Download The Effect of Oregano (Origanum vulgare)

The Effect of essential oil of Oregano (Origanum vulgare) on the in vitro growth of
the bacteria Escherichia coli, Salmonella typhimurium, and Staphylococcus aureus
Eric T. Rueda
Department of Biological Sciences
Saddleback College
Mission Viejo, CA 92692
Abstract
Oregano oil is a very potent source of the antimicrobial substance Carvacrol. Three
bacteria, Escherichia coli, Salmonella typhimurium, and Staphylococcus aureus, were
exposed to this natural active chemical. They were incubated at 37.0°C and data was
collected by subtracting the total area of inhibition (including the area occupied by
the chad) and subtracting the area of the oregano (Origanum vulgare) oil dipped
chad. Results were calculated as the average area of inhibition and graphed,
however, they did not stand up to par with previous experiments. The growth of the
bacteria was mildly effected by the presence of the oregano oil.
Introduction
The immune system is a complex defense system constantly fighting off infection
and assisting the body as it strives to achieve homeostasis. These functions will continue
regardless of the macroscopic environment that we consciously expose ourselves to. The
body thrives under control of the brain and its collective use of complex systems, such as
the nervous, lymphatic, and digestive systems. Electrical and chemical messages relay
from exterior or interior stimuli and the body will react accordingly.
In the case of an unwanted microbe or bacterium within our body, the immune
system works to destroy this parasite by surface markers, cytokines, phagocytosis, or
antibodies (Campbell et al., 2008). Multiple cells and tissues are affected by these
changes; (this sentence needs to be re-worded) such as if the body has no memory of the
parasite, then an acquired immunity develops. This allows for cells to retain information
of the parasite so that it can be destroyed faster and more efficiently. Our body is good at
(use better word choice) managing a broad spectrum of infection, however, when a
parasite (Why is the word parasite being used?? How about pathogen or microorganism?)
reproduces too rapidly within our body or it is extremely unfamiliar, we may be working
to catch up to it to destroy it. If this is the case, then one may seek medical attention.
Medical practice has developed and grown exponentially over an incredible
amount of time. Dating back to before 1400 B.C. (McCall et al., 2003), society made use
of simple, yet misunderstood blood letting techniques to remove excess bile. Currently,
the procedure of a standard infection follows that a prescription medication is
administered to the patient in hope, and through multiple trials and experience, that the
parasite will be vanquished. Prescription medication is used regularly and has become a
multibillion dollar industry (Wechsler, 2010). Through private investors and government
funding, this field targets FDA approval of microbiological based medicines. Scientists
draw inspiration from nature to fuel cognition and fabricate new medications and medical
1 of 6
techniques. Over time, plants and fungi have developed adaptations to survive extreme
environments and to keep them free of certain microbes. In particular, the oregano plant
(Origanum vulgare) (Morris 2005) makes use of two phenol compounds: Carvacrol
(C10H14O) and Thymol (C10H14O) (Preuss et al. 2005). The main body constructed in a
benzene ring with different appendage hydroxyl groups. Carvacrol, specifically, has been
shown through many in vitro experiments to be a strong antibacterial compound
(Nutraceuticals, 2001; Preuss et al., 2005; Ott et al., 2008; Sarac et al., 2008; Erickson,
2009; Wong et al., 2008; Patrone, 2010). Carvacrol has repeatedly displayed
antimicrobial activity against related bacteria found in animals and plants, such as strains
of Aspergillus, Streptococcus, Bacillus, and Candida. These concentrations are as low as
0.625 mg/mL (Can Baser, 2008). Carvacrol inhibits bacteria by creating an ionic
imbalance on the cell membrane by allowing K+ ions to leak from the cell resulting in
unstable cytoplasmic pH levels and osmotic pressure. This membrane now leaks ATP
due to the breakdown of the cellular membrane leaving the cell unable to function.
Carvacrol will also inhibit ATPase, the enzymatic active-transport pump located on the
cellular membrane which functions to regulate proton distribution between the cytoplasm
and extracellular fluid. (Campbell et al., 2008) With such a long standing and well
documented history of antimicrobial qualities, the objective of the study was to examine
if oregano oil would inhibit the growth of three bacteria: Escherichia coli, Salmonella
typhimurium, and Staphylococcus aureus. It is hypothesized that the growth of the
bacteria would be greatly effected the presence of the oil.
Materials and Methods
Forty nutrient agar plates were prepared using Difco nutrient agar. Three bacteria:
Escherichia coli, Salmonella typhimurium, and Staphylococcus aureus, were cultured and
provided by the Saddleback Biology Department. Sterile water was used as the control.
Supplies and methods were completed using aseptic technique; gloves and eye
shield were dawned and all materials used were from sterile packaging or had been
autoclaved. Serological pipettes were used to transfer 0.3 mL of E. coli to the nutrient
agar plates. A glass rod spreader was used to distribute the bacteria evenly around the
petri dish. After each use, the glass spreader was dipped in 95% ethanol, passed through a
Bunsen burner flame before being used on the next agar plate. The procedure was
repeated for S. typhimurium, S. aureus, and water control plates.
Three chad disks were dipped in the oregano oil and placed onto each agar plate
using forceps. The brand Nature’s Answer alcohol-free oregano oil, purchased from The
Vitamin Shoppe in Mission Viejo, California, was combined with olive oil and contained
active ingredient Carvacrol at 7.0 mg per 0.2 mL of oil. This dropper bottle was
purchased from The Vitamin Shoppe in Mission Viejo, California. Forceps were dipped
in 95% ethanol and passed through a Bunsen burner flame before handling each disk. All
agar plates were incubated at 37.0°C for 48 hours at Saddleback College.
Data was collected by measuring the entire diameter of the chad and area of
inhibition. Measurements were taken using a metric ruler (millimeters) and values were
recorded to the tenths. Area of inhibition of one chad disk was calculated by subtracting
the chad disk diameter, 7.0 mm, from the inhibition diameter. The summation of these
2 of 6
values was then divided by the total number (n=30) to obtain the mean diameter of
inhibition. Statistical test ANOVA was run comparing the bacterial growth to each other.
Results
The oregano oil had a similar effect on the mean area of inhibition on each
bacteria. An ANOVA statistical test was used to analyze the significance of the area of
inhibition of all bacteria in relationship to each other. A significant P-Value of 1.04E-09
was found between the groups. The Bonferroni Correction Test with MS Residual of
14.63211111 and DS Residual of 3.0, and a confidence interval of 95% was run to
compare each bacteria to each other. Compared to one another the bacteria showed no
statistical significance, with a P-Value > 0.05 (Figure 1).
Delete title on figure and the horizontal lines, X-axis label?
Figure 1. The comparison of inhibition of growth of bacteria (n=30)
Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia Coli, and Salmonella
typhimurium against oregano (Origanum vulgare) oil (Carvacrol at
7.0 mg per 0.2 mL). Control was water and showed zero inhibition.
P-Value was statistically insignificant (> 0.05) (Bonferroni
Correction Test) and bacteria are graphed with a 95% confidence
interval. S.aureus standard error of 0.158832, E.coli standard error of
0.172239, and S.typhimurium standard error of 0.229767.
Discussion
The expected results are not supported by the outcome of the collected data.
Through previous studies such as Can Baser (2008) and Wong (2008), oregano oil
inhibited the growth of these three bacteria significantly. An important factor, in this
study, that may have caused a deviation from the expected results is the low
concentration of Carvacrol in the sample tested. A small range of inhibition was due to
the presence of Carvacrol, however Carvacrol did not have a statistically significant
effect on the growth of the three bacteria Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia Coli, and
Salmonella typhimurium.
This s a very short discussion – is this worth 24 points?
3 of 6
Literature Cited – alphabetical order
Preuss, Harry G., Bobby Echard, and Ryan R. Zonosi. "The Potential for Developing
Natural Antibiotics: Examining Oregano and Monolaurin." BNet. Original
Internist, Sept. 2005. Web. Apr. 2010.
<http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0FDL/is_3_12/ai_n17211117/>.
Ott, Jessica A., and Amy N. Morris. "Homeopathic Alternatives to Conventional
Antibiotics." Bios 79.2 (2008): 50-55. JSTOR. Web. 05 Apr. 2010.
Sarac, Nurdan, and Aysel Ugur. "Antimicrobial Activities of the Essential Oils of
Origanum Onites L., Origanum Vulgare L. Subspecies Hirtum (Link) Letswaart,
Satureja Thymbra L., and Thymus Cilicius Boiss. & Bal. Growing in Wild
Turkey.(Clinical Report)." Journal of Medicinal Food 11.3 (2008): 568.
AcademicOneFile. Web. 5 Apr. 2010.
Canbek, Mediha, Mustafa Uyanoglu, Gokhan Bayramoglu, Hakan Senturk, Nilufer
Erkasap, Tulay Koken, Sema Uslu, Canan Demirustu, Erinc Aral, and K.Husnu
Can Bascr. "Effects of Carvacrol on Degects of Ischemia-reperfusion in the Rat
Liver." Phytomedicine: International Journal of Phytotherapy &
Phytopharmacology 15.6-7 (2008): 447-53. AcademicOneFile. Web. 5 Apr. 2010.
Morris, Dean G. "Oregano Oil." Alive: Canadian Journal of Health & Nutrition 269
(2005): 86-87. EBSCOhost. Web. 5 Apr. 2010.
Erickson, Kim. "Essential Oregano." Better Nutrition 71.10 (2009): 32-33. EBSCOhost.
Web. 5 Apr. 2010.
Wong, Stella Y., Irene R. Grant, Mendel Friedman, Christopher T. Elliott, and Chen Situ.
"Antibacterial Avtivites of Naturally Occurring Compounds against
Mycobacterium avium subsp. paratuberculosis." Applied and Environmental
Microbiology 74.19 (2008): 5986. ProQuest. Web. 5 Apr. 2010.
"Nutraceuticals; Oregano Oil Kills Drug-Resistant Bacteria. " Drug Week
19 Oct. 2001: ProQuest Health and Medical Complete, ProQuest. Web. 6 Apr.
2010.
Patrone, V., R. Campana, E. Vittoria, and W. Baffone. "In Vitro Synergistic Activities of
Essential Oils and Surfactants in Combination with Cosmetic Preservatives
Against Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Staphylococcus aureus. " Current
Microbiology 60.4 (2010): 237. Health Module, ProQuest. Web. 6 Apr. 2010.
4 of 6
Scollard, J., G. Francis, and D. O'Beirne. "Effects of Essential Oil Treatment, Gas
Atmosphere, and Storage Temperature on Listeria monocytogenes in a Model
Vegetable System. " Journal of Food Protection 72.6 (2009): 12091215. ProQuest Health and Medical Complete, ProQuest. Web. 6 Apr. 2010.
Can Baser, K.. "Biological and Pharmacological Activities of Carvacrol and Carvacrol
Bearing Essential Oils. " Current Pharmaceutical Design 14.29 (2008): 31063119. ProQuest Health and Medical Complete, ProQuest. Web. 6 Apr. 2010.
Dooley, Deborah. "The Ancient Greeks' favourite medicinal herb could help to destroy
modernviruses :[Final 1 Edition]. " The Times 8 May 2001, ProQuest
Newsstand, ProQuest. Web. 6 Apr. 2010.
Campbell, Neil A., Jane B. Reece, Lisa A. Urry, Michael L. Cain, Stephen A.
Wasserman, Peter V. Minorsky, and Robert B. Jackson. Biology. Eighth ed. 135138. San Francisco: Pearson Education (2008). Print.
Bibbal, D., V. Dupouy, M. Prère, P. Toutain, and A. Bousquet-Mélou. "Relatedness of
Escherichia coli Strains with Different Susceptibility Phenotypes Isolated from
Swine Feces during Ampicillin Treatment. " Applied and Environmental
Microbiology 75.10 (2009): 2999. Sciences Module, ProQuest. Web. 7 Apr.
2010.
McCall, Ruth, and Cathee Tankersley. Phlebotomy Essentials. Thrid. Philadelphia:
Lippicott Williams & Wilkins, 2003. Print.
Wechsler, J.. "Drug pricing, safety, access to dominate agenda in the year
ahead. " Formulary 45.1 (2010): 30-31. Health Module, ProQuest. Web. 12 Apr.
2010.
Wolfram, Steven. Wolfram Alpha LLC, 2010. Web. <http://www.wolframalpha.com>.
5 of 6
Review Form
Department of Biological Sciences
Saddleback College, Mission Viejo, CA 92692
Author (s): Eric T. Rueda
Title: The Effect of essential oil of Oregano (Origanum vulgare) on the in vitro
growth of the bacteria Escherichia coli, Salmonella typhimurium, and Staphylococcus
aureus
Summary
Researchers investigated the antibiotic properties of oil produced by the Oregano
plant, Origanum vulgare. Carvacrol is one of the antibiotic compounds found in the
essential oil of Oregano. The researchers found that the Carvacrol did not have a
significant inhibitory effect on the 3 types of bacteria used.
General Comments
I thought that the paper had some interesting points. A better choice of scientific
dialogue needs be used in a few areas that I highlighted. I provided some suggestions and
rewrote some areas.
Technical Criticism
Overall, organization was good. Some minor mechanical and grammatical errors
have been corrected. The graph needs to have the horizontal lines removed from the
background.
This paper was a final version
 This paper was a rough draft
Recommendation
 This paper should be published as is
 This paper should be published with revision
 This paper should not be published
Read more about Peer Review in the biological sciences at:
http://www.councilscienceeditors.org/services/draft_approved.cfm#Paragraphsix
I read the information from the site listed above:
Initials
6 of 6