Download Sample paper 1 in-class

2 100pts Paper
truth !=validity
Sample paper 1: Remember, this is not your paper topic. Once paper topic 1 opens, this is the
sample paper that I discuss in the two videos. There is also a sample paper for these two
arguments as well. This shows you how to format the paper.
Analysis of these two arguments:
(a) No arguments with mood and figure AOO-2 are sound since all arguments with mood
and figure AOO-2 are arguments with true premises and a true conclusion
(b) No arguments with mood and figure IAA-2 are sound and at least one argument with
true premises and a true conclusion are not sound so some arguments with mood and
figure IAA-2 are not arguments with true premises and a true conclusion.
Introduction:
give a definition for validity FROM BOOK!!
explain why people might mistake validity from truth
validity is form!! true premise and false conclusion shows
invalid FORM!!
Argument (a)
(a) No arguments with mood and figure AOO-2 are sound SINCE all arguments with mood
and figure AOO-2 are arguments with true premises and a true conclusion
Instance
Validity
Venn diagram
Shade 1,2,5,6
dictionary
Standard logical form
Salmon’s rules
M-1
S=2
P=2
1-1
valid
Premise 1:
Premise 2:
Conclusion:
Argument (b)
(a) No arguments with mood and figure IAA-2 are sound and at least one argument with
true premises and a true conclusion are not sound so some arguments with mood and
figure IAA-2 are not arguments with true premises and a true conclusion.
instance
Invalidity
Venn diagram
dictionary
Standard logical form
Salmon’s rules
Premise 1:
Premise 2:
Conclusion:
Paper conclusion: What do we know about argument (a)? What do we know about argument
(b)? What does this tell us about truth and validity?