Download How Islam Failed Me? - Islam

How Islam Failed Me?
Written by Amil Imani
Friday, 08 February 2013 03:55
My name is Amil Imani , and I am a former Muslim from Iran. I am often asked why I left Islam
and how did it happen. Looking back, I see no particular time or event that suddenly severed my
link with Islam. There was nothing nearly as dramatic as what reportedly happened to Paul on
the road to Damascus, transforming him from a rabid Christian persecutor to a devoted follower
of Jesus.
My alienation from Islam had its seed in the way I was raised. My parents encouraged me to
ask questions and to question everything, rather than telling me to shut up, as children are often
told.
NEVER FULLY EMBRACED ISLAM
Being born in a Muslim family in Iran, I was literally enveloped by Islam and everything Islamic.
Many questions unavoidably kept popping in my mind, and I tried to find answers to them. More
often than not, the answers I found tended to repel rather than attract me to Islam. I never fully
embraced Islam. I didn't leave Islam. Islam simply failed to take me.
From very early on, I believed in a modified version of Occam's razor , also known as the lex
parsimoniae or "law of parsimony." To me, an explanation with the fewest assumptions is either
the correct one or the preferable one. The best answers, more often than not, are the simple
ones. Islam, by contrast, seemed to supply numerous answers to the same questions in
complex and confusing forms. A great many of the answers, it seemed to me, were
improvisations of the clergy who took the freedom of saying what suited them. The Quran itself,
being bewildering, helped the clergy in their muddled pronouncements.
My search for answers has taken me on a journey of discovery in the competing, crowded, and
confusing marketplace of ideas. I noticed a universal human need to believe in some power or
forces beyond ourselves and beyond the finite and the corporeal. If there were no God, we
humans would make one up, it is said. I found out that, in this debate about this seemingly
innate need to believe in a supernatural being, three major viewpoints have emerged:
Monotheism, positing a single god who created the universe, set it in motion, and, according to
1/4
How Islam Failed Me?
Written by Amil Imani
Friday, 08 February 2013 03:55
deism, let it play out without interfering in it; polytheism, with many gods, sometimes requiring a
"super-god" above the rest, "sorting them all out," so to speak; and atheism, characterized by
dismissing any and all gods. (Other views included pantheism, humanism, freethought and myt
hicism
.)
Of the three major camps, polytheism seemed to me the most attractive and yet troubling at the
same time. And Islam's theism—"Allahism"—steeped in superstition, replete with nonsensical
explanations and discriminatory sharia law, repulsed me. I discovered eventually that all the
religious instruction I needed to guide my life was contained in the ancient Zoroastrian triad of
good thoughts, good speech and good deeds, and I accepted the Universal Charter of Human
Rights as their logical extension.
GOING TO THE SOURCE: THE QURAN
Muslims contend that their faith is squarely based on the Quran and all other Islamic dogma
should conform to the teaching of the Quran . They also claim that the Quran is a literal word of
Allah and consider Allah the one and only creator of the entire universe. According to the Quran
itself, Allah created the universe by one word of his mouth, in Arabic kon va yakoon—"be and
became." These claims made my task somewhat simpler. My search was narrowed, and I
focused myself fully on the Quran, aiming to understand it to the best of my ability, striving to
find out what exactly Allah's words were.
Although I am not Arab, I know enough Arabic to go directly to the book of Allah and study it
word by word. As I spent endless days studying the Quran, instead of becoming enlightened, I
found myself more and more confused and bewildered. At that time, I ended up with the
conviction that the Quran may indeed be the handiwork of Allah, as Muslims believe. But, in
reality it is nothing more than a smallish book consisting of a collection of confusing verbiage,
contradictory phrases and even outright errors of facts that purportedly the illiterate Mohammed
authored over the course of some 20 years in a piecemeal fashion. I am certain that presenting
the Quran for evaluation to a body of 100 of the greatest and most impartial scholars, fully
versed in Arabic, will result in a verdict similar to my own conclusion.
As Quranic scholar Gerd-R. Puin says:
2/4
How Islam Failed Me?
Written by Amil Imani
Friday, 08 February 2013 03:55
The Koran claims for itself that it is "mubeen," or clear. But if you look at it, you will notice that
every fifth sentence or so simply doesn't make sense. Many Muslims and Orientalists will tell
you otherwise, of course, but the fact is that a fifth of the Koranic text is just incomprehensible.
Moreover, the Quran is full of what could be called "hate speech" against non-Muslims. As
summarized by Dr. Moorthy Muthuswamy:
About sixty-one percent of the contents of the Koran are found to speak ill of the unbelievers or
call for their violent conquest; at best only 2.6 percent of the verses of the Koran are noted to
show goodwill toward humanity. About seventy-five percent of Muhammad's biography (Sira)
consists of jihad waged on unbelievers."
As an ethical and loving person, I just could not hate those billions of non-believing human
beings, as required by holy writ.
"About sixty-one percent of the contents of the Koran are found to speak ill of the unbelievers or
call for their violent conquest."
TIME FOR CHANGE
The 21st century presents great challenges and opportunities that demand new ways of thinking
and behaving. The doctrine of Islam may have been appropriate for the desert dwellers of some
1,400 years ago, the people Muslims themselves stigmatize as "The Ignorant." However, Islam
today is dysfunctional, to say the least. As a matter of fact, Islam went astray from the very
beginning and inflicted a great deal of suffering on both its followers and those who resisted its
advance.
Life is precious. It is to be protected, nurtured and celebrated. Mankind is moving, perhaps at a
glacier pace, toward reconciliation and ever-expanding inclusiveness, without any group or
ideology imposing itself on others. Any attempt against this trend of "unity in diversity" is
doomed to failure, as exemplified by the demise of fascism and communism.
3/4
How Islam Failed Me?
Written by Amil Imani
Friday, 08 February 2013 03:55
The Islamic "charter," the Quran, in many parts preaches discrimination, death and imposition of
its dogma on everyone. The political system of Islam, just like fascism and communism, is
likewise a dysfunctional ideology that needs to be abandoned. Humanity has matured
considerably since the time of Muhammad. In order to continue its forward march, mankind
must follow a roadmap appropriate for its age and state of development. It is foolish to insist that
a book composed nearly a millennium and a half ago must serve as the one and only guide for
humanity today.
"It is foolish to insist that a book composed nearly a millennium and a half ago must serve as
the one and only guide for humanity today."
ISLAM AS SLAVERY
Islam is a slaveholder religion. It feels that it owns you; it condemns you as an apostate to be
beheaded if you dare to leave its chains. Islam demands submission, which is the meaning of
its name, and Muslims happily call themselves "slaves of Allah." In this regard, Islam also has
a long history of actual slavery
, justified by its texts. Non-Muslims, by contrast, respect the individual as a free human being
and support one's inalienable right to believe whatever one wants to believe—even if it is a
non-belief. If one still wishes to wrap oneself in this suffocating security blanket—Islam—then, I
ask, please keep it to yourself and refrain from forcing it on others.
----
Amil Imani is an Iranian ex-Muslim activist and the author of Obama Meets Ahmadinejad and Operation Persian Gulf
.
4/4