Download Disarming the Confirmation Process

Document related concepts

Judiciary of Russia wikipedia , lookup

Supreme Court of the Philippines wikipedia , lookup

Separation of powers under the United States Constitution wikipedia , lookup

Transcript
530
CLEVELAND STATE LAW REVIEW
[Vol. 50:513
against Senator Ashcroft’s nomination to be Attorney General.117 The rules of the
game, Senate Democrats argued, would change.118
The rules changed drastically.119 Many of President Bush’s nominees went
almost two years without a hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee.120
Senator Leahy, Chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee after the defection of
Senator Jim Jeffords, stated that more controversial nominees would take more
deliberation.121 Notably, the Senate has confirmed many district court judges.122 The
percentage of Circuit Court nominees confirmed during Senator Leahy’s tenure,
however, was less than stellar.123 Nominees who appeared before the Senate
Judiciary Committee endured hearings of an almost entirely political character.124 As
promised, Senate Democrats frequently voted against nominees they considered
“outside the mainstream.”125 Many of President Bush's Circuit Court nominees were
deemed “outside the mainstream,” including Professor Michael McConnell, who
received the support of over 300 law professors, and Miguel Estrada, who served for
five years in the Office of Solicitor General during the Clinton Administration.126
117
Helen Dewar, A Serious Breach in Bipartisanship: Democrats Fire “Shot Across Bow,”
WASH. POST, Feb. 2, 2001, at A6 [hereinafter Dewar, Serious Breach] (noting that forty-two
Democrats voted against Senator Ashcroft’s nomination for Attorney General).
118
Cf. id.
119
See infra notes 120-34 and accompanying text.
120
See United States Senate Committee on the Judiciary, U.S. Courts of Appeals, at
http://www.senate.gov/~judiciary/nominations_appeals.cfm (last visited Aug. 8, 2003).
121
148 CONG. REC. S9975-02 (2002) (statement of Sen. Leahy) (“Most Senators understand
that more controversial nominees require greater review. This process of careful review is
part of our democratic system.”).
122
Senator Leahy justly deserves credit for this. See Editorial, Forgetting Anyone?, WASH.
POST, Oct. 11, 2002, at A36 [hereinafter Editorial, Forgetting Anyone?] (“Mr. Leahy deserves
credit for having moved nominees at a faster clip than the Senate managed in recent years.”).
For a full list of confirmed district court nominees, see United States Senate Committee on the
Judiciary, U.S. District Courts, at http://www.senate.gov/~judiciary/nominations_district.cfm
(last visited Aug. 8, 2003). At last count, the Senate has confirmed eighty-six district court
judges. Id.
123
See Circuit and District Court Judicial Nominations, at http://www.usdoj.gov/olp/
2yearcomparison.pdf (last visited Aug. 8, 2003) (noting that 53% of President Bush’s Circuit
Court nominees were confirmed during the first two years).
124
Senators interrogated Mr. Estrada concerning allegations made by an anonymous source
that he imposed litmus tests on Supreme Court clerkship candidates while conducting
screening interviews for Justice Kennedy. See infra note 331 (discussing the nomination of
Miguel Estrada).
125
See, e.g., 148 CONG. REC. S11502-01 (2002) (statement of Sen. Kennedy) (detailing his
concerns regarding the nomination of Dennis Shedd); see also infra Part II.B.4.c (discussing
the Owen nomination).
126
As a result of attacks from Senate Democrats, Mr. Estrada withdrew his name from
consideration on September 9, 2003. Mr. Estrada’s opponents made quite an interesting
argument against confirmation: No one knows Mr. Estrada's views on legal issues, and those
views are “outside the mainstream.” Compare Jack Newfield, The Right’s Judicial
http://engagedscholarship.csuohio.edu/clevstlrev/vol50/iss4/3
18