Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Plato’s CRITO Crito, a friend, goes to Socrates in prison, hoping to convince him to escape, to save his life. Should he do it? Socrates’ gives a lengthy argument in response, in which he concludes he has a duty not to break the law, and try to escape his punishment. This dialogue = a model of moral reasoning – Based on right and wrong – Based on self-interest CRITO: On Civil Obedience Prologue: 43a-47a Crito says why he has come to visit Logos: Socrates’ two arguments vs. escaping – Based on right &wrong 47a-53a • Fair agreement • Do no harm – Based on prudential selfinterest 53a-54c Epilogue: 54de in which Socrates accepts his fate Socrates’ Argument – I: One should never do wrong One should do what reason says is best. 46b 2. Life is not worth living if our soul* is corrupt. 48ad 3. Our soul is corrupted if we [knowingly] do wrong. 49a 4. Therefore we should never do wrong. 49b 1. *Defined as conscience or integrity of conscience. II: It would be wrong to escape 49b-53a It is wrong to: a. return evil for evil; b. violate a just agreement. 49b 2. If he breaks out, he will a. do evil [to those who have nurtured you]; b. violate his ‘contract’ with Athens 50a-51b 3. Therefore it is wrong to escape 53a 1. III. Therefore Socrates should not do it. 53a (repeated at 54b-c) 1. Never do wrong! + 2. wrong to escape/break law 3. do not escape! nd 2 argument: In addition, escape will harm Socrates. 1. Escape will harm you/your loved ones. a. There is no better city to go to 53bd b. It will destroy your life integrity. 53ce c. It will harm your friends and children 53a, 53e-54c 2. 3. Therefore it is not best/wise. 54cd Therefore Socrates should remain, even if he must die. 54d Problem of “Moral Anarchy” Government depends on people obeying the laws. If people obey only the laws they think are right, it creates “moral anarchy”—everyone decides for themselves what laws to obey or disobey Therefore unless you are an anarchist, you must believe in restricting the right to act from conscience against the law. “Letter from Birmingham Jail” Dr. King argues that “an unjust law is no law at all.” What makes a law unjust? – what do you think of his reasons? Can Dr. King answer the charge of being a ‘moral anarchist’? What is Socrates’ ‘social contract’? He can vote and participate in Athenian government and making its laws, i.e. he has political rights (51b) He has inheritance and other rights 50d Athens/his country is like his parents, has cared for and provided (education 50e-51b) He is free to leave Athens if he wishes— but if he stays, he is duty bound to obey its laws and keep the social contract 51d Which duty comes first? Socrates said in court that he would not stop philosophizing, even if the Athenians ordered him to stop. Suppose Athens passed a law making philosophy illegal. What should he do? “Persuade or obey” 51b, 51e What does this mean? That if he breaks the law, he must do it openly, and try to persuade the Athenians to change the law? = justified civil disobedience, like Dr. King Or that if he does not succeed in persuading the Athenian assembly to pass the laws he wants, he must obey whatever laws they pass? = duty to obey all democratically passed laws Questions Does it make a difference, that Socrates is 70? When is civil disobedience justified, if ever? How do you answer the argument vs. “moral anarchy”? Does Socrates’ “persuade or obey” doctrine (51bc) give him a way of dealing with the question if he would obey a law forbidding philosophy (or any law he thought was immoral)? Moral Choices When, if ever, is it justified to break the law? Should you break the law? You make about $75,000 a year and feel you pay taxes for many things the government shouldn’t be involved in, including health care, bailouts for banks and other businesses, and foreign wars you don’t like. Your friend says: “Just cheat on your taxes. I pay just 50% of what I owe. I figure they’re stealing the rest from me, so why pay it?” He shows you how to ‘adjust’ your return. Should you break the law? Your country is involved in what you believe is an unjust war, and you have been drafted to serve. Your uncle in Canada writes, to tell you that if you decide to leave the U.S., he “has a place for you.” Would it be wrong for you to break the law, and immigrate to Canada? Should you break the law? Police are conducting sweeps to find undocumented workers and families. Some have been in the U.S. for twenty years. If caught, they are deported, often splitting the family. You think this violates their human rights, and is un-Christian. Should you break the law by giving aide and encourage others also to do so? (Massive resistance and protests might overthrow the law, though at the cost of civil disturbance.) Should you break the law? Your city has passed an ordinance requiring gun owners to register their firearms and prohibiting ‘machine’ rifles and pistols. You think these laws are unconstitutional, and are fearful that if you register your weapons, they will confiscate your illegal ones. Should you break the law by not registering, and encourage others also to do so? (Massive resistance and protests might overthrow the law, though at the cost of civil disturbance.)