* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Download My first paper - Konfluence Research Institute
Newton's laws of motion wikipedia , lookup
History of fluid mechanics wikipedia , lookup
Modified Newtonian dynamics wikipedia , lookup
Faster-than-light wikipedia , lookup
Quantum field theory wikipedia , lookup
Aristotelian physics wikipedia , lookup
Equivalence principle wikipedia , lookup
Electrostatics wikipedia , lookup
Electromagnetic mass wikipedia , lookup
Lorentz ether theory wikipedia , lookup
Old quantum theory wikipedia , lookup
Quantum electrodynamics wikipedia , lookup
Partial differential equation wikipedia , lookup
Aharonov–Bohm effect wikipedia , lookup
Weightlessness wikipedia , lookup
Navier–Stokes equations wikipedia , lookup
Criticism of the theory of relativity wikipedia , lookup
Relational approach to quantum physics wikipedia , lookup
Renormalization wikipedia , lookup
History of special relativity wikipedia , lookup
Lorentz force wikipedia , lookup
Introduction to gauge theory wikipedia , lookup
Theory of everything wikipedia , lookup
Yang–Mills theory wikipedia , lookup
Special relativity wikipedia , lookup
Maxwell's equations wikipedia , lookup
History of physics wikipedia , lookup
Nordström's theory of gravitation wikipedia , lookup
Alternatives to general relativity wikipedia , lookup
Field (physics) wikipedia , lookup
History of quantum field theory wikipedia , lookup
Speed of gravity wikipedia , lookup
Introduction to general relativity wikipedia , lookup
Fundamental interaction wikipedia , lookup
Equations of motion wikipedia , lookup
Anti-gravity wikipedia , lookup
Electromagnetism wikipedia , lookup
History of general relativity wikipedia , lookup
1 Electromagnetic Antigravity L.L. Williams Colorado Institute for Space Studies, 6009 Olympic, Manitou Springs, CO, 80829 Discovery of a coupling between gravity and electromagnetism could unleash a phase of technological progress culminating in practical interstellar travel and the mastery of gravitational force. The classical Kaluza-Klein 1, 2 theory of fivedimensional relativity offers a compelling and elegant theoretical basis for such a coupling. While the field equations of this theory were studied extensively, the equations of motion have received less attention. The equations of motion are revisited here, and it is shown that the theory does predict electromagnetic corrections to Newtonian gravity which do not couple to electric charge. The scalar field characteristic of this theory is shown to vary on cosmological lengthscales, and can be identified with the gravitational constant as in Brans- Dicke 3 theory. This recognition allows a separation of scales of the dynamics of the electromagnetic and gravitational fields from the scalar field, preserving the terrestrial limit of vanishing electromagnetic fields. The gravitational constant emerges as a universal charge-to-mass ratio, and electric charge is induced by electromagnetic fields. The Newtonian limit is quantified here, predicting electric fields of order 1018 volts would neutralize earth's surface gravity. Only two years after the publication of his general theory of relativity, Einstein received the manuscript from Kaluza 1 which suggested the equations of electrodynamics could be recovered from the equations of general relativity, along with the four-dimensional equations Einstein had recently derived, if only Einstein's new theory were written in five dimensions. 2 As the greatest minds of that age took notice of and developed Kaluza's original suggestion, they evidently carried in their work two prejudices. One was an apparent interest in the unification of the field equations, and less attention paid to that other aspect of the laws of physics: the equations of motion. The equations of motion describe how matter is influenced by force, the field equations describe how force is influenced by matter. The other prejudice was that of the new quantum theory, emerging at the same time as Kaluza's paper was published. The assumption was made that relativity and quantum theory would be united. Electrodynamics did find reconciliation with quantum theory and the other two quantum forces, and so the interest in the link between electrodynamics and relativity has waned. We now know that for 80 years, the attempt to unify relativity and quantum theory has been fruitless. The elegant and straightforward unification of classical relativity and electrodynamics provided by fivedimensional relativity deserves a closer look, and in particular, its equations of motion. Recovery of electrodynamics from five dimensional (5D) general relativity requires two basic assumptions. One is the form of the 5D metric g~ in terms of the ab four-dimensional (4D) metric g and the electromagnetic vector potential A . This is given by: g~ g k 2 A A / g~5 kA g~55 g~ g g~ 5 kA / g~ 55 (1 k 2 A2 / ) / Greek indices run over 4D spacetime, roman indices over all 5 dimensions and A2 g A A . Tildes denote 5D tensors. k is a constant. (1) 3 This is essentially the 5D metric studied in a series of classic papers by Kaluza 1 , Klein 2 , 4 , Jordan 5 , and Thiry 6 . Reviews are provided by Bergmann 7 and Bargmann 8 . Applequist et al. 9 provide a historical summary, translation of some of the papers listed, and further references. The other basic assumption is that no field depends on the fifth coordinate: g~ab 0. x 5 (2) This constraint, known as the `cylinder condition', eliminates degrees of freedom but still captures general relativity and electrodynamics. Unlike Klein 2 , we need not make an interpretation of this relation in terms of the "size" of the fifth dimension. ~ ~ ~ The 5D vacuum Einstein equations, Gab Rab g~ab R / 2 0 , are used to fix the ~ value of k . G contains terms that can be identified with G as well as with an electromagnetic stress energy tensor TEM , and k is fixed by demanding correspondence with the 4D Einstein equations G (8G / c 4 )TEM , where G is the gravitational constant and c is the speed of light. In this way we demand k 2 4G / c 4 . ~ The G55 equations provide the field equations for , as Thiry 4 : g 1/ 2 k 2 3 / 2 F F (3) where is the covariant 4D derivative, and F A A . The electromagnetic field is a source for , but the lengthscale of variation is large. An electromagnetic energy density similar to the galactic average of one electron-volt per cubic centimeter would yield a lengthscale approximating the radius of the universe. This is similar to the arguments developed by Brans and Dicke 9 for their scalar field which they identified with G , and variation in can indeed be identified with variation in G / c 4 (Brans and 4 Dicke did not contemplate modifications to the equations of motion). Important for this development is the assumption that is approximately constant on terrestrial lengthscales of interest, and thus forces induced by its derivatives are negligible in the equations of motion. The 5D equations of motion arise from the 5D geodesic hypothesis ~ dU a ~ a ~ b ~ c bcU U 0 d~ (4) ~ ~ where b 2 d~ 2 g~ab dx a dx b , U a dx a / d~ , bca is the 5D affine connection, and b is a constant. We are interested in the 4D components of this equation, in terms of c 2 d 2 g dx dx and U a dx a / d : d ~ d 2 dU ~ 5 2 d 2 ~ ~ 55 (U ) 25U 5U U U U ~ 2 0 d d (5) The equation for U 5 can be had without recourse to the geodesic hypothesis. Rather, the cylinder condition (2) implies a conserved quantity ~ dU 5 ~ ~ ~ 5 d 5 U 5 kA U U ~ (kA U U ) ~ 0 d d (6) which allows the relation between the 4D and 5D line elements ~ 2 b 2 U 52 d ~ 2 2 c c d (7) so that (7) can be taken constant under the assumption that is not varying on lengthscales of interest. This simplifies (5). Correspondence with the Lorentz force law requires that the fifth component of the proper velocity must be identified with electric charge, as originally noted by Kaluza 1 . 5 U5 c q/m 2 G (8) where q and m are particle charge and mass, respectively. The gravitational constant is seen to be a natural charge-to-mass ratio. We also have the result that electric charge (8) is not conserved; rather, it is the related quantity described in (6), implying that electric charge can be induced by an electromagnetic field. As momentum is a manifestation of motion in space, and energy of `motion' in time, so electric charge is seen to be a manifestation of motion in the fifth dimension. Inspecting (5), it is clear that the term quadratic in the 4D proper velocity is the usual 4D relativistic gravity. The term linear in the 4D velocity, with the identification (8), is the Lorentz force term. The term quadratic in U 5 is entirely new. For protons and electrons, that term would dominate the equations of motion in general because the ~ gravitational constant is a relatively small charge-to-mass ratio. However, 55 vanishes for constant . Consider now the case of a body in motion under these forces and having no electric charge in its rest frame. The metric (1) implies a purely electromagnetic correction to the standard relativistic 4D field which does not couple to charge: 2G ~ 4 g ( A F A F ) c (9) The Newtonian limit of (5) consists of assuming the spatial components of the 4D proper velocity are much smaller than the time component, that the metric is approximately Minkowskian, and that there is no time dependence. Under these assumptions, the three-dimensional low-velocity flat-space equation of motion for an uncharged body is 6 d 2x 2G g 2 e2 0 2 x dt c (10) where g is the Newtonian gravitational potential, and e is an electric potential. Apparently, the effective gravitational field inside a capacitor could be increased or decreased by adjusting the direction of the electric field. A steady state voltage of order 1018 volts, with a characteristic lengthscale of 10 cm, would neutralize the earth's surface gravity. While enormous, such fields are predicted by (3) to produce characteristic lengthscales in of 10 4 km, consistent with the assumption of constant , as well as negligible variations in the 4D metric on the lengthscales of interest. Just as gravitational acceleration is independent of mass, so is the electromagnetic neutralization, so that the same electric field would in principle float a battleship as easily as a paper clip. 1. Kaluza, T. On the unity problem of physics, Sitzungsberichte der K. Preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin. 966 (1921). translated and reprinted in 12 2. Klein, O. Quantum theory and five dimensional theory of relativity, Zeitschrift f. Phys., 37, 895 (1926), reprinted in 12. 3. Brans, C. & Dicke, R. Phys. Rev. 124, 925 (1961). 4. Klein, O. The atomicity of electricity as a quantum theory law, Nature, 118, 516 (1926). 5. Jordan, P., Erweiterung der projektiven Relativitatstheorie, Ann. d. Physik, 1, 219-228 (1947). 6. Thiry, M.Y., The equations of Kaluza's unified theory, Meeting 12 Jan 1948, translation printed in 12 7. Bergmann, P. Introduction to the Theory of Relativity, Prentice-Hall: New York (1942). 7 8. Bargmann, V., Relativity, Rev. Mod. Phys. 29, 161-174 (1957). 9. Applequist, T., Chodos, A. and Freund, P.G.O., eds., Modern Kaluza-Klein Theories, Addison-Wesley: Menlo Park, CA (1987). Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to L.L.W. (e-mail: [email protected]).