Download Rethinking Foreign Policy

Document related concepts

Political economy in anthropology wikipedia , lookup

State (polity) wikipedia , lookup

Postdevelopment theory wikipedia , lookup

Transcript
Agency, structure, IR and foreign policy╇╇ 37
There is a straightforward and important sense in which neorealist and other
systemic theories are indeed theories of foreign policy. Namely, the things
that structural realist theory seeks to explain, such as balancing, the prob�
ability of major power war, or a general disposition to competitive interstate
relations are either foreign policies or the direct (if sometimes unintended)
result of foreign policies. .â•›.â•›. In this natural sense, then, systemic and neorealist theories emphatically are theories of foreign policy.
(1998: 292–293)
Yet this position has implications for any account of the unit-�level factors that
might help explain foreign policy, and when allied to Carlsanes’ claim to
embrace elements of an interpretive epistemology it will require some theoretical location where intentions, beliefs and motivations can be specified. To my
mind, this can only logically be achieved at the level of human agents, albeit
agents deeply embedded within and constituted by the structural contexts they
inhabit. Or, as Carlsnaes himself puts it, ‘action is always a combination of purposive behaviour, cognitive-Â�psychological factors and the various structural phenomena characterising societies and their environments’ (2002: 342).
From levels-�of-analysis to foreign policy
One barrier to such an integrated approach within IR, however, is the level of
analysis problem, which is clearly closely related to the ASP. Indeed, at one
point during the debate with Hollis and Smith on the ASP Wendt complains that
Hollis and Smith ‘reduce the agent–structure problem to one of the levels of
analysis’ (Wendt 1992: 181). Carlsnaes’ position on this issue is interesting
because it seems that he can only be advocating a position on the level-�ofanalysis issue that is very similar to my own; although admittedly he has not
articulated this explicitly. In short, I believe Carlsnaes’ position on the agent–
structure problem, when combined with his commitment to elements of an interpretive epistemology, and his view of foreign policy, require a fundamental
reconfiguration of the levels-�of-analysis issue along the lines indicated in my
book Agents, Structures and International Relations: Politics as Ontology
(2006).
There is no doubt that thinking about IR in terms of levels is deeply ingrained
in the disciplinary psyche. David Singer’s (1961) influential piece on this issue is
rightly considered a landmark in the theoretical development of the discipline.4
According to R.B.J. Walker, this way of thinking about the discipline is ‘all pervasive’ (1993: 131). Moreover, for Walker all talk of levels may be seriously misleading since it implies a vertical ordering of the relations between individuals,
states and system, whereas these might be better grasped as horizontal relationships (ibid.: 134). I think, however, that it is possible to defend a vertical yet non-�
hierarchical (in the sense of an a priori privileging of one level over another)
account of levels whilst accepting and expanding on Walker’s horizontal point. In
effect, the image we need is one of vertical levels spread horizontally.