Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Mounting tensions Student worksheet Slow burner: a heightened sense of international tension War is merely the continuation of politics by other means’, Carl von Clausewitz wrote around 1830. A lot of ‘politics’ had been happening in the sixteen years previous to the start of World War One. International diplomacy had been used over and over again to reduce the tension and to keep the peace. Yet, in 1914 war was started anyway. Why did the peace fail then? What made the situation 1914 different from that of previous years? In the description above it is assumed that something must have been different in Europe in 1914 in comparison to previous occasions. The result was different at least: after keeping the peace time and again, now a war was started. To get to an understanding why in one situation diplomacy suffices, while in another people decide to go to war, you’ll need to do a comparison. In this activity you will do just that: you will pair up with a fellow student and together you will compare the situation in 1914 with the situation in previous years. Using several line graphs you will analyse the development of the international tension in different regions of Europe between 1898 and 1914. With this information you will formulate an answer to the central enquiry question: Why did the peace fail in 1914? Step 1: Teaming up Get into pairs. As a pair: Discuss the enquiry question and your preconceptions about why World War One started in 1914. Step 2: Mapping the international relations A: Read through the list of events on worksheet 1 and for each individual relation between two countries draw a line between those two in worksheet 2. B: Interpret your connecting graph. Which countries were the most connected? Which countries were the least connected? What does this mean for international relations between 1898 and 1914? Step 3: Grading international relations As a pair: Provide each of the events on the list on worksheet 1 with a ‘grade’ for tension, for each of the three regions of Europe. +3 heavily increased tension between these countries +2 increased tension between these countries +1 little increased tension between these countries 0 no tension between these countries -1 little decreased tension between these countries -2 decreased tension between these countries -3 largely decreased tension between these countries Explain for each of the ‘gradings’ what you based it on. Step 4: Visualising and interpreting the data A: As a pair: Put the ‘grades’ for each of the regions in the corresponding graph in worksheet 3 by putting dots with the corresponding value in the corresponding year. Connect the dots in each graph to form three line graphs. Compare the line graphs and decide if the situation in 1914 contrasts with the earlier situations. B: Answer the enquiry question: why did the peace fail in 1914? Step 5: Sharing As a group: Present your findings in a short pitch of your answer to the enquiry question. Compare your findings to those of the other groups. What are the biggest differences and similarities between your graphs? How has this effected the answers to the enquiry question? Step 6: Reflecting Look back at the entire enquiry process. Describe for step 2, 3, 4 and 5 what they constituted to your understanding of the start of World War One. Make note of how you approached each step (2, 3, 4 and 5). Make note of what (new) insight each step (2, 3, 4 and 5) gave you. Discuss with your neighbour the use of graphs as a visual representation to facilitate comparing and contrasting historical situations and phenomena. Worksheet 1 International tension in Europe 1898 – 1914 (1/3) Date July 1898 May 1903 Situation Britain and France came close to war when colonial rivalry was inflamed by the Fashoda Incident, when Capt Marchand led a French force into Sudan. There were rumours that the French were considering making an alliance with Germany against Britain. Britain’s relations with France were greatly improved by the success of King Edward VII’s state visit to Paris. This paved the way for the Anglo-French agreement of 1904 known as the Entente Cordiale. February 1904 War began in the Far East between Japan and Russia, after Japan’s surprise attack on Port Arthur. October 1904 Fears were aroused of war between Britain and Russia after the Dogger Bank Incident, when British trawlers were sunk by Russian warships on their way to fight against Japan, Britain’s ally. March 1905 Kaiser Wilhelm II’s provcative visit to Tangier led to the First Morocco Crisis. The French army was mobilised ready for war. France was supported by Britain. September 1905 The American President, Theodore Roosevelt, mediated between Japan and Russia at Portsmouth, New Hampshire, ending the Russo-Japanese War. Relations between Britain, France and Germany Relations between Russia, Germany and AustriaHungary Relations between the Balkans, AustriaHungary and Russia Worksheet 1 International tension in Europe 1898 – 1914 (2/3) Date Situation April 1906 An international conference at Algeciras in Spain, atternded by all the European powers, settled the First Morocco Crisis and reduced international tensions. August 1907 Anglo-Russian Entente settled differences between the two powers and enabled the formation of the Triple Entente with France. October 1908 There were renewed fears of war in the Balkans when Austria-Hungary annexed Bosnia-Herzegovina, leading to furious protests from Serbia, Croatia, Russia and the Ottoman Empire. Austria was strongly supported by warlike statements by the German Kaiser. March 1909 The Bosnian Crisis was ended by the decision of Serbia to accept the annexation of Bosnia after Russia backed down from open conflict with Germany. July 1911 In May 1911 the French occupied Morocco on the pretext of suppressing a rebellion against the sultan. The decision of Germany to send a gunboat, Panther, to Agadir caused a second damgerous crisis over Morocco, with both France and Britain putting their navies on full alert ready for war. November 1911 The Agadir Crisis was resolved by lengthy French-German negotiations to agree new borders. October 1912 The Ottoman Empire was invaded by the forces of the Balkan League: Serbia, Montenegro, Bulgaria and Greece. There were fears that this First Balkan War might spill over into a general European war. Relations between Britain, France and Germany Relations between Russia, Germany and AustriaHungary Relations between the Balkans, AustriaHungary and Russia Worksheet 1 International tension in Europe 1898 – 1914 (3/3) Date Situation May 1913 After intensive mediation by the Great Powers, the First Balkan War was ended by the Treaty of London. June 1913 The peace terms of the Treaty of London led to conflict between Serbia and Bulgaria over control of Macedonia. This led to the Second Balkan War when Bulgaria invaded her former allies. August 1913 Bulgaria’s lack of success against her former allies led to her accepting the offer of peace negotiations. The Second Balkan War was ended by the Treaty of Bucharest. June 1914 July 1914 The heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne, Archduke Franz Ferdinand, was assassinated in Sarajevo by Bosnian Serb terrorists of the Black Hand movement. This led to a major international crisis as Austria-Hungary blamed Serbia and threatened retaliation. It was widely expected that an international conference would be held, possibly in London, to resolve the tensions between Austria-Hungary, Serbia and Russia. Many leading statesmen decided to take their usual summer holidays. BUT…. Relations between Britain, France and Germany Relations between Russia, Germany and AustriaHungary Relations between the Balkans, AustriaHungary and Russia Worksheet 2: International relations 1898-1914