Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Calcium oxalate retinopathy associated with generalized oxalosis: x-ray diffraction and electron microscopic studies of crystal deposits John D. Bullock, Daniel M. Albert, H. Catherine W. Skinner, William H. Miller, and John H. Galla This reports crystallographic and light and electron microscopic findings in a previously undescribed entity: calcium oxalate retinopathy associated with generalized oxalosis. The affected patient was a 66-year-old vohite male with a previous history of mild hypertensive renal disease who had undergone prolonged abdominal surgery under methoxyfiurane (MOF; Penthrane) anesthesia. He subsequently developed acute irreversible renal failure caused by renal oxalosis as shown by renal biopsy. He was maintained on renal dialysis and shortly before his death three years later he was noted to have changes in the fundus oculi suggestive of the flecked retina syndrome. Widespread oxalosis was found at autopsy. Light and electron microscopy revealed particularly heavy depositions within the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE). Positive identification of the deposits as the monohydrate form of calcium oxalate was obtained by x-ray diffraction investigations. A pected to be due to methoxyfiurane (MOF; Penthrane) anesthesia which he had received three and one-half years prior to his death and which was followed by the immediate development of irreversible renal failure. At subsequent postmortem examination, diffuse deposition of calcium oxalate crystals was found in the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) as well as in the kidney, thyroid, epididymis, myocardium, and bronchus. This report describes the x-ray diffraction and histochemical characteristics of the systemic and ocular crystals and electron microscopic study of the involved retinal pigment epithelium. fundus appearance resembling that of the "flecked retina syndrome" and particularly suggestive of fundus albipunctatus was observed in a patient with irreversible renal failure. His renal disease was sus- From the Department of Ophthalmology, Sections of Orthopedics and Dentistry, and Department of Medicine, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Conn. This study was supported by United States Public Health Service Grant EY000108-04, the United States Public Health Service Vision Center Grant EY00785-03, and the Connecticut Lions Eye Research Foundation, Incorporated. Submitted for publication Oct. 19, 1973. Reprint requests: Dr. John D. Bullock, Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Science, Yale University School of Medicine, 333 Cedar St., New Haven, Conn. 06150. Results Case report. The patient was first seen at Yale-New Haven Hospital in 1967, when 256 Downloaded From: http://jov.arvojournals.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/journals/iovs/933600/ on 06/16/2017 Volume 13 Number 4 he was 61-years-of-age with complaints of arthritis and ocular discomfort. A careful review of his history revealed that he had been seen by ophthalmologists in 1955, 1962, and 1966. Except for the presence of a presumed bacterial conjunctivitis in 1966, his eye examinations were reported as being entirely within normal limits at each of these times. His visual acuity on each occasion was better than 20/20 OU and intraocular pressures were within normal limits. Findings on slit lamp examination were unremarkable and the fundi were entirely normal in appearance. At the time of his 1967 visit he had an extensive evaluation, the results of which included a normal urinalysis and a serum creatinine of 1.5 mg. per 100 ml. A diagnosis of seronegative rheumatoid arthritis was made. He had a mild episcleritis, but his eye examination was otherwise within normal limits. The episcleritis cleared rapidly with the use of topical steroids. In January, 1969, the patient was admitted to Yale-New Haven Hospital with a clinical presentation of obstructive jaundice. The patient was otherwise in good general health except for mild hypertensive nephropathy with a serum creatinine of 3.5 mg. per 100 ml. He underwent a four and one-half hour long exploratory laparotomy under MOF anesthesia during which time correction of an intermittently obstructing duodenal diverticulum was performed. Although at the time of surgery the patient appeared to tolerate the procedure well, he developed acute irreversible nonoliguric renal failure immediately postoperatively, and a percutaneous renal biopsy performed on the thirty-eighth postoperative day showed extensive renal oxalate deposition. A diagnosis of acute renal failure associated with massive oxalate crystal deposition was made. The patient was subsequently maintained on hemodialysis for three and one-half years. The patient's general medical condition deteriorated and he died in September, 1972. Two weeks prior to his death the patient was examined as part of a program in which the eyes of terminal patients are Calcium oxalate retinopathy 257 Fig. 1. Fundus photograph, RE, showing numerous yellowish white punctate lesions in the posterior pole. examined and clinical and pathologic correlations are made when possible.1 The corrected visual acuity was 20/30 OU and mild bilateral nuclear sclerosis was noted. Dilated funduscopic examination revealed numerous yellow-white punctate lesions diffusely scattered throughout the posterior poles and midperiphery of both eyes. Fundus photography was performed (Fig. 1), but the patient died before fluorescein angiography and electroretinography could be performed. Eye pathology. The globes were removed six hours after death. The right globe was fixed in 5 per cent glutaraldehyde phosphate buffered to pH 7.4 and a collote was removed and postfixed in 1 per cent osmium for electron microscopic study. The left globe was fixed in 10 per cent buffered formalin. The eyes were of normal size and external appearance. Both were opened in the horizontal plane of section. Positive findings on gross examination of the right eye were nuclear sclerosis and extensive crystalline deposits in the pigment epithelium. These were particularly apparent when the overlying neurosensory retina was removed (Fig. 2). Using a No. 25-gauge needle one of these deposits was removed and examined microscopically between crossed polarized filters. The crystal exhibited marked birefringence. Downloaded From: http://jov.arvojournals.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/journals/iovs/933600/ on 06/16/2017 Investigative Ophthalmology April 1974 258 Bullock et dl. Fig. 2. Magnified gross photograph of retinal pigment epithelium showing numerous crystalline deposits. (Reflected polarized light, x40.) Fig. 3. Microscopic appearance showing birefringent crystalline deposits in the retinal pigment epithelial cell layer (H & E). A, low power, partially polarized light (x25). B, partially polarized light (xlOO). Gross examination of the left eye was entirely similar to the right. Microscopic examination of hematoxylin and eosin-stained sections of the right eye showed the following positive findings: iris stromal atrophy, hyalinization of the ciliary processes, occasional birefringent crystals in the area of the pigmented epithelium of the ciliary body, lenticular nu- clear sclerosis, and minimal cortical degeneration. The most striking finding was the presence of multiple birefringent crystalline deposits in the retinal pigment epithelium (Fig. 3). A few additional crystals were noted in the inner layers of the retina and occasional drusen were seen. Examination of alizarin red- and Von Kossa-stained sections not only failed to show positive Downloaded From: http://jov.arvojournals.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/journals/iovs/933600/ on 06/16/2017 Volume 13 Number 4 Calcium oxalate retinopathy 259 Fig, 4. A and B, consecutive one micron-thick section viewed with light microscopy and crossed Polaroid filters (A) and thin section viewed with electron microscopy (B). C, electron microscopic appearance of a ciystal that remained in a thin section. D, Tangential section of pigment epithelium showing hexagonal outlines of cells. Note that the large empty space occupied by the crystal appears to be completely within one pigment epithelial cell in this plane of section. The pigment granules in A through D are 1 micron in diameter. calcium crystals but also frequent empty spaces corresponding to crystals in the hematoxylin and eosin-stained sections were noted. The findings on examination of the left eye were entirely similar. Electron microscopy and light microscopy of epon sections. Alternate thick (Fig. 4, A) and thin (Fig. 4, B) oblique sections of the pigment epithelium were examined by light and electron microscopy. The thick microscopic sections were scanned for birefringent crystals under the polarizing microscope (Fig. 4, A) and when these were positively identified the corresponding thin sections (Fig. 4, B) were examined using an RCA electron microscope. The pigment epithelium was sectioned obliquely and appears in the electron micrographs as a sheet of cells. The crystals nearly always appeared elongated and arranged in a butterfly configuration as in Fig. 4, B. Most of the crystals were located in the apical region of the RPE close to Bruch's membrane. The actual crystals, with rare exception (Fig. 4, C), were absent in the thin sections, their presence being indicated by the empty space they had occupied as in Figs. 4, B and 4, D. The shape of these spaces corresponded to that of the crystal as seen with light microscopy in the corresponding thick section. This is illustrated by a comparison of the light micrograph (Fig. 4, A) with the electron micrograph (Fig. 4, B). It is usually not possible to determine whether or not the crystals are intracellular. Downloaded From: http://jov.arvojournals.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/journals/iovs/933600/ on 06/16/2017 Investigative Ophthalmology April 1974 260 Bullock et al Fig. 5. Photomicrographs of autopsy specimens showing extensive crystalline deposition. (H & E, partially polarized light, x40.) A, kidney. B, pericardium. C, thyroid. D, epididymis. E, bronchus. However, in an occasional micrograph, such as Fig. 4, D, the space occupied by the crystal appears to be entirely within the confines of one pigment epithelial cell at least in the plane of this particular section. It is our impression that the crystals may form intracellularly in pigment epithelial cells and that they tend to be localized near the part of the cell contiguous to Bruch's membrane. With increase in size, the crystals became larger than the cells themselves and are obviously eventually extracellular in location. Crystal examination. Slides of the other organs from the general autopsy were then obtained and examined by light microscopy using crossed polarizers. Identical crystals were noted in the kidney, myocardium, bronchus, thyroid gland, and epididymis (Fig. 5). "Wet" kidney preserved in formalin was noted to contain multiple grossly visible whitish crystalline deposits (Fig. 6). The crystals were insoluble in water and were teased from the specimen using small forceps. These crystals were subjected to x-ray examination utilizing a Downloaded From: http://jov.arvojournals.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/journals/iovs/933600/ on 06/16/2017 Volume 13 Number 4 Calcium oxalate retinopathy 261 Fig. 6. Gross photograph of kidney section showing numerous whitish crystalline deposits. Guinier x-ray powder diffraction camera. Calculations from the x-ray diffraction pattern gave excellent agreement with the standard pattern for calcium oxlate-monohydrate (whewellite).2 Comparison of the renal crystals with the mineral whewellite (from Bruch-Bohemia, Brush Mineral Collection No. 3788, Yale Geology Department) confirmed the identification (Table I and Fig. 7). Under the dissecting microscope, crystals were removed from the retinal pigment epithelium and in addition to the renal crystals, were optically analyzed in polarized light. The crystals were biaxial positive, and determination of their indices of refraction in three geometric planes positively distinguished the crystals as the monohydrate form of calcium oxalate (Table II). 2 ' 4 Having identified the crystals in the kidney and retinal pigment epithelium as calcium oxalate, attention was then directed to the other tissues in order to confirm their crystalline content. X-ray diffraction and optical studies were not possible on the crystals obtained from the other tissues because the concentration of crystals in these tissues was insufficient. However, positive identification of calcium oxalate was made by utilization of the histochemical "bubble" test of Johnson5 and subsequent alizarin red staining of the residual crystals. The histochemical presence of calcium oxalate was confirmed in the original kidney biopsy, the retinal pigment epithelium, and in the postmortem Fig. 7. X-ray diffraction pattern of the renal crystal (right) and the mineral whewellite (left) showing the identity as calcium oxalate monohydrate (C&C3O<-H.O). kidney, heart, (Table III). thyroid, and bronchus Discussion The present study concerns a patient with crystalline deposits in the retinal pigment epithelium occurring in association with diffuse deposition of similar crystals in the kidney, thyroid, epididymis, myocardium, and bronchus. The clinical appearance of the eye changes was consistent with the criteria outlined by Krill and Klein'1 for the "flecked retina syndrome" in 1965. In the patient herein described, the crystalline deposition was demonstrated to be calcium oxalate. The varieties of oxalate deposition or oxalosis can be subdivided Downloaded From: http://jov.arvojournals.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/journals/iovs/933600/ on 06/16/2017 262 Bullock et al Investigative Ophthalmology April 1974 Table I. X-ray diffraction analysis CaC,O4 H2O Whewellite ASTM 20-231 d (nm.) hkl. 0.593 0.579 0.452 0.378 0.365 0.341 0.312 0.301 0.2966 0.2915 0.2897 0.2840 0.2523 0.2494 0.2447 0.2417 0.2384 0.2355 0.2347 0.2263 0.2254 0.2210 0.2130 0.2089 0.2075 0.1995 0.1978 0.1957 0.1950 0.1933 0.1923 0.1890 0.1859 0.1846 0.1823 0.1813 0.1793 0.1737 Intensity 100 30 4 6 70 2 2 10 45 10 8 10 4 18 4 6 4 30 12 8 6 6 2 2 14 2 10 2 10 8 8 6 4 6 6 4 6 6 Whewellite: Bruch, Bohemia Yale Brush ColJB 1 (renal lection No. 3788 crystal) dhki (nm.) dhti (nm.) 0.591 0.593 0.577 0.579 0.454 0.379 0.378 0.364 0.365 0.3411 0.3325 METHOXYFLURANE H-C- C-O-CH, CL F TPNH CL F H- I -i-OH CL Z TPNH F \ 8 H- C -C-F F CL H- C-C-O-CH* CO, / i OH F + HF HCL I + •> 0F II I H- C-C-O-CH,3 I F CL +H20n CL 0 I ii H- C -C-OH 0 F II I HO- C-C-O-CH3 HF F CL 0.300 0.2958 0.2910 0.2892 0.2837 0.2524 0.2492 0.2419 0.2386 0.2352 0.2260 0.2210 0.2072 0.1979 0.1948 0.1933 0.1859 0.1845 0.1822 0.1792 0.1736 0.3020 0.2968 0.2912 0.2899 0.2846 0.2527 0.2497 0.2449 0.2419 0.2383 0.2357 0.2348 0.2264 0.2257 0.2212 0.2133 0.2091 0.2079 0.1995 0.1979 0.1960 0.1951 0.1935 0.1927 0.1893 0.1861 0.1848 0.1826 0.1814 0.1793 0.1737 into two major types: (1) diffuse oxalosis in which calcium oxalate crystals are noted in multiple organs; and (2) in localized form, in which the deposition is confined to the kidney, eye, or other limited location. Diffuse oxalosis can occur as an inborn error of metabolism,7's or as a result of ethylene glycol poisoning.9 While it is possible that ocular involvement may occur in such cases, no convincing documentation could be found.1012 Numerous causes OH i 0 n H- C -C-OH co2 +HCL 0 F II I HO- C-C-OH CL 0 0 n H H- C -C-OH HF +HCL HO- C-C-F HoO HOOC-COOH OXALIC ACID Fig. 8. Proposed metabolic pathway for the biotransformation of methoxyflurane to oxalic acid and ionic fluoride.14 Table II. Optical analysis n* ny n2 Axis Standard calcium oxalate-monohydrate crystal* 1.4909 1.5554 1.6502 RPE and renal crystals 1.490 1.544 1.650 Biaxial + Biaxial + of calcium oxalate deposition in the kidney have been described in the literature including oxalate, intoxication, diethylene glycol poisoning following glyoxalate or glycolate administration, and with pyridoxine or thiamine deficiency. Renal oxalosis has also been described in association with a number of systemic disorders.13 Recently, renal oxalosis with transient hyperoxaluria has been described following MOF anesthesia. MOF is a recognized nephrotoxin, probably as a result of its metabolic products, ionic fluoride and Downloaded From: http://jov.arvojournals.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/journals/iovs/933600/ on 06/16/2017 Volume 13 Number 4 Calcium oxalate retinopathy 263 Table III. Summary of crystal analyses | Histologic presence \Histochemical test5] Optical analysis \ X-ray diffraction Tissue QNS QNS Kidney (biopsy specimen) QNS QNS Bronchus ND ND Epididymis ND Kidney (autopsy specimen) QNS QNS Pericardium QNS Retinal pigment epithelium QNS QNS Thyroid ND—Not done: tissue block or wet tissue could not be located. QNS—Quantity not sufficient for analysis. oxalic acid.14 The presumed intermediary metabolic products are shown in Fig. 8. We suspect MOF to be the cause of the oxalosis in this patient. In a review of the literature, ocular calcium oxalate deposition has previously been described only in rare instances; intraretinally in the eyes of patients with longstanding retinal detachment,35 in the lenses of patients with Morgagnian cataracts,1" and in phakolytic glaucoma.17 The present report appears to be the first instance of ocular deposition of calcium oxalate in diffuse oxalosis as well as the first instance related to prolonged anesthesia with MOF. The retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) are primitive, multipotential cells which provide metabolic and functional support for the visual cells of the retina. Among the many activities in which these cells have been implicated are phagocytosis, proliferation, migration, fibrous metaplasia, osseous metaplasia, and neoplasia. Our knowledge of the function and the changes of the RPE is based primarily on histopathologic observations in enucleated eyes. The molecular nature and physiologic details of the function of the RPE cells is not clearly established. The presence of calcium oxalate crystals in association with these cells appears to be a unique finding. The predominance of crystals in the pigment epithelium and their almost total absence in other ocular tissues is not explained by the biochemistry or pathology of the RPE. It should be noted that in the previous reports of calcium oxalate crystals within the eye, involvement of the RPE was not described. Two pathologic processes involving the RPE which may bear some relationship to the present case are: (1) calcification and bone formation within the eye, and (2) the occurrence of the flecked retina syndrome. Intraocular calcium deposition and ossification are common findings in pathologic specimens. The RPE together with the inner surfaces of choroid have been noted as common sites for the presence of calcium or bone. Calcium salts are deposited in these tissues in two circumstances: (1) when excessive amounts of these salts are present in the serum and metastatic deposition occurs, and (2) degenerative conditions in which the calcium is laid down in devitalized or "dead" tissues independently of the blood calcium.18 Such calcification is thought to be related to a low CO2 tension resulting from metabolic inactivity or to a local increase in phosphate ions released from disintegrating nucleoproteins. The RPE cells have been implicated as the cells of origin for choroidal bone.19 Fibrous metaplasia along the inner choroid and proliferation of the RPE have been described as the most common changes adjacent to intraocular bone.20 In numerous histopathologic conditions the RPE may be degenerated, lose their pigment, undergo fatty or hyaline degeneration, or may be absent in areas. In certain pathologic conditions, an abnormal accumulation of basement membrane material results in the formation of drusen. The role of lysosomes of the RPE cells Downloaded From: http://jov.arvojournals.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/journals/iovs/933600/ on 06/16/2017 264 Investigative Ophthalmology April 1974 Bullock et al. in the formation of drusen has been mentioned.-1 Calcification of drusen are frequently seen, as is calcification of Bruch's membrane which commonly occurs as an aging phenomenon. No information could be found in the literature regarding the nature of these calcium salts, and this question is under investigation by the present authors. In the eye herein presented it could not be determined whether the calcium oxalate crystals were contained within the cells of the RPE. If they in fact are, their presence could be due to phagocytosis, to in situ crystal formation within the cell, or a combination of the two. The ability of RPE for phagocytosis has been well demonstrated in organ and tissue culture. Young and Bok22 have demonstrated the phagocytosis of rod outer segment discs by frog RPE. Smith23 documented the ability of chick RPE to ingest melanin pigment granules in tissue culture and, more recently, in organ cultures of human choroid and RPE, phagocytosis of thororast was demonstrated.24 The phagocytic activities of the pigment epithelium appear to be associated with lysosome-like organelles termed "lamellar inclusion bodies" or "phagosomes." An essential morphologic criterion for the recognition of phagocytic activity by electron microscopy is the presence of a membrane surrounding the phagocytosed material. Ocular tissue in the present study was fixed within six hours after the patient's death. Autolysis and artifactitious changes present make it somewhat difficult to determine if the crystals are enveloped by a distinct membrane. In most areas the size of the crystals are so large as to suggest that their location is extracellular, although the initial formation may have been intracellular. Further studies are now underway to further elucidate the pathogenesis and significance of these findings. We believe this to be important because little is known regarding oxalic acid metabolism in the normal human or animal eye.25 REFERENCES 1. Bullock, J. D.: Method of obtaining postmortem eyes for study, Am. J. Ophthalmol. 70: 149, 1970. 2. Palache, C , Berman, W., and Frondel, C : Dana's system of minerology. Ed. 7. New York, 1951, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Vol. II, p. 1099. 3. Catalina, F., and Cifuentes, L.: Calcium oxalate: crystallographic analysis in solid aggregates in urinary sediments, Science 169: 183, 1970. 4. Arnott, H. J., and Pautard, F. G. E.: Calcification in plants, In: Biological calcifications-cellular and molecular aspects, Schraer, H., editor. New York, 1970, Appleton-Century-Crofts. 5. Johnson, F. B.: A method for demonstrating calcium oxalate in tissue sections, J. Histochem. 4: 404, 1956. 6. Krill, A. E., and Klein, B. A.: Flecked retina syndrome, Arch. Ophthalmol. 71: 496, 1965. 7. Hockaday, T. D. R., Clayton, J. E., Frederick, E. W., et al.: Primary hyperoxaluria, Medicine 43: 315, 1964. 8. Williams, H. E., and Smith, L. H., Jr.: Lglyceric aciduria, N. Engl. J. Med. 278: 233, 1968. 9. Friedman, E. A., Greenberg, J. B., Merrill, J. P., et al.: Consequences of ethylene glycol poisoning, Am. J. Med. 32: 891, 1962. 10. Buri, J. R.: L'oxalose, Helvet. Paed. Acta 17: (Suppl. 11) 1962. 11. Scowen, C. F., Stansfield, A. C , and Watts, R. W. E.: Oxalosis and primary hyperoxaluria, J. Pathol. Bacteriol. 77: 195, 1959. 12. Debre, R., Royer, P., and Lestradet, H.: Les insuffisiances congenitales du tubule renal chez l'enfant, Sem. Hop. 32: 235, 1956. 13. Wyngaarden, J. B., and Elder, T. D.: Primary hyperoxaluria and oxalosis. In: The Metabolic Basis of Inherited Disease, Stan- 14. 15. 16. 17. bury, J. B., Wyngaarden, J. B., and Fredrickson, D. S., editors. New York, 1966, McGrawHill Book Co. Mazze, R. I., Trudell, J. R., and Cousins, M. J.: Methoxyflurane metabolism and renal dysfunction: clinical correlation in man, Anesthesiology 35: 247, 1971. Cogan, D. G., Kuwabara, T., Gilbert, J., et al.: Calcium oxalate and calcium phosphate crystals in detached retinas, Arch. Ophthalmol. 60: 366, 1958. Zimmerman, L. E., and Johnson, F. B.: Calcium oxalate crystals within ocular tissues, Arch. Ophthalmol. 60: 373, 1958. Flocks, M., Littwin, C. S., and Zimmerman, L. E.: Phacolytic glaucoma—a clinicopathologic study of one hundred thirty-eight cases of glaucoma associated with hypermature Downloaded From: http://jov.arvojournals.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/journals/iovs/933600/ on 06/16/2017 Volume 13 Number 4 cataract, Arch. Ophthalmol. 54: 37, 1955. 18. Duke-Elder, S., and Perkins, E. S.: Diseases of the uveal tract. In: System of Ophthalmology. St. Louis, 1966, The C. V. Mosby Company, Vol. 9, p. 740. 19. Brailey and Lobo: On choroidal new formations, Royal London Ophthalmology Hospital Reg. 10: 405, 1882. 20. Finkelstein, E. M., and Boniuk, M.: Intraocular ossification and hematopoiesis, Am. J. Ophthalmol. 68: 683, 1969. 21. Farkas, T., Sylvester, V., and Archer, D.: The ultrastructure of drusen, Am. J. Ophthalmol. 71: 1196, 1971. 22. Young, R. W., and Bok, D.: Autoradiographic Calcium oxalate retinopathy 265 studies on the metabolism of the retinal pigment epithelium, INVEST. OPHTHALMOL. 9: 524, 1970. 23. Smith, D. T.: The ingestion of melanin pigment granules by tissue cultures, Johns Hopkins Hosp. Bull. 365: 240, 1923. 24. Tso, M. O. M., Albert, D. M., and Zimmerman, L. E.: Organ culture of human choroid and retinal pigment epithelium: a model for the study of cytologic behavior of RPE in vitro, INVEST. OPHTHALMOL. (In press.) 25. Baratta, O.: Ricerca e dosaggio dell'acido ossalico nell'acqueo, Arch. Oftalmol. 43: 44, 1936. Downloaded From: http://jov.arvojournals.org/pdfaccess.ashx?url=/data/journals/iovs/933600/ on 06/16/2017