Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Forum Reply doi:10.1130/ G35636Y.1 Seawater chemistry driven by supercontinent assembly, breakup and dispersal R.D. Müller1, A. Dutkiewicz1, M. Seton1, and C. Gaina2 1 EarthByte Group, School of Geosciences, The University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia 2 Centre for Earth Evolution and Dynamics, University of Oslo, Oslo 0316, Norway We thank Norton and Lawver (2014) for their comment, which provides us with an opportunity to address the issue of geological uncertainty. We agree that our 200 Ma reconstruction needs to be adjusted to remove convergence between the Izanagi and Farallon plates. We moved the Izanagi-Farallon stage pole westward and adopted other changes in the circum-Arctic as proposed by Shephard et al. (2013) to produce a new 200 Ma age grid (Fig 1A), resulting in a 1– 65 m.y. old ocean floor area of ~192 × 106 km2. We are unsure how Norton and Lawver derived their estimate of 219 × 106 km2 and it is difficult to understand why they show our 200 Ma reconstruction in their Fig. 1, instead of their own, seeing that the purpose of their comment appears to be advancing the issue of assessing alternative reconstructions. We strongly disagree that our computed ocean floor area aged 1–65 m.y. at 100 Ma is grossly overestimated. We compare three alternative reconstructions for 100 Ma since 2008 (Figs. 1B–1D). We are curious to know how Norton and Lawver derived their substantially lower estimate for the 100 Ma ridge flank area, and note that the sole evidence for both their 200 and 100 Ma “alternative reconstructions” provided to the reader is a blue and a green dot, respectively, in the inset diagram in their Fig. 1 (reproduced from our paper). If they had provided alternative age grids for these times, then we would be in a position to assess the differences between their reconstructions and ours. Irrespective of whether we adopt our revised 200 Ma ridge-flank area estimate (Fig. 1A) or that by Norton and Lawver, our 200 Ma to present fluctuations in the area of young mid-ocean ridge flanks do not change dramatically. If we accepted, for argument’s sake, Norton and Lawver’s mysterious 100 Ma ridge flank area estimate, then the present-day ocean floor area aged 1–65 Ma is still only about 70% of their 100 Ma value (their figure 1 inset), far from being “almost constant through time.” Therefore, our inference of a dramatic decrease of the area of young mid-ocean ridge flanks since the mid-Cretaceous still stands even in the scenario promoted by Norton and Lawver. That it should not be constant has a firm underpinning provided by fully dynamic mantle convection models (Coltice et al., 2012; 2013). They illustrate that over a Wilson cycle there are variations by a factor of 2 in the rate of production of new seafloor, with concomitant major changes in the area-age distribution of the seafloor. Their models support that a stable supercontinent is accompanied by a rectangular age-area distribution (Fig. 1A), with breakup and dispersal leading to a skewed distribution (Figs. 1B–1D), reflecting the progressive creation of new crust at the expense of older crust being subducted, while the triangular distribution we observe today reflects a near constant production of oceanic lithosphere compared to what is destroyed (Coltice et al., 2013). Therefore, the main conclusions of our paper are robust, supported by independent geodynamic models, and not dependent on geological uncertainties. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Figure 1. A: Revised paleo-age grid for 200 Ma. B–D: Alternative paleo-age grids for 100 Ma, representing the “geological uncertainty” involved in alternative mid-ocean ridge geometries and back-arc basins. B: Müller et al. (2008). C: Müller et al . (2013). D: This paper (Robinson projection). Grayshaded transparent regions in the revised 100 Ma reconstruction (D) illustrate the conjugate ridge flank areas constrained by magnetic anomaly identifications. Inset age-area histograms in 20 m.y. bins (x-axis: 0–200 m.y. old crust, y-axis: 0–35%) illustrate the rectangular age-area distribution during supercontinent stability (A) and skewed seafloor distributions during supercontinent dispersal (B–D). The oldest reconstruction (Müller et al., 2008) results in an ocean floor area aged 1–65 m.y. of 269 × 106 km2 (Fig. 1B), as compared to 251 × 106 km2 of that by Müller et al. (2013) (Fig. 1C) and 253 × 106 km2 of our most recent reconstruction (Fig. 1D). The reconstructions reflect the stepwise inclusion of more complex mid-ocean ridge systems, modelling the breakup of the Ontong Java, Manihiki and Hikurangi plateaus (Fig. 1C), the subsequent inclusion of back-arc basins in the eastern Tethys and Southeast Asia, following Zahirovic et al. (2013), and some additional changes to spreading ridges in the Indian and Pacific oceans (Fig. 1D). Even though these reconstructions have undergone substantial changes through time, the seafloor age histograms, mean ages, and ridge flank areas less than 65 m.y. old have only undergone relatively minor changes (Figs. 1B–1D). This research was funded by Australian Research Council grants FL0992245, DP0987713, and DP0987604: and by the Research Council of Norway through its Centres of excellence funding scheme, Project 223272. We are grateful for Nicky Wright’s help with preparing Figure 1. REFERENCES CITED Coltice, N., Rolf, T., Tackley, P., and Labrosse, S., 2012, Dynamic causes of the relation between area and age of the ocean floor: Science, v. 336, p. 335-338. Coltice, N., Seton, M., Rolf, T., Müller, R., and Tackley, P.J., 2013, Convergence of tectonic reconstructions and mantle convection models for significant fluctuations in seafloor spreading: Earth and Planetary Science Letters, v. 383, p. 92-100. Müller, R., Dutkiewicz, A., Seton, M., and Gaina, C., 2013, Seawater chemistry driven by supercontinent assembly, breakup, and dispersal: Geology, 41, p. 907-910. v. R.D., Sdrolias, M., Gaina, C., Steinberger, B., and Heine, C., 2008, Müller, Long-term sea level fluctuations driven by ocean basin dynamics: Science, v. 319, p. 1357-1362. Norton, I.O., and Lawver, L.A., 2014, Comment: Seawater chemistry driven by supercontinent assembly, breakup, and dispersal: Geology, vol. 42, p. e334. Shephard, G.E., Müller, R.D., and Seton, M., 2013, The tectonic evolution of the Arctic since Pangea breakup: Integrating constraints from surface geology and geophysics with mantle structure: Earth-Science Reviews, v. 124, p. 148-183. Zahirovic, S., Seton, M., and Müller, R., 2013, The Cretaceous and Cenozoic tectonic evolution of Southeast Asia: Solid Earth Discussions, v. 5, doi:10.5194/sed-5-1335-2013. © 2014 Geological Society of America. For permission to copy, contact Copyright Permissions, GSA, or [email protected]. GEOLOGY FORUM | May 2014 | www.gsapubs.org e335