Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
EVIDENCE-BASED PHARMACY PRACTICE Evidence l Evidence-based Pharmacy Practice (EBPP): Fatigue Ilse Truter PharmITCom® Consulting This article will provide a general overview of fatigue and then focus on Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (CFS), a disorder that is characterised by debilitating fatigue with several associated physical, constitutional and neuropsychological complaints. Introduction The modern lifestyle with its demands “to achieve” places an enormous physical and emotional burden on many individuals. Relaxation and exercise are often neglected. Many people are not able to maintain the pace, and it is not surprising that symptoms such as fatigue develop. Fatigue can, however, also be a symptom of other conditions such as depression, insomnia or premenstrual syndrome. Sometimes fatigue is a symptom of an underlying organic disease, for example, anaemia, infection, malignancy, sub-clinical vitamin and/or mineral deficiency, hypotension or hypoglycaemia.1 Medicines can also lead to fatigue, such as recent anaesthesia, oral contraceptives and anxiolytics such as benzodiazepines.1 Fatigue is common and a symptom of many different conditions. It is said that one in 400 sustained episodes of fatigue generate a consultation with a general practitioner.2 Two percent of these consultations result in a referral to a specialist.2 Almost any disease process can cause tiredness and fatigue, whether physical or psychological. Physical causes account for approximately 9% of cases, with 75% having symptoms of emotional distress.2 The challenge is to know what exactly causes the fatigue and whether it is serious enough to seek professional help. Definition of fatigue (less than one month), prolonged fatigue (more than one month) and chronic fatigue (more than six months).4 It is important to differentiate fatigue from other medical concepts with which the symptoms are often confused. Fatigue is different from drowsiness. Drowsiness is feeling the need to sleep, while fatigue is a lack of energy or motivation. The desire to sleep may, however, accompany fatigue. Listlessness is also different from fatigue. Listlessness indicates a state of fatigue or exhaustion where the patient loses interest in his or her surroundings. Asthenia is the lack of strength or the feeling of inability to carry out daily tasks.4 It is more intense towards the end of the day and usually improves after a period of sleep. Weakness is the reduction or loss of muscular strength, and is a key symptom in muscular diseases.4 General terms that are often used by lay persons to describe fatigue are weakness, sluggishness, dullness, apathy, loss of concentration, sleepiness, lack of motivation, irritability and “not feeling like doing anything”.1 Fatigue is generally described and measured as a multidimensional phenomenon and it has a multifactorial aetiology. Cognitive, motivational and physical fatigue are strongly interrelated. Fatigue is furthermore a nonspecific symptom.5 The prevalence of fatigue is estimated to range from 5% to 10%.5 Fatigue is defined as mental or physical tiredness, following prolonged or intense activity.3 It is a desire to rest that reflects exhaustion. Fatigue is the inability of an organism, an organ or a tissue to give a normal response to a stimulus until a certain recovery period has lapsed.3 Incorrect or inadequate food intake or disease may predispose a person to fatigue.3 Fatigue, therefore, is a condition characterised by a lessened capacity for work and reduced efficiency of accomplishment, usually accompanied by a feeling of weariness. Fatigue can be acute and develop suddenly or it can be chronic and persist. Fatigue often remains the only (symptom) diagnosis in an episode of care. Serious functional impairment, psychological symptoms and disturbed sleep often accompany fatigue. Knowledge about the course of fatigue and related symptoms in a heterogeneous population is scarce, because most longitudinal studies on fatigued populations have been performed in selected groups, such as patients with CFS, post-viral fatigue or cancer.5 Generally, a distinction between the different types of fatigue is made based on the time to evolution, namely recent fatigue There are many possible physical and psychological causes of fatigue. Examples are2,6: 10 SAPJOct10pp10-16.indd 10 Aetiology of fatigue SA Pharmaceutical Journal – October 2010 10/14/2010 10:30:35 AM EVIDENCE-BASED PHARMACY PRACTICE l Aetiology of fatigue •• •• •• •• •• An allergy that leads to hay fever or asthma. Anaemia, including iron deficiency anaemia. Depression or grief. Persistent pain. Sleep disorders such as ongoing insomnia, sleep apnoea or narcolepsy. •• Under- or overactive thyroid gland. •• Use of alcohol or drugs such as cocaine or narcotics, especially with regular use. Fatigue can also accompany the following diseases6: •• Addison’s disease. •• Anorexia or other eating disorders. •• Arthritis, including juvenile rheumatoid arthritis. •• Autoimmune diseases such as systemic lupus erythematosus. •• Cancer. •• Congestive heart failure. •• Diabetes mellitus. •• Fibromyalgia. •• Infection, especially an infection that takes a long time to recover from or to treat such as bacterial endocarditis, parasitic infections, tuberculosis and mononucleosis. •• Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS). •• Renal disease. •• Liver disease. •• Malnutrition. Certain medicines may also cause drowsiness or fatigue, including antihistamines, antihypertensives, various central Stress Overwork Sleep difficulties Depression and anxiety Chronic fatigue syndrome Fibromyalgia Medical illnesses Nutritional factors Medications Inactivity and overweight Alcohol (Source: http://www.health.harvard.edu/healthbeat/Hb_images/causes-of-fatigue.jpg) nervous system medicines, steroids and diuretics. Table I gives a comprehensive list of possible causes of fatigue, and Table II provides a summary of medicine classes that may lead to fatigue. Diagnosis of fatigue Symptoms of fatigue typically include: •• Weakness, lack of energy, tiredness and exhaustion. •• Passing out or feeling as if you are going to pass out. •• Palpitations. •• Dizziness. •• Vertigo. •• Shortness of breath. Patients with fatigue have as their typical complaint that they Table I: Conditions or diseases causing fatigue7 Cause Specific examples Sleep disturbances Not enough sleep, too much sleep, sleep apnoea, shift work (changing shifts or night shifts), alcohol Heart disease Congestive heart failure, cardiomyopathy Lung disease Asthma, emphysema or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), pneumonia Nutritional disorders Malnutrition (kwashiorkor, protein deficiency or marasmus, total calorie deficiency), obesity, vitamin deficiency (thiamine, vitamin B12, vitamin B6, folate, vitamin C) Electrolyte disturbances Low potassium, low magnesium, low or high calcium, low sodium Endocrine disorders Hypo- or hyperglycaemia, hypo- or hyperthyroidism, low cortisol (Addison’s disease), high cortisol (Cushing’s syndrome) Gastrointestinal disorders Gastro-oesophageal reflux disease, peptic ulcer disease Neurological disorders Multiple sclerosis, stroke, Lou Gehrig disease Infectious causes Any chronic disease, HIV/AIDS, tuberculosis, hepatitis, mononucleosis, chronic fatigue syndrome, urinary tract infections Connective tissue disorders Osteo- and rheumatoid arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus, fibromyalgia, acromegaly General disorders Cancer, anaemia Gynaecologic conditions Pregnancy, menopause Exercise disturbances Lack of exercise, too much exercise, excessive workload Psychological Depression, anxiety, grief, stress SA Pharmaceutical Journal – October 2010 SAPJOct10pp10-16.indd 11 11 10/14/2010 10:30:36 AM ComoFer A EVIDENCE-BASED PHARMACY PRACTICE Evidence l Table II: Medicines that may cause fatigue7 Medicine class Rationale and specific examples Antihypertensives The ultimate decrease in blood pressure also means a decrease in the amount of work the heart is doing, which can lead to a feeling of fatigue. Some of the medicines also act on the central nervous system. Examples: beta-blockers, calcium channel blockers, diuretics and ACE inhibitors Cardiac medicine Fatigue can be related to the effect of the medication on the heart or to the effects on other areas of the body. Examples: Digoxin, amiodarone, procainamide Central nervous system medicines Medicines for depression and anxiety work by increasing the neurotransmitters in the brain that have a calming effect on the body, thus stimulating fatigue. Examples: Antidepressants, antipsychotics and anxiolytics Narcotics Many analgesics are opiate derived. Drowsiness can be caused by opiates (codeine, hydrocodone, oxycodone and propoxyphene). Muscle relaxants They work by decreasing the contraction of muscles. This relaxation can lead to total body relaxation, which may cause the person to feel fatigued. Example: Orphenadrine feel “run down” and need something to give them energy. Thorough history-taking is necessary to exclude obvious causes such as death of a loved one or a family crisis. The pharmacist should also enquire about associated symptoms and factors if an organic cause is suspected, such as1: •• Diet, for example a vitamin or mineral deficiency, anaemia or low blood sugar. •• Fever and/or pain due to, for example, a malignancy or an infection. •• Chronic conditions, such as diabetes mellitus, hypo- or hyperthyroidism, or asthma. •• Conditions such as sleep apnoea or a female who is perimenopausal. •• Light headedness if the patient stands up suddenly, which may be due to hypotension. Tests that may be performed include: •• Urinalysis to test for protein, blood and glucose. •• Full blood count to check for anaemia, diabetes and possible infection. In children especially, serum ferritin should be checked. •• Thyroid, kidney and liver function tests. Counselling approach to follow Since fatigue is extremely common, most patients will first selfmedicate with vitamin and/or mineral supplements, tonics or stimulants. Any patient requesting advice on fatigue should be thoroughly questioned by the pharmacist since it is most likely that the fatigue has either not responded to over-the-counter (OTC) medication or the symptoms are troublesome enough for the patient to seek advice. A thorough medical and drug history should be taken to enable the pharmacist to rule out serious pathology. A number of specific questions should be asked of the patient (see Table III). The pharmacist should also enquire about the person’s social history (for example, working conditions, and family life and circumstances) since factors such as stress, tension and anxiety can play a significant role in fatigue. It is often useful to ask the 12 SAPJOct10pp10-16.indd 12 patient what he or she thinks is wrong, because that may give an idea of the patient’s emotional state. Usually a physical examination will be performed and further tests may be conducted depending on the outcome of the history taking and physical examination. It is important to reassure the patient if there is no obvious underlying pathology. The patient should also be counselled that there is a relationship between psychological and emotional factors and fatigue, and by being aware of this, can help the patient to deal with the symptoms. When to refer The following patients need urgent referral1,2: •• A patient with depression, for example a patient with suicidal tendencies. •• If the condition does not improve after two weeks of treatment. •• If an organic cause is suspected. •• Significant weight loss. •• Localising or focal neurological signs. •• Any unexplained sudden symptoms, such as syncope, chest pain, shortness of breath, bleeding, severe pain or headache, irregular or fast heartbeat, or if other people and/ or pets in the same household have the same unexplained symptoms (possible carbon monoxide poisoning). Children presenting with sustained fatigue of any duration with no obvious cause should always be referred for paediatric review.2 Treatment Non-pharmacological treatment Non-pharmacological measures include: •• Get adequate, regular and consistent amounts of sleep at night. •• Eat a healthy, well-balanced diet and drink enough water throughout the day. •• Exercise regularly. •• Learn ways to relax, such as yoga or meditation. •• Maintain a reasonable work and personal schedule. SA Pharmaceutical Journal – October 2010 10/14/2010 10:30:39 AM EVIDENCE-BASED PHARMACY PRACTICE Evidence l Table III: Specific questions to ask the patient with fatigue6,7 Aspect Specific questions to ask Onset • • How long have you had the fatigue? Did it develop recently or a while ago? Have you experienced fatigue in the past? Quality • • • • • Does the level of fatigue remain constant throughout the day? Does it get worse as the day progresses, or are you fatigued at the start of the day? Is there a pattern to your fatigue? Time of day or year? Does your fatigue occur at regular cycles? What usually helps to relieve the fatigue? Medication • Do you take any prescription or over-the-counter medicines? If yes, what are you taking? Emotional state • • • • Are you feeling unhappiness or disappointment in your life? Has anyone close to you recently passed away? Do you feel depressed, anxious or stressed? Are you bored? Sleep pattern • • • • How much do you sleep? What hours do you sleep? Do you awake rested or fatigued? How many times do you wake during a typical night? Are you able to fall back asleep? Are you snoring? Exercise • Do you get regular exercise? Stress • Have you had any new stressors in your life, for example moving home, work problems or travelling (jet lag)? Were there any recent changes in your relationship, job, school or living arrangements? • Diet • • • • • Associated symptoms • • Do you eat a balanced diet? Do you take in adequate fluid? Do you regularly consume alcohol? How often do you drink coffee or beverages containing caffeine? Are you currently on a diet? Have you had any recent change in appetite (more or less)? Have you experienced a weight change (increase or decrease)? Do you experience any fever, pain, nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea, blood in urine or stool, shortness of breath, chest pain, constipation, muscle cramps or aches, easy bruising, cough, changes in thirst or urination, inability to sleep lying flat, inability to walk up more than one flight of stairs, menstrual irregularities, swollen legs or any lumps? Do you have any symptoms possibly indicative of poisoning? •• Change stressful circumstances if possible. •• Avoid alcohol, nicotine, excessive consumption of energy drinks and drug use. •• Antibiotics to control infections. •• Vitamins and/or minerals for marginal vitamin/mineral deficiencies The most common cause of persistent fatigue is stress and the emotional response to it. People who feel fatigued most of the time do not necessarily have more stress in their lives, but they may be more sensitive to its effects or may not be able to handle stress well. Stress-induced emotions consume huge amounts of energy. Relaxation therapy in combination with cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) may therefore be beneficial. Relaxation therapies may include a wide variety of therapies, for example, meditation, yoga, self-hypnosis, tai chi, progressive muscle relaxation, aromatherapy and massage. Preparations which can be used to relieve fatigue mainly contain a central nervous system stimulant such as caffeine, together with various vitamins and minerals, or plant extracts1, such as ginseng. There are a wide variety of these products available on the South African market. Stimulants (including caffeine) are, however, not effective for the long-term treatment of fatigue. Pharmacological treatment If there is an underlying disorder causing the fatigue, such as chronic pain or depression, that should be treated first. Many causes of fatigue can be treated with medication, for example: •• Iron supplements for anaemia. •• Medicine or devices to help with sleep apnoea. •• Medicine to control blood glucose or thyroid function. 14 SAPJOct10pp10-16.indd 14 Chronic fatigue syndrome Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) is defined as longstanding, severe, disabling fatigue without demonstrable muscle weakness.8 Underlying disorders that could explain the fatigue are absent. Depression, anxiety, and other psychological diagnoses are typically absent. The intense fatigue of unknown cause limits the patient’s functional capacity, producing various degrees of disability. Treatment is rest and psychological support, often including medicines to alleviate symptoms. SA Pharmaceutical Journal – October 2010 10/14/2010 10:30:39 AM The definition of CFS has several variants and the diverse names for the syndrome over the years, reflect the many and controversial hypotheses about its aetiology.9 CFS was previously known as Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME) which means “inflammation of the brain and spinal cord with muscle pain”. ME is used in the ICD-10 classification system of the World Health Organization as a subheading under Brain Disorders – Post-viral fatigue syndrome. CFS and ME are commonly used as synonyms. Further names that have been used to refer to CFS are, for example, allergic encephalomyelitis, immune dysfunction syndrome, neuroendocrine immune dysfunction syndrome, post viral syndrome, Iceland disease, neurasthenia, Royal Free disease4 and “yuppie flu”. Prevalence is therefore difficult to estimate accurately, but it is said to vary from 7 to 38 in 100 000 people.8 Other sources estimate the prevalence at 0.2% to 2.6%.2 CFS occurs more in females, and patients are generally between 25 and 45 years of age.8,9 Aetiology The aetiology of CFS is controversial, and the precise cause remains unknown. CFS seems to be distinct from typical depression, anxiety or other psychological disorders. Several hypotheses have been postulated, namely4,8: Infectious theory A chronic viral infection has been proposed as a cause because many patients relate the onset of CFS to an event similar to influenza or mononucleosis. Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) has also been proposed as a cause, but immunologic markers of exposure do not appear to be sensitive or specific.8 Approximately 10% of patients are diagnosed with CFS after EBV.9 Other possible but unproven viral causes include enteroviruses, human herpesvirus 6, and human T-cell lymphotropic virus.8 Immunological theory Allergic reactions have also been proposed (about 65% of patients report previous allergies, and the rate of cutaneous reactivity to inhalants or food is 25% to 50% higher in this group than in the general population).8 Immunisation has also been mentioned as a possible cause.2 Various immunologic abnormalities have been reported in patients with CFS. They include low levels of immunoglobulin G (IgG), decreased lymphocytic proliferation, low interferon-g levels in response to mitogens, and poor cytotoxicity of natural killer cells.8 Some patients have abnormal IgG, with circulating autoantibodies and immune complexes. Many other immunologic abnormalities have been studied, but none provides adequate sensitivity and specificity for defining the syndrome.8 There is, therefore, no scientific evidence to attribute the cause of CFS to a primary disorder of the immune system. Neuroendocrinological and other theories Other proposed mechanisms include neuroendocrine abnormalities, abnormal levels of neurotransmitters, inadequate SA Pharmaceutical Journal – October 2010 SAPJOct10pp10-16.indd 15 EVIDENCE-BASED PHARMACY PRACTICE l cerebral circulation and elevated levels of angiotensin converting enzyme (ACE).8 Data indicate that relatives of patients with CFS have an increased risk of developing the syndrome, suggesting a familial or genetic component.8 Symptoms, signs, diagnosis and prognosis The onset of CFS is usually abrupt, and many patients report an initial viral-like illness with swollen lymph nodes, extreme fatigue, fever and upper respiratory symptoms. The main symptom is fatigue (usually for six months or more) that interferes with daily activities (see Table IV for the diagnostic criteria). Because the cause is unknown, diagnosis is by clinical criteria. Further evaluation aims to exclude treatable disorders. There is no laboratory test that can diagnose the condition or measure its severity. A reasonable assessment includes a full blood count and measurement of electrolytes, erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) and thyroid-stimulating hormone. In some cases, chest X-ray and tests for antinuclear antibody, rheumatoid factor, hepatitis, and HIV could be added.8 Viral antibody and other expensive tests are usually unlikely to shed light on the diagnosis or cause. Obvious depression or severe anxiety excludes the diagnosis of CFS. There is an average time of five years from the beginning of the symptoms to the diagnosis of the syndrome, with reported total recovery rates of between zero and 37%, and improvement between 6 and 63%.4 Younger patients and patients without concomitant psychiatric diseases are thought to show the best prognosis, although other studies have shown that the rates for both groups are similar.4 It is estimated that 55% of adults will still have symptoms after six months, with the risk increasing three times if there is an existing history of anxiety or depression.2 Generally the prognosis is better for children.2 Treatment Many symptoms of CFS respond to treatment. Even modest improvements in symptoms can make an important difference to the patient’s degree of self-sufficiency. Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs alleviate headache, diffuse pain and feverishness. Allergic rhinitis and sinusitis are common, and antihistamines Chronic fatigue syndrome Depression Loss of motivation Loss of appetite Fibromyalgia Myalgia/arthralgia Tender points Unrefreshing sleep headaches Prolonged fatigue states Fatigue Pain Poor concentration Irritable mood Anxiety Panic attacks Avoidant behaviour Irritable bowel syndrome Diarrhoea/constipation Abdominal pain Bloating (Source: http://www.eheintl.com/newsltrs/images/chronic_fatigue_syndrome.gif) 15 10/14/2010 10:30:40 AM EVIDENCE-BASED PHARMACY PRACTICE Evidence l Table IV: Diagnostic criteria for chronic fatigue syndrome8 Unexplained, persistent, or relapsing chronic fatigue that is: • new or has a definite onset • not due to ongoing exertion • not substantially alleviated by rest, and • substantially reduces occupational, educational, social or personal activities At least four of the following for 6 months or longer (must not predate the fatigue): Impaired short-term memory (self-reported) severe enough to substantially reduce occupational, educational, social or personal activities Sore throat Low-grade fever Tender, enlarged, painful cervical or axillary lymph nodes Muscle pain Abdominal pain Multijoint pain without joint swelling or tenderness (arthralgia) Headaches that are new in type, pattern or severity Unrefreshing sleep Postexertional malaise lasting more than 24 hours Cognitive difficulties (especially with concentrating and sleeping) and/or decongestants may be helpful. Non-sedating antidepressants are commonly prescribed, although their value is undetermined. Although they improve mood and disordered sleep, they may also attenuate the fatigue. Antiviral treatments with acyclovir and amantadine do not appear to be effective.8 Studies of immunologic treatments, including high-dose immune globulins, dialysable white blood count extract, amphigen, interferons, isoprinosine and corticosteroids have been inconclusive and mostly disappointing.8 Dietary supplements and high-dose vitamins are commonly used, but their usefulness has not been substantiated. Psychological intervention and/or physical rehabilitation programmes may help some patients. Persistent or prolonged rest should be firmly discouraged because it can worsen deconditioning and promote progressive frailty, and also negatively impact on the patient’s self-image. Conclusion Fatigue can become a vicious cycle. If a person feels fatigued, he or she may avoid most forms of physical activity, start worrying about the fatigue and start taking various forms of stimulants. This in turn may cause the person to become physically unfit, stressed about not getting better and dependant on some or other type of “upper” to let him or her feel better. It is difficult to break this cycle once established. There is no single treatment for fatigue. It is imperative that the underlying cause be determined. A thorough history-taking by the pharmacist is therefore important to determine possible causes and also to exclude serious underlying pathology. There are numerous strategies to help a person regain the physical and mental energy needed to enjoy life to its fullest.r References 1. Dekker A, Dreyer AC & Smit R. 1993. Pharmacist Initiated Therapy: Recognition and treatment of minor ailments. Kenwyn: Juta & Co, Ltd. 2. Simon C, Everitt H & Van Dorp F. 2010. Oxford Handbook of General Practice, 3rd Edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 3. Concise Medical Dictionary. 2007. 7th Edition. Oxford: Oxford University Press. 4. Fernández AA, Martín AP, Martínez MI, Bustillo MA, Hernández FJB, Labrado J de la C, Peňas RD, Rivas EG, Delgado CP, Redondo JR & Giménez JRR. 2009. Chronic Fatigue Syndrome: Aetiology, diagnosis and treatment. BMC Psychiatry, 9 (Suppl 1): S1. Available on the web: http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-244X/9/S1/S1 (date accessed: 21 May 2010). 5. Nijrolder I, Van der Windt DAWM & Van der Horst HE. 2008. Prognosis of fatigue and functioning in primary care: A 1-year follow-up study. Annals of Family Medicine, 6 (6): 519-527. 6. Fatigue. 2010. MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia. Available on the web: http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/003088.htm (date accessed: 13 August 2010). 7. Haviland JC & Worthington R. 2010. Fatigue. Available on the web; http:// www.emedicinehealth.com/fatigue/article_em.htm (Date accessed: 13 August 2010). 8. The Merck Manual. 2006. 18th Edition. Edited by Beers MH, Porter RS, Jones TV, Kaplan JL & Berkwits M. Whitehouse Station: Merck Research Laboratories. 9. Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. 2010. Harrison’s Principles of Internal Medicine, 17th Edition Edited by Fauci AS, Braunwald E, Kasper DL, Hauser SL, Longo DL, Jameson JL & Loscalzo J. The McGraw-Hill Companies. Available on the web: http://www.accesspharmacy.com/popup. aspx?aID=2908099&print=yes_chapter (date accessed: 21 May 2010). Although fatigue may be an inescapable part of life for most people, there is no need “to take it lying down”. The body is geared towards generating energy as well as expending it. 16 SAPJOct10pp10-16.indd 16 SA Pharmaceutical Journal – October 2010 10/14/2010 10:30:41 AM