Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
1 Running head: HYPERTENSION TREATMENT Hypertension Treatment Integrative Literature Review Sarah Thomas State University of New York Polytechnic Institute 2 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT Hypertension Treatment Integrative Literature Review Hypertension is the most common condition that presents in primary care. About 1 in 3 US adults have high blood pressure (CDC, 2014). Hypertension is defined as a systolic blood pressure (SBP) greater than 140 mm Hg and/or a diastolic blood pressure (DBP) greater than 90 mm Hg (James, et al., 2014). Hypertension can lead to myocardial infarction, stroke, renal failure and death if not detected early and treated appropriately (James et al., 2014). It is known as the “silent killer” because patients with elevated blood pressure are typically asymptomatic with no warning signs unless target organ damage is involved (Dunphy, Winland Brown, & Thomas, 2011). Although clinical guidelines exist for the treatment of hypertension, management and adequate control still present as major clinical challenges for providers and National Health Care Systems (Tocci, Borghi & Volpe, 2013). According to the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES), only 53% of adults with hypertension are controlled with blood pressures of less than 140/90 mm Hg. The goal of treatment in hypertensive patients is to reduce cardiovascular and renal morbidity and mortality (James et al., 2014). Purpose Statement The purpose of this review is to perform an integrative analysis of the most current literature. The literature review is aimed at finding the current state of science and best practice guidelines for the treatment of hypertension. The goal is to provide scientific evidence that will improve quality of care for patients with hypertension by providing direction and insight for health care providers and institutions. 3 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT Methodology Relevant articles for the purpose of this literature review were obtained using the State University of New York Institute of Technology, Cayan Library electronic database. MedlinePlus, CINAHL Plus with Full Text and PubMed were the primary databases utilized. Centers for Disease Control, American Heart Association and the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute were also utilized for additional searches. The key terms used to execute this literature review were ‘hypertension’, ‘hypertension treatment’, ‘antihypertensive agents’, ‘hypertension drug therapy’, ‘blood pressure medications’ and ‘hypertension medications’. The literature search was restricted to research articles that were published in academic journals and printed in the English language. The search was also restricted to articles published between the years 2011 and 2015. Literature dated before 2011 was also reviewed for comparison and analysis. The articles were reviewed for relevance, sorted by subject, and summarized for the purpose of this literature review. 12 quality research articles that focus on the management and treatment of hypertension were finally chosen and an analysis of these articles was completed (see Appendix A). Treatment There are seven major classes of effective antihypertensive medications and an array of combinations designed to reduce pill burden and improve compliance to therapy. Still however, only half of US adults with hypertension are adequately controlled (Cushman, 2012). The main challenge for providers in managing hypertension is in choosing the most appropriate drug, whether as initial treatment or add-on therapy (Cushman, 2012). Steps towards greater control of hypertension are being made however, in large part due to the publication and widespread 4 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT adoption of guidelines produced by the Joint National Committee on the Prevention, Detection, Evaluation and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (Harman et al., 2013). Pharmacologic Therapy Monotherapy. According to Tocci, et al. (2013), the majority of physicians consider ACE inhibitors (ACEIs) and angiotensin receptor blockers (ARBs) the most useful, effective and well tolerated options to start antihypertensive monotherapy treatment. Only a small number of physicians consider the use of beta blockers (BB’s), calcium channel blockers (CCBs) or diuretics (Tocci et al., 2013). Harman et al. (2013) discuss however that the African American population demonstrate a reduced blood pressure response to monotherapy with ACEIs, or ARBs compared with diuretics or calcium channel blockers (CCBs). African American patients using a thiazide diuretic are more likely to have blood pressure controlled to their therapeutic target than persons not taking thiazides (Harman et al., 2013). Conversely, Giles et al. (2013) state that nebivolol (BB) is an effective first-line monotherapy in adults aged 18-54 years with stage 1 or 2 hypertension. Although thiazide diuretics are considered an effective treatment in the older population (55-69 years), they are less effective with those aged 21-54 years (Giles et al., 2013). According to Giles et al. (2013) treatment with nebivolol in this population results in significant SBP and DBP reductions in as early as 2 weeks after initiation and improves overall blood pressure control regardless of sex, race, ethnicity, stage of hypertension and obesity status. Sendur et al. (2014) also report that nevibolol is an effective treatment option for monotherapy by significantly lowering blood pressure and improving endothelial function. Participants seeing results with nevibolol in this study have mean age of 50.1 (Sendur et al., 2014). 5 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT Combination therapy. According to Bays, Zhu and Schumacher (2013), 75 % of patients will require combination therapy to adequately control their blood pressure. In fact, initial use of combination therapy compared with monotherapy may achieve earlier blood pressure control, improve long-term adherence and reduce cardiovascular risk in many patients (Bays, et al., 2013). According to Harman et al. (2013), if a patient’s blood pressure is greater than 20 SBP/10 DBP mm Hg over their target; two medications should be prescribed as initiation therapy. This is especially true for African Americans who often require more aggressive treatment (Harman et al., 2013). The literature demonstrates that drug therapy combinations which include thiazide diuretics provide the greatest blood pressure reduction and control (Bays et al., 2013; Harman et al., 2013; Toth, 2014). Combinations that include diuretics are also preferred in patients with high cardiovascular risk due to the benefits of fluid volume reduction (Bays, et al., 2013). Bays et al. (2013) reviewed and compared nine randomized, double-blind studies of the ARB telmisartan and thiazide diuretic hydrochlorothiazide as compared with monotherapies. The data demonstrates that telmisartan/hydrochlorothiazide significantly lowers blood pressure as early as 1–4 weeks after therapy initiation and achieves greater goal attainment than with monotherapies or placebo (Bays, et al., 2013) Similarly, Toth (2014) examines combination drug therapy including a thiazide diuretic in patients who are at high cardiovascular risk and whose blood pressure was not adequately controlled despite current drug therapy. The study involves treatment with the triple-drug combination perindopril (ACEI) 10 mg/indapamide (thiazide diuretic) 2.5 mg/amlodipine (CCB) 5 or 10 mg (Toth, 2014). Results indicate that reductions in blood pressure can be noted just 1 month after the switch to perindopril/indapamide/amlodipine in patients with resistant hypertension that were previously treated unsuccessfully with a wide 6 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT array of antihypertensive agents (Toth, 2014). Participants demonstrated a mean blood pressure decrease of 28.3 systolic and 13.8 diastolic mmHg and an overall control rate of 72% (Toth, 2014). Likewise, Harman et al. (2013) state that for African American patients, thiazide diuretics are particularly effective for dual and combination therapy with one or more drugs from other antihypertensive classes. African Americans represent a high proportion of adults with hypertension, and there is a recognized need for more aggressive therapy and tailored therapy to achieve adequate control in this ethnic group (Harman et al., 2013). Blood Pressure Variability Variability in blood pressure is associated with increased risk of stroke, coronary heart disease, and mortality. Using antihypertensive agents to control blood pressure throughout a 24 hour period with minimal variability is of great clinical importance, especially among elderly patients (Omboni, Malacco, Mallion, Fabrizzi & Volpe, 2013). Cardiovascular events tend to occur most frequently with fluctuations in blood pressure, especially in the morning (Kario, Kushiro, Termukai, Ishikawa, Hiramatsu, Kobayashi and Shimada, 2013). Morning SBP is one of the strongest independent predictors for stroke among clinic, 24-hour, sleep, awake, evening, and pre-awake blood pressures (Kario et al., 2013). According to the literature, studies show that ACE inhibitiors are not as effective in controlling blood pressure variability when compared with other antihypertensive agents (Omboni, et al., 2013; Muntner, et al., 2014). Omboni et al. (2013) state that olmesartan (ARB) is an effective antihypertensive in control morning blood pressure rise as compared with ramipril (ACEI) which failed to provide adequate morning blood pressure control. Similarly, Muntner et al. (2014) discuss methods in which to limit visit-to-visit variability in SBP (2014). Patients 7 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT taking chlorthalidone (thiazide diuretic) or amlodipine (CCB) had lower variability of blood pressure when compared with those taking lisinopril (ACEI). Martinez-Garcia, Capote and Campos-Rodriguez (2014) also examine the management and reduction of blood pressure variability by using continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) to reduce mean 24-hour blood pressure in patients with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). According to Martinez-Garcia et al. (2014), OSA is present in 70% of patients with hypertension. The application of CPAP for 4 of more hours per night shows a significant reduction in 24-hour mean blood pressure in patients with OSA as compared to those without CPAP (Martinez-Garcia, et al., 2014). Alternative Therapy An important component in the strategy to decrease cardiovascular risk is the recommendation for patients to adopt lifestyle changes that reduce blood pressure (Briasoulis & Bakris, 2013). Data shows that lifestyle changes such as reduced salt intake, eating a healthy and well-balanced diet, weight loss, aerobic exercise, and stress relief are known to reduce cardiovascular risk (Briasoulis & Bakris, 2013). According to Houston and Sparks (2013), essential nutritional deficiencies are common in individuals with hypertension, especially the elderly. Macro and micronutrients are fundamental in the regulation of blood pressure and in preventing organ damage. Houston and Sparks (2013) present data that support the use of combination nutraceutical supplements to lower blood pressure. The research demonstrates that an active daily blend of seven nutrients (vitamin C, grape seed extract, magnesium, vitamin B6, biotin, vitamin D3, pyridoxine, and taurine) taken by hypertensive patients significantly lowers both systolic and diastolic blood pressure with an average decrease of 15.9 mm Hg and 11.35 mm Hg respectively (Houston & Sparks, 2013). 8 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT In addition to lifestyle and dietary changes, many additional modalities are being utilized and evaluated due to their potential ability to lower blood pressure (Briasoulis & Bakris, 2013). Non-traditional treatments are being used by a growing number of people for the prevention and treatment of hypertension. According to Park et al. (2014), attempts to avoid potential side effects of antihypertensive medications and failure of these treatments to control hypertension are two commonly reported reasons patients use complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). Qigong is a traditional Oriental medicine used to heal and prevent disease through movement, meditation, breathing and energy flow (Park et al., 2014). According to Park et al. (2014), qigong is an effective CAM for patients with both prehypertension and essential hypertension with an average SBP decrease of 17.03 mm Hg and DBP decrease of 9.98 mm Hg. Park et al. (2014) also state that no adverse events have been reported for qigong, while patients report unwanted side effects related to their antihypertensive medications. According to the American Heart Association, it is reasonable for individuals with blood pressure levels over 120/80 mm Hg to consider alternative therapies as adjuvant methods to help lower blood pressure (Briasoulis & Bakris, 2013). Analysis Similarities and Differences A trend that is apparent in much of the literature involves treatment options that reduce variability of blood pressure readings. Omboni et al. (2013) and Martinez-Garcia et al. (2013) explore both pharmacological and non-pharmacological options for reducing mean 24-hour blood pressure. Kario et al. (2013) also discuss medications that provide sustained 24-hour blood pressure lowering effects, while specifically targeting morning systolic blood pressure. Muntner et al. (2014) focus on hypertensive agents that limit visit-to-visit variability in blood pressure. 9 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT Both Omboni et al. (2013) and Muntner et al. (2014) conclude that ACEIs are not as effective in controlling blood pressure variability as other antihypertensive agents such as CCBs and ARBs. Another marked similarity among the literature is the use of thiazide diuretics in pharmacological combinations that are used for treatment and management of hypertension. Bays et al. (2013), Harman et al. (2013) and Toth (2014) all report effective treatment of hypertension in combinations that that include a thiazide diuretic. Bays et al. (2013) and Harman et al. (2013) present information on dual-therapy with the inclusion of hydrochlorothiazide while Thoth (2014) focuses on triple combination therapy that includes indapamide. Age also presents as another similarity among the literature. The majority of research focuses on older adult populations above the age of 55 years. This could be in large part due to the fact that hypertension generally presents in the older population and is a very frequent condition among persons age 65 years and over (Omboni, et al., 2014). Harman et al. (2013), Kario et al. (2013) and Muntner et al. (2014) all include research findings with a mean age of 60 or above. Omboni et al. (2013) specifically include participants age 60 years and older in their research. Bays et al. (2013), Martinez-Garcia et al. (2013) and Tocci et al. (2013) present findings with a mean age of 54 or above. Adversely, Giles et al. (2013) specifically target adults with hypertension aged 54 and younger. Sendur et al. (2014) also present data for participants with a mean age of 50.1 years. Both of these studies conclude that nevibolol is an effective hypertensive medication as monotherapy for this age group. According to Giles et al. (2013) this population has a different hemodynamic profile of hypertension when compared with those 55 and older, therefore warranting a separate assessment in regards to treatment. 10 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT Conclusion It is evident from the literature that many different treatment options and medications are available that are effective in treating and managing hypertension. Options for treatment however may vary based on the population being treated. Controlling blood pressure to below target goals proves to be more difficult in certain populations such as the elderly and African Americans. It is also apparent that younger populations with hypertension may require different types of therapy based on their differences in cellular and cardiovascular function. There is an abundance of literature supporting different medication classes and treatments in the older adult population due to their high incidence of hypertension. Only one study in this review specifically targets individuals under the age of 55. A second study however presents similar results with the same medication (nevibolol) on patients with newly diagnosed hypertension and had a statistically lower mean age (50.1) than the rest of the studies. Therefore, the logical direction for treatment research at this time would be in the younger adult population. Obesity, especially childhood obesity, is becoming an epidemic, and it is known that there is a positive correlation between obesity, high blood pressure and higher risks of cardiovascular related illness and mortality. According to the reviewed literature, nevibolol (BB) is an effective first-line treatment for hypertensive patients age 54 and below due to its specific action on endothelial function, which plays a large part in the typical etiology of hypertension in younger patients. In looking at the current published guidelines for hypertension however, BBs are not typically utilized as first line monotherapy treatment. This may be due to the fact that the research and literature guiding these publications is heavily targeting older adults. Another conclusion that can be made from the literature analysis is that a growing number of patients are seeking out alternative therapies to medications. Whether it is due to 11 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT adverse medication affects, financial burden or not being properly controlled on medications, CAM therapy is becoming a part of many treatment regimens. Patients are going to be requesting information and asking questions about these treatment modalities and want the opinions of medical professionals. They are going to wonder if what they read on the internet or saw on television or what their neighbor has tried will work on them too. It is also the statement of the American Heart Association that alternative therapies have a legitimate place in the management of hypertension. In order to provide patients with the most useful and up-to-date information and recommendations, clinicians need to become more aware of the CAM therapies that are available and get familiar with those that have been shown effective in managing hypertension. All treatment avenues should be utilized in the battle to reduce cardiovascular risk, and in an attempt to increase the percentage of people whose blood pressure is adequately controlled. 12 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT References Bays, H., Zhu, D. & Schumacher, H. (2014). Single-pill combination of telmisartan and hydrochlorothiazide: studies and pooled analyses of earlier hypertension treatment. High Blood Pressure and Cardiovascular Prevention, 21(2), 119-126. Briasoulis, A. & Bakris, G. (2013). Complementary alternative therapies for hypertension: Is it worth it? Retrieved from American Heart Association Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2014). High Blood Pressure. Retrieved from http://www.cdc.gov/bloodpressure/ Cushman, W. (2012). Rethinking the role of thiazide-type diuretics in the management of hypertension. Journal of Family Practice, 61(8), S15-S18. Giles, T., Khan, B., Lato, J., Brener, L. Ma, Y. & Lukic, T. (2013). Nebivolol monotherapy in younger adults (younger than 55 years) with hypertension: A randomized, placebocontrolled trial. Official Journal of the American Society of Hypertension, Inc., 15(9), 687-693 Dunphy, L., Winland Brown, J., Porter, B., & Thomas, D. (2011). Primary Care: The Art and rd Science of Advanced Practice Nursing. 3 Edition. Philadelphia: F.A Davis. Harman, J., Walker E., Charbonneau, V., Akylbekova, E., Nelson, C., Wyatt, S. (2013). Treatment of hypertension among African Americans: The Jackson heart study. Official Journal of the American Society of Hypertension Inc., 15(6), 367-374. Houston, M. & Sparks, W. (2013). Combination nutraceutical supplement lowers blood pressure in hypertensive individuals. Integrative Medicine, 12(3), 22-29. James, P.A., Oparil, S., Carter, B.L., Cushman, W.C., Dennison-Himelfarb, C., Handler, J., Lackland, D.T., LeFevre, M…Ortiz, E. (2014). 2014 Evidence-based guidelines for the 13 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT management of high blood pressure in adults. Report from the panel members appointed to the eighth joint national committee (JNC 8). Journal of the American Medical Association, 311(5), 507-520. Kario, K., Saito, I., Teramukai, S., Ishikawa, Y., Hiramatsu, K., Kobayashi, F & Shimada, K. (2013). Effect of the angiotensin II receptor antagonist olmesartan on morning home blood pressure in hypertension: HONEST study at 16 weeks. Journal of Human Hypertension, 27(12), 721-728. Martinez-Garcia, M., Capote, F. & Campos-Rodriguez, F. (2014). In patients with obstructive sleep apnea and resistant hypertension, CPAP reduced 24-hour blood pressure. Journal of the American Medical Association, 310, 2407-15. Muntner, P., Levitan, E., Lynch, A., Simpson, L., Whittle, J., Davis, B…Oparil, S. (2014) Effect of chlorthalidone, amlodipine, and lisinopril on visit-to-visit variability of blood pressure: Results from the antihypertensive and lipid-lowering treatment to prevent heart attack trial. The Journal of Clinical Hypertension, 16(5), 323-330. Omboni, S., Malacco, E., Mallion, J., Fabrizzi, P. & Volpe, M. (2014). Olmesartan vs ramipril in elderly hypertensive patients: review of data from two published randomized, doubleblind studies. High Blood Pressure and Cardiovascular Prevention, 21, 1-19. Park, J., Hong, S., Lee, M., Park, T., Kang, K., Jung, H., Shin, K. & Liu, Y. (2014). Randomized, controlled trial of Qigong for treatment of prehypertension and mild essential hypertension. Alternative Therapies, 20 (4), 21. Sandur, M., Guven, G., Yorgun, H., Ates, A., Canpolat, U., Sunman, H., Karaham, S., Kaya, B & Aytemir, K. (2014). Effect of antihypertensive therapy on endothelial markers in newly 14 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT diagnosed stage 1 hypertension: a randomized single-centre study. Anadolu Kardiyol Derg, 14, 363-369. Tocci, G., Borghi, C. & Volpe, M. (2012). Clinical management of patients with hypertension and high cardiovascular risk. High Blood Pressure and Cardiovascular Prevention 21, 107-117. Toth, K. (2014). Antihypertensive efficacy of triple combination perindopril/indapamide plus amlodipine in high-risk hypertensives: Results of the PIANIST study. American Journal Cardiovascular Drugs, 14, 137-145. 15 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT Appendix A Studies Focus Subjects Population Age Method Findings Bays, et al. (2013) Telmisartan + HCTZ combo for earlier HTN management N = 5.358 From 9 studies Adult patients with hypertension and failed monotherapy Mean 54 y Randomized, doubleblind studies BP targets safely, and more rapidly achieved with combo of T/H as initial therapy and after failed monotherapy when compared with either monotherapy Giles et al. (2013) Nevibolol monotherapy in adults < 55 years N = 414 nebivolol N= 207 placebo Adult patients with BP > 140/90 age 18-54 Men 55.5% Mean 45.3 y Phase IV, multicenter, randomized, doubleblind, placebocontrolled, parallelgroup trial Nebivolol treatment resulted in significant DBP and SBP reductions (observed as early as 2 weeks after treatment initiation) and improvement in BP control among adult patients mean age: 45.3 yea Harman, et al. (2013) Treatment of hypertension in African Americans N = 5,302 3393women 1909 men African American Adults with hypertension living in Jackson, Mississippi 60 + or - 11 Large scale medical study, community centered Houston & Sparks (2013) Nutraceutical supplements to lower BP N = 22 intervention group N= 20 control n/a randomized, doubleblind, placebo controlled clinical trial Kario, et al. (2013) Effect of olmesartan on morning home BP’s Average 64.8 + or – 11.9 years Prospective observational study with 2 year f/u MartinezGarcia, et al. (2013) Reduction of 24 hr BP in pts with OSA with CPAP 18-75 y Mean 56 Randomized multicenter trial Muntner, et al. (2014) Which antihypertensive agents limit visit-to-visit variability in BP Mean 66.8 y Multi-center randomized control trial ALLHAT chlorthalidone and amlodipine were associated with lower VVV of BP when compared with lisinopril Omboni, et al. (2013) Olmesartan vs Ramipril in elderly pts with HTN N = 1426 Adult Patients with diagnosed hypertension 23 females 19 males olmesartan-naive patients with essential htn and no history of recent acute cardiovascular events Pts with OSA and primary resistant HTN uncontrolled despite the use of 3 or more medications Pts with HTN at 623 clinical sites across the United States,Canada, Puerto Rico, and the US Virgin Islands Elderly patients with mild-moderate essential HTN most commonly used medication diuretics, taken by 65% of treated persons. African Americans more difficult to control and may need use of different med classes significant reduction of SBP over 4-week period with treatment using standardized blend of seven nutrients. Larger groups #’s and longer treatment periods recommended both clinic and morning home BP in all, DM and CKD patients improved with 16week olmesartan-based treatment. Results showed a sustained 24-hour BP-lowering effect of olmesartan. Continuous positive airway pressure reduced mean 24-hr BP in pts with OSA and resistant HTN 65-89 y Randomized, doubleblind studies Park, et al. (2014) effect of qigong on prehypertension and mild hypertension Olmesartan or nebivolol on BP and endothelial function markers N = 40 19 qigong 21 control SBP between 120 and 159 mm Hg and/or DBP between 80 and 99 mm Hg. Newly diagnosed Patients with Stage 1 essential HTN 50 males 19 - 65 y Randomized, control trial Olmesartan superior to Ramipril in providing sustained and more homogeneous BP control throughout 24-h period. It is effective first line option qigong effective intervention in reducing BP in prehypertension and mild hypertension Mean 52 + or – 9 years Mean Nevibolol = 50.1 Olmesartan=54.9 Mean 54.2 years Randomized open label study Both olmesartan and nebivolol caused similar responses in BP and flow mediated vasodilatation and endothelial function improved Observational, crosssectional survey Over 18 years Multi-center, prospective, observational, noninterventional, 4 month open-label clinical study RAS blocking agentsare preferred choice by the majority both for starting and for up-titrating combination therapies, (RAS blocking agents plus either diuretics or calcium-channel blockers, has reported to be the most effective option for sustained control and also high levels of adherence Mean BP decreased and mean HR decreased. BP targets reached by 72% of patients, 85.7% of patients with grade 1 HTN 69.5% for grade 2 HTN in patients who failed to meet goals prior Sendur et al. (2014) Tocci, et al. (2013) physicians’ attitudes and preferences for daily management of hypertension Toth, K. (2014) Efficacy of triple combination Perindopril/Indapamide plus amlodipine in high pts with difficult to control HTN N=21,341 50.5% women N = 194 65% men N=33,357 55% male N = 85 N=557 physicians 478 male N=4,731 2,350 female Physicians. 261 specialized and 296 general practitioners Pts with high CV over 18 years of age withnHTN not properly controlled despite therapy 16 HYPERTENSION TREATMENT