
[however = in whatever way]
However, the effects of cholate on peptide carboxylase have not yet been fully studied.
[however= link to show contradiction]
The final report, however, was not released until the politician had fled the country.
[however= link to show contradiction]
Fused Sentences and Comma Splices need Semi-Colons (;)
The following notes have examples of when, and when not, to insert punctuation.
1. The course was difficult it required five different texts.
The course was difficult and it required five different texts could both be individual
sentences. They are control units and so need something stronger than a comma to
separate them. They need a full stop, a semi colon or a joining word.
The course was difficult because it required five different texts
The course was difficult; it required five different texts.
2. The lemonade was too tart, however, James drank it anyway.
[Again, what could almost be 2 control units. Place a semi-colon after tart]
3. Janet was distraught, she couldn’t find her research paper notes.
[here, try a semi colon after distraught OR join with a real word: …distraught because
she … note that good writing puts in all the words so the reader can see the writer’s
reasoning. Don’t forget to use because if you want to say there is a cause and effect]
4. Ernest Hemingway’s style is quite distinctive, he makes extensive use of the
compound sentence to create an impression of balanced tension.
In 4, the comma between distinctive and he is not strong enough to carry what again
could be 2 control units.
To edit:
6



Separate into independent sentences
Use a semi colon
Use a subordinating conjunction (because, for, and, …)
Semicolons separate items which require commas to mark off sub support units.
That is, semi colons acts as headings to distinguish the main units. If there are no
subunits, then use commas, not semi-colons.
The dingfluff is known for three main characteristics: its reproductive flexibility, because
it is both hermaphrodite and heterosexual; its diet, which consists entirely of vegemite
sandwiches; and its longevity, as some dingfluffs live to 356.
A multitude of grafting techniques have been employed by plant propagators over many years.
These techniques may be classified into three broad categories: (1) the detached scion, where the
scion is removed from the plant and then grafted; (2) the approach method, where the scion is
grafted to the rootstock and removed from the mother plant after the union is established; and (3)
the repair method, which is applicable for repairing damaged mature trees (Barque & Ruette,
2002).
Do Not Separate SVO by Punctuation
The essential unit of meaning is a SVO and so this unit cannot be divided up.
1. Exegesis of biblical and patristic literature, has been undertaken for at least two
thousand years. (Separation of S and O)
Rather: Exegesis of biblical and patristic literature has been undertaken for at least two
thousand years.
2. The woman in the red suit, is the owner of the purple car. (Separation of S and O)
Rather: The woman in the red suit is the owner of the purple car
3. Following analysis by SIMS and FLUX, the core samples were removed, to the
outlying coral reefs where they were reburied. (Separation of V and O)
Rather: Following analysis by SIMS and FLUX, the core samples were removed to the
outlying coral reefs where they were reburied.
[To find object: ask the question of the verb: where were they removed to?
Object cannot be separated from its verb.]
COLONS
To indicate that a list, statement or quotation is to follow:
John Paul Getty once made this observation: “If you can calculate how much you have,
then you are not a billionaire.”
We need to check the following items: printers, answering machines and mobile phones.
7
BUT NOT:
The secretary typed: letters, memos and reports.
The colon can only be used to preface a list if the words before the colon could be a
complete sentence.
X: There are three types of marsupial including: koalas, kangaroos and wombats.
√: There are three types of marsupial: koalas, kangaroos and wombats.
OR The three types of marsupials are koalas, kangaroos and wombats
Colons can also be used to summarise or clarify words:
The author made a difficult decision: he would abandon the script. (To abandon the script
is the decision)
Music communicates: it is an expression of deep feeling. (The deep feeling is what music
communicates)
Colons introduce bulleted points. The words before a colon should be a control unit.
The study involves 3 factors:



Data-gathering
Analysis
Interpretation
Punctuation Practice:
The eastern Kanto Plain is a relatively flat dissected plain where even in the early stages
of the postglacial transgression rich coastal environments would have existed at
reasonably convenient distances from high dry bluffs, a place humans could live
comfortably.
The sea would flood narrow valleys on the dissected plain creating a complex coastline
with multitudes of small bays, estuaries, and coves.
Dr Altieri found a more startling result children fed coco pops excelled in maths exams.
Don’t Double Subjects in Sentences
a) From Figure, 4.6, it can be seen that the convection flow increases.
[it is a pronoun standing for Figure 4.6. It is completely redundant here. Try;
8
Figure 4.6 illustrates how the convection flow increases. (SVO)
Better: The convection flow increases (Figure 4.2).
b) For figure 24 (a) it shows the asymmetric flow for Gr number equal to 32000.
The asymmetric flow for Gr number equal to 32000 (Figure 24 a).
c) By building an overpass, it will increase the number of pedestrians to the city.
An overpass will increase the number of pedestrians to the city.
DISTORTED PASSIVE
Active and passive are voices; they refer to different word orders. Passive is not past
tense.
Active voice = SVO
Passive voice = OVS (very loosely)
The postgraduate wrote the thesis. (active, past tense)
The thesis was written by the postgraduate. (passive past tense)
The postgraduate writes the thesis. (active, present tense)
The thesis is written by the postgraduate. (passive present tense)
The postgraduate will write the thesis. (active, future tense)
The thesis will be written by the postgraduate. (passive future tense)
Generally, active voice is clearer and easier to understand. Academic writing, and all
elegant writing, employs a mixture of both active and passive voices. Scientific writing
generally tends to use passive voice because the subject of the action (“the doer”) is not
normally important.
Eg. The scientist filled the flask with distilled water. (active)
The flask was filled with distilled water. (passive)
Passive voice is acceptable in scientific and academic writing, but what is unacceptable
and difficult to read is the distorted passive. The distorted passive occurs when the verb is
taken and hidden in a sort of noun.
1. Acid-etching removed the rust.
Active voice - acceptable
2. The rust was removed by acid etching.
Passive voice- acceptable
3. Removal of the rust was...(?verb?)...by acid-etching.
Distorted passive -pompous
The problem with sentence 3 is that the real verb which shows the action (removing) is
lost in a weak noun, and so another verb must be supplied in the sentence. The various
9
suggestions for filling in this gap are invariably the same tired, non-verbs: facilitated,
achieved, accomplished, carried out, performed, undertaken, effected, done. None of
these actually tell the reader what precisely was done. Only the precise verb, to remove,
tells the reader what happened. The rust was removed is clear and precise: Removal was
carried out sounds pompous.
Rewriting Distorted Passive:
•
•
•
Check if you have written one of the non-verbs; achieved, performed etc.
Find the hidden verb earlier in the sentence (in the sentence above it was remove
from the noun removal).
Use this hidden verb as a direct verb in the sentence.
Turn the following distorted passive into clear passive voice or active voice.
1. Measurement of the resistance was carried out by the ohmmeter.
2. Daily measurement of the leaf area was undertaken.
3. Dropping of the glass slipper was carried out by Cinderella.
4. Containment of the adult squidgens was achieved by the use of a net trap.
5. Destruction of the seaside area was effected by the strong gales.
See how the sentence is improved by SVO flow
X: To ensure the accuracy of the numerical results a grid independence study was
performed.
√: The accuracy of the numerical results was checked against a grid independence study
Avoid floating participles (Fparts)
X: This descriptive survey investigated the pre-diagnostic decision-making process of
Australian males, concerning their values and influencing socio-demographic variables
relating to treatment choices for early prostrate cancer.
A participle has an —ing ending. E.g swimming, running, dreaming, concerning,
relating.
Participles function as parts of verbs. I am swimming; he is dreaming, but they must be
attached to other verbs (here is and am).
Participles on their own can also be gerunds (i.e. they act as nouns). Reading is my
favourite activity.
However, participles are often used incorrectly in the middle of sentences. They pretend
to be verbs, but have no clear action, and they have no clear subject. In this case, they are
10
floating participles, because they do not clearly connect to any part of the rest of the
sentence.
Good writing is unambiguous and subjects and verbs should be clearly stated.
X: Artificial fertilisers and pesticides are used extensively, resulting in heavy nutrient
(nitrogen and phosphorus) loading and POP pollution.
[the reader asks: “what results in heavy nutrient loading?” But there is no answer to this,
so no clear subject in the sentence. To correct, use full verbs.
√: Artificial fertilisers and pesticides are used extensively and result in (cause?) heavy
nutrient (nitrogen and phosphorus) loading and POP pollution.
√: The application of artificial fertilisers and pesticides results in heavy nutrient (nitrogen
and phosphorus) loading and POP pollution.
(Note: try to avoid the overuse of “use”]
X: Chlorine is required by certain growth hormones, making it important for plants to
increase in size. [what makes “it important”, what is “it”? Note redundant pronoun it, and
increase in size; Try SVO]
√: Chlorine is essential to plant growth hormones
Since the completion of this dam and many minor ones, the sediment discharge has been
reduced to 3×108 t a-1 or less since the 1990s, implying that average suspended sediment
concentration has been reduced (Figure 4.4).
Avoid concerning, relating to, regarding, being, implying, meaning, particularly in
the middle of a sentence following a comma.
X: The establishment of sound educational principles took many years, meaning that the
college did not produce a graduate for twenty years.
√: The establishment of sound educational principles took many years, and so the college
did not produce a graduate for twenty years.
X: The issue regarding the new policy is that the recommendations are unenforceable.
√: The recommendations of the new policy are unenforceable.
X: The problem concerning the breakdown of gases has received little attention in the
literature.
[But what is the problem with the breakdown? The mechanism of the break down? The
dispersal of gases after breakdown? The inablility of the gases to breakdown? The
possibilities are endless. Good writing should be unambiguous]
11
X: The problem in relation to the shortage of applicants is that there is a danger of hiring
unsuitable people.
√: The shortage of applicants could lead to the employment of unsuitable people.
Or The problem of the shortage of applicants is….
In relation to can nearly always be replaced by “of” or another preposition.
Avoid floating pronouns (FPs)
This and it are pronouns. However, be careful that they refer to specific antecedents.
Sometimes these pronouns are loosely used to indicate vaguely “everything or something
that went before”. In particular, do not begin sentences with It or This alone. These words
are normally floating pronouns which have no specific or concrete reference. If you see It
or This, then rewrite to provide the specific word required.
John used to ride carelessly and finally smashed his bike into a tree. This made his
father angry.
It is not clear whether his father was angry because of the careless riding or the accident.
This is singular and should refer back to one specific antecedent. This is, here,
ambiguous.
Rewrite: The accident made his father angry.
Pam always wanted to be the top salesperson in her company. She was happy
when she got it.
There is no antecedent for it. Rewrite:
She was happy when she achieved her goal.
Or: She was happy when she attained this position. (Replace get with better verb)
Visiting dignitaries watched yesterday as ground was broken for the new highenergy physics laboratory. This is the first visible evidence of the university’s
plans for modernization and expansion.
This has no antecedent. Try seeking the real subject of the verb is. What is the first visible
evidence? There is no single word/noun in the previous sentence to which this refers.
However, the writer probably wanted to write this ceremony.
Try: Visiting dignitaries watched yesterday as ground was broken for the new
high-energy physics laboratory. The ceremony is the first visible evidence of the
university’s plans for modernization and expansion.
Note: Do not replace “this” with the equally meaningless “this means”.
12
Poorly constructed sentences force the reader to stop and try to figure out what the writer
really meant. This means that the reader loses the thread of the writer’s arguments.
Note the floating pronouns in the following:
a) The first analysis was to assess if the occurrence of a storm affected the number of fish
spawning in both the storm and wet seasons. This was tested using a chi-squared test
(Zar, 1984).
What does this stand for? Something unsaid in the preceding? This hypothesis?
b) The agitation of eggs by the male may also assist in preventing sediment build-up. This
would give significant survival advantages in the natural environment where flash floods
with huge sediment loads occur frequently during the storm season.
c) However, many would argue that the evolving form of the medical practitioner is
developing into an independent service provision orientation in the competitive
workplace of an experience economy (Stanhope 1983; Smith 1999, 1993; Wesson 1992;
Bertha 1993). This is different from the ‘role’ representation where doctors were
perceived as fulfilling the ‘function’ of the community guru. This new perspective on
doctors has been used extensively in this dissertation.
d) If the porphyroblasts are affected by subsequent deformation events it is highly
probable that the amount of rotation experienced by individual porphyroblasts will vary
because of the heterogeneity of strain plus interference effects (Beirmeier & Stuwe,
2003). This would lead to a girdle like distribution after a single overprinting event and
subsequent events would lead to a random distribution (Ham & Bell, 2004).
Try to rewrite these sentences to avoid floating pronouns
1. The rise in the dollar has been marked by reduced exports in the cattle industry. This
has worried some economists.
2. Poorly constructed sentences force the reader to stop and try to figure out what the
writer really meant. This means that the reader loses the thread of the writer’s arguments.
Avoid Starting Sentences with Prepositions
SVO sentences should not double up on the subject. The pronouns become redundant in
the following sentences.
X: By building the overhead pass, it will ease congestion in the city.
√: Building the overhead pass will ease congestion in the city.
X: With respect to the continuing idealist philosophy, it can be seen to be
influential on emerging Nihilism of the 1890s.
√: Idealist philosophy influenced the emerging Nihilism of the 1890s.
13
Omitting prepositions not only makes the sentence more concise, but prevents doubling
the subject.
X: With a paved walkway across Denham St, this will have a positive effect on the
CBD development.
√: A paved walkway across Denham St will have a positive effect on the CBD.
(SVO)
Better: A paved walkway across Denham St will increase the numbers of shoppers to the
CBD. (Be precise: let the reader know what sort of effect)
With is a joining word; it cannot substitute for other, more precise words such as
since, because, after or and.
X: With no children, he was succeeded to the throne by his brother.
√: Because he had no children, he was succeeded by his brother.
X: With a woman boss, there’s a belief she will be better, more caring and sharing.
√: A woman boss is expected to be better.
Don’t use with when you mean and or because.
X: The child was transported by helicopter to Cairns, with the other children going by
ambulance.
√: The child was transported by helicopter to Cairns, and the other children went by
ambulance.
X: With his teeth falling out, he went to the dentist.
√: Because his teeth were falling out, he went to the dentist.
MODIFIERS
To modify means to describe something else. A modifier is anything which develops the
meaning of another element in a sentence. Adjectives and adverbs are modifiers.
The old woman walked slowly to the bus stop.
Old modifies woman, and slowly modifies the verb, walked.
A whole clause can be a modifier:
She wore a beautiful dress of red silk as she lounged in the seaside apartment that
she rented from her former husband.
of red silk- modifies dress
that she rented from her former husband- modifies apartment.
14
Modifiers are useful, but they can be placed incorrectly. If they are not related to a
specific word, they are said to dangle (a dangling modifier).
Jumping into bed, the sheets were cold.
The sentence literally says that the sheets were jumping into bed. The phrase, jumping
into bed, must modify a noun. The only noun in the sentence is sheets, but this does not
make sense. Thus, a new word needs to be inserted into the sentence.
Jumping into bed, John found that the sheets were cold.
RULE: Be careful to keep your modifier close to the element that it is
modifying.
Modifiers like rarely and only must be next to the word they modify, or the whole
meaning of the sentence is changed.
Only George bought lamingtons at the store yesterday. (He was the only
person.)
George only bought lamingtons at the store yesterday. (He did not sell any
himself.)
George bought only lamingtons at the store yesterday. (He did not buy any
other groceries.)
George bought lamingtons at the only store yesterday. (There is only one
store.)
George bought lamingtons at the store only yesterday. (The lamingtons are
still fresh.)
George bought lamingtons at the store yesterday only. (He did not shop on
any other day.)
Word Stacks
Too many modifiers, strung together, without clear relationships to specific words,
confuses the reader. Look at this noun stack: a qualified French history teacher. This
stack has three possible meanings:
• a qualified teacher of the history of France;
• a qualified history teacher from France;
• a qualified teacher of the history of the French language.
15
How many meanings can you find in the noun stack: emergency pilot orientation
program?
In such sentences, it is better to use a few more words and make the meaning perfectly
clear.
EXERCISE
Correct the ‘dangling’ and ‘misplaced’ modifiers in these sentences:
1. The waitress brought our meals with a friendly smile.
2. Suddenly reaching an arm through the bars of the cage, the man’s pocket was torn by the
monkey.
3. Running poorly and rusting quickly, I decided to repair my old car.
4. Before submitting the final draft, the instructor insisted that we check our work carefully.
5. Striding across the field, the dollar note was found by the hiker.
6. Blue lights pulsing, I saw the police car speed through the intersection and disappear around
the corner.
7. Before being tested, the engineer brought the experimental equipment to the laboratory.
8. Wondering what to do next, the clock struck midnight.
9. Unlike black bears, campers must remembers that grizzlies can be very aggressive.
10. Receiving a substantial rise, the worker’s house could be repaired.
11. To play golf well, daily practice is necessary.
12. While giving the interviews, the questions became clear to the audience.
16
Punctuation Practice
1.
The company did not operate for long but in those few months its
accomplishments became legendary.
2.
Quieting the crowd with a wave of his hand the senator began his address.
3.
Shifting uneasily as one unsettling statement followed another they waited to hear
something optimistic.
4.
After the bleak description of international problems the senator switched to an
analysis of the state’s economy.
5.
I was angry with her she was angry with me.
6.
Unless we hear from you we will begin at the official time.
7.
She has the qualifications consequently she must be considered to be a candidate
for the job.
8.
The machine is only producing 305 units an hour therefore we know something
must be wrong.
9.
The riders hired by the pony express company were brave stalwart and young.
10.
Road maps provide motorists with useful facts including locations of towns and
cities the routes from place to place and the mileage between them.
11.
This system has even greater capacity it can hold 4.2 gigabytes of data.
12.
Production levels will depend upon three factors good weather low equipment
maintenance and harmonious industrial relations.
13.
She performed unlike the others extremely well in the test.
14.
His research was concerned with understanding the similarities between tsunamis
large waves caused by underwater earthquakes and maelstroms very large
whirlpools.
15.
Ragged right justification is discussed elsewhere in this book see pp. 35-6.
16.
Further research this time funded by SAG snipers against gun control produced
findings that were quite different.
17.
The focus of their deliberations whether such a large budget item should be
approved of or not was being lost.
18.
The final outcome was disaster.
19.
She was the author of a little known novel. / The novel is little known around here.
17
20.
He read the ten page document. / The document was ten pages long.
21.
18