Download EPI Fact Sheet 1: Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary Prevention Fact

EPIDEMIOLOGY FACT SHEET 1: Primary, Secondary, and
Tertiary Prevention Fact Sheet - TB Examples
INSTRUCTOR’S GUIDE VERSION 1.0
EPI Fact Sheet 1: Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary Prevention Fact Sheet –
Tuberculosis Examples
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
After reviewing this Fact Sheet, participants should be able to:
 Distinguish among primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention activities
 Provide examples of primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention activities related to
the prevention and control of M. tuberculosis
ASPH EPIDEMIOLOGY COMPETENCIES ADDRESSED
C.6. Apply the basic terminology and definitions of epidemiology
C.8. Communicate epidemiologic information to lay and professional audiences
ASPH INTERDISCIPLINARY/CROSS-CUTTING COMPETENCIES ADDRESSED
I.8. [Public Health Biology] Apply biological principles to development and
implementation of disease prevention, control, or management programs
L.1. [Systems Thinking] Identify characteristics of a system
Please evaluate this material by clicking here:
http://www.zoomerang.com/Survey/?p=WEB229TEZYZS68
This material was developed by the staff at the Global Tuberculosis Institute
(GTBI), one of four Regional Training and Medical Consultation Centers funded
by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. It is published for learning
purposes only. Permission to reprint excerpts from other sources was granted.
Case study author(s) name and position:
George Khalil, MPH (work done as MPH candidate)
Marian R. Passannante, PhD
Associate Professor, University of Medicine & Dentistry of New Jersey, New
Jersey Medical School and School of Public Health
Epidemiologist, NJMS, GTBI
For further information please contact:
New Jersey Medical School Global Tuberculosis Institute (GTBI)
225 Warren Street
P.O. Box 1709
Newark, NJ 07101-1709
or by phone at 973-972-0979
Suggested citation: New Jersey Medical School Global Tuberculosis Institute. /Incorporating
Tuberculosis into Public Health Core Curriculum./ 2009: Epidemiology Fact Sheet 1: Primary,
Secondary, and Tertiary Prevention Fact Sheet - TB Examples INSTRUCTOR’S GUIDE Version 1.0.
Date Last Modified: November 16, 2009
1
EPIDEMIOLOGY FACT SHEET 1: Primary, Secondary, and
Tertiary Prevention Fact Sheet - TB Examples
INSTRUCTOR’S GUIDE VERSION 1.0
Introduction
Epidemiology is an important part of tuberculosis (TB) control efforts because the
information on patterns of infection and disease can assist in identifying people or groups of
people at risk for TB, understanding how the disease is transmitted, prioritizing cases, and
planning appropriate use of staff and resources.1
The objectives of epidemiology are to:
 Identify the cause of disease or risk for disease
 Determine the burden of disease in a community
 Study the natural history and prognosis of disease
 Evaluate both existing and new preventive and therapeutic measures and modes of
health care delivery
 Provide the foundation for developing public policy and regulatory decisions relating to
environmental problems2
In a community or group with a high burden of disease, it is the responsibility of public health
officials, knowing its cause and biologic implications, to put in place preventive measures to
alleviate the burden. There are three prevention approaches that are crucial in decreasing
mortality and morbidity of a disease: primary, secondary, and tertiary prevention. These
levels of prevention were first described by Leavell and Clark3 and continue to provide a
useful framework to describe the spectrum of prevention activities.
Primary Prevention
“Primary prevention denotes action taken to prevent the development of a disease in a
person who is well and does not have the disease in question” (page 6).2 These activities
include health promotion as well as disease prevention activities. Health promotion activities
can be as simple as using appropriate hand washing techniques or can be more
sophisticated such as vaccination to prevent disease occurrence.
1. Vaccines
The only vaccination for TB on the market is the bacille Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccine;
however, its use is rarely indicated in the United States. Before putting a vaccine on the
market in the United States, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) along
with the US Food and Drug Administration and other government agencies, must evaluate
the vaccines efficacy, safety, contraindications, utility, and cost effectiveness.
Two controlled prospective community trials before 1955 and studies done in 1947, 1950,
and after 1975 using different BCG strains, found poor efficacy ranging from 0% to 80%.4,5 In
addition to poor efficacy, the BCG vaccine is not indicated in the United States because
secondary prevention techniques are greatly hindered by the BCG vaccine, which can
interfere with the management of persons who are possibly infected with M. tuberculosis.
Date Last Modified: November 16, 2009
2
EPIDEMIOLOGY FACT SHEET 1: Primary, Secondary, and
Tertiary Prevention Fact Sheet - TB Examples
INSTRUCTOR’S GUIDE VERSION 1.0
Safety is another concern when evaluating a vaccine. High rates of local reaction and
infection often leave a permanent scar at the site of a BCG vaccine. Also, the estimated risk
of a complication from a subcutaneous abscess is 387 per 1 million vaccinations, 0.39-0.89
per 1 million from a musculoskeletal lesion, and 0.19-1.56 per 1 million fatalities from
disseminated lesions.6
Since the resurgence of TB in the early 1990s, the BCG vaccine was again evaluated for use
in the United States. Since then, the CDC has made the following recommendations 6 : 1)
BCG is considered for children in the United States who have a negative tuberculin skin test
(TST) and are continually exposed to an untreated or ineffectively treated patient who has
infectious TB and/or drug-resistant TB and cannot be isolated from the patient; 2) BCG is
also considered on a case-by-case basis for health care workers in high-risk settings.
Currently, new vaccines for the prevention of TB are in the development phase. 7
2. Environmental controls
Another form of primary prevention for TB is environmental control, such as ultraviolet lights
and ventilation; however, these measures are taken mostly at hospitals and cannot be
practically implemented at places where most TB transmission exists (e.g., nursing homes,
prisons, in the community, etc.).8 However, programs aimed at decreasing overcrowding can
also be considered primary prevention measures for TB.
Secondary Prevention
“Secondary prevention denotes the identification of people who have already developed a
disease, at an early stage in the disease’s natural history, through screening and early
intervention.” “The rationale for secondary prevention is that if we can identify disease earlier
in its natural history, intervention measures will be more effective. Perhaps we can prevent
mortality or complications of the disease and use less invasive or less costly treatment to do
so”.2 (page 6)
1. Detection of latent TB infection (LTBI)
The CDC recommends a strategy to identify those who have LTBI and, if indicated, the use of
chemotherapy to prevent the latent infection from progressing to active TB disease.
There are two tests that can be used to help detect LTBI.
a. The Tuberculin Skin Test (TST)
The first is a skin test in which testing material, called tuberculin, is injected intradermally
into the individual and in 2 to 3 days, the patient returns to the health care worker who
checks to see if there is a reaction to the test.8
b. QuantiFERON-TB Gold (QFT-G)
The second test used to identify LTBI is QFT-G, a blood test that measures how a
person’s system reacts to the bacteria that causes TB.9
As mentioned previously, secondary control methods for TB are greatly hindered by the BCG
vaccine. Post-vaccination BCG-induced tuberculin reactivity ranges from no induration to an
Date Last Modified: November 16, 2009
3
EPIDEMIOLOGY FACT SHEET 1: Primary, Secondary, and
Tertiary Prevention Fact Sheet - TB Examples
INSTRUCTOR’S GUIDE VERSION 1.0
induration of 19 mm at the skin-test site. Tuberculin reactivity caused by BCG vaccination
wanes with time and is unlikely to persist >10 years after vaccination in the absence of M.
tuberculosis exposure and infection. Recent studies have suggested that the QFT-G is more
sensitive than the TST.10 Another recent study that compared TST and QFT-G found that the
QFT-G test was highly specific and unaffected by BCG vaccination status, a major cause of
false-positive TST responses.10 Since there is no gold standard for screening tests to
determine if someone has TB disease, other specialized tests such as chest X-ray and a
sample of sputum may be needed. Table I is a summary of evidence comparing TST to QFTG, a type of interferon-gamma assay.
Nahid P, Pai M, Hopewell PC./2006/Advances in the diagnosis and treatment of tuberculosis/
Proceedings of the American Thoracic Society/3:103-110. Official Journal of the American
Thoracic Society. © American Thoracic Society. Reprinted with permission.
Secondary prevention of TB involves the identification and testing of targets groups of people
and communities with greater likelihood of being infected. "Targeted tuberculin testing for
LTBI is a strategic component of tuberculosis (TB) control that identifies persons at high risk
for developing TB who would benefit by treatment of LTBI, if detected”.8
Some of these high risk groups are:
 Health care workers who work with patients at risk of TB
 Those who have lived or traveled extensively in areas where TB is endemic
 Immunocompromised individuals
 Those who have had a recent positive conversion of a skin test
 Persons who live in a congregant setting (e.g. jails and nursing homes)
Date Last Modified: November 16, 2009
4
EPIDEMIOLOGY FACT SHEET 1: Primary, Secondary, and
Tertiary Prevention Fact Sheet - TB Examples
INSTRUCTOR’S GUIDE VERSION 1.0

Homeless persons
Another type of secondary prevention measure is called a contact investigation. During a
contact investigation a public health worker interviews patients with active TB disease in
order to identify “contacts” or people who may have been exposed to that person. Once
identified the contacts will be evaluated for LTBI and TB disease and provided with
appropriate treatment, when necessary.
2. Treatment of LTBI
Patients who are identified as being infected with TB should be evaluated for active TB
disease, by receiving a chest X-ray, and a focused clinical evaluation. Once active disease is
excluded, one of the following treatments listed in Table 2 is indicated.
Table: Drug Regimens for the Treatment of LTBI
Drugs
Duration
(months)
Isoniazid 9
Isoniazid 6
Rifampin 4
Interval
Minimum
doses
Daily
270
Twice
weekly*
76
Daily
180
Twice
weekly*
52
Daily
120
* Directly observed therapy (DOT) is
mandatory for patients on twice weekly
(intermittent) therapy
Table source: modified version of CDC table available at:
http://www.cdc.gov/TB/pubs/tbfactsheets/treatmentLTBI.htm. Accessed March 19, 2008.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. TB fact sheet.
Date Last Modified: November 16, 2009
5
EPIDEMIOLOGY FACT SHEET 1: Primary, Secondary, and
Tertiary Prevention Fact Sheet - TB Examples
INSTRUCTOR’S GUIDE VERSION 1.0
Directly observed therapy (DOT) is suggested for patients with LTBI at high risk of not
adhering to the prescribed therapy, and mandatory for those on twice weekly regimens. For
DOT, a health care worker or other trained person who is not a family member watches as
the patient swallows antituberculosis medicines for at least the first 2 months of treatment.
DOT thus shifts the responsibility for cure from the patient to the health care system.
Tertiary Prevention11
The treatment of people who have already developed a disease is often described as tertiary
prevention. The final strategy used for preventing and controlling TB in the United States is
identifying and treating patients with active TB. Each person with infectious TB has the
potential to infect many others; however, the site of the infection is important in determining
its capability to spread. For example, the lungs and larynx are two common organs where TB
may be highly infectious. If instead, the TB infection is localized to areas such as lymph
nodes or outside the lung, treatment is necessary, yet it is not transmissible and, therefore, is
not a major public health concern.
The treatments used for people with active TB will vary depending on whether the TB is
resistant to some of the standard TB medications. Treatment can take 6 months or longer.
Some of the most common drugs used to treat TB are:




isoniazid (INH)
rifampin (RIF)
ethambutol
pyrazinamide
DOT is used to be sure that patients who have active disease to remember to take their TB
medications.
Works Cited
1. Passannante M and Ahamed N. Basic Epidemiology for Tuberculosis Program Staff.
Newark, NJ: New Jersey Medical School National Tuberculosis Center. 2005.
http://www.umdnj.edu/ntbcweb/products/basicepi.htm
2. Gordis L. Epidemiology: Second Edition. New York, NY: W.B. Saunders Co. 2000.
3. Leavel HR and Clark EG. Preventive Medicine for the Doctor in His Community. New York,
NY: McGraw-Hill. 1965.
4. Rosenthal SR, Loewinsohn E and Graham ML et al. BCG vaccination against tuberculosis
in Chicago: a twenty year study statistically analyzed. Pediatrics. 1961; 28: 622-641.
5. Rosenthal SR, Loewinsohn E and Graham ML et al. BCG vaccinations in tuberculosis
households. Am Rev Respir Dis. 1961; 84:690-704.
Date Last Modified: November 16, 2009
6
EPIDEMIOLOGY FACT SHEET 1: Primary, Secondary, and
Tertiary Prevention Fact Sheet - TB Examples
INSTRUCTOR’S GUIDE VERSION 1.0
6. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The role of BCG Vaccine in the prevention
and control of Tuberculosis in the United States: A joint statement by the Advisory Council for
the Elimination of TB and the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices. MMWR
Recomm Rep. 1996; 45 (RR-4):1-18.
http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/00041047.htm
7. Brennan MJ, Fruth U, Milstien J, Tiernan R, de Andrade Nishioka S, et al. (2007)
Development of New Tuberculosis Vaccines: A Global Perspective on Regulatory Issues.
PLoS Med 4(8): e252 doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0040252.
http://medicine.plosjournals.org/perlserv/?request=getdocument&doi=10.1371/journal.pmed.0040252
8. Targeted tuberculin testing and treatment of latent tuberculosis infection. American
Thoracic Society. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 2000;161:S221-247.
http://www.thoracic.org/sections/publications/statements/pages/mtpi/latenttb1-27.html
9. Madariaga MG, Jalali Z and Swindells S. Clinical utility of interferon gamma assay in the
diagnosis of tuberculosis. J Am Board Fam Med. 2007; 20:540-547.
http://www.jabfm.org/cgi/content/full/20/6/540
10. Diel R, Lodden Kemper R, Meywala Walter K, Niemann S, Niehhaustt. Predictive value of
a whole-blood IFN-gamma assay for the development of TB disease. Am J Respir Crit Care
Med. 2008;177:1164-1170.
11. Questions and Answers About TB, 2007 Accessed on the CDC website
http://www.cdc.gov/tb/faqs/qa_TBDisease.htm#Active1 Accessed on February 9, 2009.
Date Last Modified: November 16, 2009
7