Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Hybrid Imaging with PET/CT and with PET/CT and SPECT/CT SPECT/CT: : Improving Improving Therapeutic Decisions Therapeutic Decisions American College of Osteopathic Internists g p October 14, 2011 San Antonio, Texas Aaron C. Jessop, MD Assistant Professor Department of Nuclear Medicine UT MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston, Texas EARLY PET EARLY PET 11C-glucose C glucose ACOI 2 0 1 1 Courtesy of R.E. Coleman Early CT Early CT ACOI 2 0 1 1 Complimentary role of Anatomical & Molecular Imaging • Anatomical imaging (CT or MRI): best imaging modalities to evaluate the relationship between organs and vascular structures. structures • SPECT SPECT and PET: provide functional images but lack and PET: provide functional images but lack anatomical landmarks for accurate localization. • Optimal interpretation and localization is obtained when both are interpreted in conjunction with each other. ACOI 2 0 1 1 Correlation of Anatomical and Functional IImages mages • Visual correlation • Fusion of images obtained separately using registration software g – Straightforward for rigid structures (e.g. brain) – Problems with non‐rigid structures (e.g. body) • Breath‐hold versus breathing • Internal motion of organs • Position of the patient on the imaging table • Integrated imaging systems I di i – SPECT/CT – PET/CT ACOI 2 0 1 1 Integrated PET/CT Imaging System Benefit of the combined technique: q 1) Attenuation correction with CT 2) Anatomical localization PET CT Attenuation Att ti Correction Anatomical localization • 62 year old male 62 year‐old male – Two weeks of abdominal pain abdominal pain – CT abdomen • Retroperitoneal Retroperitoneal adenopathy • Hepatic steatosis ACOI 2 0 1 1 • 62 year old male 62 year‐old male – Two weeks of abdominal pain abdominal pain – CT abdomen • Retroperitoneal Retroperitoneal adenopathy • Hepatic steatosis ACOI 2 0 1 1 Retroperitoneal node biopsy: Metastatic Pancreatic Adenocarcinoma FDG PET and PET/CT: Impact on Management FDG PET and PET/CT: Impact on Management g y • Diagnostic Accuracy – FDG PET: superior diagnostic accuracy than conventional imaging for staging and restaging FDG‐avid imaging for staging and restaging FDG avid malignancies malignancies – PET/CT: incremental impact on diagnostic accuracy: 40‐50% 40 50% patients – Discriminating metastatic from physiologic foci – Improving lesions detection on both PET and CT – Precise localization of metastatic foci P i l li ti f t t ti f i ACOI 2 0 1 1 Supplement to JNM;2001:42: May 2001, Guest editor: Sajiv Supplement to JNM;2001:42: May 2001, Guest editor: Sajiv S. S. Gambhir Gambhir Supplement to JNM;2004;45: January 2004, Guest editor: Johannes Czernin Supplement to JNM;2004;45: January 2004, Guest editor: Johannes Czernin FDG PET and PET/CT: Impact on Management FDG PET and PET/CT: Impact on Management p g • Impact on Management: – FDG PET: ~30% patients (range 10%‐60%) – PET/CT: incremental impact on Patient’s management: 10‐20% patients, including – Planning radiation therapy Planning radiation therapy – Guiding biopsies. ACOI 2 0 1 1 Supplement to JNM;2001:42: May 2001, Guest editor: Sajiv Supplement to JNM;2001:42: May 2001, Guest editor: Sajiv S. S. Gambhir Gambhir Supplement to JNM;2004;45: January 2004, Guest editor: Johannes Czernin Supplement to JNM;2004;45: January 2004, Guest editor: Johannes Czernin FDG PET and PET/CT: Impact on Management FDG PET and PET/CT: Impact on Management Disease Process Author Year # patients Mixed tumors Bar-Shalom 2003 204 Modality Compariso n Change of management FDG PET/CT PET alone 14% 10 Mixed tumors Roman 11 2005 173 FDG PET/CT PET alone 12.5% Mixed tumors Hillner 12 (NOPR) 2008 22,975 , FDG PET (16%) PET/CT (84%) Referringg physician questionnair e 36.5% ACOI 2 0 1 1 Delbeke D et al. Semin Delbeke D et al. Semin Nucl Med 2009;39(3): 308‐ Med 2009;39(3): 308‐40. NOPR: National Oncologic PET Registry A Nationwide (US) Collaborative Program: 2006‐2008 • Nationwide prospective registry • Goal: – Evaluate the impact of PET on physicians plans of patient management patient management • Providers: – Pre‐PET and post‐PET physician questionnaires • condition for reimbursement ACOI 2 0 1 1 NOPR: Results Overall Impact on Patient Management – Diagnosis Diagnosis, Staging, Restaging, Recurrence Staging Restaging Recurrence – Data on 22,975 scans from May 8, 2006 – May 7, 2007 – J Clin Oncol 2008; 26:2155‐61 Impact on Patient Management by Cancer Type – Staging, Restaging, Recurrence (proven cancer type) – Data on 40,863 scans from May 8, 2006 – May 7, 2008 – J Nucl Med 2008; 49:1928‐35 J Nucl Med 2008; 49:1928‐35 Treatment Monitoring – Data on 10,447 scans from May 8, 2006 Data on 10 447 scans from May 8 2006 – Dec 31, 2007 Dec 31 2007 – Cancer, published on‐line Nov 17, 2008 NOPR: Cohort Profile • First year of NOPR (5/8/06 to 5/7/07) • 22,975 “consented” cases from 1,519 facilities • Technology profile – 84% PET/CT – 71% non non--hospital – 76% fixed sites • Indications – – – – Diagnosis 24% Initial Staging 28% Restaging 24% Recurrence 24% Hillner et al., J Clin Oncol 2008;26 (13):2155‐61. NOPR: National Oncologic PET Registry Clinical Indication for PET Study (%) Pre-Pet PrePlan Post-PET PostPlan Treat Dx Staging Restaging Recurrence All n=5,616 n=6,464 n=5,607 n=5,388 n=22,975 Same 16.0 46.5 15.8 20.4 25.5 Non--Treat Non Same 52.9 14.0 48.0 40.7 37.9 Non--Treat Non Treat 23.2 31.6 28.6 29.2 28.3 Treat Non--Treat Non 7.9 7.9 7.5 9.7 8.2 31.1 31 1 39.5 39 5 36.1 36 1 39.0 39 0 36.5 36 5 Patients with change g post--PET (%) post PET Changed Intended Management in 36 36.5% 5% of Cases Hillner et al., J et al., J Clin Clin Oncol 2008;26 (13):2155‐ 2008;26 (13):2155‐61. Hillner et al., J et al., J Clin Clin Oncol 2008;26 (13):2155‐ 2008;26 (13):2155‐61. NOPR: PET Impact on Management by Cancer type (Overall: 38%) Impact of PET on intended management in the top 10 cancers in the NOPR Cancer No of % change in No. scans intended treatment % imagingimagingadjusted impact Prostate 5,309 35.1 15.0 Ovary 4,509 41.4 16.2 Bladder 3,578 37.9 15.4 Pancreas a c eas 3,314 3,3 39.0 39 0 14.8 8 Stomach 3,025 36.9 14.5 Small--cell lung Small 2,983 41.2 13.1 Kidney 2 877 2,877 35.8 35 8 16.0 16 0 Uterus 2,869 36.5 15.1 Myeloma 1,784 48.7 11.5 Connective Tissue 1,350 36.4 13.6 Hillner B et al. J Nucl Med 2008;49 (12):1928(12):1928-35 Summary Table of Medicare Coverage Policy (US) for FDG PET/CT as of April 2009 Cancer Type Initial Treatment Strategy Evaluation Subsequent Treatment Strategy Evaluation Breast Covered 1 Covered Cervix Covered 2/ CED Covered Colorectal Covered Covered Esophagus Covered Covered Head Neck Covered Covered Lymphoma Covered Covered Melanoma Covered 3 Covered Myeloma Covered Covered NSCLC Covered Covered Ovary Covered Covered Prostate NC CED Thyroid Covered Covered 4/CED All other solid tumors Covered CED 63‐year 63‐ year‐‐old male with newly with newly diagnosed lung ca From Delbeke From Delbeke D. Diagnostic Imaging 2003 Lung Cancer (NSCLC): Initial Staging The PLUS Multicenter Randomized Trial The PLUS Multicenter Randomized Trial • 188 patients from 9 hospitals were randomized to – Conventional work‐up (CWU) – CWU + PET • End point: futile (unnecessary) thoracotomy • Results – CWU: 41% futile thoracotomy – CWU + PET: 21% futile thoracotomy Decrease in unnecessary surgery by 50% ACOI 2 0 1 1 Van Tinteren Van Tinteren H et al. Lancet 2002;359 (9315):1388‐ H et al. Lancet 2002;359 (9315):1388‐1393. Lung Cancer PET/CT f R di ti T t t Pl i PET/CT for Radiation Treatment Planning • Change TNM stage: 25‐30% • Change treatment from curative to palliative: 10‐25% • Increase GTV: LN not meeting size criteria g • Decrease GTV: atelectasis, post‐obstructive pneumonia ACOI 2 0 1 1 Delbeke D et al. Semin Nucl Med 2009;39(3): 308308-40. 92 year‐old woman with NSCLC underwent PET/CT 92 year‐ old woman with NSCLC underwent PET/CT for radiation for radiation therapy planning From Spratt DE et al. Clin From Spratt DE et al. Clin Nucl Med 2010;35:237‐ Med 2010;35:237‐243. NOPR: Change During g in Intended Management g g Treatment • 8,240 patients who had 10,497 treatment 8 240 ti t h h d 10 497 t t t monitoring PET scans at 946 centers – Chemotherapy alone 82% – Radiation therapy alone 6% – Combination 12% • Metastatic disease in 54% of scans • Type of cancer: 37% of patients had ovarian, pancreatic or lung cancers p g ACOI 2 0 1 1 Hillner B et al. Cancer B et al. Cancer 2009 2009;;115 115 ((2):410 ):410‐‐18 18,, NOPR: Change During g in Intended Management g g Treatment • 8,240 patients who had 10,497 treatment monitoring PET scans at 946 centers t 946 t • If PET was not available, intended management : – Other imaging 53% – Ongoing treatment 41% – Biopsy or watching 6% • Post‐ PET intended management: – Switching to another therapy: 26‐28% of scans – Adjusting of dose or duration of therapy: 16‐19% of scans Adjusting of dose or duration of therapy 16 19% of scans – Switch to palliative care: 6% • PET enabled 91% of patients to avoid future tests PET enabled 91% of patients to avoid future tests ACOI 2 0 1 1 Hillner B et al. Cancer 2009;115 (2):410 B et al. Cancer 2009;115 (2):410‐‐18. FDG PET/CT for Breast Cancer • A 40 Year old female with stage IV breast A 40 Year‐old female with stage IV breast cancer – Pulmonary Pulmonary and Skeletal Metastases and Skeletal Metastases – Systemic therapy – Progression of skeletal metastases noted on Progression of skeletal metastases noted on PET/CT – Therapy changed to include capecitabine Therapy changed to include capecitabine – Repeat PET/CT following two cycles of chemotherapy ACOI 2 0 1 1 Prior to Change in Therapy: Following Change in Therapy: 1/46 CT FDG PET/CT for Breast Cancer • A 40 Year old female with stage IV breast A 40 Year‐old female with stage IV breast cancer PET/CT ACOI 2 0 1 1 FDG PET/CT for Breast Cancer • Initial staging – Early breast cancer: Sentinel node biopsy is standard of care – Locally advanced breast: • Increased risk for distant metastases • Inner quadrant lesions (internal mammary LN ~ 25%*) – Technically difficult or Positive SLNB (?) – Equivocal lesions by other modalities • Restaging – To replace multiple modalities • Monitoring chemotherapy of locally advanced disease – Identify non‐responders early. ACOI 2 0 1 1 Eubank BE et al. Semin Nucl Med 2005;35:84‐ Eubank BE et al. Semin Med 2005;35:84‐99. *Bellon JR et al. Am J JR et al. Am J Clin Clin Oncol 2004;27 (4):407‐ 2004;27 (4):407‐410. PET/CT Imaging: Impact on Management B C Breast Cancer Disease Process Author Year # patients Modality Comparison Change of management Breast cancer Breast cancer Radan 75 2006 Suspected Suspected Recurrence FDG PET/CT FDG PET/CT Contrasted Contrasted CT 51% Breast cancer Breast cancer Heron 80 Heron 2006 simulation FDG PET/CT FDG PET/CT Radiation Radiation therapy planning (simulation) 50% ACOI 2 0 1 1 Delbeke D et al. Semin Delbeke D et al. Semin Nucl Med 2009;39(3): 308‐ Med 2009;39(3): 308‐40. PET/CT for Brain Imaging PET/CT for Brain Imaging old male • 41 year 41 year‐old male – – – – HIV positive Presented to emergency department New onset neurological symptoms Fever • MRI of Brain ACOI 2 0 1 1 Axial FLAIR Axial T1‐wt p Gd PET/CT for Brain Imaging PET/CT for Brain Imaging • 18F‐FDG PET/CT – Relative decreased metabolism in left basal ganlgia – Corresponds to ring‐enhancing lesion on MRI Toxoplasmosis abscess of the brain Toxoplasmosis abscess of the brain ACOI 2 0 1 1 PET/CT for Brain Imaging PET/CT for Brain Imaging • Toxoplasmosis – – – – Intracellular protozoan parasite Toxoplasma gondii Seroprevalence = 15% US, 50% Europe Usually asymptomatic in immunocompetent hosts Toxoplasmic encephalitis: 2.2 per 1000 person years (HIV patients) ACOI 2 0 1 1 PET/CT for Brain Imaging PET/CT for Brain Imaging • Toxoplasmosis of the Brain Toxoplasmosis of the Brain – HIV patients at higher risk for opportunistic infections and lymphoma – Toxoplasmosis and lymphoma may appear similar on MRI – Accurate diagnosis required promptly – 18F‐FDG PET/CT • Lymphoma: HOT Lymphoma: HOT • Toxoplasmosis: NOT ACOI 2 0 1 1 CNS Lymphoma CNS Lymphoma T1‐wt p Gd 18F‐FDG PET/CT Toxoplasma gondii PET/CT for Brain Imaging PET/CT for Brain Imaging – Clinical Course • Prompt initiation of anti‐ toxoplasmosis therapy • Rapid clinical improvement 8 week follow‐up MRI 8 week follow up MRI ACOI 2 0 1 1 Hybrid SPECT/CT Imaging System Integrated system provides: O ti l attenuation Optimal tt ti correction ti Fusion images for anatomical mapping Clinical Applications for Hybrid SPECT/CT – Clinical Indications: • Cardiac attenuation correction • Neoplasms – Thyroid carcinoma (131I‐iodide) – Parathyroid adenoma ( y (99mTc‐MIBI) ) – Somatostatin receptor‐positive tumors (111In‐Octreotide) – Pheochromocytoma/Neuroblastoma (I‐MIBG) – Hemangioma (99mTc‐RBC) – Focal nodular hyperplasia ( Focal nodular hyperplasia (99mTc Tc‐sulfur sulfur colloid) colloid) – Splenosis – Sentinel node localization – Lymphoma (67Ga) – Prostate carcinoma ( Prostate carcinoma (111In‐Prostascint) In Prostascint) – Skeletal (99mTc‐MDP) • Infection (111In‐ and 99mTc‐WBC and 67Ga) • Bone trauma (99mTc‐MDP) ACOI 2 0 1 1 Keidar Z et al. Semin Z et al. Semin Nucl Med 2003;XXXIII (3):205‐ Med 2003;XXXIII (3):205‐218 Buch AK et al. J Nucl AK et al. J Nucl Med 2008;49 (9): 1407. Thyroid Carcinoma with 131I‐SPECT/CT • Review of 71 patients – Vanderbilt: n = 39, Rambam Vanderbilt: n = 39 Rambam Medical Center: n =32 Medical Center: n =32 – Post‐therapy: n = 54, Diagnostic scintigraphy: n = 17 • Incremental Diagnostic Value of 131I‐SPECT‐CT over planar imaging i 57% f ti t in 57% of patients: • Precise localization – In the neck: 21% of patients – To the skeleton: 17% of patients p • Characterization as physiologic or benign: 13% • Incremental clinical value: Impact on therapy: – Impact on therapy: • Surgery versus 131I‐therapy • Dose for 131I‐therapy – Impact on prognosis ACOI 2 0 1 1 Tharp K et al. Tharp K et al. Europ Europ J J Nucl Nucl Med 2004;31 (10):1435‐ Med 2004;31 (10):1435‐1442. A 60‐ year A 60‐ year‐‐old female s/p total thyroidectomy for papillary thyroid carcinoma was evaluated for metastases .. metastases Diagnosis: Probable metastases in the neck and left femur Diagnosis: Probable metastases in the neck and left femur. A bone radiograph of the left femur was normal A 60‐ year A 60‐ year‐‐old female s/p total thyroidectomy for papillary thyroid carcinoma was evaluated for i l df metastases .. metastases Diagnosis: Metastases in the neck and precisely localized in the left femur on the SPECT/CT images. Integrated CT 131I SPECT Fusion integrated SPECT/CT • A 53 year‐old male with papillary thyroid carcinoma ill th id i – Stage II, T2 Nx Mx • 123I scintigraphy I scintigraphy prior to prior to radioactive iodine therapy therapy 1/24 ACOI 2 0 1 1 • A 53 year‐old male with papillary thyroid ill th id carcinoma • Unsuspected Unsuspected pulmonary pulmonary metastasis on 123I SPECT/CT • Changed management by altering planned therapeutic dose of 131I ACOI 2 0 1 1 • Post therapy Post‐therapy 131I scintigraphy ACOI 2 0 1 1 99mTc Parathyroid Adenoma with Tc‐‐MIBI MIBI‐‐SPECT/CT y / g pp • Modification of Surgical Approach – 36 patients with primary hyperparathyroidism – Impact on management of 39% patients Impact on management of 39% patients • Retrotracheal parathyroid glands p p y • Ectopic parathyroid adenoma • Distorded neck anatomy ACOI 2 0 1 1 Krausz Y et al. World J Surg Y et al. World J Surg 2006;30:76 2006;30:76‐‐80 99mTc Parathyroid Adenoma with Tc‐‐MIBI MIBI‐‐SPECT/CT y / y • A 75 year‐old male with primary hyperparathyroidism – Serum Calcium: 10.4 mg/dL Serum Calcium: 10.4 mg/dL – PTH: 142 pg/mL Early Delayed ACOI 2 0 1 1 Krausz Y et al. World J Surg Y et al. World J Surg 2006;30:76 2006;30:76‐‐80 A 53‐year A 53‐ year‐‐old male with old male with hyperparathyroidism: hyperparathyroidism: the fusion SPECT/CT image allowed precise the fusion SPECT/CT image allowed precise localization of the focus of uptake in the left localization of the focus of uptake in the left mediastinum mediastinum. Brown . Brown tumors tumors are also seen in are also seen in the ribs. Integrated CT 99mTc Tc‐‐MIBI SPECT Fusion integrated SPECT/CT Neuroendocrine Tumors with SPECT/CT Tumors with SPECT/CT • 54 patients with known or suspected neuroendocrine tumors – 111In‐octreoscan: n = 43 – 123I‐MIBG: n=11 – High‐end spiral CT with contrast: n=54 • Comparison SPECT and high‐end CT for 120 lesions Comparison SPECT and high end CT for 120 lesions – Histopathology or follow‐up for 114 lesions – Concordance: 49% of lesions – Discordance: 51% of lesions ACOI 2 0 1 1 Pfannenberg AC et al. Europ AC et al. Europ J J Nucl Nucl Med 2003;30:835‐ Med 2003;30:835‐843. Neuroendocrine Tumors with SPECT/CT Tumors with SPECT/CT • Value of fusion images for discordant lesions: – 31 equivocal or benign ‐> malignant – 27 equivocal or malignant ‐>benign – Highest accuracy (99%) by combined analysis SPECT and high Highest accuracy (99%) by combined analysis SPECT and high‐ end CT. • Impact on therapy of image fusion: 28% (14/50) patients Impact on therapy of image fusion: 28% (14/50) patients – Sparing of unnecessary surgery (n =8) • Benign (n = 5), metastases (n = 3) – Surgical approach changed (n = 4) – Medical treatment changed (n = 2) ACOI 2 0 1 1 Pfannenberg AC et al. Europ AC et al. Europ J J Nucl Nucl Med 2003;30:835‐ Med 2003;30:835‐843. A 39 year A 39 year‐‐old male with suspected pancreatic old male with suspected pancreatic neuroendocrine neuroendocrine tumor. 111In‐Octreotide 4 hours 24 hours A 39 year A 39 year‐‐old male with suspected pancreatic old male with suspected pancreatic neuroendocrine neuroendocrine tumor. 111In‐Octreotide 24 hour SPECT 1/30 A 39 year A 39 year‐‐old male with suspected pancreatic old male with suspected pancreatic neuroendocrine neuroendocrine tumor. 111In‐Octrotide SPECT/CT CT with contrast Pathology: Well‐differentiated/intermediate grade pancreatic Pathology: Well‐ endocrine neoplasm measuring 2.4 X 2.4 X 2.0 cm. A 71‐year A 71‐ year‐‐old female who had recent resection of a rectal polyp with carcinoid old female who had recent resection of a rectal polyp with carcinoid presented with a 1 cm LN in the mesorectum presented with a 1 cm LN in the mesorectum Transrectal exploration: negative Surgical exploration: metastatic lymph node Sentinel Node Localization with SPECT/CT Sentinel Node Localization with SPECT/CT p ( • 34 patients with sentinel LN localization (28 melanoma and 6 SCC of head and neck) / g g • SPECT/CT imaging identified: – Multiple draining basins in: • 50% (6/12) of patients with trunk melanoma • 33% (3/9) of patients with head and neck SCC – Sentinel LN missed on planar images in 43% (9/21) of patients, two of which were involved by tumors: • Three located close to injection site Three located close to injection site • Two in‐transit LN • Fourth in an additional basin ACOI 2 0 1 1 Even‐‐Sapir E et al. J Even Sapir E et al. J Nucl Nucl Med 2003;44:1413‐ Med 2003;44:1413‐1420. A 42 year‐‐old male with a right parietal scalp melanoma referred A 42 year old male with a right parietal scalp melanoma referred for sentinel node localization g g Planar images show migration inferior to the right ear. SPECT/CT localize the sentinel node node in the posterior triangle in node in the posterior in the posterior triangle in triangle in the right occipital chain ACOI 2 0 1 1 From Delbeke D & Israel O (eds From Delbeke D & Israel O (eds): Hybrid PET/CT and ): Hybrid PET/CT and SPECT/CT Imaging –– A Teaching File. Springer SPECT/CT Imaging A Teaching File. Springer 2009 2009.. A 52 year A 52 year‐‐old male with Clark level IV invasive melanoma of the mid‐‐upper back mid pp ACOI 2 0 1 1 A 52 year A 52 year‐‐old male with Clark level IV invasive melanoma of the mid‐‐upper back mid pp • Pathology: – 1 left posterior cervical node: metastatic melanoma – 5 left axillary nodes (3/5 hot): negative – 2 right axillary nodes (1/2 hot): negative 2 right axillary nodes (1/2 hot): negative ACOI 2 0 1 1 A 73 year A A 73 year‐‐old male with prostate cancer ‐ old male with prostate cancer ‐ elevated PSA following prostatectomy p y ACOI 2 0 1 1 A 73 year A A 73 year‐‐old male with prostate cancer ‐ old male with prostate cancer ‐ elevated PSA following prostatectomy p y ACOI 2 0 1 1 L5 metastasis In Summary In Summary • Hybrid PET/CT and SPECT/CT Hybrid PET/CT and SPECT/CT – Incremental diagnostic value over: • PET or SPECT alone PET or SPECT alone • PET or SPECT correlated with separate CT ACOI 2 0 1 1 In Summary In Summary • Hybrid PET/CT and SPECT/CT Hybrid PET/CT and SPECT/CT – Improved lesion detection – Precise lesion localization Precise lesion localization – Differentiation of physiologic from pathologic uptake ACOI 2 0 1 1 In Summary In Summary • Hybrid PET/CT and SPECT/CT Hybrid PET/CT and SPECT/CT – Affect clinical management by: • Guiding further procedures Guiding further procedures • Excluding the need for further procedures • Changing inter‐ g g and intramodalityy therapy py • Providing prognostic information ACOI 2 0 1 1