* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Download EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC
Survey
Document related concepts
Transcript
e t u b tri INVESTOR PRESENTATION \\ STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL O B U - Do s i tD o N EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC National Association of College and University Business Officers February 8, 2013 G S E C on e d fi ia t n N l C A For further information, please contact: Stephen L. Guillette (212) 813-4600 | [email protected] THIS PRESENTATION AND THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN SHALL NOT CONSTITUTE AN OFFER TO SELL OR THE SOLICITATION OF ANY OFFER TO BUY WHICH MAY ONLY BE MADE AT THE TIME A QUALIFIED OFFEREE RECEIVES A CONFIDENTIAL PRIVATE OFFERING MEMORANDUM (“CPOM”) DESCRIBING THE OFFERING AND RELATED SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND IN THE CASE OF ANY INCONSISTENCY BETWEEN THE DESCRIPTIONS OR TERMS IN THIS DOCUMENT AND THE CPOM, THE CPOM SHALL CONTROL. SECURITIES SHALL NOT BE OFFERED OR SOLD IN ANY JURISDICTION IN WHICH SUCH OFFER, SOLICITATION OR SALE WOULD BE UNLAWFUL UNTIL THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE LAWS OF SUCH JURISDICTION HAVE BEEN SATISFIED. WHILE ALL THE INFORMATION PREPARED IN THIS DOCUMENT IS BELIEVED TO BE ACCURATE, EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) MAKES NO EXPRESS WARRANTY AS TO THE COMPLETENESS OR ACCURACY NOR CAN IT ACCEPT RESPONSIBILITY FOR ERRORS APPEARING IN THE DOCUMENT. ANY PROJECTIONS, MARKET OUTLOOKS OR ESTIMATES IN THIS DOCUMENT ARE FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS AND ARE BASED UPON CERTAIN ASSUMPTIONS. OTHER EVENTS WHICH WERE NOT TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT MAY OCCUR AND MAY SIGNIFICANTLY AFFECT THE RETURNS OR PERFORMANCE OF ESG FUNDS. ANY PROJECTIONS, OUTLOOKS OR ASSUMPTIONS SHOULD NOT BE CONSTRUED TO BE INDICATIVE OF THE ACTUAL EVENTS WHICH WILL OCCUR. FURTHER, ESG, IN ITS SOLE DISCRETION, MAY ADJUST ESG FUND STRATEGIES, OBJECTIVE OR TERMS IN RESPONSE TO MARKET CHANGES. THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT INTENDED FOR PUBLIC USE OR DISTRIBUTION. AN INVESTMENT IN THE ESG FUNDS IS SPECULATIVE AND INVOLVES A HIGH DEGREE OF RISK. OPPORTUNITIES FOR WITHDRAWAL/REDEMPTION AND TRANSFERABILITY OF INTERESTS ARE RESTRICTED, SO INVESTORS MAY NOT HAVE ACCESS TO CAPITAL WHEN IT IS NEEDED. THERE IS NO SECONDARY MARKET FOR THE INTERESTS AND NONE IS EXPECTED TO DEVELOP. THE FEES AND EXPENSES CHARGED IN CONNECTION WITH AN INVESTMENT IN AN ESG FUND MAY BE HIGHER THAN THE FEES AND EXPENSE OF OTHER INVESTMENT ALTERNATIVES AND MAY OFFSET PROFITS. ANY INVESTMENT IN THE ESG FUNDS BEARS CONSIDERABLE RISK AND THE RISKS RELATED TO AN INVESTMENT IN A PARTICULAR ESG FUND ARE DETAILED IN SUCH FUND’S CPOM, WHICH SHOULD BE REVIEWED CAREFULLY BY EACH INVESTOR. AN INVESTOR SHOULD NOT MAKE AN INVESTMENT IN AN ESG FUND UNLESS IT IS PREPARED TO LOSE ALL OR AS SUBSTANTIAL PORTION OF ITS INVESTMENT. EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Executive Summary e t u b tri Executive Summary s i tD The world is in the midst of a global deleveraging crisis. The crisis began in the USA, moved to Europe and will soon be in China. The European crisis is far from over. Europe will have: 1. Negative GDP growth 2. Five countries soon in the “ECB Hospital” 3. Little to no progress on the fiscal side O B U o D - o N China will soon be Act III in the global deleveraging crisis. China will no longer enjoy a healthy trade surplus. China remains at the “Nexus” of the global liquidity cycle. While the US has been given a pass due to its reserve currency status and the more pressing problems in Europe and China, the debt problems in the US will soon move to the forefront of investor’s minds. China, Japan, and EM will begin to look inward to focus on their own problems. The continually shortening maturity profile of US debt makes the US even more vulnerable. n o C e d fi ia t n N l C A Emerging Markets are considered by most investors to be the one bright spot on the globe yet returns have trailed the troubled developed world. Most EM investors use flawed EM investment products and fail to benefit from the enormous dispersion between winners and losers. EM equities are not cheap. G S E PAGE | 1 e t u b tri EUROPE G S E n o C e d fi ia t n N l C A O B U o D - o N s i tD EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Executive Summary s i tD Europe represents just another step in the global deleveraging crisis that began in the US and will eventually have implications for Asia and broader emerging markets. o N The Eurozone was designed to fail given it lacks any economic rationale. The break up of a monetary union which condemns most of its members to recession and surging unemployment is not a tail risk but an inevitability. o D - The economic outlook remains bleak given the continued toxic combination of fiscal austerity, contracting bank lending, soaring unemployment, uncompetitive exchange rate, and structural rigidities. O B U Without growth, it is virtually impossible to resolve a debt problem without restructuring. C A The German solution is the promise of debt mutualization after years of austerity and structural reforms in the periphery for which there is no socio-political consensus. We do not believe this will ever happen. N l Social and political tensions in the periphery continue to grow with almost daily demonstrations against austerity and rising support for radical political parties. e d fi ia t n The European policy response has constantly remained behind the curve and while LTROs and promises of renewed ECB bond buying have reduced the risk of a complete collapse of the financial system, there has been no meaningful change to long-term sustainability of public finances, the banking sector, nor any impact on private credit growth. n o C We believe that spreads will reach new highs and the Eurozone will look very different 1-2 years from now. G S E PAGE | 3 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Previous Spikes in Public Debt/GDP Have Always Resulted in a Surge in Sovereign Default s i tD Previous to the early-1900s, under the gold standard, high debt levels were mainly reduced through default. Since the advent of fiat currencies, a combination of inflation and default has been used to reduce debt. Current levels of debt have always resulted in a surge of inflation and/or default.* SOVEREIGN DEFAULTS & INFLATION BO 50 U C A 45 40 35 30 n e id 25 f n o 20 15 10 0 C -N 1826 1830 1834 1838 1842 1846 1850 1854 1858 1862 1866 1870 1874 1878 1882 1886 1890 1894 1898 1902 1906 1910 1914 1918 1922 1926 1930 1934 1938 1942 1946 1950 1954 1958 1962 1966 1970 1974 1978 1982 1986 1990 1994 1998 2002 2006 2010 SG E 5 it al o D - o N 90 Total public debt/GDP world average (% right axis) 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 Percent of countries in default or restructuring (% left axis) Percent of countries with annual inflation over 20% (% left axis) Source: Carmen Reinhart *There can be no assurance that this trend will continue PAGE | 4 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Multi-Decade Surge in Developed Economies Debt s i tD Developed market economies have seen a rapid increase in debt since the 1970s when major currencies became completely floating and the world ended centuries of currency regimes backed by precious metals. The surge in debt in Eurozone countries since the inception of the common currency has been particularly rapid, with many peripherals seeing debt levels triple or quadruple. O B U o D - o N GOVERNMENT PLUS FINANCIAL DEBT TO GDP G S E n o C e d fi ia t n N l C A Spain PIIGS UK Italy US EU France Source: DB, BIS, Bloomberg PAGE | 5 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Eurozone – Ill Conceived Monetary Union s i tD The Eurozone is particularly vulnerable to a deleveraging cycle because it has locked itself into an ill conceived monetary union. In the three decades leading up to the introduction of the Euro, significant and continuous currency adjustment was needed for the vast majority of the members of the EU against Germany. As the chart below shows, the current most problematic Eurozone countries – Greece, Portugal, Italy and Spain – were the countries with the weakest pre-Euro currencies. O B U o D - o N EUROZONE CURRENCIES DEPRECIATION VERSUS DEM SINCE USD/GOLD CONVERTIBILITY WAS ABANDONED AND DURING THE 1990S G S E n o C e d fi ia t n N l C A Source: Deutsche Bank PAGE | 6 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Degree of Required Fiscal Adjustments is Extreme s i tD Average primary balance required to stabilize the public debt/GDP ratio at 2007 level (% of GDP) NEVER BEFORE IN OBSERVABLE Over 5yrs Over 10yrs Over 20yrs Primary balance in 2011 Austria 5.1 3.0 2.0 -0.1 France 7.3 4.3 2.8 Germany 5.5 3.5 Greece 5.4 Ireland 11.8 ECONOMIC HISTORY HAVE SO MANY COUNTRIES HAD SO MUCH DEBT. THE ADJUSTMENTS TO PRIMARY FISCAL BALANCES JUST TO BRING DEBT BACK TO 2007 LEVELS ARE EXTREME. FOR EXAMPLE, PORTUGAL WILL NEED TO AVERAGE A 5.7% PRIMARY SURPLUS FOR EACH OF THE NEXT 5 YEARS TO STABILIZE DEBT/GDP AT 2007 LEVELS, WHILE THE LARGEST PRIMARY SURPLUS OVER THE LAST 10 YEARS HAS BEEN 1%. E SG o C Largest primary balance 20002010 2.0 -2.2 -1.1 0.4 -0.7 0.3 2.1 2.8 CU 1.5 -3.0 -1.0 2.7 5.4 2.2 -9.2 -0.7 4.8 5.1 3.4 2.5 -0.5 2.3 4.1 10.1 6.4 4.5 -8.0 -4.9 -2.4 Netherlands 6.7 3.7 2.3 -3.4 0.4 2.3 Portugal 5.7 3.1 1.8 -4.4 -1.8 1.0 Spain 6.1 2.9 1.3 -4.3 0.1 2.8 UK 10.6 5.8 3.5 -7.6 -2.2 3.0 US 8.1 4.3 2.4 -7.1 -2.6 3.1 Italy Japan l- ia t n e d i nf BO o D - o N Average primary balance 20002010 NA 2.4 Source: IMF PAGE | 7 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri ECB Action Has Previously Only Provided Temporary Relief s i tD There has been an endless procession of summits over the past two and a half years proposing “Grand Plans” to resolve the crisis. All of these plans have failed and only last minute emergency measures by the ECB have prevented the situation in the Eurozone from completely unraveling. Previous episodes of ECB bond purchases and liquidity injections initially triggered sharp moves lower in periphery yields, similar to the recent rally, but failed to have a lasting impact. We believe the latest version of ECB bond buying, with its strict conditionality, will be no more effective. O B U o D - o N SPANISH 10 YEAR SPREAD VERSUS GERMANY G S E n o C ia t n N l e d fi C A Source: Bloomberg PAGE | 8 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Eurozone Still Far from Medium-term Sustainability s i tD The ECB’s OMT program provides one leg of support for a sustainable Eurozone but much more needs to be done. Most of the remaining legs have low probability of positive outcome. Core Europe governments and voters remain supportive despite growing contingent liabilities and actual costs to budgets Germany and markets allow for slower pace of fiscal austerity in periphery and France BO U C A Social rejection of austerity and reform remains manageable e d fi Banking Union – Agreement on common supervision leads to common deposit guarantee and bank resolution mechanisms G S E C on N l ia t n Banks, especially in periphery, complete deleveraging, provide credit to economy Fiscal Union - Countries to give up significant sovereignty over budgets o D - o N Greece remains in Euro. Depends on both EU writing checks and survival of weak coalition government Spain achieves fiscal consolidation, restrains independence movement in Catalonia, completes cleanup of banking system Eurozone only sustainable with a return to solid growth, falling unemployment and sustainable debt trajectories ECB/ESM provide credible lender of last resort role Italy elections produce strong reform minded government French government implements strong structural reforms Supportive global growth over coming years There can be no assurance that any or all of these scenarios will materialize. PAGE | 9 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Eurozone Had Stopped Functioning as a Monetary Union s i tD Despite the common currency, government bond markets in the periphery are becoming increasingly de-integrated from the rest of the Eurozone as foreign ownership plummets to pre-Euro levels. o D - o N GOVERNMENT MARKETABLE DEBT, FOREIGN HOLDERS (% OF TOTAL) G S E n o C e d fi C A N l ia t n O B U Source: Eurostat, Morgan Stanley Research PAGE | 10 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Europe 2013 and Beyond s i tD 1) Weak GDP growth at best 2) Five countries to enter the “ECB Hospital” 3) Austerity Kills the patient O B U 4) Non-existent fiscal improvement G S E n o C e d fi C A N l ia t n o D - o N PAGE | 11 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Growth Outlook for Europe Remains Bleak s i tD Spreads in Europe have rallied, fuelled by promises of ECB bond buying and a global search for yield that is creating a growing credit bubble. However, the growth outlook for Europe remains bleak due to the toxic combination of fiscal austerity, contracting bank lending, soaring unemployment, non competitive exchange rate, and structural rigidities. Without growth, it is virtually impossible to resolve a debt problem without restructuring. The Eurozone is expected to enter recession in 2013 with the ongoing deep recessions in the periphery to continue. O B U o D - o N MUCH OF EUROZONE FACES MANY YEARS OF STRUCTURAL LOW GDP GROWTH G S E e d i f n o C ia t n N l C A US – “weak recovery” Germany – “booming economy”?? UK France Euro Area Spain Italy IMF Forecasts Source: IMF There can be no assurance that low GDP will materialize as forecasted. PAGE | 12 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Eurozone Economic Data Continues to Deteriorate EUROZONE UNEMPLOYMENT % % yoy G S E n o C o D - o N C A N l ia t n O B U EUROZONE CONSUMER CONFIDENCE e d fi s i tD EUROZONE INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTION EUROZONE RETAIL SALES % yoy Source: Bloomberg PAGE | 13 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Growth Forecasts Have Consistently Proved Far Too Optimistic s i tD As shown below, actual GDP growth has fallen far short of consensus forecasts in 2011 and 2012. We expect that to be the case in 2013 as well. ITALY- YOY REAL GDP G S E n o C e d fi O B U o D - C A N l ia t n o N SPAIN - YOY REAL GDP e e FRANCE- YOY REAL GDP e Source: Deutsche Bank There can be no assurance that growth estimates will materialize. PAGE | 14 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Growing Social Tensions s i tD Some estimates of turnout for independence demonstration in Barcelona were over one million. G S E n o C e d fi C A N l ia t n O B U o D - o N Source: El Pais PAGE | 15 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Political Risk Growing s i tD In the recent Catalonia elections in Spain, a far left pro-independence and anti-austerity party more than doubled its votes to become the second largest party in the regional parliament. In Italy, Berlusconi is back and his party is rising in the polls ahead of the February 24 elections based on a anti-Europe, antiausterity platform. The anti-establishment Five Star Movement has become a major political force. In Greece, the left wing, anti-austerity Syriza party is now leading the polls. The neo-Nazi Golden Dawn party is rising strongly and is now polling 13% support. O B U o D - o N SHARE OF SUPPORT FOR NON-MAINSTREAM POLITICAL PARTIES (LAST ELECTION BEFORE CRISIS BEGAN IN 2010-PRESENT) G S E n o C ia t n N l e d fi C A Source: Credit Suisse PAGE | 16 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Spain – Past the Point of No Return s i tD It is hard to be bullish about a country where people of working age are leaving in growing numbers and whole regions may vote to secede. SPAIN NET MIGRATION n o C O B U C A N l ia t n e d fi o D - o N SHOULD CATALONIA BECOME INDEPENDENT? Source: INE, population nowcast G S E Source: Goldman Sachs PAGE | 17 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Greece – Still a Very Significant Risk s i tD Greece will likely, once again, fail to meet the conditions of the bailout loans. Greece has already implemented more austerity than any other country on an IMF program ever, and the weak coalition government is unlikely to be able to muster the political will to do what is being asked of it. The far left Syriza is now leading opinion polls with the neo Nazi Golden dawn party rising to third. Combined, they now have 45% support. O B U o D - o N LATEST POLL – SUPPORT FOR GREEK POLITICAL PARTIES G S E n o C ia t n N l e d fi C A Source: VPRC PAGE | 18 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Spain: Entering a Greek Like Vicious Circle s i tD Despite never ending austerity measures, the Spanish fiscal deficit looks likely to once again miss the official target by a wide margin. The deficit target for 2012 has already been revised twice, from 4.6% to 5.3% of GDP and then to 6.3%. It will likely be around 8.0%. The fiscal/economic outlook in Spain looks increasingly similar to Greece where austerity led to a sharp contraction in the economy, which resulted in overshooting of fiscal deficit targets and required further austerity. O B U o D - o N SPANISH BUDGET DEFICIT EVOLUTION G S E C f n o N l ia t n e d i C A 2011 2012 2011 2012 2011 2012 2011 2012 Revisions to 2011 during 2012 Changes to projected deficit during 2012 Source: IGAE, Spanish Finance Ministry, J.P. Morgan PAGE | 19 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Short-Term Fiscal Austerity May Kill the Patient s i tD We are highly skeptical that the Eurozone policymakers will implement medium-term reforms needed to make the Eurozone a sustainable monetary union. The argument may end up being irrelevant with a strong possibility of short-term austerity killing the patient. o D - o N AUSTERITY ONLY MAKING THE PROBLEM WORSE E SG C on e d fi C A N l ia t n O B U E E Source: Goldman Sachs There can be no assurances that estimated percentages will come to fruition. PAGE | 20 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Despite Austerity, Debt Levels Continue to Grow s i tD Despite years of austerity, the Euro area is still far from achieving sustainable primary surpluses of the size required to stabilize debt levels. GOVERNMENT DEBT %GDP G S E n o C e d fi C A N l ia t n O B U o D - o N Source: IMF There can be no assurances that the estimated metrics will materialize.. PAGE | 21 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Austerity Combined with Private Sector Deleveraging Creating a Perfect Storm s i tD Fiscal austerity alone of the magnitude required to stabilize debt levels in Europe would be painful. When combined with deleveraging of the highly indebted private sector, a perfect storm is created. …..AND AS A RESULT ARE REDUCING THEIR BALANCE SHEETS EURO AREA BANKS ARE HIGHLY LEVERAGED…. G S E n o C e d fi O B U C A N l ia t n o D - o N Source: Goldman Sachs PAGE | 22 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Austerity Combined with Private Sector Deleveraging Creating a Perfect Storm Even when credit is available, it is prohibitively expensive in the periphery. This has not been corrected, as promised, by Draghi’s OMT. o D - s i tD o N THE CORE-PERIPHERY LENDING GAP SME LOAN RATES, 1-5 YEARS G S E n o C C A N l ia t n e d fi O B U Source: IMF PAGE | 23 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Greece Will Need Further Debt Restructuring s i tD The debt trajectory for Greece, announced in a second bailout in March, has already soared way beyond even the worst case scenarios, requiring a third bailout just eight months later. o D - o N EVOLUTION IN PROJECTIONS FOR GREEK GOVERNMENT DEBT % OF GDP E SG n o C e d fi C A N l ia t n O B U E E E E E E E E Source: Moody’s There can be no assurances that the estimated metrics will materialize.. PAGE | 24 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri Complacency Returns s i tD Whether or not the Eurozone becomes a functional and sustainable monetary union will ultimately be decided by politicians and not central bankers. Politicians will need to ignore electoral calendars and make long term commitments to highly unpopular structural reforms of their domestic economies and cede significant sovereignty over their economies, budgets, and banking systems to European institutions. Northern European governments will need to convince their taxpayers to accept years of fiscal transfers to Southern European countries in the name of European unity. However, once again, with market pressure easing, complacency has returned to Eurozone capitals. Progress on negotiations over reforms such as fiscal and banking union, touted as vital to save the Eurozone just a few short months ago, have come to a standstill. The first and easiest step towards banking union (common bank supervision) will likely be delayed until 2014, at the earliest. Greater fiscal union is now seen as a “medium-term” goal. Politicians now claim that the Eurozone crisis is over and the ECB, without buying a single bond, has relieved them of any need to make urgent progress on structural reforms. We believe that they are, once again, mistaken. G S E n o C e d fi C A N l ia t n O B U o D - o N Source: Moody’s PAGE | 25 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri The Developed World’s Debt Crisis is Ridiculous SPAIN 10YR BOND YIELD* 8 O B U 7.5 7 6.5 6 5.5 5 n o C 4.5 G S E e d fi o N C A N l ia t n o D - s i tD * Updated as of: 1/8/2013 Source: Bloomberg PAGE | 26 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Europe e t u b tri The Developed World’s Debt Crisis is Ridiculous FRANCE 10YR BOND YIELD* 3.4 3.2 O B U 3 2.4 2.2 N l 2 n o C 1.8 G S E e d fi ia t n o N C A 2.8 2.6 o D - s i tD The next trade: short these countries in absolute yield – not in spread. * Updated as of: 1/8/2013 Source: Bloomberg PAGE | 27 e t u b tri CHINA G S E n o C e d fi ia t n N l C A O B U o D - o N s i tD EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) China e t u b tri Executive Summary s i tD While the world is obsessed with Europe, we believe that China will move to the forefront of investors’ minds over the next 1-3 years. Much like the US and Europe, we believe that China will soon be dealing with the fallout from a credit bust. o N • China has engaged in highly wasteful investment and credit expansion in the past decade. o D - • Between 2000 and 2008, China funded investment with huge FX inflows, but those inflows have stopped. • In 2012, China sustained investment through a rapid expansion of off-balance sheet financing, which is very risky. O B U • Unless massive inflows resume, China will be forced to increase risks in off-balance sheet assets, print massively, or face a hardlanding. C A Any China focused strategy needs to appreciate the five different paths that China can go down. G S E n o C e d fi ia t n N l PAGE | 29 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) China e t u b tri Trade Surplus as a Share of GDP Investment NET EXPORT AS A SHARE OF GDP 0.08 CHINA’S HEFTY TRADE SURPLUSES ARE A THING 0.07 OF THE PAST. O B U 0.06 e d fi 0.02 n o C N l ia t n 0.03 o N C A 0.05 0.04 o D - s i tD 0.01 G S E 0 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 Net Export as a Share of GDP Source: CEIC PAGE | 30 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) China e t u b tri Deposit Growth Slows Dramatically s i tD YOY % CHANGE IN CHINA’S DEPOSITS 30% 28% 26% 24% 22% 20% 18% 16% 14% G S E 12% n o C nt e d fi ial O B U - Do o N DEPOSIT GROWTH HAS SLOWED DRAMATICALLY. IN 2009, CHINA HAD PLENTY OF “DRY POWDER” WITH WHICH C A -N WHILE STILL IN THE LOW DOUBLE-DIGITS, CHINA’S TO IGNITE A “STIMULATIVE” BOOM IN PROPERTY AND INFRASTRUCTURE. THIS IS NOT SO TODAY. 10% 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Source: CEIC PAGE | 31 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) China e t u b tri China’s Trade Surplus No Longer Generates Naturally Abundant Liquidity s i tD In the past, Chinese stimulus programs were easily funded out of the abundance of liquidity created by China’s trade surpluses and consequent FX reserve accumulation. o N Today, with FX reserves stagnating, the liquidity to fund any stimulus program would have to be created by the PBOC, which would likely result in CNY weakness, an accelerated reduction of FX reserves, and potentially high inflation. CHINA’S FX INFLOW (BARS) IS NO LONGER DRIVEN BY TRADE SURPLUSES (LINE). ia t n FX RESERVES ARE NOW MAINLY DRIVEN BY CAPITAL FLOWS, LARGELY IN THE FORM OF “HOT MONEY.” G S E n o C N l e d fi C A O B U o D - CHINA’S FX RESERVES ARE NOW STAGNATING (AND LIKELY HEADING INTO REVERSE). PAGE | 32 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) China e t u b tri Economic Rebalancing is a Myth s i tD Efficient, wealth-creating investment should generate the productivity enhancements, jobs, and income, to naturally facilitate the “hand-off” to consumption. This is not happening in China. CHINA’S “GROWTH” IS FAR TOO RELIANT ON HIDDEN SUBSIDIES TO FIXED ASSET INVESTMENT AND INEFFICIENT SOE’S. HALTING SUCH POLICIES IN ORDER TO REBALANCE THE ECONOMY WOULD NECESSITATE A LENGTHY PERIOD OF MUCH LOWER GROWTH. POLITICAL REALITIES SUGGEST THIS IS UNLIKELY. G S E n o C e d fi C A N l ia t n O B U o D - o N PAGE | 33 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) China e t u b tri China’s Growth Model: “If You Build it, They Will Come” s i tD CEMENT CONSUMPTION PER CAPITA VS. GDP PER CAPITA EACH SET OF SYMBOLS REPRESENTS A NATION’S DEVELOPMENT PATH OVER TIME. CHINA’S PATH KOREA’S PATH BY THIS METRIC, THE RATE AT WHICH CHINA IS BUILDING BO U C A THINGS RELATIVE TO ITS GROWTH IN INCOMES IS UNPRECEDENTED IN MODERN ECONOMIC HISTORY. SOMEDAY BE ABLE TO PRODUCTIVELY UTILIZE ALL THE INFRASTRUCTURE, PROPERTY AND INDUSTRIAL CAPACITY, THE DEBT WITH WHICH IT WAS FINANCED NEEDS TO BE SERVICED TODAY. G S E n o C e d fi SPAIN’S PATH N l ia t n EVEN IF, AS THE BULLS ARGUE, CHINA MIGHT o D - o N Source: J.P. Morgan Calculations PAGE | 34 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) China e t u b tri Funding Past Malinvestment Requires Ever Larger Doses of New Credit o D - CONVERSION OF INCREMENTAL DEBT INTO INCREMENTAL ONE UNIT OF NEW FINANCING IN 2006 CREATED 1.16 UNITS OF ADDITIONAL GDP IN 2007. 140% 120% TODAY, 88% 77% 60% ADDITIONAL CREDIT PRODUCES LESS THAN HALF A UNIT OF NEW GDP. G S E n o C U C A 100% EACH UNIT OF e d fi 0% 1 o N 116% 2003 81% N l 71% ia t n 40% 20% BO GDP1 105% 80% s i tD Credit growth has become much less efficient in generating new GDP, as increasing portions go to the rolling of principal and accumulating interest on past debts. 2004 38% 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 44% 2010 50% 37%* 2011 2012 Incremental Nominal GDP / Prior Year’s Total Social Financing. Source: PBOC, World Bank Ever-expanding credit growth is required to both fund past malinvestments and ensure continued new investment at levels sufficient to meet government GDP targets. * 2012 estimate assumes 10% growth in nominal GDP and 16% growth in social finance, which are the 1H growth rates. PAGE | 35 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) China e t u b tri The Explosion of Grey Market Financing and Risks s i tD Rapid rise in wealth management products (WMPs) and other shadow financing (see below) Through WMPs, credit risks have shifted from banks to millions of corporations and households. WMPs, with three to six month maturity, finance multi-year projects. o D - Banks put some of their worst assets in WMPs, but investors assume there is no risk. O B U GROWTH IN WMPS AND SHADOW FINANCING 60 50 40 30 20 n o C 10 E SG C A N l ia t n e d fi o N 0 2011 WMPs as % of GDP 2012 Shadow Banking Assets as % of GDP Source: Fitch, BAML PAGE | 36 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) China e t u b tri The Explosion of Grey Market Financing and Risks s i tD Contrary to the assumption of many investors, WMPs are legally not guaranteed by the banks. Banks are beginning to default on WMPs, which they have sold on behalf of third parties. In a panic, it is generally impossible to roll all of the underlying assets in WMPs back on banks’ balance sheets unless the PBOC drastically reduced RRR. A panic in WMPs can easily lead to a run on the banks. G S E n o C e d fi C A N l ia t n O B U o D - o N Source: 21CBH.com PAGE | 37 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) China e t u b tri A Fiscal Solution or a Foreign Bailout of China’s Financial System is Impossible s i tD Total Assets in the Chinese banking system in excess of 300% of GDP, or 150% of US GDP. In the five years to end-2012, China’s banking system assets will have grown by USD 14T, equivalent in size to the entire US commercial banking system. o D - o N BANKING SYSTEM ASSETS AS A PERCENTAGE OF GDP (END 2011) O B U 450% 400% 350% 300% 79% 250% 200% 421% 373% 150% on 100% 50% 0% G S E C A Shadow Banking C ia t n e d fi 328% N l 240% 192% 180% 144% 117% 112% 106% 94% 76% Source: PBoC, CEIC, World Bank PAGE | 38 e t u b tri US G S E n o C e d fi ia t n N l C A O B U o D - o N s i tD EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) US e t u b tri Executive Summary s i tD Fed QE has the effect of dramatically shortening the average maturity of US debt. Financing a debt load of 70% of GDP (and rising) at 3-year average maturity would be viewed as highly irresponsible anywhere else. o N This irresponsible fiscal behavior is made temporarily possible by large scale, price-insensitive buying of US assets by global central banks. o D - However, the ability of foreign central banks to “recycle” of excess liquidity, thereby accommodating Fed printing, is coming to an end as the EM world’s Balance of Payments surplus has effectively disappeared. O B U Fed QE has been effective in pushing inflation breakevens higher (thereby lessening debt loads in real terms). The bond rally is the result of a sharp decline in real yields, which are poised to head sharply higher as the “global recycling” game comes to an end. N l C A US yields are not suppressed because “we are like Japan.” US yields are trading well (and unsustainably) through the growth rate in nominal GDP, which is running at a steady 4%. By contrast, low JGB yields were justified by flat-lining nominal GDP. G S E n o C e d fi ia t n PAGE | 40 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) US e t u b tri The Limit to the Fed Backstop: Treasury’s Funding Stance is Becoming Highly Unstable s i tD Let us say Treasury issues USD 100bn in 30-year bonds. The Fed then “issues” USD 100bn in excess reserves (overnight deposits) at 0.25% and uses the proceeds to purchase USD 100bn in 30-year bonds. On a consolidated basis the US Government has funded itself via the issuance of overnight debt. As the US Treasury has endeavored to lengthen the average maturity of its debt outstanding, a seemingly prudent policy at generational lows on interest rates, Fed QE policies have more than offset those efforts. O B U AVERAGE MATURITY OF US TREASURY MARKETABLE DEBT G S E C on N l ia t n e d fi C A o D - o N Fed QE has pushed the average maturity of the US debt outstanding to a mere three years – lower than anything seen in peripheral Europe. Fed QE policies are creating a massive “rollover risk.” Any Fed attempt to step up QE purchases to cap yields in the face of waning interest on the part of foreign central banks will risk a run on the Dollar. Source: Federal Reserve, US Treasury, calculations by Encima Global. PAGE | 41 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) US e t u b tri The Exorbitant Privilege: US Treasuries Afloat Upon a Sea of “Ink-Money” s i tD How long can the US government expect to fund patently irresponsible fiscal deficits at near-zero interest rates? As long as global central banks remain willing and able to act as the marginal buyers, regardless of the rates on offer. Fully half of the outstanding supply of US Treasuries has now been monetized by global central banks (including the Fed). o D - o N P roport ion of Treasuries O ut st anding Held by G lobal C ent ral Banks O B U (Including Fed Holdings) C A 60.0 N l 52.5 45.0 n e id 37.5 G S E C f n o tia 60.0 52.5 45.0 37.5 30.0 30.0 22.5 22.5 15.0 15.0 95 Source: Hav er Analytics 00 05 10 PAGE | 42 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) US e t u b tri The Machinery of Global Liquidity Recycling is Breaking Down s i tD Global reserve accumulation has been the accommodating factor for excess US credit growth pre-crisis and Fed QE post-crisis, creating the illusion of a money-printing “free lunch” for the US. o N But as higher EM inflation erodes competitiveness and liquidity-destroying local credit busts unfold, EM’s ability to sustain the process is coming to end. o D - With global partners becoming unable to further accommodate Fed money printing, the inflationary effect on the Dollar and US long yields will start to reveal itself. O B U BRICKS* FX RESERVE ACCUMULATION (Y/Y) 50% ia t n 30% 20% n o C 10% e d fi 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 0% 2002 G S E C A N l 40% -10% * Brazil, Russia, India, China, Korea, Singapore Source: Haver Analytics / ESG Calculations PAGE | 43 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) US e t u b tri The Yield Decline is Solely a “Real Rate” Phenomenon s i tD As inflation expectations ratchet higher with each spin of the Fed printing press, so to do real yields push to more negative levels. A clean break above 2.50% in the 10-year breakeven would be a big event technically. Barring a complete meltdown in Europe, it is hard to see nominal yields trading lower when breakeven inflation rates are breaking out to the topside. The Fed floor under the breakeven inflation rate should also broadly serve as a floor on nominal yields. O B U o D - o N US 10YR REAL RATES (TIPS) VERSUS THE 10YR INFLATION BREAKEVEN G S E n o C e d fi ia t n N l C A Treasury buyers are locking in a decade of -0.77% real returns – hardly a sustainable strategy. PAGE | 44 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) US e t u b tri If the US were “Becoming Japan” Rates Would Not be Trading through Nominal GDP JAPAN POST-CRISIS NGDP GROWTH = 0% US POST-CRISIS NGDP GROWTH = 4% SEE THE SIMILARITIES? NEITHER DO WE! G S E n o C e d fi ia t n N l C A O B U - Do o N s i tD US nGDP = 4% US 10y Note = 1.6% 10y less nGDP = -2.4% 10y JGB = 0.8% Japan nGDP = -0.5% 10y less nGDP = +1.3% PAGE | 45 e t u b tri EM G S E n o C e d fi ia t n N l C A O B U o D - o N s i tD EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) EM e t u b tri Executive Summary s i tD The EM consumer should be the focus for investors. Traditional avenues of EM investing FAIL! EM growth and increased EM consumerism does not equal returns – stock picking does! EM Universe filled with big winners and big losers and exciting dispersion. O B U EM equities are not cheap. They are expensive. G S E n o C e d fi C A N l ia t n o D - o N PAGE | 47 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) EM e t u b tri Domestic Demand is the “Sweet Spot” of Emerging Market Equities s i tD ESG believes that global consumption growth will come predominantly from emerging markets. o N ESG believes that emerging markets are now positioned at the beginning of an exciting credit cycle. HOUSEHOLD DISPOSABLE INCOME OVER US$10,0001 2020e 2019e 2018e 2017e 2016e 2015e 2014e 2013e 2012e 2011e 2010e 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2004 2003 2002 e d fi 1996 1993 1992 G S E 1991 0 n o C 1995 50 1994 100 o D - C A ia t n 2000 150 Euro Area N l 1999 200 1998 250 1997 300 O B U US Number of Households (Millions) 350 BRICs 2001 400 (1) Source: Euromonitor, Morgan Stanley Research. Forward projections are Euromonitor Estimates. Note: data end-2009; 2010 data not finalized as of August 2011. (2) Source: IMF IFS, Central Bank data, BofA Merrill Lynch Global Research estimates. There can be no assurance that estimated regional growth will materialize. PAGE | 48 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) EM e t u b tri Domestic Demand is the “Sweet Spot” of Emerging Market Equities s i tD MISALLOCATION OF CAPITAL ESG believes that traditional emerging market vehicles do not provide adequate exposure to the exciting emerging market consumer sector. Indices and many long-only vehicles1: Dominated by megacaps Significant commodity and export-related exposure Underweight niche emerging market growth opportunities which are driven by domestic demand Top 10 Holdings of MSCI Emerging Markets Index (EEM) Name Samsung Electronics 3.12% Description Global Exporter Petrobras 2.63% Commodity Vale 2.11% Taiwan Semiconductor 1.90% on China Mobile en fid C A Name N l tia Commodity Global Exporter Top 10 Holdings of Brazil Bovespa Index (IBOV) Weighting Description PetroChina China Construction Bank Industrial & Commercial BoC 10.19% Commodity 10.14% Name Weighting Description Vale 10.93% Commodity Bank Petrobras 10.22% Commodity 9.81% Bank OGX 5.46% Commodity Bank of China 9.77% Bank Itau Unibanco 4.54% Bank China Life Insurance China Petroleum & Chemical 6.46% Insurer BM&F Bovespa 3.49% Exchange 6.30% Commodity Banco do Brasil 3.29% Bank PDG Realty 3.26% Homebuilder Gerdau 3.10% Commodity Chinese Telco 1.76% Commodity America Movil 1.41% Telco Ping An Insurance 5.40% Insurer China Construction Bank 1.30% Bank 4.97% Commodity Itau Unibanco Industrial & Commercial Bank of China 1.29% Brazilian Bank China Shenhua Energy Agricultural Bank of China 3.59% Bank Banco Bradesco 3.02% Bank 1.11% Bank China Merchants Bank 2.72% Bank Usiminas 2.66% Commodity SG E Weighting O B U Top 10 Holdings of Hang Seng China Enterprises Index (HSCEI) 1.82% Gazprom (1) o D - o N C As of Q1 2012; Source: Bloomberg. Composition of top 10 holdings in the respective regional indices are subject to change over time. PAGE | 49 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) EM WIDE DISPERSION BETWEEN WINNERS AND LOSERS CREATES A ROBUST ENVIRONMENT FOR STOCK SELECTION ESG Universe of EM Domestic Demand Stocks (MSCI EM: 19% 2010) # of Stocks 400 300 In 2011, 417 stocks were down greater than 20%, while there were 343 stocks that were positive. 227 61 100 250 150 # of Stocks >100% 36 E SG C nt e d i (1) Source: ESG Internal Analysis, Bloomberg; The information contained herein has been prepared by Emerging Sovereign Group. The dispersion data analysis is based on the "universe" of stocks that are primarily, emerging market domestic demand focused names, which trade more than a total of $5mm a day, on a rolling six month daily average basis. (2) Through 09/30/12 ial >25% & <50% 50 o N >0% &<25% 180 Losers 68 55 57 <0% & >-10% <-10% & >-20% <-20% (MSCI EM: -18.3% 2011) 181 76 627 Losers 150 109 101 250 350 417 450 >100% 550 450 350 # of Stocks Opportunities exist to generate returns on both sides of the portfolio (long and short). CU A N - 50 BO >50% & <100% o D - 343 Winners 50 f n o 155 136 - Growing dispersion presents an exciting opportunity for fundamental stock picking. s i tD 579 Winners 200 100 It is not surprising that some EM hedge funds have struggled in the past 12 months as the market has not behaved in a directional manner. e t u b tri ESG UNIVERSE OF EMERGING MARKET DOMESTIC DEMAND STOCKS - PERFORMANCE DISPERSION IN 2010 , 2011 & 20121 >50% & <100% >0% &<25% <0% & >-10% <-10% & >-20% <-20% (MSCI EM: 12.2% 20122) 577 351 747 Winners 236 250 150 >25% & <50% 118 42 328 Losers 50 50 105 124 84 120 150 >100% >50% & <100% >25% & <50% >0% &<25% <0% & >-10% <-10% & >-20% <-20% PAGE | 50 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) EM e t u b tri Keys to Hedge Fund Success in EM s i tD Focus on 3 to 1 return to risk opportunities – eliminate everything else. Low net – let stock picking drive returns! Limit country exposures – let stock picking drive returns! No FX risk – let stock picking drive returns! O B U Only analyzable businesses / Commodity stocks are unanalyzable o D - o N Focus on individual long and shorts. Indices add no alpha and create commodity and market cap mismatches. Exclusively liquid stocks – Liquidity in EM is king! G S E n o C e d fi ia t n N l C A PAGE | 51 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) EM e t u b tri Long | Short Equity Risk Management: The “Matrix” Approach¹ s i tD MATRIX AND NET PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT 1000 Stocks = ESG Universe o D - 450 Stocks = ESG Matrices O B U o N C A “1 Matrix” LOWER BOUND 100 n o C ial 75 fid t n e -N 3 to 1 +/- UPPER BOUND 50 25 1 to 1 +/- 1 to 3 +/- 0 At a score of 75: the average upside/downside ratio is 3 to 1 G S E At a score of 25: the average upside/downside ratio is 1 to 3 (1) The Matrix Approach is included to illustrate ESG’s current intended approach to risk management. This approach and the parameters set forth herein may be adjusted at any time in ESG’s discretion. PAGE | 52 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Private Fund Risk and Other Disclosures e t u b tri The products described herein are unregistered private investment funds commonly called “hedge funds” (each, a “Private Fund”). Private Funds, depending upon their investment objectives and strategies, may invest and trade in many different markets, strategies and instruments (including securities, non-securities and derivatives) and are NOT subject to the same regulatory requirements as mutual funds, including requirements to provide certain periodic and standardized pricing and valuation information to investors. There are substantial risks in investing in a Private Fund, including risks associated with limited or no regulatory oversight. You should note that: s i tD o N A Private Fund represents a speculative investment and involves a high degree of risk. Investors must have the financial ability, sophistication/experience and willingness to bear the risks of an investment in a Private Fund. An investor could lose all or a substantial portion of his/her/its investment. o D - An investment in a Private Fund is not suitable for all investors. An investment in a Private Fund should be discretionary capital set aside strictly for speculative purposes. Only qualified eligible investors may invest in a Private Fund. O B U A Private Fund’s prospectus or offering documents are not reviewed or approved by federal or state regulators and its privately placed interests are not federally or state registered. C A An investment in a Private Fund may be illiquid and there are significant restrictions on transferring or redeeming interests in a Private Fund. There is no secondary market for an investor’s investment in a Private Fund and none is expected to develop. Substantial redemptions within a limited period of time could compel a Private Fund to liquidate its securities positions more rapidly than otherwise would be desirable, which could adversely affect the value of the distribution proceeds and the value of the remaining interests in a Private Fund. ia t n N l The net asset value of a Private Fund may be determined by its administrator or a pricing committee retained by the Private Fund in consultation with its manager or advisor in certain cases. Certain portfolio assets may be illiquid and without a readily ascertainable market value. Since the value assigned to portfolio securities affects a manager’s or advisor’s compensation, the manager’s or advisor’s involvement in the valuation process creates a potential conflict of interest. The value assigned to such securities may differ from the value a Private Fund is able to realize. Instances of mispriced portfolios, due to fraud or negligence, have occurred in the industry. n o C e d fi A Private Fund may trade in commodity interests and futures, may execute a substantial portion of trades on foreign exchanges, and/or may invest in credit instruments, real estate, alternative or non-traditional assets or other instruments, each of which involve specified risks as disclosed in such Private Fund’s offering documents and which could result in a substantial risk of loss. Commodities and futures prices may be highly volatile and are difficult to predict. G S E A Private Fund may use derivative financial instruments, including, futures, swaps, options, credit default swaps and credit default indices, both for hedging and speculative purposes. The use of derivative instruments involves a variety of material risks, including the high degree of leverage often embedded in such instruments and the possibility of counterparty non-performance as well as of material and prolonged deviations between the actual and the theoretical value of a derivative instrument. PAGE | 53 EMERGING SOVEREIGN GROUP, LLC (“ESG”) Private Fund Risk and Other Disclosures (cont.) e t u b tri A Private Fund’s manager or advisor has total trading authority over a Private Fund. The death or disability of the portfolio manager or advisor, or their departure, may have a material adverse effect on a Private Fund. s i tD A Private Fund may use a single advisor or employ a single strategy, which could mean a lack of diversification and higher risk. A Private Fund may involve a complex tax structure, which should be reviewed carefully, and may involve structures or strategies that may cause delays in important tax information being sent to investors. o N A Private Fund’s fees and expenses which may be substantial regardless of any positive return will offset such Private Fund’s trading profits. If a Private Fund’s investments are not successful, these payments and expenses may, over a period of time, deplete the net asset value of a Private Fund. o D - A Private Fund and its managers/advisors and their affiliates may be subject to various potential and actual conflicts of interest. A Private Fund may employ investment strategies or techniques aimed to reduce the risk of loss which may not be successful. O B U A Private Fund may not be required to provide periodic pricing or valuation information to investors. A Private Fund may employ leverage. The more leverage used, the more likely a substantial change in value may occur, either up or down. N l C A The above summary is not a complete list of the risks, tax considerations and other important disclosures involved in investing in a Private Fund and is subject to the more complete disclosures in such Private Fund’s offering documents, which must be reviewed carefully prior to making an investment. ia t n These Materials have been distributed by TCG Securities, L.L.C., a limited purpose broker/dealer registered with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) and member of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (“FINRA”). Related financial products and services are only available to investors deemed to be “qualified purchasers” as defined in Section 2(a)(51) of the Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended, and “accredited investors” as defined in Regulation D of the 1933 Securities Act, as amended. G S E n o C e d fi PAGE | 54