Download The Later Evolution of Low Mass Stars (< 8 solar masses)

The sun - past and future
The Later Evolution of
Low Mass Stars
(< 8 solar masses)
During 10 billion years
the suns luminosity
changes only by about
a factor of two.
After that though,
changes become
rapid
http://apod.nasa.gov/apod/astropix.html
What happens when
the sun runs out of
hydrogen in its center?
H
He
The outer envelopes of
H
He
10.9 x 109 yr
L
T
All surfaces become convective
Recall convective structure on the main sequence
Evolution to
Red Giant
Stage
cross hatching
indicates where
in the HRdiagram a star
spends a long
time.
H-shell ignition
M > 2.0
Type I Cepheids are shortlived-stages of massive
stars as the cross the HR diagram on the way to
becoming red giants.
Red Giant 1.3 Gy
He core burning 100 My
Helium Burning
and Beyond
3
*
lasting only a few minutes. Up to 100 billion solar luminosities in center.
Adjustment time scale ~105 yr
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helium_flash
Helium Burning
4He
+ 4He 8Be
8Be
+ 4He 12C + Helium burning, often called the triple alpha process occurs above
temperatures of 100,000,000 K. 8Be is unstable and decays back into
He in 2.6 10–16 secs, but in the stellar interior a small equilibrium of
8Be exists. The 8Be ground state has almost exactly the energy of two
alpha particles. In the second step, 8Be + 4He has almost exactly the
energy of an excited state of 12C. This resonance greatly increases
the chances of Helium fusing and was predicted by Fred Hoyle.
As a side effect some Carbon fuses with Helium to form Oxygen:
12C
+ 4He 16O + The net result is:
3
(
4
)
He 12
C + 7.27 MeV
or 5.8 x 1017 erg g-1
The extra burning to oxygen, 12C(,)16O raises
this to 7.5 x 1017 erg g-1, or about 10% of what
hydrogen burning gave.
Because helium burning produces less energy and
because the luminosities are actually greater, helium
burning is a shorter stage in the life of a star than
the main sequence.
The Sun
Horizonal
Branch
Star
For stars of one
solar mass and less,
lower mass HB stars
are hotter (bluer) than
higher mass ones
The globular cluster M10. The bright yellow and orange
stars are red giants burning hydrogen in a shell, but the
bright blue stars are horizontal branch stars, burning
helium in their centers. Both kinds of stars are more
massive and brighter than the low mass main sequence stars
in M10.
Globular Cluster M5
http://www.dur.ac.uk/ian.smail/gcCm/gcCm_intro.html
M
TO = turn off mass; HB = horizonal branch;
Gap is a region of atmospheric instability
AGB STARS
The Seven Ages of the Sun
• Main sequence
10.9 Gy
• First red giant
1.3 Gy
• Helium burning
100 My
•Second red giant
20 My
•Unstable pulsation
400 Ky
•Planetary nebula
10 Ky
•White dwarf
forever
Cutaway drawing of the interior structure of an Asymptotic Giant Branch
or AGB star. Hydrogen an helium burning shells are both active, though
not necessarily both at the same time. The He and H burning regions
are much thinner than this diagram suggests. The outer layers are convective.
The C-O core is degenerate and transports its radiation by conduction.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_Nebula
AGB stars are known to lose mass at a prodigious rate during their final
stages, around 10-5 - 10-4 solar masses per year. This obviously cannot
persist for much over 100,000 years.
The mass loss is driven in part by the pulsational instability
of the thin helium shell. These pulses grow more violent
with time. Also, and probably more importantly, the outer
layers of the star get so large
and cool owing to the high
luminosity, that they form
dust. The dust increases the
opacity and material is
blown away at speeds
~ 10 – 30 km s-1
The evolution is terminated
as the outer layers of the star
are blown away.
The Ring Negula in Lyra (M57)
700 pc; magnitute 8.8
NGC 2440 – White dwarf ejecting envelope. One of the
hottest white dwarfs known is in the center of the picture
About 200,000 K and 250 times the sun’s luminosity
http://homepage.oma.be/gsteene/poster.html
Note the consequences for nucleosynthesis here.
Blinking eye
Egg
Kissing squid
Hourglass
Cats Eye
Red Rectangle
The outer layers of the star contain hydrogen and helium
to be sure, but also nitrogen from CNO processing and C
and O from helium burning. It is thought that stars in this
mass range are responsible for producing most of the
nitrogen and maybe 60 – 80% of the carbon in the universe.
The rest of carbon and most other elements comes from
massive stars.
Additional Nucleosynthesis – The s-Process.
years
44.5 days
This is called the slow process of neutron addition
or the s-process. (There is also a r-process)
The s-process of neutron addition
Beginning of the s-process
63Cu
60Ni
Z
59Co
56Fe
57Fe
58Fe
N
61Ni
62Ni
60Co
61Co
59Fe
60Fe
5.27 y
44.5 d
64Cu
12.7 h
63Ni
100 y
= (n,)
= (e-)
Each neutron capture takes you one step to the
right in this diagram. Each decay of a neutron to a
proton inside the nucleus moves you up a left diagonal.
WHITE DWARFS
MASS RADIUS RELATION
FOR WHITE DWARFS
if supported by
GM non-relativistic electron
Pc =
= 1.00 1013 ( Ye )5/3
2R
degeneracy pressure
3M GM 5/3
5/3
4 R 3 GM 3M 1 = 1.00 1013 4 R 3 2 2R
2R
2
3G M
13 3 4 = 1.00 10 8 R
8
M
1/3
5/3
3
= 1.00 10 8 2/3
13
R = 3.631019 / M 1/ 3
M R = 2.9 10 M 8
1/ 3
cm
M 5/3
R5
1
GR
White dwarfs are
known with
temperatures
ranging from 4000 K
to 200,000 K
IK Pegasi A
Class A star
P = 21.7 days
The sun
IK Pegasi B
Te = 35,500 K
THE CHANDRASEKHAR MASS
As usual examine the constant density case for guidance
As M gets larger and the radius decreases, the density rises
3M 4 R 3 3
Eventually at greater than about 10 g cm electrons in the
central part of the white dwarf start to move close to the speed
of light. As the mass continues to grow, a larger fraction of the
star is supported by relativistic electron degeneracy pressure.
Consider the limit:
GM 4 /3
R
= 1.24 1015 ( Ye ) =
Pdeg
2R
7
1.24 10
15
Ye4/3
M
2/3
3M 4 R 3 1/3
=
Nb. R drops out
= 1.24 10
15
GM
= Pcentral / 2R
Ye4/3 3 4 1/3
2
G
M 2/3 = 2.3 10 22 Ye4/3
M = 3.5 10 33 Ye2 gm = 1.75 Ye2 M Actually
M = 5.7 Ye2 M = 1.4 M if Ye = 0.5
Aside:
This result extends beyond white dwarfs.
There can be no stable star whose pressure
depends on its density to the 4/3 power
EVOLUTION OF WHITE DWARF STARS
Crystallization in white dwarfs
When the interior temperature
declines to ~5000 K, the
carbon and oxygen start
to crystallize into a lattice.
This crystallization releases
energy and provides a
source of luminosity that
slows the cooling.
The number counts pile up.
For a WD of constant mass, R = constant
Hansen et al (2007)
NGC 6397 - globular cluster
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_dwarf
The coolest, faintest white dwarfs still have a
surface temperature of ~4000 K. The universe
is not old enough for black dwarfs to have
formed yet.
Critical Masses
0.08 M Contracting protostars below this mass do not ignite hydrogen
burning on the main sequence. They become brown dwarfs or planets.
0.50 M Stars below this mass are completely convective on the main sequence
do not ignite helium burning
2.0 M E.g., 0.59 solar mass WD - like the sun will make takes about 1.5 billion years to cool to 7140 K
and another 1.8 billion years to cool to 5550 K.
Stars below this mass (and above .5) experience the helium core flash
Stars above this mass are powered by the CNO cycle (below by the pp-cycles)
Stars above this mass have convective cores on the main sequence (and
radiative surfaces)
8 M
Stars below this mass do not ignite carbon burning. They end their lives
as planetary nebulae and white dwarfs. Stars above this mass make supernovae.
~ 150 M Population I stars much above this mass pulse apart on the main sequence.
No heavier stars exist.