Download Ch 5. Efficiency and Equity

Ch. 5: EFFICIENCY AND EQUITY





Allocative Efficiency
Consumer surplus
Producer surplus
Market failures.
Corrections for market failure.
Efficiency and the Social Interest
Allocative efficiency
 occurs when it is not possible to produce
more of a good or service without giving up
some other good or service that is valued
more highly.
 depends on people’s preferences.
Allocative Efficiency
• Marginal Benefit
 the benefit a person receives from
consuming one more unit of a good or
service.
 the dollar value of other goods and services
that a person is willing to give up to get one
more unit of it.
 decreasing marginal benefit implies that as
more of a good or service is consumed, its
marginal benefit decreases.
Allocative Efficiency
• For any given price, a
consumer will buy all
units of the good where
MB>P
• The MB curve will be
identical to the
consumer’s demand
curve.
• Market demand curve is
summation of individual
MB curves
P
MB
Q
Allocative Efficiency
• Marginal Cost
 the opportunity cost of producing one more
unit of a good or service.
 the dollar value of other goods and services
required to produce one more unit of the
good.
 increasing marginal cost implies that as more
of a good or service is produced, its marginal
cost increases.
Allocative Efficiency
 The MC curve is
upward sloping.
 A firm will produce
all units of a product
where P>MC
 The MC curve is the
firm’s supply curve
(more details later).
MC
P
Q
Allocative Efficiency
• Efficiency and Inefficiency
– If MB>MC, should produce and consume more of the
good.
– If MB<MC, should produce and consume less of the
good.
– If MB=MC, allocative efficiency obtained.
MC
MB
Q*
Quantity
Value, Price, and Consumer Surplus
• Consumer Surplus
– Difference between maximum amount
consumers are willing to pay and the price of
a good.
– Measured by the area under the demand
curve (marginal benefit curve) and above the
price paid, up to the quantity bought.
Value, Price, and Consumer
Surplus
Cost, Price, and Producer
Surplus
• Producer Surplus
– the price of a good minus the marginal cost of
producing it, summed over the quantity sold.
– measured by the area below the price and
above the supply curve, up to the quantity
sold.
Cost, Price, and Producer
Surplus
Suppose that John is willing to sell his Bengals
football ticket for anything above $10 and Mary is
willing to pay up to $50 for a ticket. If John sells
Mary the ticket for $25, the consumers surplus is
____ and the producers surplus is _____.
a)
b)
c)
d)
$0; $25
$15; $25
$25; $15
$25; 0
25%
25%
25%
$15; $25
$25; $15
0%
$0; $25
25%
30
$25; 0
Is the Competitive Market Efficient?
At the equilibrium
quantity,
– MB=MC, so the
quantity is the
allocatively efficient
quantity.
– The sum of consumer
and producer surplus
is maximized at this
efficient level of
output.
Deadweight loss from overproduction.
Deadweight loss from underproduction.
What are the additional costs to producers of increasing
pizza production from 5,000 to 10,000 per day? (keep in
mind that quantity is measured in 1000s in the diagram
below).
0%
30
What are the additional benefits to consumers of
increasing pizza production from 5,000 to 10,000
per day?
0%
30
If pizza production is at 5,000 the benefits to
society of one additional pizza would be
______ than the cost of one additional
pizza.
a)
b)
c)
d)
$5 greater than
$10 greater than
$5 less than
$10 less than
25%
25%
25%
0%
$5 greater
tha...
$10 greater
th...
$5 less than
25%
30
$10 less than
If the economy is producing more than the
allocatively efficient amount of a good, the MB of
additional production will exceed the MC of
additional production.
50%
50%
0%
se
Fa
l
Tr
ue
a) True
b) False
30
If the MC of additional production of a good is
greater than the MB of additional production,
production must be greater than the allocatively
efficient level.
50%
50%
0%
se
Fa
l
Tr
ue
a) True
b) False
30
Obstacles to Efficiency





Externalities
Price ceilings and floors
Taxes, subsidies, and quotas.
Monopoly
Public goods and common resources
Externalities
When there are negative externalities:
• Social MC = Private MC + per unit negative externality
When there are positive externalities:
• Social MB = Private MB + per unit positive externality
• Regardless of whether there are externalities, in a
competitive market:
 Supply = Private MC
 Demand = Private MB
Is the Competitive Market
Efficient?
When there are
negative externalities,
• SMC>PMC
deadweight loss
•The market produces
“too much”
S=PMC
neg externality
•deadweight loss
results
•Taxes could “fix”
market.
SMC
D=PMB=SMB
Q
efficient
Qmarket
Is the Competitive Market
Efficient?
When there are positive
externalities,
deadweight loss
S=PMC=SMC
• SMB>PMB
•The market produces
“too little”
•deadweight loss
results
•Subsidies could “fix”
market.
SMB
D=PMB
pos ext.
Q market Q efficient
If second hand smoke represents a “cost” on nonsmokers and there is no government intervention
in the cigarette market, the market outcome will
result in:
50%
50%
n
st
ha
Le
s
or
e
M
0%
th
a
n
th
e
th
e
...
...
a) More than the allocatively
efficient amount of cigarette
smoking.
b) Less than the allocatively
efficient amount of cigarette
smoking.
30
If there is a positive externality associated with tree
planting, the market outcome would result in (more, less)
than the allocatively efficient amount of trees and
government could fix this problem by (taxing, subsidizing)
25% 25% 25% 25%
tree planting).
iz.
..
ub
sid
g.
ax
in
s;
t
Le
ss
;s
M
or
e
;s
ub
;t
or
e
M
0%
Le
s
sid
iz .
..
More; taxing.
More; subsidizing.
Less; taxing.
Less; subsidizing.
ax
in
g.
a)
b)
c)
d)
30
Is the Competitive Market Fair?
Ideas about fairness can be divided into two
groups:
 It’s not fair if the result isn’t fair
 It’s not fair if the rules aren’t fair
Is the Competitive Market Fair?
It’s not fair if the result isn’t fair
 Utilitarianism:
• Maximize happiness by distributing income equally
– Since MB of income falls with income, can
increase happiness by taking from rich and
giving to poor
– Ignores inefficiencies created by income
redistribution (equity – efficiency trade-off)
Is the Competitive Market Fair?
• It’s Not Fair If the Rules Aren’t Fair
 Symmetry principle: the requirement that
people in similar situations be treated
similarly.
 Equality of opportunity, not equality of
income.
• The state must create and enforce laws that
establish and protect private property.
• Private property may be transferred from one
person to another only by voluntary exchange.