Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Aldosterone in Cerebral Salt Wasting BY JOH X H. K. ALTHOUGH recent studies of patients with cerebral and pulmonary salt wasting have implicated "inappropriate"' antidiuretic hormone secretion as the basic defect, the norinality of aldosterone responsiveness has not been firmly established.'-' This paper reports a patient with cerebral salt wasting and hyponatremia in whom bal VOGEL, M.D. Downloaded from http://circ.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 14, 2017 eific gravity of 1.016, pH 5.5, negative for sugar, protein, and on microscopic. The white blood-cell (ouMt was 6,100 per mm.3, with a normal differential. The hematocrit value was 41 per cent. Fasting blood sugar was 77 mg. per 100 ml., nonproteiin nitrogen 27, and cholesterol 235. Serumn sodium wqs 127 mEq. per L.. potassium 5.1, chloride 81.6, and carbon dioxide content 24. The serum total pr otein was 7.2 Gm. per cent, with 3.9 albumin anid ) 3 globulin. The thvmol turbiditv was 3.0, cephalin flocculation 0 to 48 hours, and prothrombin time 72 per cent. A serologic test and L.E. preparations were negative. Seru-m calcium, phosphorus, and alkaline phosphatase were niorma.l. Urinary. 17-hydroxvcorticoids were normal, varying from 6.3 to 19 mg. per 24 hours. The electroencephalogram was norial and an electrocardiogram was normal except for loIw voltage. The chest film suggested miinimal pulmonarv el)hpvsema, spine films were nornmal, and skulll filmus revealed an old fracture on tlhe left and burr holes on tbe right. A spirogram wras normal. The chest pain varied markedly and was un1related to aetivitv, position, or neals with inconsistent responses to medications and placebos. The weakness of the legs was inconstant, did not inhibit normal activity, and u-as unrelated to serum sodiuin levels. Neuroloogic consultants found no evidence of residual or active disease. Psyehiatric evaluation suggested a psvehopatbic personality. On ad lib. water intake of 1,890 to 3,500 ml. per day and sodiumL intake of 90 mltlq., hyponatremia with urinary sodium wasting' persisted. Therefore. ietabolic balance stuidies wrere insti- anee studies suggested normal aldosterone response and inappropriate antidiuretie lbor n.tio-ne activity. Case Report A 38-year-old white, single, race-car driver, was admitted to Vanderbilt Universitv Hospital, Nashville, Tennessee, November 4, 1959, with the chief comiplaint of chest pain of 6 months' duration. Four months prior to admission he was involved in an automlobile accident resulting in a depressed skull fracture of the left parietal area and a subdural hematoma in the right frontal-parietal area requiring drainage with burr holes. Recovery was allegedly unieventful without neurologic deficit. One monith prior to admission hle was seen at G(rady Meiemorial Hospital in Atlanta, Georgia, with chest pain. An electrocardiogram and chest filmn were normal. Hyponatremia with urinary salt wasting was demonstrated, however, whieh subsequently responded to water restriction but not to salt loading. An intravenous pyelogram, blood nonprotein nitrogen? and urinary phenolsulfonphthaleirn exeretion were normal. Urinary 17hydroxvcorticoids were normnal both resting and after stimulation with ACTH. He addmitted to moderate alcoholic intake and Wave a histor-v of acute pvelonephritis involving the riiht ki-dnev 5 y ears prior to admiission. On physical exaamination the blood pressure was 108/98 nmm. Hg, the pulse was 84, and respirations were 16 per m-inute. The skin was of good tu-rger and color with normal hair distribution and no abnormal pigmentation. Skull defects were palpated in the areas of the old fracture and burr holes. Except for slight weakness in the le,s. tl-he phyvsical ex.aiminition w:ns otherwise within tuted. Methods A weighed diet with a basic content of 250 rnl. of water and 8.6 mEq. of sodium-l witlh constant calorie, carbohydrate, fat, and protein comuposition was given daily. This permitted sodium and water intake to be varied without altering the basic diet. Body weight was determinied dail-v under standard conditions. Urine u-as collected in 24-hour lots from 8:00 a.m. to 8:00 a.m., and hlood was drawn at 8 :00 a.m. daily. Serum and urine were analyzed for sodium and potassium by flame photometer. Osmolality (mOsml Kg.) of serum and urine was determined in duplicate froim. freezing-point depression with a Fiske osinometer. Urinary aldosterone was deter-mined in triplicate by the double-isotope derivative assay of Kliman and Peterson.9 Normal exeretion by this technic normal1st I limits. Laboratory results: Urinalysis revealed a speFrom the Departmeiit of Medlicine, Vanderbilt Selool of AMedicine, Nashville, Tennessee. litiiersity 44 Cireculotion, 'Voluzme rXXVII, Ja!tarur/ 196; ALDOSTERONE IN CEREBRAI SALT WASTING 200 Na INTAKE Meq/DAY 100 - 100- I I I 2 3 4 1 9 5 10 II -l 12 13 14 15 16 14 15 16 14 I-- 16 DAYS 3000 WATER INTAKE cc/DAY 1000 0 140 SERUM Na - 120 - Meq/L L .-- Downloaded from http://circ.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 14, 2017 200 1 -3 2 4 T 5 6, 8 DAYS -r 9 I 12 13 1 ~~~~t-I -**-*I ~~~~~~~I I 9g 0 1 II - URINE No 100 1-1 Meq/DAY -F °2I URINE ALDOSTERONE ,Ag/DAY 0 1 1 4 3 04 1 403020 o 01 a DAYS 6 3 ~ 12 1 13 10 V 15 F 2 8 1 91 DAYS 61 2 II 13114 I1 is MOSM URINE -@ o {3 4 6 5 8 4 e 9 0 9 10 o t---~-------11 I 13 1 14 15 1 DAYS 66 BODY WEIGHT Kg 64- -_ 52 2 3 I 41 5 6 1 I 8 I I IP 12 13 ' 14 1 15 ! I DAYS Figure 1 Effects of various sodium and water intakes. 10 ,ug. per 24 hours and ranges from 5 to 19. No aldosterone values were determined on days 4, 6, 8, 9, 15, and 16. averages Results Effects of high sodium and high water intake: (Days 1-3, table 1 and fig. 1) Prior to the balance study while on ad lib. water and Circulation, Volume XXVII, January 1963 sodium intake, the serum sodium varied from 117 to 127 mEq. per L. and the 24-hour urinie sodium excretion from 47 to 239 mEq. On the first and third days of the study the findings were similar. However, on the second day only, the patient failed to take the full water allowance with a subsequent rise in aldoster- VOGEL 46 oiie and serum sodium and a decreased uri (- ,o N cl z cq CA O z CA QO) N rl 1C-"C1 Downloaded from http://circ.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 14, 2017 a). t-9 . , 0) 0) 0) 0) 1't- L& a) t- 0) 1>. 01 )] @1t .3 .C -3 C.3 3 O . . . U) e) rl co C) C) 01CA ?0o C1i r-l C:) 1c10A C) "r Ct ) 01 . . r- -- * ) 0) 0) ) 0) = 1- " 0 O] CJ . . a)0) I.-1 .~ .~ . .~ .-1 .~ .l .e alm C1 CA v m <w It It m r1r-. E-4 i . . . . * L J C)t 'A CJ C3CC 0C lCI a) CA CA -- - II Ii i 1. c c1 CO clz0C0 7 " ^]0C 011 z ]C]t 1C ]Nm ]C]C1C 0 I1 nary sodium. Effects of high sodiunm and low water intake: (Days 4-7, table 1 and fig. 1) There was a conspicuous rise in serum sodium and osnmo- - 4=- c) C)- -l x " -* )- C 01-rCi r- . "I -~ . . - t -, . m = r.4 r- vC c < C) -Q 0c, r '-4 -4 r I IC: tc0 t:'- 00) V00 x v C01 (, 01 t- 't : lfC C-It;CG10?Ia ' fcy 'CC'O CA c CQI 0)C. v . cl 0 If: a'A tn. X C - 1 -w 1 =-or, rH i r ri .1 '- kr 17. i -Z .- -z !V .- 1 : i 7-. - '-. 17* r-' 1H. )C 00> > CC 4 C0 )C l. c t z o4 In.o C)o 0I -f o.' m A-tID~ 01 to C)D )c c> )c .C lalitv associated with a decrease in body weight. Urinary sodium exeretion continued as in the previous period with nio change in aldosterone excretion. Effects of low sodiumv and low water intake: (Days 8-12, table I and fig. 1) There was a norm-ial rise in aldosterone excretion to 35 t,g. In addition, there was a progressive fall in urinary sodiumn exeretioni and a further increase in serunl sodiuit and osmnolalitv. Effects of low sodiutm and high uwater intak(e: (Days 13-16. table 1 and fig. 1". The rapid fall in serumji sodium osmolality and uriniarv aldosterone in association with inereasing urinary sodium excretion and body weight is clearly shown. The n-onprotein: nlitrog,eni an-id serumy creatinine were normual throughout the study. Of note is the urinary osiolality, which was ii-i excess of serum osnmolality throughout the entire study. Effects of ivatcr avd alcohol loads: (Table *. and fig 2). Ilaviing been on normal sodiun and water intake, the patient and the normal ontrol were fasted for 6 hours. Subsequently I-hour eontrol urinie anid serumll specimens were collectedl anid anialyzed for sodium., creatiiiinei aind osmalality. The subjects remainied supine throughout the study except when providing specimens. Urine volume was recorde(d and free water clearance calculated. The subjects theni received water loads by mouth of 20 ml. per KIg. over a 5- to 1.0-minute period and urine and seruma specimnenis were collected at hourly intervals. The conitrol (fig. 2. top) clearlv reveals a i1ornoal response wvitli a moderate increase in urinie flow and free water clearanee and a decrease in urine osmolality, becomning maximnal 1 hour after the water load.'0 By contrast., the patielnt revealed a markedly abnormal response with miinimal increase in urine flow and free water clearance with failure to lower urine osmolality below 121. No significant Circulation. Volume XXVii, January 1963 47 ALDOSTERONE IN CEREBRAL SALT WASTING Table 2 Free Water Clearance (ml./mnin.) Time Hr. Control Patient - .4 -1.0 1 H20 Load 2 3 4 MOS/L 1.5 6.4 4.6 .8 1.2 2.5 5.8 .1 SERUMG --.--- URINE Alcohol Load 5 6 7 8 .2 4001 -1 ---20 e- .8 URINE cc/M1in.5 1490cc FLOW Downloaded from http://circ.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 14, 2017 change in creatinine clearance occurred in either subject. Three hours after the water load each subject received 50 ml. of 95 per cent ethyl alcohol by mouth over a 5- to 10-minute period. In the control subject there was a significant increase in urine flow and free water clearance 1 hour after the alcohol load, resulting in a negative water balance of 168 ml. during the 7-hour period (excluding insensible water loss). In the patient, no significant change occurred in urine flow or free water clearance, resulting in a positive water balance of 445 ml. during the 7-hour period. No significant change in creatinine clearance occurred in either subject. Discussion Cerebral disease with hyponatremia and excessive urinary sodium wasting has been reported by Peters et al.,8 MeCrory and Macauly,5 Epstein and Levitin,4 Goldberg and Handler,1 and Carter et al.6 In McCrory and Macauly's patient,5 a 51½2month-old girl with diffuse cerebral disease, restriction of water in relation to sodium resulted in normal serum sodium levels. The response to a water load was abnormal as manifested by a failure of urine osmolality to fall below 150. A bioassay for antidiuretic hormone while the patient was hyponatremic was markedly positive, but a control was essentially negative. With exogenous salt-retaining steroids there was an increase in body weight, but not of serum sodium. Epstein and Levitin's patient,4 a 19-yearCirculation, Volume XXVII, January 1963 0- I1 2 6 5 4 3 6 7 HOURS N P H20POI 600- MOSM/ 50cc PO 95% C215° 11320 ce + .1370 cc INTAKE IT 400- SERUM a.0 URINE -*e ----- 200- - 0-I URINE FLOW cc/Milt_ * 92S cc o_ 0-Il OUTPUT 2 3 4 O is HIOURS Figure 2 and Effect of water alcohol loads. Top, normal subject; bottom, patient. old girl with epilepsy, was similar to the above patient. There was a definite inverse relation between water intake and serum sodium, positive bioassay for antidiuretic hormone after water loading, and failure to decrease urine osmolality normally following an alcohol load. With combined sodium and water restriction, however, the urinary sodium excretion decreased to 2 mEq. per day. The four patients studied by Goldberg and Handler' were strikingly similar to the patients noted above. Their serum sodiums were \rOGEL 48 Downloaded from http://circ.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 14, 2017 iinverselv proportional to water in-take, aiid large sodium loads were ineffective in raising the serum levels unless combined with water restriction. One patient failed to ehange urine osmolality with alcohol. As with our patient, one of Carter et al 's.6 patients developed hyponatremia followving a skull fracture, and although the fracture healed eompletely he remained persistently hvponatremic when allowed free access to water. With either restriction of sodiuim to 17 mEq. per dav or 9-alpha-fluorohvdroeortisone a positive sodium balanee wvas attained. The basic defect in these cases of cerebral salt wasting would appear to be the inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone. However, the positive responses to salt restriction or exogenous salt-retaining steroids sugest a normal aldosterone mechanism. A similar syndrome of salt wasting associated with bronehogenic carcinoma has been reported by Schwartz et al..2, 3 and careful studies in three patients revealed hyponatremia, urine osmolality consistently higher than serum osmlolality, and excessive urinary salt wasting, which was attribuited to inappropriate antidiuretic hormone secretion. The serum sodium was closely related to and inversely proportional to fluid intake, with no significant response to high-sodium intake except during water restrietion. All patients developed a positive sodium balanee on exogenous salt-retaining steroids and after ACTH. Aldosterone determinations were low normal in the presencee of hyponatremia during both low- and high-sodium intake. These results sug,gested normal aldosterone responsiveness. Dossetor et al.]" recently reported another patient with bronehogenic carcinoma complieated by hyponatremia in whom an inverse relationship between serum sodium and water intake was noted, and thought to be a consequence of inappropriate antidiuretic hormone. As with our patient, aldosteron-e excretion was normal during balance periods of low sodium with excess water intake and high sodium with -restrieted water intake. The effect of comnbined low sodium and water intake was not studied, biut presumablY would havre re sulted in an in-icreased aldosterone exeretio'-i, as oeeurred in our patient. Dashe and Hern kin12 have also reported a case of inappropriate antidiureticlhormone secretion follow- ing yttrium90 hypophysectomy. The role of extracellular fluid volume in teli regulation of aldosterone seeretion has beeni well documented by Bartter et al.13 They produced the control findings in our patietnt by the simultaneous admlinistration of Pitressin and a water load to a salt-depleted subject. This resulted in a decreased aldosterone exere tion, serum sodium, and osmolality but ati increase in urinary sodium excretion and body weight. Similar results have beeni noted- bV Cox, Leonard, and Singer,14 anid Leaf et al.l' in human subjects. ani by Leaf and Mamb01l in dogs. Thus, it is clear that inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone may be the basic abnorimalitv in this type of excessive urinary sodiunm wasting with hIyponatremia. The second study period in our patient of water restriction with normal sodium initake. during which urinary sodium excretion re mained high and aldosterone low, has also been produced by Bartter et al.'3 They dem onstrated that bv maintenance of a normal extracellular fluid volume with a reduced fluid intake of hvpertonic coneentration and subsequent contraction of the intracellular space, aldosteromie and sodium excretion continued unchanged. WVith combined sodium and water restriction, the extracellular fluid volume will decrease and aldosterone secretion will increase in aii effort to re-expand the extracellular fluid volum-ie by the conservationi of sodium, if the aldosterone mechanism is normal, and, as shown (days 8-12), this occurred in our pa- tient. The last phase of the study fdays 13-16)< stresses further the regulatory importance of the extracellular fluiid volume. With a normal water intake and low sodiumB intake, the extracellular fluid volume increased rapidlv b)v virtue of the abnormal level of antidiuretie lhorm-none with a prompt decrease in aldosteronie excretion and an increase in urinary sodiuni exeretion. Circulation Volume XXVII, Jan-uary 1f963 ALDOSTERONE IN CEREBRAL SALT WASTING Downloaded from http://circ.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 14, 2017 The response in the control subject to water and alcohol loads, characterized by maximum diuresis 1 hour after the respective loads is in agreement with other reports in normal subjects."6 The failure of our patient to decrease urine osmolality below 100, or to sustain any significant change in free water clearance after water and alcohol loads in the face of a normal creatinine clearance, is highly suggestive of inappropriate antidiuretic hormone secretion.3 The studies of Rubini et al.,17 suggest that the effect of ethyl alcohol is on the release or production of antidiuretic hormone in that normally a 60- to 90-minute lag period occurs before a response to the alcohol load is noted. This represents the time necessary for circulating antidiuretic hormone to be cleared. Thus, the failure of our patient and othersl-4 to respond to alcohol loads suggests inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone. Of interest is a recent report by Grumer et al."8 on a patient with episodic inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone, but no apparent underlying disease. In their patient and in our patient, the mechanism of the inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone is not clear. Whether there has been a resetting of the "osmostat," or persistence of an abnormal stimulus to antidiuretic hormone secretion is not apparent. The results in our patient suggest a normal responsiveness in aldosterone stimulation, secretion, and end-organ effectiveness in association with inappropriate antidiuretic hormone secretion. The maintenance of a normal aldosterone mechanism suggests that the receptors regulating aldosterone-stimulating hormone may be independent of the hypothalamus. In support of this are recent studies suggesting that these receptors may be located in the kidney.19' 20 Summary A metabolic balance study in a patient with cerebral salt wasting is reported. The results suggest that a normal aldosterone mechanism was present in association with inappropriate antidiuretic hormone secretion. Circulation, Volume XXVII, January: 1963 Acknowledgment The author wishes to thank Donald Island, B.S., for the aldosterone determinations, Dr. Grant W. Liddle, for his advice and criticism, and Dr. Elbert P. Tuttle, Jr., for referring the patient. References 1. GOLDBERG, M., AND HANDLER, J. S., Hyponatremia and renal wasting of sodium in patients with malfunction of the central nervous system. New England J. Med. 263: 1037, 1960. 2. SCHWARTZ, W. B., BENNETT, W., CURELOP, S., AND BARTTER, F. C.: Syndrome of renal sodium loss and hyponatremia probably resulting from inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone. Am. J. Med. 23: 529, 1957. 3. SCHWARTZ, W. B., TASSEL, D., AND BARTTER, F. C.: Further observations on hyponatremia and renal sodium loss probably resulting fromn inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone. New England J. Med. 262: 743, 1960. 4. EPSTEIN, F. H., AND LEvInN, H.: "Cerebral salt wasting": An example of sustained inappropriate release of antidiuretic hormone. J. Clin. Invest. 38: 1001, 1959. 5. MCnROY., W. W., AND MACAULAY, D.: Idiopathic hypoinatreinia in ani infaint with diffuse cerebral damage. Pediatrics 20: 23, 1957. 6. CARTER, N. W., RECTOR, F. C., JR., AND SELDIN, D. W.: Hyponatremia in cerebral disease resulting from the inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone. Newv England J. Med. 264: 67, 1961. 7. ROBERTS, H. J.: Syndrome of hyponatremia and renal sodium loss probably resulting from inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone. Ann. Int. Med. 51: 1420, 1959. 8. PETERS, J. P., WELT, L. G., SIMs, E. A. H., ORLOFF, J., AND NEEDHAM, J.: A salt-wasting syndrome associated with cerebral disease. Tr. A. Am. Physicians 63: 57, 1950. 9. KLIMAN, B., AND PETERSON, R. E.: Double isotope derivative assay of aldosterone in biological extracts. J. Biol. Chem. 235: 1639, 1960. 10. ROBINSON, F. J., POWER, M. H., AND KEPLER, E. J.: Two new procedures to assist in the recognition and exclusion of Addison's disease. Proc. Staff Meet., Mayo Clin. 16: 577, 1941. 11. DOSSETOR, J. B., VENNING, E. H., AND BECK, J. C.: Hyponatremia associated with superior vena cava obstruetion. Metabolism 10: 149, 1961. 12. DASHE, A. M., AND HENKIN, R.: Water intoxication after hypophysectomy: an unusual case. Am. J. M. Sc. 241: 752, 1961. 13. BARTTER, F. C., LIDDLE, G. W., DUNCAN, L. E., JR., BARBER, J. K., AND DELEA, C.: The regulation of aldosterone secretion in man: the role of fluid volume. J. Clin. Invest. 35: 1306, 1956. VOGEL -ao 14. Cox, J. R., LEONARD, P. J., AND SINGER, B.: Effect of vasopressin on the volume of body fluid compartments and its relation to aldos terone excretion. Clin. Sc. 21: 205, 1961. 15. LEAF, A., BARTTER, F. C., SANTOS, R. F., AND WRONG, 0.: Evidence in man that urinary electrolyte loss induced by pitressin is a function of water retention. J. Clin. Invest. 32: 868, 1953. 16. LEAF, A., AND MAMBY, A. R.: An antidiuretic mechanism not regulated by extracellular fluid tonicity. J. Clin. Invest. 31: 60, 1952. 17. RUBINI, M. E., KLEEMAN, C. R., AND LAMDIN, E.: Studies on alcohol diuresis. I. The effect of ethyl alcohol ingestioil on water, electrolyte, and acid-base metabolism. J. Clin. Invest. 34: 439, 1955. 18. GRUMER, H. A.,. DERRYBERRY, V., DUBIN, A., AND WALDSTEIN, S. S.: Idiopathic, episodic inappropriate secretion of antidiuretic hormone. Am. J. Med. 32: 954, 1962. 19. DAVIS, J. 0.: A critical evaluation of the role of receptors in the control of aldosterone secretion and sodium excretion. Progr. Cardiovas. Dis. 4: 27, 1961. 2O. MULROW, P. J., AND GANONG, W. F.: Role of the kidney and the renin-angiotensin system in the response of aldosterone secretion to hemorrhage. Circulation 25: 213, 1962. Downloaded from http://circ.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 14, 2017 Richard Bright He could not have been called a brilliant man. He miade at first no great impressioni on those about him. But brillianey is often ephemeral; very often brilliancy spells instability. Bright showed a steadfastness of purpose and an equanimity that are rarer and more precious than mnere brilliancy. He was a simple, straightforward, kindly man, who met life with charity and tolerance and serenity; a conscientious, painstaking physician; a patient, careful, modest, scrupulous time-taking observer. He became a wise and learned man, and the fruits of his labours assure him a well-nmerited and honourable immortality. Bright was buried in Bethnal Green. There is a tablet dedieated to his memory in St. James' Church in Piccadilly. The inscription ends with these words: "He contributed to medical science many discoveries and works of great value, And died while in the full practice of his profession after a life of warm affection unsullied purity and great usefulness."-W. S. THAYER (B.M.J., 1927). The Quiet A rt: A Doctor's Anthology. Compiled by DR. ROBERT COOPE. Edinburgh & London, E. & S. Livingstone Ltd.. 1952, p. 66. Circulation, Volume XXVII, January 196S Aldosterone in Cerebral Salt Wasting JOHN H. K. VOGEL Downloaded from http://circ.ahajournals.org/ by guest on June 14, 2017 Circulation. 1963;27:44-50 doi: 10.1161/01.CIR.27.1.44 Circulation is published by the American Heart Association, 7272 Greenville Avenue, Dallas, TX 75231 Copyright © 1963 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Print ISSN: 0009-7322. Online ISSN: 1524-4539 The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on the World Wide Web at: http://circ.ahajournals.org/content/27/1/44 Permissions: Requests for permissions to reproduce figures, tables, or portions of articles originally published in Circulation can be obtained via RightsLink, a service of the Copyright Clearance Center, not the Editorial Office. Once the online version of the published article for which permission is being requested is located, click Request Permissions in the middle column of the Web page under Services. Further information about this process is available in the Permissions and Rights Question and Answer document. Reprints: Information about reprints can be found online at: http://www.lww.com/reprints Subscriptions: Information about subscribing to Circulation is online at: http://circ.ahajournals.org//subscriptions/