Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Manufacturing White Paper Targeted Sales Incentive Management for Automobile Manufacturers: Building the Required Capabilities About the Authors A V Krishna Rao Business Consultant, Manufacturing Innovation and Transformation Group (ITG), TCS Krishna has over 18 years of industry and consulting experience with major automotive OEMs. His experience includes diverse areas such as customer experience management in the sales and marketing function, order management, dealer management, warranty management, automotive finance, insurance, and analytics. Having extensively worked with various OEMs, he is an expert in incentive management. Krishna holds a Bachelor of Engineering Degree in Mechanical Engineering and a Management Degree from Xavier Labor Relations Institute (XLRI), Jamshedpur. Akshay Jadhao Business Analyst, Manufacturing Innovation, and Transformation Group (ITG), TCS Akshay has extensive consulting experience in customer experience management and business process modeling for large manufacturing clients. He has in-depth knowledge in dealer incentive management, manufacturing excellence, and supply chain transformation business processes. Akshay is certified in Production and Inventory Management (CPIM) from APICS, USA. He is also a Six Sigma Green Belt (CSSGB) and a certified professional in Programmable Logic Controller (PLC) and Supervisory Control & Data Acquisition (SCADA) Automation. Apart from holding a Bachelor of Technology degree in Instrumentation, Akshay holds a Management degree from the Indian Institute of Management, Kozhikode. Targeted incentive management is increasingly becoming a high focus area for most automotive Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) today Automotive manufacturers in the US spend an astounding 45 billion USD per annum on incentives. Targeted incentive capabilities for dealers result in the right offer being made for the right model mix in the right market. OEMs need to leverage targeted incentive capabilities as a strategic tool to gain a competitive advantage in the automotive retail market and increase the volume of vehicles sold, while maintaining the same overall incentive expense. A targeted incentive management application is required to overcome operational complexity resulting from acquiring superior levels of flexibility, intelligence, and targeting capability in automotive incentive management. This will result in a more effective utilization of the incentive fund — the savings potential can be so substantial that OEMs can break even in the very first year of operations. This white paper describes a targeted incentive management framework and also dwells upon some important aspects of automotive incentive management. Contents The Incentive Cost Challenge 7 Acquiring Targeted Incentive Management Capabilities 7 Building Intelligence Capabilities in Targeted Incentive Management 8 Building Targeted Incentive Execution Capabilities 10 Primary Capability 10 Advanced Capability 10 Framework for Achieving Targeted Incentive Capability 11 Targeted Incentive Management Process Overview 13 Incentive Program Design 13 Incentive Launch 15 Incentive Validation and Payment 15 Analytics Data Mining 16 17 Big Data in Incentive Management 17 Incentive Management Capability Maturity Model 18 The Way Forward 19 The Incentive Cost Challenge Incentives in the automotive industry play a significant role in the marketing mix of most OEMs. Apart from sweetening a deal, incentives allow OEMs to customize pricing as a response to demand and supply fluctuations in the market. The incentive amount per vehicle is a function of historical data, inventory levels, market elasticity of demand, and product pricing.¹ In the US market alone, auto makers spend billions of dollars on incentives. Latest trends indicate that the percentage of vehicles covered by incentives is growing². Considering the dollar spend on incentive management, this area is fast becoming a high focus area for most automotive OEMs. Automotive OEMs equipped with targeted incentive management capabilities are better placed to get favorable returns for their incentives. In our experience, the savings potential is so substantial that some OEMs break even on the investment in the first year of operations. Acquiring Targeted Incentive Management Capabilities OEMs today need to leverage targeted incentive capabilities as a strategic tool to gain a competitive advantage in the automotive retail market and increase the volume of vehicles sold. While doing this, however, they must be watchful about maintaining the same overall incentive expense. Typical challenges that drive OEMs to acquire targeted incentive management capability include: n Lack of flexibility in generating a large number of scenarios with incentive costs calculated by the system to arrive at the most optimal mix of incentive scenarios within the given constraints n Lack of ability within the incentive management system to target a specific segment of vehicles, customers, geographies, or a mix of these n Lack of comprehensive analytics and data mining capabilities Incentives are now an essential ingredient in the sales promotion recipe of automotive OEMs and are considered to be qualifiers more than differentiators ¹Design Incentives, Incentives and the Automotive Industry (2005), accessed May 1, 2013, http://www.incentivecentral.org/pdf/incentives_and_auto_ind.pdf ²CNW Research, Retail Automotive Summary (Mar 2013), accessed May 1, 2013, http://automotivedigest.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/Retail-Automotive-SummaryMarch-2013.pdf 7 Targeted incentive management capabilities entail acquiring intelligence and execution capabilities as depicted in Figure 1. Acquiring Targeted Incentive Management Capabilities Intelligence Capability Execution Capability Helps in identifying and selecting targets within the budget constraints Equips the user with capability to target the segment at all desired granularity level with customized incentive schemes Figure 1: Acquiring Target Incentive Management Capabilities Building Intelligence Capabilities in Targeted Incentive Management In our experience, the savings potential is so substantial that OEMs can break even on the investment in the very first year of operations Incentive management systems are complex enterprise applications that extensively interface with several other key internal and external enterprise applications, and should ideally allow a seamless flow of information across the incentive management value chain. In many OEMs, incentive management systems merely work as workflow management systems – building intelligence into such systems can result in better planning of incentive schemes. An effective incentive management application typically includes the following capabilities: 1. Generates incentive program scenarios using a scenario generator 2. Calculates incentive cost for any given scenario based on production planning inputs and penetration rates, and compares the costs with allocated budgets across car models, geographies, and time period 3. Builds business intelligence into the system using a business rule engine, enhancing the system's predictive capabilities 4. Provides a large variety of incentive types for launching various incentive programs 8 5. Plans and tracks the yearly budget (Budget Planner) 6. Interfaces with key enterprise applications to gather real-time process and business data 7. Acts as a decision support system, leveraging analytics, data mining and big data capabilities 8. Enables close integration between modules Close integration between the various incentive modules enables a seamless flow of information across the incentive management value chain, as depicted in Figure 2. inistration and S Adm e cu m rity ste y S Design Planning and Budgeting of Incentive Scenarios, Scenario Generation, Taking Approvals Analytics Datamart, Dashboards, Geo Mapping, Ad Hoc Reports, Data Mining, Provide Inputs for Scenario Generator Launch Incentive Management System Creation of Incentive Program Documents, Communication to Stakeholders Accounting Payment Reconciliation, Posting of Expenses to Financial System Validation and Payment Qualification of Dealer Claims, Payment to Dealers Figure 2: Seamless Flow of Information across the Incentive Management Value Chain [3] Wired, Fiat releases details of first ever crowd-sourced car (Aug 2010), accessed Aug 1, 2013, http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2010-08/18/fiat-mio 9 Building Targeted Incentive Execution Capabilities Primary Capability Primary targeted incentive capability comprises the ability to filter by slight variations in model, customer geography, and dealer geography for any given time period. This enables the OEM to design customized incentive schemes for a specific model or model year (right up to option code and color) with either a specific customer geography (even a ZIP code) or a specific dealer geography (right up to the dealer code) (Figure 3). Primary targeted incentive capabilities can be acquired by building a high degree of granularity for model year/customer geography/ dealer geography Advanced Capability Advanced targeted incentive capability can be achieved by integrating the incentive management system with the Customer Relationship Management (CRM) system (to build customer-facing incentive programs) and by integrating dealer systems (to build dealer-facing incentive programs). This is depicted in Figure 3. With advanced capability, building a specific program becomes much easier as it merely involves setting the parameters in the system. The system in turn builds the incentive program by fetching the relevant data from the CRM database. Some scenarios are listed below. Advanced Targeted Capability System with Intelligence Customer Facing Offer Primary Capability Customer Filter Dealer Facing Offer Dealer Filter Vehicle Filter Loyalty offersCustomers Conquest Events and who OffersGeographic bought Vehicle ExhibitionsTargeting Direct Mail two or exchange Detroit Auto Campaigns more OEM offers to Show for a vehicles in owners of Country selected list the past competing handRegion raisers of customers 10 years brand Geographic Targeting Brand Make Model Line Model Year Model Code Trim Body Style Drive Train Engine Transmission Option Code Exterior Color State District City Colony Zip Code CRM Integration Customer Demographic Profile + Extended Targeting Opportunities Advanced Capability: Integration with CRM gives the ability to target a specific customer segment Incentive Duration Flexibility Country Region State District City Colony Zip Code Dealer Category A, B and C tiered dealers in particular district RatingsTop 10 dealers in the latest balance scorecard ratings Inventory OfferingDealers with more than 30 cars in the inventory for more than 2 months Dealer System Integration Dealer Profile / Category / Size Extended Targeting Opportunities Advanced Capability: Integration with Dealer System gives the ability to target a specific Dealer Group Intelligence System Support Figure 3: Targeted Incentive Management – Advanced Capability 10 CRM Integration – Customer-Facing Offers for Advanced Targeted Incentive Capability 1. Loyalty offers for customers who bought two or more vehicles from the OEM in the past 10 years 2. Conquest offers for customers who own a competing brand car that is over four years old 3. Incentive offers for auto show 'hand-raisers' (leads) 4. Direct mail campaign to customers: A list of customers that be generated on a parameter (or a mix of parameters) such as demographic profile. For example, the offer might target high-net-worth customers above a certain income level or young customers below a certain age level or high-net-worth young women. Based on the data, the list is queried from the CRM system and an incentive program is created for this specific customer segment. Dealer System Integration – Dealer-Facing Offers for Advanced Targeted Incentive Capability 1. Incentive programs based on specific dealer category such as A, B, C category: The category is defined by the size of the city or the size of the dealership. 2. Incentive programs based on dealer ratings: for example, specific incentive programs for Top 100 dealers in balanced scorecard rating 3. Inventory offerings: Incentive schemes targeted to dealers with non-moving stocks of a particular model. Based on stocks of the model at dealerships, the system calculates the incentive cost outflow to help plan the scheme. Based on the data, a list of targeted dealers is queried from the dealer system database and an incentive program is created for this specific dealer segment. Framework for Achieving Targeted Incentive Capability Planning, launching, and managing incentive schemes with high levels of granularity is a complex activity. The incentive management system needs to handle high level of functionality and complex logic along with extensive workflows. An end-to-end incentive management application is necessary to increase process automation and accuracy of information. The application should cater to the entire lifecycle of all incentive types applicable to new vehicles. A comprehensive targeted incentive management framework, as shown in Figure 4, provides the basic building blocks for the implementation. The framework must be conceptualized to enable a seamless flow of real-time, accurate, and relevant information across enterprise applications. A business rule engine, coupled with the availability of relevant real-time information, helps the system respond intelligently beyond just performing workflow management tasks. 11 The key drivers of as well as barriers to implementation of an effective incentive management system are indicated in Figure 4. OEM Third Party Interfaces OEM Internal Interfaces Vehicle Customer CRM Production Planning Vehicle Registration Inventory PIN Codes Competitor Incentive Schemes Drivers n n Incentive Design Planning for Various Incentive Types Scenario Generator Generate Targeted Incentive Scenarios with specific granularity levels Launch Validation and Payment Accounting Selection of Mode of Distribution Receiving Claims Setting up Payment Controls Selection of Recipients Receiving claim supporting proof Posting of information expenditure into finance system Generation of Program Documents Validation of information Accounts Reconciliation Business Plan Creator Payment Generation of Reports System Administration and Security Security Audit Analytics Regulatory Reporting Analytics Data Mining Integration Framework – FTP / Web Services / Others % Operational Reporting OEM Third Party Interfaces System Administration Accessories Coupons Information n Program Approval (Final) and Launch Third Party Verification n Incentive Approvals Dealership Sales Force Training n Lack of Standardization across Geographies in formats like Vehicle Hierarchy, Geographical Hierarchy, Dealer Class, Single Sign on access, Taxation and Legal Requirements, Business Calendar Cycles (FY vs Model Yr). Lack of Standardization in incentive types or incentive programs Differences in Incentive Program Structures. Differences in Currency, brand, language etc. Dealer Portal Grouping of scenarios. Comparison of Incentive Program Cost vs. Budget. Barriers n Financial System n A System OEM Internal Interfaces n Management Captive Finance Company n Incentive Dealer n Competitive Advantage due to Targeted Incentive Capability Significant Improvement in Process Automation, Speed & Accuracy of Information Improved Communication with Dealers and Customers Improved Analytical capability Mitigation of risk associated with complex incentive programs calculations manually Prevent Revenue leakage External B2C Websites Legal Document Generator Operational Data Store Datamart Figure 4: Targeted Incentive Management Framework 12 Targeted Incentive Management Process Overview Figure 5 elaborates the process overview of a state-of-the-art targeted incentive management system in a connected enterprise. Incentive Program Design The system should have the following capabilities: n Improve planning: The system should enable the OEM to plan incentive budgets for any time period. Flexible scenario generators can generate several incentive scenarios at required levels of granularity. Mining and analysis of historical data to spot historical trends and co-relations also helps in the effective design of incentive programs. n Effective design of finance or lease schemes: Many incentives are passed on to the customer as finance or lease schemes. The system should enable the user to design an effective finance or lease scheme for the customer by providing historical information on loan tenure and customer credit ratings. For example, the system should be able to provide information on the customer demographics/spread and the interest rates based on tenure and credit rating based on similar schemes run in the past. The system should enable the user to allocate different subvention amounts to different tenure or credit rating segments and should also have finance/lease sandbox facility which gives the field users or regional managers the flexibility to tweak the incentive schemes within the defined constraints. n Improved cost projections: The system should factor in production planning data and historical penetration rates in order to project the incentive cost. The system should be able to analyze the incentive cost across geography, model, time periods, or a combination of these. n Better decision-making: The system should facilitate comparison of various incentive programs across timelines for better decision making. It should allow executive management to make decisions quickly online by allowing the submitted incentive programs to be approved, rejected, or put on hold. The system utilizes production planning data and historical penetration rates for similar incentive programs, to project the incentive cost. 13 Data Mining n n Analytics Analyze current Incentive Programs Data mine historical Data for spotting patterns, trends, correlations, Spatial Data Mining etc. Payments Claim Validation by OEM Posting information to Financial System Claims Scenario Generator Scenario2 Accounting and Reconciliation Scenario2 Scenario7 Scenario1 Vehicle Retail Delivery Report Scenario1 Scenario1 Scenario2 Generation of Targeted Incentive Scenarios with specific granularity levels for Model / Geography / Time Period / Customer Segment / Dealerselations, Spatial Data Mining etc. Dealer files Claims with OEM Third Party Verification REJECTED Communication of Rejections to Dealers Reports Incentive Passed on by Dealer to Customer Customer approaches Dealer for vehicle purchase and incentive Customer gets information of the incentive scheme Iteration Check if Cost of Incentive Scenarios is exceeding budget. If yes, the scenarios need to be modified suitably in an iterative process. Dealer checks eligibility of vehicle / customer for incentive scheme B2C Websites Generation and Approval of Program Documents Approval of Executive Management emails Dealer gets information of the incentive scheme Incentive Program Launch Communication of Incentive related Information with Customers / Dealers / Finance Companies / Other Stakeholders Portals Figure 5: Targeted Incentive Management Process Overview 14 Incentive Launch The incentive management system should have an automated document generation capability to facilitate the program document creation and distribution process. The launch of the incentive program is the first functional area for incentive administration. It serves the following purposes: n Allows building of customized target lists for a particular incentive program n Allows users to create program documents with selected or uploaded templates n Distributes the right program documents to the right audience at the right time at the right place through the chosen mode of distribution Incentive Validation and Payment The classification of various incentive types and their validation methodology is given in Table 1. # Incentive Group Incentive Type 1. Cash and Target Incentives Cash Basic cash Incentives for customers and dealers. Payment made after sale of the specified vehicle Sales TargetBased Volume-based incentives for dealers PerformanceBased Incentives paid to dealers based on ranking on a certain criteria such as sales or balance scorecard scores; also includes incentives paid directly to dealer sales executives or managers on achievement of targets Finance Incentives triggered by the finance company include This is a two-step process Annual Percentage Rate (APR), lease, special discounts, etc. where notifications from the financial institution are validated in the system using retail receipts, and the payment is made to the beneficiary. 2. Finance Incentives 3. Third Party Claims-Based Incentives Incentive Claim Validation Methodology Incentives for which claims have to be submitted to get benefits, such as customer loyalty programs, coupons, certificates, etc. Simple one-step validation process. Data sent by the dealer in the form of New Vehicle Retail Delivery Report or Retail Receipts is processed and paid. Third-party incentives are either handled by or routed through third-party vendors for validation. Verification is done by checking vehicle registration details or calling up the customers. Table 1 : Classification of Incentive Types and their Validation Methodology 15 Figure 6 depicts the incentive type classification on the basis of the process flow and incentive award. Direct and indirect multi-entity processes, depicted in the last row of the figure, aid or complete the overall validation and payment function. These include dispute resolution, registration status, adjustments, etc. Stacking of various incentive programs can be achieved by building business rules in the rule engine. Dealer Communication Financial/ Third Party Incentives Third Party Agencies Cash & Target Incentives Retail Delivery Report Financial Incentives Retail Delivery Report Third Party Incentives Retail Delivery Report Validation & Approval DirectIndirect Multi-Entity Processes Requests & Queries Requests & Notifications IMS Engines Processing Claims Qualification on the basis of Payment Information & Sales type Notification & Contract Details Enterprise Level Transaction Financial Transactions Credit/Debit for Audit Purpose Disputes/ Adjustments Miscellaneous Legends Process Flow Actor Processes Figure 6: Incentive Validation and Payment Analytics The purpose of having an analytics solution is to increase and improve the OEM's ability to obtain, analyze, and report on incentive data generated during the lifecycle, as well as on other incentive program-related information coming from external systems and data sources. This calls for a data mart, as well as a robust reporting and analytics framework. These components allow access to historical incentive-related data for executive dashboards and comprehensive reporting on all aspects of incentive management and compensation process. An analytics solution for the incentive management system should have features such as dashboards, data mining, and geo-mapping reports. 16 Data Mining Data mining requirements are met using exploratory data analysis, statistical technique, and simulation models. We believe the following solutions for customer segmentation and profiling will improve an organization's understanding of its customers, as well as their purchasing and response behavior, to make incentive programs more effective. n Predictive modeling: Develop various predictive models to find out the customers (within different customer segments) likely to respond to the incentive programs. This will help target the right customer with the right incentive program and will improve the overall return on investment. n Fraud identification: Mitigate payments or services to fraudulent claims by constructing data driven strategies. n Attribute identification: Identify the key attributes of vehicle models that help in increase in sales. n Pattern recognition functionality: Find patterns and develop classification schemes for data in very large data sets. This will help determine previously unknown or unexpected relationships between incentive management factors and other incentive indicators (such as incentive spend and profitability). n Geo-spatial data mining: Search for and analyze relationships and patterns between data elements and geographic components. For example, in case of a mispricing in the market, a geo-spatial data mining algorithm can be developed to look for inherent spatial groups in the point data and assign customers to geographically similar areas. Big Data in Incentive Management Big Data can help automotive companies achieve the desired sales and revenue targets by helping users make the right decisions and thereby optimizing incentive spends. Increased competition, social media consumption, and advance analytical techniques make Big Data an obvious choice for automotive manufacturers. Big Data helps build intelligence into the Incentive Management System, thereby aiding manufacturers to make the right decisions, not just on the basis of monthly or yearly data but also by using a number of internal and external data sources with direct inputs from consumers and dealers. As can be seen in Figure 7, the Big Data capabilities of the automotive industry for dealer and customer incentives have a lot of scope for growth. Big Data helps build intelligence into an Incentive Management System, facilitating effective decisionmaking, something that wasn't possible a few years ago. 17 Analytical Capability Automotive Value Chain Procurement Product Development Finance Un-explored Big Data Capability in Future Marketing Logistics Dealer & Customer Incentives Warranty Very Weak Weak Minimum Threshold Average Strong Very Strong Legends Below Threshold: Yet to emerge as Competitive Advantage Above Threshold: Emerged as Competitive Advantage Figure 7: Big Data in Incentive Management (Source: TCS Internal Research) Incentive Management Capability Maturity Model The Incentive Management System will vary depending on the maturity level of the existing incentive management capabilities in an OEM. Four levels of maturity are defined and depicted at the Incentive Management Capability Maturity Model shown in Figure 8. As an OEM moves up these levels, its incentive management maturity, capability, and performance improve, whereas the risks associated with incentive management reduce. 18 IMCMM Incentive Management Capability Maturity Model Incentive Management IT Systems Maturity High Level 4 Incentive Management Performance Incentive Management Capability Incentive Management Maturity Level 3 Low Business Intelligent Incentive Management System with Analytics, Incentive Scenario Generation and Targeted Incentive Capabilities Level 2 Automated Workflow Management, Limited Interfacing Capability Leading to Lack of Information Availability Level 1 Basic Incentive Management Programs and Procedures Advanced Data Mining Capabilities, Decision Support System for proper Incentive Planning, Early Warning System for Incentives Programs not giving desired results Advanced Capabilities Low Extended Capabilities Enhanced Capabilities Incentive Management Risk Basic Capabilities High Incentive Management Process Maturity Figure 8: Incentive Management Capability Maturity Model The Way Forward A state-of-the-art targeted incentive management system is vital for optimizing the incentive offerings and gaining a competitive advantage. Quite a few automotive OEMs have already started upgrading their existing legacy systems because the savings potential is huge. A framework can help perform a quick, detailed gap assessment of the existing system and benchmark it against industry best practices. This will help unearth hidden areas of improvement opportunities. 19 About the Manufacturing Solutions Unit Global manufacturers are trying to reduce operational expenditure, invest in process improvement, utilize existing capacity optimally and increase efficiencies, while maintaining product quality and meeting safety and regulatory norms. TCS' Manufacturing Solutions provide you the bandwidth to innovate on business models, leveraging contemporary technology solutions. We believe in leveraging learning from across the segments in developing business solutions. Be it in applying the concepts of lean new product introduction from discrete industries to a chemical manufacturer, or leveraging the aerospace industry experience in service management for the automotive sector, our dedicated Manufacturing Centers of Excellence (CoEs) under these focus vertical industries are continuously looking at breakthrough solutions. Clients can benefit from our rich experience in both the discrete (automotive, industrial machinery and equipment, aerospace) and process industries (chemicals, cement, glass and paper). Contact For more information, contact [email protected] Subscribe to TCS White Papers TCS.com RSS: http://www.tcs.com/rss_feeds/Pages/feed.aspx?f=w Feedburner: http://feeds2.feedburner.com/tcswhitepapers About Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) Tata Consultancy Services is an IT services, consulting and business solutions organization that delivers real results to global business, ensuring a level of certainty no other firm can match. TCS offers a consulting-led, integrated portfolio of IT and IT-enabled infrastructure, engineering and assurance services. This is delivered through its unique Global Network Delivery ModelTM, recognized as the benchmark of excellence in software development. A part of the Tata Group, India’s largest industrial conglomerate, TCS has a global footprint and is listed on the National Stock Exchange and Bombay Stock Exchange in India. IT Services Business Solutions Consulting All content / information present here is the exclusive property of Tata Consultancy Services Limited (TCS). The content / information contained here is correct at the time of publishing. No material from here may be copied, modified, reproduced, republished, uploaded, transmitted, posted or distributed in any form without prior written permission from TCS. Unauthorized use of the content / information appearing here may violate copyright, trademark and other applicable laws, and could result in criminal or civil penalties. Copyright © 2014 Tata Consultancy Services Limited TCS Design Services I M I 02 I 14 For more information, visit us at www.tcs.com