Download Define the terms identity, ethnicity, race, class, culture

Wendy Campbell 10014139
Identity, Belief and Culture
Shantikara
Define the terms identity, ethnicity, ‘race’, class, culture and gender, and explore the
differences, similarities and links between them.
Briefly discuss the nature of religion, and the relationship between identity and belief
from both religious and non-religious perspectives.
Suggest ways in which schools can positively acknowledge and affirm the identities of
learners from a diverse range of cultural, ethnic or religious backgrounds, both in the
curriculum and in their organisation.
In today’s multicultural society, groups and individuals identify themselves and live
within the context of their ethnicity, ‘race’, class, culture and gender. A clearer
understanding of the terms and how they are interlinked, also how the role of religion
plays a part within this framework can help schools to promote tolerance and acceptance
of a rich diversity of people both throughout the curriculum and within their
establishment.
Any individual can identify themselves on a myriad of levels: in a personal sense, a social
sense, on an ethnic, cultural, spiritual or religious basis and by way of their moral values.
As a consequence, identities can be seen as flexible or even conflicting (cited in
Bhavnani and Phoenix 1994), with no one person’s identity being the same as another,
and each person having their own unique mix of allegiances (Richardson and Wood
2000). In order for any individual to feel valued all of these separate themes need to be
acknowledged. Cummins suggests,
‘Affirmation of identity thus refers to the establishment of
the respect and trust between educators and students…”
(1996, pg 4)
1
Wendy Campbell 10014139
Identity, Belief and Culture
Shantikara
therefore proposing that shared understanding of a student’s perspectives is critical to the
approval of their personal identity. Furthermore, the negotiation of an individual’s
identity has far reaching effects for their sense of self and both personal and social
aspirations.
Ethnicity refers to a collection or nation of people who are more than a mere collective
group but an aggregate consciously related by common origins and shared experiences.
Incorporated into a group’s ethnicity is a distinct language, religious beliefs and political
institutions which are passed down generations. (Cashmore, 1984). Similarly Madge
(2001) considers a list of requirements that embodies ethnicity which include country of
origin, society, aspects of skin colour and culture. However Meighan and Siraj –
Blatchford (2003) argue that everyone has an ethnic and cultural identity but often the
term ‘ethnic’ is used to objectify a minority group or as a
‘…euphemism for ‘black’’.
(pg 350)
Meighan and Siraj – Blatchford (2003) also remind us that
there is no scientific
foundation for defining the human races, that the variation within the human population
is bigger than between; humans are in fact therefore more homogenous that any other
species. This view is shared by Jones (1991) who believes that what is meant by ‘race’, is
in effect colour. He argues that classifying people leads to judging people which in turn
2
Wendy Campbell 10014139
Identity, Belief and Culture
Shantikara
leads to prejudice (cited in Haralambus and Holburn 2000).
The term ‘class’ is purely a social stratification of wealth and prestige the result being
social inequalities. An individual’s class position can be predetermined by birth, ‘race’
and education nonetheless sociologists argue that within a capitalist society, an
individual’s class position can be largely achieved (Haralambus and Holburn
2000).Unlike the Indian belief in the caste system by which you are born into your class
and remain so.
Cultures, argues Cashmore (1984), are not rigid but evolve and develop. Cultural
traditions can be indistinct within a society for example because of technological
advances. Culture has many definitions but the definition made by Linton (1945) who
considered culture as a way of life for its members, a gathering of routines and ideas that
are shared and conveyed to further generations has common links with the idea of
ethnicity, so the two seem to be intrinsically linked.
Gender has far reaching effects within some social settings for the individual. While ‘sex’
is the biological difference between male and female, gender is the social construction
and the cultural role that society imposes upon the individual. (Abbot and Wallace 1997).
The role of the individual, depending on their ‘race’ and gender and within their cultural
and ethnic setting helps to establish their personal and social identity and so each have
inherent common characteristics.
3
Wendy Campbell 10014139
Identity, Belief and Culture
Shantikara
A belief is something which is true and real for the individual whether or not it is based
on factual evidence or a belief based on a religious or faith institution. Taylor et al (2002)
define religion as a collective of individuals with a shared system of beliefs who adhere
to a set of approved practices and activities while Hammer (1995) defines religion as a
system of beliefs and practices that help the participants cope with life.This can often be
at the heart of a people (cited in Taylor et al 2000). Dimensions often regarded as
fundamental to a religion can shape the individual. Smart (1968) identifies seven
common dimensions that religions share: Doctrinal, Mythological, Ethical, Ritual,
Experiential, Social and Material. (cited in Bastide, 1987).
Doctrines or common beliefs are shared by followers therefore uniting them, but this
idea is not exclusive to religion; non religious sectors share common beliefs particularly
in light of loss of faith in institutions and belief systems by members of society. An
example of this is the emergence of New Age beliefs, developing spirituality through
individualism (Haralomobos and Holburn 2000).
The mythological dimension relates to stories, myths and historical narratives that are
passed down through generations such as the Bible and the Qur’an. Copley states that
stories are
“..central to the great world faiths”
(Copley, 1994, pg 28)
4
Wendy Campbell 10014139
Identity, Belief and Culture
Shantikara
and suggests that stories can be used as a useful teaching and learning tool. This allows
individuals to think about their beliefs, whether secular or religious, in terms of the
themes and morals of the story.
Similarly, the Ethical doctrine relates to the way in which a life is lived. This is more a
moral code of living that can be taught and developed through historical narratives.
Religion often provides the guiding rule for human actions and principles of conduct with
social values firmly rooted in religion even for secular beliefs, with the recognised moral
code for the Christian faith being the Ten Commandments (Taylor et al, 2000).
Rituals, festivals and ceremonies endorse social solidarity whatever the event and
promote a sense of social unity, as does group worship by unifying individuals and
upholding their sense of belonging. The same sense of community can be felt within a
non religious or secular context from the football terraces to the Scouts and Brownie
packs each with shared ceremonies and symbols continuing this sense of membership
(Taylor et al, 2000).
The Experiential doctrine deals with the supernatural element of faith, the inner strength
provided by the faith an individual has in a belief system and the overwhelming trust and
certainty for that faith. This trust and confidence however is not exclusive to religious
belief and can be attributed to those who have humanist ideals, occult or pagan beliefs
(Harolombus and Holburn 2000).
5
Wendy Campbell 10014139
Identity, Belief and Culture
Shantikara
The Social doctrine considers the shared interests and communal involvement of
followers of a religion, valuing the need for being a part of something. Shared worship
and rituals can create a sense of belonging and unity therefore providing a social support
for each other. (Taylor et al, 2000). This aspect of social inclusion is shared by many non
secular movements also.
Finally, the Material dimension relates to buildings, important works of art and places.
Many religions have sacred places in which to worship and also important places
geographically that they visit. These include Lourdes, Mount Sinai and the river Ganges
to name a few. However non-religious groups also identify with places of worship for
example Stonehenge is particularly important to Paganism.
Educators have an immense task of positively affirming all of the children in their
establishment in order to create a sense of inclusion. Increased understanding of equal
opportunities within a school creates an inclusive environment which benefits all children
regardless of ‘race’, sex, ability or background. There is however the concern of the
“hidden curriculum” by which children are learning attitudes from their educators that go
toward the reproduction of potentially negative aspects of our culture (Meighan and Siraj
– Blatchford, 2003).
Within most classrooms various faiths are represented. Affirming a child by
acknowledging and celebrating their religion helps to extend the knowledge of others
6
Wendy Campbell 10014139
Identity, Belief and Culture
Shantikara
around them. This way, children understand that people and religions are not all the same
while celebrating their richness and diversity (Copley, 1994).
From a personal perspective, I firmly believe that children should be entitled to celebrate
their individual skin colours without risk of racism or stereotyping. Having mixed race
children myself has highlighted the fact that racism is still alive and well in UK society.
For example, subtle messages during unguarded moments from well-meaning
acquaintances - ‘well he’ll be good at sports, won’t he’ –have, unfortunately confirmed
this.
The Barnet Civic Forum developed the ‘Celebrating Diversity Action Team’ to enable
children in school to challenge racism. With a wide cross section of faith and ethnic
minority members, the team issued a statement which announced a stance on diversity
and racism. In brief, they were to value and celebrate the diversity of cultures, faiths and
languages; allow everyone to participate fully in the life of a community; acknowledge
that racism prevents this; challenge all forms of discrimination and stand up to racism.
This action motivated both the children and parents take the issue of racism seriously
(Paxton, 2003). Another successful approach was Bradford’s Linking Schools Projects
whereby two very different schools within the same district, one with English as the first
language and one with mainly South East Asian heritage and English as a second
language, were brought together to promote friendship and tolerance in a bridge building
exercise, in view of the inclusive nature of the exercise children with physical and
behavioural difficulties were included, the results being an undoubted success. (Ackroyd
7
Wendy Campbell 10014139
Identity, Belief and Culture
Shantikara
et al 2003) These positive and successful approaches could surely be adapted and used
throughout Primary school.
Equally, black people should be positively represented throughout the curriculum so that
white children appreciate the valuable contributions other cultures have made to human
progress. Positive images of a wide variety of different ethnic groups should be displayed
in order to challenge stereotypes and to instill self-worth and respect. A further issues is
the media portrayal of particular groups which can serve to perpetuate stereotypes – for
example Black people are often portrayed as athletic or criminal, and some countries are
only portrayed as famine-stricken.( Brown 1990).
The same inclusive approach needs to be extended to those children who live with a
disability. Brown (1990) states that often people refer to someone as ‘a disabled person’
recognising only their disability and attitudes such as this need to be addressed. All
children should be given the opportunity to interact with each other and positive images
of people with disabilities are presented to the children not stereo typical images.
Equipment, toys and activities should be accessible for all children to be able to play
together dispelling any misconceptions or fears in other children and provide support and
knowledge to those who need it.
Similarly the need to be inclusive and aware of the hidden curriculum lies in the way
boys and girls are differentiated. Sexism is often based on the idea that an individual’s
sex predetermines their potential therefore restricting opportunities, with females often
8
Wendy Campbell 10014139
Identity, Belief and Culture
Shantikara
discriminated against the most because of patriarchal attitudes. Gender attitudes develop
early therefore children need to see both sexes involved in a wide-ranging variety of roles
both conventional and unconventional to ensure acceptance. It is essential that the
curriculum includes females particularly within Science, History and Literature topics as
stereotypical imagery within school texts perpetuates imbalances in society. (Robinson
and Richardson, 1997). Wallace and Abbot (1997) warn that even with the introduction
of the National Curriculum girls are subtly encouraged to make choices that propel into
‘female’ jobs and a secondary role within a patriarchal society. It is crucial that the
attitudes of educators reflect an inclusive society and do not unintentionally reflect
stereotypical roles, for example asking a boy to carry something heavy but asking a girl
to wash the paint pots.
The expectations of a child are often based not on objective evidence about them, but on
assumptions made about them. Many of these are inferred or unconscious and not
expressed, and are usually related to ‘race’, culture, ethnicity, gender and social class
(Richardson, 2002). It is an educator’s job to embrace and acknowledge the rich diversity
all the children collectively bring to the classroom, while understanding that the children
do not need to be treated the same because they are not the same as each other, but be
respected and accepted for their differences.
(Word count 2001)
9
Wendy Campbell 10014139
Identity, Belief and Culture
Shantikara
REFERENCES
Abbot, P. and Wallace, C. (1997) An Introduction to Sociology – feminist perspective.
London: Routledge
Ackroyd,C, Grant,p ,Kershaw,J Kotler,A. (2003) Building Bridges – Making Links:
Bradford’s Linking Schools Project, 2001 – 2004 Race Equality Teaching, Vol. 21, No.3,
Summer. pp11 - 14
Bastide, D. (1987) Religious Education 5 – 12. Lewes : Falmer Press
Bhavnani & Pheonix (1994) Shifting Identities, Shifting Racisms – a Feminism &
Psychology reader. Sage: London
Brown, B. (1990) All our children – a guide for those who care. BBC EDUCATION
Cashmore, E,E. (1984) Dictionary of Race and Ethnic Relations. London :Routledge and
Kegan Paul
Copley, T. (1994) Religious Education 7 - 11 developing primary teaching skills.
London: Routledge
Cummins, J. (1996) Negotiating Identities: Education for empowerment in a Diverse
Society. Ontario :C.A.B.E
Haralambos and Holborn (2000) Sociology themes and Perspectives 6th edition London :
Harper Collins
Madge, N. (2001) Understanding difference The meaning of ethnicity for young lives.
National Childrens Bureau : London
10
Wendy Campbell 10014139
Identity, Belief and Culture
Shantikara
Meighan,R. & Siraj – Blatchford (2003) A Sociology of Educating 4th edition. London :
Continuum
Paxton, J. (2003) Celebrating diversity/challenging racism – a project for secondary
schools. Race Equality Teaching Vol 21. No 2 Summer pp 26 – 28
Richardson,R. (2002) Expectations great and small – the mental maps of teachers and
systems. Race Equality Teaching. Vol 21. No 1 Autumn pp15 - 19
Richardson and Wood (2000) Inclusive Schools Inclusive Society - race and identity on
the agenda. London: Trentham Books
Robinson,V. and Richardson, D. (1997) Introducing Women’s Studies. 2nd edition.
Hampshire:PALGRAVE
Taylor et al (2002) Sociology in Focus. Lancashire : The Causeway Press
11