Download The period of War Communism

The period of War Communism
Introduction:
The Bolshevik seizure of power in October 1917 was the beginning rather than the end of the
revolution. The Bolsheviks government had a tenuous grip on power and some observers
thought that it would only survive a few weeks. For three years between 1918 and 1921, a
bitter civil war was fought between the Bolsheviks and their enemies. Following on
immediately from the First World War, which had already brought Russia to its knees
economically, it was fought in conditions of extreme hardship and deprivation. The overall
death toll, including civilian deaths from hunger and epidemics as well as those caused by
military action, may have been as high as ten million. The Bolsheviks won the war largely due
to the geographical advantages of the Red Army, the lack of unity among the opposition forces
and the abilities of Leon Trotsky, who led and organised the Red forces throughout the conflict.
Lenin took charge of the day-to-day business of the Sovnakom and the problems he faced
were formidable. Chief amongst these was the rapid deterioration of the economy in the spring
of 1918. He pursued a policy of War Communism to keep the Bolshevik state afloat.
Why did Lenin adopt War Communism?
To ensure their survival in the first months after the October Revolution, the Bolsheviks had
handed over control of the land to the peasants and control of the factories to the workers'
committees. The pressure from peasants and workers had been irresistible. But it was not long
before the shortcomings of both policies became apparent.
Industry fell apart as workers' committees proved incapable of running the factories (although
the economic collapse was underway well before the workers took over, so they cannot be
blamed entirely). This was compounded by acute shortages of raw materials created by the
Civil War. Industrial output, particularly consumer goods, shrank in the Bolshevik-held central
area. The shortage of goods led to soaring price inflation and the value of the rouble collapsed.
Peasants would not supply food to the cities if there were no goods for which food could be
exchanged and paper money was worthless. Moreover, the rich wheat areas of the Ukraine
were outside Bolshevik control. So the food shortages got worse and as early as February 1918
the bread ration in Petrograd had reached an all-time low of only 50 grams per person per day.
There were food riots in many cities in early 1918. Workers started to flee from the cities,
leaving factories short of workers. The situation was desperate. Lenin was faced with two main
problems:
1. Keeping the workers in the cities to produce munitions, essential war supplies and
other desperately needed goods.
2. Feeding the workers
“By the end of 1920 the proletariat, the class the revolution was all about, had shrunk to
only half its pre-revolutionary size. Petrograd lost 60 per cent of its workforce by April
1918 and one million people had left the city by that June. In Russia as a whole the
urban proletariat decreased from 3.6 million in January 1917 to 1.4 million two years
later. Starving and unemployed workers left the towns to return to the villages, to join
the Red Army, or to enter the ever-growing ranks of the bureaucracy. Hardest hit were
the large state-owned metallurgical factories employing the very section of the working
class which had provided the Bolsheviks with the core of their support in 1917. The
Vyborg district of Petrograd saw its population fall from 69,000 to 5,000 by the summer
of 1918”.
B. Williams, The Russian Revolution 1917-21, 1987, pp. 62-63
It was not only economic problems that Lenin faced in the summer of 1918; he was also
confronted by the full onslaught of the Civil War. From this point onwards, the Bolsheviks were
fighting for their lives. As a result, the whole economy of the Red-held part of Russia was
geared towards the needs of the army. The name given to the policies Lenin adopted from
1918 to 1921 is War Communism.
The main features of War Communism
Grain requisitioning
The Bolsheviks had been sending units of Red guards and soldiers out into the countryside to
find grain for the hard-pressed cities. In May 1918 a Food-Supplies Dictatorship was set up to
establish the forcible requisitioning of grain as the standard policy. Unsurprisingly, the
peasants resisted bitterly.
Banning of private trade
All private trade and manufacture were banned. However, the state trading organisation was
extremely chaotic and industry was simply not producing enough consumer goods. So an
enormous black market developed, without which most people could not have survived.
Nationalisation of industry
All industry was brought under state control and administered by the Supreme Council of
National Economy (Vesenkha). Workers' committees were replaced by single managers
reporting to central authorities. These were often the old bourgeois managers now called
'specialists'. This was the only way to stop the chaos caused by the factory workers'
committees who had voted themselves huge pay rises, intimidated management and stolen
materials for illegal goods. Not all workers were against nationalisation: many, faced with the
closure of their factory, urged that it be nationalised and kept open. They were desperate to
keep their jobs.
Labour discipline
Discipline was brought back to the work place. There were fines for lateness and absenteeism.
Internal passports were introduced to stop people fleeing to the countryside. Piece-work rates
were brought back, along with bonuses and a work book that was needed to get rations.
Rationing
A class-based system of rationing was introduced. The labour force was given priority along
with Red Army soldiers. Smaller rations were given to civil servants and professional people
such as doctors. The smallest rations, barely enough to live on, were given to the burzhui or
middle classes - or as they were now called, 'the former people'.
The Red Terror
Another crucial element of War Communism was the systematic use of terror to back up the
new measures and deal with opposition. An assassination attempt on Lenin'’ life in August
1918 prompted the Cheka to launch the Red Terror. Execution, previously the exception, now
became the rule. Official records put the figure for deaths at the hands of the Cheka for the
years 1918-20 at nearly 13,000, but estimates place the real figure at nearer 300,000.
The Cheka was particularly active in the countryside, helping requisitioning brigades to collect
grain from the peasants. Quotas were filled even if this left peasants starving. The peasants
resisted in a wave of uprisings and attacked the peasants.
What was life like during War Communism?
Peasants in the countryside deeply
resented War Communism, which demanded
that their surplus crops be taken by the
government to feed factory workers and
soldiers (food dictatorship). They had won the
right to own their land under the Communists,
but now they wanted to profit from this by
selling their crops. They did not see why they
should simply hand over their surplus produce.
Many peasants simply decided there was no
point in growing any more food than they
needed for themselves. In 1919 they started
to sow less grain and breed fewer animals.
The result was a food shortage in 1920 and
then a terrible famine in 1921. Starvation,
cold weather and disease killed a total of
seven million Russians. According to
Pravda, the Communists’ own newspaper,
twenty five million Russians were living below
the subsistence level.
The workers in cities were also discontented. They were forced to work longer hours under
strict new laws that included the death penalty for striking. Their rations were completely
inadequate and often there were none. Some peasants brought food to barter or sell in the cities but
the price of this black market food was too high for most workers. Those caught trading for profit
were often shot. The big cities soon began to empty as workers returned to the countryside in the
hope of finding food. Petrograd lost 70 per cent of its inhabitants and Moscow lost 50 per cent
during the period of War Communism. This represented a considerable thinning of the Communists’
erstwhile supporters. The proletariat, which was meant to lead the revolution, was visibly wasting
away. Many of those who remained moved to the extreme left of the party and became more and
more opposed to the Government. They showed their feelings by joining in a number of illegal
strikes in February 1921.
By early 1921, discontent with War Communism was at its height. In the countryside, the Red Army
had to put down a number of full-scale rebellions by peasants that cost the army almost a quarter of
a million lives in the space of a year. Both Trotsky and Lenin saw the dangers in War Communism.
They tried to have the policy changed but were defeated by other leading Communists who believed
that, whatever the problems caused, it was necessary.
The final straw came when discontent in at Petrograd spread to the sailors at the Kronstadt naval
base. This came as a shock, for the Kronstadt sailors were believed to be among Lenin’s most loyal
supporters. In 1917, Trotsky had described the sailors as, “the pride and joy of my revolution”. In
1921, Trotsky and other Red Army generals surrounded Kronstadt with 60,000 troops. They bombed
the naval base and then attacked the sailors’ headquarters. In the fighting that followed thousands
of the rebels were killed and many more arrested and later shot by the Cheka. The event had also
cost the Red Army 10,000 lives.
“After carrying out the October Revolution, the working classes hoped for freedom. But the
result has been greater slavery. The bayonets, bullets and harsh commands of the Cheka –
these are what the working man of Soviet Russia has won. The glorious emblem of the
workers’ state – the hammer and sickle – has been replaced by the Communist authorities
with the bayonet and the barred window. Here in Kronstadt we are making a third revolution
which will free the workers and the Soviets from the Communists”.
Official statement from the Kronstadt sailors.
The Kronstadt rising was crushed, but Lenin realised a change in policy was needed if there were to
be no more risings like it.
The period of War Communism
Introduction
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Why do you think the Bolsheviks were in such an unstable position in October 1917?
What promises would Lenin now have to deliver? (think back to your Russia in Revolution work)
When were the Bolsheviks forced to fight a civil war?
What was the human cost of the war?
Give three reasons for the Bolsheviks success in the civil war.
How did the responsibilities of Trotsky and Lenin differ during the civil war?
Why did Lenin adopt War Communism?
1. What concessions did the Bolsheviks make to the peasants and workers after the October
Revolution?
2. Why were there already shortages in (a) industrial goods and (b) food by 1918?
3. How did urban workers respond to the shortages?
4. What were the two main problems Lenin faced?
5. Why are the economic policies Lenin adopted between 1918 and 1921 known as War
Communism?
The main features of War Communism
1. Define the following:
Grain requisitioning
Requisitioning brigades
Private trading
Black market
Nationalisation
Vesenkha
Cheka
Red Terror
2. Summarise the key features of War Communism. Think carefully about how you present the
information.
3. How many people died at the hands of the Cheka between 1918 and 1920?
4. Why was the Cheka more active in the countryside than the cities?
What was life like during War Communism?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Why did the peasants resent War Communism?
How did they display their feelings about this policy?
What were the consequences of their actions?
Why were urban workers discontented?
What measures did workers in cities take during this period?
Why do you think there was disagreement among leading Communists about whether to
continue with War Communism or not? (HINT: Think about the basic beliefs of Communists)
7. What happened at Kronstadt naval base in 1921 and why was it such as setback for the
Communists?