Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Interest Groups Interest Groups “in no country of the world has the principle of association been more successfully used or applied to a greater multitude of objectives than in America.” • Interest Groups – An organized group of individuals sharing common objectives who actively attempt to influence policy makers – Often spawned by social movements • Lobbyists – An organization or individual who attempts to influence legislation and the administrative decisions of government • Hyperpluralism – The ability of interest groups to mandate policy or to defeat policies needed by the nation • Detriment to effective government? Federalist #10 blah, blha, blah……blah, blha, blah……blah, blha, blah…… ……blah, blha, blah……blah, blha, blah …… blah, blha, blah……blah, blha, blah……blah, blha, blah…… ……blah, blha, blah……blah, blha, blah …… Why so many interest groups? • 1st Amendment - guarantees facilitate group formation – Right • Assemble • Petition to redress grievances • Groups amplify individual opinions • Many pressure points in our federal system • Diversity gives rise to many views – Ethnic, religious, economic, etc. • Social changes, economic pressures and technological developments disturb the status quo, leading to group formation – Examples: industrialization, urbanization, civil rights movement Why join an interest group? • Latent interests – public-policy interests that are not recognized or addressed by a group at a particular time • Many people wait for “collective good” to be addressed rather than join a group – “free rider problem” – When benefits can be obtained without joining the group • People generally join when they perceive that their effort will make a difference – Small groups seeking benefits for a specific group are more successful in recruiting members Why join an interest group? • Incentives – Solidary • Companionship, sense of belonging, pleasure of associating – Ex. National Audubon Society – Material • Discounts and opportunities – Ex. AARP – Purposive • Satisfaction of taking action with a group an individual agrees with – Ex. NRA Fortune Power 25 Rank 2005 Organization Website 1 National Rifle Association www.nra.org 2 AARP www.aarp.org 3 National Federation of Independent Business www.nfibonline.com 4 American Israel Public Affairs Committee www.alpac.org 5 Association of Trial Lawyers of America www.atla.org 6 American Federation of Labor-Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL-CIO) www.aflcio.org 7 Chamber of Commerce of the U.S.A. www.uschamber.org 8 National Beer Wholesalers Association www.nwba.org 9 National Association of Realtors www.realtor.com 10 National Association of Manufacturers www.nam.org • http://quizlet.com/4157274/the-power-25-interest-groups-flash-cards/ • http://www.congresslink.org/print_lp_specialinterestgroups_fortune.htm (2001) Types of Interest Groups • Economic* – Business • Umbrella groups represent types of business or industry – – – – Ex. US Chamber of Commerce Ex. National Association of Manufacturers Ex. American Pet Products Manufacturers Ex. Better Business Bureau – Agricultural • Small by population but very influential – Ex. American Farm Bureau Federation – Ex. The Peanut Growers Group – Ex. American Farmland Trust – Labor • About 12% of the workforce belong to a union – Ex. AFL-CIO – Public-Employee • more public-sector members than private-sector members – Ex. NEA – Professional • Many different groups represented – Ex. American Bar Association – Ex. American Medical Association *largest category of interest groups Types of Interest Groups • Environmental – National Audubon Society – Sierra Club – National Wildlife Federation – Environmental Defense Fund – Greenpeace Types of Interest Groups • Public-Interest – Many different “publics” in a country of 300m+ • “Nader Organizations” – “Nader’s Raiders” • • • • ACLU League of Women Voters Common Cause MoveOn.org Types of Interest Groups • Other – Single issue groups • More focused • Members more passionate • Less complex goals – Ex. NRA, MADD • Foreign – Over 300 foreign entities represented by lobbyists • Ex. Coalition to Save Darfur Contemporary Interest Groups What Do Interest Groups Do? • Inform • Lobby • Campaign Activities – Political Action Committees – Issue Advocacy Keys to an Effective Interest Group • Size and Resources • Leadership • Cohesiveness Interest Group Strategies • Direct – – – – Lobbying Ratings Building alliances Campaign assistance • Indirect – – – – Generating public pressure Climate control Using constituents as lobbyists Unconventional • Marches, boycotts Techniques for Exerting Influence • Publicity, Mass Media, and the Internet – – • Mass Mailing/E-Mailing – • endorsements New Political Parties – • Through PACs/Super Pacs or bundling – collecting individual donations and presenting together Candidate Support/Opposition – • Organized to raise awareness Astroturf lobbying Contributions to Campaigns – • Initiate lawsuits Amicus curiae briefs Protest – – • Government agencies publish proposed regulations in the Federal Register and invite responses from all interested person before rules are finalized Litigation – – • Increases reach and effectiveness of interest groups Direct Contact with Government – • Influences votes during elections Motivates constituents to contact representatives Often just to publicize a cause Cooperative Lobbying – Like-minded groups form cooperative groups Who are lobbyists? • Often former public servants – Revolving Door • Employment cycle in which individuals who work for government agencies that regulate interests eventually end up working for interest groups or businesses with the same policy concern – 33% of those who lost seats in Congress following 2010 election employed by lobbying firms – 20% employed by lobbying clients – 2007 Honest Leadership and Open Government Act • More disclosure of employment history for lobbyists • Stricter limits on lobbying activities • Longer cooling off period – Many participate in issue networks • Relationships among interest groups, congressional committees and subcommittees, and the government agencies that share a common policy concern – Specialized knowledge often allows them to wield tremendous influence – Demographics: 30,000 registered in Washington • 1/3 women • 200 black • 60 Hispanic Lobbying? http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2011/dec/16/newt-gingrich/newtgingrich-said-he-never-lobbied-freddie-mac-un/ What Do Lobbyists Do? • Provide money for reelection campaigns – Also provide volunteers for campaign activities • Sometimes just their failure to support opposition is enough to increase reelection odds • Provide information – Political information • Ex. Who supports/opposes legislation – Substantive information • Ex. Impact of proposed laws, technical assistance drafting bills, identifying persons to testify at hearings American Legislative Exchange Council – ALEC http://www.alec.org/ http://www.brookings.edu/research/articles/2013/12/06 -american-legislative-exchange-council-jackman Regulating Lobbyists • 1946 – Federal Regulation of Lobbying Act – Provided for disclosure – Defined lobbyist • Any person or organization that received money to be used principally to influence legislation before Congress – Lobbyists had to register their clients and purpose of their efforts • Disclosed quarterly – Limited effectiveness • Only some lobbyists registered (only full-time) – Only if they were directly influencing Congress • Not required to register if lobbying the executive branch, federal agencies, courts, congressional staff, etc. Regulating Lobbyists • 1995 – Lobbying Disclosure Act – Redefined lobbyist • Anyone who spends at least 20% of their time lobbying members of Congress or staff, or executive branch officials – Must register with House or Senate within 45 days of first contact or being hired – Reports (now quarterly) disclosing • General nature of lobbying, specific issues and bills, estimated cost of campaign, list of branches contacted (not names) – Representatives of US owned subsidiaries of foreignowned entities must register – Grassroots and tax-exempt organizations exempted Regulating Lobbyists • 2007 – Honest Leadership and Open Government Act – Tightened reporting rules – Longer waiting period • 2 years for Senators • 1 year for Rep. – Limited lobbying spouses – Only trips pre-approved by Ethics Committee Recent Lobbying Scandal: Jack Abramoff © 2006 Time, Inc./Getty Images. Reprinted by permission. Interest Groups and Representative Democracy • Interest Groups: Elitist or Pluralist? – The existence of interest groups would appear to be an argument in favor of pluralism. However, interest groups are often led by upper-class individuals, which argues for elite theory. • Interest Group Influence – Even the most powerful groups do not always succeed in their demands. – The most successful groups focus on single issue Interest Groups and the Policy Process http://www.madd.org Web Links • The Center for Public Integrity • Opensecrets.org-Money in Politics Data • Common Cause—Holding Power Accountable • Federal Election Commission • Public Citizen