* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Download stringcos2012-final Jae Weon Lee
Orchestrated objective reduction wikipedia , lookup
Renormalization group wikipedia , lookup
Many-worlds interpretation wikipedia , lookup
Renormalization wikipedia , lookup
Theoretical and experimental justification for the Schrödinger equation wikipedia , lookup
Hawking radiation wikipedia , lookup
Quantum key distribution wikipedia , lookup
Bohr–Einstein debates wikipedia , lookup
EPR paradox wikipedia , lookup
Interpretations of quantum mechanics wikipedia , lookup
Canonical quantization wikipedia , lookup
Quantum teleportation wikipedia , lookup
AdS/CFT correspondence wikipedia , lookup
History of quantum field theory wikipedia , lookup
Hidden variable theory wikipedia , lookup
Jae-Weon Lee (Jungwon univ.) Outline • Quantum mechanics from information loss at causal horizons • Entropic gravity from information loss • A derivation of Holographic principle • Origin of quantum entanglement • Dark energy from information loss Problems of Newton’s gravity F GMm R2 1. Instant action at a distance? (nonlocal) 2. Origin of the Inverse square law?? Mach & Einstein gravity Einstein gravity dispelled the “action at a distance”; Spacetime distortion mediates gravity with light velocity. Conjecture G T ; Geometry=Matter why???? It is thermal, TdS=dE Jacobson Action at a distance revived QM has “Spooky action at a distance”! = Nonlocal quantum correlation (entanglement) But even with entanglement we can not send information faster than light (No-Signaling) Why???? Big questions •What is the origin of Gravity, QM, Q. Entanglement? & holography? Information can be the key to the solution A motivation) There are strong similarities between holography and Q. entanglement; Area proportional, related to information loss, observer dependency…. Cf) Bekenstein, Wheeler, ‘t Hooft … What is information? The information embodied by a thing = the identity of the particular thing itself, that is, all of its properties, all that makes it distinct from other things. = a complete description of the thing, divorced from any particular language. (Wikipedia) = minimum BITS required to describe a thing completely For a thing with random variables Information (Shannon) entropy Why entropy? BH horizon ? an outside observer Shannon entropy Entropy is 1) a measure of the uncertainty associated with a random variable 2) a measure of the average information content one is missing when one does not know the value of the random variable. wikipedia New postulates (not QM) 1) Information has finite density and velocity Nosignaling causal horizons 2) General Equivalence principle All observers (coordinates) are equivalent in formulating physical laws; No observer has a privilege 3) Information is fundamental Physical laws should respect observer’s information about a system 4) Metric nature of spacetime (not Einstein Eq.) 5) information theory From these we can derive QM and Einstein Gravity! QM & Gravity are emergent conjecture Major Physical Laws simply describe thermodynamics regarding phase space information loss at local causal (Rindler) horizons Information loss at horizons Path integral & Thermodynamics QM & Einstein (entropic) gravity holographic principle Q. Entanglement Too ambitious? Roadmap Gauge theory BH physics Dark energy Entanglement Holographic DE Lee11 KK? Gravity Bekenstein -Hawking Unruh Q. Informational DE LLK 2007 Holographic principle Thermody namics Jacobson Verlinde Padmanabhan LLK Lee11 dE=TdS Quantum Mechanics Information No-signaling Lee10 loss Verlinde Newton Mechanics Inverting the logic of Unruh •Unruh Effect QFT + curved spacetime Thermal •New theory Information loss + curved spacetime Themal QFT Why random? Phase space information loss For a fixed outside observer entropy S increases (Thermodynamics) ? M Coordinate trans. Horizon 2 dE=Mc =TdS For an free falling observer (QM) Physical laws should be such that the both observers are satisfied QFT from information loss ??? f? f: field, some function of spacetime Maximize Shannon entropy (Entanglement entropy) Constraint Energy conservation Boltzmann distribution Thermal with temperature 1/ Quantum Mechanics from information Lee FOP arXiv: 1005.2739, rest observer accelerating observer Rindler observer will have no more information about fields crossing the horizon What the observer can do is just to estimate the probability of the field configuration inside. QFT from information Maximize Shannon entropy Boltzmann distribution For Rindler observer (continuous version + coord. Transf. ) Unruh showed that this is equivalent to Quantum partition function! (Unruh Eff.) Origin of QM and path integral! QM from phase space information loss Conventional QM is a single particle limit of QFT QM can be easily reproduced in our theory. Quantum fluctuation is from ignorance of Rindler observer about the particle phase space information beyond a horizon QM from information loss •Quantum fluctuation for a free falling observer is a thermal fluctuation for a fixed observer •QM for the FF observer is a statistical physics regarding information loss for the fixed observer QM is not fundamental but emergent! • Horizon entropy represents uncertainty about field configurations or phase space information •Horizon Energy is just the total energy inside the horizon BH laws of thermodynamics Unruh effect and Hawking rad. are from information loss Explaining some Mysteries of QM 1)Entanglement does not allow superluminal communication because QM itself is from the no-signaling condition. 2) Wave function collapse is just the realization of a uncertain information for some observers 3) Apparent non-locality is due to redundancy from the holography (shown later) 4) Thermal and path integral nature Microscopic DOF? S phasespace Volume O( ) 3 lP Sint ernal O(10) S phasespace S S phasespace Sint ernal S phasespace Phase space entropy is dominant and internal structure is irrelevant upto Planck scale for gravity and QM (if there is no other force) We can not know the true microscopic DOF with low energy gravity or QM experiments Gravity and QM are universal Planck’s constant 1/ T some fundamental temperature associated with one bit of information 1bit.E dE=k TdS=k* * red shift Derivation of 1st law dE=TdS Free E F E TS 1 ln Z R dF 0 dE TdS dE TdS , 1st Law! Maximum entropy minimum F extremizing action Most contributing path Classical path Newton’s mechanics Verlinde theory •Maximum entropy condition is just quantization condition This seems to be the origin of the 1st law of thermodynamics Next order Saddle point approx. This also explains why Verlinde’s derivation involves Planck’s constant which is absent in the final F = ma formula. There is a log correction term Verlinde’s entropic force from information loss J.Lee FOP arXiv:1003.4464 ? Verlinde’s entropy formula •Verlinde’s holographic screen is just Rindler horizon. •Verlinde’s formalism is successfully reproduced Gravity from Information loss Lee FOP arXiv:1003.4464 Rindler horizon Mc 2 Eh 2kTU S BH TU Mc 2 / 2kS BH GM R2 S mx TU TU S GMm F 2 x R Information loss Entropic gravity S mx Jacobson’s idea where using Raychaudhuri eq. using Bianchi identity Einstein eq. Is related to local Rindler observers! How our model avoids the problems of Verlinde’s model •Entropy-distance relation naturally arises •Unruh temperature is natural for Rindler horizon •Horizon and Entropy are observer dependent no worry about time reversal symmetry breaking. Explains the identity of the DOF and entropy •neutron interference experiments Information loss depends on coordinates •Canonical distr. Equipartition law A derivation of holographic principle Lee 1107.3448 1) According to the postulate 2 (nosignaling), we restrict ourselves to local field theory 2) For a local field, any influence from the outside of the horizon should pass the horizon. 3) According to postulate 3, all the physics in the bulk is fully described by the DOF on the boundary holographic principle! A derivation of holographic principle Lee 1107.3448 information loss at a horizon allows the outside observer to describe the physics in the bulk using only the DOF on the boundary. The general equivalence principle demands that this description is sufficient for understanding the physics in the bulk, which is the holographic principle. Theorem (holographic principle). For local field theory, physics inside 1-way causal horizon can be described completely by physics on the horizon. A derivation of Witten’s prescription Lagrange multiplier Boundary op Bulk Witten’s prescription Boundary Quantum Entanglement from holography R Proof by contradition 1) Assume there is no entanglement in the bulk 2) All possible states are product states B1 B2 Bj 3) # of boundary bits O(R 2 ) # of bulk bits O(R 3 ) 4) One can not fully describe the bulk physics using only boundary DOF 5) contradictory to the holographic principle QED boundary bits b 0 1 Bulk bits B 00 01 10 11 Entaglement ~ horizon radius Then exactly how entanglement arises? 1) There is redundancy in the bulk bits Bi 2) Bi Bi ({b }) 3) There always should be correlated bits which have smaller information than bit size ex) Assume combination of two bits B1and B2 which is decribed by b such that both of (B1 , B2 ) (1, 0) and (B1 , B2 ) (0,1) corresponds to b 1 Outside observer can not distinguish two cases. Thus statistical prob. should be added. P(b=1)=P((1, 0)) P((0,1)) For inside observer this corresponds to an entangled state ~ 1 0 0 1 Gravity as Quantum Entanglement Force. Jae-Weon Lee, Hyeong-Chan Kim, Jungjai Lee arXiv:1002.4568 Total entanglement of the universe Arrow of time Entanglement force Dark energy problem • Observed 10121 discrepancy for Sum of all oscillators • Zero point Energy 1) Why it is so small? 2) Why it is not zero? 0 3) Why now? H 02 M P2 M P4 QFT can’t solve this 4) Why the cosmological constant is zero or tiny 0 Dark energy from entanglement LLK:JCAP08(2007)005 Landauer’s principle A black hole-like universe Hawking temperature Entanglement entropy Or Bekenstein-Hawking entropy Horizon energy Expanding event horizon Information Holographic dark energy One can also say it is cosmic Hawking radiation! erasing Zhang & Wu, astro-ph/0701405 Our solution to dark energy problem 1) Why it is so small? Holographic principle (QFT overcounts ind. DOF; QFT is emergent not fundamental) 2) Why it is not zero? 3) Why now? Due to quantum vacuum fluctuation Inflation with N~60 or r~ O(1/H) 4) Zero cosmological constant Holographic principle & dE=TdS Without fine tuning one can explain magnitude and equation of state of dark energy! Open subjects Explain, in this context, 1)gauge theory and Q. gravity 2)BH information paradox 3)Fermions 4)Cosmology including dark energy 5)AdS/CFT correspondence etc Conclusion: Physics from phase space information loss No-signaling information loss at the horizons 1)General relativity (through Jacobson’s idea ) & dark energy (applied at a cosmic horizon) 2) Verlinde’s theory (F=ma) Classical Mechanics 3) Quantum Mechanics (by reverting Unruh’s logic) Physical laws seem to simply express the information loss at local Rindler horizons. Albeit heuristic, this approach seems provide a new way to explain many puzzles in a self-consistent manner Thank you very much! Merits of our theory Our new quantum theory i •is simple & calculable •explain origin of entropic gravity and path integral •Connect Jacobson’s model with Verlinde’s model Energy budget of the universe R 1 3 Scale factor =0 DE+DM DE w<0, negative pressure antigravity Acceleration = Force Eq. of state metric Holography and Entanglement Entanglement has 1.Area Law (in general) 2.Nonlocality 3.Related to causality 4.Fundamental 5.Observer dependent It reminds us of the Holographic principle! Entanglement entropy , Entanglement entropy SEnt Tr ( A log A ) Tr ( B log B ) A A 0 ~ Area information B AB If there is a causal horizon (information barrier), it is natural to divide the system by the horizon and consider entanglement entropy. Our works so far 1) Dark energy from vacuum entanglement. JCAP 0708:005,2007. dark energy from information 2) Does information rule the quantum black hole? arXiv:0709.3573 (MPLA) Black hole mass from information 3) Is dark energy from cosmic Hawking radiation? Mod.Phys.Lett.A25:257-267,2010 Dark energy is cosmic Hawking radiation Verlinde’s paper: Gravity and mechanics from entropic force arXiv:1001.0785 1) Gravity from Quantum Information. 1001.5445 [hep-th] gravity is related to quantum entanglement or information loss 2) Gravity as Quantum Entanglement Force. arXiv:1002.4568 [hep-th] 3) Zero Cosmological Constant and Nonzero Dark Energy from Holographic Principle. arXiv:1003.1878 (Lee) 4) On the Origin of Entropic Gravity and Inertia. arXiv:1003.4464 [hep-th] (Lee) Verlinde’s theory from quantum information model 5) Quantum mechanics emerges from information theory applied to causal horizons arXiv:0041329 (Lee) Negative pressure M. Li 3d 2 M P2 Rh 2 d ( R3 ) p dR(3R 2 ) 1 2 1 3 d Friedmann eq. & perfect fluid EOS Friedmann equations from entropic force Cai et al T M Friedmann equation QM from information loss Lee , FOP f? f: matter filed inside the horizon Maximize Shannon entropy Constraint Energy conservation Boltzmann distribution This Z is equivalent to QM partition function. (Unruh effect) QM is emergent! S mx Comparison with Verlinde’s theory Our theory Verlinde’s theory • • • • • • • • # of bits N •Holographic principle on screen •dS~ dx •Equipartition energy E~NkT •Spacetime is emergent? •Thermal horizon energy? •Differential geometry •Unruh T in general • Information coarse graining Holographic entropy S Landauer’s principle, dE=TdS Causal (Rindler) horizon Jacobson’s formulation Spacetime is given Differential geometry Information erasing (loss) •Mainly informational •Mainly thermodynamic •Assume degrees of freedom on screen Verlinde’s Idea 1: Newton’s 2nd law JHEP04(2011)029 arXiv:1001.0785, E T S F x E T S F x x S mx Unruh T TU a Entropic force F ma ! Newton’s 2nd law Holographic screen?? Verlinde’s Idea 2: Newton’s gravity Ac3 R 2 # of bits N G G entropy 2 NkT R Equipartition E Mc 2 T 2 G GM T 2 R S mx T S GMm F 2 x R Newton’s gravity! Inverse square law explained? Concerns about Verlinde’s Idea 1. strange entropy-distance relation ???? 2. Using holographic principle and Unruh T for arbitrary surfaces? 3. Time reversal symmetry breaking? 4. Origin of the entropy and boundary DOF? 5. Why can we use equipartition law? 6. neutron interference experiments Our information theoretic interpretation resolves these problems EOS WMAP7 Gong et al Our idea2:Quantum Informational dark energy arXiv:0709.0047, 1003.1878 without QFT ~ Horizon area For Event horizon r=Rh ~ Rh Holographic dark energy ~1/Area The simplest case, S= Bekenstein-Hawking entropy M P2 magnitude M P2 H 2 for r O(1/H). 2 r For event horizon we need an inflation with N ~ 60 Zero Cosmological Constant Jae-Weon Lee, 1003.1878 Action in QFT Too large vacuum energy But according to our theory (holographic principle + dE=TdS) should be zero QFT should be modified at cosmological scale Cf) Curved spacetime effect Dark energy problem Sum of all oscillators • Zero point Energy 10121 discrepancy • Observed for 1) Why it is so small? 2) Why it is not zero? 0 3) Why now? H 02 M P2 M P2 4) Why the cosmological constant is zero or tiny 0 Holographic dark energy Only modes with Schwarzschild radius E~ a survives (Cohen et al) Relation between a and L UV IR saturating L If L~1/H, a~1/Mp Problem: no acceleration! This energy behaves like matter rather than dark energy M. Li suggested that if we use future event horizon Rh we can obtain an accelerating universe. 3d 2 M P2 Rh2 But what is the physical origin? Black hole and Entanglement |Dead>|Env0>+|Alive>|Env1> possible? Quantum vacuum fluctuation (Hawking Radiation) allows entanglement between inside and outside of the horizon due to the uncertainty problem. |Env> ’t Hooft G, (1985), Bombelli L, Koul R K, Lee J and Sorkin (1986) Black hole entropy is geometric entropy ( Entanglement entropy) Entanglement of what? Basic Logic of my theory Outside observer :Thermodynamics inside observer: QM ?E, S Coordinate transformation dE=TdS Double Slit Experiment Lee arXiv:1005.2739, FOP How to calculate Entanglement entropy • Hamiltonian Srednicki,PRL71,666 , • Vacuum=ground state of oscillarots • Reduced density matrix R • entropy Eigenvalues Area Calculable! Holographic dark energy Only modes with survives (Cohen et al) E~ a Relation between a and L UV IR saturating L If L~1/H, a~1/Mp Problem: no acceleration! This energy with H behaves like matter rather than dark energy M. Li suggested that if we use future event horizon Rh we can obtain an accelerating universe. 3d 2 M P2 Rh2 But what is its physical origin? Hawking radiation as dark energy Without regularization in flat spacetime After renormalization in de Sitter spacetime Too small T g H 4 p But With UV cut-off Mp ~ M P2 H 2 since k 2 ( H )2 ~ (2k ) 2 HDE LLK, Mod.Phys.Lett.A25:257 Black hole mass Landauer Hawking Mass increase T decrease KLL 0709.3573 Black hole thermodynamics Bekenstein & Hawking 1) The First Law 2) The Second Law dE=THdS BH area always increases =entropy always increases Nobody knows the physical origin of these laws! Black hole entropy contains fundamental constants thermodynamics Bekenstein-Hawking entropy S BH relativity Holographic principle k B c3 Area 4G gravity quantum Hawking radiation Entropy is proportional to Area not to volume Holographic principle Holographic principle • All of information in a volume can be described by physics on its boundary. • The maximum entropy within the volume is proportional to its area not volume. S within R S BH Area R 2 S Ent 4 Plank area R Scientific American August 2003 Relativity, Quantum & Information Q. Gravity Quantum Physics Relativity Information • Information links quantum mechanics with relativity History • BH thermodynamics (Bekenstein & Hawking ) dE=TdS (Gravity +QM BH Thermodynamics) • Holographic principle (t’Hooft & Susskind) Entropy ~ Area • Gravity from thermodynamics Thermodynamics Gravity (Jacobson, Padmanabhan) • Dark energy from information (Information Gravity) JWLee, JJLee, HCKim (LLK) • Entropic gravity (Verlinde) (Entropy Gravity) • QM and Entropic gravity from information loss (Lee11) Superluminal signaling using entanglement? Alive cat 0 Al i en - Dead cat 1 Al i en NO! Quantum mechanics somehow prohibits superluminal communications even with q. entanglement 1) No-signaling could be one of the fundamental principles 2) QM and Gravity cooperate mysteriously 3) Information may be physical It from Bit I think of my lifetime in physics as divided into three periods. In the first period, extending from the beginning of my career until the early 1950's, I was in the grip of the idea that Everything Is Particles…. I call my second period Everything Is Fields. From the time I fell in love with general relativity and gravitation in 1952 until late in my career, I pursued the vision of a world made of fields,… "Now I am in the grip of a new vision, that Everything Is Information. The more I have pondered the mystery of the quantum and our strange ability to comprehend this world in which we live, the more I see possible fundamental roles for logic and information as the bedrock of physical theory. J. Wheeler. Why does physics involve with information? Landauer’s principle • Erasing information dS consumes energy >=TdS Solving Maxwell’s demon problem Single Thermal Bath with T M. B. Plenio and V. Vitelli quant-ph/0103108 C. Bennett Experimental Demonstration Toyabe et al, Nature Physics 6 2010 We can extract energy from information Quantum mechanics and bit Cˇ . Brukner, A. Zeilinger quant-ph/0005084 The most elementary quantum system represents the truth value of one proposition only (bit?). This principle is then the reason for the irreducible randomness of an individual quantum event and for quantum entanglement. Cf) Simon, Buˇzek, Gisin: nosignaling as an axiom for QM t’ Hooft’s quantum determinism quant-ph/0212095 “Beneath Quantum Mechanics, there may be a deterministic theory with (local) information loss. “ Equivalence class =information loss