Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Tourism Development Promotes Co2 Emissions In Asia Pacific Countries: Panel Granger Analysis TOURISM DEVELOPMENT PROMOTES CO2 EMISSIONS IN ASIA PACIFIC COUNTRIES: PANEL GRANGER CAUSALITY TEST BAHRAM SHAKOURI Assistant Professor Department of EconomicsCollege of Law, Political Science & Economics Islamic Azad University, South Tehran Branch, Tehran, IranNo.223 ،North iranshahr St, Tehran, Tehran, Iran Email: [email protected] Abstract: This study examines the influence of tourism and economic growth on CO2 emissions; using panel data of selected Asia Pacific countries for 1995-2013 are performed to examine the long-run relationship between economic growth, tourism, energy consumption and CO2 emissions through testing Environmental Kuznets Curve hypothesis. Tourist arrivals have significant positive effects on carbon dioxide emission levels in long- run. The results of the Granger causality tests reveal that there is unidirectional causality from energy consumption to tourism arrivals and unidirectional causality from CO2 emissions to tourism arrivals for Asia Pacific countries. Keywords: CO2 Emissions, Economic Growth, Panel Granger Causality Test, Tourism Arrivals, Asia Pacific. 1. (CO2) emissions. However, the relationship of energy and climate change with segments or sectors of the economy deserves attention. One such sector is that of international tourism. Development in international tourism and an increase in the number of international tourists not only contribute to a country's economy but also lead to an increase in energy consumption. However, tourism development is also likely to make changes in climate through various channels; such as, an increase in tourism activities comes with increased energy demand in various functions which is also likely to lead to environmental degradation and pollution. Participating in a global market has consequences for a country’s economic evolution, both for the value of the output produced and the resulting consumption. The question here is whether the economic growth and social and environmental indicators improve over time or if they decrease. Recently, CO2 emissions levels have been growing at varying degrees throughout the Asia Pacific Environmental issues are complex in nature and transcend national boundaries. Yet it would be right to expect that tourism development could have a positive impact on carbon emission level through energy expansion. It is obvious that growth of carbon emissions is likely to occur as a result of tourism development, through the construction of hotels and tourist facilities as well as other aspects of tourism. To our knowledge, this paper examines the causal link between CO2 emissions, economic growth, energy consumption, international tourist arrivals and financial development in Asia pacific for the period 1995-2013. Section 2 investigates the literature, Section 3 introduces the data and methodology; Section 4 presents the empirical results and discussion, and Section 5 concludes the study. INTRODUCTION Tourism is a rapidly growing phenomenon and has become one of the most important industries in the world. The impact of tourism is extremely varied. In some cases, it may contribute to a broader cultural understanding by creating awareness, respecting the diversity of cultures and lifestyles. Meanwhile, complaints from tourist destinations concerning massive negative impacts on the environment, culture and residents 'ways resulted in a demand for more sustainable development in tourism [1]. In the 21st century, the globalization of capitalism, the movement of populations and advances in transportation and communications technology have helped develop the travel and tourism sector into one of the largest in the world. Tourism has made a significant contribution to the economy of many communities around the world because world due to its ability to create income, taxes, hard currency and employment [2]. Tourism development can have both positive and negative impacts on destinations. Sustainable tourism development is trying to find a balance between these effects to create a better quality of life for the host community and the destination. The World Commission on Economic Development (WCED) describes sustainable development as "development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs [3]. The connection between tourism and climate change are associated with energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, and pollution.There have been many attempts in the energy saving literature to determine the link between energy, environmental degradation or pollution, and economic growth. Climate change is considered as one of the proxies for environmental degradation in the literature, and climate change has also been widely proxies by carbon dioxide 1 Tourism Development Promotes Co2 Emissions In Asia Pacific Countries: Panel Granger Analysis 2. growth, renewable energy and tourism arrivals. Using panel data for the period 1995-2010, the econometric results showed that renewable energy and tourist arrivals have a negative impact on CO2 emissions. They indicated that the tourism arrivals contribute to carbon reduction in the long-run. Katircioglu et al. [10] applied Granger causality, unit root, and ARDL by using international tourism, energy consumption, and carbon dioxide emissions for the period 1979-2009 in Cyprus. The study concluded that there was causality between tourism, energy use and carbon dioxide emissions. However, by the assumptions Environmental Kuznets Curve (EKC) the tourist arrivals may contribute to reduction in carbon dioxide emissions in the long-run. Tourists prefer places, where pollution tends to decrease. Al- Mulali et al. [11] studied the relation between tourism arrivals, and CO2 emissions in the transport sector. The authors utilized a panel data with cointegration analysis. They selected five regions (Africa; Middle East; The Americas; Asia and Pacific and Europe). Considering as explanatory variables tourism arrivals, energy consumption, and urban population, the econometric results showed that these variables have a positive impact on CO2 emissions, with exception tourism demand is not statistically significant in Europe. Solarin [12] investigated income per capita, tourism arrivals, energy consumption, urban population and carbon dioxide emissions in Malaysia for the period 1972-2010. He used a multivariate model (unit root test, ARDL, and Granger causality). When the author applied DOLS model, the results demonstrated that there is a positive correlation between tourism arrivals and carbon dioxide emissions. LITERATURE REVIEW The literature review section summarizes and pulls together the relevant documentation in relation to the objectives of the paper as stated above. Besides the influence of tourism on economic growth, energy consumption, financial development and CO2 emissions are included. Davies and Cahill [4] mentioned that there are three categories for the environmental impact of tourism, including: (i) direct impacts, including impacts of the travel to a destination, the tourist activities in and of themselves to this destination, such as hiking or boating, and from the creation, operation and maintenance of facilities that cater to the tourist; (ii) "upstream" impacts, resulting from service providers "ability to influence suppliers; and "downstream" impacts, where service providers can influence the behavior or consumption patterns of custom. Nepal [5] studied international tourism as one of the major energy-consuming sectors in South Africa. He indicated that the transportation sector, especially air transportation, is responsible for the majority of energy consumption and emissions resultant resulting activities related to international tourism. The existing literature of energy economics generally focused on the link among economic growth, energy, and carbon emissions (as a proxy of environmental pollution). He found that primary energy sources include wood and kerosene, but the use of renewable energy and locally developed energy-saving technologies increases in the tourism sector. The United Nations World Tourism Organization [6] estimated the global tourismrelated CO2 emissions for about 5 percent of total global emissions. Most of these emissions are generated by the transport of tourists, especially air travel. Thus, the contribution of the tourism sector to climate change is on a global level and is substantial. Scott et al. [7] painted a more disturbing picture of the potential threat of threat of high CO2 emissions related to tourism. They reported that the tourism sector could become a leading global source of greenhouse gases in the future. They alternately found that with significant policy and practice changes in air travel, emissions reductions could be significantly reduced. How tourism responds to climate change is critical to the tourism sustainability. Lee and Brahmasrene [8] investigated the influence of tourism on economic growth and CO2 emissions in European Union (EU) countries using econometric panel data procedures and found that tourism incurs a involves a significant negative impact on the high CO2 emissions. Jebli et al. [9] considered the relationship between carbon dioxide emissions, economic 3. MODEL, DATA AND METHODOLOGY 3.1. Model Environmental pollution is extensively widely by CO2 emissions (kt) in the energy studies of the relevant literature. The starting point of the theoretical setting in the present study is that international tourism could be a determinant of carbon emission level. It is expected that tourism leads to an increase real income and, therefore, in pollution level. Therefore, the following tourisminduced EKC model can be suggested in this study: CO2it = f(GDPit , ENCit, , ENCit , TOUR it ) (1) The tourism-induced EKC model in Eq. (1) can be expressed in logarithmic form to capture the growth impacts in the economic longterm period: LnCO2it = β0 +β1 LnGDPit + β2 Ln GDPit2 + β3 LnENCit + β4 Ln TOUR it (2) 2 Tourism Development Promotes Co2 Emissions In Asia Pacific Countries: Panel Granger Analysis Where CO2 is carbon dioxide emissions, GDP is real income, GDP2 is the square of real income, ENC is energy consumption, and TOUR stands for international tourism arrivals. β1, β2, β3, and β4 are the coefficients of repressors and ε is the error disturbance. distribution. The CDLM test, which is also another test to examine cross-sectional dependence, is calculated with the formula mentioned below. CDLM = √ CDLM1adj = [ (T−K)ρ2ij μTij √v2ij ] ~N (0.1) ( 6) Panel unit root tests are similar to unit root tests carried out on a single series. The ADF model for panel data may be expressed as: p ∆yit = ρi yit−1 + ∑j=1 δi ∆yit−j + xit́ β + εit ( 7) Where yit is the series of interest being i = 1,2,...,N cross-section units over periods t = 1,2,...,T, xit represents a column vector of exogenous variables, including any fixedeffects or individual trends, ρi is the mean-reversion coefficient, ρ is the lag length of the autoregressive process and it εit a idiosyncratic disturbance assumed to be a mutually independent. I f|ρi | < 1 , yit is said to be weakly (trend) stationary, and if ρi = 1, then yit presents a unit root. Two natural assumptions may be made about ρi in the ADF model for panel data. Firstly, one can assume that the persistence parameters are common across countries, so that ρi = ρ for all i. Using this assumption, the Breitung [15] and Levin et al [16] approaches (both testing for a null hypothesis of a unit root against the alternative of no unit root), and the Hadri [17] one (which tests the null of no unit root against the alternative hypothesis of a unit root) can be applied. Secondly, one can allow ρi being freely varying across units, allowing for individual unit root processes. The case of ADF and PP tests was proposed by Maddala and Wu [18] and Choi [19] and IPS test proposed by Im et al. [20]. The three of them test the null hypothesis of a unit root against the alternative hypothesis of some individuals without unit roots. In general, the possible deterministic components employed are fixed effects, and individual effects and individual trend. 3.3. Methodology The normalization of the data is necessary to transform the values to the same unit of measurement since CO2 emissions were presented as metric tons, while others were presented in US$. Therefore, transformation into a natural log mitigates possible distortions of dynamic properties of the series. It is commonly assumed that disturbances in panel data models are cross-sectionally independent, especially when the cross-section dimension is large. There is, however, considerable evidence that cross-sectional dependence is often present in panel regression settings. Cross-sectional dependency could be explained in terms of econometrics as individuals forming panels are related to error terms in the panel data model, which is given in Equation (3). It could be explained that in a situation in which individuals forming a panel are affected by a shock, then other individuals of the panel are affected as well: 𝐲𝐢𝐭 = 𝛂𝐢 + 𝛃𝐢 𝐱 𝐢𝐭 + 𝛆𝐢𝐭 𝐂𝐎𝐕(𝛆𝐢𝐭 , 𝛆𝐢𝐉 ) ≠ 𝟎 (3) The CDLM2 test, which is another test to examine cross-sectional dependence, is calculated as below. 1 1 CDLM1 3.3.2. Panel unit root tests 3.3.1. Panel Cross-section Dependence Test N(N−1) N ̂ [∑N−1 i=1 ∑j=i+1 TPij ]~N (0.1) ( 5) This test is based on the sum of correlation coefficient squares among crosssectional residuals. This test, which is asymptotically standard normal distribution, is used when T >N and N>T. The null and alternative hypothesis of this test is similar to CD LM1 and CDLM2 tests. Finally, the CDLM1adj test is a modified version of the CDLM1 test, which was developed by Pesaran, Ulla, and Yamagata [14]. This test is formulated below. 3.2 Data This empirical study uses annual data on 12 selected Asia Pacific countries includes: Australia, China, Hong Kong, India, Indonesia, Japan, Korea, Malaysia, New Zealand, Philippines, Singapore and Thailand over the period 1995–2013. Carbon dioxide emissions (CO2) CO2 per capita is in metric tons, Real GDP (GDP), squared constant Real GDP are measured in constant 2005 US $, energy use (ENC) (kt of oil equivalent) and international tourist arrivals (TOUR) is the number of international tourists who visit Asia Pacific countries and stay in the touristic establishments. Data is obtained from the World Bank [13]. CDLM2 = √ 2T N(N−1) N ̂ [∑N−1 i=1 ∑j=i+1 TPρij ]~N (0.1) (4) In this equation, ρ̂2 ij show the estimation of the sum of cross-sectional residuals. The test, which is used when N and T are great (T →∞ and N → ∞), is asymptotically normal 3 Tourism Development Promotes Co2 Emissions In Asia Pacific Countries: Panel Granger Analysis 3.3.3 Panel causality analysis Japan Panel causality test developed by Dumitrescu - Hurlin [20] was used. This test can be used when N is growing and T is constant. Moreover, it can also be used when T > N and when N > T. The test, which is based on VAR, assumes that there is no cross-sectional dependency. If the panel data model is considered: K yit = Korea, Rep Malaysia k (k) ∑ γi yi,t−k k=1 + (k) ∑ βi xi,t−k k=1 New Zealand + εi,t (8) Here, K stands for the lag length. Moreover, the panel for the test is a balanced (k) panel. γi ,which is an autoregressive parameter, (k) and βi , which is the regression coefficient pitch may change between groups. In addition to these, the tests do not have a random process. This test is a fixed one and has a fixed coefficient model. Apart from these, individual remainders for each cross-sectional unit are independent. This test is based on normal distribution and allows for heterogeneity. Also, individual remainders are independently distributed among the groups. The alternative hypothesis of HNC allows for some of the individual vectors (βi ) as being equal to zero. For the Dumitrescu - Hurlin test, the H NC average statistic WN.T , hypothesis can be written as follows: Philippines Singapore Thailand 1 = ∑ Wi,T N (9) Here,Wi,T stands for the individual Wald statistical values for cross-sectionunits. 4. EMPIRICAL RESULTS Table 1 summarizes the descriptive statistics for Asia Pacific countries. This result provides an overview of the tourist arrivals to Asia pacific countries in addition to the CO2 emissions, GDP and financial development. Table 1 Summarizes the Descriptive Statistics for Asia Pacific Australia China Hong Kong India Indonesia CO2 342958.3 382464.4 281941.0 St. Deviation 28395.87 GDP 6492.878 8671.520 480.2200 1837.190 ENC TOUR CO2 GDP ENC TOUR CO2 GDP ENC TOUR CO2 GDP ENC TOUR CO2 GDP ENC TOUR CO2 171647.8 5113158. 5670267. 2431.409 1747558. 40875842 38023.37 177.7360 12967.68 13564316 1483675. 8565.991 14771890 7864579. 358719.3 296.1280 173960.1 5702684. 1203745. 1228877 6382000. 9919518. 4912.954 2927727. 57725000 42754.00 241.7801 16093.00 25661000 2274345. 14897.76 80944606 16626000 583984.6 449.1423 225008.5 8802000. 1259328. 92558.00 3726000. 3318056. 942.3076 1044454. 20034000 29365.00 129.7221 3195.000 5037000. 920046.6 4487.215 64659.50 3056000. 210210.8 214.5795 130817.4 4324000. 1101028. 256255.4 723186.3 2358079. 1279.050 664443.6 13511337 3735.199 38.73110 2913.594 6417207. 430668.3 3325.290 29567004 4374780. 117151.4 75.37182 29662.88 1292281. 35962.69 Max. Min. 4784.542 4132.182 499315.6 507083.3 451500.0 208.2892 23015. TOUR CO2 GDP ENC TOUR CO2 GDP ENC TOUR CO2 GDP ENC TOUR CO2 GDP ENC TOUR CO2 GDP ENC TOUR CO2 GDP ENC TOUR 6166526. 478729.6 866.5006 206937.6 6415053. 34.38413 140.8484 57966.81 15660895 32211.32 107.4179 23150.68 2045053. 73020.41 103.0276 38732.75 2704053. 36584.14 128.4841 24826.28 7274000. 240018.7 171.1978 92141.03 12791684 10364000 609426.3 1199.004 265002.2 12176000 227692.9 207.9514 77907.30 25715000 34759.49 129.7143 134681.0 2629000. 84012.46 155.6088 45511.90 4681000. 69240.29 202.4218 34279.50 11899000 323370.9 230.3713 121147.5 26547000 3345000. 364833.5 553.3310 144755.8 3684000. 107934.5 90.11091 33881.80 5551000. 27146.80 81.91460 14889.00 1112000. 60710.85 69.12891 33514.00 1760000. 13479.89 76.30928 18069.10 4703000. 167585.6 125.6893 61924.00 6952000. 1973641. 72304.34 210.7229 36840.99 2479850. 42911.46 36.57773 14708.53 7256155. 2037.602 15.90966 27024.03 481783.3 6427.351 26.24569 2452.363 877008.3 15745.17 40.59057 5687.071 2042386. 50848.63 34.18027 20594.71 5315934. It appears that the highest and lowest mean international tourism arrivals observed is in China and New Zealand, respectively. The real GDP data indicates that Japan and Philippines had the highest and lowest average. The CO2 emissions data shows that China and Malaysia had the highest and lowest average. These figures suggest that tourism development in Asia pacific countries is likely to affect CO2 emissions. Moreover, it should be noted that although these figures show the importance of international tourism to the economies Asia pacific countries. As outlined earlier, testing for crosssectional dependency in a panel causality study is crucial for selecting an appropriate estimator. Taking into account cross-sectional dependency in the empirical analysis is crucial since countries are highly integrated and have a high degree of globalization in economic relations. Therefore, our empirical study starts with examining the existence of cross-sectional dependency across the countries in concern. To investigate the existence of cross-sectional dependence, we carried out four different tests and illustrate the results in Table 2. It is clear that the null of no cross-sectional dependency across the countries was strongly rejected at the conventional significance levels, implying that the GMM, SUR method is more appropriate than a country - by -country OLS estimation. i=1 Mean. 4467.823 ENC Source: Author's Estimation using Eviews 9 N H NC WN.T GDP Table 2 Cross–Sectional Dependence Test CDBP CDLM CD LM adj Statistic 210.3278** 11.51766** -1.062987 71. 363466** Prob 0.0000 0.0000 0.2878 0.0000 ** indicates significance at the 0.5 level. 4 Tourism Development Promotes Co2 Emissions In Asia Pacific Countries: Panel Granger Analysis The first line contains the results of Breusch-Pagan LM test. Eviews 9 shows the test statistic value, test degree-of-freedom, and the associated p-value. In this case, the value of the test statistic, 372.3844 is well into the upper tail of ℵ2, 66 and we firmly reject the null hypothesis of no correlation at conventional significance levels. The next two lines present results for the two scaled Breusch-Pagan tests. Both the Pesaran scaled Breusch-Pagan LM, and CD LM tests are asymptotically standard normal, and the test statistic results of 11.51766 and 71. 363466 respectively, strongly reject the null hypothesis at conventional levels. The Baltagi et al. biasadjusted LM test statistic value is -1.062987 significantly below that of the scaled LM tests, this test does not reject the null at conventional at 5% significance levels. Table 3 summaries the results of these six tests by using Eviews 9. The statistical properties of each variable are individually considered and some classic methods to investigate whether the series are stationary I (0) or non-stationary I (1) are applied. As can be observed all the variables have a unit root. This result implies that all series are integrated of the same order, and hence the cointegration between variables can be studied. Table 4 Panel GMM Variables DLn GDP DLn GDP2 DLn ENC DLn TOUR C R-squared Prob (Jstatistic) Instrument rank Ln ENC Ln TOUR -0.17809 Ln GDP2 Level 0 0.02220 0.80758 -0.73396 0.66359 1.21004 5.18476 5.91010 1.32305 4.36253 24.9573 5.70428 4.49640 17.7580 10.8773 22.8678 30.4104 23.5019 45.0208 22.1960 Level 1 -7.29684** -6.69175** -8.64666** -1.63604** -5.95219** -5.44234** -8.90540** -4.64792** 80.8057** 74.6673** 117.311** 64.8418** 127.574** 111.896** 703.674** 156.075** Ln CO2 Levin, Lin& Chu t* Im, Pesaran and Shin Wstat ADF - Fisher Chi-square PP - Fisher Chi-square Levin, Lin& Chu t* Im, Pesaran and Shin Wstat ADF - Fisher Chi-square PP - Fisher Chi-square Ln GDP 97.9915 ** 180.230** Prob [0.0000] [0.0170] [0.0000] [0.0000] [0.0001] 2.66E-16 5 The above estimations show that tourist arrivals have a positive and statistically significant impact on CO2 emissions. It can be seen from the first long-run model, 1 percent change in the tourist arrivals will lead to 0.27 percent decrease in CO2 emissions as other things is constant. The impact economic growth to CO2 emissions is 1.51, -0.06, respectively. CO2 emissions and energy consumption have positive and statistically significant interactions in the long-run. The time series approach overlooks crosssectional dependency across countries in the causality test; therefore, they can result in misleading conclusions about the nature of causality between tourism arrivals and economic growth. We find strong evidence for the existence of cross-section dependence among transition countries. The bootstrap panel Granger causality results are reported in Tables 5. Table 5 Panel Granger Causality Test Panel -7.61182 ** -7.38288 ** Std. Error 0.344127 0.025614 0.039259 0.057710 1.494888 ** denotes rejection of the hypothesis at the 0.05 level Source: Author's calculation using Eviews 9 Table 3.Panel Unit Root Tests Unit root test Coefficient 1.51** -0.06** 0.48** -0.27** 6.16** 0.888619 Austria China Hong Kong India Indonesia Japan Notes: All unit root tests were performed with individual trends and intercept for each series. The optimal lag length was selected automatically using the Schwarz information criteria. The null hypothesis is a unit root for all the tests (**) (***) denotes statistical significance at the (5%), (l0%). Source: Author's Estimation using Eviews 9 Korea, Rep Malaysia New Zealand Philippines The panel causality analysis based on estimating a panel vector autoregression and /or panel vector error correction model by means of generalized method of moments, is an appropriate detection approach for causal linkages between tourism arrivals and CO2 emissions in these Asia Pacific countries. The GMM-model indicates that a long-run equilibrium relationship exists among these variables. The results show in the Table 4. Singapore Thailand DLnCO 2→DLn TOUR 0.71320 [0.5452] 1.38038 [0.2887] 3.54950* ** [0.0615] 0.08820 [0.9162] 0.04416 [0.9570] 0.84899 [0.4520] 0.37585 [0.6945] 0.06296 [0.9393] 0.35346 [0.7093] 0.37844 [0.6928] DLnTOUR →DLnCO2 DL ENC→ DLn TOUR DLn TOUR →DLn ENC 829.3691** [0.000] 3.11806*** [0.0812] 5.45405** [0.0207] 0.30300 [0.7389] 2.32788 [0.1399] 4.82244** [0.0090] 0.40849 [0.6736] 3.67373** [0.0569] 15.5458** [0.0005] 0.63213 [0.5483] 0.30725 [0.7411] 12.0380** [0.0014] 7.78290*** [0.0068] 2.82361*** [0.0989] 2.39436 [0.1333] 2.02761 [0.1743] 0.84764 [0.4525] 1.26650 [0.3169] 2.13978 [0.1604] 0.20285 [0.8191] 0.79618 [0.4735] 1.6578 [0.2314] 9.13954** [0.0039] 4.16147** [0.0424] 0.20685 [0.8160] 2.69042*** [0.1083] 7.46795** [0.0078] 5.91851** [0.0163] 0.99554 [0.3981] 2.08358 2.19212 [0.1544] 3.66796* * [0.0571] 0.18039 [0.8372] 2.00455 [0.1774] 0.88369 [0.4385] 2.55503 [0.1190] 5.31622** [0.0222] [0.1672] 0.41022 [0.6725] 0.22537 [0.8015] 2.89674*** [0.0941] 2.53096 [0.1210] 9.03455** [0.0040] Note: **, *** The statistical significance at the 5%, 10 % levels. Denote x → y means x Granger causes y. Source: Author's Estimation using Eviews 9 The Results show panel Granger causality between tourism arrivals and CO2 emissions at the 5 Tourism Development Promotes Co2 Emissions In Asia Pacific Countries: Panel Granger Analysis 5% and 10% significant level. There is unidirectional causality from CO2 emissions to tourism arrivals at the 5%, 10% significant level for Austria, Hong Kong, India, Korea, New Zealand, and Thailand. A reverse relationship from tourism arrivals to CO2 emissions is found for Singapore and a feedback hypothesis is found for China. However, we find that neutral relationships exist for Indonesia, Japan, and Philippines. Also, there is unidirectional causality from CO2 emissions to tourism arrivals for Asia Pacific countries. Signs of coefficients for all the countries are positive. The panel Granger causality tests shows that the relationship between tourism arrivals and energy consumption at the 5% and 10% significant level. There is unidirectional causality from tourism arrivals to energy consumption for Singapore. A reverse relationship from energy consumption to tourism arrivals is found for China, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Japan, Korea and Thailand and a feedback hypothesis is not found. However, we find that neutral relationships exist for Austria, India, Malaysia, and New Zealand. There is unidirectional causality from energy consumption to tourism arrivals for Asia Pacific countries. We speculate on the effects of the size of National economy, the level of openness of the country and the level of travel restrictions as feasible factors in the differences among these countries. In addition to these factors, the degree of dependence on tourism, tourism destination life cycles, and levels of economic development can be considered part of the other determinants. Further researches will be needed in the area since Katircioglu [22] and Katircioglu et al. [23] found that tourism development deteriorates air quality and leads to increases in CO2 emissions, respectively, in the cases of Turkey and Cyprus contrary to the findings. They are similar to the findings of Lee and Brahmasrene [24] in the case of EU. the panel Granger causality approach to test whether tourist arrivals promote CO2 emissions. Results suggest important implications for policy makers: because it has been proven that the tourism arrivals and GDP, squared GDP would lead to declines in carbon dioxide emissions in the case of Asia pacific countries, the EKC hypothesis through tourism development is confirmed. One could conclude that policy implications driven from the causality approach account for cross-sectional dependency and seem to be more appropriate, implying that each country develops its tourism policies. A final suggestion is in order regarding the prospect of global CO2 emissions underlines the need to transform carbon-intensive economies rapidly into green economies. In order to implement such an approach, further empirical analyses are needed to estimate the future associated emissions and the future mitigation potential of growth. REFERENCES 1. UNCSD NGO, (1999). “Sustainable Tourism: A NonGovernmental Organization Perspective, Commission on Sustainable Development”, Seventh Session, Paper # 4, New York. 2. L., Dwyer, & P. Forsyth, (2008), “Economic measures of tourism yield: what markets to target?” International Journal of Tourism Research, 10(2). 3. S., Khoshnevis Yazdi, B. Khanalizadeh, B., Shakouri, (2013). “The Granger Causality among Tourist Arrival, Economic Growth and CO2 Emissions in Iran”, Advances in Environmental Biology 4. T., Davies, S., Cahill, (2000). “Environmental Implications of the Tourism Industry”, Discussion Paper, 00-14, Washington. 5. S.K, Nepal (2008), “Tourism-induced rural energy consumption in the Annapurna region of Nepal”. Tourism Management; 29:89–100 6. UNWTO, (2008). “Climate change and tourism: Responding to global challenges. Madrid, Spain 7. Scott, D., Amelung, B., Becken, S., Ceron, J.P., Dubois, G., Gössling, S., Peeters, P., Simpson, M.C. (2010). “Climate Change and Tourism: Responding to Global Challenges”. World Tourism Organization, Madrid, Spain. 8. J.W., Lee, T., Brahmasrene, (2013). “Investigating the influence of tourism on economic growth and carbon emissions: evidence from panel analysis of the European Union”, Tourism Management, 38: 69–76. 9. S., Jebli, M.S., Ben Aïssa, M., Ben Youssef, (2014). “Output, renewable energy consumption and trade in Africa”. Energy Policy, 66: 11-18. 10. ST, Katircioglu (2014). “International tourism, energy consumption, and environmental pollution: The case of Turkey”. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2014; 36:180–187. 11. U., Al-Mulali, H.G., Fereidouni, J.Y.M., Lee, (2014). “Electricity consumption from renewable and nonrenewable sources and economic growth: Evidence from Latin American countries”. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Review, 30, 290-298. 12. A.S., Solarin, (2014). “Tourism Arrivals and Macroeconomic Determinants of CO2 in Malaysia, Anatolia: An International Journal of Tourism and Hospitality Research”, 25 (2): 228-241. 13. World Bank, (2015). “World Development Indicators”, Accessed at: 5. CONCLUSIONS This paper empirically investigated the tourism-induced CO2 emissions, and therefore, the long-run equilibrium relationship and the direction of causality between tourism development and carbon dioxide emissions through the channels of energy consumption and real income growth in Asia Pacific countries for 1995-2013.Tourism arrivals also has a statistically significant and negative impact on the level of carbon dioxide emissions in the long run period. The results confirm the validity of tourism-induced EKC hypothesis. The theoretical EKC framework has been taken into consideration in empirical analysis with this. This study applies 6 Tourism Development Promotes Co2 Emissions In Asia Pacific Countries: Panel Granger Analysis 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. http://www.worldbank.org/data/onlinedatabases/onlinedata bases.html H.Pesaran, M., Aman Ullah, and T., Yamagata, (2008). “A Bias-Adjusted LM Test of Error Cross-Section Independence”, Econometrics Journal, 11(1): 105-127. J., Breitung, (2005). A parametric approach to the estimation of cointegration vectors in panel data. Econometric Reviews”, 24, 151–173. A., Levin, C. F., Lin and J., Chu, (2002). “Unit root tests in panel data: asymptotic and finite-simple properties”, Journal of Econometrics, vol. 108, pp. 1-24. K., Hadri, (2000). “Testing for unit roots in heterogeneous panel data, Econometrics Journal”, vol. 3, pp. 148-161. G. S., Maddala and S., Wu, (1999). “A comparative study of unit root test with Panel Data and a new simple test”, Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, vol. Special issue, pp. 631-652. I., Choi, (2001). “Unit Root Tests for Panel Data”, Journal of International Money and Finance, 20, 249–272. K. S. Im, M. H. Peseran and Y. Shin, (2003), “Testing for unit roots in heterogeneous panels, Journal of Econometrics, vol. 115, pp. 53-74 E.I., Dumitrescu, C., Hurlin, (2012), “Testing for Granger non-causality in heterogeneous panels”, Economic Modelling, 29(4), 1450-1460. ST, Katircioglu (2014). “International tourism, energy consumption, and environmental pollution: The case of Turkey”. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2014; 36:180–187. S.T, Katircioglu, M, C., Feridun Kilinc (2014). “Estimating tourism-induced energy consumption and CO2 emissions: the case of Cyprus”. Renew Sustain Energy Rev, 2014; 29: 634–40. J.W., Lee, T., Brahmasrene, (2013). “Investigating the influence of tourism on economic growth and carbon emissions: evidence from panel analysis of the European Union“, Tourism Management, 38: 69–76. 7