Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Contents About the Author 4 Author’s acknowledgement 5 About the American Chamber of Commerce 5 Foreword7 A Letter from the Ambassador 9 Chapter 1: Irish-US Economic Links remain Resilient and Dynamic11 Chapter 2: Irish-US Engagement: The Nexus between Foreign Investment and Trade 37 Chapter 3: Ireland: A Resurgent Economy51 Chapter 4: A Testing Time for the Future of the Transatlantic Economy63 Chapter 5: The Road Ahead for Irish-US Commercial Relationship77 Key terms and definitions 84 About the Author 4 Joseph Quinlan is a Transatlantic Fellow at both the German Marshal Fund in Washington D.C. and at the Centre for Transatlantic Relations, the Paul H. Nitze School of Advanced International Studies of Johns Hopkins University, Washington D.C. He also served as a Bosch Fellow at the Transatlantic Academy in Washington, D.C. in 2010/11. Mr. Quinlan regularly debriefs policy makers and legislators on Capitol Hill on global trade and economic issues. He has testified before the European Parliament and has served as a consultant to the U.S. Department of State. He is also a board member of Fordham University’s Graduate School of Arts and Science and serves on Fordham University’s President Council. In 2006, the American Chamber of Commerce to the European Union awarded Mr. Quinlan the 2006 Transatlantic Business Award for his research on U.S.Europe economic ties. In 2007, he was a recipient of the European-American Business Council Leadership award for his research on the transatlantic partnership and global economy. He is the author, co-author, or contributor to eighteen books. His most recent book, “The Last Economic Superpower” was released by McGraw Hill in November 2010 and was selected as one of the best books on globalization by Axiom Business Book Awards in 2011. He has published more than 125 articles on economics, trade and finance that have appeared in such publications as Foreign Affairs, the Financial Times, The Wall Street Journal and Barron’s. He regularly appears on CNBC, as well as Bloomberg television, PBS and other media venues. Mr. Quinlan lectures on finance and global economics at New York University, where he has been a faculty member since 1992. He also lectures at Fordham University and regularly speaks at various universities around the world. He is presently a visiting professor at Wuhan University, Wuhan, China. A veteran Wall Street global economist/strategist, Quinlan was named on the 2011 Irish America Wall Street 50 list, a list comprised of accomplished and leading financial professionals on Wall Street with Irish heritage. Author’s acknowledgement While I have benefitted from the insights of many during this project, I carry sole responsibility for the content of this report. The views expressed here are my own, and do not necessarily represent those of any sponsor, institution or company. data presented within the report. I would also like to thank Mark Redmond, Chief Executive at the Chamber, for his continuing support and for his energetic leadership in strengthening the Irish-U.S. relationship. I am particularly indebted to many people at the American Chamber of Commerce Ireland for help in preparing this report. Many thanks to the communications and policy team of Brian Harrison, Jonathan Small and Stephen Hopkins for assistance in overseeing this production. I am deeply grateful to Dermot O’Leary, Chief Economist, Goodbody for his insights on the performance of the Irish economy and I’d like to offer my appreciation to officials within Ireland’s Central Statistics Office (CSO) and the Department of Finance for their observations on the Finally, I am particularly indebted to Brian Cotter of the American Chamber of Commerce Ireland. Brian was instrumental in launching the first report of this series (“Built to Last”), and was again intimately involved with this project, providing invaluable guidance and assistance to the final report. Brian remains one of the leading voices in strengthening not only the Irish-U.S. partnership but also the transatlantic partnership. It is always a pleasure working with Brian and the entire team at the American Chamber of Commerce Ireland. About the American Chamber of Commerce Ireland The American Chamber of Commerce Ireland is the leading international business organisation in Ireland and is the leadership voice of US companies here. Consistently recognised as the most influential advocacy organisation in the country, the American Chamber’s membership includes US companies operating from Ireland, their strategic partners, and organisations with strong bilateral trade linkages between Ireland and the United States. • Networking: Engagement with our members is at a leadership level to ensure that only very senior networking opportunities arise at every event. • Representation: Joining the Chamber gives companies a powerful voice as part of what is recognised as one of the most influential business groups in the country. • Business Growth: The Chamber runs a high quality event programme covering a range of subjects to support our members to grow business in Ireland 5 6 Foreword 7 March 2016 This report provides a very clear picture of the enduring strength of the Irish US economic relationship. It highlights very clearly the benefits to both nations and outlines the many reasons to be confident that the relationship will continue its impressive growth trajectory. Of course economic statistics can only tell one side of the story. What the figures truly represent is the hard work, innovation and creativity of 140,000 people. This World of Talent in Ireland is celebrated consistently as one of the most accomplished workforces in the world. A look at the breadth of the achievements by US companies in Ireland can only serve to underline that view. We are delighted that this report also focuses on the reciprocal nature of Ireland’s relationship with the US. Our economic ties have always been two-way and as our domestic economy continues to expand there is a growing number of Irish firms seeking to develop opportunities in US markets. As this report notes Ireland and the US now stand as two of the strongest growing economies in the transatlantic economy. US companies are continuing to invest in Ireland in impressive numbers, and continue to provide skilled jobs, support innovation and generate economic growth. In turn, Irish companies continue to grow their US operations and invest in research and development throughout the United States. The story of the Ireland US economic relationship is one that continues to thrive. Sincerely, Bob Savage President Mark Redmond Chief Executive 8 A Letter from the Ambassador 9 Dublin, Ireland March, 2016 Embassy of the United States of America President Obama, in his 2016 State of the Union speech, said, “I believe a thriving private sector is the lifeblood of our economy.” As the United States Ambassador to Ireland, I believe a thriving private sector is the lifeblood of the U.S.-Ireland relationship. It is the lifeblood that runs through the veins of that relationship, and sustains the deep and abiding friendship our countries share. I understood that on an intellectual level before I arrived as Ambassador in 2014, but I understand it on a much deeper level now. The private sector portion of our relationship is much more than what is represented by the significant numbers: the record $58 billion in new U.S. FDI to Ireland in 2014, the $310 billion value of the stock of U.S. FDI here, and the significant share of Irish GDP which is driven by that investment. Our thriving private sector invigorates and sustains 140,000 employees as well as their families. I have seen this personally as I have visited numerous U.S. companies around Ireland, observed their operations, and met with the people who make these companies go. It’s incredibly gratifying to meet Irish people who are so proud of the work they do for American companies. To all members of the American Chamber of Commerce in Ireland, to its staff and Board, and to all the people who work at these great companies: keep doing what you’re doing. In the same way that our business relationship was built on the familial and personal ties that have linked our countries since before either one was independent, the economic ties help forge new personal links across the Atlantic. I’m proud to be a part of that, and I hope you are, too. Sincerely, Kevin F. O’Malley United States Ambassador to Ireland 10 Chapter 1: The Irish-US Economic Nexus remains Resilient and Dynamic Chapter 1 highlights: • Ireland and the United States now stand as two of the strongest growing economies in the transatlantic economy. Ireland’s economic growth rate was one of the strongest in the world in 2015, while the US economy is now in the seventh year of an economic expansion. Both economies will lead the transatlantic economy again in 2015. Ireland remains one of the prime destinations for U.S. foreign direct investment. • U.S. direct investment stock in Ireland totalled a record $310 billion in 2014, according to data from the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA). Ireland’s share of U.S. investment stock in Europe has soared over the past decade, with Ireland’s share amounting to 11.1% of the total in 2014 versus 6.2% in 2004. • U.S. investment flows to Ireland surged to a record $58.1 billion in 2014. Ireland performed strongly within Europe during 2015, accounting for nearly 20% of total U.S. investment flows to Europe in the January-September period The comparable shares for France and Germany were 3% and 2%, respectively. • In 2014, U.S. investment stakes in Ireland ($310 billion) were greater than many regions of the world, including Latin America ($139 billion), Central America ($118 billion), Africa ($64 billion), the Middle East ($52 billion) and China ($66 billion). U.S. investment flows to China in the first nine months of in 2015 were just 16.8% of those to Ireland in the same period; comparable figures for India, Brazil, and Russia were 7%, 6.2% and less than 1% respectively, reflecting Ireland’s track record as a high-performance, attractive and stable investment location within Europe. • Ireland’s investment stakes in the U.S. are significant as well, with Irish affiliates estimated to have generated some $90 billion in affiliate sales from their US operations in 2014 and $35 billion in U.S. economic output. Whether through rising output, employment, R&D expenditures—Ireland’s local presence in the U.S. bestows a host of benefits to the U.S. • US affiliate output in Ireland totalled roughly $83 billion in 2014 a more than five-fold increase since 2000. For years, US affiliates have produced more output in Ireland than in many key emerging markets. For instance, U.S. affiliate output in Ireland in 2013 ($76 billion), the last year of actual data, was substantially higher than comparable figures in China ($52 billion), India ($21 billion) and Brazil ($46 billion). Ireland accounted for 11.7% of total US affiliate output in Europe in 2013, up from 5% in 2000. • R&D outlays by US affiliates in Ireland totalled $1.9 billion in 2013 and an estimated $2 billion in 2014. These figures are up significantly from the start of the century. Ireland’s share of US affiliate R&D in Europe was 6.2% in 2013, up from a share of 3.6% in 2000. On a global basis, Ireland accounted for 3.8% of total US affiliate R&D in 2013, a global 11 12 share not that far behind Japan’s (4.2%), India (5.3%) and China (4.4%). • The sales of US majority-owned affiliates in Ireland rose nearly five-fold between 2000 and 2013, with Ireland’s share of US-European affiliate sales rising from 5.3% in 2000 to 11.3% in 2013. Helping to boost sales and the operations of US firms have been the steady advance of R&D investments by US affiliates, with US R&D outlays in Ireland nearly quadrupling between 2000 and 2013. • For decades, US firms in Ireland have been instrumental in creating jobs and income for Irish workers, adding skills, raising quality standards, developing talent, accelerating innovation, providing business opportunities for indigenous firms, and tax revenues for local and national governments. The combination of a businessfriendly climate in Ireland and the large, in-country presence of U.S. firms has helped transform and sustain Ireland’s status as one of the most resilient and dynamic economies in the world. Ireland and the United States now stand as two of the strongest growing economies in the transatlantic economy. Ireland‘s economic growth rate at +6% of GDP was one of the strongest in the world in 2015, while the US economy is now in the seventh year of an economic expansion. Both economies will lead the transatlantic economy again this year. But these are challenging times for global commerce. In the last year alone, firms of all stripes have had to wrestle with the geopolitics of the Middle East, the stunning economic slowdown of China, the collapse in world commodity prices, regulatory uncertainties in the U.S. and Europe, and the unrelenting march of gamingchanging technological advances. Another overarching challenge for international business - sluggish global growth, with the world economy still struggling to heal and “normalize” in the post-crisis era. The global economy expanded by around 3% in 2015 and is expected to do only marginally better in 2016. The post-war annual average real growth for the world economy is closer to 3.7%. However, against this backdrop of subpar global growth, there are a few slivers of optimism, notably as it pertains to the IrishUS economic partnership. Firms in both the United States and Europe have had to sharpen their competitiveness through increased capital spending, mergers and acquisitions, rationalizing and consolidating their global operations, and by leveraging the attributes of nations that have a proven track record in providing a business environment that supports the performance of firms. 1 Enter Ireland, which in a world of increasing disorder and unrelenting change, remains one of the prime destinations of U.S. foreign direct investment (FDI). Yes, there has been a great deal of churn and change in the global economy since our last report. But what has not changed is international investors’ overriding preference for doing business in Ireland. Various metrics point towards Ireland and the United States deepening their well-established trade and investment linkages, borne out by the following: • After surging to a record $58.1 billion in 2014, U.S. investment flows to Ireland performed relatively strongly again in 2015, accounting for nearly 20% of total U.S. investment flows to Europe in the January-September period. The comparable shares for France and Germany were 3% and 2%, respectively, albeit on lower levels of overall transatlantic investment flows. • Since 2008, Ireland has been second only to the Netherlands in attracting more U.S. investment flows to Europe on a cumulative basis. • U.S. direct investment stock in Ireland totalled a record $310 billion in 2014, according to data from the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA). Ireland’s share of U.S. investment stock in Europe has soared over the past decade, with Ireland’s share amounting to 11.1% of the total in 2014 versus 6.2% in 2004.1 For the purposes of making international comparisons for investment and trade flows this paper focuses on using official US data. Due to different methodologies between the US Bureau of Economic Analysis and Ireland’s Central Statistics Office (CSO), total figures vary, but the principal trends and relative performance of Ireland in attracting FDI remains similar. 13 14 FIGURE 1.1 TOTAL USUS FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT STOCK IN IN IRELAND TOTAL FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT STOCK IRELAND TOP U.S. FDI DESTINATIONS: Q1-Q3 2015* (Billions of $) (Billions of $) Netherlands 350 Ireland United Kingdom 300 Luxembourg Switzerland 250 Canada 200 Singapore Australia 150 Japan China 100 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 35 40 45 Source: Bureau of Economic 25 Analysis. 0 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 FIGURE 1.2 TOP U.S. FDI DESTINATIONS (TOTAL FDI FLOWS): q1-q3 2015 TOP U.S. FDI DESTINATIONS: Q1-Q3 2015* (Billions of $) Netherlands Ireland United Kingdom Luxembourg Switzerland Canada Singapore Australia Japan China 0 Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis. 5 10 15 20 25 30 • According to data from the BEA, U.S. investment stakes in Ireland ($310 billion) are greater than many regions of the world, including Latin America ($139 billion), Central America ($118 billion), China ($66 billion), Africa ($64 billion), and the Middle East ($52 billion). • Reflecting the preference of corporate America for Ireland versus the newly developed nations, U.S. investment flows to China in the first nine months of last year were just 16.8% of those to Ireland in the same period; comparable figures for India, Brazil, and Russia were 7%, 6.2% and less than 1%, respectively. • U.S. companies invested nearly $116 billion in Ireland between 2008 and 2014; the comparable figure for Brazil: $31 billion; India: $21.4 billion; China: $20.4 billion; and Russia: $1 billion. • Finally, deeper examination of the data focused on investments in productive assets by accounting for direct investment flows from U.S. holding companies (or excluding these figures from the total), U.S. investment stakes in Ireland remains impressive and reinforces the nation’s position as a premier destination for US firms seeking to serve global markets. By this metric, U.S. investment in Ireland totalled $161 billion in 2014, well above comparable levels in Germany ($86 billion), France ($63 billion) and China ($62 billion) for that matter. 15 16 FIGURE 1.3 MOST FAVORED NATION: IRELAND VERSUS THE BRICs 17 MOST FAVORED NATION: IRELAND VERSUS THE BRICS U.S. Cumulative FDI: 2008-2014 (Billions of $) 120 115.9 100 80 60 40 31.0 20 0 21.4 20.4 India China 1.0 Ireland Brazil Russia *Excludes flows to nonbank holding companies. Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis. The multiple attractions of Ireland It is not one variable but many variables—a package of attributes and endowments—that account for Ireland being among the most attractive destinations in the world for U.S. foreign direct investment. A few attributes stand out and include the following: To start, U.S. firms prefer, not surprisingly, to invest in economies or markets that are healthy and expanding, and on this basis, Ireland stands heads and shoulders above the rest of Europe and the bulk of newly developed nations for that matter. As discussed further in Chapter Three, to the surprise of many, Ireland has emerged as one of the fastest growing economies in the world over the past year, expanding by +6% in 2015. Indeed, Ireland’s level of real growth was on par with China’s last year; 4%+ real growth is expected in 2016, maintaining Ireland’s position as the fastest growing economy in the transatlantic universe. Ireland’s turnaround reflects the resilience of the economy and Ireland’s adaptability, flexibility and foresight to ever-changing and challenging circumstances, traits that are very attractive to U.S. multinationals. While the nation’s competitive and certain corporate tax rate is a cornerstone for foreign firms, the critical building blocks include: 18 • a strategic focus to develop and evolve policies designed to encourage high-valued-added investments in advanced manufacturing and global business services in industries like electronics, computer software, medical and healthcare technologies and finance; • an internationally respected and transparent tax and legal framework supporting business to develop global markets; • strong tradition of political stability; • an attractive R&D ecosystem of proven innovation capacity and incentives; • a leadership track record for turning-up projects rapidly, responding flexibly to change and delivering on business targets; • and, a globally focused, young, well-educated and English-speaking specialist talent pool that continues to grow and attain higher levels of skills and knowledge. Ireland, in the end, offers these competitive levers to firms interested in doing business in the country. A third variable enhancing the attractiveness of Ireland lies with its membership of the European Union—still the wealthiest and largest economic bloc in the world. While the United States and China loom large in the hierarchy of the global economy, so does the European Union. This fact is often overlooked or ignored by a common consensus, which is more attuned with what’s wrong with Europe, as opposed to what’s right. In nominal U.S. dollar terms, the European Union (plus Norway, Switzerland, Iceland) accounted for 25.6% of world output in 2014 according to estimates from the International Monetary Fund. That was greater than America’s share (22.5%) and well in excess of China’s—13.4%. Even based on purchasing power parity figures, the European Union’s share was slightly greater than both the United States and China in 2014. Meanwhile, 15 of the 25 wealthiest nations in the world are European, with per capita income levels in Europe light years ahead of those in India and China, and all of Africa. Add in Europe’s cyclical rebound, with the European Union expected to expand by 2% this year, and Ireland’s attraction as a strategic gateway to the broader European market looks even better in the eyes of many US multinationals. For 2015, we estimate that U.S. FDI outflows to Europe totaled $185 billion, a 7.7% rise from the levels of 2014 ($171.8 billion). Since hitting a post-crisis peak of $235 billion in 2011, US FDI outflows to Europe have increased in four consecutive years. On a global basis, in contrast, US FDI outflows in 2015 were basically flat from a year ago, totaling an estimated $316 billion for the year. The upshot: Europe accounted for a larger global share of U.S. FDI outflows in 2015—or nearly 60% of the total, up from 54% in 2014. The AsiaPacific region represented just 16.1% of the total, underscoring the bias and preference among U.S. firms for Europe versus Asia, and the fact that US multinationals continue to prefer the developed nations over the newly developed nations. With Russia and Brazil in recession, India still mired in socio-economic challenges of great complexity and magnitude, and China tested by a deep structural slowdown, US FDI investments to the these regions have remained subpar during the post-crisis era. 2 Firms prefer to invest in nations that respect the rule of law, are politically stable, are supported by a worldclass infrastructure, have an educated work force, embrace market-friendly macroeconomic policies, and are home to wealthy consumers—all factors that lead US firms to Europe in general and Ireland in particular. In the end, the Transatlantic Economy remains one of the most important arteries of commercial activity and exchange in the world, woven together more by foreign direct investment than cross-border trade. Indeed, trade figures—the conventional measurement of global engagement—hardly begin to capture the depth and breadth of the Irish-US commercial relationship. As Figure 1.4 makes clear, how U.S. firms look to Ireland as a transatlantic nexus is really a tale of two interconnected metrics of trade. Exports figure only nominally in the equation, while foreign affiliate sales2, reflecting the large US investment position in Ireland, are the overwhelming means by which American firms deliver goods and services to Irish customers and third parties. This is illustrated by the difference between US exports of goods and services to Ireland in 2014 (roughly $50 billion) and the estimated foreign affiliate sales in Ireland the same year (nearly $350 billion). Looked at from this vantage point—investment rather than trade—one begins to understand the extent of US investment flows to Ireland and comprehend the depth of commercial linkages between the two parties. U.S. Foreign Affiliate Sales - See key Terms and Definitions on the final page of the report. 19 20 The critical role of US foreign affiliates Figure 1.5 outlines the extensive presence of Corporate America in Ireland. The figures for 2014 are the author’s estimates but before delving into the specifics, it is worth taking the long view or highlighting the deep integration of Ireland and the United States over this century. To this point, US affiliate output (contribution to gross domestic product) in Ireland totalled roughly $83 billion in 2014 by our estimates, a more than five-fold increase from the start of the century. For years, US affiliates have produced more output in Ireland than in many key emerging markets. For instance, U.S. affiliate output in Ireland in 2013 ($76 billion), the last year of official full-year data, was substantially higher than comparable figures in China ($52 billion), India ($21 billion) and Brazil ($46 billion). Ireland accounted for 11.7% of total US affiliate output in Europe in 2013, up from 5% in 2000.Of notable interest as it pertains to US affiliate output in Ireland that year is the following: nearly 60% of US affiliate output in 2013 ($76 billion) was classified as “manufacturing”. US affiliates in Ireland, in other words, are in the business of developing products, transacting business, creating good jobs and providing good income to Irish employees in the process. FIGURE 1.4 U.S. SALES OF FOREIGN AFFILIATES* IN IRELAND EXCEED U.S. TOTAL EXPORTS TO IRELAND 21 U.S. SALES OF FOREIGN AFFILIATES* IN IRELAND EXCEED U.S. TOTAL EXPORTS TO IRELAND (Billions of $) 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Total Sales (Goods and Services) of U.S. Foreign Affiliates in Ireland Total U.S. Exports (Goods and Services) to Ireland *Majority-owned nonbank affiliates (2006-2008). Majority-owned bank and nonbank affiliates 2009-2014. Estimate for 2014 Total Sales. Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis 2013 2014 22 FIGURE 1.5 THE GROWING PRESENCE OF U.S. FOREIGN AFFILIATES* IN IRELAND (MILLIONS OF DOLLARS) 2014 2013 $ $ % of Europe % of World 83,000 76,164 11.7% 5.5% 1,250,000 1,172,013 8.4% 5.2% Affiliate Employment*** 110.0 108.0 2.6% 0.9% - Manufacturing*** 49.0 48.6 2.8% 1.0% R&D of Affiliates 1,950 1,858 6.2% 3.8% 345,000 313,211 11.3% 5.2% Affiliate Gross Product Affiliate Assets Foreign Affiliate Sales Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis. *Majority-owned nonbank affiliates (1985-2008). Majority-owned bank and nonbank affiliates 2009-2013. **Author estimates. ***Thousands of employees. 23 FIGURE 1.5 THE GROWING PRESENCE OF U.S. FOREIGN AFFILIATES* IN IRELAND (MILLIONS OF DOLLARS) 2010 2000 $ % of Europe % of World $ % of Europe % of World 61,741 10.3% 5.0% 16,420 5.0% 2.7% 840,882 7.4% 4.3% 106,276 3.7% 2.2% 98.0 2.4% 0.9% 90.5 2.4% 1.1% 54.4 3.1% 1.2% 66.5 3.5% 1.5% 1,431 6.0% 3.6% 465 3.6% 2.3% 269,639 10.8% 5.2% 68,626 5.3% 2.7% 24 As much as US affiliates in Ireland are associated with various service activities—banking, leasing, computer data services, insurance and related activities—manufacturing makes up the bulk of total output among affiliates in Ireland. What’s more, in 2013, manufacturing output from Irish US affiliates was in excess of comparable figures in France ($26.6 billion), and greater than affiliate output from the world’s big league manufacturers, Germany ($42 billion) and China ($31 billion). Digging deeper, under the category of manufacturing, US affiliates in Ireland are large producers of “chemicals” ($16.5 billion in 2013) and “computers and electronic products” ($19.4 billion). Indeed, in both categories, US Irish affiliates are leaders, underscoring the extent of high-valued activities of US affiliates operating in Ireland. This is reflected in IBM’s 2015 Global Locations Trends report which shows that Ireland continued to forge ahead in attracting highvalue foreign direct investment (FDI) projects in terms 3 IBM Global Location Trends: 2015 Annual Report of the quality and value of investments. It heads a list that also includes Switzerland, Sweden, Denmark, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Hong Kong, Finland, India and Germany3. U.S. affiliate assets in Ireland topped $1 trillion for the first time in 2012 and totalled an estimated $1.25 trillion in 2014. Only the United Kingdom, Luxembourg and the Netherlands report more in the way of U.S. assets, although the definition of “total assets” must be used with care. Assets of foreign affiliates include current assets (or assets that can be temporary in nature and can be changed into cash with a short period of time); a fixed asset which can be quickly converted to cash at or near book value; an intangible asset which does not have material substance, like goodwill; and a liquid asset which can very easily be converted into cash without appreciable loss in value. These assets are in constant flux, but that said, year after year, the asset base of US affiliates in Ireland ranks as one of the largest in the world. FIGURE 1.6 MANUFACTURING EMPLOYMENT OF U.S. FOREIGN AFFILIATES** IN IRELAND 25 MANUFACTURING EMPLOYMENT OF U.S. FOREIGN AFFILIATES** IN IRELAND (Thousands of Employees) 60 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 20 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14* 15* *Author estimates **Majority-owned nonbank affiliates (1983-2008). Majority-owned bank and nonbank affiliates 2009-2015. Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis. As shown in Fig 1.5, US Affiliates have ave added tens of thousands Irish workers to their payrolls since the start of the century. That equates to a 21.5% increase in employment growth over the 2000-2015 period, which stands in contrast to France and Spain, for instance, where US affiliate employment declined 15% between 2000 and 2015 in the former and by 4.4% in the latter. Affiliate employment growth was basically flat in Italy over the same period and up only modestly in Germany and the United Kingdom. Reflecting Ireland’s sustained investment-pull factor, the country’s Industrial Development Authority (IDA 4 IDA, End of Year Statement 2015 Ireland) reports that its foreign direct investment sector reached an all-time high of almost 190,000 employees (or almost 10% of the entire Irish workforce) in 2015. The agency reported 213 new inward investment projects for 2015, 44% from organisations making an investment in the country for the first time.4 These investments were broad-based across all existing industry sectors present in Ireland, and the majority of the projects were capital and/or knowledge intensive, seeking to build substantive business units to serve international markets4. 26 27 Manufacturing employment, however resilient recently, has experienced a structural decline since the turn of this century, dropping from 66,500 in 2000 to a low of 47,000 in 2012 before strengthening again to approximately 50,000 in 2015. While much of Ireland’s modern advanced manufacturing base in ICT and healthcare technologies has continued to expand over the past decade, this initial overall dip in manufacturing employment reflects a number of variables including: increasing capital intensity within various manufacturing activities; the leveraging of higher skills within industry; the relocation of lower value-added activities to more competitive locales in central Europe and elsewhere; and the impact of technology on both process and production innovation combined with a globalisation of supply chains. Around the world—and not just in Ireland— firms are manufacturing more goods with less labour and more capital, i.e. via automation. Counter to this trend, however, there has been a greater emphasis on knowledge-based, service-led activities in Ireland, and this has resulted in overall steady employment growth by US affiliates in the country as a whole. As for research and development expenditures, outlays by US affiliates in Ireland totalled $1.9 billion in 2013 and an estimated $2 billion in 2014. Ireland has built-up its research strengths and technological capabilities to establish a reputation for world class research and development in targeted areas aligned to its industry base. For the past decade, and despite the enormous impact of the financial crisis on Ireland’s fiscal policy, the State broadly maintained its commitment to R&D and US multinationals have remained focused on investing in innovative activities within its operations and ecosystems in Ireland. Significantly, US companies’ total spending on R&D in Ireland increased from $465m in 2000 to an estimated $2b in 2014. Ireland has become an increasingly significant R&D location in the past 15 years, and in the process established global credibility in such areas as immunology, nanotechnology, nutritionals, computer science and advanced materials. This is testament to the efforts, amongst others, of successive Governments, Ireland’s commitment to developing scientific and engineering excellence, and active engagement between the academic and business communities on key national innovation priorities. All of these factors helped boost Ireland’s share of US affiliate R&D in Europe to 6.2% in 2013, up from a share of 3.6% in 2000. On a global basis, Ireland accounted for 3.8% of total US affiliate R&D in 2013, a global share not that far behind Japan’s (4.2%), India (5.3%) and China (4.4%). US sales of majority-owned affiliates in Ireland rose more than five-fold between 2000 and 2014, with Ireland’s European share of US affiliate sales in 2013, the last year of available data standing at 11.3%, more than double the level of 2000 (5.3%). The large increase reflects not only the rising export-intensity of US affiliates but also strong local demand for US goods and services. 28 FIGURE 1.7 IRELAND FDI STOCK IN THE U.S. IRELAND FDI STOCK IN THE U.S. (Billions of $) 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis. Ireland’s sizable presence in the United States As one of the largest recipients of FDI, the United States receives capital from many nations around the world, Ireland included. On a historic cost basis, Ireland’s investment stock in the U.S. totalled roughly $16 billion in 2014, an investment stake larger than many other nations like Finland, Denmark, Brazil, China and India. Ireland’s investment stakes in the U.S. are significant, with Irish affiliates generating an estimated $90 billion in affiliate sales in 2013 and $35 billion in U.S. economic output. According to data from the BEA, Irish affiliates in the US sunk some $2.6 billion in research and development in the United States, accounting for 6.6% of total European R&D in the US. Whether through rising output, employment, or R&D expenditures— Ireland’s local presence in the U.S. bestows a host of benefits to the U.S. and U.S. workers. Demonstrating the Substantive Nature of Investments In this report, as in our previous edition on Irish-U.S. economic relations, we have carried out an exercise to adjust the foreign direct investment figures provided by the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) to account for the role of U.S. holding companies in determining U.S. investment flows to Ireland to more accurately pinpoint US affiliate investments producing goods and services within industries based in Ireland. This analytical lens is warranted since U.S. parent companies have been apportioning an increasing share of their foreign direct investment (FDI) to Ireland and the world at large through holding companies. In 2003, the figure was 16% of the total. More recently, nearly half of the total was classified as flows from holding companies. 29 As the BEA notes: “The growth in holding-company affiliates reflects a variety of factors. Some holding-company affiliates are established primarily to coordinate management and administration of activities—such as marketing, distribution, or financing—worldwide or in a particular geographic region. One consequence of the increasing use of holding companies has been a reduction in the degree to which the US Direct Investment Abroad position (and related flow) estimates reflect the industries and countries in which the production of goods and services by foreign affiliates actually occurs.’ 30 FIGURE 1.8 U.S. FOREIGN INVESTMENT STOCK IN IRELAND (EXCLUDING HOLDING COMPANIES) U.S. FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT STOCK IN IRELAND (EXCLUDING HOLDING COMPANIES) (Billions of $) 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 161.0 2014 2013 131.3 2012 111.7 2011 98.8 85.9 2010 69.7 2009 2008 105.0 88.3 2007 2006 75.2 54.0 2005 2004 64.0 2003 51.2 Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis. Adjusted the lens but the same narrative for Ireland Even after adjusting for U.S. FDI flows to Ireland from holding companies, U.S. FDI flows to Ireland remain substantial and critical to the underlying success of U.S. firms, with Ireland clearly among the most favoured nations in the world for Corporate America. Case in point: • In 2014, the last year of complete data, U.S. FDI flows to the nation totalled nearly $33 billion, a record high on this measure. • In 2014, U.S. investment to Ireland rose nearly 63% from the prior year, helping to boost U.S. FDI to the European Union by nearly 50%. On a global basis, US FDI outflows rose by only 11%. • Ireland accounted for 45% of total US FDI to the European Union in 2014, a record high. The figure was nearly 20% of the global total. • Over the 2008-2014 timeframe, cumulative U.S. FDI flows to Ireland tallied $115.9 billion, representing 25.7% of aggregate US FDI to the European Union and 10.3% of the global total. • Over the 2008-14 span, at 10.3% Ireland ranked as the second most attractive market in the world for U.S. FDI, trailing only the United Kingdom (12.0%). • Similarly, over the same period U.S. firms have invested more capital on this measure in Ireland ($115.9 billion) than the BRICs combined ($74 billion). Corporate America’s investment in Ireland since 2008 is more than 5 times larger than comparable investment levels in both China and India. No matter how you cut that data, America’s investment stock in Ireland remains sizable—even after adjusting for flows associated with holding companies. Between 2003 and 2014, America’s investment stock in Ireland (minus capital from holding companies) expanded 214%; while over the same period, U.S. investment stock in the EU rose 97%. FIGURE 1.9 2008-2014: TOP TEN MARKETS FOR U.S. FDI OUTFLOWS EXCLUDING HOLDING COMPANIES (NONBANK) Rank Country $ % of Total 1 United Kingdom 135,275 12.0% 2 Ireland 115,931 10.3% 3 Canada 107,247 9.5% 4 Singapore 68,947 6.1% 5 Netherlands 66,388 5.9% 6 Switzerland 59,716 5.3% 7 Australia 53,471 4.7% 8 Luxembourg 48,657 4.3% 9 United Kingdom Islands, Caribbean 47,796 4.0% 10 Mexico 34,725 3.1% Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis 31 32 The bottom line The depth and breadth of US affiliate activity in Ireland is remarkable and rather unique. The figures depict the extent to which US firms are embedded in the Irish economy—with mutual benefits to both parties. This strong transatlantic linkage not only benefits US parent firms who have turned to Ireland to extend their global reach, boost their competitiveness and enhance their operational performance. It also benefits multiple stakeholders in Ireland. At the same time investment by Irish firms in the U.S. generates an estimated $90 billion in sales, makes significant contributions to research and development, and confers a host of benefits to the U.S. and U.S. workers. developing talent, accelerating innovation, providing business opportunities for indigenous firms, and tax revenues for local and national governments. Higher wages, net employment gains, increased trade, the transfer of technology, the upgrading of managerial and technical skills, access to global markets—the benefits of foreign direct investment for the host nation run the gamut, and hence the global premium governments place on attracting capital investment from the best companies in the world. The combination of a business-friendly climate in Ireland and the large, in-country presence of U.S. firms has helped transform and sustain Ireland’s status as one of the most resilient and dynamic economies in the world. For decades, US firms in Ireland have been instrumental in creating jobs and income for Irish workers, adding skills, raising quality standards, FIGURE 1.10 IRELAND - U.S. GLOBAL LINKAGES 2014 (billions of dollars) U.S. IN IRELAND IRELAND IN U.S. Foreign Direct Investment* 310.6 16.2 Total Assets of Affiliates** 1,250.0 205.0 Foreign Affiliate Sales** 345.0 90.0 Value Added of Affiliates** 83.0 35.0 *Based. on a historic-cost basis. **Author estimates. Data are for majority-owned bank and nonbank affiliates. Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis. 33 IF CALIFORNIA WAS A STANDALONE COUNTRY IT WOULD BE THE 8TH LARGEST ECONOMY IN THE WORLD • Population: 38,802,500 • Dominant Sectors (Private): Trade, Professional & Business Services, Leisure & Hospitality • GDP grew by 2.8% in 2014 • 23.9% of the population is under 18 years • No1. US State for Exports to Ireland with a year on year increase since 2011. In 2015 $952 million worth of goods were exported to Ireland. • California based companies accounted for in access of 25,000 jobs in Ireland. • Enterprise Ireland, from their office in Silicon Valley, work with over 400 Irish technology and software companies either already exporting into the US or looking to export there. Did you know? The announcement in 2015 of new flights to the West Coast now means passengers can travel to Los Angeles four times per week and San Francisco five times a week. Recent investments into Ireland: • Oracle has opened new state-of-the-art offices to accommodate its 450 new roles for Dublin. • LinkedIn announced it now employs 900 people, an increase of 300 over the past twelve months, with more than 100 additional open positions at present. • In the biggest single jobs announcement by a US company in Ireland in over three years Apple is set to create 1,000 new jobs in Cork by expanding its Hollyhill campus. • Workday, a leader in enterprise cloud applications for finance and human resources announced the opening of its new European HQ in Dublin. Workday plans to create another 200 highly skilled jobs for the city over the next three years. 36 Chapter 2: Irish-US Engagement: The Nexus between Foreign Investment and Trade Chapter 2 highlights: • Transatlantic trade and investment between the United States and Ireland is highly complementary. They don’t occur in isolation but are largely driven by each other. • U.S. investment in Ireland has been largely tradecreating for both parties, and in both goods and services, but notably in the latter. Ireland is a critical source of service exports (receipts) for the U.S., while the U.S. is a key market for Irish goods exports. • 36% of US exports (goods) to Ireland were classified as related party trade in 2014. Reflecting the close linkages between US parent firms and their Irish affiliates, nearly 91% of US imports from Ireland were classified as related-party trade in 2014, a record high. This is testimony to the fact that U.S. parents remain dependent on their Irish affiliates for specialized goods and in many cases, services. • Ireland ranks as the fifth largest market in the world for U.S. service exports. In 2014, US service exports to Ireland topped $40 billion for the first time. • Due in part to the presence of trade-oriented U.S. affiliates in Ireland, the nation’s current account balance has rapidly improved over the past few years, with the current account surplus as a percentage of GDP more than doubling between 2013 (3.1%) and 2015 (estimated at 4.5%). • While the United States runs a rather large trade deficit in goods with Ireland ($26.2 billion in 2014), this deficit was nearly offset by the $25.7 billion surplus in services. Net trade, in other words, between Ireland and the United States is relatively balanced. • US affiliate operations in Ireland are primarily geared for exports, particularly to the European Union, with Ireland serving as a strategic beachhead to one of the wealthiest and largest markets in the world. In 2013, roughly onefifth of affiliate sales were to the local market, while so-called 3rd markets (notably the EU) accounted for 61% of the total. Affiliate exports to the United States accounted for the remainder, or just over 19%. • US affiliate sales to the local market is substantial, reaching a record high of roughly $60 billion in 2013, the last year of available data. • On a global basis, Ireland ranked 14th as the largest market in the world for local affiliate sales in 2013. Sales in Ireland were larger than sales in such markets as China, India, Russia and Spain. Ireland is a strategic export platform for US firms, with US affiliate exports from Ireland totalling $244 billion in 2013. 37 38 Of the top twenty exporting companies in Ireland, the majority are domiciled in the United States. Foreign investment and trade rarely occur in isolation, notably when two economic entities are as integrated and interdependent as Ireland and the United States. The two variables are highly correlated since the activities of parents and their affiliates are intertwined and interrelated. Hence the common narrative that most U.S. foreign direct investment obviates the need for crossborder trade is misguided. In many cases, investment drives or supports trade, and vice versa. In the case of Ireland, U.S. affiliates operating on the ground are tightly bound and integrated with their parent firm in the United States, meaning that parent and affiliates are constantly exchanging innovative ideas, goods, intellectual property, capital, and other resources. These activities are referred to as intra-firm activities, with Irish-US intra-firm trade among the strongest in the world. In reality this means the following: US affiliates in Ireland are constantly generating demand for goods and services from their parent company, and vice versa, whether the goods are specialized parts and components manufactured by the parent, or high-value added services, like intellectual property rights that are channelled between the two parties. This type of trade typically leads to trade creation for the home and host nation. Quantifying this dynamic, according to the U.S. Census Bureau, roughly 36% of U.S. exports (goods) to Ireland were classified as related-party trade in 2014, the highest share since 2002. Meanwhile, over 90% of U.S. imports from Ireland were designated as related party trade, well above the U.S. global average. 1 www.cso.ie’ Balance of International Payments Q3 2015 Against this backdrop, U.S. parents remain dependent on their Irish affiliates for specialized goods (pharmarelated goods, chemicals, and medical devices) and services like intellectual property rights, computer/ information services, and related items. The deeper the links between parent firms and their affiliates, the denser the web of related-party trade - as is the case with Ireland and the United States. While U.S. goods exports to Ireland are rather small, service exports are much larger. Indeed, what is notable about U.S. exports to Ireland is the following: services exports (or receipts) are far more prominent than exports of goods, with $7.8 billion in goods exports versus $40.4 billion in service exports. It is trade in services where the link between U.S. foreign direct investment and trade is most evident, with Ireland ranked as the fifth largest market in the world for U.S. service exports in 2014. The bulk of this trade takes place between Irish affiliates of U.S. firms and US parents. Only the United Kingdom, ranked first, followed by the Canada, Japan and China ranked ahead of Ireland. In the end, U.S. investment in Ireland has been largely trade-creating for both parties, and in both goods and services, but notably in the latter. Ireland is a critical source of service receipts for the U.S., while the U.S. is a key market for Irish goods exports. And due in part to the presence of trade-oriented U.S. affiliates in Ireland, the nation’s current account balance has rapidly improved over the past few years, with the current account surplus as a percentage of GDP rising from 3.1% in 2013 to 4.5% by Q3 20151. 39 40 FIGURE 2.1 RELATED PARTY TRADE: IRELAND (MILLIONS OF DOLLARS) U.S. Imports: Total Trade Related Trade 2002 22,374 19,506 2003 25,766 2004 U.S. Exports: Related Party Trade Related Party Trade Total Trade* Related Trade 87.2% 6,387 2,403 37.6% 22,459 87.2% 7,226 2,147 29.7% 27,401 24,480 89.3% 7,615 2,361 31.0% 2005 28,385 24,294 85.6% 8,702 2,710 31.1% 2006 28,921 25,833 89.3% 7,825 2,356 30.1% 2007 30,292 26,867 88.7% 8,427 2,544 30.2% 2008 31,298 27,772 88.7% 8,080 2,263 28.0% 2009 28,102 23,808 84.7% 6,969 2,118 30.4% 2010 33,822 28,004 82.8% 6,489 1,727 26.6% 2011 39,072 34,593 88.5% 6,189 1,483 24.0% 2012 33,198 29,857 89.9% 6,093 1,869 30.7% 2013 31,336 28,660 91.5% 5,659 1,994 35.2% 2014 33,100 30,070 90.8% 6,776 2,436 35.9% *Domestic exports Source: U.S. Census Bureau. . as a % of Total as a % of Total FIGURE 2.2 U.S. IMPORTS OF GOODS FROM IRELAND 41 U.S. IMPORTS OF GOODS FROM IRELAND (Billions of $) 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15* *Monthly data through November annualized for full year estimate. Source: U.S. Census Bureau. Finally, while the United States runs a rather large trade deficit in goods with Ireland ($26.2 billion in 2014), the deficit in goods was nearly offset by the $25.7 billion surplus in services. Net trade, in other words, between Ireland and the United States is relatively balanced. But beyond transatlantic trade flows supported by foreign direct investment, there is yet another component of Irish-U.S. trade that is critically important to both parties. This is the role U.S. affiliates play in driving Irish trade with the rest of the world. Before delving into the specifics of U.S. affiliate trade from Ireland, it is worth noting that the U.S. remains among the largest markets in the world for Irish exports. In 2014, the IMF recorded that the US accounted for 20.6% of Ireland’s global exports, up from a share of 18% in 2012. In the first eight months of 2015, the share bumped up slightly, to 20.8%. 42 The export-propensity of US foreign affiliates Gateway to Europe for US Business U.S. affiliates in Ireland play a unique role for U.S. parent firms. Rather than being designed to serve the local Irish market, U.S. affiliate operations in Ireland are primarily geared for exports—notably to the European Union, with Ireland serving as a strategic beachhead to one of the largest and wealthiest economic entities in the world. It is Ireland’s membership of this cluster of wealthy nations that is highly valued by U.S. multinationals, since U.S. exports to the EU do not enjoy the same preferential treatment as exports from Ireland. Against this backdrop, it is very hard to make the case that U.S. foreign direct investment in Ireland is destroying trade with the United States, or that U.S. FDI is deleterious to the jobs and incomes of U.S. workers. The accompanying Exhibit 2.4 underscores the growth in strategic importance of Irish based units of US firms. Note that in 1982, the split between U.S. foreign affiliate sales in Ireland versus sales for export was roughly 40:60. By 2013, the last year of available data, the ratio was roughly 20:80. The breakdown: local sales accounted for roughly 20% of the total in 2013, while affiliate exports to 3rd markets (notably the EU) accounted for 61% of the total, with the U.S. market accounting for the rest, or 21%. To the contrary, foreign affiliate engagement in Ireland is critical to the success of many U.S. firms, with Ireland’s strategic access to the EU allowing U.S. firms to boost the scale and scope of their operations in Europe in a cost efficient manner, generating, in turn, greater profits, exports, investment and jobs and income in the United States. The greater the output and activity of U.S. affiliates in Ireland, the greater the demand for goods and services from the parent firm in the United States. This, in turn, generates more output for the parent firm. As we have highlighted elsewhere, the activities of U.S. parents and their affiliates are closely bound together, with goods and services being “pushed” and “pulled” between both parties. Notice that for the entire European Union, U.S. affiliate sales are generally geared towards local markets (with local affiliates sales accounting for over half of total sales in 2013), followed by exports to 3rd markets and the U.S., a distant third. Hence, Ireland’s U.S. FDI base serves as a pan-European platform for those firms – reflecting its status as a gateway to the continent. That said, while local affiliate sales in Ireland accounted for just 20% of total sales in 2013, one of the lowest host-sales ratios in Europe, that number is deceiving. It is not that U.S. affiliates are not selling any goods locally to Irish consumers. To the contrary, foreign affiliate sales to the local market totalled roughly $60 billion in 2013, a record high, with local sales greater than comparable figures in such nations as China, India, Russia, and Spain. On a global basis, Ireland was ranked as the 14th largest market in the world for local affiliate sales in 2013. Another note of interest: local foreign affiliates sales of $60 billion in 2013 easily dwarfed US exports of goods and services in the same year ($39 billion), illustrating the sophisticated and complex nature of Irish-U.S. commercial engagement. Ireland’s strategic role as a U.S. export platform is very evident in Exhibit 2.3. In 1982, the nation ranked well down the list as a strategic beachhead for U.S. firms, with Ireland ranked 13th in the world in terms of U.S. foreign affiliate exports. Then, U.S. affiliate exports totalled $2.8 billion, although exports grew to $9.5 billion in 1990 and to $51 billion by 2000. In the first decade of this century, as the industrial capacity of U.S. affiliates in Ireland surged, so did U.S. affiliate exports. With the latter soaring nearly five times between 2000 and 2013. 43 44 FIGURE 2.3 TOP 20 U.S. AFFILIATE SALES ABROAD BY DESTINATION* (MILLIONS OF DOLLARS) 1982 2000 1990 2013 Rank Country Value Country Value Country Value Country Value 1 United Kingdom $33,500 United Kingdom $51,350 United Kingdom $94,712 Singapore $262,748 2 Switzerland $27,712 Canada $46,933 Canada $94,296 Ireland $244,112 3 Canada $25,169 Germany $41,853 Germany $69,522 Switzerland $214,125 4 Germany $19,117 Switzerland $38,937 Netherlands $67,852 United Kingdom $191,603 5 Netherlands $15,224 Netherlands $33,285 Singapore $56,961 Canada $149,524 6 Belgium $11,924 France $24,782 Switzerland $56,562 Germany $121,987 7 Singapore $11,579 Belgium $21,359 Ireland $51,139 Netherlands $118,834 8 France $11,255 Singapore $15,074 Mexico $37,407 Belgium $81,497 9 Indonesia $8,289 Hong Kong $9,951 France $35,797 Mexico $74,286 10 Hong Kong $4,474 Italy $9,562 Belgium $32,010 France $65,295 11 Italy $3,993 Ireland $9,469 Hong Kong $22,470 Hong Kong $57,438 12 Australia $3,710 Spain $7,179 Malaysia $16,013 China $51,691 13 Ireland $2,842 Japan $7,066 Sweden $15,736 Australia $40,393 14 United Arab Emirates $2,610 Australia $6,336 Italy $14,370 Brazil $37,355 15 Brazil $2,325 Mexico $5,869 Spain $12,928 Norway $29,837 16 Japan $2,248 Indonesia $5,431 Japan $11,845 Spain $27,270 17 Malaysia $2,046 Brazil $3,803 Australia $9,370 Malaysia $26,371 18 Panama $1,662 Norway $3,565 Brazil $8,987 Italy $26,341 19 Spain $1,635 Malaysia $3,559 China $7,831 Japan $24,642 20 Mexico $1,158 Nigeria $2,641 Norway $6,238 S. Korea $22,301 All Country Total $252,274 All Country Total $398,873 All Country Total $857,907 All Country Total $2,317,237 Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis. *Destination = 3rd Market + Sales to U.S. for majority-owned bank and nonbank foreign affiliates. 45 FIGURE 2.4 U.S. AFFILIATE SALES IN EUROPE BY DESTINATION CALENDAR 1982 CALENDAR 1990 CALENDAR 2103 Region Local Market Exports to 3rd Market Exports to U.S. Local Market Exports to 3rd Market Exports to U.S Local Market Exports to 3rd Market Exports to U.S World 63.7% 25.6% 10.7% 67.0% 22.8% 10.2% 59.8% 30.4% 9.9% Europe 61.4% 35.0% 3.6% 64.8% 31.2% 4.0% 52.9% 39.6% 7.5% Austria na na na 77.8% 21.1% 1.1% 67.4% 29.9% 2.7% Belgium 39.7% 57.2% 3.1% 41.5% 55.5% 3.0% 38.2% 55.6% 6.3% Denmark n.a. n.a. n.a. 75.7% 20.0% 4.3% 46.6% 46.3% 7.1% Finland 97.6% na na 97.4% 2.3% 0.4% 67.1% 27.7% 5.2% France 74.1% 24.0% 1.9% 72.4% 24.6% 3.0% 69.1% 27.8% 3.0% Germany 69.8% 28.1% 2.1% 68.4% 29.0% 2.6% 63.3% 32.1% 4.6% Ireland 39.5% 56.7% 3.8% 29.3% 64.9% 5.8% 19.6% 61.0% 19.3% Italy 83.0% 16.0% 1.0% 82.3% 16.2% 1.5% 76.2% 19.5% 4.3% Netherlands 44.1% 53.0% 2.9% 41.8% 55.7% 2.5% 45.2% 50.2% 4.6% Norway 45.7% 41.7% 12.6% n.a. 37.7% n.a. 47.2% 49.0% 3.8% Poland n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. n.a. 63.1% 34.4% 2.5% Portugal 76.6% 22.8% 0.6% 79.5% 20.1% 0.4% 76.1% 18.4% 5.5% Spain 72.9% 25.8% 1.3% 74.7% 23.7% 1.7% 64.3% 32.6% 3.1% Sweden 81.0% 18.1% 0.9% 78.8% 19.1% 2.1% 64.5% 29.1% 6.4% Switzerland 12.4% 81.3% 6.3% 25.4% 63.5% 11.1% 24.6% 67.2% 8.2% United Kingdom 68.3% 26.4% 5.3% 74.6% 20.3% 5.1% 68.3% 23.7% 8.1% 46 Affiliate exports totalled $244 billion in 2013, trailing only Singapore, but ahead of Switzerland and the United Kingdom. Relative to other nations, US affiliate exports from Ireland in 2013 were nearly five times greater than comparable exports from China ($51.6 billion), and well ahead of America’s NAFTA partners, Canada ($150 billion) and Mexico ($74 billion). This underscores how much more U.S. multinationals have turned to Ireland as an export base versus low cost locales. On a standalone basis, U.S. affiliate exports from Ireland are greater than most nation’s total exports. Such is the export-intensity of U.S. affiliates in Ireland and the strategic importance of Ireland to the corporate success of U.S. firms operating in Europe. As for these U.S. firms, Exhibit 2.5 lists the top twenty export companies in Ireland. The majority are domiciled in the United States or look to the US as their largest export market—which is hardly surprising given the intensive trade and investment links between the U.S. and Ireland. Summarizing all of the above, expanding Irish-U.S. investment ties have been trade-creating and tradesupporting for both parties. Cross border trade flows are part of the glue that binds the U.S. and Ireland together, to the mutual benefit of all stakeholders. FIGURE 2.5 TOP 20 EXPORT COMPANIES IN IRELAND RANK COMPANY NAME 1 Microsoft Ireland LTD 2 Google Ireland LTD 3 Medtronic Ireland 4 Johnson & Johnson 5 Ingersoll Rand PLC 6 Actavis (Warner Chilcott PLC & Allergan PLC) 7 Dell Products 8 Smurfit Kappa Group 9 Oracle EMEA LTD 10 Pfizer Global 11 Apple Ireland 12 Intel Ireland LTD 13 Kerry Group 14 Boston Scientific Group PLC 15 Kingston Technology International LTD 16 Sandisk International LTD 17 Perrigo Co PLC 18 Total Produce PLC 19 Facebook Ireland Limited 20 MSD Ireland Source: Irish Exporters Association, Top 250 Exporters 2015 47 • Population: 10,097,343 • There are 15 Fortune 500 companies and 26 Fortune 1000 companies with headquarters in Georgia. • The state of Georgia is the 11th largest economy in the United States. • 24.9% of the population under the age of 18 Georgia - Ireland Trade Relationship • Georgia exported $125m worth of Goods to Ireland in 2015. • Ireland is among the top 10 international countries with businesses in Georgia. Irish companies are among the top 10 employers in Georgia employing nearly 9,000 people. • The main sectors with Irish operations include Tech, Construction & Engineering. Georgia is the US HQ for Oldcastle (CRH), the single largest Irish employer of American workers. • Georgia headquartered companies such as Coca Cola contribute to over 5,000 jobs in Ireland. Irish relations with Georgia have been strengthened in recent years with the opening of an Irish Consulate in Atlanta in 2011. • Equifax, a global leader in consumer, commercial and workforce information solutions have announced the opening of a new IT Talent centre in Dublin creating up to 100 highly skilled research roles. • First Data has announced it intends to establish a research and development center in Ireland that will house up to 300 highly skilled employees. • GE Healthcare announced a $40 million investment in its manufacturing facility in Carrigtwohill, Cork. This significant investment will position GE Healthcare globally for growth in developing precision medicine and biopharmaceuticals. 50 Chapter 3: Ireland: A Resurgent Economy • Ireland is rarely compared to either China or India but this unlikely troika were among the fastest growing economies in the world last year, with each posting real economic growth of 6% or better. Comparable rates in the United States and the European Union were 2.5% and 1.5%, respectively. • Key micro traits make Ireland an attractive destination for foreign direct investment as well. These micro characteristics—skills availability, physical and digital infrastructure, established industrial clusters and a growing recognition as a source of innovation—are extremely important in terms of sustaining growth and boosting productivity. • Ireland’s robust growth speaks volumes to the nation’s ability to adapt and adjust to shifting economic circumstances, and the wherewithal of the country to face up to challenging economic circumstances. • Based on various global rankings and metrics, Ireland ranks as one of the most competitive countries in the world, a variable that underpins the economy’s underlying attractiveness to US multinationals. • The nation’s recovery has been gaining momentum thanks to improved competitiveness and its business friendly investment climate combining to propel Ireland to the top of Europe’s growth league. Ireland is expected to remain among the strongest economies in the European Union again in 2016. • In the latest readings from the IMD World Competitiveness Yearbook Rankings Ireland ranked 16th, up from a ranking of 24th in 2011. Ireland ranked Number One for the fourth straight year in its track record in attracting high value-add, knowledge intensive projects according to an IBM-produced global index of favoured investment locations. Chapter 3 highlights: • Ireland’s economic and employment expansion is broadening and gaining strength across all sectors of the economy. Investment spending is expected to remain solid in 2016; personal consumption expenditures remain healthy; and add in that net exports are forecast to make a positive contribution to growth in 2016, and Ireland is firing on all cylinders • The growth dynamic within Ireland, in addition to the nation’s ability to adapt to prevailing global conditions, makes it a natural economic partner for the United States. Growth attracts growth. • At both the macro and micro level, Ireland has done an admirable job of differentiating itself within Europe and also from many emerging markets. This has not gone unnoticed by international investors. 51 52 Ireland is rarely compared to either China or India, or mentioned in the same breath with Asia’s economic giants. Ireland’s entire population, after all, is just a fraction of a typical city in both nations, as is the nation’s total GDP. But that said, there is a common denominator linking the three nations: against a backdrop of fragile global economic growth, this unlikely troika were among the fastest growing economies in the world last year, with each posting real economic growth of 6% or better. Comparable rates in the United States and the European Union were 2.5% and 1.5%, respectively. That Ireland achieved Indian and Chinese-like growth rates last year speaks volumes to the nation’s ability to adapt and adjust to shifting economic circumstances, and the wherewithal of the country to face up to challenging economic circumstances. From peak to trough, output in Ireland fell by 21% in nominal terms following the global financial crisis, while real output fell almost 10% between 2008, and 2010 as falling consumer demand, combined with public sector contraction and a decline in domestic capital investment converged to suppress growth. Then, Ireland was considered part of Europe’s troubled periphery and categorized with the slow-growth, structurally-flawed nations of the Mediterranean. However, as Exhibit 3.1 highlights, while Ireland’s output contraction was notably deep relative to Spain and Italy, the nation’s economy snapped back much faster than others, aided and abetted by a number of factors. First, unit costs adjusted faster in Ireland than in other European nations. Second, the rebound was assisted by the nation’s key attributes of competitive corporate taxes, a flexible and highly skilled workforce, and its FIGURE 3.1 IRELAND VERSUS CLUB MED IRELAND VERSUS CLUB MED Real GDP (annual percent change) 7 5 Ireland 3 Spain Portugal Italy 1 -1 -3 -5 -7 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 *IMF 2015 estimate; 2016 forecast. Ireland data for 2015 & 2016 author estimates. 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015* 2016* pro-enterprise and jobs policies. These dynamics helped create a third pillar to growth: surging levels of foreign direct investment flows, with rising capital inflows from overseas (notably from the US) boosting employment, incomes, exports, and government revenue in 2015. On a global basis, very few nations have leveraged foreign direct investment as a vehicle of growth in the post-crisis era as well as Ireland. Ireland has been propelled to the top of Europe’s growth league. In the third quarter of 2015, the last available data, Ireland’s economy expanded by 1.4% quarteron-quarter, well above the 0.3% for the euro area in general. Exhibit 3.2 highlights Ireland’s 6.6% growth in 2015 (estimated) versus the rest of Europe. The growth differential is basically night and day. Average annual growth in the Euro Area and wider European Union accelerated last year, but was still shy of 2% for the year. Europe’s core—Germany and France—posted growth of less than 2%. Nevertheless, courtesy of lower oil prices, the depreciation of the euro, and monetary easing, most of Europe is in the midst of a measured but positive cyclical recovery. FIGURE 3.2 IRELAND LEADS EURO AREA GROWTH FORECASTS IRELAND LEADS EURO AREA GROWTH FORECASTS (Real GDP Growth, 2015) Ireland* Malta Slovakia Spain Luxembourg Slovenia Latvia Netherlands Estonia Portugal Germany Lithuania Euro area Belgium Cyprus France Italy Austria Finland Greece -2 *Author estimate. Source: European Commission Data as of November 2015. -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 53 54 That is the good news. The worrisome news is that the durability of the expansion remains uncertain. Greece’s debt burden, Europe’s refugee crisis, the continent’s aging workforce, the collapse in trade with Russia, China’s economic slowdown, structurally poor productivity levels across the region—all of these factors will weigh on aggregate growth towards 2020. That the French President pronounced that the nation confronted an “economic emergency” at the start of the New Year speaks volumes about the structural challenges to growth in Europe. Yet Ireland is expected to remain among the strongest economies in the European Union in 2016. Economic growth is forecast to moderate this year, although expected real annual growth of up to 4.5% would maintain Ireland’s pole position as the fastest growing economy in the European Union.1 What’s more, 2016 should mark the sixth year that Ireland has outperformed or expanded at a faster clip than the euro area average, 1 European Commission, Winter Economic Report 2015 a remarkable achievement considering that Ireland initially emerged as one of Europe’s more fragile economies in the aftermath of the Great Recession of 2009-2011. As Figure 3.3 highlights, Ireland’s growth rate this year will be modestly lower than India and China, but well ahead of the pace expected in Russia and Brazil. What’s more, Ireland’s expansion is broadening and gaining strength across all sectors of the economy. Investment spending in the economy is expected to remain solid this year, assisted in part by rising foreign direct investment. Courtesy of rising employment and low inflation, personal consumption expenditures are expected to expand by 3-4%. Net exports are forecast to continue to make a positive contribution to growth this year. Add in a modest expansion in government spending, and Ireland is generating economic activity on all cylinders—a rare feat in today’s world. FIGURE 3.3 IRELAND VERSUS BRICs 55 IRELAND VERSUS BRICS Real GDP (annual percent change) 15 10 India China 5 Ireland 0 Russia Brazil -5 -10 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 *IMF 2015 estimate; 2016 forecast. Ireland data for 2015 & 2016 author estimates. Data as of October 2015 Source: IMF 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015* 2016* 56 Meanwhile, as the economy has improved over the past few years, so have many key macro indicators. The general government deficit, for instance, is expected to have fallen to 1.5% % of GDP in 2015 off the back of stronger-than-expected tax receipts. That is down from 3.9% of GDP and solidly below the original target of 2.7%. The narrowing public sector deficit, in turn, has helped trim general government debt, which dropped below the 100% of GDP mark at the end of 2015 for the first time since 2010. Estimated by the European 2 European Commission, Winter 2016 Economic Forecast Commission at 98% of GDP in 2015, Ireland’s debt level is not far from the Euro-zone average of 94%, and has dropped steadily over the past few years2. The growth dynamic within Ireland, in addition to the nation’s ability to adapt to prevailing global conditions, makes it a natural economic partner for the United States. Growth attracts growth. In addition, favourable micro economic components also explain the deep integration between the Irish-US economies, and is the topic of the next section. FIGURE 3.4 IRELAND VERSUS THE EUROPEAN UNION 57 IRELAND VERSUS THE EUROPEAN UNION Real GDP (annual percent change) 7 5 3 1 -1 -3 -5 -7 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015* 2016* *IMF 2015 estimate; 2016 forecast. Ireland data for 2015 & 2016 author estimates. Data as of October 2015. Source: IMF IRELAND EU The view from the ground up It is not just the macro backdrop that makes Ireland an attractive destination for foreign direct investment. Key micro traits are critical as well. These micro characteristics—skills availability, physical and digital infrastructure, established industrial clusters and a growing recognition as a source of innovation—are extremely important in terms of sustaining growth and boosting overall productivity. Such variables are critical in determining the overall competitiveness of a nation; in turn, a country’s over-arching competitiveness acts as a key signal or metric for multinationals when deciding where to invest globally. For U.S. firms, investing at home is just as attractive now as investing overseas. With a large skills pool; a sophisticated financial sector; innovative incubators sprinkled all over the country; and some of the lowest energy costs among the developed nations—many US firms are opting to stay at home when it comes to investing, putting a high threshold on nations like Ireland to get it right to attract inward investment. The key investment trends among US multinationals are: 1) firms are doing more with less thanks to surging use and innovations within automation, robotics and other advanced technologies; 2) firms are doing more at 58 home given the cost competitiveness of the U.S. market; and 3) they are doing more in fewer global locations, as supply chains are rationalized and consolidated and the number of suppliers within the orbit of multinationals are reduced for greater effectiveness and deeper strategic partnerships. US investment in Europe, for instance, has become very concentrated over the past decade, with Ireland one of the favoured locations. So why Ireland? Because the business climate, based on various global rankings and metrics, ranks as one of the most competitive in the world, a variable that underpins the economy’s underlying attractiveness to multinationals. In the latest readings from the IMD World Competitive Yearbook Rankings3, for instance, Ireland ranked 16th, up from a ranking of 24th in 2011 as the country got to grips with the fallout from the Great Recession. Among the top variables cited by respondents as key attributes of Ireland: a competitive tax regime; a business-friendly environment, a skilled/educated labour force, and policy stability. Specifically, Ireland ranked Number One in the flexibility and adaptability of its workforce; Number One for the availability of senior management talent; and Number Four for most motivated work force. Overall the US ranked as the most competitive in the world, which is one reason America itself remains among the most favoured destinations in the world for inward investment. Ireland also fared well in the World Bank’s latest Ease of Doing Business report4, with Ireland ranked 17th out of 189 nations in the last survey. This survey is significant in that it takes into account critical micro issues like how long it takes to start a business; time and costs to connect to the electrical grid, build a warehouse and transfer property; and time and costs related to commercial dispute settlements, tax regulations and credit information. Other significant variables included: the independence of the judiciary and the quality of regulations regarding real estate, electricity and related items. A critical point related to the Ease of Doing Business Index4 is this: while the rate by which a particular nation grows and expands certainly matters to US multinationals, the ease of doing business, or the efficiency and competency of rules and regulations, in a given location is also immensely important to firms. Country and industry rules and regulations can either help or hinder business and investment and thus negate the positive macro dynamics of economic growth, market size and related variables. To shed more light on this topic, one can examine the World Bank annual rankings for the regulatory climate of 189 nations. Per the specifics, Ireland scored well in a number of key categories including: border compliance, documentary compliance, domestic transport, strength of legal rights, credit information, time it takes to start a business, dealing with construction permits and registering property. These functions are about the details, and on multiple fronts, Ireland gets the details right. 3 ‘www.img.org’ IMD, World Competitiveness Yearbook 2015 4 ‘www.doingbusiness.org’ Word Bank, Ease of Doing Business 2015 Meanwhile, when it comes to high-value foreign direct investment, Ireland ranked 1st for the fourth straight year according to an IBM-produced index. The indicator asses the added value and knowledge intensity of jobs created by investment projects, with Ireland at the top of the league due to the nation’s ability to attract highend FDI in such industries as life sciences, ICT and related activities. This type of investment is critical to any nation’s economy since this investment is typically associated with high-paying employment opportunities. Ireland is now in the Global Top 20 for the quality of its scientific research, and is ranked first in the world for its research in nanoscience, second in computer science and in immunology, third in animal and dairy science, and fifth in materials science5. 5 And the list of competitive accolades goes on. As highlighted in Figure 3.5, Ireland ranked 4th in the Forbes Best Country for Business and 4th in the 2015 Global Supply Chain Resilience Index. Overall, Ireland scores well in a number of salient benchmarks of global competitiveness. These figures speak to the micro attributes of Ireland and critical on-the-ground metrics that greatly influence where multinationals decide to invest. By various metrics, Ireland fares very well. At both the macro and micro level, Ireland has done an admirable job of differentiating itself within Europe and also from many emerging markets. This has not gone unnoticed by US multinationals looking to invest in global operations. Thomson Reuters, Essential Science IndicatorsSM FIGURE 3.5 IRELAND VERSUS THE WORLD Measure Year Index and Rank World Bank "Ease of Doing Business" Rank 2016 (17/189) IMD World Competitiveness Rank 2015 (16/61) FM Global Supply Chain Resilience Index 2015 (4/130) Forbes Best Country for Business 2015 (4/145) IBM Global Location Trends 2014 1* *Top-ranking destination by average job value of investment projects. It includes all countries with more than 30 investment projects. Sources: World Bank; IMD; FM Global; Forbes; IBM. Data as of November 2015. . 59 New York is the third largest economy in the United States. If New York State were an independent nation, it would rank as the 15th largest economy in the world GDP GREW BY 2.5% IN 2014 POPULATION: 19.75MILLION 21.6% OF THE POPULATION UNDER 18 New York City dominates the economy of the state. It is the leading centre of banking, finance and communications in the United States and with the location of the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) on Wall Street it continues to be central to financial life in the US New York - Ireland Trade Relationship • 10th Largest US State for Exports to Ireland, with exports of $234 million in 2015. • In 2014, the most recent year for which figures exist, Ireland was the 19th largest international importer of goods and services to the state of New York. Irish imports in that year totalled $1.605 billion. • New York based companies contribute in excess of 13,000 jobs in Ireland • The traditional areas of focus for Irish companies investing in New York are in the financial services, retail, educational and construction sectors. Irish companies with US headquarters in New York include Trinity Biotech, which specialises in producing diagnostic kits. • Pfizer announced approximately 130 jobs across three manufacturing sites in Ireland including Grange Castle in Dublin and Little Island and Ringaskiddy in Cork. • Regernon, a leading science-driven biopharmaceutical company announced an additional $350 million investment in Limerick. This will add another 200 jobs, bringing the total expected job creation in the Limerick area to 500 jobs and total investment to $650 million by the end of 2017. • IBM is to expand its IBM Ireland Analytics & Solutions Lab to advance cloud collaboration and HR analytics software that help organisations build and maintain a smarter workforce. It is anticipated that this expansion will create up to 110 jobs. Did You Know? Irish state agencies with offices in New York include the IDA, Enterprise Ireland and Bord Bia. Chapter 4: A Testing Time for the Future of the Transatlantic Economy Chapter 4 highlights: • The transatlantic economy remains one of the most important arteries of commercial activity and exchange in the global economy. The United States, like Ireland, has emerged stronger from the financial crisis and is poised to continue on the path of growth. The European Union is expected to expand by roughly 2% in 2016 • Importantly, the growth gap between the US and EU is improving: the US economy is expected to expand by around 2.5%, thus narrowing the growth gap to 0.5 percentage points versus a growth gap as high as 3 percentage points in 2012. • The transatlantic energy gap has also narrowed in the past year thanks to the collapse in world oil prices, which has benefited the United States and Europe. The cost advantage enjoyed by US firms thanks to the North American shale revolution has been offset or neutralized by surging production from Saudi Arabia and Russia, which has helped reduce world oil prices from a peak of around $110 per barrel in June 2014 to between $30-35 at the start of 2016. • Divergence in trade, job creation, and the development of the digital economy between the two economic blocs presents real challenges to a true partnership. Transatlantic policies on the digital economy between the US and the EU remain uncoordinated - yet a strategic approach to the shared digital economy has massive potential, with some 315 million internet users spread across the European Union and another 280 million users in the USA. • The US Federal Reserve and ECB are operating under different assumptions and expectations. While the US Federal Reserve is expected to raise rates at least twice in 2016, the ECB is expected to remain on hold; one consequence could be an even stronger US dollar relative to the Euro. • Seven years after the global financial crisis, the transatlantic economy is healing, albeit slowly. There are still gaps to be closed, policies to be coordinated, and work to be done in tightening the bonds of the United States and Europe, but the cyclical rebound in Europe will assist in all three areas. • The secular case for investing in Europe remains positive since the European Union remains one of the largest economies in the world. In nominal U.S. dollar terms, the European Union (plus Norway, Switzerland, Iceland) accounted for 25.6% of world output in 2014; greater than America’s share (22.5%) and well in excess of China’s—13.4%. • In addition to being large, Europe is also wealthy, and wealth matters. Wealth is correlated with highly skilled labour, innovation, and a world class R&D infrastructure, among other things. Gaining access to wealthy consumers is among the primary reasons why US firms invest overseas, and hence the continued attractiveness of wealthy Europe to American companies. 63 64 • Europe continues to attract more than half of U.S. aggregate foreign direct investment (FDI) outflows, with Ireland contributing strongly to the region’s overall success. Europe’s share of U.S. FDI has remained relatively constant at 56% of the total over this decade, basically unchanged from the first decade of this century but up slightly from the 1990s level. • Europe, long the weak link of the global economy, is in recovery mode and remains a formidable economic entity. The region remains large, wealthy, and richly endowed with human capital, respect for the rule of law, political stability, and other business-friendly policies. 2015 was a challenging year for the European Union. The Greek financial and political crisis, terrorism in the streets of European cities, continued conflict in Ukraine, a staggering refugee crisis, the risk of the United Kingdom exit from the Union—all of these dynamics have emerged to challenge the unity of the European Union membership and test the commitment of corporate America to one of the largest economic blocs in the world. Growth in both the US and Europe is accelerating, and if we have learned anything since our last publication, the developing nations, notably China, are not without their own internal problems and challenges, and are not ready to shoulder the burden of leading the global economy. Indeed, if anything, the developing nations are now a collective drag on global growth, with such large and important markets as Brazil, Russia and South Africa mired in recession. Hence, the transatlantic economy remains one of the most important arteries of commercial activity and exchange in the global economy. The United States, like Ireland, has emerged stronger from the global financial crisis and is poised to continue on the path of growth. In addition, the cyclical rebound in Europe, propelled by falling oil prices, a weaker euro and monetary easing from the ECB is gaining momentum. The European Union is expected to expand by roughly 2% in 2016, with only Greece expected to post negative growth again this year. 65 66 FIGURE 4.1 U.S. VS EU UNEMPLOYMENT RATE U.S. VS. EU UNEMPLOYMENT RATE (%) 12 11 10 EU 9 8 7 6 U.S. 5 4 3 2 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 Data as of January 2016. Source: OECD. Minding the Transatlantic gaps Importantly, the growth gap between the US and EU is improving: against roughly 2% growth this year in the EU, the US economy is expected to expand by around 2.5%, thus narrowing the growth gap to 0.5 percentage points versus a growth gap as high as 3 percentage points in 2012. A key difference, of course, is that the US is well into an elongated economic expansion, while the economic upturn in the EU is just beginning to gather strength. The transatlantic energy gap has also narrowed in the past year thanks to the collapse in world oil prices, which has benefited both the United States and Europe. The cost advantage enjoyed by US firms thanks to the North American shale revolution has been offset or neutralized by surging production from Saudi Arabia and Russia, which has helped reduce world oil prices from a peak of around $110 per barrel in June 2014 to a third of that as we start 2016. While energy costs remain structurally higher in Europe than the US due to the former’s fragmented energy markets, America’s cost advantage has been narrowed by the energy shock of the last year. In contrast, three other transatlantic gaps—employment, trade and digital—have seen little improvement in the past year. While the jobs backdrop in Europe has improved over the past year, the improvement has been On the trade front, divergent growth and the depreciation of the euro against the US dollar have manifested themselves in America’s widening trade gap (in goods) with the European Union. The trade gap totaled $139.6 billion in the first eleven months of last year, and roughly $151 billion for the year, another record high. As shown on Fig 4.2 America’s trade deficit with the EU has increased six years in a row, and more than doubled between 2009 and 2015. In the first eleven months of 2015, US imports from the EU rose 2.1% from the prior year, while US exports slipped 1.2% from the same period, boosting America’s trade deficit with the EU by 8.6%. nowhere near the extent and pace of the United States. From a peak of 10% in October 2009, the US jobless rate has been cut in half, dropping to 5% at the end of 2015. For the year, the US economy added over two million new jobs, although wage gains have remained relatively subdued. The U.S. unemployment rate is expected to trend lower this year, to around 4.5%, well ahead of projected jobless rates in the majority of states in Europe. According to Eurostat, the unemployment rate in the Euro area was roughly 10.4% at year-end 2015, with a number of nations struggling to combat joblessness. For December 2015, the unemployment rate in Spain was over 20%, 11% in Italy, 12% in Portugal, and 10% in France. FIGURE 4.2 U.S. TRADE BALANCE WITH EUROPE U.S. TRADE BALANCE WITH EUROPE (Billions of $) 0 -20 -40 -60 -80 -100 -120 -140 -160 -180 00 01 02 03 04 *Estimate based on monthly data through November 2015. 05 06 07 08 Source: U.S. Census Bureau 09 10 11 12 13 14 15* 67 68 Reflecting the growth differential between the US and Europe over the past few years, US exports to EU last year —estimated at $275 billion—slipped below the pre-crisis levels of $277 billion recorded in 2008. Notable spots of weakness: US exports to Germany, Greece, Portugal and Spain still remain below pre-crisis levels; nearly half of America’s EU trade deficit in 2015 emanated from Germany—Europe’s largest economy and largest trader. For the year, the US merchandise trade deficit with Germany totaled an estimated $74 billion in 2015, relatively flat from the year before. However, America’s trade deficit with Germany last year was larger than America’s trade gap with Japan. In addition to trade and employment, there exists a digital gap between the US and European Union as well. Indeed, Europe’s more precautionary-based approached to digital regulations, and the EU’s extensive rules and regulations regarding personal data, and cross border rules governing e-commerce sales is often contrasted with America’s approach towards the digital economy. In general, the U.S.-led development of software, social media, cloud computing, Big Data, and related activities are regarded in the U.S. as facing stiff policy resistance and constraints across Europe. In the US, the prevailing view is that a backlash to the digital economy is building in Europe, which could undermine Europe’s technological future. At risk: growth in US-EU trade in digitally deliverable services like advertising, legal services, finance, software, architectural design, and consulting, as well as activities like the management of intellectual property. In that USEU trade and investment in services holds significant growth potential for both parties, policies that overly impede innovation on the Internet or the free flow of data across borders could curb transatlantic trade/ investment in services and weaken transatlantic supply chains—the very linkages that should be binding the two parties together in the digital age. FIGURE 4.3 THE DIGITAL DIVIDE: U.S. VS WESTERN EUROPE 69 THE DIGITAL DIVIDE: U.S. VS WESTERN EUROPE (IT spending: % of global total) 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 2006 U.S. 2007 2008 2009 2011 2012 2013 2014 Western Europe Data as of December 2015. Source: International Data Corporation. In a world where every day there are 803 million Tweets; 36 million Amazon purchases; 8.8 billion YouTube videos watched; 186 million Instagram photos taken; 152 million Skype calls; and 4.2 billion Google searches, the US and Europe must not work at cross purposes, with transatlantic policies on the digital economy uncoordinated and fashioned more on ad hoc basis as opposed to a coherent strategic game plan. Yet the EU digital economy has massive potential, with some 315 million internet users spread across the European Union. The problem lies with the EU’s fragmented digital markets, and the existing barriers 1 2010 to enter among EU members. As a result, much of the digital market in Europe is either solidified around national lines or runs off US-based online services. Indeed, according to the European Commission1, national online services account for 42% of the EU total, while US-based online services account for 54%. Meanwhile, EU cross border online services represent only 4% of the digital market in EU. In other words, EU consumers are more likely to buy something on line locally, as opposed to buying something in another member state. According to the European Commission, only 7% of SMEs in the EU sell cross-border, with SMEs facing ‘http://ec.europa.eu/’ European Commission, Digital Single Market 70 around €9,000 in extra costs for having have to adapt to national laws. Also not helping matters, SMEs online businesses conducting cross border transactions confront a VAT compliance cost of at least €5,000 annually for each EU member state it wishes to supply or ship to. This stifles growth and cross-border trade and investment. To this point, according to the European Commission, if the same rules for e-commerce were applied in all EU member states, 57% of companies surveyed would either start or increase their online sales to other EU nations. Not only are EU regulations stifling to businesses, so is Europe’s underdeveloped digital infrastructure. According to the Commission, only 59% of Europeans can access 4G technology, while the figure drops to just 15% in rural areas. Yet a final key difference between the US and the EU lies with monetary policy. In this realm, American and European officials are working in opposite directions. While the US Federal Reserve, after raising rates in December, is expected to raise rates at least twice in 2016, the ECB is expected to remain on its current course, and maintain ultra-low interest rates over the balance of 2016. This monetary divergence reflects the different growth paths of the US and Europe, with the former’s economic expansion well established and entrenched versus Europe’s nascent and less than balanced recovery. As the US Federal Reserve raises rates this year while the ECB remains on hold, one consequence could be an even stronger US dollar relative to the Euro. The bottom line: the digital gap between the U.S. and Europe remains substantial. With so much commerce, trade and investment going digital, with the global digital economy set to explode with more entrants from the developing nations, Europe risks being left behind. It is to be hoped that an ambitious set of reforms can deliver a Digital Single Market in the EU; and one that boosts Europe’s digital potential to the benefit of the transatlantic economy. In the end, seven years after the global financial meltdown of 2008-09, the transatlantic economy is gradually healing, albeit slowly. There are still gaps to be closed, policies to be coordinated, and work to be done in tightening the bonds of the United States and Europe. The cyclical rebound in Europe will assist in all three areas; importantly, the transatlantic economy is gaining some cyclical steam, which should engender rising capital inflows and outflows across the Atlantic. But beyond cyclical components, the case for continued investment in Europe remains and is discussed below. In time, both the US and Europe will adapt and embrace disruptive technologies—but at a different pace and different scale, creating friction and tension points between the two parties. Notwithstanding the many shared values and strategic bonds of the US and Europe, the parties have significant differences over the rules of engagement regarding the Internet and cross border flows of massive amounts of data. Managing this transatlantic digital divide is highly important to the future of the transatlantic partnership. Why Europe Still Matters 71 The secular case for investing in Europe remains positive for a number of reasons. First, while both the United States and China loom large in the hierarchy of the global economy, so does the European Union, still one the largest economies in the world. This fact is often overlooked or ignored by a common consensus, which is more attuned with what’s wrong with Europe, as opposed to what’s right. As shown in Fig. 4.4, in 2014 the European Union (plus Norway, Switzerland, Iceland) accounted for 25.6% of world output in nominal U.S. dollar terms according to estimates from the International Monetary Fund. That was greater than America’s share (22.5%) and well in excess of China’s—13.4%. Even based on purchasing power parity figures, the European Union’s share was slightly greater than both the United States and China in 2014. FIGURE 4.4 SHARE OF THE WORLD GDP, 2014 SHARE OF WORLD GDP, 2014 (% of World Total) 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 EU 28 + ISK + CHE + NOK Source: International Monetary Fund. Data as of October 2015. U.S. China India 72 Second, in addition to being on the mend and one of the largest economic blocs in the world, Europe is also wealthy, and wealth matters. Wealth is correlated with highly skilled labour, rising per capita income, innovation, and a world class research and innovation infrastructure, among other things. In the aggregate, 15 of the 25 wealthiest nations in the world are European. Per capita levels in Europe are light years ahead of those in India and China, and all of Africa. Wealth drives consumption, with the EU accounting for nearly 25% of global personal consumption expenditures in in 2014 as shown in Fig 4.5, a slightly lower share than that of the United States but well above that of China (roughly 9%) and India (less than 3%) and the BRICs combined (roughly 17%). Gaining access to wealthy consumers is among the primary reasons why US firms invest overseas, and hence the continued attractiveness of wealthy Europe to American companies. And third, as discussed elsewhere in this report, real growth in the emerging markets has move down a gear, notably in Brazil, Russia and China. Both Russia and Brazil are in recession, and are expected to remain so over the course of 2016. Growth prospects in China, meanwhile, have slowed considerably as the nation shifts towards more consumption and service-led growth and away from export- and investment-driven growth. 2015 was a very challenging year for China, and more challenges are in front of the country. India’s economy is on the rebound but the nation is not developed enough and too closed to make much of a difference to the trade and investment ties with the U.S. While the nations just mentioned are regularly hyped as among the most dynamic in the world, strong real GDP growth does not necessarily equate to a favorable environment for business. Other factors need to be factored into the equation, like the rise of state capitalism in many developing nations, continued intellectual property right infringements, capital controls, and discriminating domestic policies against foreign firms. These factors have become favorite policy tools in many key emerging markets, further enhancing the attractiveness of Europe—notably Ireland—in the eyes of U.S. multinationals. Given all of the above, Europe continues to attract more than half of U.S. aggregate foreign direct investment (FDI) outflows, with Ireland contributing strongly to the region’s overall success. As Fig 4.6 shows, Europe’s share of U.S. FDI has remained relatively constant at 56% of the total over this decade, basically unchanged from the first decade of this century but up slightly from the 1990s level. In summary, Europe, for a long time the weak link of the global economy, is in recovery mode and remains a formidable economic entity. The region remains large, wealthy, and richly endowed with human capital, respect for the rule of law, political stability, and other business-friendly policies. Due to all of the above, Europe will remain a critical and indispensable location in the global operations of U.S. companies, with Ireland front and centre as a bridge linking the United States and Europe together. FIGURE 4.5 SHARE OF WORLD PERSONAL CONSUMPTION, 2014 73 SHARE OF WORLD PCE, 2014 (% of World Total) 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 United States EU 28 + ISK + CHE + NOK China India Source: United Nations. Data as of December 2015. FIGURE 4.6 CUMULATIVE U.S. FDI OUTFLOWS (Millions of $) FIGURE 4.6 CUMULATIVE U.S. FDI OUTFLOWS (Millions of $) Europe as a All Countries Europe % of World 20,363 3,997 19.6% 1960-1969 40,634 16,220 39.9% 1970-1979 122,721 57,937 47.2% 1980-1989 171,880 94,743 55.1% 1990-1999 869,489 465,336 53.5% 2000-2009 2,056,009 1,149,810 55.9% 2010Q1-2015Q3 1,850,513 1,042,439 56.3% 1950-1959 Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis Data as of January 2016. • Texas’s large population, natural resources, & leading higher education institutions have contributed to a large and diverse economy. • As a stand-alone country, it would be the 12th biggest economy in the world • Population: 26.96 million • GDP grew by 5.2% in 2014 • 26.6% of the population is under the age of 18 • Texas has been the top exporting state in the US for 12 consecutive years, with over $279.7 billion a year. Did You Know? In 2015, Ireland has officially opened the new Irish Consulate in Austin to further enhance bilateral links. Announcements In 2015, Dell announced that it is creating 100 new Innovation Technology R&D roles at its Limerick Campus. Texas- Ireland Trade Relationship • Ireland’s economic relationship with Texas has developed significantly in recent years, with a 21% rise in Irish imports to Texas in one year from 2013 to 2014 and a 33% rise in exports from Texas over the same period. • Texas was the 6th largest US state exporter to Ireland exporting $407m worth of exports in 2015. • With large university systems coupled with initiatives like the Texas Enterprise Fund and the Texas Emerging Technology Fund, a wide array of different high tech industries have developed in Texas including Dell who have multiple operations in Ireland. • Notable examples of Texan companies who have established European operations in Ireland include Alcon, KCI (both medical devices), LoneStar funds (financial services), BMC Software, and engineering and R&D company Cameron. • Irish companies feature across sectors with operations in Software, Life Sciences & Engineering. • Between 2003 and 2013 Irish companies invested $849.6m in FDI into Texas (creating 1483 jobs). Chapter 5: The Road Ahead for Irish-US Commercial Relationship Chapter 5 highlights: • Looking ahead to 2020, the United States and Ireland now stand as two of the strongest economies of the transatlantic partnership, drawing strength and stability from each other. • The mutual dependence of Ireland and the United States has grown stronger since 2008. And as we have highlighted in the past, the commercial ties between Ireland and the United States are built to last. • For Ireland to remain attractive for investment, Europe must find a sustainable path to growth and muster the political will to tackle the difficult challenges before it. The response to the recent refugee crisis has exposed the short comings of the EU—its lack of co-ordination among member states and political indecisiveness. • Ireland is a small open economy highly exposed to global shocks and cycles. That means the nation can never rest, and must always remain diligent about sustaining and nurturing its competitiveness. • Having established its reputation as a global centre of operational excellence for its FDI base and built new credentials in fundamental research and process innovation, Ireland should seek to build out an innovation ecosystem to more applied and commercial ventures with stronger local, academic and business collaborations to become a recognized source of creativity for global corporations seeking growth and shareholder value. 77 78 • Ireland has an opportunity to become a champion of Europe’s digital single market and help shape EU initiatives that create more technological synergies between the EU and the US. • The critical task in front of Ireland is ensuring its place in the high-end, value-added chain of multinationals, notably in services and evolving technologies that will change the nature of work and production. Ireland understands this dynamic very well. Rising to the challenge is something Ireland excels at, with the nation’s economic acceleration in the past year just one more piece of evidence of Ireland’s dynamic economic character. • For Ireland, the successful agreement of a new USEU trade and investment treaty would incrementally add to growth, employment, incomes and trade, with particular benefits to its medical technologies, pharmaceutical, information technology and broadbased manufacturing sectors. In a world in perpetual change, one strand of continuity remains - the sturdy economic bond between Ireland and the United States. Since the start of the century, Irish-US linkages have become stronger, not weaker. Looking to the future, the United States and Ireland now stand as two of the strongest economies of the transatlantic partnership, drawing strength and stability from each other. The mutual dependence of Ireland and the United States has grown stronger since 2008 and is built to last. Yet much remains in play. The Irish-US partnership is not immune to the turbulence buffeting the global economy. The emerging economies are struggling with one of the worst cyclical downturns in decades. The geopolitics of the Middle East continue to deteriorate. The plunge in oil prices has unhinged the global capital markets. China faces years of slower growth. And although the European Union is in the midst of a cyclical recovery, many structural issues confront its member states. The debate in the U.K. on continuing E.U. membership has raised uncertainty as to the direction of the Union. The refugee crisis has stirred the same concerns, with rising risks that member states will close their borders to those wishing to cross them freely. The response to the recent crisis has exposed the short comings of the EU—its lack of co-ordination among member states and political indecisiveness, thus impacting confidence in the largest economic bloc in the world. Greater coherence is needed to ensure the ‘European Project’ continues and the Euro survives. Yet again in 2016, there is talk of political strife – the UK referendum, the risk that Greece struggles as a Euro Zone member, regional independence pressures in Spain, the emergence of reactionary political movements with ‘pop-economic’ policy appeal - scenarios that only serves to damage business confidence in Europe and its economy on both sides of the Atlantic. For Ireland to remain attractive for investment, Europe must find a sustainable path to growth and muster the political will to tackle the difficult challenges before it. As a bridge or gateway to Europe for US firms seeking growth opportunities, Ireland stands to gain from success in achieving this turnaround. The strength and purpose of this ‘bridge’ will be determined by the health of the European economy and Ireland stands to lose or gain disproportionately on the outcome. The future potential of Irish-US commercial and economic ties is strongly dependent on Europe staying together, not drifting apart. It is also conditioned on Ireland building on from the success of the past few years; Ireland is a small open economy highly exposed to global shocks and cycles, substantially built on attracting inward investment to drive export-led growth and attached to a continent presently confronting a political malaise and structural economic challenges. That means the nation can never rest, and must always remain diligent about sustaining and nurturing its competitiveness. Key will be Ireland’s recognized competitiveness for the availability of talent. A credible skills and talent strategy must remain a top priority to maintain an edge, where that factor alone is becoming increasingly important in foreign direct investment decision making for the types of high-value activities that Ireland has established such a track record in winning and retaining. Linked to this high-value skills base is the evolution of Ireland’s research, development and innovation (RD&I) performance as a new opportunity for economic growth. Having established its reputation as a global centre of operational excellence for its FDI base and built new credentials in fundamental research and process innovation, Ireland should seek to build 79 80 out an eco-system to more applied and commercial ventures with stronger local, academic and business collaborations to become a recognized source of innovation for global corporations seeking growth and shareholder value. As Irish RD&I spending as a percentage of GDP lags the EU average, Ireland should be innovative in seeking to boost the level of investment to ensure opportunities are not lost as it prioritizes research programs to achieve critical mass, international excellence and leadership, and maximum impact in addressing social and economic challenges that are often global in nature. Examples include, but are not limited to, the convergence of medical science and communications technologies, advances in nutrition, the application and integration of the ‘internet of things’ and the management of natural resources. The prize for Ireland is that it establishes a new reputation within the EU for sustained economic growth on the back of its RD&I strategy to position it to lead a number of key transatlantic initiatives – thus attracting corporate centres of research and innovation to locate in Ireland. Such an evolution has the potential to raise the U.S. investment base in Ireland by 2025 to over US $480b. With more US manufacturing projects migrating back to a more competitive and growing America, and with China’s innovative capabilities on the rise, these trends, coupled with an uncertain Europe and a changing corporate tax landscape, means that Ireland will have to redouble its efforts in sustaining a strong foundation of human capital, a favourable cost base and a businessfriendly work environment. The nation must become a champion of Europe’s Digital Single Market and help shape EU initiatives that create more technological synergies between the EU and the US. The critical task in front of Ireland is ensuring its place in the high-end, value-added chain of multinationals, notably in services and evolving technologies that will change the nature of work and production. This is critical since the number of “technology and manufacturing-capable” nations is steadily rising, giving multinationals more opportunities to spread and leverage their global operations. Ultimately, the race to remain globally competitive never ends. Unlike many nations in Europe, Ireland understands this dynamic all too well. Rising to the challenge is something Ireland excels at, with the nation’s economic rebound just one more piece of evidence of Ireland’s dynamic economic character. What about the future of the US-EU trade and investment relationship? While a high degree of market integration already exists between the U.S. and Europe thanks to past and existing trade and investment agreements, much more can be done to fuse the world’s two largest economies together. Hence the on-going talks since July 2013 to craft a transatlantic trade and investment agreement (or free trade pact referred to as ‘TTIP’) that would not only reduce tariffs but more importantly, reduce non-tariff barriers and harmonize the web of regulatory standards that inhibits transatlantic trade and investment flows and adds to the cost of doing business on both sides of the ocean. This is a course that is worth running to completion. A more barrier-free transatlantic economy would be highly beneficial to all stakeholders on both sides of the pond—consumers, corporations and governments. Per the actual details of any such an agreement, we are talking about important micro business and consumer issues like agreeing mutually acceptable high food safety standards, e-commerce protocols to expand opportunities for small and medium sized businesses, agreed data privacy principles and protections, and standardizing a myriad of service-related activities in such sectors as aviation, retail trade, maritime, telecommunications and procurement rules and regulations, especially at US State and EU regional level. The move towards fewer impediments to markets would also include agreed product standardization so that a car tested for the highest safety levels in Berlin can be sold without further tests in Boston. Or a drug or food product approved under agreed high standards by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in Washington is deemed safe and market-ready in Brussels and vice versa. Technical regulations and safety standards are not exciting topics but when these hurdles to doing business are stripped away, the end results are lower costs for companies, lower prices to consumers and more demand for goods and services. As for tariffs, average transatlantic tariffs are relatively low, in the 5%-7% range, although tariffs remain quite high in such categories as agriculture, textiles and apparel, and footwear. So there is room for barriers to fall. More importantly, in that a large percentage of transatlantic trade is intra-firm, or trade in parts and components within the firm, even small tariffs can add to the cost of production and result in higher prices for consumers on both sides of the pond. The more intense the intra-industry trade component of trade between two parties, like the one that characterizes Irish-U.S. trade, the greater the effects and benefits of lower tariffs. For Ireland, successful agreement of TTIP would incrementally add to growth, employment, incomes and trade, with particular benefits to its medical technologies, pharmaceutical, information technology and broad-based manufacturing sectors. A recent report from the World Trade Institute1 indicates that Ireland would be a lead beneficiary of a comprehensive agreement with positive contributions to growth in output and wages for all in employment, alongside more investments. The report indicates that GDP would be increased by 1.3% permanently, and exports to the US could be expected to increase by 19%. Ireland’s position as a transatlantic trade and investment gateway suggests it’s in a very good position to benefit from an agreement, as Ireland exports over 80% of its output, with hundreds of thousands of jobs depending on the ability to trade overseas. The US is a vital market, consuming over 20% of Irish exports including some €500m from the fast growing food and drink sector. In the end, think of this Transatlantic agreement as yet another significant step towards the deeper integration of the United States and Europe, and by extension, the US and Ireland. The benefits to both parties would be substantial, with any moves to strengthen and deepen the transatlantic economy proving quite beneficial to America’s primary bridge to the EU market: Ireland. www.amcham.eu’ World Trade Institute, TTIP and the EU member states 1 81 • 13 of the Fortune 500 companies are located in Massachusetts • Dominant Sectors (Private): Biotechnology, finance, health care & tourism • Massachusetts is one of the most export orientated states • Population: 25,145,561 • 20.8% of the population under 18 Massachusetts- Ireland Trade Relationship • 2nd Largest US State for Exports to Ireland with a year on year increase since 2009, with exports rising from $300m in 2009 to $952 million in 2015. • Ireland exported $1.6 worth of goods to Massachusetts • Massachusetts based companies account for over 14,000 jobs in Ireland • Irish companies have a significant presence in the Life Sciences sector with 5 Irish companies operating in the sector. Irish companies also have a presence in the Engineering, Security and Tech sectors. • Ireland is the 6th largest exporter and 11th largest importer to Massachusetts. Fidelity Investments have created 200 new jobs with the opening of a Dublin office Sun Life Financial opens new Waterford office, creating up to 50 jobs Did You Know? In addition to daily flights from Dublin to Boston, it was announced in 2016 that direct flights will begin from Cork Airport to Boston. 84 Key terms and definitions Affiliate Assets: Something of value that is owned such as: a current asset which is of temporary nature and will be changed into cash within a short period; a fixed asset which is durable and can be used repeatedly; a floating asset which can be quickly converted into cash at or near its book value; an intangible asset which has no material substance like goodwill; a liquid asset which can very easily be converted into cash without appreciable loss in value as opposed to a frozen asset which may be difficult to sell quickly without loss in value. Cross-border trade in goods and services: Transactions in merchandise goods and services between the residents of one country and the residents of another country. From the U.S. viewpoint, it consists of exports and imports of goods and services between U.S. residents and foreign residents. It includes both trade within multinational companies (intra-firm trade) and trade between unaffiliated parties. It is one of two channels of delivery of services in international markets; the other is sales of goods and services through foreign affiliates of multinational companies. Direct investment: Investment in which a resident of one country obtains a lasting interest in, and a degree of influence over, the management of a business enterprise in another country. In the United States, the criterion used to distinguish direct investment from other types of investment is ownership of at least 10 percent of the voting securities of an incorporated business enterprise or an equivalent ownership interest of an unincorporated business enterprise. Direct investment (capital) flows: Funds that parent companies provide to their affiliates net of funds that affiliates provide to their parents. For U.S. direct investment abroad (outflows), capital flows also include funds that U.S. direct investors pay to unaffiliated foreign residents when foreign affiliates are acquired and funds that U.S. investors receive from them when foreign affiliates are sold. There are three components of foreign direct investment: equity capital flows, intercompany debt, and reinvested earnings. Similarly, for foreign direct investment in the United States (inflows), capital flows include funds that foreign direct investors pay to unaffiliated U.S. residents when U.S. affiliates are acquired and funds that foreign direct investors receive from them when U.S. affiliates are sold. Foreign direct investment in the United States also include debt and equity transactions between U.S. affiliates and members of their foreign parent groups other than their foreign parents. Direct investment income: Return that direct investors receive on their investment in affiliates abroad. It consists of the direct investors’ share in the earnings of the affiliates, plus net interest on intercompany debt. Direct investment position (stock) at historical cost: Stock means/denotes cumulative investment, showing the total outstanding level of U.S. direct investment abroad at year end. It largely reflects prices at the time of the investment rather than prices of the current period and is not ordinarily adjusted to reflect the changes in the current costs or the replacement costs of tangible assets or in stock market valuations of firms. Holding Company: Within the data sets of the US Bureau of Economic Analysis the term refers to a company whose primary activity is holding the securities or financial assets of other companies and captures all activity of such holding firms regardless of location. Majority-owned foreign affiliate (MOFA): A foreign affiliate in which the combined ownership of all U.S. parents exceeds 50 percent. U.S. foreign affiliate sales: Goods and services sold in international markets through the channel of direct investment, specifically through foreign affiliates. From the U.S. viewpoint, it consists of sales of goods and services to foreigners by foreign affiliates of U.S. companies and U.S. purchases of goods and services from other countries’ U.S. affiliates. Value added (applicable to Affiliate Gross Product): The gross output of an industry or a sector less its intermediate inputs; the contribution of an industry or sector to gross domestic product (GDP). Value added by industry can also be measured as the sum of compensation of employees, taxes on production and imports less subsidies, and gross operating surplus. It represents the firm’s contribution to gross domestic product in its country of residence, which is the value of goods and services produced by labour and property located in that country.