Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
From the Editor: Introduction, Definitions, and Historiography: What Is Atlantic History? Author(s): Alison Games Source: OAH Magazine of History, Vol. 18, No. 3, The Atlantic World (Apr., 2004), pp. 3-7 Published by: Organization of American Historians Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/25163675 Accessed: 28/07/2010 14:12 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use. Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=oah. Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission. JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Organization of American Historians is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to OAH Magazine of History. http://www.jstor.org From the Editor Introduction, and Definitions, Historiography is Atlantic What Alison What is Atlantic history and what does it have to offer those who teach the history of the geographic region that became the United States? This issue of the OAH Magazine of to a field of study with is dedicated History a neither ally accepted nor definition single even Games the Atlantic varied coast were economic, nonetheless social, issue This of a departure readers' a and ing problems issues focus controversies eral this Instead, that the range a one American small history, interconnected large, multifaceted, and African trade 1492 voyage only sphere by 1888, but not until themiddle of the twentieth century inmuch of Atlantic therein. Itespecially focuses on those people whose section topher 1492. transformed of the four continents by after momentous Columbus's These the are not societies for example, North America, or the western or the region lantic Chris and coast surround of historians perspective Within who explore convergences, around, itself? another. seeking the space and these four an At adopt commonalities larger patterns derived from the new interactions of people in necessarily places along the Atlantic Ocean Peru, continents, inter voyage pro generally and independence, through one marks The abo possible 1825, ending. lition of slavery?in the western hemi of these four centuries were interactions revolution Africa?provides societies world. vide a good starting point and the age of Ocean contained about century and especially Atlantic history is most literally the study of a geographic region: the four continents that surround the Atlantic the people or traders, rather transformations, experiences, in one place in terms of condi Columbus's portion. and trans their world example?but in themid-fifteenth con comprises found contact?ports, for European tained within a newly revitalized field of which United States and, more broadly, North its If its beginning point is relatively fixed, Atlantic history's terminus ismore fluid. issue of approaches and around tions deriving from that place's location in on emerg in estab particular of points explaining and events suggesting subjects. showcases Indians migrants, areas of specialization while innovative ways to teach these lished trade diets formed by pathogens, animals, and plants well before they laid eyes on a European. Nor is Atlantic history only about the lit something from other to sharpen strive marks slave while repercussions, American field so inchoate and so elusive that al though its practitioners debate particular issues vigorously, the field as awhole has no overarching points of historiographic contention. in the ensnared and political the world were altered by the new products of the Americas. Many gener parameters, chronological History? "Europe supported by Africa and America," from volume two of John Gabriel Stedman's Narrative, of a Five Year Expedition 1796. Image courtesy of the Lilly Library, Indiana (London, University ing the Great Lakes. Places and people on Bloomington.) the Pacific coast of the Americas were engaged in processes originating from the Atlantic, regardless of their actual geographic location. Africans who lived hundreds ofmiles from within, and across the Atlantic. At the same time, the Atlantic did not form amonolithic region. The Atlantic world may be a coherent unit of analysis, but that does not mean that it was singular, uni form, or harmonious. While people in the Atlantic world might have shared common ordeals that recurred over time in different places, there were also marked variations. OAH Magazine of History Indeed, April 2004 3 is no there nor on the Atlantic, perspective single a narrative single that "circum-Atlantic history: history," as a whole thrust and is the main which which history number a comparative emphasizes looks at a particular place can be fruitfully taught lesson below all include place?a perspective, now universities and introductory provide advertise General Atlantic interdisciplinary journal, forum for research. and Colleges in Atlantic for both for positions history advanced example, Atlantic History state, colony, as Dennis Education An Mode imedici gl'infermi might gration, consumption, transmission place lie elsewhere. The essays in this volume larger in one events for the illustrate the perspective?explaining of the great Atlantic the confluence that or warfare; focused disease shaped and In each case, the contributors labor issue have Nel qnando any of the different nations within the Atlantic. Set within the Atlantic World, the United States, in both its colonial in tutte & I'altrc? I'ljata Spagnuola^ i lot tncdici voleuano curare in* qmkhe fermo^ndauano and early national shared more periods, in and new nations other colonies nel luogo dou'cgUflaua a darli ilfumo>& quando cura to,la MAggwr era bemimbriacato infe ,pointornando with erafht~ diceua the Americas mille mater ie^dieffeteflat 0 at concilia degli Dei, pajfando pifioni atte, voltauano poi Vinfermo 1re b qmttro volte, & tofregauano conlemani il beyond the national borders of a single trans privi national has come history of measures. number by any the existence of tion decades perspective of a cadre of schol particular history, and, European and American larly aggressive in their pursuit added benefit of helping the shadow of the new perspectives Atlantic history, of colonial North Historians predilection. feature of the past to represent tend overwhelmingly economic African the diaspora, history, For colonial historians British history. increasingly, and to integrating perspectives America have of an Atlantic context, are a natural been which particu has the them extricate early American history from United States and the nationalism that infuses its history. Greatly bolstered by the support of Harvard University's International Seminar on the History of the Atlantic World <http:// 4 OAH Magazine of History to this contributors gathered here issue. research American, history. Their insights build on research in multiple April 2004 and and Dutch, ian, Spanish, eluding in different archives in multiple in languages, French, scholars to juggling multiple accustomed the historians history, early modern the African European diaspora, history, and United States, particularly early have approaches (2). These fields?colonial history environmental European visitors often depicted indigenous treatment of illnesses. This interest reflected in part the increased frequency of disease Indian populations. Benzoni, La Historia among (From Girolama del Mondo Nuova [Venice, 1572].) Although offered useful explanatory power is a distinguishing two of The its own of the twentieth the emergence century, ars for whom Atlantic perspective inter The of Atlantic and teach in the fields of world history, into an Atlantic dates from the middle it differed. than is reflected in the fields of specializa leges history without borders. Atlantic is in any way the story although of Atlantic approaches a in which the ways they challenge of national of history exceptionalism looked to explain entity important political formations. Atlantic then, history, explicitly nor do States, tant dimension configurations. and lesson plans, in essays to this essays are not are teenth century through the rise of the coffee house, itself a product of Atlantic commodities re that American, uniquely in the eigh culture political examining a story the and knowledge?that The approach. might be uniquely Atlantic. One impor and in the context of British abolition and the solidification of racialized citizenship during the creation of the United States; or of transfer, plans here on the United convey they to Africa migration exploring dis empires in of factors integration by exploring the Americas quire and lesson revolution, conquest, cultural an Atlantic this of advantages history. swer that question. the illustrate They to funda of answers power explanatory mi historical mental questions?about in this explanations in Atlantic pur in United States or North specialize American The essays and les history? son to an contained here hope plans nel regional larger an ap provides history of na that the requires rejection proach assumes tional histories. Atlantic history that can who chc tengono medicare degrees in students What canAtlantic history offer those DEL DELVHTSTOBJB At for University, Georgetown in history. Graduate at some institutions requirement Atlantic context, At classes. (History 3) fulfills one half of the college's answers seek aspects in seminars, research another sue that world. who those soon will Studies, in scope; lantic perspective should only be invoked if the Atlantic offers a logical unit of But for analysis. and explanations colloquia, of direction of Atlantic to present opportunities regular A new and workshops. the history answers require Atlantic questions the entire of a single an Atlantic in different find history demonstrates. Not all subjects are Atlantic not experience "trans-Atlantic issue; history," and "cis-Atlantic approach; history," an Atlantic context within (i). Atlantic from any vantage any point, through the history be taught within plan the Atlantic of this and of approaches, or nation?can likewise 1.Maika's takes which under www.fas.harvard.edu/~atlantic/index.html>, Bernard historians Bailyn, engaged emerges. David Armitage has identified three different types of Atlantic Ital German, countries. They bring the historiographic conventions of a number of subfields to Atlantic history, thus reinforcing the heterogeneity of the field itself. Atlantic are which disease. ways dents history privileges of this the focus These themes to explore to engage delineate linked?by elsewhere, offer connections issues some migration, of the most three interactions, obvious and and accessible to enable interest. contemporary world the people of the Atlantic and of news in one and region culture, of and commodities, the Atlantic around in which ways commodities produced by the transmission and issue: of historical the many the connections and stu They were consumed by networks, and by diseases that came from far away but had an enormous another of part impact in Disease figures in J.R.McNeill's article, "Yellow Jackand Geopolitics: Environment, Epidemics, and the Struggles for Empire in the American Tropics, and 1650-1825," in Karen E. Carter's lesson "Disease plan, in the Atlantic World, 1492-1900." Both contributors explore the different ways inwhich epidemic diseases affected all of the populations of the Atlantic. Disease shaped the geopolitics of the Atlantic world. It facilitated con as American Europeans, and devastating diseases. quest by unfamiliar enous of commentators the Americas, to prepare of how to a range of and indig European theme of the invasion succumbed for Indeed, a recurring of Chocolate," quests Karen Carter Norton Marcy their and preparation us that reminds then, and them helped corrosive of some and, secure in ultimately, tling of those empires. the potent Then, America colonial ern Atlantic. He both tion production, North als shaped such illnesses, mosquito-born particular danger men, his second theme overarching in search of goods to trade?salt, and chocolate sugar, became more Atlantic conquests to learn how needed are two nection new in the coffeehouse engages im globalization that students and also about choices number of can contemporary issues. of con than form any other interaction within and The gion. varied re the of circumstances the emergence shaped of cul tures around the Atlantic, both through were highly controversial. Commodities This image depicts in a negative the use of coffee and tobacco light. (From Two Broadsides courtesy Against Tobacco 1672], page [London, of the Folger Shakespeare Library.) and as malaria, some shaped the of as McNeill notably, illus this issue is commodities. ivory, spices, fabric, minerals such these of which questions migration most rise the more world Other like commodities, products. in Europe and elsewhere readily available through and environmental transformations. Europeans to use Euro third theme of the volume is migration, which defined the Atlantic such as gold and silver, and dyes. They found these commodities, but they also found many others with which they were unfamiliar. To bacco a often in which The Europeans ventured across the Atlantic and south toWest and Central Africa one and plan, consumption to any apply and historical of of on lesson portant trates, the destruction of empires and the emergence of the first two republics of the western Atlantic, the United States and Haiti. The was commodities affair, and their own culture. Christopher Doyle most profound political transformations in the Atlantic world in their to European cura the great of production, but also the ritu re Commodities consumption. their own spaces, their own rituals, of focuses military conventions all joined to create aworld conducive to the aedes aegyptimosquito and the spread of yellow fever. In turn, yellow fever and other new quired re a number rivalries and peans learned from Indians not only the of the west imperial a secular madrigal, tobacco of methods and Africans, the environ Europeans that sustained transformations sugar a wrote protracted variables converged to provide a world in which yellow fever thrived. Migration of mental deeply in also essay controversial. tive powers of the plant (3).The introduc mortality similarly shaped geopolitics. McNeill examines the differential impact of yellow fever on the African, European, populations that argues were unprocessed produced themselves. This continued high mortality shaped colonial societies as fully as any other feature. High and differential and American-born Her chocolate. song, about tobacco in which he evoked in both music and lyrics the mind-spin ning impact of the powerful nicotine of settle never populations of (1575-1623) by the high mortality of European settlers. In the Chesapeake, decades passed before the colonial population could sustain itself without infusions ofmigrants, while in the Carolinas, Georgia, and the colonies of the Caribbean, to the complex readers The English composer Thomas Weelkes disman Colonial and In "Con Indian products and practices; and the effects were unknown. substances The more powerful commodities the more their use. debated were, Europeans as now, were narcotics in celebrated songs. popular powerful em their in southeastern especially were and in the Caribbean, ments, social of adaptation of the more pires, it similarly played a role in settlement patterns the also Europeans did not know how to use them; they feared the possibly in particular focuses introduces consumption as now, commodities on the havoc wreaked by smallpox among the indigenous people of New France. If disease facilitated conquest by Euro peans but them, story of chocolate and how Europeans adopted Indian practices false game and then drawing on the Jesuit Relations, consume and set by soldiers, inventive true or an Using Indians was disease alike, whether or traders. tlers, terms cultural contexts inwhich commodities might be employed. the world. substances not just in practical 63. the transmission pean tion cultures Image of African in and (4). Because transforma was slavery Euro and their the subject of the April 2003 OAH Magazine ofHis tory, it is not featured in this issue, but themigration of enslaved Africans is certainly the dominant story of transatlantic migration, and all who teach migration in this period should be acutely aware of the striking disparity in statistics between African and European 1,042,100 example, and ing mainland cans in the same Between migration. Europeans Caribbean 1800, for includ America, to 2,333,140 Afri compared are even more pronounced colonies, The period. and 1600 to British migrated disparities the two regions of British settlement: 752,200 Europeans migrated to the mainland, compared to 287,600 Africans, while within 289,900 Europeans 2,045,550 Africans numbers continue to be striking, traveling across the Atlantic 1800, Africans compared clearly did Europeans, to migrated the Caribbean, compared to (5). Incorporating the entire western Atlantic, the with to 1,410,000 Europeans as coerced traveled and especially African 7,615,000 to the Americas captives in the period before between 1500 captive laborers, and 1783 (6). but so too those from the British Isles to British OAH Magazine of History April 2004 5 of whom the majority colonies, laborers. bound were People is one the most the valuable of violence and in North and Even "voluntary'' ostensibly were migrations to migrate. sions that were patterns in scope. Migration often triangular were also that shaped deci shaped two The in eco embedded by on essays about decisions In "German-Speaking travel. a place defined migration cultures Roman on a long of miles colonies to west phe nomenon inUnited States his were patterns the around "Come, Sirrah Jack, Ho," from four continents continents frame. cultures these at work. to colony, as Africa they also ventured of return migration to returned of migrants 15 percent to the Americas east, from are for Europeans Trade: African Her Leone. more and many England, delineates essay settlement focuses migration of on two the networks important (Boston, MA: consisting Marion Liberia. English Menzin's travelers lesson to the mainland plan on J. Maika's lesson plan, "New York was a Always Amsterdam," provides a capstone to the issue by engaging a single fundamental question: What did itmean to live in a single place in the Atlantic world? He answers this question by exploring the global nature century, of New Amsterdam reminding us under that New 6 OAH Magazine of History Dutch in the seventeenth dominion York was April 2004 always a place shaped by its Beacon Press, 1992). in Armitage and Braddick, eds., The British Dewald, ed., Europe (New York: Charles 1991. eds. The British Atlantic World, 1500 David and Michael J. Braddick, Armitage, 2002. 1800. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, Itinerario 20 (1996): 19-44. "The Idea of Atlantic History." Bailyn, Bernard. P. and Anthony eds. Colonial Canny, Nicholas Identity in the Atlantic Pagden, colonies, Global City: The Impact ofWorld Trade on Seventeenth-Century New of the Atlantic Slave plications American Destinations and New World for further Suggestions reading: in Ida and James Horn, eds. 'ToMake America': Airman, European Emigration CA: University of California the Early Modern Period. Berkeley, Press, but reminds us of the many variables that shaped decisions about and of the centrality of labor to colonial development. Dennis For issues in Jonathan "The Atlantic Games, Ocean," of the Early Modern World 1450-1780,: Encyclopedia Scribner's Sons, 2004). 6. Alison migration Finally, is hotly debated. applied to Africans, see, for example, Paul E. Lovejoy, these Enslaved Africans "Identifying in the African from Diaspora," in the ed., Lovejoy, Identity Regional Origins, in David Eltis Games, 5. Alison "Migration," Atlantic World, 41. of Africans and people of African descent in the United States and in Canada and British and American abolitionists, who organized the migrations that created the British colony of Sierra Leone and the American the Atlantic and David Richardson, eds., Routes to Developments," in Transatlantic Slave Trade and the Direction, Slavery: Ethnicity, Mortality and Richard Price, (London: Frank Cass, 1997), 122-45; Sidney W. Mintz Culture: An Anthropological The Birth of African-American Perspective fiend anticipated a return but died before achieving their goal. Nemata Blyden's essay, "Back to Africa: the Migration of New World Blacks to Sierra Leone and Liberia," highlights one such migratory flow in her survey of those Africans and people of African descent who elected to leave the Americas for Africa, specifically for the colonies of Liberia and Sierra to of migrants ability of Old World elements across and ethnicities Shadow (New York: of Slavery Continuum, 1-29; Philip 2000), D. Morgan, Im "The Cultural ishly difficult to determine, but in the seventeenth century asmuch as 10 to cultures world, cross they traveled. And Rates and Europe. and frame. in Philip Ledger, ed., The Oxford Book of English Madrigals (Lon Press don: Oxford University 4. The transfer and the ocean ing imperial and national bor ders continents the period of people convergence these of Department, 1978), 70-1. This song is available on numer ous recordings and is generally to students. amusing frequently Atlantic colony 19-44. (1996): Weelkes, 3. Thomas varied also moved People from more far but tory, early modern Endnotes Ifthe United States was only one small corner of the Atlantic World, itwas nonetheless for the entire modern period a place defined by the transforming convergence of people and away. as an east treated corner small Music is generally Migration the ocean and and to ven Empire and expensive journey to English thousands continents the cir encouraged migrants from the Holy ture by the transforming religious that permitted of information one only the entire in David Armitage "Three Concepts of Atlantic History," J. Braddick, eds., The British Atlantic World, (New 1500-1800 York: Palgrave Macmillan, 11-27. 2002), 2. See especially Itinerario 20 Bernard Bailyn, "The Idea of Atlantic History," across east to migrate not west into but rather the Atlantic, who the small minority elected Beiler's essay explores Europe. to travel west. Her research created primarily reveals networks, complex culation for Armitage, and Michael tended circles, of four was i. David central dissenting compet in Immigrants the British Atlantic World, 1680-1730," Rosalind J.Beiler uncovers the networks that furthered the migration of German-speaking people within the British Atlantic world. German-speaking people in general within and can States If the United society. it was nonetheless Atlantic world, interactions illustrate the complex web of information and experience that shaped people's and Afri Indians, Europeans, where reluctant proximity, ing empires shared contested borders, and where the heterogeneity, innovation, and hybridity of any single place were both a product and reflection of Atlantic connections and a defining attribute of Ameri subor dination. nomic, political, religious, and cultural dislocation generally replicated for any where America, place single cans lived in uncomfortable across the of enslavement coercion, global ties. His approach can be more as Atlantic commodities So the larger story of migration of the Atlantic world. Atlantic across ventured among -, Press, World, NJ: Princeton University 1500-1800. Princeton, ed. Europeans on the Move: Studies on European Migration, Press, Oxford, UK: Oxford University 1994. Cook, Noble David. Born to Die: Disease and New World Conquest, 1987. 1500-1800. 1492-1650. UK: Cambridge Press, University 1998. Cambridge, and Cultural Conse Crosby, Alfred W. The Columbian Exchange: Biological CT: Greenwood, quences of 1492. Westport, 1972. Curtin, Philip D. The Rise and Fall of the Plantation Complex: Essays inAtlantic History. Second Edition. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1998. The Old World and the New, 1492-1650. Cambridge, John Huxtable. Press, 1970. University Cambridge Eltis, David. The Rise of African Slavery in the Americas. Cambridge, Press, 2000. University Cambridge Alison. Borders: Teaching American Games, "History without History Indiana Magazine Atlantic Context." of History 91 (1995): 159-78. Elliott, -. UK: UK: in an Klooster and Alfred Americas. Mann, Kristin Padula, eds., The Atlantic Imagination. Upper the Odds: Free Blacks Saddle Essays on NJ: Prentice World: River, in the Slave Societies of the London: Frank Cass, 1996. Edna G. Bay, eds. Rethinking and a Making of Black Atlantic Frank Cass, 2001. World the African Diaspora: the in the Bight of Benin and Brazil. London: I The Shaping of America: A Geographical Perspective on 500 Years Volume I, Atlantic America, 1492-1800. New Haven, CT: Yale Press, 1986. Syndey W. Sweetness and Power: The Place of Sugar inModern History. New York: Viking, 1985. David. Africa's Discovery Northrup, of Europe, 1450-1850. New York: Oxford Press, 2002. University University "Round Press, 1995. University eds. Atlantic American Societies: From Karras, Alan L. and J. R. McNeill, Columbus 1992. through Abolition 1492-1888. London: Routledge, "The Rise and Transformation In of the Atlantic World." Klooster, Wim. and Slavery, Migration, Hall, 2004. Landers, Jane G., ed. Against of History. Mintz, and the Origins of the English Atlantic World. Migration Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1999. -. Itinerario 23 (1999): "Teaching Atlantic History." 162-73. David. Citizens of theWorld: London Merchants and the Integration of Hancock, the British Atlantic Community, UK: Cambridge 1735-1785. Cambridge, Wim D. W. Meinig, Table Conference: Nature The of Atlantic Itinerario History." 23 (1999): 48-173. Stuart B., ed. Implicit Understandings: and Schwartz, Reporting, Observing, on the Encounters Between Reflecting Europeans and Other Peoples in the UK: Cambridge Press, 1994. Early Modern Era. Cambridge, University in theMaking Thornton, John Kelly. Africa and Africans of the Atlantic World, Second edition. UK: Cambridge 1400-1800. Cambridge, University Press, Alison 1998. Games is associate professor of history at University. Georgetown She is the author ofMigration and the Origins of the English Atlantic World (1999), which won the 1999 Theodore Saloutos Book Award in American Immigration History from the Immigration and Ethnic History Society. She has also written articles on various aspects of the seventeenth centuryAtlantic World and on teaching Atlantic history, which she offers as an introductory ...Top ljoup courses survey course at Georgetown. in Larlij American history 1 "Colonial America is a good, solid | of North 1 history of the colonization covers the America that accurately j roles and contributions of Native | Americans and Africans." | Rick Pointer, Westmont College 1 y I HH^fl^^S^HI^^^^P Atlantic peoples of the four continents,and discusses the social, Lives A Comparative Approach to Early America Timothy J. Shannon, Gettysburg College ?2004 272 pages Paper ISBN 0-321-07710-5 each chapter thematically, new reader features Organizedof this primary source selections that place Early a American in comparative History context with the wider Atlantic World. are drawn The selections from a wide of non-traditional travel narratives including variety Africa, the Caribbean, sources, from West is very well balanced "The material | all the European between expansion in the western the Africa, hemisphere, native American and the populations, of both Europeans, mterrnixing | and American natives." 1 Africans, - Tom Baptist Wayland University Ray, To order examination copies- Web: www.ablongman.com l|| E-mail: [email protected] i | || |l 1 l|| Fax:(617)848-7490 1 Contact your local sales representative 111 and Latin America. OAH Magazine of History April 2004 7