Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Kontos 1 Michael Kontos Harry Davidson Music 89S November 14th, 2012 Improvisation – How Bach Spawned a New Generation of Music Improvisation is a specific style of music where a performer has the major influence on his or her music. The emotion and feeling that is flowing through the performer at the very moment of musical creation is utilized to freely develop an individual idea on top of the subject of a piece. This style is one that is totally unique to the performer and yields a different performance every time. One of the founders of this unique style was composer Johann Sebastian Bach. Bach was born to a family of musicians in 1685 in Eisenach, a small town within Germany. His movement across Germany over the course of his life caused him to have a dynamic musical style.1 Because Bach was born in the early Baroque period, he was thrown into a generation of music where the composers “sought to describe with objectivity, feelings and emotions, which were distinct from what they actually felt.”2 For example, most Baroque pieces sounded busy and were full of a diverse instrumentation that one could generally associate with a negative emotion.3 1 “Johann Sebastian Bach’s Life,” last modified March 29, 2002, http://www.let.rug.nl/Linguistics/diversen/bach/map.html 2 “Baroque Music ‐ Part 1,” by Elaine Thornburgh, accessed November 9th, 2012. http://trumpet.sdsu.edu/M151/Baroque_Music1.html 3 “Baroque Music,” Music of the Baroque, accessed November 9th, 2012. http://www.baroque.org/baroque/whatis.htm Kontos 2 However, another style that is not necessarily associated with negative emotion is improvisation. This style, which is seen today in most Jazz music pieces, really began with a young Johann Sebastian Bach. These early pieces spawned the generation of improvisation, which led to an influence on future artists such as John Coltrane and Bobby McFerrin. Bach wrote and performed plenty of pieces that show the basic idea that comes with this improvisational style, but there are a few in particular that demonstrate what the style was about and could have easily influenced future artists. Ordinarily, a piece will start with the introduction of a subject. This subject will be played repeatedly throughout the piece and can be played, in some cases, across all instrumentation. Improvisation is incorporated into these pieces usually by the soloist. Once he or she has finished playing through the subject, they will improvise and play on top of the other instruments, which are ordinarily mimicking the soloist or playing in a style called “comping”. Comping involves the lower register instruments filling out the chord while the soloist bases their solo around the chord progression. This section allows for bending, sliding, trilling, or anything else that the performer believes would better the piece as a whole. For example, in Bach’s Violin Concerto in A Minor (BWV 1041), the soloist, the violin 1 on the top of the staff, begins the piece by playing the subject while the orchestra backs him to form a basic chord progressions as seen here4: 4 “Violin Concerto in A Minor, BWV 1041 (Bach, Johann Sebastian),” last updated December 5th, 2006. Kontos 3 But after the subject is finished, the violinist begins to elaborate more on the subject and add more and more of his own flourishes and elegance to the piece. The more elaborate subject can be seen later on the piece here5 Now, this is not exactly improvisation because the soloist is not freely applying his own style to the music. He is playing what is written on the page, but, because the subject becomes more complex, it shows the change in the music throughout the piece. This is just the beginning of what we know today as improvisation. http://imslp.org/wiki/Violin_Concerto_in_A_minor,_BWV_1041_(Bach,_Johann_Seba stian) 5 ibid. http://imslp.org/wiki/Violin_Concerto_in_A_minor,_BWV_1041_(Bach,_Johann_Seba stian) Kontos 4 Some of the other pieces that Bach composed during his lifetime that showed his desire to improvise were his short organ pieces. When Bach first began performing music as an organist, it was said that often times, the chorus within the church he performed in would become lost because his rendition of the piece would move in directions they did not recognize. One of his pieces that easily demonstrates the improvisational style is his organ work titled “Wo soll ich fliehen hin?” (BWV 646) which can be translated as, “Whither shall I flee?” This piece immediately begins with the subject being introduced on the organ. As the piece progresses however, Bach begins to layer multiple other parts on top of the subject. Not only does this make it is almost impossible to determine what the rhythm of the piece is, but the subject of the piece also becomes lost within the chaotic new piece. While this is not exactly what improvisation is defined as, it still shows how a performer can take what was provided to him and incorporate his own style to the piece. Bach chose to layer his original subject with what he felt would sound best over top of that. Throughout the rest of his career, Bach continued to emulate the style associated with improvisation. This must have reflected upon John Coltrane as he integrated into the world of Jazz music. Coltrane, the world famous saxophonist, was born in 1926 in Hamlet, North Carolina. Similar to Bach, Coltrane was always surrounded by music. His father, who was employed as a tailor, had an immense love for music and fueled John’s desire to become a musician. Even from the early age of 13, John Coltrane listened to and imitated the sounds of saxophonists such as Charlie Parker and Johnny Hodges. Unfortunately, in 1939, when Coltrane was only Kontos 5 13, his father, grandparents and uncle all passed away, leaving his family to be run solely by Coltrane’s mother, Alice. When his family decided to move north in order to find work, Coltrane stayed and finished high school while living with family friends. In 1943, he ended up moving toward his family in order advance his career as an aspiring musician. He studied at both Granoff Studios as well as the Ornstein School of Music in Philadelphia. Unfortunately, wartime came calling and Coltrane was asked to serve the country. Despite the negative connotation associated with wartime, Coltrane managed to make his first Jazz recording with a few of his fellow Navy sailors. At the conclusion of his service, he returned to Philadelphia and began playing with more jazz bands. He managed to play with prestigious performers such as Dizzy Gillespie and Duke Ellington, all the while building a name for himself. Soon after being fired from his gig with Duke Ellington due to his drug dependencies, Coltrane managed to sign with Columbia records and join the Miles Davis Quintet. He filled out their group with a smooth tenor saxophone sound that complimented the groups’ brass and piano. Unfortunately, after a brief stint together, Miles Davis fired Coltrane for his inability to give up heroine and soon afterwards, John Coltrane began his solo career. This new opportunity would allow him to release to the world what he believed to be his own, unique sound and style of Jazz music.6 Jazz music is “not the result of choosing a tune, but an ideal that is created first in the mind, inspired by one’s passion, and willed next in playing music. Its unique expression draws from life experience and human emotion as the inspiration of the creative force, and through this discourse has chronicled the history of a 6 “John Coltrane: biography” last updated 2012, http://www.biography.com/people/john‐coltrane‐9254106 Kontos 6 people.”7 It truly depends on the performer to put their personalities and feelings forward and play the music from their soul. It is the epitome of improvisation, in that any performer must be providing their individual influence on the work. This strikes the listener very similarly to the way Baroque style music would: full of emotion. There is the potential for the music to be crazy; anger rushing through the artist’s mind conveyed through a loud and chaotic tune with an innumerable amount of brass instruments, or it could be a slow and quiet piano concerto that depicts someone suffering from hidden love. The parallels between the two styles are simply obvious. Just as Bach’s music began this offshoot of musical style, some of Coltrane’s most iconic works were excellent representations of improvisation. For example, in one of his most widely recognized pieces “Impressions,” Coltrane introduces the subject in the first bar of the music and then proceeds to make up the entire song within the moment. Even the sheet music just shows an oversimplified version of the subject and then encourages the performer to improvise from there8: 7 “Jazz History and Jazz Education” last updated 2012, http://www.apassion4jazz.net/ 8 “John Coltrane‐Impressions” (screenshot), Online Sheet Music, accessed on November 10th, 2012. http://www.onlinesheetmusic.com/impressions‐ p403769.aspx?utm_expid=47617476‐ 1&utm_referrer=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com%2Furl%3Fsa%3Dt%26rct%3 Dj%26q%3D%26esrc%3Ds%26source%3Dweb%26cd%3D5%26ved%3D0CFAQFj AE%26url%3Dhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.onlinesheetmusic.com%252Fimpres sions‐ p403769.aspx%26ei%3D29KjUNe_KYSm8gSRg4DoDQ%26usg%3DAFQjCNGSf2Upa YqKav5VVVgtwHE4clC4MA Kontos 7 It can almost be guaranteed that the recording of “Impressions” is unique. Any performance or any other opportunity Coltrane had to record that piece would almost certainly be different, because ordinarily, a human would not be feeling exactly the same way emotionally each time they performed the piece. A second piece that demonstrates improvisation was “In a Sentimental Mood,” which Coltrane popularized with fellow performer Duke Ellington. Despite being similar to Impressions in form, this song has a much slower tempo and adds Duke Ellington on the piano. Instead of the subject being introduced by the soloist and then having that transition into complete improvisation, each performer has an individual subject that they introduce. Despite the fact that these two subjects are completely different, there is a very obvious “mirroring” to what Ellington and Coltrane are playing. This performance is indicative of the fact that each performer is fully involved within the music. The two are capable of having a conversation back and forth, throwing their emotion into their respective sections of the piece. Ellington is given an extended period of time to solo, changing the overall key of the piece from minor to major, forcing the listener to change their mentality from the initial, sad minor key to this happier sounding one. Once again, it is obvious that this Kontos 8 musical style of improvisation was the main focus of John Coltrane. Without Bach’s initial pieces in the Baroque period, Coltrane would not have had one of his major influences to guide his music. Another artist that advanced the genre of vocal music and improvisation was a man named Bobby McFerrin. McFerrin, “ranks among the most distinctive and original singers in contemporary music ‐‐ equally adept in jazz, pop, and classical settings, his octave‐jumping trademark style, with its rhythmic inhalations and stop‐ on‐a‐dime shifts from falsetto to deep bass notes often sounds like the work of at least two or three singers at once, while at the same time sounding quite unlike anyone else.”9 Despite being slightly biased, this source continues to say “Many have tried to describe the Bobby McFerrin experience, but there is simply no way to explain a voice that…goes where no man’s has gone before… Bobby’s vocal technique is often non‐verbal, a construction of his own invention. When he engages in song, he surrenders to his creative mind, not to the whims of the marketplace.”10 Similar to both Bach and Coltrane, McFerrin was born in March of 1950 to a family of musicians. As he grew up, he was surrounded by the music of his mother and father; a beautiful mix of classical vocals. McFerrin attended and studied piano at California State College at Sacramento and Cerritos College. After his college days, he performed with multiple cover bands, cabaret acts, and dance troupes just as any rising star would do to spread his name. Soon after 1977, he decided to make his vocal debut, which earned a lot of attention, including an invite, extended to him via 9 “Bobby McFerrin, Extended Bio.” Written by Jeff Tamarkin for BobbyMcFerrin.com. Accessed on November 10th, 2012. http://bobbymcferrin.com/whos‐bobby/press‐ kit/extended‐bio/ 10 ibid. http://bobbymcferrin.com/whos‐bobby/press‐kit/extended‐bio/ Kontos 9 Bill Cosby, to attend the 1980 Playboy Jazz. In 1984, McFerrin released his album “The Voice,” which revolutionized Jazz music. It was the first album released by a major record label where the soloist recorded the album in its entirety without any sort of accompaniment or overdubbing.11 Throughout the rest of his performance career, which is still continuing today, McFerrin continued to revolutionize music. His own website describes his genre of music as “go‐with‐the‐flow music, created on the spot, never to be repeated.”12 This, again, is the exact definition of the improvisational style that was created by Bach and then carried over by John Coltrane. While McFerrin’s entire style emulates “improvisation,” there are plenty of examples that can be picked out to demonstrate how perfect of an example he is of a performer influenced by Bach. The first tune that shows how McFerrin adopted the improvisational style is titled “Good Lovin’” As more of an a cappella piece, this song incorporates multiple vocal levels, all done by McFerrin. He creates a moving bass line underneath the more lyrical melody. This bass line is also filled out with slightly higher voice parts that complete the moving chords underneath the melody. In this song, the improvisation shows within McFerrin’s lyrics, which contrasts with the other two artists. While they solely improvised on their instruments, McFerrin uses language to express his emotions and feelings. Despite the fact that the lyrics of this song are not particularly complicated, McFerrin still conveys through the words “I was feelin' 11 “Bobby McFerrin” written by Jason Ankeny for allmusic.com. Accessed on November 10th, 2012. http://www.allmusic.com/artist/bobby‐mcferrin‐ mn0000768367 12 “Bobby McFerrin, Extended Bio.” Written by Jeff Tamarkin for BobbyMcFerrin.com. Accessed on November 10th, 2012. http://bobbymcferrin.com/whos‐bobby/press‐kit/extended‐bio/ Kontos 10 so bad, I asked my family doctor just what I had. I said, Doctor ‐ Doctor ‐ Mr. M.D. – Doctor, now can you tell me what's ailin' me,” that he’s been hurting for something, to which the Doctor replies “Good lovin'‐Gimme that good, good lovin. Good lovin'‐ All I need is lovin.”13 While the overall sound of the piece seems “pop‐like” and happy, this song is describing how alone someone can feel, and how much companionship and “good‐lovin’” can better a person’s mood and state of mind. This expression of emotion again, is a perfect representation of the improvisational style. Yet another piece that represents this style is McFerrin’s rendition of Bach’s “Air.” The original piece is almost exactly the same as Bach’s other violin concertos; there is a violin soloist with an orchestral accompaniment. The piece starts out with a basic introduction of the subject and then the soloist opens up and continues to play a smooth melody on top of the moving chords created by the lower instrument. The whole introduction can be seen here14 13 “Bobby McFerrin‐Good Lovin’ Lyrics,” last modified 2012. http://www.lyrics007.com/Bobby%20Mcferrin%20Lyrics/Good%20Lovin'%20Lyr ics.html 14 “Bach, Johann Sebastian‐Air on the G String Sheet Music” (screenshot), 8 notes.com, last modified 2012. http://www.8notes.com/scores/560.asp Kontos 11 However, in McFerrin’s rendition of the piece, he uses his voice to represent the violin 1 while an orchestra is used for accompaniment. A performer’s voice has tremendous power compared to an instrument, especially during a performance like this one. With someone with such excellent vocal control like McFerrin, the emotion that he is feeling, along with the emotion that is meant to be conveyed by the piece are easily meshed and conveyed to the audience. Also, because he is not restricted by a physical piece of music or a conductor, McFerrin is able to add extra musical flourishes to the piece to further make it his own, unique improvisational performance. With his unique performing style, McFerrin coveys the emotion and meaning that Bach had demonstrated during his initial writing and performance of the piece. Kontos 12 By studying all of these artists’ personal musical styles, we are able to see the effect that Bach’s music had on the future of the art. If Bach had chosen to conform to the music presented in front of him rather than perform the organ pieces in his style, then the idea of improvisation would have never been fleshed out in his later works. Without Bach’s violin concerto, with the soloist performing high above the orchestra, Jazz music, with its soul and emotion, would not have attained such popularity. As a result, John Coltrane would not have found his own niche as a solo performer and could have possibly overdosed on heroine, rather than focus on his dream to become an acclaimed musician. If Coltrane had not continued his work after being fired from his gig with Miles Davis, Bobby McFerrin could have quite possibly neglected his dream to become such a prestigious vocalist, and a cappella music could have been changed for forever. One would not expect how much of an effect an early composer, such as Bach, could have on the world of music. Without his courage and desire to go beyond the musical norm and create a style known as improvisation, our music today could have been drastically different. Kontos 13 Works Cited 1. “Johann Sebastian Bach’s Life,” last modified March 29, 2002, accessed November 9th, 2012. http://www.let.rug.nl/Linguistics/diversen/bach/map.html 2. “Baroque Music ‐ Part 1,” by Elaine Thornburgh, accessed November 9th, 2012. http://trumpet.sdsu.edu/M151/Baroque_Music1.html 3. “Baroque Music,” Music of the Baroque, accessed November 9th, 2012. http://www.baroque.org/baroque/whatis.htm 4. “Violin Concerto in A Minor, BWV 1041 (Bach, Johann Sebastian),” last updated December 5th, 2006, accessed November 9th, 2012. http://imslp.org/wiki/Violin_Concerto_in_A_minor,_BWV_1041_(Bach,_Johann_Seba stian) 6. “John Coltrane: biography” last updated 2012, accessed November 9th, 2012. http://www.biography.com/people/john‐coltrane‐9254106 7. “Jazz History and Jazz Education” last updated 2012, November 9th 2012. http://www.apassion4jazz.net/ 8. “John Coltrane‐Impressions” (screenshot), Online Sheet Music, accessed on November 10th, 2012. http://www.onlinesheetmusic.com/impressions‐ p403769.aspx?utm_expid=47617476‐ 1&utm_referrer=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com%2Furl%3Fsa%3Dt%26rct%3 Dj%26q%3D%26esrc%3Ds%26source%3Dweb%26cd%3D5%26ved%3D0CFAQFj AE%26url%3Dhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.onlinesheetmusic.com%252Fimpres sions‐ p403769.aspx%26ei%3D29KjUNe_KYSm8gSRg4DoDQ%26usg%3DAFQjCNGSf2Upa YqKav5VVVgtwHE4clC4MA 9. “Bobby McFerrin, Extended Bio.” Written by Jeff Tamarkin for BobbyMcFerrin.com. Accessed on November 10th, 2012. http://bobbymcferrin.com/whos‐bobby/press‐kit/extended‐bio/ 11. “Bobby McFerrin” written by Jason Ankeny for allmusic.com. Accessed on November 10th, 2012. http://www.allmusic.com/artist/bobby‐mcferrin‐ mn0000768367 13. “Bobby McFerrin‐Good Lovin’ Lyrics,” last modified 2012, accessed on November 11th, 2012. http://www.lyrics007.com/Bobby%20Mcferrin%20Lyrics/Good%20Lovin'%20Lyr ics.html Kontos 14 14. “Bach, Johann Sebastian‐Air on the G String Sheet Music” (screenshot), 8 notes.com, last modified 2012, accessed on November 11th, 2012. http://www.8notes.com/scores/560.asp