Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
nutrition and Performance Ergogenic Aids to Performance in the Race Horse: Nutrients or Drugs1 DAVID H. SNOW2 EquiSci International, Wahroonga, New South Wales, Australia INDEXING KEY WORDS: •ergogenic •horse •performance •nutrients •drugs Horses compete in a variety of athletic disciplines controlled by regulations that govern the presence of drugs at the time of competition. These regulations try to ensure a "level playing field" as well as protect the welfare of the horse and rider. In addition, where betting is involved they also try to prevent the use of compounds to manipulate performance. Prevention of manipulation is vital if owner and punter support, and thus the financial stability of racing, is to be main tained. Racing jurisdictions have developed regulations from the extremely strict operation in most thorough bred racing countries that prohibit the presence of all compounds that can influence the systems of the body. 0022-3166/94 If fully enforced, these would lead to the absurdity of banning all nutrients! In most states in the United States there is more latitude, as both prerace medica tion (furosemide and phenylbutazone) and compounds such as anabolic steroids are allowed. Although few would argue against the banning of stimulants and de pressants, debate continues in many jurisdictions as to whether any, some or all therapeutic drugs should be permitted and what constitutes legitimate nutri tional supplements. Attempts to decide which substances should be prohibited at the time of racing are made difficult be cause of the problems in demonstrating experimentally whether a compound can influence performance. Due to the large number of variables, a 1% change in per formance, which can have a dramatic effect on the outcome of a race, is virtually impossible to demon strate using either treadmill exercise tests or race track performance. This difficulty has also enabled claims for performance enhancement to be made for a variety of compounds. Support for these claims is often only based on anecdotal evidence or even just hope. This difficulty is also used as a justification for having blan ket rules prohibiting the presence of all compounds that may be considered to affect the body. Difficulties in proving effects on performance may also explain why most regulations in horse racing are virtually all encompassing compared with the defined substances in the International Olympic Committee's rules on prohibited substances. Ergogenic aids (ergogenic, meaning "tending to in crease work or work producing") can be used to im prove performance in the following ways (Williams 1983): 1) improve physiological capacity directly, 2) remove psychological restraints to physiological ca1 Presented as part of the Waltham Symposium on the Nutrition of Companion Animals in association with the 15th International Congress of Nutrition, at Adelaide, SA, Australia, on September 23-25, 1993. Guest editors for this symposium were Kay Earle, John Mercer and D'Ann Finley. 1 To whom correspondence should be addressed: EquiSci Inter national, 45 Campbell Drive, Wahroonga, NSW, 2076, Australia S3.00 ©1994 American Institute of Nutrition. 2730S Downloaded from jn.nutrition.org by on February 29, 2008 ABSTRACT Since the domestication of the horse and its use in various types of athletic competition, its diet has developed from that associated with grazing to feeding of additional energy in the form of grains up to the present situation when numerous supplements are fed in hopes of enhancing performance. Many if not all of these may be considered as ergogenic aids, and under the rules of racing in many countries should be con sidered as a prohibited substance. Until recently, a blind eye has been turned to whether the rules should be enforced against many nutritional supplements, for ex ample, vitamins and amino acids, especially when given in amounts vastly in excess of normal requirements. However, although arguably a nutrient, large doses of sodium bicarbonate and possibly other compounds with the potential of improving buffering capacity have been used extensively, and rules and detection methods have been introduced to curtail this. This paper reviews the nutritional supplements currently in use and discusses whether the singling out of alkalinizing agents as an enforceable prohibited substance is justified, whereas other substances such as fats can be supplemented in high amounts. J. Nutr. 124: 2730S-2735S, 1994. ERGOGENIC AIDS TO PERFORMANCE 2731S ergogenic aid; would it also be considered the first doping agent, if some of today's regulators were present? Since those early days of domestication, when feed ing grain in addition to hay or grass commenced, there was virtually no change in the feeding of horses until the last 30 years. However, our general increase in knowledge about the nutritional demands of exercise has led to changes in feeding patterns and to what is fed. This has contributed to what could be considered as part of the fine tuning of the horse's body and im proved performance. However, I believe we are now at a stage where there are uncertainties as to what is an allowable nutritional supplement to have a horse fit for the racecourse and what may be considered to enhance performance, thereby breaching racing's reg ulations. In attempting to consider where we presently stand, the usage of nutritional supplements is briefly considered. Although it may be debatable which sup plements should be considered as potential ergogenic agents, all are discussed in the recent texts on ergogenics (Lamb and Williams 1991;, Williams 1983). Further details on many of the compounds discussed are provided in these proceedings by Hintz (1994) and Kronfeld et al. (1994). Carbohydrate and glycogen The successful training and racing of a horse re quires sufficient energy intake to maintain an ideal body weight and glycogen stores. To do this, the pro portion of grain in the diet is increased, levels being controlled to prevent an animal becoming overweight, developing laminitis or exertional rhabdomyolysis. For whatever reason the horse has the ability to store large quantities of glycogen within muscle; Concentrations in the well-trained and well-fed horse are 600-700 mmol glucosyl units/kg dry matter (DM) (Snow 1993b). Despite this high content, some workers in the field have investigated glycogen supercompensa tion programs. Although there have been some claims that this can be achieved (Snow 1993b), overall the results are equivocal. Studies showing some benefit have controls with relatively low muscle glycogen content. In addition to attempts to supercompensate, attempts have also been made to see if glycogen re pletion rates can be increased. The use of intravenous (IV) glucose, oral glucose and glucose polymers has been investigated (Snow 1993b). These were of no benefit, and this work has been supported by the recent studies of Davies et al. (1994). Fat It has been well documented that horses can tolerate fat in concentrations considerably higher than would be found in their normal diet [National Research Council (NRC) 1989, Potter et al. 1992]. In addition Downloaded from jn.nutrition.org by on February 29, 2008 pacity and 3) provide a mechanical advantage specific to the sport. Over the last 30 years, great advances have been made in all three categories, leading to marked im provements in human athletic performance. Lesser improvements have been seen in equine sports. The possibilities of motivational enhancement led to the employment of sports psychologists. In the horse world, changing behavioral attitude, often influenced by sex hormones, can have a marked influence on per formance. The terms losing heart or becoming sour are words only too commonly used to describe a dis appointing performance. The ability to prevent or overcome this often is the hallmark of a good trainer. In the third category, improvements in equipment and track design following detailed biomechanical in vestigations have led to marked improvements. This has also occurred within horse racing, resulting from such things as improved horseshoes, sulky (cart) and track design. Of relevance to this paper are the ergogenic aids that may lead to improvement through physiological pathways. These may be obvious drugs such as am phetamines, caffeine, narcotics and anabolic steroids or compounds that are in the grey area between nu trients and when in excess drugs. Physiologically, per formance can be enhanced by either increasing max imum work output per unit time, that is, increased strength, delaying the onset of fatigue at a particular level of performance or improving neuromuscular co ordination. All of these are influenced by training and conventional nutritional programs. However, our in creased knowledge of the causes of fatigue, for ex ample, acidosis and the decline in muscle ATP, glycogen depletion, hypovolemia and hyperthermia, also allow possible improvement through nutritional sup plementation as well as by drugs. The use of stimulants such as amphetamine to change central perception of fatigue are universally condemned, whereas the al lowable use of anabolic steroids for possible strength enhancement varies between countries (see review by Snow 1993a). Where a diversity of views exists is the use of com pounds that can delay the onset of fatigue due to their peripheral effects. Most of these compounds may be considered normal nutrients, but when given in ab normal quantities the question whether their use should be permitted is raised. In the wild, a horse spends most of its time grazing, with occasional bursts of activity when playing or es caping from predators. All its nutritional requirements are met by eating native grasses. Domestication of the horse and its employment in tasks requiring increased energy utilization led to dietary modifications. In the notes to Xenophon The Art of Horsemanship, there is reference to, in Greek times, the feeding of barley (Morgan 1984). Therefore, the feeding of grain to pro vide additional energy could be considered the first IN THE HORSE 2732S SUPPLEMENT Cernitine Carnitine, a low-molecular-weight water-soluble quaternary amine, is associated with numerous aspects of fat and carbohydrate metabolism. Because of this, it has been claimed that carnitine could be a useful ergogenic aid. In humans and laboratory animals, re sults on the use of this compound have been equivocal. Studies in horses have found that carnitine is poorly absorbed after oral administration to horses (Foster and Harris 1989, Foster et al. 1988). After high dose IV administration, there appeared to be no change in muscle carnitine concentration (Foster 1989). There fore, despite the availability in Australia of a carnitine preparation for IV administration, there appears to be no rational reason for its use. Protein From the early 1970s to mid-1980s, the feeding of high protein diets was in vogue. Diets often contained up to 16% protein. These diets probably followed the fashion of human athletes consuming diets with high amounts of protein. It is now generally accepted that it is not necessary to exceed ~10% of protein in the diet. Furthermore, it is the quality of the protein as well as the amount of key amino acids that is of im portance rather than the quantity. Following mainly anecdotal reports on the improvement of performance in humans seen with tryptophan and branched chain amino acids (Grunewald and Bailey 1993), these com pounds have also been sold for horses. The beneficial effects of tryptophan in humans have been recently discounted in a study by Stensrud et al. (1992). Vitamins Many vitamins, especially those belonging to the B-complex, are vital in metabolic regulation. It has, therefore, been suggested that their requirements in crease during periods of intense activity. However, these increased requirements are usually met by in creased feed intake, especially if complete rations are used. However, just as in the human athlete, there is a belief among many trainers that megadoses of vita mins enhance performance. One extremely successful horse race trainer has been reported to feed 20 g ascor bic acid and 10 g vitamin E daily to his race horses (Snow and Frigg 1987). Just as in many other areas examining the effects of nutrition on performance, equivocal results have been reported in humans when supplementation with var ious vitamins has been examined (Williams 1983). In horses, studies have been extremely limited. A study of biotin supplementation showed no effect on the de velopment of the lactate threshold (Lindner et al. 1992). The effects of the relationship between lipid peroxidation, which may contribute to fatigue and vi tamin E status, have been recently investigated with respect to endurance performance (McMeniman and Hintz 1992, Petersson et al. 1991). Electrolytes and water It is well accepted that adequate amounts of elec trolytes and water are required for optimum perfor mance as well as the avoidance of risks to the health of the animal. The major thermoregulatory mechanism in the horse is sweating. As sweat in the horse is hypertonic, depletion of electrolytes as well as water are major causes of fatigue in endurance events. To pre vent problems arising from electrolyte and water de pletion, adequate supplementation of electrolytes and water before and during competition is undertaken. In addition to water, of major concern is adequate intake of sodium because normal diets are very low in this electrolyte. The necessity for supplementation with trace elements is unknown. In race horses, it has been common practice to give electrolyte solutions in travenously (jugging) or orally (drenching) before competition. The rationale for this and its usefulness Downloaded from jn.nutrition.org by on February 29, 2008 to the obvious use of fat as an energy-dense compound to increase energy intake in horses with a poor appetite or with very high energy demands (e.g., horses com peting in endurance competitions), it has also been claimed that increased fat intake will enhance perfor mance (Potter et al. 1992) in both endurance and sprinting events. It has also been claimed (Potter et al. 1992, Snow 1993b) that feeding increased fat will in crease muscle glycogen concentrations. Again, in creased muscle glycogen has been seen in those studies where it would appear that controls had initially low muscle glycogen content. One study has shown that by using isoenergetic diets, both high protein and high fat diets resulted in lower muscle glycogen than the normal diet (Pagan et al. 1987). On the other hand, Harkins et al. (1992) using isoenergetic diets found increased glycogen content when a higher proportion of fat was fed. A recent study at the University of Sydney found that 3 wk of feeding fat had no influence on muscle glycogen content (Eaton et al. 1994). Harkins et al. (1992) found decreased sprinting time in horses fed a high fat diet. However, this study can be criticized because a cross-over design was not used. Some studies have found increased blood or plasma lactate concen trations associated with maximal exercise, whereas others have found decreased concentrations (Snow 1993a). On metabolic grounds, it is difficult to under stand how feeding increased fat can improve perfor mance requiring supramaximal effort. In endurance activities, feeding fat will be beneficial in ensuring ad equate energy intake and may also lead to a glycogensparing effect due to enhanced free fatty acid utiliza tion (NRC 1989). ERGOGENIC AIDS TO PERFORMANCE is questionable. It may be of some benefit after a long trip to the racecourse during which the horse may have lost considerable amounts of fluid and electrolytes through sweating. Buffering compounds 2733S owners and regulators is should all of these nutritional attempts be considered legal and advances in optimal feeding or should some differentiation be made? In human athletics it would appear that presently there are no constraints on the use of any nutritional agents. Enhancement of muscle glycogen stores, megadoses of vitamins and the use of electrolytes, including so dium bicarbonate, are all permitted at any time before competition. In endurance events in both human and equine competitions, the use of energy substrates, electrolytes and water are not only permitted but also encouraged because of welfare concerns despite al lowing improved performance. However, in horse racing the situation is different with, as discussed pre viously, regulations in many countries banning all nu trients because all, in one way or another, affect the various systems of the body. However, for obvious reasons these rules are not enforceable, although it could be argued that certain dietary alterations, for example, feeding fat, could lead to enhanced and ma nipulated performances. There also appears to be no monitoring of the use of amino acid and vitamin sup plements. Prohibition of buffering compounds In contrast to the freedom to use most nutrients, many racing jurisdictions have recently introduced regulations against the use of compounds that will improve buffering capacity. Presently, this rule is only enforced in some countries, notably in Australia, by the measuring of prerace blood or plasma bicarbonate or total CO2 concentrations. Because of endogenous concentrations, threshold levels have been established (Auer et al. 1993). The levels have been set to prevent the administration of bicarbonate before racing rather than daily supplementation with low doses. The latter have not been found to alter normal resting values (D. Lloyd and R. J. Rose, personal communication). The established threshold levels may vary, for example, in New South Wales the threshold is presently 35 and 37 mmol/1 of total carbon dioxide within plasma for standardbreds and thoroughbreds, respectively. In the United States where the diuretic furosemide may be permitted, the establishment of threshold values will be even more difficult because this drug could influ ence bicarbonate excretion (Roelofson 1993). The strongest argument against the use of buffering agents is the possibility of manipulation of races by having horses running on or off bicarbonate. When sodium bicarbonate was being freely used in standardbred racing in Sydney, there was apparently a strong relationship between betting and horses ad ministered bicarbonate (D. Lloyd, personal commu nication). On the other hand, it could be argued that the attainment of high blood bicarbonate concentra tions with minimal health risk should be just as permissable as using supplements to ensure high muscle Downloaded from jn.nutrition.org by on February 29, 2008 With high intensity exercise, fatigue is thought to be related to increasing acidity of muscle and a de crease in muscle ATP. It has been suggested that im provement in either intra- or extracellular buffering could improve performance. In humans, it has been demonstrated that in certain situations, oral admin istration of sodium bicarbonate several hours before competition is beneficial. In horses, a number of stud ies have been carried out examining whether sodium bicarbonate administration can influence supramaxi mal performance (Harkins and Kammerling 1992, Lloyd et al. 1993a, Snow 1993c). Overall, these studies have been unable to show any improved race track performance. However, metabolic studies found that sodium bicarbonate administration resulted in an in creased blood lactate concentration and reduction in decline in muscle ATP (Greenhaff et al. 1991). This would theoretically lead to prolonged onset of fatigue and allow faster racing times. Despite the lack of ben eficial effects seen experimentally, anecdotal evidence from the extremely widespread use of sodium bicar bonate (often termed by horsemen a milkshake when incorporated with other ingredients) on the race track (until its prohibition), especially in standardbreds, suggests a beneficial effect. On the race track, amounts up to 1 g/kg of sodium bicarbonate, resulting in venous blood total carbon dioxide concentrations in excess of 40 mmol/1 (Lloyd et al. 1993b), have been reported. In contrast to humans where doses in excess of ~0.3 g/kg are often associated with gastrointestinal side ef fects, these extremely high doses would appear to be generally well tolerated by horses. More recently, the oral administration in humans of very high doses (20-30 g/d for up to 5 d) of creatine has been shown to increase muscle total creatine pool in some individuals (Harris et al. 1992). It has been reported that this can enhance sprinting performance (Harris et al. 1993). It has been suggested that this is brought about by increasing the creatine/phosphocreatine pool, enhancing dynamic buffering within mus cle. It is thought to be of most benefit in muscle with relatively low creatine phosphate content. The effects of creatine administration on race horse performance are being currently investigated. In a number of coun tries including Australia it is being fed to race horses with anecdotal reports of beneficial effects. The overview presented here indicates that com pounds belonging to different nutritional categories have and are still being used in an attempt to improve performance. The difficult question for feed and sup plement manufacturers, nutritional advisors, trainers, IN THE HORSE 2734S SUPPLEMENT lators are justifiably concerned about manipulation of performance, it is surprising that one of the easiest ways to influence performance, that is, racing outside the horses ideal weight, is not monitored by the very easy weighing of horses before a race. This option has been used for many years in greyhound racing and in Japan for thoroughbred racing. The questions raised are extremely difficult to answer, especially in racing, whose future is dependent on a betting public de manding the minimum of underhanded tactics. How ever, it is time that these questions are openly dis cussed. LITERATURE CITED Auer, D., Skelton, K. V., Tay, S. & Baidock, F. C. (1993) Detection of bicarbonate administration (milkshake) in Standardbred horses. Aust. Vet. J. 70: 336-340. Davies, A. J., Evans, D. L., Hodgson, D. R. & Rose, R. J. (1994) Effects of an oral glucose polymer on muscle glycogen resynthesis in standard bred horses. }. Nutr. 124: 2740S-2741S. Eaton, M. D., Hodgson, D. R., Evans, D. L., Bryden, W. L. &. Rose, R. J. (1994) Effect of diet containing supplementary fat on the capacity for high intensity exercise. Equine Vet. J. (suppl). 18 (in press). Foster, C. V. L. (1989) Aspects of Carnitine Metabolism and Function in the Horse. PhD thesis, Animal Health Trust, New market, England. Foster, C. V. L. a Harris, R. C. (1989) Plasma carnitine concen trations in the horse following oral supplementation using a triple dose regime. Equine Vet. J. 21: 376-377. Foster, C. V. L., Harris, R. C. & Snow, D. H. (1988) The effect of oral L-carnitine supplementation on the muscle and plasma concentrations in the Thoroughbred Horse. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. A Comp. Physiol. 91: 827-835. Greenhaff, P. L., Harris, R. C., Snow, D. H., Sewell, D. A. &.Dunnett, M. (1991 ) The influence of metabolic alkalosis upon exercise metabolism in the thoroughbred horse. Eur. J. Appi. Physiol. 63: 129-134. Grunewald, K. K. & Bailey, R. S. (1993) Commercially marketed supplements for bodybuilding athletes. Sports Med. 15: 90-103. Harkins, J. D. &. Kammerling, S. G. (1992) Effects of induced alkalosis on performance in Thoroughbreds during a 1,600m race. Equine Vet. J. 24: 94-98. Harkins, J. D., Morris, G. S., Tulley, R. T., Nelson, A. G. &. Kam merling, S. G. (1992) Effect of added dietary fat on racing per formance in Thoroughbred horses. J. Equine Vet. Sci. 12: 123129. Harris, R. C., Sodehund, K. & Hultman, E. (1992) Elevation of creatine in resting and exercised muscle of normal subjects by creatine supplementation. Clin. Sci. 83: 367-374. Harris, R. C., Viru, M., Greenhaff, P. L. & Hultman, E. (1993) The effect of oral creatine supplementation on running perfor mance during short-term exercise in man. J. Physiol. (Lond.) 467: 74P. Hintz, H. F. (1994) Nutrition and equine performance. J. Nutr. 00 (suppl. 4): 000-000. Kronfeld, D. S., Ferrante, P. L. &. Grandjean, D. (1994) Optimal nutrition for athletic performance of dogs and horses. J. Nutr. 00 (suppl. 4): 000-000. Lamb, D. R. &.Williams, M. H. (1991 ) Ergogenics—Enhancement of Performance in Exercise and Sport. Perspectives in Exercise Science and Sports Medicine, Vol. 4. Wm. C. Brown, Ann Arbor, Michigan. Downloaded from jn.nutrition.org by on February 29, 2008 glycogen. Because bicarbonate administration can alter postrace urine pH and also cause diuresis, it might interfere in the excretion of other drugs. It therefore has the potential as a masking agent. A study has in dicated that it will make the detection of the narcotic etorphine more difficult to detect (D. Lloyd, personal communication). Other arguments against its legiti mate use include the following: I) it is not given as a normal nutrient in the feed but in very vast quantities in an unnatural manner (nasogastric tubing) and 2) al terations in blood bicarbonate concentrations result in nonphysiological levels, therefore resulting in a pharmacological effect. The relative ease in monitoring bicarbonate admin istration allows abuse to be readily detected, although the significance of concentrations just in excess of threshold values can lead to controversy. However, what is going to be the situation if creatine supple mentation is shown to be successful? The alteration of intracellular buffering will not be easily determined and detection will probably have to rely on measure ment of plasma or urinary creatine concentrations. If as in humans creatine administration only increases muscle creatine to concentrations still within normal physiological ranges, it could be argued that this should be permissible as a relative deficiency is being corrected by supplementation. This is despite the compound not being present in the normal diet and being administered in megadoses. Interestingly, al though creatine under the present rules is illegal in Australia, in Sweden it was recently decided that it is a legitimate compound to feed (S. Persson, personal communication). On the other hand, the administra tion of bicarbonate before racing is illegal in Sweden. Apparently the different rulings are based on the fact that nasogastric tubing before racing is illegal, the normal way of bicarbonate administration and not on whether it may influence performance. What would be the situation if a delayed release preparation of bi carbonate could be developed? If these buffering compounds are prohibited, why should fat administration be allowed if anecdotal and some scientific evidence indicates it enhances perfor mance? Is there not just as much scope for manipu lation of form? Should not fat administration be con sidered in a similar manner to creatine, that is, the feeding of a nutrient in amounts not found in the nor mal diet? As our knowledge of the relationship of cer tain of the body's compounds to performance increases and may allow us to adopt feeding strategies to im prove performance, which are we going to accept or are we going to remain in a time warp? Are we going to prevent the use of substances that may im prove performance and even reduce postcompetition stresses? Are scientifically based nutritional improve ments to be considered as providing optimal sports nutrition, or because they could be used to manipulate performance will they be prohibited? Although regu ERGOGENIC AIDS TO PERFORMANCE 2735S Potter, G. D., Hughes, S. L., Julen, T. R. & Swinney, D. L. (1992) A review of research on digestion and utilisation of fat by the equine. In: Europaische Konferenzuber die Ernährung des Pferdes, pp. 119-123. Pferdeheilkunde 1-216. Hippiatrika Verlagsgessel/Schaft, Calw, Germany. Roelofson, R. (1993) Sucrose and bicarbonate overloading of Standardbred horses in Ontario In: Proc. 9th Int. Conf. of Racing Analysts and Veterinarians. Vol. II. pp. 145-147. New Orleans, LA. Snow, D. H. (1993a) Anabolic steroids in drug use in performance horses. Vet. Clin. North Am., Equine Practice 9, pp. 563-576. Snow, D. H. (1993b) A review of nutritional aids to energy pro duction for athletic performance. In: Proc. llth Annu. Meet. Assoc. Equine Sports Medicine, 1992 (Foreman, J., éd.), pp. 9195. Veterinary Practice Publishing Company, Santa Barbara, CA. Snow, D. H. (1993c) Update on the use of sodium bicarbonate in horses. In: Proc. 11th Annu. Meet. Assoc. Equine Sports Med icine, 1992 (Foreman, J., éd.),pp. 86-90. Veterinary Practice Publishing Company, Santa Barbara, CA. Snow, D. H. &.Frigg, M. (1987) Plasma concentrations at monthly intervals of vitamin A, C, E and 0-carotene in two thoroughbred racing stables and the effects of supplementation. In: Proc. 10th Equine Nutr. and Physiol. Soc. Meeting, pp. 617-623. Colorado State University. Stensrud, T., Ingger, F., Holm, H. & Stromme, S. B. (1992) Ltryptophan supplementation does not improve running perfor mance. Int. J. Sports Med. 13: 481-485. Williams, M. H. (1983) Ergogenic aids. In: Sport Human Kinetics. Publishers Inc., Champaign, IL. Downloaded from jn.nutrition.org by on February 29, 2008 Lindner, A., von Wittke, P. &. Frigg, M. (1992) Effect of biotin supplementation on the VLA4of Thoroughbred horses. J. Equine Vet. Sci. 12: 149-151. Lloyd, D. R., Evans, D. L., Hodgson, D. R., Suann, C. J. & Rose, R. J. (1993a| Effects of sodium bicarbonate on cardiorespiratory measurements and exercise capacity in Thoroughbred horses. Equine Vet. J. 25: 125-129. Lloyd, D. R., Reilly, P. & Rose, R. J. (1993b) The detection and performance effects of sodium bicarbonate administration in the racehorse. In: Proc 9th Int. Conf. of Racing Analysts and Vet erinarians. Vol. II, pp. 131-128. New Orleans, LA. McMeniman, N. P. & Hintz, H. F. (1992) Effect of vitamin E status on lipid peroxidation in exercised horses. Equine Vet. J. 24: 482-484. Morgan, M. H. (1984) Xenophon—The Art of Horsemanship, p. 28. J. A. Allen and Company Ltd, London, England. National Research Council (1989) Nutrient Requirements of Horses. National Academy Press, Washington, DC. Pagan, J. D., Essen-Gustavsson, B., Lindholm, A. & Thornton, J. (1987) The effect of dietary energy source on exercise perfor mance in Standardbred horses. In: Equine Exercise Physiology 2 (Gillespie, J. R. & Robinson, N. E. eds.), pp. 686-700. ICEEP Publications, Davis, CA. Petersson, K. H., Hintz, H. F., Schryver, H. F. &. Coombs, G. F. Jr. (1991) The effects of vitamin E on membrane integrity during submaximal exercise. In: Equine Exercise Physiology 3. (Persson, S. G. B., Lindholm, A. & Jeffcott, L. B. eds.), pp. 315-322. ICEEP Publications, Davis, CA. IN THE HORSE