Download Colorado Compendium

Document related concepts

Medical ethics wikipedia , lookup

Dental emergency wikipedia , lookup

Adherence (medicine) wikipedia , lookup

Management of multiple sclerosis wikipedia , lookup

Multiple sclerosis research wikipedia , lookup

Transcript
Colorado Compendium
(17) A prediction rule to identify low-risk patients with community-acquired
pneumonia.
Fine MJ, Auble TE, Yealy DM et al.
N Engl J Med. 1997 Jan 23;336(4):243-50.
Departments of Medicine and Emergency Medicine, University of Pittsburgh; Department of
Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital; Division of Infectious Diseases, Dalhousie University,
Halifax, Nova Scotia.
Clinical Practice Guideline
Four million adults are diagnosed with community acquired pneumonia (CAP) each year. Of
these patients, 600,000 are hospitalized costing an estimated $4 billion annually. Yet the criteria
for admission vary widely. The subjective impression of clinical appearance often guides the
physician’s decision to admit and physicians generally overestimate the risk of death in patients
who present with pneumonia. As a result of this expensive subjectivity, the authors of this study
validate a prediction rule known as the PORT score.
The study looked at over 14,000 inpatients with CAP (AIDS patients were excluded). The
derivation of a prediction rule was divided into two steps. Step 1 involved the identification of a
subgroup of patients at low risk of death based only on history and physical exam. Step 2 looked
at the remaining patients and quantified the risk of death based on history, physical, and lab and
radiographic findings. Having established the rule, it was then validated in 38,039 patients. The
following factors were associated with increased mortality:
1. Age > 50
2. Presence of cancer, CHF, cardiovascular disease, liver disease, renal disease
3. PE Findings: altered mental status, Pulse >125, RR >30, SBP <90, Temp <35 or >40
Step 2 expanded on these finding to include a variety of radiographic and lab findings which are
listed on page 246. Using these factors, patients were placed in Class I through V
categorizations. Patients who fell in the lowest risk class (Class I) could be sent home without
any further lab or radiographic evidence. Class II and III patients could also be treated as
outpatients in most cases.
The use of this prediction rule would have reduced inpatient stays by 31 percent. But how many
patients who would have been characterized as Class I, II, or III died? The answer is 3, or 1% of
this group. Another 18 patients (4.3%) were admitted to an ICU. Furthermore, if this prediction
rule was already in place, 5 out of the 6 patients who were sent home and died would have been
admitted as Class IV patients. It should be noted that any patient in Class I, II, or III who is
hypoxic in the ED should probably be admitted.
Some weaknesses of the study include the need to consider whether a patient will take antibiotics
as an outpatient (psychosocial). Rare conditions such as cystic fibrosis are not included in the
variables and would obviously affect admission decisions. Finally, the yes/no dichotomous
variables may oversimplify patient presentations. This paper is best appreciated by looking
closely at the tables.
Reviewed by Kurt Whitaker
17