Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
HOUSEHOLD WEALTH: GROWTH PROSPECTS IN NEW EUROPE Alessandro Profumo CEO UniCredit Rome, June 8, 2004 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The analysis provides a new picture of individuals' wealth in New Europe countries The major gap highlighted vs. existing EU-15 members provides a new way of looking at the challenge in terms of EU convergence Bridging of that gap and growth of the financial sector appear to be compatible with non-increase of individuals' propensity to save, provided that macroeconomic stability is assured For this reason, the efforts of both policy-makers (in terms of tax control and improvements in competitiveness) and financial institutions (in terms of product offerings and support of Foreign Direct Investments) is needed 2 AGENDA Market overview Key conditions for a convergence process Prospects for the New Europe financial market 3 FOR NEW EUROPE MARKETS THE BIGGEST MARGINS FOR CONVERGENCE CONCERN FINANCIAL WEALTH …. 2003 data Population (mn) EU-15(1) 380 NE-12(2) ITALY(3) 177 57 53% 63% # of Bank Accounts / Inhabitants 134% Per capita GDP (euro) 24,174 3,998 21,930 Per capita financial wealth (euro) 41,628(4) 1,897 35,800 Per capita liabilities (euro) 14,498(4) 362 5,296 64% 62% 76% Home ownership New Europe countries feature a much bigger gap in terms of financial wealth than in terms of income (GDP) Despite home-ownership levels, substantially aligned with those of EU-15, there is still a gap in terms of quality, suggesting need for further requalification Note: (1) As of 2002; (2) The NE(12) – New Europe - definition includes 8 CEECs that are new EU members, plus other candidates or or countries approaching the EU (I.e. Bulgaria, Romania, Croatia and Turkey). Malta and Cyprus are excluded. Slovenia has been excluded due to unavailability of data on personal financial assets; (3) As of 2002; (4) Proxy for the EU aggregate including Italy, France, Germany, The Netherlands, Spain and UK. Sources: PFA Database, New Europe Research Network, and Eurostat 4 … WHICH TODAY LAGS SIGNIFICANTLY BEHIND THE EU AVERAGE, ALBEIT WITH BIG DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE VARIOUS COUNTRIES … The difficult process of transition to a market economy, plus the banking and financial crises of the early 1990s, slowed down accumulation of wealth in New Europe countries – which today are still significantly lagging behind the EU-15 average Households’ Financial Wealth as % of GDP (2003) Italy(1) = 163% Portugal(1) = 195% 170% (1) 68% 73% 47% 49% 50% 50% 52% The countries featuring the highest levels of financial wealth are those that have been better able to manage the transition to a market economy EU Czech R. Croatia Hungary Poland Turkey Slovakia NE Bulgaria Latvia Estonia Lithuania Romania 26% 16% 21% 34% 34% 5 Note: (1) As of 2002 Source: New Europe Research Network … … WHICH MAKES ACCUMULATION OF FINANCIAL WEALTH MAINLY A QUESTION OF FLOWS AND NOT OF STOCKS Per capita Financial Wealth 2003 – EUR 2003 EUR EU Average(1) = 41,628 6,000 40,000 Czech R. Per capita wealth 5,000 Italy(2) = 35,800 5592 6.000 5.000 3630 3796 4.000 3.000 2.000 1.000 2283 NE Average = 1,897 338 773 883 2628 1246 1251 1424 Croatia 4,000 Hungary 3,000 Slovakia Poland 2,000 Turkey Bulgaria 1,000 Latvia Lithuania Romania 0 Estonia Czech R. Croatia Hungary Slovakia Poland Turkey Estonia Latvia Lithuania Bulgaria Romania 0 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 Per capita GDP Average NE per capita wealth is less than 5% of the EU-15 level There is a strong direct correlation between per capita income and per capita wealth, meaning that accumulation is above all a matter of flows and not of stocks 6 Note: (1) As of 2002. Proxy for the EU aggregate including Italy, France, Germany, The Netherlands, Spain and UK; (2) As of 2002. Source: PFA Database, New Europe Research Network ON THE LENDING MARKET THE DIFFERENCES ARE LESS ACCENTUATED Italy(1) = 24% Portugal(1) = 71% Spain(1)=53% HOUSEHOLDS’ LIABILITIES percentage of GDP and billion € - 2003 4,568 7.2 59.3% 11.7 11.1% 16.5% Bulgaria Czech R. Estonia Poland Hungary (2) 9.1% EU 5.0% NE 4.5% 29.1% Croatia 3.2% 4.0% Slovakia 9.3% 12.5% 7.4% 7.1% Latvia 0.4 Turkey 9.1 63.9 1.3 Romania 1.8 21.7 2.1 Lithuania 0.5 7.3 0.7 Present status of the lending market - where the delay versus EU-15 is less accentuated than in the case of financial wealth – is the result of a credit boom fuelled by consumer spending growth and a simultaneous decrease in the cost of debt 7 Note: (1) As of 2002. (2) As of 2002. EU aggregate includes Italy, France, Germany, The Netherlands, Spain and UK Sources: PFA Database, New Europe Research Network AGENDA Market overview Key conditions for a convergence process Prospects for New Europe financial market 8 THE ENLARGEMENT PROCESS ASSURES NEW MEMBERS PROSPECTS OF STEADY LONG-TERM ECONOMIC GROWTH … Per capita GDP in PPP (EU12=100) The experience of past EU enlargement processes shows that catching up implies decades of average growth above EU standards 150 Ireland 100 Spain Portugal 50 1970 1981 1992 1986 Spain and Portugal in EU 1973 Ireland in EU GDP Growth 3.9 3.5 4.4 4.1 2.8 2.8 1.9 1.6 0.9 2000 For 20 years Spain, Portugal, and Ireland experienced growth of 2 to 3% above the EU average 2003 2001 New Europe 2002 Excl. Turkey 0.4 2003e EU* 2004-06** 9 Note: *EU only for this figures is referred to EU12; **2004-2006 CAGR A 2000 EU Commission report states that growth in New Europe countries will exceed average EU levels for the next 13 to 35 years … AND ASSURES EU-15 MEMBERS ROOM TO IMPROVE THEIR COMPETITIVENESS IN INTERNATIONAL MARKETS Weight of EU-15 Weight of EU-15 in total IMPORT in total EXPORT (2003 - %) (2003 - %) INCREASING EU COMPETITIVENESS - The relatively cheap and highly skilled labour in New Europe countries would further increase the competitiveness of European goods in the world market. The manufacturing system has in fact already initiated a profound relocalisation process aiming for better use of production factors – combined with coverage of new commercial geographies Turkey 43.0 52.2 Poland 61.1 68.8 Czech Rep. 59.2 69.8 Hungary 55.0 73.7 Romania 57.6 67.7 Slovakia 51.6 60.8 Baltics 48.7 54.8 professional levels of workforces in New Europe countries aid a profitable exchange of human capital within the EU Slovenia 67.3 58.4 TRADE BENEFITS (mainly long-term) – A foreseeably Bulgaria 49.6 56.7 Labour costs per hour – 2003 USD 22.47 % population aged 25-64 with at least upper secondary education (2002) 81 65 2.44 New EU-15 Europe1 New EU-15 Europe2 HUMAN CAPITAL – The high educational and rapid and sustainable economic boom of the countries concerned could result in a further acceleration of import growth which would further boost the growth of EU countries' GDP INCREASING ROLE IN INTERNATIONAL TRADE (mainly long-term) - Enlargement represents a chance for the Union to increase its weight in world economy and trade. Enlargement (with 10 CEE candidates) has brought more than 110 million new customers into the Union increasing the European single market to 500 million. 10 Note: (1) Considering only Eastern Central European countries; (2) Including only new EU members Source: EIU, Eurostat THE DIFFERENT PROSPECTS OF GROWTH IN THE PROPENSITY TO SAVE … Real convergence means growth in income levels that have two contrasting effects on individuals' propensity to save: A positive impact from increase in the number of households able to save A negative impact from increase in consumption appetite On balance, we foresee non-increase in individuals' propensity to save Such non-increasing saving propensity of individuals can be associated to sustainable growth pattern and catching up to EU standards. However two conditions have to be met: Fiscal control should be guaranteed (no crowding out) Current Account deficits should be financed by FDI (thus avoiding external indebtedness of the country) 11 … ATTRIBUTE A KEY ROLE TO POLICY-MAKERS Focus Policy-makers Actions Tax discipline Control on budget spending (avoiding crowding-out effects) Competitiveness Credit quality Monitoring credit quality without unduly weighing down market development 12 Infrastructures development Tax competitiveness Legal and regulatory framework Support for Small and Medium Enterprises AGENDA Market overview Key conditions for a convergence process Prospects for the New Europe financial market 13 NUMEROUS FACTORS REQUIRE THAT THE BANKING INDUSTRY MODIFY ITS OFFERING … Macroeconomic environment Financial markets Individuals Interest rates convergence towards EU levels Decreasing overall risk driving reduction in government bond spread over EU yield curve Integration in a pan-European market More opportunities with lower risks Pension reform Expectation of increase in personal income and wealth Less attractiveness for traditional banking products Switch towards more diversified and structured products Development of innovative services able to respond to new needs 14 … CALLING ON IT TO PERFORM A MAJOR ROLE IN THE CONVERGENCE PROCESS Focus Financial Institutions Actions Support for consumption and intermediation Support for development of financial sector 15 Note: (*) An approximate threshold could be fixed at 5,000 EUR GDP per capita In low income countries(*): traditional intermediation, gradual increase in lending in anticipation of consumption and support for FDI In medium income countries: lending to support anticipation of consumption (target selection), supply of more sophisticated products and support for FDI Investment banking Product development Services development … AND TUTORING MOVING TOWARDS MORE MARKETORIENTED SYSTEMS Bank Oriented System Baltics Poland Bank deposits of non Banks Debt Securities Stock Market Capitalisation (as % of GDP 2002) (as % of GDP 2002) (as % of GDP 2002) 28 10 37 Slovak R. Euro Area 15 34 54 Czech R. 21 33 58 Slovenia Hungary Market Oriented System 11 47 67 23 57 42 20 15 55 84 111 48 The convergence process will cause New Europe banking systems to gradually move from being “bank-oriented” towards being increasingly “market-oriented” 16 HOUSEHOLD WEALTH: GROWTH PROSPECTS IN NEW EUROPE Alessandro Profumo CEO UniCredit Rome, June 8, 2004