Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
J Community Health DOI 10.1007/s10900-014-9899-6 ORIGINAL PAPER Jewish Holidays and Their Associated Medical Risks Jacob Urkin • Sody Naimer Ó Springer Science+Business Media New York 2014 Abstract Religiosity is inherent in human cultures. Being different in many aspects, all have rules regarding appropriate behavior and rituals. Celebrations of social events and of holidays prevail in all major religions. These include code of dress, prayers, special food and activities which may have negative health implications. The Jewish religion is ‘blessed’ with an abundance of holidays each with its unique health implications. In this paper we provide an outline of the character of these festivals and possible medical repercussions on those celebrating them. Observant members of the Jewish religion and teams treating this population should be knowledgeable of potentially associated risks. Pre-holiday periods should be specifically targeted for educational and preventive activity in order diminish injury or morbidity. Keywords Jewish holidays Medical risks Injuries Prevention Introduction Religiosity is inherent in human cultures. Being different in many aspects, all have rules regarding appropriate behavior and rituals. Celebrations of social events and of holidays prevail in all major religions. These include code of dress, prayers, special food and activities which may have negative health implications. For example, the incidence of J. Urkin (&) S. Naimer Division of Community Health, Department of Family Medicine and Siaal Research Center for Family Practice and Primary Care, Faculty of Health Sciences, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, P.O. Box 653, 84105 Beer-Sheva, Israel e-mail: [email protected] acute myocardial infarction increases on Islamic and Christian high seasons [1, 2]. Christmas and New Years day involve greater consumption of alcohol with associated injuries relating to falls as well as the risk of driving under its influence leading to serious or fatal automobile accidents. We also observe increased death rates from neoplasms, respiratory diseases, endocrine/nutritional/ metabolic diseases and digestive diseases [3]. Muslim Ramadan is associated with increased risk of duodenal ulcer and diabetic imbalance [4]. Mass gathering of pilgrims at the Muslim Hajj carry the risk of injuries and communicable diseases [5]. Even major sporting events involve alcohol abuse leading to its related risks. The associated risks with holidays have practical implications. Observant members of each religion should be alerted and educated regarding measures that could alleviate those risks. Pre-holiday periods should be specifically targeted for this activity. Medical staff, emergency services, police, firefighters and social workers should prepare themselves for the surplus load of anticipated morbidity and potential mortality. In many cultures and religions, holidays are an opportunity for family reunions and traditional events that recur on a yearly basis. Jewish holidays are of no exception. Most Jewish festivals commemorate biblical and historic events dating two to four thousand years ago. Although many holidays are characterized by happiness and joy, some are devoted to sincere spiritual self-reflection. For readers unfamiliar with the Jewish tradition we must open with explanation of a number of principles which are worth mentioning. The Jewish calendar day begins with nightfall and not at midnight. The year is based on a merge of the lunar and solar calendars. The lunar year lasts 12 months where every 2–3 years a thirteenth month is added in order to keep the holidays close to the solar year and thus the holidays 123 J Community Health will be adherent to the same season every year. Namely, Passover must always fall in the spring, therefore the whole year falls into place season by season. There is a daily routine that includes three prayers and blessings that precede or follow many of the regular activities such as eating, sleeping, washing etc. Every Sabbath and Holiday (rest days) before the sunset of their onset, are greeted by a candle lighting ceremony (at least two), accompanied by the appropriate blessing. These days are embellished by lengthy extravagant full course and well planned festive meals. Each is preceded by the traditional ‘‘Sanctification’’ (Kidush) ceremony which is the recital of a designated blessing over a cup of wine both night and day. All participants are expected to taste from the alcoholic beverage. The purpose of this article is to summarize the literature and the authors’ experience regarding health hazards that are related to Jewish holidays. The paper is arranged chronologically according to the holidays, starting from the beginning of the Jewish year. For each holiday, a short description of the holiday and its characteristics precedes the description of the involved risks and health hazards. ‘‘Rosh Hashana’’ (New Year) This is the beginning of the Jewish year in the end of summer. Rounded shaped foods symbolize the wish to live another full year. Consuming the cranial aspect of either fish or lamb symbolizes a good beginning and as we pray to be ‘‘heads and not tails’’. Consumption of honey and sweet food address the wish for a sweet year. The holiday is also the time for reflection and a wish to get cleared-off the last year’s sins as within 10 days, the fate of each individual is determined by the almighty. Prayers are accompanied by blowing a ram’s horn (‘‘shofar’’). Medical risks that was described in association with handling live fish, include severe local infection and blood poisoning by Vibrio vulnificus bacteria that entered open skin wounds [6]. Many instances of incarcerated fishbones lodged in the posterior pharynx or esophagus peak around these festive meals and may have been the source of customizing the traditional East European Jewish cuisine includes a grounded cooked fish ball (‘‘Gefilte fish’’). Housewives who tasted this raw murine nutrition became infested by fish tapeworms of the genus Diphyllobothriasis. Such an infestation has also been described in women practicing Scandinavian cuisine and it is called: ‘‘Jewish and Scandinavian housewife’s disease’’ [7–9]. There is always the potential of subsequent Vitamin B12 deficiency anemia in those infected with D. latum and other pseudophyllidean tapeworms. Three cases of botulism from homecanned ‘‘gefilte fish’’ were described [10]. Horn- blowing may cause emphysema [11]. The extremes of elevated 123 intra-abdominal pressure can inflict hemorrhoid expulsion or exacerbation of previously existent umbilical or inguinal hernias. Raised intracranial pressure may lead in extreme cases to hemorrhage and there may even be a threat of either dissection or outright rupture of an aneurysm if present. A patient may present with petechiae especially of the face (eyelids) and neck regions, which may be generated by retching and vomiting. This may be a result of bulimic overeating or the after effects of an irregular combination of alcohol and spices, tastes and flavors of greater magnitude and quality than the gastric mucosa is accustomed to thus leading to content expulsion. ‘‘Yom Kipurim’’ (Day of Atonement) This is the holiest day in Jewish life which is devoted to prayer. It includes special dress and shoes that are not made of leather. Fasting is preceded and ends by special meals. Male children younger than 13 years old or females younger than 12, the sick and weak are exempted from fasting but not all accept that option. The health hazards are related mostly to fasting. Headache, dehydration, syncope and ketotic hypoglycemia are quite common. Patients with type one and type two diabetes mellitus are prone to develop severe metabolic imbalance including diabetic ketoacidosis if the routine medication regimen is interrupted [12]. Fasting may provoke premature contractions during gestation and even labor in women close to term pregnancy [13]. Pancreatitis secondary to very high-fat meals associated with the day of Atonement has been described [14]. If patients refrain from ingesting their regular medication as indicated they run the risk of exacerbation of chronic conditions such as: breakthrough seizures, uncontrolled hypertension or tachycardia in those inflicted by atrial fibrillation. Bicycle, skateboard and roller-blade injuries are 5 times higher compared to other days of the year as these activities are allowed while there is no care traffic on the roads [15]. ‘‘Sukkot’’ (Tabernacles) In this holiday all men are commanded to dwell for seven whole days in temporary shelters with a roof made of fresh tree branches (‘‘sukkah’’). This tradition mimics the temporary shelters that the Israelites used in their 40 years of exodus in the desert from slavery in Egypt to become a free nation in the land of Israel. Building of the ‘‘sukkah’’ is usually the chore of the father and boys. Scrap wood is hammered together by nails (unless the lazy family goes out and purchases a manufactured easily assembled frame). Because this activity is J Community Health recruited by all and not necessarily those dexterous all year round, this time of the year we observe many injuries from stepping on nails (foreign body penetration), hitting fingers by a hammer (mallet finger) or corneal deposition by foreign bodies. Palm leaves have thorny spikes that tend to break after puncturing the skin. Toxins that are released by the leaf tips stimulating immediate severe inflammatory reactions are often mistaken as a localized infection. These splinters are very painful and at a later phase run the risk of creating a soft tissue infection or create a full blown abscess. Lighting candles in the ‘sukkah’ as dictated by Jewish law in a flammable environment without standard safety measures exposes many homes to smoke and fire dangers [15]. Unfortunately, we have experienced the consequences of unattended flames and two of my patients succumbed such an event (JU). Therefore all efforts should be taken to assure that necessary precautions are undertaken to prevent further atrocities. ‘‘Hanukkah’’ (Festival of Lights) Hanukkah lasts for 8 days. It commemorates the rededication of the Holy Temple at the time of the Maccabean Revolt against the Greeks, 2,200 years ago. It is observed by the kindling of the lights of a unique candelabrum that has nine branches called the ‘‘Menorah’’. There is a tradition to give children coins and tender to buy gifts and play with spinning tops (dreidels). There is an obligation to light candles near windows or balconies in particular parts of the house exposed to the public in order to publicize the historical ‘MIRACLE’ (of the single candle that remained lit 8 days long). As above, explicit safety measures should be employed and fire extinguishers should be available to defend against the potential dangers of a fire outbreak. Most of the injuries Hanukkah are related to burns in children who were carelessly handling lighted candles [15]. Many are related to a game in which colored candles are held in the horizontal position and the heated wax is dripped on a surface of paper forming a decorative piece of art. A related wax foreign body in the eye was described [16]. A commonly encountered season’s delight of chocolate coins covered by aluminum foil may inadvertently be swallowed by overzealous children and in one instance has caused esophageal perforation [14]. Up to about 50 years ago some families were smelting lead into wooden casts in order to prepare home-made spinning tops. This practice caries the risk of lead poisoning. One of the most popular delicatessen products universally appearing during this holiday are deep fried donuts representing the miracle occurring with oil. This brings many children and adults alike to seek ailments for burns on the soft and hard palates, gingival, tongues and buccal mucosal surfaces. We assume that the reason for these injuries is that the fluid cream, jam or caramel at the center of the pastry tends to heat much quicker than the surrounding baked dough especially when heated in the microwave oven. Then, without sensing its extreme heat at the center, the hungry subject will bite into burning hot fluid. ‘‘Purim’’ Purim commemorates the deliverance of the Jewish people from destruction that was plotted by Haman in Persia 2,500 years ago. It is characterized by dressing in special costume disguises and breaking the strict laws of code of dress. Being happy is compulsory and thus the restrictions of becoming drunk from alcohol consumption are lifted. It is stressed that illegal and illicit experimental drugs are strictly forbidden by Jewish Law. The most serious hazards are related to the relatively new habit of using firecrackers and cap guns. The unacceptable noise is traditionally intended to erase the memory of the wicked Haman who devised the annihilation of the Jewish people. Finger injuries and eardrum injuries have occurred. Very low safety quality assurance exists for products imported from the far-east and we have seen complete packages of caps detonated by friction in kids’ pockets resulting in local first and second degree burns. Children’s costume disguises that are not fire proof can catch fire easily. Severe burns have occurred. Masks and other costume eyewear worn on Purim can obscure vision, therefore not only should the alcohol dosed adults keep away from the wheel, but even children donning various garments, hats, toy spectacles and scarves should be deterred from cycling, skating and riding wagons in domains of transportation. We have observed cases of skin allergy and eye irritations secondary to the use of color sprays and face colorings (JU, SN). As some of the strict rules governing children year round are lifted on Purim it is quite common to observe young school-aged children smoking cigarettes and drinking alcohol. Injuries from falls of drunk subjects and hypoglycemia in those who do not consume enough carbohydrates were described [17]. Many unaccustomed to high concentrations of alcohol reach uncontrollable bouts of emesis that can inflict severe esophageal hemorrhage as Boerhave syndrome. Likewise, as mentioned, binge alcohol drinking in those licensed to drive run the risk of serious accidents if they take to the wheel during intoxication. Meticulous precaution must be taken with diabetes mellitus patients non adherent to warnings of binge drinking attempting to perform the obligation of ‘‘drinking until jolly’’. Especially type I patients are especially in jeopardy of ketoacidosis especially when ample quantities of water have not been consumed. 123 J Community Health A traditional food is a cookie filed with a sweet past of poppy seeds. A case of opioid poisoning by overconsumption of these cookies was described [11]. The use of fireworks and inflamable disgises result in burns [15]. ‘‘Pesach’’ (Passover) This 7 day holiday commemorates the liberation of the Jewish people from slavery in ancient Egypt 3,300 years ago. This is the most important family gathering. Preparation for the holiday includes scrupulous cleaning of the house. No remains of certain foods, especially cultured dough or leavened bread (‘‘hametz’’) is allowed. Bread is replaced by ‘‘Matzo’’ which is made of wetted flower that is baked immediately after becoming a mixture. Other foods and medications should be authorized by the rabbinate establishment as ‘‘Kosher for Passover’’. The time of preparation for Passover, caries special risks. Parents are busy moving household furniture and preoccupied by ‘‘spring cleaning’’ every corner. Their ability to retain full control and observe their toddlers and young babies is reduced. Cleaning materials are not always kept locked in safety cupboards. At this time of less supervision, dangerous substances such as toxic powders and industrial fluids, pesticides, petrol etc. are all suddenly exposed and raise the curiosity of youngsters drawn by the new colors and shapes of containers never positioned at an accessible level before. Poisoning by cleaning materials such as acids bases and detergents are far more common this time of the year [15, 18]. Severe corrosive caustic mouth and esophageal ulceration may be a result of accidental swallowing of cleaning agents, especially strong bases that are used to clean stoves. Keeping chemicals in non-original containers, especially disposable food containers, is exceptionally dangerous and runs the risk of confusion with food and thus poisoning. Eating utensils and cooking gear as all other kitchen aids coming in contact with food are traditionally soaked in boiling water in very large containers that are heated by open fire on the streets of the neighborhood. Burns occur in schoolchildren as result of handling the boiling hot vessels by unfortunately those often sent to perform this task. The almost obsessive cleaning that takes place weeks before the holiday, is associated with musculoskeletal overuse syndromes. Patellar bursitis, tendinitis, muscle strain and lowback pain are common complaints (SN). All primary clinicians are prepared for the long line of housewives expecting sick leave in this time of year. Preparation of ‘‘Matzo bread’’ by people who are not professional bakers, is associated with burns and hand trauma as crush injuries and finger amputation [19]. Consumption of the dry Matzo bread for seven full days is associated with an increased 123 tendency to develop constipation, yet to be elucidated, since most of the manufacturers use whole flour. An increase in dietary fiber without increasing fluids may possibly contribute to this and if so, adopting a diet with greater fluid content can alleviate this ailment. However, paradoxically others still report 7 days of diarrhea this week, such that this is a challenging topic worthy of futures research. Consumption of calories beyond energy expenditure is common in many of the Jewish holidays but Passover is probably the most prominent. The risks associated with handling live or raw fish are as were described in ‘‘Rosh Hashana’’ [6–10]. The ill-effects of excessive calorie intake and high fat and carbohydrate composition of the diet contribute to the dreaded epidemic of the metabolic syndrome which is beyond the scope of this paper. As not all the medications are approved as ‘‘Kosher for Passover’’, some patients are reluctant to take certain medications and thus run the risk of under treatment [20]. Therefore primary care physicians confronted with patient deterioration should address the issue of non-compliance. ‘‘Lag BaOmer’’ This is an evening to celebrate historic events from the time of the rebellion against the Roman Empire 1,800 years ago. It is not followed by a holiday. The tradition is to set bonfire in public areas. Hundreds of thousands of campfires are lit within a couple of hours. The first day after Passover is the accepted date sending children all over the place seeking wood. They will spend the next thirty or so days roaming around, sneaking into construction sites and lumber yards, climbing trees and visiting garbage dumps to the same aim. This is a period of an abundance of injuries from splinters and rusty nails that penetrate children’s feet. The risk of burns on ‘‘Lag BaOmer’’ evening is obvious [15]. The whole night sky is filled with smoke in the air, everywhere. This is accompanied by an increase in the incidence of asthma and exacerbation of bronchitis [21]. ‘‘Shavuot’’ (Feast of Weeks or Pentecost) ‘‘Shavuot’’ commemorates the anniversary of the day when the holy Bible was given to the Jews. This is also an agricultural festival celebrating the start of harvesting the wheat. Traditional food is made of dairy products. Aside from danger of exposure to milk products by those with hypersensitivity no specific medical risk is associated with this. However, consumption of high fat dairy products means that high cholesterol and food with high fat concentrations are ingested. The custom dictates spending the J Community Health whole night awake learning the scriptures in order to repent for the historical event that the Israelites were sleeping and had to be awakened by the Almighty the evening prior to the deliverance of the tablets. Sleep deprivation as a rule runs the risk as other stresses to the central nervous system that may trigger seizures in epileptic patients. In addition, the alteration of the sleep–wake cycle the following day, when the individual replenishes the loss of sleep, can interrupt routine medication ingestion as ‘Yom Kippur’. This can lead to unnecessary errors of medication omission from anticoagulation and thyroid agents to contraceptive pills, each with their associated ill effects. Death Rate in Jewish Holidays Some studies have demonstrated that death rate decreases the week before and during holidays. The death rate is ‘‘corrected’’ by an increasing above average immediately after the holidays [22]. This suggests a psychosomatic factor delaying fatal consequences. Medical Risks that are Shared in All Holidays The holidays that are mentioned in the Bible are idle days where working and many chores and duties are forbidden as in the Sabbath which is celebrated every Saturday. These include limitations in traveling, forbiddance of setting or extinguishing fire and turning on or off any electronic or electric devices. However, the uses of electric timers are allowed, as long as they were set before the holiday. In order to have hot meals in the holiday, food is kept warm by putting the pots and food containers on an electric plate. Hot water for drinking is constantly heated in metal urn overlying hot trays. These two devices are a common culprit for burns in children [23, 24]. We’ve witnessed terrible second degree plantar burns of toddlers after foolish parents left these appliances on the floor and were totally surprised that the children entered the forbidden utility room. Lighting candles precedes the Sabbath and all the holidays that are mentioned in the bible. That happens again when the holiday or Sabbath are over. Except of the risk from open fire, it has been described that the relative risk of orthodox Jewish children to ingest paraffin lamp oil, is 374 times that of other children [25]. Aspiration of the oil carries the risk of developing chemical pneumonitis as in any hydrocarbon ingestion. The traditional holiday and Sabbath meal includes eating fish. A study on 108 cases of fish bone impaction in the aero-digestive tract have demonstrated that 50.9 % occurred at home and over the weekends (Sabbath) [26]. ‘‘Para-holiday’’ Medical Risks ‘‘Bein-Hazmanim’’ is a period adjacent to a three big holidays when children are out of schools. ‘‘CHol-Hamoed’’ are similar, 1 week periods that occur in Sukkot and Passover. These are the periods where families go on vacation and youngsters experiment physical challenges on nature hikes, rappelling and water sports. At this time of the year there is an increase rate of road accidents, drowning, injuries from fall off cliffs and dehydration or heat stroke evolving into rhabdomyolysis. These very unfortunate incidents inflicting completely healthy members of the orthodox Jewish population that miscalculate the heat intensity and repercussions of long exposure to physical exertion without sufficient water supplies and onset of exhaustion. [15–27]. In conclusion, the customs of many Jewish festivals carry some special or increased medical risks. These examples relating specifically to Jewish holidays provide a window into the pitfalls associated with holidays of other religions and with secular celebrations such as national holidays and major sporting events. Consciousness and awareness of these will allow us to indulge in taking necessary precautions and educating the population in order to reduce these health hazards to a minimum. Conflict of interest The authors have no conflict of interest to disclose. No external funding was secured for this study. References 1. Zubaid, M., Thalib, L., & Suresh, C. G. (2006). Incidence of acute myocardial infarction during Islamic holiday seasons. European Journal of Epidemiology, 21(3), 191–195. 2. Phillips, D. P., Jarvinen, J. R., Abramson, I. S., & Phillips, R. R. (2004). Cardiac mortality is higher around Christmas and New Year’s than at any other time: The holidays as a risk factor for death. Circulation, 110(25), 3781–3788. 3. Phillips, D., Barker, G. E., & Brewer, K. M. (2010). Christmas and New Year as risk factors for death. Social Science and Medicine, 71(8), 1463–1471. 4. Bdioui, F., Melki, W., Ben Mansour, W., Loghmari, H., Hellara, O., Ben Chaabane, N., et al. (2012). Duodenal ulcer disease and Ramadan. Presse Medicale (Paris, France: 1983), 41(9 Pt 1), 807–812. 5. Steffen, R. (2013). Mass gatherings—Health risks and preventive strategies. Therapeutische Umschau, 70(6), 350–352. 6. Bisharat, N., Agmon, V., Finkelstein, R., Raz, R., Ben-Dror, G., Lerner, L., et al. (1999). Clinical, epidemiological, and microbiological feature of Vibrio vulnificus biogroup 3 causing outbreaks of wound infection and bacteremia in Israel. Israel Vibrio study group. Lancet, 354, 1421–1424. 123 J Community Health 7. Loeb, L. J. (1982). Gefilte fish and diphyllbothriasis. JAMA, 247, 1566. 8. Food and Drug Administartion. (2012). Bad Bug Book, Foodborne pathogenic microorganisms and natural toxins handbook (2nd ed., pp. 152–154). Food and Drug Administartion. http:// www.fda.gov/Food/FoodborneIllnessContaminants/CausesO fIllnessBadBugBook/default.htm. 9. Zaroff, L. (2006). Tale of tapeworm. The New York Times, August 8, 2006. http://nytimes.com/2006/08/08/health. 10. Armstrong, R. W., Stenn, F., Dowell, V. R, Jr., Ammerman, G., & Sommers, H. M. (1969). Type E botulism from home-canned gefilte fish. Report of three cases. JAMA, 210, 303–305. 11. Berant, M., & Lanzkowsky, P. (1983). Rare medical occurrences in Jewish traditions. JAMA, 250, 2469–2470. 12. Katz, Y., Zangen, D., Leibowitz, G., & Szalalt, A. (2009). Diabetic patients in the Yom Kippur fast—Who can fast and how to treat the fasting patients. Harefuah, 148, 586–591. 659, 658. 13. Wiser, A., Maymon, E., Mazor, M., Shoham-Vardi, I., Silberstein, T., Wiznitzer, A., et al. (1997). Effect of the Yom Kippur fast on parturition. Harefuah, 132(745–8), 824. 14. Solomon, G. (1996). Jewish holiday hazards. Journal of Family Practice, 42, 84. 15. Hemmo-Lotem, M., Jinich-Aronovitz, C., Endy-Findling, L., Molcho, M., Klein, M., Waismam, Y., et al. (2005). Child injury in Israel: Emergency room visits to children’s medical center. The Scientific World Journal, 5, 253–263. 16. Naimer, S. A. (2002). Candle wax as ocular foreign body. The Israel Medical Association Journal, 4, 316. 17. Kohn, M., & Shenker, R. (1996). Purim syncope. Journal of Adolescent Health, 18, 245. 18. Amitai, Y., Bentur, Y., Lifshitz, M., Fainmesser, P., Applebaum, D., Waisman, Y., et al. (2000). Poison exposure in children 123 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. before Passover. The Israel Medical Association Journal, 2, 142–144. Ashur, H., & Mushayov, R. (1994). Passover hand injuries. Harefuah, 126, 413–415. 427. Chusid, E. L., & Jerlinski, A. M. (1982). Selecting respiratory medications during the passover holiday. Chest, 81, 524–525. Ainbinder, R., Vinker, S., & Nakar, S. (2005). Lag Ba-Omer bonfires—Is there any association between the tradition and asthma and COPD exacerbations. Harefuah, 144(6), 386–388, 456. Phillips, D. P., & King, E. W. (1988). Death takes a holiday: Mortality surrounding major social occasions. Lancet, 2, 728–732. Benmeir, P., Sagi, A., Rosenberg, L., Picard, E., & Ben Yakar, Y. (1989). ‘Sabbath’ electric plate burn: A ritual hazard. Burns, Including Thermal Injury, 15, 39–41. Shoufani, A., & Golan, J. (2003). Shabbes burn, a burn that occurs solely among Jewish orthodox children; due to accidental shower from overhead water heaters. Burns, 29(1), 61–64. Hoffman, R. J., Morgenstern, S., Hoffman, R. S., & Nelson, L. S. (2004). Extremely elevated relative risk of paraffin lamp oil exposures in Orthodox Jewish children. Pediatrics, 113, e377– e379. Dagan, E., Yakirevich, A., Migirov, L., & Wolf, M. (2011). The role of economics and weekend meals in impacted fish bone occurrence in central Israel. The Israel Medical Association Journal, 13(1), 48–50. Thomas, J., & Crowhurst, T. (2013). Exertional heat stroke, rhabdomyolysis and susceptibility to malignant hyperthermia. Internal Medicine Journal, 43, 1035–1038.