Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
The Capabilities Framework: theory and applications Tania Burchardt London School of Economics Why capabilities? • Conceptual advance in welfare economics and political philosophy • Applications in international development, measurement of welfare, inequality • Many problems remaining... – which functionings? how to choose? – how to measure capabilities? – which version of equality? – who cares? ...so a fruitful area for further research Rejection of welfarism 1. Income is a poor proxy for utility (a) differential rates of conversion (b) non-income sources of SWB 2. Utility is the wrong ‘object of value’ (a) adaptive preferences (b) agency goals, not just individual well-being (c) freedom to achieve, not just achievement Framework(s) Sen • functionings • capability sets Nussbaum • list of basic capabilities • reflective equilibrium Applications (1): international development UNDP Human Development Index • to replace GDP per capita • life expectancy + knowledge (literacy, schooling) + standard of living (GDP): basic capabilities • UK ranked 13th, behind Scandinavia, Canada, Japan • eg South Africa, Saudi Arabia do much worse on HDI than GDP • eg Cuba, Georgia do much better on HDI than GDP • how to combine? HDI, HPI 1 & 2 • distribution? Gender-Related Development Index Applications (2): gender and race inequality (i)‘Missing women’ Women expected minus actual women eg China, gender ratio 0.94 = 48 million missing women eg Kerala (in India), gender ratio 1.04, cf all India 0.93 Policy and culture are important factors in determining individual capability sets. (ii) Black and White mortality rates in the US • black male mortality 1.8 x white male • black female mortality 2.9 x white female • even adjusting for income, differentials are 1.2 and 2.2 • by age late-30s, Black Harlem male survival rates fall below Bangladeshi male and way below Chinese male Applications (3): income and well-being Different rates of conversion of income into well-being. Eg extra costs of disability. extension of equivalisation Per cent below 60% median income Poverty rates, using three different income distributions 70 60 50 I Unadjusted 40 II Minus benefits 30 III Equivalised 20 10 0 Non-disabled Disabled All Potential and limitations • Opportunity for all • Capacity-building • New lens through which to view inequality BUT • Normative issues to be resolved • Technical difficulties • Consensus or controversy Some key references and websites