Download SS 20-1 - Ch 6 notes

Social 20-1: Chapter 6:
Nationalism and Ultranationalism
Chapter Issue: How can nationalism lead to ultranationalism?
Related Issue #2:
Should nations pursue national interests?
Name: _______________________________
Chapter 6: Nationalism and Ultranationalism
Related Issue #2: Should nations pursue national interests?
Chapter Issue: To what extent can nationalism lead to ultranationalism?
Examine the photos on page 136 and read the excerpt on page 137.
We will discuss the questions on page 137 together as a class.
What is ULTRANATIONALISM? (PAGES 138-140)
Even when people do not agree on what NATIONALISM is, some say that it is the most
powerful political force in the world. Some people also believe that ultranationalism - an
extreme form of nationalism - is one of the most destructive forces in the world.
ULTRANATIONALISM: Write out 5 points from page 138 below.
Ultranationalists have a strong sense of their own national identity but little respect for the
national identity of others. They may believe that their own nation-state can do NO wrong,
even when it denies the human rights of some people. Some historians believe, for example,
that the treaties that gave Britain and France control over the Middle East following World
War I are examples of ultranationalism. Those treaties made sure that the peoples of the
Middle East did not enjoy the same rights as citizens of Britain and France.
Ultranationalists often separate people into “us” and “them”. In Turkey, read about the story of
Hrant Dink, a Turkish journalist who was murdered because he wrote about the massacre of
the Armenian people in 1915 in Turkey. Hrant Dink angered many Turks as many felt he
publicly insulted the Turkish people.
Ultranationalist often promote their own national interests - while ignoring or trampling on
the national interests of other people within their own country and in other countries. This
exaggerated sense of national interest, or ultranationalism, can even inspire them to invade and
take over other countries.
From Nationalism to Ultranationalism
Many people agree that ultranationalism includes elements of racism and fanaticism and that it
can lead to conflict. But people do not always draw the line between nationalism and
ultranationalism in the same place.
Whether people call a particular policy nationalistic or ultranationalistic often depends on the
nation they identify with. Some might say that the actions of people in their own group are
patriotic but claim that similar actions by peoples in other groups are ultranationalistic.
Building a strong military, for example, may be viewed as nationalistic in your own country but ultranationalistic in another country, especially if the country threatens your country's
national security.
Propaganda and Ultranationalism (Page 140)
Propaganda refers to information and ideas that are spread to achieve a specific goal. The
information and ideas are often misleading and may be dishonest. Ultranationalist often use
propaganda to manipulate strong human emotions - especially fear and insecurity - and
persuade people to behave in certain ways.
We will examine the ideas of ultranationalism on pages 139, 140, and 141. Ultranationalism under
Stalin in the former Soviet Union is covered on page 139 and 140. Ultranationalism under Hitler in
Nazi Germany is covered on page 140 and 141. Please complete the chart on the next page in point
form to help you understand what ultranationalism is and how ultranationalism develops.
Please write down the 3 other points of propaganda below from the right margin on page 140:
* spreading carefully selected information, rumours, and ideas
Soviet communist government and Hitler's Nazi fascist government used propaganda to benefit their
leadership over the people in the 1930’s and 1940’s. Joseph Goebbels, Adolph Hitler’s minister
for public enlightenment and propaganda, built a huge propaganda organization to control all
forms of the media. Goebbels used this propaganda machine to feed Germans‘ fears and
insecurities and to deceive the German people into believing that they were SUPERIOR and
Jews were EVIL.
Ultranationalism under Stalin and Hitler
Ultranationalism in Russia
under Stalin
Ultranationalism in Germany
under Hitler
How does ULTRANATIONALISM develop? (pages 141-148)
Various factors and events can combine to transform nationalism into ultranationalism. An
economic crisis, for example, can cause people to focus on their own needs and national
interests. Sometimes a leader appears who can inspire people to follow and who is powerful
enough to take control of an entire country. Leaders like this often use national symbols and
myths to convince people that they are superior to the people of other nations.
***Factors that contribute to the development of ultranationalism:***
*a social or economic crisis*
*a charismatic, powerful leader*
*national symbols and myths that promote feelings of superiority*
Countries in Crisis
Please look at Figure 6-9 in the left margin on page 136.
On October 29, 1929, the price of stocks on the New York Stock Exchange dropped. The result
of this stock market crash had dramatic effects on the American economy and on the rest of
the world.
Charismatic Leaders
During the 1920’s and 1930’s, ultranationalist dictators emerged in the Soviet Union
(Stalin), Italy (Mussolini), Germany (Hitler), Spain (Franco) and Japan (Hirohito). These
leaders were CHARISMATIC. They inspired enthusiasm and devotion in their followers
- and FEAR in people who questioned their leadership or policies. They used deadly
force to put down opposition.
Instilling Ultranationalistic Values
The dictatorhips in the Soviet Union, Germany, Italy, and Japan promoted extreme
nationalist values. Domestic and foreign policies promoted these values, and strong
military and police forces were built to protect them. Education was used to instil these
values in children. Culture and art were also used to serve the ultranationalists’ goals
and DROWN OUT opposing voices.
Factors That Can Contribute to the Development of Ultranationalism
Factor
How This Factor Can Help Transform Nationalism into
Ultranationalism
Germany: Factors that Contribute to the
Development of Ultranationalism
Examples
Examples
•extreme inflation in Germany
•German money became worthless
•Great Depression began 1929
•German workers faced homelessness
and starvation
•German gov’t trying to pay off
reparation payments
•Germany deeply in debt to USA
•Germans looked for a strong leader to fix the
country
• Hitler began to gain support, told the
Germans who was to blame for their problems
and how they could fix them
• Hitler appealed to the rich because Hitler
would keep them rich if they followed Nazi
rules
• Hitler appealed to the working class because
he would get them their jobs back
• Hitler elected in 1933
A social or
economic crisis
Charismatic,
powerful leaders
Factors
That Can
Contribute to
Ultranationalism
National symbols and
myths that promote
feelings of superiority
Examples
*Nazi propaganda experts used radio, movies, public address systems and giant posters to keep
Hitler’s image and message before the public
*Nazis issued carefully planned news releases and photographs to the media
*Nazi party members organized mass meetings that attracted audiences over 100,000
*Culture and art were used to serve the ultranationalist’s goals and drown out opposing voices
*glorified the old German operas of Wagner that represented a glorified time of the past
*Nazis introduced racist policies to eliminate anyone that was deemed inferior, including Jews,
Roma, homosexuals, people with disabilities
*anyone who challenged Nazi rule was eliminated
*marriage and eventually friendship between Jews and non-Jews was forbidden
*children and university students were taught Nazi values and any teachers that opposed these Nazi
values were eliminated
*schools burned books that were against an un-German spirit
*German history was re-written to glorify the past and to justify invading territory that belonged to
other countries
Japan after World War I
Please look at Figure 6-11in the right margin on page 137 about Japan’s emperor, Hirohito.
We will examine the development of ultranationalism in Japan now.
During World War I, Japan had supported the Allies. After the war, Japanese agriculutural
and industrial exports to Europe and the United States increased. But, when the Great
Depression started, these trading partners tried to support their own industries by limiting
imports - and people back in Japan lost their jobs.
Questions (page 144):
1. What happened in 1932 in Japan?
2. Who did Japanese ultranationalists blame for the crisis?
3. What did Japanese ultranationalists get even angrier about next?
4. Who did Japan invade in 1931?
5. Why did Japan invade this territory in 1931?
6. Where is this territory located?
7. What did Japan look like by 1937 and who were they at war with?
8. What did military leaders bring back to Japan?
9. What was created around emperor Hirohito?
“Hirohito and Tojo” Questions (page 145):
1. What did Japanese ultranationalists work to do in the years before World War II?
2. What is an example of Japanese foreign policy under the leadership of the military?
3. What two things did the Japanese leaders want?
4. How did they justify their territorial expansion to their people?
5. Who became prime minister in 1941 in Japan and what did he do?
6. How would you describe this General and what did he promise the Japanese people?
“Ultranationalist values in Japan” Questions (page 148):
1. How were Japanese and Nazi ultranationalism similiar?
2. What beliefs and values were fostered by the Japanese leaders leading up to World War II?
3. What was the Japanese government’s “foreign policy” doing while ultranationalist were
taking over the “domestic” affairs of Japan?
4. What 3 things were students in Japan taught in the 1930’s?
5. Whose ideas were scorned by Japan and whose ideas were praised in the 1930’s?
6. What were priorities in Japan and what did these include?
7. Who were honoured in Japan under this regime?
8. What is Japan’s national religion called and what does this religioin teach?
9. Who is honoured in this religion?
10. Who are the Kami?
11. Why is the Shinto Yasukuni Shrine in Tokyo, Japan controversial?
12. What do some Japanese people want today concerning the shrine?
Japan: Factors that Contribute to the
Development of Ultranationalism
Examples
Examples
• Many Japanese lost their jobs during Great
Depression because USA/Europe reduced
Japanese exports
•Japanese produced silk but many people
around the world could not afford luxury item –
many lost their jobs in Japan - blamed the
West
• rice crops failed in 1932 – caused famine in
Japan
• Japanese ultranationalists blamed their
politicians for the famine crisis-need to turn
to new leadership in Japan
• Japanese got mad at USA, Canada,
Australia for not accepting Japanese
migrants
• Japan invaded Manchuria in 1931
•By 1937, military controlled Japanese gov’t
and at war with China
•Military leaders brought back traditional
warrior values such as obedience to the
emperor and state
*a cult-like atmosphere was created around
emperor Hirohito
A social or
economic crisis
Charismatic,
powerful leaders
Factors
That Can Contribute
to Ultranationalism
National symbols and
myths that promote
feelings of superiority
Examples
* ultranationalists worked to rid Japan of democracy and make it a one party state ruled by military
* commander’s of Japan’s armed forces decided was in the country’s national interest
* Japan invaded China for raw materials to continue to increase industrialization in Japan-justified
their expansion into China because they saw USA and European colonies doing same thing since the
early 1800’s
* General Tojo Hideki became prime minister in 1941 and transformed Japan into a military
dictatorship; Tojo was an aggressive ultranationalist who promised Japan would use its military to
dominate Asia
* ultranationalists in Japan were preparing the nation for war and fostering racist beliefs in Japan by
convincing the Japanese people that they were superior to other people and had a mission to expand
How have people responded to ULTRANATIONALISM? (pages 149-154)
Ultranationalism infects all aspects of a country's life - social, economic, cultural, and political.
Ultranationalists often believe that they have the right to invade other countries and take over
territory by force. When this has happened, national leaders around the world have found it
difficult to find peaceful ways to respond.
Please read Martin Neimoeller's words in Voices in the right hand margin on page 149.
Discuss the following questions:
ο
What is he saying about why some people failed to take action?
ο
Why might people have failed to speak up?
ο
In a similar situation, what might make you speak up?
ο
How might people who failed to take action feel when they found about the Holocaust?
The failure to act is one response to ultranationalism.
Sometimes fear, apathy, or ignorance can lead people to respond to ultranationalism
by doing nothing.
Advantage: You may be able to remain invisible and therefore safe.
Disdvantage: Others may suffer and feel abandoned by their friends and neighbours.
Here is a List of the Items We Will Cover in This Next Section:
1. Appeasement
i) Opposition to Appeasement
ii) Failure of the League of Nations
iii) Ethiopia
2. War as a Response to Ultranationalism
i) Total War
ii) Propaganda and Censorship in Canada
iii) Conscription in Canada
3. Internment Camps in Canada
i) Ukrainian Canadians in World War I
ii) Japanese Canadians in World War II
4. Peacekeeping as a Response to Ultranationalism
i) Suez Canal Crisis
Appeasement as a Response to Ultranationalism (page 149)
Questions:
1.
Why did people wish to avoid war in the years before World War II?
2.
Who began to take over other countries and territory in Europe?
3.
What is appeasement?
4.
When did Germany begin expanding its European territory?
5.
In 1938, who was British prime minister?
6.
In 1938, who was French prime minister?
7.
In 1938, who was Italian dictator?
8.
What was Germany's land claim and where is it located?
9.
Why was their conflict over this region?
10.
What did Hitler promise at this meeting?
11.
What did the British, French, and Italians promise in return?
12.
What did Chamberlain say to the British people to make them feel more secure?
Opposition to Appeasement (page 149)
1.
Who did not agree with the philosophy in Britain?
2.
Who was Winston Churchill?
3.
Who was prime minister of Britain during World War II?
4.
What was Churchill's comment about an appeaser?
5.
What did Churchill say about the choice made by Chamberlain, Deladier, and Mussolini?
6.
What happened in 1939?
7.
Look at the map on page 149 Figure 6-15 and identify the territories that Germany took
over between 1935 and 1938.
8.
In 1938, when Germany took over the Sudetenland, would you have agreed with Neville
Chamberlain's or Winston Churchill's response? Explain why.
Failure of the League of Nations (page 150)
By 1934, 58 countries, including Canada, Britain, and France, were members of the League of
Nations, which had been created after World War I. League members agreed to help one
another and to take action to maintain peace.
If one country invaded another country, League members could:
*
*
*
But member countries were not required to provide troops to stop invasions. When Japan
invaded Manchuria in 1931, for example, China appealed to the League for help. The League
condemned the invasion. Japan responded by resigning its membership in 1933. After that,
League members COULD NOT agree on what action to take - and ended up doing nothing.
Ethiopia
1.
What did Italy suffer following World War I?
2.
Who was appointed prime minister of Italy in 1922?
3.
What did he promise to do?
4.
Who was Mussolini and what did he do “politically-speaking” to Italy for himsef ?
5.
How was Mussolini's like Hitler and Stalin?
6.
What did his policies include?
7.
Why did Italy expect to be rewarded following World War I?
8.
Why were ultranationalists’ angry in Italy after World War I?
10.
What did Mussolini order in 1935?
11.
What was the irony of Mussolini's order?
12.
Who is Haile Selassie?
13.
What did Selassie do in June 1936?
14.
What did Selassie say in his speech to the League of Nations in 1936?
More to the story:
On August 23, 1939, Germany and the Soviet Union signed the Nazi-Soviet Non-aggression Pact.
This treaty assured Hitler that his armies would not have to fight on two fronts when Germany began
taking over Europe. The world was shocked at a pact between fascist and communist governments - such
a development seemed unbelievable. Seven days later, Germany invaded Poland.
War as a Response to Ultranationalism (pages 143-145)
On September 1, 1939, Hitler's armies invaded Poland. Thousands of tanks and 1.5 million
soldiers attacked by land while German airplanes bombed Polish cities. German blitzkrieg had
begun. The Polish army was no match for highly trained and well-equipped German forces.
Poland surrendered to the invaders within four weeks.
Total War and Canada Declares War (page 151)
Canada entered World War II far different from how they entered World War I. By 1939,
Canada’s foreign policy was no longer tied to that of Great Britain’s, like it had been in 1914.
This meant Canada did not declare war on Germany as soon as Britain did. The Canadian
government debated the merits of entering the war, and one week later after the formal
declaration of war by Great Britain, Canada declared war on Germany - September 10th, 1939.
Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King used an emotional and difficult speach on the
radio to inform all Canadians at the time the decision of the Canadian government and the
reasons as to why that decision had been made. His speach is on the bottom of page 143.
Total War: Propaganda and Censorship in Canada (page 151)
Canada entered World War II and Canada's national interest now focused on the war effort.
Canadians were encouraged to support the war effort by joining the armed forces, working in
wartime industries, or volunteering to help in other ways. The Canadian government, however,
began to adopt features used in dictatorships. Propaganda campaigns were launched to recruit
soldiers and persuade Canadians to buy war bonds. No employer was allowed to hire anyone
who did not have a permit from an employment office, and employment could be restricted to
specific locations or industries considered essential to the war effort.
Official censorship was introduced to ensure that no essential information fell into the hands of
the enemy. Government censors approved every speach broadcast on the CBC and examined all
stories published in all newspapers and magazines. Military censors read all letters from
members of the armed forces as well as letters to soldiers in enemy prisoner of war camps.
Anything that revealed to much was blacked out.
Examine the Wartime Propaganda posters on pages 151 and 152.
After you have read page 151, 152 and 153 answer the following question:
By introducing propaganda and official censorship, tactics that are also used in dictatorships,
was the Canadian government starting down the path to ultranationalism?
What do you think? Yes or no!
Discussion!!!
Conscription in Canada (page 153)
To the leaders of Germany, Italy, Japan, and the Soviet Union, conscription - compulsory
military service - was in the national interest. A strong military was essential to secure their own
borders and to invade other countries. In dictatorships, it is not hard to force people to become
soldiers.
When World War II started, the Canadian Armed Forces were made up entirely of volunteers.
Soon after the war began, Prime Minister William Lyon Mackenzie King introduced a limited
form of conscription. But he promised that conscripts would be asked only to defend Canada.
They would not be sent overseas.
King did not want to repeat the turmoil - including protests and riots - that had occurred when
conscription was introduced during World War I. In 1917, the government had imposed
conscription after the Allies had suffered severe losses.
The issue divided Canada during World War I and was set again to divide Canada during World
War II. Many Canadians of British descent believed that conscription was in the national
interest, but others disagreed. Some worried about what would happen to their families and
farms. Many Francophones did not believe that they should be forced to fight for the British
Empire. Still, Francophones had volunteered at about the same rate as Anglophones.
As casualties mounted during World War II, King decided to hold a special vote to ask
Canadians' permission to break his promise not to send conscripts overseas.
Internment Camps in Canada (pages 152-153)
During World War I and World War II, many Canadians became caught up in the racism and
extreme nationalism of the time. Thousands of people of German, Ukrainian, and Japanese
origin were interned - sent to prison camps - as enemy aliens.
“Peacekeeping” as a Response to Ultranationalism (page 148)
Questions:
1.
Why was the United Nations formed?
2.
What did UN missions involve at first?
3.
What happened in 1956?
4.
What does the Suez Canal link and when was it built?
5.
What benefit did the Suez Canal have for the people of the world?
6.
What continent did ships no longer need to travel around?
7.
What did ships pay to get through the canal and where did the profits go?
8.
Who owned the Suez Canal in 1956?
9.
Why did the Egyptian government take control of the canal in 1956?
10. Looking at the map in Figure 6-28, do you think the Egyptian government might have
felt entitled to take over the Suez Canal?
11. Do you believe Egypt's actions in 1956 were nationalistic or ultranationalistic?
Explain your answer.
12.
Who invaded the Suez Canal zone in response to Egyptian actions?
13. Which country supported Egypt and what did they threaten to do?
14.
What was the result of this in regards to the rest of the world?
15.
What was Lester B. Pearson's role at the time in Canadian politics in 1956?
16.
What did Pearson propose to help diffuse the situation in Egypt?
17.
How did the UN respond to Pearson's suggestion?
18.
What was the result?
19.
What did this event start?
20. What does the Canadian governments believe and how does it relate to our foreign
policy?
21. By 2007, how many peacekeeping missions had Canada taken part in?