Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Health Care in the 2008 Election Elise Gould, Ph.D. October 20th, 2008 Columbia University Medical Center What Must (Good) Health Reform Accomplish? • Access – Cover the uninsured – Ensure minimal disruption of current coverage – Ensure minimum benefits and coverage of certain conditions • Cost – Affordable premiums and cost-sharing – Risk pooling – Efficiencies of scale • Quality – – – – Encourage research and best practice-driven medicine Oversight and regulation for consumer protection Reduce disparities Efficient and effective chronic care management % of Under 65 Population Uninsured between 2001-2003 Access: The Crisis of the Uninsured 40% 45 million Non-elderly uninsured in 2007 (17.1%) 36% 35% (CPS) 30% 26% 25% 20% 17% 15% 9% 10% 4% 5% 0% At any time More than 4 months More than a year More than 2 years Duration of Uninsurance, 2001-2003 (SIPP) 3 years Costs: Unsustainable Growth Nearly 50% of GDP by 2062 (CBO) Premium increase (+115%) Workers earnings (+29%) Overall inflation (+24%) KFF/HRET Employer Benefits Survey, 2007 OECD Health Data, 2005 Sweden Japan Finland Norway France Infant Mortality Across Countries (2005) Belgium 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 Greece Germany Ireland Spain Austria Switzerland Denmark Italy Netherlands Australia United Kingdom New Zealand Canada United States Infant Deaths per 1,000 Live Births Value: International Comparison US spends 15.5% of GDP $7,439 per person (OECD) Quality: Stark National Inequalities Infant Mortality by Race, 2004 Black White CDC Linked Data Life Expectancy at 60 by Income, 2001 Top 50% Bottom 50% Waldron, 2007 Two Visions for Reform in 2008 Barack Obama •Build on current employersponsored system •Strengthen public system by building large insurance pools •Give tax credits to selfemployed, near-poor, and small businesses to help purchase coverage John McCain •Radically change current system •Replace current tax subsidies for employerbased insurance with tax credits •Replace employer-based coverage with a national deregulated individual insurance market Obama: More Coverage Tax Policy Center Analysis Obama: Keep the Coverage You Have Obama Plan McCain Plan National Exchange Employerprovided Individual Public Employerprovided Uninsured Tax Policy Center Analysis Public 20 million Lose their employersponsored insurance McCain: On Your Own in the Individual Market • The individual market offers lower benefits at greater financial risk • The individual market is less efficient than employer-sponsored group insurance • Administrative costs 2.5-4x higher than large employer pools • McCain has proposed removing the current system of state-based protections, making the already insufficient individual market only riskier McCain Plan’s Effects on New York • 1,605,030 individuals, or 15.5% of those currently covered, would lose their employerprovided insurance (1 in 7) • New York residents would also lose important protections, such as – Minimum medical loss prevention – Pure community rating – Mandated coverage of ambulance services, cancer chemotherapy, and cervical cancer screening Obama Plan: More Bang for Your Buck Total 10-Year Cost of Plan Obama: $1.6 Billion McCain: $1.3 Billion Tax Policy Center Analysis Quality: Changes to Medical Practice • Four key provisions: – Evidence-based medicine – Health information technology – Chronic disease management – Medical Home • Only Obama’s plan can effectively reach both public and private sectors – Less fragmentation; more oversight Conclusion • Moral and economic imperative for reform • Most effective method of lowering costs and improving quality is by covering everyone – access, cost, and quality are complementary goals not competing ones www.epi.org