* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Download Secular Outlook - BMO Bank of Montreal
Survey
Document related concepts
Transcript
Global Global Investment Investment Forum Forum 2014 2014 –– 2019 2019 Secular Outlook Table Table of of contents contents Shew-stone Shew stone paths 22} } The TheWest WestRides RidesAgain Again BMO pleased toispresent – 2019 BMO Global Global Asset Asset Management Management is(BMO GAM) pleasedour to2014 present ourGlobal 2014 Forum Secular Outlook. Outlook. The The Outlook Secular Outlook is a product of our –Investment 2019 Secular Investment is a product of our annual annual global investment a full and evening of sharing, discussion global investment forum; forum: a full day andday evening of sharing, discussion and and collaboration among organization’s investment leaders and strategists collaboration amongst ourour organization’s investment leaders and strategists from from around around the the world, world, in in addition addition to to select select outside outside experts. experts. 55} } Synchronized SynchronizedGrowth Growth 66} } Broken BrokenChina/Eurozone China/Eurozone 88} } Conclusion Conclusion This This secular secular (longer-term) (longer-term) outlook outlook informs informs our our strategic strategic portfolio portfolio allocations allocations and and establishes establishes guard guard rails rails for for active active asset asset allocation allocation opportunities opportunities that that may may arise arise through to month) 18-month) strategy work. through our our cyclical cyclical (shorter-term/12(shorter-term/12-18 strategy work. Shew-Stone Outlook, is a reference to an object, like “Shew StonePaths, Paths”,the thetitle titleofofthis thisyear’s year’sSecular Outlook, is a reference to an object, like a crystal aball, crystal ball, used in the art ancient art ofor scrying or the practice seeing intoOur theForum future. used in the ancient of scrying the practice of seeingofthe future. Our Global Investment Forum served shew stone and what saw a number served as this Shew Stone and what as weasaw were a number of we paths orwere scenarios that of paths scenarios that couldaplay out, each havingThe a decided probability. Thewith three titled could or play out, each having decided probability. three titled scenarios their scenarios their respective respectivewith probabilities are: probabilities are: Rides •• The West The WestAgain Rides(60%) Again (60%) Growth Growth (30%) (30%) •• Synchronized Synchronized (10%) (10%) •• Broken China/Eurozone Broken China/Eurozone In Ineach eachscenario scenariowe weinclude includeaahigh highlevel levelsummary summaryof ofthe theglobal globalconditions conditionsattached attachedto tothat scenario as well metrics important to thetoscenario. In addition, for each scenario we that scenario as select well select metrics important the scenario. In addition for each scenario identify areasareas of investment emphasis and and de-emphasis. we identify of investment emphasis de-emphasis. The investment reach of our BMO Global Asset Management team includes: investment oversight of over $132 billion in assets, 1,000 investment related personnel spanning staff and boutiques across the U.S., Canada Europe, Asia and Middle East. BMO Global Asset Management’s resources provide solutions for each major asset and sub asset class, including alternatives, within and across the developed, emerging and frontier markets. The west rides again (60%) In The West Rides Again, growth in the U.S., which has surpassed most of the rest of the developed world in recovering from the crash of 2008 and the Great Recession, accelerates from its current slow pace and reaches “normal” levels. Meanwhile, Europe grows slowly as it emerges from the recent recession, while continuing to wrestle with high government debt, instability caused by the euro and demographic challenges. An initially stronger euro reduces export competitiveness and Germany pushes back on unconventional central bank policies intended to stimulate growth. Japan continues current reforms, which enables the country to avoid slipping back into recession. China’s curtailing of credit growth and a general pullback of foreign capital inflows impairs economic growth for many emerging-market countries, but there is no Chinese hard landing. We believe that The West Rides Again is the most likely prospect because the structural and demographic problems of the United States are much less severe than those of Europe, China and Japan. As Figures 1 and 2 indicate, population growth rates have slowed everywhere, but U.S. demographic prospects are more favorable than those of the rest of the developed world. Population in the U.S. is at least moving in a positive direction; while growth is slow, at 0.7% per year, there is no comparison with southern Europe or Japan, where populations are actually shrinking. Dependency ratios, rising across most developed economies, are doing so more slowly in the U.S. than in Europe and Japan, as shown in Figure 2; this trend will be reinforced if immigration to the U.S. accelerates. FIGURE 1 Finally, world population growth is leveling off 12,000,000 Population (thousands) 10,000,000 Growth rate (%) Population (LHS) Growth rate (RHS) 2.5 100 Japan Italy Europe North America Oceania Asia 90 80 70 50 40 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2030 2050 While much ink has been spilled on the topic of government debt, such debt is lower in the U.S. than in many other key countries. Although Figure 3 shows gross debt, U.S. government debt held by the public (the economically relevant measure) is only 73% of Gross Domestic Product (GDP), while the corresponding number for European countries ranges as high as 120% in Italy and averages 83% in the European Union; in Japan, it’s about 200% and rising. In addition, the current account deficit in the U.S. fell from -60% in 2008 to -2.0% year-to-date. FIGURE 3 Compared with many other countries, U.S. government debt is moderate 250 Percent 244 184 143 150 1.5 132 129 106 100 98 94 92 1.0 4,000,000 2040 Source: United Nations Population Division – 2012 Revision (medium variant); Pyrford International 200 6,000,000 Dependency ratio = population age 0-14 and 65+ divided by population age 15-64 60 2.0 8,000,000 50 87 80 34 0.5 2,000,000 0 1950 FIGURE 2 Dependency ratios are soaring, with Europe and Japan leading the way 0 2000 2050 2100 Source: United Nations Population Division – 2012 Revision (medium variant); Pyrford International 0.0 Japan Greece Portugal Italy Ireland U.S. Spain France UK Canada Germany Australia Note: Figure 3 shows gross debt. Narrative in text refers to debt held by the public (which is numerically lower) Sources: OECD Economic Outlook – May 2013; IMF October 2013 2 And, as shown in Figure 4, deleveraging has proceeded much more expeditiously in the U.S. than elsewhere, with improvement in both corporate and household balance sheets. FIGURE 4 Household deleveraging in the U.S. has brought debt-to-income ratio back to 2003 levels 170 Percent Canada Australia UK U.S. 150 130 110 90 70 50 30 1977 1980 1983 1986 1989 1992 1995 1998 2001 2004 2007 2010 2013 Sources: Reserve Bank of Australia; Statistics Canada & Thomson Datastream E359, E389 The West Rides Again Over emphasize Under emphasize EQUITIES Developed markets U.S. • Allocate across large-, mid- and • Utility and telecommunication small-cap stocks sectors • Companies with improving • Companies with debt-laden top-line growth and margins, and balance sheets those within cyclical sectors Non U.S. • Stocks with relatively cheaper valuations and stronger growth prospects Emerging and • Country selection and sector • Markets with inflation concerns allocation are important • Active management over passive • Pay attention to valuations and look for opportunities arising from consumption trends frontier markets • European Union banking sector as they undergo stress tests and face capital concerns • Cautious on southern Europe and Japan Impact on asset class returns — Equities In a scenario where the U.S. leads in macroeconomic performance, U.S. equities also lead globally, with a continuation of the current bull market. Valuation multiples have already reached respectable – although not alarmingly – high levels, and there are fewer opportunities for cost cutting, so further stock gains will have to be supported by sales or revenue (“top-line”) growth. This is typical of a later cycle bull market. Early in the bull cycle, the market recovers powerfully from depressed levels through multiple expansion; later, sales and earnings grow to justify the higher multiples. Equity categories that can be expected to lead as the bull market extends should include industrials, financials, consumer discretionary and technology stocks; for example, industrials where capacity is being re-utilized. Because the yield curve will probably steepen, financials will have higher interest rates with which to attract depositors and investors, and these companies, which have a heavy weight in value benchmarks, could do well. With interest rates rising, investors would do well to underweight utilities and other interes-rate-sensitive issues, as well as companies relying on a very low cost of capital to enhance their growth. On a cautionary note, Figure 5 shows profit margins for the S&P 500® over the last decade, and Figure 6 shows overall (NIPA) corporate profits as a percentage of GDP over two-thirds of a century; both indicators of profitability are at historic highs. Margins may revert toward their historical average, which is a skinny 5.9% over 19522013 (not shown) and 8.3% over the last decade (as shown in Figure 5). Companies have already aggressively cut labor costs and other expenses, and little profit improvement can be expected from further action along those lines. Some productivity gains from increased automation and reduced energy costs may support margins. FIGURE 5 Net profit margin of S&P 500®, 2003-2013 10 Percent S&P 500® — net margin 9 FIXED INCOME • Shorter duration - Global credit including U.S. - High yield - Emerging market debt - Bank loans • Intermediate to long duration • Developed market sovereign debt. • Private equity • Fixed income defensive hedges • REITs • Private real estate 8 7 6 ALTERNATIVES 5 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 Source: Bloomberg L.P. 3 FIGURE 6 NIPA corporate profits as a percentage of GDP, 1946-2013 14 nominal GDP growth, both numbers should rise to the 4% to 5% range in The West Rides Again scenario. (Nominal GDP growth of 5% could consist of 2% inflation plus 3% real growth, a modest uptick from current circumstances, so we could get to a 4% to 5% Treasury yield pretty quickly.) A rise of that magnitude in the 10-year Treasury yield, from the current 2.75%, would mean a capital loss of 7% for that category of bonds. Whether Treasury bonds produce a positive total return (including coupon income) depends on how fast interest rates rise, but there is some likelihood that bond total returns could be modest to negative for another year or so. Percent 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 1946 1956 1966 1976 1986 1996 2006 2013 Source: Bloomberg L.P. However, if the U.S. experiences significant top-line (sales) growth, the task of maintaining these profit margins is less difficult. As the U.S. gradually returns to trend GDP growth, sales growth in the corporate sector can be expected. What we have been experiencing since the end of the Great Recession is well below trend. When people have more money to spend, sales, profits and stock prices can all improve. In The West Rides Again, European and emerging-market economies lag the United States, but equities in these countries do not necessarily lag. Valuations in these markets have remained more subdued than in the U.S., where the powerful bull market seems to be discounting strong growth in the near future. Thus, we would recommend active management to select markets, sectors and securities carefully. We would not necessarily underweight Europe or emerging markets overall, but we would probably allocate away from the more volatile markets of peripheral Europe (Italy, Spain, Portugal, Ireland and Greece) and emerging markets with substantial inflation concerns such as Brazil and India. In addition, with increased urbanization, the consumer sector is likely to stay attractive. When bonds as a general category sell off, credit spreads usually provide some protection, and investment-grade corporate bonds are likely to outperform Treasuries. This is especially true in a growing economy. Unfortunately, spreads are already thin and have limited potential to narrow further, making corporates as well as Treasuries vulnerable over the medium term of three to five years. Outside the U.S., in The West Rides Again scenario, we expect interest rates to remain unchanged because of slower growth in those regions. Thus, international bonds will outperform U.S. bonds in local-currency terms. However, if the dollar appreciates, that would be negative for U.S. holders of international fixed income. Other asset classes While commodities are known to be sensitive to changes in global demand, changes in supply have an often-unappreciated effect. There has been a great deal of supply expansion in the all-important energy sector, particularly in Canada and the U.S. In a scenario where U.S. real growth ratchets up from 2% to 3% or more, but not much improvement takes place elsewhere, commodity prices will be flat. However, quality private equity funds remain attractive in The West Rides Again scenario, along with some select defensive fixed income hedges and correctly positioned macro strategies. If U.S. inflation remains low, rising nominal interest rates mean higher real rates. This would cause the dollar to strengthen, which in turn impacts international equity returns as experienced by U.S. investors. Fixed income Treasury bonds will do poorly in the U.S. as the recovering economy enables the Federal Reserve (Fed) to “taper,” and as free-market (longer-term) interest rates rise even further than they have in anticipation of trend growth. If one applies the rule of thumb that nominal long-term Treasury yields are approximately equal to 4 Synchronized growth (30%) Impact on asset class returns — Equities In Synchronized Growth, Europe and Japan strengthen along with the U.S., following the tendency of expansive fiscal and monetary policies to produce positive results sooner or later. We are already beginning to see recovery in Spain, for example, and a lessening of euro-related tensions, in general; if a virtuous cycle develops in the Eurozone, sovereign credit improves, people get back to work, tax collections rise and demands for austerity wane. “Abenomics” in Japan is an aggressive policy designed to weaken the yen, reverse deflationary trends and prevent the country’s vast government debt from expanding further in real terms; so far, results have been favorable, with a weak yen boosting exports and stock prices in 2013 and, it is hoped, beyond. However, it is still early. Meanwhile, in this scenario, the U.S. returns toward its full growth potential through a confluence of favorable circumstances: the bull market in U.S. equities boosts consumer confidence and spending, immigration reform helps to resolve the shortage of specialized workers and Congress gets out of its own way. Free trade agreements open up new markets for exporters and lowers costs of importers. A Synchronized Growth scenario also hinges on emerging markets continuing to produce macroeconomic results superior to those of the developed world, with only a limited degree of slowing in China. Emerging markets benefit from both renewed commodity consumption and exports to developed countries. Chinese growth still has to be lower than the 10% number to which investors have become accustomed. (See Figure 7 for a recent historical perspective.) It is simply too hard to grow anything that big at 10%. But Chinese growth in the 7% to 8% range still represents a huge marginal increase in demand for commodities each year and is of major benefit to wage earners in that country, whose consumption will reinforce growth elsewhere. Moreover, because the Chinese economy is now so much bigger than it used to be, 7% or 8% growth in China represents a much bigger increment to global demand – and supply – than 10% growth did a decade ago. (In real, purchasing-power-adjusted terms, China’s economy in 2012 produced $12.6 trillion of goods and services, compared with $15.9 trillion for both the U.S. and the European Union. In 2000, the equivalent number for China, in today’s dollars, was $3 trillion, and in 1980 it was $248 billion.) Globally, Synchronized Growth would mean – finally! – a decisive end to the secular global bear trend that many would argue started in 2000. Although we’ve experienced coordinated growth and a global bull market fueled by housing and financial services in 2003-2007, our Synchronized Growth scenario involves more diversified growth. In such a circumstance, global equities are clearly the asset of choice, but nearly all risk asset classes benefit from global growth and the resulting increased appetite for risk. Emerging-market equities, in particular, surge due to cheaper starting valuations, higher growth and, when returns are translated into U.S. dollars, a boost from currency appreciation. Still, not all emerging economies are equal, and we envision a “diverging markets” world in which active managers choose country weights that are substantially off-index, for example, underweighting Brazil and India, which are experiencing inflation, and overweighting non-BRIC countries. Figure 8 shows the differential performance of major emerging markets so far in the 21st century. Note the huge range of individualcountry returns around the index return. (The scale, or y-axis, runs from -87.5% to +1500!) While the range has narrowed since the early days of emerging-market investing in the 1980s and 1990s, there has been close to a 100 percentage point difference between the best- and worst-performing countries even in recent years. It certainly seems worthwhile to explore active bets in such an environment. FIGURE 8 Emerging markets: individual country equity returns versus MSCI index 800 Percent MSCI Emerging Markets Index MSCI Index 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 -100 1987 1989 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011 2013 Source: FactSet FIGURE 7 Chinese real GDP growth “collapses” toward a higher rate than anywhere in the developed world 17.5 Annual percent change Year over year Quarter over quarter 15.0 12.5 10.0 7.5 5.0 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 Source: BCA Research, Inc. 5 Fixed income In Synchronized Growth, inflation rates rise globally, hitting centralbank targets. In the fixed income markets, real interest rates rise essentially everywhere, sending investment-grade bonds into a period of negative to flat nominal returns (depending on the speed of the rate rise). Credit spreads tighten, helping to offset some of the damage to bond portfolio values caused by rising sovereign-debt yields. No currency trends are discernible among the Big Four (dollar, euro, yen, pound) but emerging-market currencies likely rise versus the developed world. Finally, Synchronized Growth causes commodities to be a more attractive asset than they have been recently. Despite recent supplyside improvements, especially in the energy sector in Canada and the U.S., commodities trend higher on resurgent demand from both developed and emerging economies. Other asset classes Private equity and real assets would be large beneficiaries in a Synchronized Growth scenario. Most “risk on” alternatives assets would stand to benefit. Synchronized Growth Over emphasize Under emphasize U.S. • Generally, all equities will be positively affected in this scenario. Allocate across large-, mid- and small-cap stocks • Defensive sectors • Dividend paying companies Non U.S. • Generally, all equities will be positively affected in this scenario. Allocate across large-, mid- and small-cap stocks Emerging and • Allocate to non-BRIC countries • Markets with inflation concerns (Brazil, Russia, India and China) • Active management over passive • All market capitalization ranges • Growth as a centerpiece • Cyclical sectors • Commodity plays • Opportunities arising from consumption trends EQUITIES Developed markets frontier markets Broken China/Eurozone (10%) In Broken China, rapid deceleration in Chinese growth is the catalyst for continued or renewed recession in Europe and Japan, and a nearrecession in the United States. A broken China may be the result of President Xi’s efforts to rein in China’s apparent credit expansion and to curtail infrastructure investing. A “broken” Chinese economy might continue to grow slowly, but in a world that is geared up and priced for 7% or better Chinese growth, a real GDP growth rate under 5% in that country would represent a shriveling of demand for commodities in other emerging-market countries, relative to expectations, and would remove upward pressure on wages globally. We do not want China to be broken! Broken Eurozone. The Eurozone (excepting the core northern countries) is already pretty badly broken, but things could get worse. A further implosion in the Eurozone region may come from social unrest in one or more peripheral countries, causing a partial or full breakup of the euro. Even a messy exit by one small country would be seen as greatly increasing the likelihood of an eventual breakup of the entire euro machinery. Given the fragility in both Europe and China, if one negative event occurs, it is likely to trigger another such event in the other region. Moreover, the U.S. economy is now in its fifth year of recovery after the Great Recession and is vulnerable to a correction. Inflated asset prices could deflate and the correction would damage consumer and business confidence, savings and investment. Impact on asset class returns The Broken China/Eurozone scenario implies that recent market advances would be corrected and a new bear market could ensue, not just in China and the Eurozone but in the U.S. and other seemingly unrelated markets. The present bull market is five years old and vulnerable to bad news. While we believe such a scenario is unlikely (a 10% probability), it is damaging enough to warrant some exploration. FIXED INCOME • Adjustable rate issues • Shorter duration/higher quality • Intermediate to long duration • • • • • • REITs • Fixed income defensive hedges ALTERNATIVES Fixed income hedges Currency long/short Private equity Real assets Infrastructure 6 Equities In this scenario, all risk assets do poorly. Europe and emerging markets are hit the hardest. In a global bear market for risk assets, the dollar rises due to its safe haven status, making international asset returns even worse when converted to U.S.-dollar terms. Broken China/Eurozone Over emphasize Under emphasize U.S. • Defensive sectors • Stocks with lower beta or lower volatility • Higher dividend yielding • Lower multiples (e.g., P/B, P/E) • • • • Higher beta stocks Higher volatility stocks Cyclical sectors Commodities Non U.S. • Stocks with relatively cheaper valuations and stronger growth prospects • • • • European Union Japan Australia Canada EQUITIES Developed markets Fixed income and other asset classes Bonds, however, become a good investment – even at today’s low yields – because nominal interest rates do not rise; with very limited inflation, or possibly some deflation, bondholders enjoy positive real interest rates. This is not true of Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities (TIPS), which rely for much of their return on an inflation adjustment that, in this scenario, would be very small. Cash also preserves purchasing power in this scenario, even though central-bank easing would continue so that the long-awaited rise in nominal yields would not materialize. One can make the case for gold as a refuge asset in the Broken China/Eurozone scenario, but other, non-monetary commodities will trade sharply lower. Other asset classes The Broken China/Eurozone scenario would most likely come down hard on private equity, real estate, commodities and the risk on assets, in general. True defensively positioned hedge funds would be in a position to benefit. Emerging and • In general, reduce allocation to emerging markets • In general, reduce allocation to frontier markets frontier markets FIXED INCOME • High quality, U.S. Treasury • Shift to intermediate and longer term durations • Emerging market and lower quality debt • High yield • Adjustable rates • Long/short • Currency hedges • Fixed income defensive hedges • • • • ALTERNATIVES Commodities Real estate Private equity Infrastructure 7 At BMO Global Asset Management, we follow a solutions-based mindset with our clients. We work to understand and establish the appropriate investment objectives for our clients, and then access our global tool kit of solutions that fit the circumstances expected but can be adapted — should scenarios and/or needs change. We are proud of our worldwide and world-class team of investment professionals; our track record is extraordinarily strong, as well. A testimony to both our performance and service is our 98% client retention rate and the rapid rise of assets under our oversight. Conclusion The first two scenarios argue for a full U.S. equity position to take advantage of the 90% likelihood that one of those two scenarios will occur. Whether to underweight Europe or emerging markets depends on valuation. Relative to the U.S., Europe is attractively valued but some emerging markets are even more attractively valued. We would consider giving Europe a market weight and seeking out selected opportunity in the emerging world, a bet that would especially benefit if Synchronized Growth plays out. Summing across scenarios, we expect investment-grade credit to do well in relative terms (that is, after adjusting for the effect of duration), so that adding some credit exposure would diversify the fixed income allocation and improve its performance. Note that we do not recommend avoiding duration altogether because the yield curve is steep, making duration reduction a costly decision in terms of current yield. Most real assets do well only in the second scenario of coordinated growth. But, if that scenario materializes, they should do extraordinarily well because they are priced for a much more disappointing global economic outcome. Thus, one can make a case for a modest allocation to real assets given our scenario analysis. While always vulnerable to shocks, the world of global investments is a moderately attractive place – equities more so than fixed income – as 2014 begins. We hope this Secular Outlook engaged and stimulated your thinking on global investment issues. Investments cannot be made in an index. This is not intended to serve as a complete analysis of every material fact regarding any company, industry or security. The opinions expressed here reflect our judgment at this date and are subject to change. Information has been obtained from sources we consider to be reliable, but we cannot guarantee the accuracy. This publication is prepared for general information only. This material does not constitute investment advice and is not intended as an endorsement of any specific investment. It does not have regard to the specific investment objectives, financial situation and the particular needs of any specific person who may receive this report. Investors should seek advice regarding the appropriateness of investing in any securities or investment strategies discussed or recommended in this report and should understand that statements regarding future prospects may not be realized. Investment involves risk. Market conditions and trends will fluctuate. The value of an investment as well as income associated with investments may rise or fall. Accordingly, investors may receive back less than originally invested. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. BMO Global Asset Management is the brand name for various affiliated entities of BMO Financial Group that provide investment management, retirement and trust and custody services. Certain of the products and services offered under the brand name BMO Global Asset Management are designed specifically for various categories of investors in a number of different countries and regions and may not be available to all investors. Products and services are only offered to such investors in those countries and regions in accordance with applicable laws and regulations. BMO Financial Group is a service mark of Bank of Montreal (BMO). Investment products are: NOT FDIC INSURED — NO BANK GUARANTEE — MAY LOSE VALUE. © 2014 BMO Financial Corp. 8