Download Civil Procedure

Survey
yes no Was this document useful for you?
   Thank you for your participation!

* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project

Document related concepts

Professional negligence in English law wikipedia , lookup

Negligence wikipedia , lookup

Transcript
1. Whenever you have a legal claim, even when joined to an equitable one,
jury trial firght always attaches. Even if legal claim a counter claim.
2. In diversity cases, state law determines the substantive dimension of the
claim, but federal law determines the right to a jury trial
D. Reviewing a denial
1. would a directed verdict have been appropriate? Was there any for the the
trier of fact to decide differently than the judge?
II. ROLE OF THE JURY
A. Jury decides fact, judge decides law. But not always easy to define that line.
B. Court usually says when you get to the ultimate question of applying law to
facts, belongs to jury (i.e. what reasonable means) (Dobson)
C. When there is not enough evidence on either side for the jury to make a
reasonable determination of fact, the judge can take the decision away from the
jury (Ried)
III. APPROACH
A. Is there a right to a jury trial?
B. Will either party assert it?
C. If exercised, who decides the issues?
IV. JUDGMENT AS A MATTER OF LAW (directed verdict, JNOV)
A. Basics:
1. Standard: FRCP rule 50((a)(1) – no legally sufficiency evidentiary basis for
a reasonable jurer to rule in their favor.
2. Effect: takes case away from jury, if no rational jury could find it, forget
about the hullabaloo.
3. When: Can make a JML any time after opposing party has made their case,
can renew after verdict.
a. Party waives their right to JML after closing statements and more
importantly after verdict (7th Amend., can’t try facts after jury has)
B. Directed verdict v. JNOV
1. When party moves for DV, jury has sat through whole trial, don’t want to
take it away from them, if it is so one-sided let the jury decide it and judge
can overturn with a JNOV
2. If close call, judge prefer a JNOV, because reversal of DV means a whole
new trial, reversal of a JNOV simply reinstatement of verdict.
C. JML v. Summary Judgment v. pleading motion (12b6)
1. Pleading motion: brought before trial, often before answer. Court can not
look at evidentiary material, basis for decision is the pleading.
2. Summary judgment: Brought before trial, court can look at evidentiary
hearing. Courts look to pretrial written submissions (depos, affs and
documents)
a. Standard really the same for SJ and JML
b. SJ saying nothing to have trial about, JML says nothing for jury to
deliberate about
3. JML: Brought usually at the close of trial and renewed after the verdict,
court can look at evidentiary material, and bases decision on life testimony
and other evidence presented during trial.