Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Open subgroups of free topological groups Jeremy Brazas Spring Topology and Dynamics Conference, New Britain, CT March 23, 2013 Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Free topological groups The free Graev topological group on a based space (X , e) is the topological group FG (X , e) equipped with a based map σ : X → FG (X , e): Given f : X → G, f (e) = eG X / FG (X , e) σ f # ∃!e f G TopGrp(FG (X , e), G) Top∗ (X , U(G)) The unbased version is the free Markov topological group FM (X ). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Free topological groups The free Graev topological group on a based space (X , e) is the topological group FG (X , e) equipped with a based map σ : X → FG (X , e): Given f : X → G, f (e) = eG X / FG (X , e) σ f # ∃!e f G TopGrp(FG (X , e), G) Top∗ (X , U(G)) The unbased version is the free Markov topological group FM (X ). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Free topological groups The free Graev topological group on a based space (X , e) is the topological group FG (X , e) equipped with a based map σ : X → FG (X , e): Given f : X → G, f (e) = eG X / FG (X , e) σ f # ∃!e f G TopGrp(FG (X , e), G) Top∗ (X , U(G)) The unbased version is the free Markov topological group FM (X ). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Free topological groups The free Graev topological group on a based space (X , e) is the topological group FG (X , e) equipped with a based map σ : X → FG (X , e): Given f : X → G, f (e) = eG X / FG (X , e) σ f # ∃!e f G TopGrp(FG (X , e), G) Top∗ (X , U(G)) The unbased version is the free Markov topological group FM (X ). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Free topological groups The free Graev topological group on a based space (X , e) is the topological group FG (X , e) equipped with a based map σ : X → FG (X , e): Given f : X → G, f (e) = eG X / FG (X , e) σ f # ∃!e f G TopGrp(FG (X , e), G) Top∗ (X , U(G)) The unbased version is the free Markov topological group FM (X ). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Free topological groups I Introduced by Markov (1940s) FM (X ) Graev (1960s) FG (X , e) Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Free topological groups I Introduced by Markov (1940s) FM (X ) Graev (1960s) FG (X , e) I Free topological groups take the place of free groups in the general study of topological groups. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Free topological groups I Introduced by Markov (1940s) FM (X ) Graev (1960s) FG (X , e) I Free topological groups take the place of free groups in the general study of topological groups. I Typically, X is Tychonoff (σ : X ⊂ FG (X , e)). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Free topological groups I Introduced by Markov (1940s) FM (X ) Graev (1960s) FG (X , e) I Free topological groups take the place of free groups in the general study of topological groups. I Typically, X is Tychonoff (σ : X ⊂ FG (X , e)). I As groups, FM (X ) = F(X ) FG (X , e) = F(X \e) = F(X )/heiF(x) Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Topological Nielsen-Schreier? Nielsen-Schreier Theorem: Every subgroup of a free group is free. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Topological Nielsen-Schreier? Nielsen-Schreier Theorem: Every subgroup of a free group is free. Question: Is every subgroup H ≤ FG (X , e) a free Graev topological group? Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Topological Nielsen-Schreier? Nielsen-Schreier Theorem: Every subgroup of a free group is free. Question: Is every subgroup H ≤ FG (X , e) a free Graev topological group? No, not even if H is closed (Graev; Brown; Clarke; Hunt, Morris). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Topological Nielsen-Schreier? Nielsen-Schreier Theorem: Every subgroup of a free group is free. Question: Is every subgroup H ≤ FG (X , e) a free Graev topological group? No, not even if H is closed (Graev; Brown; Clarke; Hunt, Morris). Yes, if X is Hausdorff kω -space and H is open (R. Brown, J.P. Hardy; P. Nickolas). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Topological Nielsen-Schreier? Nielsen-Schreier Theorem: Every subgroup of a free group is free. Question: Is every subgroup H ≤ FG (X , e) a free Graev topological group? No, not even if H is closed (Graev; Brown; Clarke; Hunt, Morris). Yes, if X is Hausdorff kω -space and H is open (R. Brown, J.P. Hardy; P. Nickolas). Yes, in abelian case AG (X , e), X Tychonoff and H open (Morris, Pestov). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Topological Nielsen-Schreier? Nielsen-Schreier Theorem: Every subgroup of a free group is free. Question: Is every subgroup H ≤ FG (X , e) a free Graev topological group? No, not even if H is closed (Graev; Brown; Clarke; Hunt, Morris). Yes, if X is Hausdorff kω -space and H is open (R. Brown, J.P. Hardy; P. Nickolas). Yes, in abelian case AG (X , e), X Tychonoff and H open (Morris, Pestov). Question: Is every open subgroup H ≤ FG (X , e) a free Graev topological group? (at least for Tychonoff X ) Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Main Results Theorem 1: Every open subgroup of a free Graev topological group is a free Graev topological group. Theorem 2: Every open subgroup of a free Markov topological group is a free Markov topological group iff it is disconnected. *No separation axioms are required. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Main Results Theorem 1: Every open subgroup of a free Graev topological group is a free Graev topological group. Theorem 2: Every open subgroup of a free Markov topological group is a free Markov topological group iff it is disconnected. *No separation axioms are required. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Putting algebraic topology to work Algebraic topology: The fundamental group π1 and covering space theory provide a straightforward proof of the Nielsen-Schreier Theorem. Topology o / Algebra Extension: Use a topologically enriched version πτ1 of the fundamental group and a generalization of covering spaces (semicovering spaces). “Wild” Topology o Jeremy Brazas / Topological algebra Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Putting algebraic topology to work Algebraic topology: The fundamental group π1 and covering space theory provide a straightforward proof of the Nielsen-Schreier Theorem. Topology o / Algebra Extension: Use a topologically enriched version πτ1 of the fundamental group and a generalization of covering spaces (semicovering spaces). “Wild” Topology o Jeremy Brazas / Topological algebra Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch The Nielsen-Schreier Theorem Nielsen-Schreier Theorem: Every subgroup of a free group is free. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch The Nielsen-Schreier Theorem Nielsen-Schreier Theorem: Every subgroup of a free group is free. Lemma: The fundamental group of a graph is free. ' Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Completing the proof. Proof. S 1 , x0 W There is a covering map p : Y → A S 1 such that p∗ (π1 (Y , y0 )) = H. Suppose H ≤ F(A )= π1 W A The covering of a graph is a graph, so Y is a graph. Since Y is a graph, H π1 (Y , y0 ) is free. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Completing the proof. Proof. S 1 , x0 W There is a covering map p : Y → A S 1 such that p∗ (π1 (Y , y0 )) = H. Suppose H ≤ F(A )= π1 W A The covering of a graph is a graph, so Y is a graph. Since Y is a graph, H π1 (Y , y0 ) is free. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Completing the proof. Proof. S 1 , x0 W There is a covering map p : Y → A S 1 such that p∗ (π1 (Y , y0 )) = H. Suppose H ≤ F(A )= π1 W A The covering of a graph is a graph, so Y is a graph. Since Y is a graph, H π1 (Y , y0 ) is free. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Completing the proof. Proof. S 1 , x0 W There is a covering map p : Y → A S 1 such that p∗ (π1 (Y , y0 )) = H. Suppose H ≤ F(A )= π1 W A The covering of a graph is a graph, so Y is a graph. Since Y is a graph, H π1 (Y , y0 ) is free. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Completing the proof. Proof. S 1 , x0 W There is a covering map p : Y → A S 1 such that p∗ (π1 (Y , y0 )) = H. Suppose H ≤ F(A )= π1 W A The covering of a graph is a graph, so Y is a graph. Since Y is a graph, H π1 (Y , y0 ) is free. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Completing the proof. Proof. S 1 , x0 W There is a covering map p : Y → A S 1 such that p∗ (π1 (Y , y0 )) = H. Suppose H ≤ F(A )= π1 W A The covering of a graph is a graph, so Y is a graph. Since Y is a graph, H π1 (Y , y0 ) is free. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Topologizing π1 Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Topologizing π1 Guiding principle: If αn → α in Ω(X , x), then [αn ] → [α] in π1 (X , x). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Topologizing π1 Guiding principle: If αn → α in Ω(X , x), then [αn ] → [α] in π1 (X , x). Ω(X , x) → π1 (X , x), α 7→ [α] should be continuous. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch The quasitopological fundamental group Natural choice: Give π1 (X , x) the quotient topology with respect to Ω(X , x) → π1 (X , x) (Biss). I πqtop (X , x) is a quasitopological group (Calcut, McCarthy). 1 I πqtop (X , x) can fail to be a topological group even for Peano continua (P. Fabel). 1 I The topology of πqtop (X , x) is often complicated but can retain more local data 1 than shape invariants. A left adjoint τ : qTopGrp → TopGrp removes the “fewest number” of open sets from quasitopological G until a topological τ(G) is obtained. Let πτ1 (X , x) = τ(π1 qtop Jeremy Brazas (X , x)) Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch The quasitopological fundamental group Natural choice: Give π1 (X , x) the quotient topology with respect to Ω(X , x) → π1 (X , x) (Biss). I πqtop (X , x) is a quasitopological group (Calcut, McCarthy). 1 I πqtop (X , x) can fail to be a topological group even for Peano continua (P. Fabel). 1 I The topology of πqtop (X , x) is often complicated but can retain more local data 1 than shape invariants. A left adjoint τ : qTopGrp → TopGrp removes the “fewest number” of open sets from quasitopological G until a topological τ(G) is obtained. Let πτ1 (X , x) = τ(π1 qtop Jeremy Brazas (X , x)) Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch The quasitopological fundamental group Natural choice: Give π1 (X , x) the quotient topology with respect to Ω(X , x) → π1 (X , x) (Biss). I πqtop (X , x) is a quasitopological group (Calcut, McCarthy). 1 I πqtop (X , x) can fail to be a topological group even for Peano continua (P. Fabel). 1 I The topology of πqtop (X , x) is often complicated but can retain more local data 1 than shape invariants. A left adjoint τ : qTopGrp → TopGrp removes the “fewest number” of open sets from quasitopological G until a topological τ(G) is obtained. Let πτ1 (X , x) = τ(π1 qtop Jeremy Brazas (X , x)) Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch The quasitopological fundamental group Natural choice: Give π1 (X , x) the quotient topology with respect to Ω(X , x) → π1 (X , x) (Biss). I πqtop (X , x) is a quasitopological group (Calcut, McCarthy). 1 I πqtop (X , x) can fail to be a topological group even for Peano continua (P. Fabel). 1 I The topology of πqtop (X , x) is often complicated but can retain more local data 1 than shape invariants. A left adjoint τ : qTopGrp → TopGrp removes the “fewest number” of open sets from quasitopological G until a topological τ(G) is obtained. Let πτ1 (X , x) = τ(π1 qtop Jeremy Brazas (X , x)) Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch The quasitopological fundamental group Natural choice: Give π1 (X , x) the quotient topology with respect to Ω(X , x) → π1 (X , x) (Biss). I πqtop (X , x) is a quasitopological group (Calcut, McCarthy). 1 I πqtop (X , x) can fail to be a topological group even for Peano continua (P. Fabel). 1 I The topology of πqtop (X , x) is often complicated but can retain more local data 1 than shape invariants. A left adjoint τ : qTopGrp → TopGrp removes the “fewest number” of open sets from quasitopological G until a topological τ(G) is obtained. Let πτ1 (X , x) = τ(π1 qtop Jeremy Brazas (X , x)) Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Topological π1 Characterizations: I The topology of πτ (X , x) is the finest group topology on π1 (X , x) such 1 that Ω(X , x) → π1 (X , x) is continuous. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Topological π1 Characterizations: I The topology of πτ (X , x) is the finest group topology on π1 (X , x) such 1 that Ω(X , x) → π1 (X , x) is continuous. I Transfinite approximation by quasitopological groups Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Topological π1 Characterizations: I The topology of πτ (X , x) is the finest group topology on π1 (X , x) such 1 that Ω(X , x) → π1 (X , x) is continuous. I Transfinite approximation by quasitopological groups Utility: realizing universal topological groups I πτ (Σ(Z+ )) FM (πqtop (Z)) where Σ(Z+ ) = Z × I/Z × {0, 1} is a 1 0 generalized wedge of circles. I Topological van-Kampen theorems Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Semicovering maps Definition: A map p : Y → X is a semicovering map if I p is a local homeomorphism I Whenever f is a path or homotopy of paths starting at p(y0 ) = x0 , there is a unique lift e f starting at y0 I Each lifting function f 7→ e f is continuous on mapping spaces. Every covering map is a semicovering map but not every semicovering is a covering map. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Semicovering maps Definition: A map p : Y → X is a semicovering map if I p is a local homeomorphism I Whenever f is a path or homotopy of paths starting at p(y0 ) = x0 , there is a unique lift e f starting at y0 I Each lifting function f 7→ e f is continuous on mapping spaces. Every covering map is a semicovering map but not every semicovering is a covering map. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Semicovering maps Definition: A map p : Y → X is a semicovering map if I p is a local homeomorphism I Whenever f is a path or homotopy of paths starting at p(y0 ) = x0 , there is a unique lift e f starting at y0 I Each lifting function f 7→ e f is continuous on mapping spaces. Every covering map is a semicovering map but not every semicovering is a covering map. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Semicovering maps Definition: A map p : Y → X is a semicovering map if I p is a local homeomorphism I Whenever f is a path or homotopy of paths starting at p(y0 ) = x0 , there is a unique lift e f starting at y0 I Each lifting function f 7→ e f is continuous on mapping spaces. Every covering map is a semicovering map but not every semicovering is a covering map. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Semicovering maps Definition: A map p : Y → X is a semicovering map if I p is a local homeomorphism I Whenever f is a path or homotopy of paths starting at p(y0 ) = x0 , there is a unique lift e f starting at y0 I Each lifting function f 7→ e f is continuous on mapping spaces. Every covering map is a semicovering map but not every semicovering is a covering map. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Semicovering maps Definition: A map p : Y → X is a semicovering map if I p is a local homeomorphism I Whenever f is a path or homotopy of paths starting at p(y0 ) = x0 , there is a unique lift e f starting at y0 I Each lifting function f 7→ e f is continuous on mapping spaces. Every covering map is a semicovering map but not every semicovering is a covering map. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch A semicovering which is not a covering Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Traditional Covering Theory A covering map p : Y → X induces an injection p∗ : π1 (Y , y0 ) → π1 (X , x0 ) of groups. Let H = p∗ (π1 (Y , y0 )). Classification of covering maps: If X is locally “nice” (locally path connected, and semilocally simply connected), then there is a bijective correspondence ( ) Equivalence classes of o coverings p : Y → X Jeremy Brazas / ( Conjugacy classes of subgroups H ≤ π1 (X , x) ) Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Semicovering Space Theory A semicovering map p : Y → X induces an open embedding p∗ : πτ1 (Y , y0 ) → πτ1 (X , x0 ) of topological groups. Let H = p∗ (πτ1 (Y , y0 )). Classification of semicovering maps: If X is locally wep-connected, then there is a bijective correspondence ( ) Equivalence classes of semicoverings p : Y → X o Jeremy Brazas / ( ) Conjugacy classes of open subgroups H ≤ πτ1 (X , x) Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Top-graphs Replacement of graphs: A Top-graph Γ consists of a discrete space of vertices and an edge space Γ(x, y) for each ordered pair of vertices (x, y). Lemma: If Γ is a Top-graph, then πτ1 (Γ, x) is a free Graev topological group. Proof. Use universal constructions of topologically enriched categories and groupoids (i.e. Top-categories and Top-groupoids). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Top-graphs Replacement of graphs: A Top-graph Γ consists of a discrete space of vertices and an edge space Γ(x, y) for each ordered pair of vertices (x, y). Lemma: If Γ is a Top-graph, then πτ1 (Γ, x) is a free Graev topological group. Proof. Use universal constructions of topologically enriched categories and groupoids (i.e. Top-categories and Top-groupoids). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Top-graphs Replacement of graphs: A Top-graph Γ consists of a discrete space of vertices and an edge space Γ(x, y) for each ordered pair of vertices (x, y). Lemma: If Γ is a Top-graph, then πτ1 (Γ, x) is a free Graev topological group. Proof. Use universal constructions of topologically enriched categories and groupoids (i.e. Top-categories and Top-groupoids). Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Proof sketch Suppose H ≤ FG (X , e) is open. Find Z such that πqtop (Z) X (D. Harris) 0 The unreduced suspension Γ = SZ is a Top-graph such that πτ1 (Γ, x) = FG (X , e). There is a semicovering p : Y → Γ such that p∗ (πτ1 (Y , y)) = H. A semicovering of a Top-graph is a Top-graph, so Y is a Top-graph. Since Y is a Top-graph, p∗ : πτ1 (Y , y) H is free Graev topological. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Proof sketch Suppose H ≤ FG (X , e) is open. Find Z such that πqtop (Z) X (D. Harris) 0 The unreduced suspension Γ = SZ is a Top-graph such that πτ1 (Γ, x) = FG (X , e). There is a semicovering p : Y → Γ such that p∗ (πτ1 (Y , y)) = H. A semicovering of a Top-graph is a Top-graph, so Y is a Top-graph. Since Y is a Top-graph, p∗ : πτ1 (Y , y) H is free Graev topological. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Proof sketch Suppose H ≤ FG (X , e) is open. Find Z such that πqtop (Z) X (D. Harris) 0 The unreduced suspension Γ = SZ is a Top-graph such that πτ1 (Γ, x) = FG (X , e). There is a semicovering p : Y → Γ such that p∗ (πτ1 (Y , y)) = H. A semicovering of a Top-graph is a Top-graph, so Y is a Top-graph. Since Y is a Top-graph, p∗ : πτ1 (Y , y) H is free Graev topological. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Proof sketch Suppose H ≤ FG (X , e) is open. Find Z such that πqtop (Z) X (D. Harris) 0 The unreduced suspension Γ = SZ is a Top-graph such that πτ1 (Γ, x) = FG (X , e). There is a semicovering p : Y → Γ such that p∗ (πτ1 (Y , y)) = H. A semicovering of a Top-graph is a Top-graph, so Y is a Top-graph. Since Y is a Top-graph, p∗ : πτ1 (Y , y) H is free Graev topological. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Proof sketch Suppose H ≤ FG (X , e) is open. Find Z such that πqtop (Z) X (D. Harris) 0 The unreduced suspension Γ = SZ is a Top-graph such that πτ1 (Γ, x) = FG (X , e). There is a semicovering p : Y → Γ such that p∗ (πτ1 (Y , y)) = H. A semicovering of a Top-graph is a Top-graph, so Y is a Top-graph. Since Y is a Top-graph, p∗ : πτ1 (Y , y) H is free Graev topological. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch Proof sketch Suppose H ≤ FG (X , e) is open. Find Z such that πqtop (Z) X (D. Harris) 0 The unreduced suspension Γ = SZ is a Top-graph such that πτ1 (Γ, x) = FG (X , e). There is a semicovering p : Y → Γ such that p∗ (πτ1 (Y , y)) = H. A semicovering of a Top-graph is a Top-graph, so Y is a Top-graph. Since Y is a Top-graph, p∗ : πτ1 (Y , y) H is free Graev topological. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups Free topological groups Topological π1 Semicoverings Proof Sketch References J. Brazas, Semicoverings: A generalization of covering space theory. Homology Homotopy Appl. 14 (2012) 33-63. J. Brazas, The fundamental group as topological group. Topology Appl. 160 (2013) 170-188. J. Brazas, Open subgroups of free topological groups. Submitted. 2013. arXiv:1209.5486. R. Brown, J.P.L. Hardy, Subgroups of free topological groups and free topological products of topological groups, J. London Math. Soc. (2) 10 (1975) 431-440. P. Fabel, Multiplication is discontinuous in the Hawaiian earring group. Bull. Polish Acad. Sci. Math. 59 (2011) 7783. Graev, M.I. Free topological groups. Amer. Math. Soc. Transl. 8 (1962) 305-365. Markov, A.A. On free topological groups. Izv. Akad. Nauk. SSSR Ser. Mat. 9 (1945) 3-64. S.A. Morris, V.G. Pestov, Open subgroups of free abelian topological groups. Math. Proc. Camb. Phil. Soc. 114 (1993) 439-442. P. Nickolas, A Schreier theorem for free topological groups, Bulletin of the Australian Math. Soc. 13 (1975) 121–127. O. Schreier, Die Untergruppen der freien Gruppen, Abh. Mat Sem. Univ. Hamburg 3 (1927) 167-169. Jeremy Brazas Open subgroups of free topological groups